Using recombinant camel chymosin to make white soft cheese from camel milk

Effect of Freeze-Dried Camel Rennet Extract on Coagulation of Camel-Goat Milk Mixture and Characterization of the Cheese Obtained

This study aims at the use of freeze-dried camel rennet extract (FDCR) in the manufacture of fresh cheeses from a mixture of camel and goat milk in comparison with the microbial coagulating agent (FDMC). Physical properties, chemical composition, microstructure, and sensory analysis of the cheeses were performed. The recommended amount of FDCR for coagulation of camel-goat milk mixture was 0.2 g/L. The cheese obtained was mainly characterized by dry matter 34.99 ± 0.57% and protein content 36.26 ± 1.75%/DM. Texture profile analysis revealed that the obtained cheese was mainly characterized by cohesiveness 0.32 ± 0.01 and springiness 14.25 ± 0.63 mm. The microstructure showed that the obtained cheese had more and wider pores. FTIR was used to monitor the differences in the gross composition of the obtained cheese compared to that coagulated with FDMC. The main difference was the presence of amide I in the cheese coagulated with FDCR. For X-ray diffraction, the results noted that the use of FDCR as a natural extract in the coagulation of camel-goat milk mixture did not lead to the appearance of crystalline structure in the cheese. For sensory evaluation, the panelists preferred the cheese coagulated with FDCR with a score of 9/15.

Tobacco Plant: A Novel and Promising Heterologous Bioreactor for the Production of Recombinant Bovine Chymosin

The natural source of chymosin, a key enzyme in the dairy industry, is insufficient for rapidly growing cheese industries. Large-scale production of recombinant proteins in heterologous hosts provides an efficient alternative solution. Here, the codon-optimized synthetic prochymosin gene, which has a CAI index of 0.926, was subcloned from a cloning vector (pUC57-bCYM) into the pBI121 vector, resulting in the construct named pBI121-bCYM. CAI ranges from 0 to 1 and higher CAI improves gene expression in heterologous hosts. The overexpression of the prochymosin gene was under the control of constitutive CaMV 35S promoter and NOS terminator and was transferred into the tobacco via A. tumefaciens strain LBA4404. Explant type, regeneration method, inoculation temperature, cell density (OD600) of Agrobacterium for inoculation, and acetosyringone concentration were leaf explants, direct somatic embryogenesis, 19 °C, 0.1, and 100 µM, respectively. The successful integration and expression of the prochymosin gene, along with the bioactivity of recombinant chymosin, were confirmed by PCR, RT-PCR, and milk coagulation assay, respectively. Overall, this study reports the first successful overexpression of the codon-optimized prochymosin form of the bovine chymosin enzyme in the tobacco via indirect transformation. Production of recombinant bovine chymosin in plants can be an easy-to-scale-up, safe, and inexpensive platform.

Isolation and identification of milk-clotting proteases from Prinsepia utilis Royle and its application in cheese processing

The aim of this study was to isolate and identify the main milk-clotting proteases from Prinsepia utilis Royle. Protein isolates obtained using precipitation with 20 %-50 % ammonium sulfate (AS) showed higher milk-clotting activity (MCA) at 154.34 + 0.35 SU. Two milk-clotting proteases, namely P191 and P1831, with molecular weight of 49.665 kDa and 68.737 kDa, respectively, were isolated and identified using liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS). Bioinformatic analysis showed that the two identified milk-clotting proteases were primarily involved in hydrolase activity and catabolic processes. Moreover, secondary structure analysis showed that P191 structurally consisted of 40.85 % of alpha-helices, 15.96 % of beta-strands, and 43.19 % of coiled coil motifs, whereas P1831 consisted of 70 % of alpha-helices, 7.5 % of beta-strands, and 22.5 % of coiled coil motifs. P191 and P1831 were shown to belong to the aspartic protease and metalloproteinase types, and exhibited stability within the pH range of 4-6 and good thermal stability at 30-80 °C. The addition of CaCl2 (<200 mg/L) increased the MCA of P191 and P1831, while the addition of NaCl (>3 mg/mL) inhibited their MCA. Moreover, P191 and P1831 preferably hydrolyzed kappa-casein, followed by alpha-casein, and to a lesser extent beta-casein. Additionally, cheese processed with the simultaneous use of the two proteases isolated in the present study exhibited good sensory properties, higher protein content, and denser microstructure compared with cheese processed using papaya rennet or calf rennet. These findings unveil the characteristics of two proteases isolated from P. utilis, their milk-clotting properties, and potential application in the cheese-making industry.

Milk clotting enzymes from marine resources and their role in cheese-making: A mini review

With the continual increase in global cheese consumption, rennet, the traditional milk coagulant, is unable to meet the growing demand in cheese production. Although several proteases from other sources have been used for cheese-making, they suffer various shortcomings. The ocean is home to a huge and diverse range of life forms, which represent a vast potential source of proteases. Marine proteases have been isolated from a number of marine species, including sponge, jellyfish, seaweed and marine animals, and some have been shown to be suitable as milk-clotting enzymes for cheese making. This review summarizes the latest studies on rennet substitutes from marine resources and their role in cheese-making. The emphasis of the review is on the isolation and purification of the marine proteases, the biochemical characteristics of these enzymes, especially their caseinolytic and milk-clotting properties, as well as their cleavage sites on casein. Some of the marine proteases have been applied as milk-clotting agent in cheese-making, with the resultant production of cheese with comparable characteristics, including sensory characteristics, to calf rennet cheese. The review concludes by highlighting the challenges and opportunities for future research in the field.

A Review on Processing Opportunities for the Development of Camel Dairy Products

Camel milk has a significant and pivotal role in the diet of people residing in semi-arid and arid regions. Ever since ancient times, marketing of camel milk has remained insignificant due to nonexistence of processing amenities in the camel nurturing areas, hence the utilization of unprocessed camel milk has continuously remained limited at family level by the nomads. Due to the superior medicinal values and health promoting effects, incredible growth in the demand of camel milk and dairy products have been noticed all over the world during last two decades. Such emergence has led dairy industry to provide diversified camel dairy products to the consumers with superior nutritional and functional qualities. In contrast to bovine, very few food products derived from camel milk are available in the present market. With the advancements in food processing interventions, a wide range of dairy and non-dairy products could be obtained from camel milk, including milk powder, cheese, yogurt, ice cream, and even chocolate. In some regions, camel milk is used for traditional dishes such as fermented milk, camel milk tea, or as a base for soups and stews. Current review highlights the processing opportunities regarding the transformation of camel milk into various dairy products via decreasing the inherent functionality that could be achieved by optimization of processing conditions and alteration of chemical composition by using fortification method. Additionally, future research directions could be devised to improve the product quality.

Low-moisture part-skim mozzarella cheese made from blends of camel and bovine milk: Gross composition, proteolysis, functionality, microstructure, and rheological properties

Camel (CM) milk is used in variety of ways; however, it has inferior gelling properties compared with bovine milk (BM). In this study, we aimed to investigate the physicochemical, functional, microstructural, and rheological properties of low-moisture part-skim (LMPS) mozzarella cheese, made from BM, or BM mixed with 15% CM (CM15%) or 30% CM (CM30%), at various time points (up to 60 d) of storage at 4°C after manufacture. Low-moisture part-skim mozzarella cheeses using CM15% and CM30% had high moisture and total Ca contents, but lower soluble Ca content. Compared with BM cheese, CM15% and CM30% LMPS mozzarella cheese exhibited higher proteolysis rates during storage. Adding CM affected the color properties of LMPS mozzarella cheese manufactured from mixed milk. Scanning electron microscopy images showed that the microstructure of CM15% and CM30% cheeses had smooth surfaces, whereas the BM cheese microstructures were rough with granulated surfaces. Low-moisture part-skim mozzarella cheeses using CM15% and CM30% showed significantly lower hardness and chewiness, but higher stringiness than BM cheese. Compared with BM cheese, CM15% and CM30% cheeses showed lower tan δ levels during temperature surges, suggesting that the addition of CM increased the meltability of LMPS mozzarella cheese during temperature increases. Camel milk addition affected the physicochemical, microstructural, and rheological properties of LMPS mozzarella cheese.

Obtaining of Recombinant Camel Chymosin and Testing Its Milk-Clotting Activity on Cow's, Goat's, Ewes', Camel's and Mare's Milk

In the cheese-making industry, commonly chymosin is used as the main milk-clotting enzyme. Bactrian camel (Camelus bactrianus) chymosin (BacChym) has a milk-clotting activity higher than that of calf chymosin for cow's, goat's, ewes', mare's and camel's milk. A procedure for obtaining milk-clotting reagent based on recombinant camel chymosin is proposed here. Submerged fermentation by a recombinant yeast (Pichia pastoris GS115/pGAPZαA/ProchymCB) was implemented in a 50 L bioreactor, and the recombinant camel chymosin was prepared successfully. The activity of BacChym in yeast culture was 174.5 U/mL. The chymosin was concentrated 5.6-fold by cross-flow ultrafiltration and was purified by ion exchange chromatography. The activity of the purified BacChym was 4700 U/mL. By sublimation-drying with casein peptone, the BacChym powder was obtained with an activity of 36,000 U/g. By means of this chymosin, cheese was prepared from cow's, goat's, ewes', camel's and mare's milk with a yield of 18%, 17.3%, 15.9%, 10.4% and 3%, respectively. Thus, the proposed procedure for obtaining a milk-clotting reagent based on BacChym via submerged fermentation by a recombinant yeast has some prospects for biotechnological applications. BacChym could be a prospective milk-clotting enzyme for different types of milk and their mixtures.

The Texture of Camel Milk Cheese: Effects of Milk Composition, Coagulants, and Processing Conditions

Numerous people in African, Middle Asian, Middle Eastern, and Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries highly value camel milk (CM) as it plays a vital role in their diet. The protein composition of CM as well as the structure of its casein micelles differs significantly from bovine milk (BM). Cheeses made from CM have a weak curd and soft texture compared to those made from BM. This review article presents and discusses the effect of milk protein composition, processing conditions (pasteurization and high-pressure treatment), and coagulants (camel chymosin, organic acids, plant proteases) on the quality of CM cheeses. CM cheese's weak texture is due to compositional characteristics of the milk, including low κ-casein-to-β-casein ratio (≈0.05 in CM vs. ≈0.33 in BM), large micelle size, different whey protein components, and higher proteolytic activity than BM. CM cheese texture can be improved by preheating the milk at low temperatures or by high pressure. Supplementing CM with calcium has shown inconsistent results on cheese texture, which may be due to interactions with other processing conditions. Despite their structure, CM cheeses are generally well liked in sensory studies.

Low-fat akawi cheese made from bovine-camel milk blends: Rheological properties and microstructural characteristics

Camel milk (CM) can be used as an ingredient to produce various dairy products but it forms weak rennet-induced and acid-induced gels compared with bovine milk (BM). Therefore, in this study, we aimed to investigate the effect of blending bovine milk with camel milk on the physicochemical, rheological (amplitude sweep and frequency sweep), and microstructural properties of low-fat akawi (LFA) cheese. The cheeses were made of BM only or BM blended with 15% (CM15%) or 30% (CM30%) camel milk and stored at 4°C for 28 d. The viscoelastic properties as a function of temperature were assessed. The LFA cheeses made from blended milks had higher moisture, total Ca, and soluble Ca contents, and had higher pH 4.6-water-soluble nitrogen compared with those made from BM. Analysis by scanning electron microscopy demonstrated that the microstructures formed in BM cheese were rough with granular surfaces, whereas those in blended milk cheeses had smooth surfaces. Hardness was lower for LFA cheeses made from blended milk than for those made from BM only. The LFA cheeses demonstrated viscoelastic behavior in a linear viscoelastic range from 0.1 to 1.0% strain. The storage modulus (G') was lower in LFA cheese made from BM over a range of frequencies. Adding CM reduced the resistance of LFA cheeses to flow as temperature increased. Blended cheeses exhibited lower complex viscosity values than BM cheeses during temperature increases. Thus, the addition of camel milk improved the rheological properties of LFA cheese.

Exogenous Enzymes in Cheese Making: An Overview

Abstract:

The flavour in mature cheese results from a complex series of biochemical events that occur in the curd during ripening. More than 500 varieties of cheese are produced in the world, and each of them possesses its typical sensory characteristics. Flavour depends on milk variety, starter bacteria used in cheese-making and ripening. Amino acids and free fatty acids (FFA) act mainly as precursors of a series of catabolic reactions, still not well understood. These reactions lead to the production of aroma compounds such as esters, fatty acids, aldehydes, alcohols, ketones, hydrocarbons, lactones, and sulphur. Enzymes involved in all these processes are derived from milk, Lactic Acid Bacteria (LAB), Non-Starter Lactic Acid Bacteria (NSLAB), rennet, or fungi. In cheese industrial production, the milk pasteurization process leads to the removal of endogenous bacteria, therefore it is necessary to add exogenous enzymes to enrich and standardize cheeses flavour. Here, we reviewed some exogenous enzymes used in industrial cheeses production, or which have interesting potential in cheese making and ripening.

Advances in research on calf rennet substitutes and their effects on cheese quality

Milk coagulation is an important step in cheese production, and milk-clotting enzymes (MCEs) play a major role in this process. Calf rennet is the most widely used MCE in the cheese industry. The use of calf rennet substitutes is becoming necessary due to the limited availability of calf rennet and the increase in cheese consumption. The objective of this review is to summarize the latest findings on calf rennet substitutes (animal MCEs, plant-derived MCEs, recombinant MCEs and microbial MCEs) and their application in cheese production. Special emphasis has been placed on aspects of the effects of these substitutes on hydrolysis, functional peptides, cheese variety and cheese yield. The advantages and disadvantages of different calf rennet substitutes are discussed, in which microbial MCEs have the advantages of less expensive production, greater biochemical diversity, easier genetic modification, etc. In particular, some of these MCEs have suitable characteristics for cheese production and are considered to be the most potential calf rennet substitutes. Moreover, challenges and future perspectives are presented to provide inspiration for the development of excellent calf rennet substitutes.

The effects of camel chymosin and Withania coagulans extract on camel and bovine milk cheeses

Withania coagulans (W. coagulans) extract and camel chymosin have aspartic protease capable of coagulating milk for cheese production. This study investigated the quality of camel and bovine milk cheeses coagulated using Withania extracts, came chymosin, and their mixture in two experiments. In Experiment (1), a factorial design with four factors (W. coagulans, camel chymosin, incubation time, and incubation temperature) was performed. The effect of these factors on cheese's yield and hardness were assessed. An enzyme concentration corresponding to a 36 µg/L of milk of W. coagulans, 50 IMCU/L of camel chymosin, holding time of 4 h, and incubation temperature of 60 °C provided the optimal textural hardness for both camel and bovine milk cheeses. Seven treatments were analyzed in experiment (2) were analyzed for physicochemical properties, yield, and sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGEitation). The results showed that pure Withania extract exhibited the lower coagulating effect resulting in cheeses with low yield, hardness, fat, protein, and total solids. The SDS-PAGE electropherograms of camel cheese showed several low molecular weight bands as compared to bovine cheese. This phenomenon is due to excessive proteolysis in camel cheese, which we believed is caused by the presence of endogenous enzymes.

Effects of Pasteurization and High-Pressure Processing of Camel and Bovine Cheese Quality, and Proteolysis Contribution to Camel Cheese Softness

The effects of high-pressure processing (HPP) compared to thermal treatments on the quality of camel vs. bovine cheeses were studied. The study showed that camel milk has a lower microbial load compared to bovine milk, which is maintained during 7 days' storage of the processed milk. The effect of three HPP treatments (350, 450, and 550 MPa for 5 min at 4°C) and two pasteurization treatments (65°C for 30 min and 75°C for 30 s) on the quality of soft unripened camel and bovine milk cheeses were accessed. The cheeses were evaluated for pH, yield, proximate composition, textural and rheological properties, microstructure, and protein profile by SDS-PAGE electrophoresis. The effects of the treatments on cheese's hardness were different between the camel and bovine cheeses; while heat treatment at 65°C for 30 min gave the hardest bovine milk cheese (1,253 ± 20), HPP treatment at 350 MPa for 5 min gave the highest value for camel milk cheese (519 ± 5) (p < 0.05). The hardness of the cheeses was associated with low yield and moisture content. SDS-PAGE electrophoresis revealed that extensive proteolysis might have contributed to the softness of camel cheeses compared to bovine and suggested the involvement of some residual enzyme activities.

Biological activities of the bioaccessible compounds after in vitro digestion of low-fat Akawi cheese made from blends of bovine and camel milk

The objective of this study was to assess protein degradation and biological activities of the water-soluble extract (WSE) and the 10 kDa permeable and nonpermeable fractions of in vitro digesta of low-fat Akawi cheese made from blends (100:0, 85:15, or 70:30) of bovine milk and camel milk and ripened for 28 d. Biological activities, such as antioxidant activities, amylase and glucosidase inhibition, angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibition, and antiproliferative of the WSE, and the 10 kDa permeable and nonpermeable fraction of the digesta were assessed. To identify the nature of the bioaccessible compounds, untargeted metabolomic analysis was carried out by ultra-high performance liquid chromatography-quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometry. Higher o-phthaldialdehyde absorbances were observed in cheeses made of bovine-camel milk blends compared with cheese from bovine milk only. The WSE from these blends also exhibited higher angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitory effects and higher antiproliferative effects than from bovine milk. The results from this study suggest that the use of blends of camel milk and bovine milk can modulate biological activities of low-fat Akawi cheese.

Constitutive expression of Camelus bactrianus prochymosin B in Pichia pastoris

Camel chymosin can be efficiently employed to produce cheese. Traditionally the rennet enzyme produced by the glands of the fourth stomach of ruminant animals (abomassum) is used in cheese making. Full-length Camelus bactrianus (Bactrian camel) prochymosin gene was synthesized and constitutively expressed in Pichia pastoris cells under glyceraldehydes-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAP) promoter. It was purified by sequential anion and cation exchange chromatography. SDS-PAGE analysis resulted in two bands, approximately 42 and 35 kDa. The 42 kDa band vanished when the sample was treated with endoglycosidase H, indicating that the recombinant protein is partially glycosylated. Optimal pH for the activity of the highest-purity recombinant chymosin was pH 4.5 for cow's milk and pH 4.0 for mare's milk. The range 45-50 °C and 70 °C for cow's and mare's milk types, respectively, was found to be the most appropriate for maximal relative milk-clotting activity. Concentration of CaCl2 that ensured the stability of the chymosin milk-clotting activity was between 20 and 50 mM with an optimum at 30 mM. Milk-clotting activity of camel recombinant chymosin and ability to make curd was successfully tested on fresh mare's milk. Pichia pastoris strain with integrated camel chymosin gene showed high productivity of submerged fermentation in bioreactor with milk-clotting activity 1412 U/mL and 80 mg/L enzyme yield. These results suggest that the constitutive expression of the camel chymosin Camelus bactrianus in the yeast Pichia pastoris has good prospects for practical applications.