Comparison of two strategies for ex vivo lung perfusion

Porcine lungs perfused with three different flows using the 8-h open-atrium cellular ex vivo lung perfusion technique

The number of lung transplantations is limited due to the shortage of donor lungs fulfilling the standard criteria. The ex vivo lung perfusion (EVLP) technique provides the ability of re-evaluating and potentially improving and treating marginal donor lungs. Accordingly, the technique has emerged as an essential tool to increase the much-needed donor lung pool. One of the major EVLP protocols, the Lund protocol, characterized by high pulmonary artery flow (100% of cardiac output [CO]), an open atrium, and a cellular perfusate, has demonstrated encouraging short-EVLP duration results. However, the potential of the longer EVLP duration of the protocol is yet to be investigated, a duration which is considered necessary to rescue more marginal donor lungs in future. This study aimed to achieve stable 8-h EVLP using an open-atrium cellular model with three different pulmonary artery flows in addition to determining the most optimal flow in terms of best lung performance, including lung electrolytes and least lung edema formation, perfusate and tissue inflammation, and histopathological changes, using the porcine model. EVLP was performed using a flow of either 40% (n = 6), 80% (n = 6), or 100% (n = 6) of CO. No flow rate demonstrated stable 8-h EVLP. Stable 2-h EVLP was observed in all three groups. Insignificant deterioration was observed in dynamic compliance, peak airway pressure, and oxygenation between the groups. Pulmonary vascular resistance increased significantly in the 40% group (p < .05). Electrolytes demonstrated an insignificant worsening trend with longer EVLP. Interleukin-8 (IL-8) in perfusate and tissue, wet-to-dry weight ratio, and histopathological changes after EVLP were insignificantly time dependent between the groups. This study demonstrated that stable 8-h EVLP was not feasible in an open-atrium cellular model regardless of the flow of 40%, 80%, or 100% of CO. No flow was superior in terms of lung performance, lung electrolytes changes, least lung edema formation, minimal IL-8 expression in perfusate and tissue, and histopathological changes.

Technical Advances Targeting Multiday Preservation of Isolated Ex Vivo Lung Perfusion

Indications for ex vivo lung perfusion (EVLP) have evolved from assessment of questionable donor lungs to treatment of some pathologies and the logistics. Yet up to 3 quarters of donor lungs remain discarded across the globe. Multiday preservation of discarded human lungs on EVLP platforms would improve donor lung utilization rates via application of sophisticated treatment modalities, which could eventually result in zero waitlist mortality. The purpose of this article is to summarize advances made on the technical aspects of the protocols in achieving a stable multiday preservation of isolated EVLP. Based on the evidence derived from large animal and/or human studies, the following advances have been considered important in achieving this goal: ability to reposition donor lungs during EVLP; perfusate adsorption/filtration modalities; perfusate enrichment with plasma and/or donor whole blood, nutrients, vitamins, and amino acids; low-flow, pulsatile, and subnormothermic perfusion; positive outflow pressure; injury specific personalized ventilation strategies; and negative pressure ventilation. Combination of some of these advances in an automatized EVLP device capable of managing perfusate biochemistry and ventilation would likely speed up the processes of achieving multiday preservation of isolated EVLP.

Lung Donor Selection and Management: An Updated Review

The shortage of donor lungs for transplantation is a major challenge, resulting in longer waitlist times for patients with a higher risk of waitlist mortality. It is crucial to continue promoting awareness about organ donation through legislation, public campaigns, and health care provider education. Only a small number of cadaveric donors meet the ideal criteria for lung donation, leaving many lungs unused. Donor lung utilization can be improved by carefully considering the extended-criteria donors, actively participating in donor management, and by utilizing the modalities to assess and manage the marginal lungs after retrieval from the donor. The purpose of this article is to provide an up-to-date review of donor selection, assessment of donor lungs, and donor lung management to enhance organ recovery rates for lung transplantation.

Current status and future potential of ex vivo lung perfusion in clinical lung transplantation

Lung transplantation is accepted as a well-established and effective treatment for patients with end-stage lung disease. While the number of candidates added to the waitlist continues to rise, the number of transplants performed remains limited by the number of suitable organ donors. Ex vivo lung perfusion (EVLP) emerged as a method of addressing the organ shortage by allowing the evaluation and potential reconditioning of marginal donor lungs or minimizing risks of prolonged ischemic time due to logistical challenges. The currently available FDA-approved EVLP systems have demonstrated excellent outcomes in clinical trials, and retrospective studies have demonstrated similar post-transplant survival between recipients who received marginal donor lungs perfused using EVLP and recipients who received standard criteria lungs stored using conventional methods. Despite this, widespread utilization has plateaued in the last few years, likely due to the significant costs associated with initiating EVLP programs. Centralized, dedicated EVLP perfusion centers are currently being investigated as a potential method of further expanding utilization of this technology. In the preclinical setting, potential applications of EVLP that are currently being studied include prolongation of organ preservation, reconditioning of unsuitable lungs, and further enhancement of already suitable lungs. As adoption of EVLP technology becomes more widespread, we may begin to see future implementation of these potential applications into the clinical setting.

Establishing an economical and widely accessible donation after circulatory death animal abattoir model for lung research using ex vivo lung perfusion

BACKGROUND

Ex vivo lung perfusion (EVLP), is a platform that allows simultaneous testing and treatment of the lungs. However, use of EVLP is costly and requires access to lab animals and accompanying facilities. To increase the use of EVLP for research, we developed a method to perform EVLP using abattoir procured lungs. Furthermore, we were also able to significantly decrease costs.

METHODS

Six pair of lungs were procured from abattoir sheep. The lungs were then flushed and stored in ice for 3 h. A low-flow (20% of cardiac output) approach, a tidal volume of 6 ml/kg bodyweight and total perfusion time of 3 h were chosen. Perfusion fluids and circuits were self-made. Lung biopsies, perfusate collection, respiratory values, circulatory pressures were recorded and hourly blood gas analyses were performed.

RESULTS

Mean pO₂ remained stable from 60 min (49.3 ± 7.1 kPa) to 180 min (51.5 kPa ± 8.0), p = 0.66. Pulmonary artery pressure remained ≤15 mm Hg and the left atrial pressure remained between 3 and 5 mm Hg and peak respiratory pressures ≤20 cmH₂ O. Lactate dehydrogenase increased from start (96.3 ± 56.4 U/L) to the end of perfusion (315.8 ± 85.0 U/L), p < 0.05. No difference was observed in ATP between procurement and post-EVLP, 129.7 ± 37.4 μmol/g protein to 132.0 ± 23.4 μmol/g, p = 0.92.

CONCLUSIONS

Sheep lungs, acquired from an abattoir, can be ex vivo perfused under similar conditions as lab animal lungs with similar results regarding e.g., oxygenation and ATP restoration. Furthermore, costs can be significantly reduced by making use of this abattoir model. By increasing accessibility and lowering costs for experiments using lung perfusion, more results may be achieved in the field of lung diseases.

Taking a Deep Breath: an Examination of Current Controversies in Surgical Procedures in Lung Transplantation

Purpose of Review

This article reviews controversial questions within the field of lung transplantation, with a focus on data generated within the last 3 years. We aim to summarize differing opinions on a selection of topics, including bridge-to-transplantation, intraoperative machine circulatory support, bronchial anastomosis, size mismatch, delayed chest closure, and ex vivo lung perfusion.

Recent Findings

With the growing rate of lung transplantations worldwide and increasing numbers of patients placed on waiting lists, the importance of determining best practices has only increased in recent years. Factors which promote successful outcomes have been identified across all the topics, with certain approaches promoted, such as ambulation in bridge-to-transplant and widespread intraoperative ECMO as machine support.

Summary

While great strides have been made in the operative procedures involved in lung transplantation, there are still key questions to be answered. The consensus which can be reached will be instrumental in further improving outcomes in recipients.

Ex Vivo Lung Perfusion: Current Achievements and Future Directions

There is a severe shortage in the availability of donor organs for lung transplantation. Novel strategies are needed to optimize usage of available organs to address the growing global needs. Ex vivo lung perfusion has emerged as a powerful tool for the assessment, rehabilitation, and optimization of donor lungs before transplantation. In this review, we discuss the history of ex vivo lung perfusion, current evidence on its use for standard and extended criteria donors, and consider the exciting future opportunities that this technology provides for lung transplantation.

Human Lungs Airway Epithelium Upregulate MicroRNA-17 and MicroRNA-548b in Response to Cold Ischemia and Ex Vivo Reperfusion

BACKGROUND

Lung ischemia-reperfusion injury after transplantation is associated with worse clinical outcomes. MicroRNA (miR) are critical regulators of gene expression that could provide potential targets for novel gene therapy. Herein, we aim to examine the feasibility of using the ex vivo lung perfusion (EVLP) platform to examine the changes in miR expression in human lungs in response to cold ischemia and ex vivo reperfusion (CI/EVR).

METHODS

Twenty-four human lungs were perfused in cellular EVLP system for 2 h, and tissue samples were obtained before and after EVLP as well as from control donors. MicroRNA expression profiling of the lung tissue was performed using next-generation sequencing and downstream predicted target genes were examined. In situ hybridization assay of the validated miR was used to identify the expressing cell type.

RESULTS

After 2 h of EVLP, cytokines production was significantly increased (IL-1β, IL-6, IL-8, IL-10, and TNF-α). MicroRNA sequencing identified a significant change in the expression of a total of 21 miR after CI and 47 miR after EVR. Validation using quantitative polymerase chain reaction showed significant upregulation of miR-17 and miR548b after CI/EVR. Downstream analysis identified abundant inflammatory and immunologic targets for miR-17 and miR-548b that are known mediators of lung injury. In situ hybridization assays detected positive signals of the 2 miR expression in alveolar epithelial cells.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates the feasibility of using the EVLP platform to study miR signature in human lungs in response to CI/EVR. We found that miR-17 and miR-548b were upregulated in alveolar epithelial cells after CI/EVR, which merit further exploration.

Early pulmonary function and mid-term outcome in lung transplantation after ex-vivo lung perfusion - a single-center, retrospective, observational, cohort study

Outcomes after transplantation of lungs (LuTX) treated with ex-vivo lung perfusion (EVLP) are debated. In a single-center 8 years of retrospective analysis, we compared: donors' and recipients' characteristics, gas exchange and lung mechanics at ICU admission, 3, 6, and 12 months, and patients' survival of LuTX from standard donors compared with EVLP-treated grafts. A total of 193 LuTX were performed. Thirty-one LuTX, out of 50 EVLP procedures, were carried out: 7 from nonheart beating and 24 from extended criteria brain-dead donors. Recipients' characteristics were similar. At ICU admission, compared with standard donors, EVLP patients had worse PaO₂ /FiO₂ [276 (206; 374) vs. 204 (133; 245) mmHg, P < 0.05], more frequent extracorporeal support (18% vs. 32%, P = 0.053) and longer mechanical ventilation duration [28 days of ventilator-free days: 27 (24; 28) vs. 26 (19; 27), P < 0.05]. ICU length of stay [4 (2; 9) vs. 6 (3; 12) days, P = 0.208], 28-day survival (99% vs. 97%, P = 0.735), and 1-year respiratory function were similar between groups. Log-rank analysis (median follow-up 2.5 years) demonstrated similar patients' survival (P = 0.439) and time free of chronic lung allograft disease (P = 0.484). The EVLP program increased by 16% the number of LuTX. Compared to standard donors, EVLP patients had worse respiratory function immediately after LuTX but similar early and mid-term outcomes.

Cellular Ex Vivo Lung Perfusion Beyond 1 Hour May Improve Marginal Donor Lung Assessment

BACKGROUND

Ex vivo lung perfusion (EVLP) permits extended evaluation of donor lungs for transplant. However, the optimal EVLP duration of Lund protocol is unclear. Using human lungs rejected for clinical transplant, we sought to compare the results of 1 versus 2 h of EVLP using the Lund protocol.

METHODS

Twenty-five pairs of human lungs rejected for clinical transplant were perfused with the Lund EVLP protocol. Blood gas analysis, lung compliance, bronchoscopy assessment, and perfusate cytokine analysis were performed at both 1 and 2 h. Recruitment was performed at both time points. Donor lung transplant suitability was determined at both time points.

RESULTS

All cases were divided into four groups based on transplant suitability assessment at 1 h and 2 h of EVLP. In group A (n = 10), lungs were judged suitable for transplant at both 1 and 2 h of EVLP. In group B (n = 6), lungs were suitable at 1 h but nonsuitable at 2 h. In group C (n = 2), lungs were nonsuitable at 1 h but suitable at 2 h. Finally, in group D (n = 7), lungs were nonsuitable for transplant at both time points. In both groups B and C (n = 8), the transplant suitability assessment changed between 1 and 2 h of EVLP.

CONCLUSIONS

In human lungs rejected for transplant, transplant suitability differed at 1 versus 2 h of EVLP in 32% of lungs studied. Evaluation of lungs with Lund protocol EVLP beyond 1 h may improve donor organ assessment.

Endothelial Glycocalyx Shedding Occurs during Ex Vivo Lung Perfusion: A Pilot Study

Background

Damage to the endothelium has been established as a key pathological process in lung transplantation and ex vivo lung perfusion (EVLP), a new technology that provides a platform for the assessment of injured donor lungs. Damage to the lung endothelial glycocalyx, a structure that lines the endothelium and is integral to vascular barrier function, has been associated with lung dysfunction. We hypothesised that endothelial glycocalyx shedding occurs during EVLP and aimed to establish a porcine model to investigate the mechanism underlying glycocalyx breakdown during EVLP.

Methods

Concentrations of endothelial glycocalyx breakdown products, syndecan-1, hyaluronan, heparan sulphate, and CD44, were measured using the ELISA and matrix metalloproteinase (MMP) activity by zymography in the perfusate of both human (n = 9) and porcine (n = 4) lungs undergoing EVLP. Porcine lungs underwent prolonged EVLP (up to 12 hours) with perfusion and ventilation parameters recorded hourly.

Results

During human EVLP, endothelial glycocalyx breakdown products in the perfusate increased over time. Increasing MMP-2 activity over time was positively correlated with levels of syndecan-1 (r = 0.886; p=0.03) and hyaluronan (r = 0.943; p=0.02). In the porcine EVLP model, hyaluronan was the only glycocalyx product detectable during EVLP (1 hr: 19 (13–84) vs 12 hr: 143 (109–264) ng/ml; p=0.13). Porcine hyaluronan was associated with MMP-9 activity (r = 0.83; p=0.02) and also with dynamic compliance (r = 0.57; p=0.03).

Conclusion

Endothelial glycocalyx products accumulate during both porcine and human EVLP, and this accumulation parallels an accumulation of matrix-degrading enzyme activity. Preliminary evidence in our porcine EVLP model suggests that shedding may be related to organ function, thus warranting additional study.

Implementation of an experimental isolated lung perfusion model on surgically resected human lobes

Isolated lung perfusion (ILP) is an ideal model to study treatment effects on a variety of pathologies. As published research mostly relies on rejected donor lungs or animal organs, this study investigates the use of surgically resected human lobes as an alternative and novel model for personalized experimental research. Ten surgically resected lobes were perfused in acellular and normothermic condition. The indication for surgery was lung cancer. Perfusion and ventilation were adapted to the size of the lobes and both functional and metabolic parameters were assessed during ILP. Patients (age 67.5 y (59–81)|♀n = 3|♂n = 7) underwent anatomic pulmonary lobectomy. Ischemic time between arterial ligation and ILP was 226 minutes (161–525). Median duration of ILP was 135 (87–366) minutes. Gas exchange and mechanical respiratory parameters remained steady during ILP (pulmonary venous pO₂ 196(151–219) mmHg | peak AWP: 14.5(11–22) cmH₂O). Metabolism stayed constant during ILP (Glucose consumption: 1.86 mg/min/L_TLC (95%CI: −2.09 to −1.63) | lactate production: 0.005 mmol/min/ L_TLC (95%CI: 0.004 to 0.007)). ILP of surgically resected human lobes is a feasible and promising method. By maintaining a near physiological setting, this model may pave the way for future experimental lung research including cancer research, transplantation, physiology, pharmacology and mechanical ventilation.

Continuous Hemodialysis Does Not Improve Graft Function During Ex Vivo Lung Perfusion Over 24 Hours

BACKGROUND

Extended periods of ex vivo lung perfusion (EVLP) lead to several inadvertent consequences including accumulation of lactate and increasing electrolyte concentrations in the perfusate. We sought to determine whether continuous hemodialysis (CHD) of the perfusate would be a suitable modality for improving ionic homeostasis in extended EVLP without compromising functional outcomes.

METHODS

Twelve porcine lungs were perfused using EVLP for 24 hours. All lungs were ventilated with negative pressure ventilation. Lungs in the treatment group (n = 6) underwent continuous hemodialysis of the perfusate. Functional parameters, edema formation, and histopathologic analysis were used to assess graft function. Electrolyte and lactate profiles were also followed to assess the efficiency of hemodialysis.

RESULTS

Lungs in both treatment and control groups demonstrated stable and acceptable oxygenation to 24 hours. Lungs demonstrated a decrease in compliance over time. There was no difference in oxygenation and compliance between groups. CHD-EVLP lungs had higher pulmonary vascular resistance and pulmonary artery pressures. Despite increased perfusion pressures, weight gain at both 11 and 23 hours was not different between groups. Perfusate sodium and lactate concentrations were significantly lower in the CHD-EVLP group.

CONCLUSION

The addition of continuous hemodialysis to EVLP did not improve graft function up to 24 hours despite improved maintenance of perfusate composition.

Lung transplantation after ex vivo lung perfusion in two Scandinavian centres

OBJECTIVES

We reviewed our combined clinical outcome in patients who underwent lung transplantation after ex vivo lung perfusion (EVLP) and compared it to the contemporary control group.

METHODS

At 2 Scandinavian centres, lungs from brain-dead donors, not accepted for donation but with potential for improvement, were subjected to EVLP (n = 61) and were transplanted if predefined criteria were met. Transplantation outcome was compared with that of the contemporary control group consisting of patients (n = 271) who were transplanted with conventional donor lungs.

RESULTS

Fifty-four recipients from the regular waiting list underwent transplantation with lungs subjected to EVLP (1 bilateral lobar, 7 single and 46 double). In the EVLP and control groups, arterial oxygen tension/inspired oxygen fraction ratio at arrival in the intensive care unit (ICU) was 30 ± 14 kPa compared to 36 ± 14 (P = 0.005); median time to extubation was 18 h (range 2-912) compared to 7 (range 0-2280) (P = 0.002); median ICU length of stay was 4 days (range 2-65) compared to 3 days (range 1-156) (P = 0.002); Percentage of expected forced expiratory volume at 1s (FEV1.0%) at 1 year was 75 ± 29 compared to 81 ± 26 (P = 0.18); and the 1-year survival rate was 87% [confidence interval (CI) 82-92%] compared to 83% (CI 81-85), respectively. Follow-up to a maximum of 5 years did not show any significant difference in survival between groups (log rank, P = 0.63).

CONCLUSIONS

Patients transplanted with lungs after EVLP showed outcomes comparable to patients who received conventional organs at medium-term follow-up. Although early outcome immediately after transplantation showed worse lung function in the EVLP group, no differences were observed at a later stage, and we consider EVLP to be a safe method for increasing the number of transplantable organs.

A novel concept for evaluation of pulmonary function utilizing PaO2/FiO2 difference at the distinctive FiO2 in cellular ex vivo lung perfusion-an experimental study

For more accurate lung evaluation in ex vivo lung perfusion (EVLP), we have devised a new parameter, PaO₂ /FiO₂ ratio difference (PFD); PFD_1-0.4  = P/F ratio at FiO₂ 1.0 - P/F ratio at FiO₂ 0.4. The aim of this study is to compare PFD and transplant suitability, and physiological parameters utilized in cellular EVLP. Thirty-nine human donor lungs were perfused. At 2 h of EVLP, PFD_1-0.4 was compared with transplant suitability and physiological parameters. In a second study, 10 pig lungs were perfused in same fashion. PFD_1-0.4 was calculated by blood from upper and lower lobe pulmonary veins and compared with lobe wet/dry ratio and pathological findings. In human model, receiver operating characteristic curve analysis showed PFD_1-0.4 had the highest area under curve, 0.90, sensitivity, 0.96, to detect nonsuitable lungs, and significant negative correlation with lung weight ratio (R²  = 0.26, P < 0.001). In pig model, PFD_1-0.4 on lower and upper lobe pulmonary veins were significantly associated with corresponding lobe wet/dry ratios (R²  = 0.51, P = 0.019; R²  = 0.37, P = 0.060), respectively. PFD_1-0.4 in EVLP demonstrated a significant correlation with lung weight ratio and allowed more precise assessment of individual lobes in detecting lung edema. Moreover, it might support decision-making in evaluation with current EVLP criteria.

Cellular and acellular ex vivo lung perfusion preserve functional lung ultrastructure in a large animal model: a stereological study

Background

Ex vivo lung perfusion (EVLP) is used by an increasing number of transplant centres. It is still controversial whether an acellular or cellular (erythrocyte enriched) perfusate is preferable. The aim of this paper was to evaluate whether acellular (aEVLP) or cellular EVLP (cEVLP) preserves functional lung ultrastructure better and to generate a hypothesis regarding possible underlying mechanisms.

Methods

Lungs of 20 pigs were assigned to 4 groups: control, ischaemia (24 h), aEVLP and cEVLP (both EVLP groups: 24 h ischaemia + 12 h EVLP). After experimental procedures, whole lungs were perfusion fixed, samples for light and electron microscopic stereology were taken, and ventilation, diffusion and perfusion related parameters were estimated.

Results

Lung structure was well preserved in all groups. Lungs had less atelectasis and higher air content after EVLP. No significant group differences were found in alveolar septum composition or blood-air barrier thickness. Small amounts of intraalveolar oedema were detected in both EVLP groups but significantly more in aEVLP than in cEVLP.

Conclusions

Both EVLP protocols supported lungs well for up to 12 h and could largely prevent ischaemia ex vivo reperfusion associated lung injury. In both EVLP groups, oedema volume remained below the level of functional relevance. The group difference in oedema formation was possibly due to inferior septal perfusion in aEVLP.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1186/s12931-018-0942-5) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Machine perfusion of thoracic organs

This article summarizes recent knowledge and clinical advances in machine perfusion (MP) of thoracic organs. MP of thoracic organs has gained much attention during the last decade. Clinical studies are investigating the role of MP to preserve, resuscitate, and assess heart and lungs prior to transplantation. Currently, MP of the cardiac allograft is essential in all type DCD heart transplantation while MP of the pulmonary allograft is mandatory in uncontrolled DCD lung transplantation. MP of thoracic organs also offers an exciting platform to further investigate downregulation of the innate and adaptive immunity prior to reperfusion of the allograft in recipients. MP provides a promising technology that allows pre-transplant preservation, resuscitation, assessment, repair, and conditioning of cardiac and pulmonary allografts outside the body in a near physiologic state prior to planned transplantation. Results of ongoing clinical trials are awaited to estimate the true clinical value of this new technology in advancing the field of heart and lung transplantation by increasing the total number and the quality of available organs and by further improving recipient early and long-term outcome.