SfABCC2 transporter extracellular loops 2 and 4 are responsible for the Cry1Fa insecticidal specificity against Spodoptera frugiperda

Interactions between insecticidal cry toxins and their receptors

Bacillus thuringiensis is a prominent, eco-friendly entomopathogenic bacterium used as a plant-incorporated toxin in genetically modified crops and as a stomach poison for insects in the form of spore formulations. Upon entering the alkaline environment of the insect gut, the toxin undergoes proteolytic breakdown, converting the protoxin into its activated form. The activated toxin then binds to receptors, forming pores that disrupt the ionic balance within the cell, ultimately leading to the insect's death. Alongside the four major receptors (Cadherin, ABCC, APN, and ALP), several other notable receptors are present on the Brush Border Membrane Vesicle of insects. Binding to these receptors plays a crucial role, and any mutations in these receptors can result in improper binding, leading to the development of resistant insect strains. This review explores the major receptors of insecticidal Cry toxins, the intricate interactions between toxins and receptors, receptor mutations, and strategies to overcome the resistance.

Insights into the structural changes that trigger receptor binding upon proteolytic activation of Bacillus thuringiensis Vip3Aa insecticidal protein

Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) bacteria produce different pore forming toxins with insecticidal activity, including Cry and Vip3 proteins. While both Cry and Vip3 cause insect death by forming pores in susceptible lepidopteran larval midgut cells, their mechanisms of action differ. The Vip3Aa protoxin adopts a tetramer-structure, where each monomer has five distinct domains. Upon proteolytic activation, the Vip3 tetramer undergoes a large conformational change forming a syringe like structure that is ready for membrane insertion and pore formation. Here we show that Vip3Aa protoxin had low binding to Spodoptera frugiperda brush border membrane vesicles (BBMV) unlike the activated toxin that bound specifically in a concentration dependent way, suggesting that a structural change upon Vip3Aa proteolytic activation is required for efficient receptor binding. Consistently, the Vip3Aa protoxin showed no toxicity to Sf9 cells compared to the activated toxin. In contrast, Cry1Fa protoxin and its activated toxin, were both highly toxic to Sf9 cells. To identify the region of Vip3 involved in binding to BBMV proteins, different overlapping peptides from Vip3Aa covering domains III, IV and V were expressed, and binding analysis were performed against BBMV, showing that domain III is the primary binding domain. Additionally, domains III, IV and V amino acid residues that become exposed upon activation of Vip3Aa were identified. Mutagenesis of these exposed residues revealed three amino acids (K385, K526 and V529) located in two structural adjacent loops, domain III loop β5-β6 and loop α11-β16 that connects domains III and IV, that are crucial for binding to the midguts of S. frugiperda larvae and for toxicity. Our results demonstrate that proteolytic activation of Vip3Aa exposes a receptor binding region essential for its toxicity.

Transcriptional regulation of Cry2Ab toxin receptor ABCA2 gene in insects involves GATAe and splicing of a 5' UTR intron

Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) produces Cry toxins that are used to control insect pests worldwide. However, evolution of insect resistance threatens the sustainable application of these toxins. In some cases, Cry toxin resistance has been linked to mutations affecting toxin receptors expression. Previous work identified HaGATAe transcriptional factor (TF) to be involved in the expression of multiple Cry1 receptor genes. Also, it was reported that 5´untranslated region (UTR) could be involved in regulation of gene expression in eukaryotic cells. The ABCA2 protein functions as Cry2A toxin receptor in multiple lepidopteran species. Here, we investigated regulation of HaABCA2 expression in Helicoverpa armigera and in different insect cell lines. Transient expression of HaABCA2 gene resulted in susceptibility to Cry2Ab in Sf9 cells. Transient expression of HaGATAe transcriptional factor in Sf9 cells enhanced the expression of multiple larval midgut proteins including SfABCA2, increasing the susceptibility to activated Cry2Ab. The silencing of HaGATAe expression in H. armigera larvae by RNAi, resulted in lower expression of HaABCA2 which correlated with reduced susceptibility to Cry2Ab. The GATAe-binding site in the promoter of HaABCA2 gene was identified by systematic truncations, site directed mutagenesis and DNA Pull-down analysis. In addition, 5' RACE analysis revealed that HaABCA2 transcripts in larval midgut cells had at least three different 5' UTRs. Here we also show that the retention of an intron in one of these 5' UTRs significantly inhibited the HaABCA2 expression. A short sequence after the start codon of translation of HaABCA2 was identified to be required for the intron removal. These findings provide new insight for mechanism of Cry2Ab resistance in H. armigera.

Contribution of the transcription factor SfGATAe to Bt Cry toxin resistance in Spodoptera frugiperda through reduction of ABCC2 expression

Insect resistance evolution poses a significant threat to the advantages of biopesticides and transgenic crops utilizing insecticidal Cry-toxins from Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt). However, there is limited research on the relationship between transcriptional regulation of specific toxin receptors in lepidopteran insects and their resistance to Bt toxins. Here, we report the positive regulatory role of the SfGATAe transcription factor on the expression of the ABCC2 gene in Spodoptera frugiperda. DNA regions in the SfABCC2 promoter that are vital for regulation by SfGATAe, utilizing DAP-seq technology and promoter deletion mapping. Through yeast one-hybrid assays, DNA pull-down experiments, and site-directed mutagenesis, we confirmed that the transcription factor SfGATAe regulates the core control site PBS2 in the ABCC2 target gene. Tissue-specific expression analysis has revealed that SfGATAe is involved in the regulation and expression of midgut cells in the fall armyworm. Silencing SfGATAe in fall armyworm larvae resulted in reduced expression of SfABCC2 and decreased sensitivity to Cry1Ac toxin. Overall, this study elucidated the regulatory mechanism of the transcription factor SfGATAe on the expression of the toxin receptor gene SfABCC2 and this transcriptional control mechanism impacts the resistance of the fall armyworm to Bt toxins.

Individual transmembrane domains of SfABCC2 from Spodoptera frugiperda do not serve as functional Cry1F receptors

The fall armyworm (Spodoptera frugiperda) is a major global pest causing severe damage to various crops, especially corn. Transgenic corn producing the Cry1F pesticidal protein from the bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis (Cry1F corn) showed effectiveness in controlling this pest until S. frugiperda populations at locations in North and South America evolved practical resistance. The mechanism for practical resistance involved disruptive mutations in an ATP binding cassette transporter subfamily C2 gene (SfABCC2), which serves as a functional Cry1F receptor in the midgut cells of susceptible S. frugiperda. The SfABCC2 protein contains two transmembrane domains (TMD1 and TMD2), each with a cytosolic nucleotide (ATP) binding domain (NBD1 and NBD2, respectively). Previous reports have demonstrated that disruptive mutations in TMD2 were linked with resistance to Cry1F, yet whether the complete SfABCC2 structure is needed for receptor functionality or if a single TMD-NBD protein can serve as functional Cry1F receptor remains unknown. In the present study, we separately expressed TMD1 and TMD2 with their corresponding NBDs in cultured insect cells and tested their Cry1F receptor functionality. Our results show that the complete SfABCC2 structure is required for Cry1F receptor functionality. Moreover, binding competition assays revealed that Cry1F specifically bound to SfABCC2, whereas neither SfTMD1-NBD1 nor SfTMD2-NBD2 exhibited any significant binding. These results provide insights into the molecular mechanism of Cry1F recognition by SfABCC2 in S. frugiperda, which could facilitate the development of more effective insecticidal proteins.

Screening for resistance alleles to Cry1 proteins through targeted sequencing in the native and invasive range of Spodoptera frugiperda (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae)

The fall armyworm, Spodoptera frugiperda (J. E. Smith), is a highly polyphagous pest native to the tropical Americas that has recently spread to become a global super-pest threatening food and fiber production. Transgenic crops producing insecticidal Cry and Vip3Aa proteins from Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) are used for control of this pest in its native range. The evolution of practical resistance represents the greatest threat to sustainability of this technology and its potential efficacy in the S. frugiperda invasive range. Monitoring for resistance is vital to management approaches delaying S. frugiperda resistance to Bt crops. DNA-based resistance screening provides higher sensitivity and cost-effectiveness than currently used bioassay-based monitoring. So far, practical S. frugiperda resistance to Bt corn-producing Cry1F has been genetically linked to mutations in the SfABCC2 gene, providing a model to develop and test monitoring tools. In this study, we performed targeted SfABCC2 sequencing followed by Sanger sequencing to confirm the detection of known and candidate resistance alleles to Cry1F corn in field-collected S. frugiperda from continental USA, Puerto Rico, Africa (Ghana, Togo, and South Africa), and Southeast Asia (Myanmar). Results confirm that the distribution of a previously characterized resistance allele (SfABCC2mut) is limited to Puerto Rico and identify 2 new candidate SfABCC2 alleles for resistance to Cry1F, one of them potentially spreading along the S. frugiperda migratory route in North America. No candidate resistance alleles were found in samples from the invasive S. frugiperda range. These results provide support for the potential use of targeted sequencing in Bt resistance monitoring programs.

Genetic mutations linked to field-evolved Cry1Fa-resistance in the European corn borer, Ostrinia nubilalis

Transgenic corn, Zea mays (L.), expressing insecticidal toxins such as Cry1Fa, from Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt corn) targeting Ostrinia nubilalis (Hübner) (Lepidoptera: Crambidae) resulted in over 20 years of management success. The first case of practical field-evolved resistance by O. nubilalis to a Bt corn toxin, Cry1Fa, was discovered in Nova Scotia, Canada, in 2018. Laboratory-derived Cry1Fa-resistance by O. nubilalis was linked to a genome region encoding the ATP Binding Cassette subfamily C2 (ABCC2) gene; however, the involvement of ABCC2 and specific mutations in the gene leading to resistance remain unknown. Using a classical candidate gene approach, we report on O. nubilalis ABCC2 gene mutations linked to laboratory-derived and field-evolved Cry1Fa-resistance. Using these mutations, a DNA-based genotyping assay was developed to test for the presence of the Cry1Fa-resistance alleles in O. nubilalis strains collected in Canada. Screening data provide strong evidence that field-evolved Cry1Fa-resistance in O. nubilalis maps to the ABCC2 gene and demonstrates the utility of this assay for detecting the Cry1Fa resistance allele in O. nubilalis. This study is the first to describe mutations linked to Bt resistance in O. nubilalis and provides a DNA-based detection method that can be used for monitoring.

Large genomic deletion linked to field-evolved resistance to Cry1F corn in fall armyworm (Spodoptera frugiperda) from Florida

The fall armyworm (Spodoptera frugiperda) is a highly polyphagous lepidopteran pest of relevant food and fiber staple crops. In the Americas, transgenic corn and cotton producing insecticidal proteins from the bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) have controlled and reduced the damage caused by S. frugiperda. However, cases of field-evolved S. frugiperda resistance to Bt corn producing the Cry1F insecticidal protein have been documented in North and South America. When characterized, field resistance to Cry1F is linked to insertions and mutations resulting in a modified or truncated ABC transporter subfamily C2 (SfABCC2) protein that serves as Cry1F receptor in susceptible S. frugiperda. In this work, we present detection of a large genomic deletion (~ 8 kb) affecting the SfABCC2 and an ABC transporter gene subfamily 3 –like gene (SfABCC3) as linked to resistance to Cry1F corn in a S. frugiperda strain from Florida (FL39). Monitoring for this genomic deletion using a discriminatory PCR reaction in field-collected S. frugiperda moths detected individuals carrying this allele in Florida, but not in surrounding states. This is the first report of a large genomic deletion being involved in resistance to a Bt insecticidal protein.

Bacillus thuringiensis Cry1Ac Protoxin and Activated Toxin Exert Differential Toxicity Due to a Synergistic Interplay of Cadherin with ABCC Transporters in the Cotton Bollworm

Bacillus thuringiensis Cry proteins are used worldwide for insect control. It was proposed that Cry-protoxins must be converted into activated toxin by proteases to bind midgut cell proteins to kill insects. However, Cry-protoxins also bind to midgut proteins and kill insects that have evolved resistance to activated toxins suggesting an independent toxicity pathway. Cadherin (CAD) and ABCC transporters are recognized as important receptors for Cry proteins. Here we constructed different Helicoverpa armigera mutations in these receptors by CRISPR/Cas9. HaCAD-KO mutant showed much higher resistance to Cry1Ac activated toxin than to Cry1Ac protoxin. In contrast, the HaABCC2-M and HaABCC3-M mutants showed higher resistance to Cry1Ac-protoxin than to activated toxin. However, in the double HaABCC2/3-KO mutant, very high levels of resistance were observed to both Cry1Ac protoxin and activated toxin, supporting that both ABC transporters have redundant functions for these two proteins. In addition, Hi5 cells transfected with HaCAD were susceptible only to the activated toxin but not to protoxin. In contrast, both forms of Cry1Ac were similarly toxic to Hi5 cells expressing HaABCC2 or HaABCC3. Co-expression of HaCAD with HaABCC2 or HaABCC3 revealed a more important synergistic effect for activated toxin compared to protoxin. Overall, our results show that toxicity of Cry1Ac activated toxin involves synergistic interplay of HaCAD with ABCC transporters, while the Cry1Ac protoxin toxicity is mainly mediated by ABCC transporters with little participation of HaCAD. These data help to understand the mode of action of Cry proteins that will be relevant to enhance efficacy and durability of Bt-crops. IMPORTANCE Better understanding of the mode of action of Bacillus thuringiensis toxins is beneficial for the sustainable application of Bt crops. It is generally accepted that Cry-protoxins need to be activated by proteases to bind with midgut cell proteins and exert toxicity against insects. Here, we provide new insights into the toxic pathway of Cry proteins in the cotton bollworm. First, our results demonstrate that Cry1Ac protoxin is able to exert cytotoxicity against the insect cells expressing ABCC transporters. Second, we reveal that CAD plays a critical role in the different toxicity of protoxin and toxin by facilitating a synergistic interplay with ABCC transporters. Our results provide in vivo and in vitro experimental evidence supporting that Cry1Ac protoxin exerts toxicity against H. armigera via different steps from that of toxin. These new findings on the mode of action of Cry proteins could be beneficial for efficacy enhancement and durability of Bt-crops.

Recombinant Expression of ABCC2 Variants Confirms the Importance of Mutations in Extracellular Loop 4 for Cry1F Resistance in Fall Armyworm

Fall armyworm (FAW), Spodoptera frugiperda, is a highly destructive and invasive global noctuid pest. Its control is based on insecticide applications and Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) insecticidal Cry toxins expressed in transgenic crops, such as Cry1F in Bt corn. Continuous selection pressure has resulted in populations that are resistant to Bt corn, particularly in Brazil. FAW resistance to Cry1F was recently shown to be conferred by mutations of ATP-binding cassette transporter C2 (ABCC2), but several mutations, particularly indels in extracellular loop 4 (ECL4), are not yet functionally validated. We addressed this knowledge gap by baculovirus-free insect cell expression of ABCC2 variants (and ABCC3) by electroporation technology and tested their response to Cry1F, Cry1A.105 and Cry1Ab. We employed a SYTOX^TM orange cell viability test measuring ABCC2-mediated Bt toxin pore formation. In total, we tested seven different FAW ABCC2 variants mutated in ECL4, two mutants modified in nucleotide binding domain (NBD) 2, including a deletion mutant lacking NBD2, and S. frugiperda ABCC3. All tested ECL4 mutations conferred high resistance to Cry1F, but much less to Cry1A.105 and Cry1Ab, whereas mutations in NBD2 hardly affected Bt toxin activity. Our study confirms the importance of indels in ECL4 for Cry1F resistance in S. frugiperda ABCC2.

Genetic Knockouts Indicate That the ABCC2 Protein in the Bollworm Helicoverpa zea Is Not a Major Receptor for the Cry1Ac Insecticidal Protein

Members of the insect ATP binding cassette transporter subfamily C2 (ABCC2) in several moth species are known as receptors for the Cry1Ac insecticidal protein from Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt). Mutations that abolish the functional domains of ABCC2 are known to cause resistance to Cry1Ac, although the reported levels of resistance vary widely depending on insect species. In this study, the function of the ABCC2 gene as a putative Cry1Ac receptor in Helicoverpa zea, a major pest of over 300 crops, was evaluated using CRISPR/Cas9 to progressively eliminate different functional ABCC2 domains. Results from bioassays with edited insect lines support that mutations in ABCC2 were associated with Cry1Ac resistance ratios (RR) ranging from 7.3- to 39.8-fold. No significant differences in susceptibility to Cry1Ac were detected between H. zea with partial or complete ABCC2 knockout, although the highest levels of tolerance were observed when knocking out half of ABCC2. Based on >500-1000-fold RRs reported in similar studies for closely related moth species, the low RRs observed in H. zea knockouts support that ABCC2 is not a major Cry1Ac receptor in this insect.

Genetic Screening to Identify Candidate Resistance Alleles to Cry1F Corn in Fall Armyworm Using Targeted Sequencing

Simple Summary

Monitoring of resistance alleles is critical to the sustainability of transgenic crops producing insecticidal Cry proteins. Highly sensitive and cost-effective DNA-based methods are needed to improve current bioassay-based resistance screening. Our goal was to evaluate the use of targeted sequencing in detecting known and novel candidate resistance alleles to Cry proteins. As a model, we used field-collected fall armyworm (Spodoptera frugiperda) from Puerto Rico, the first location reporting continued practical field-evolved S. frugiperda resistance to corn producing the Cry1F insecticidal protein, and sequenced the SfABCC2 gene previously identified as critical to Cry1F toxicity. Targeted sequencing of SfABCC2 detected a previously reported Cry1F resistance allele and mutations originally identified in populations from Brazil. Importantly, targeted sequencing also identified nonsynonymous and frameshift mutations as novel candidate resistance alleles. These results advocate for the use of targeted sequencing in screening for resistance alleles to Cry proteins and support potential gene flow, including resistance alleles, between S. frugiperda from Brazil and the Caribbean.

Abstract

Evolution of practical resistance is the main threat to the sustainability of transgenic crops producing insecticidal proteins from Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt crops). Monitoring of resistance to Cry and Vip3A proteins produced by Bt crops is critical to mitigate the development of resistance. Currently, Cry/Vip3A resistance allele monitoring is based on bioassays with larvae from inbreeding field-collected moths. As an alternative, DNA-based monitoring tools should increase sensitivity and reduce overall costs compared to bioassay-based screening methods. Here, we evaluated targeted sequencing as a method allowing detection of known and novel candidate resistance alleles to Cry proteins. As a model, we sequenced a Cry1F receptor gene (SfABCC2) in fall armyworm (Spodoptera frugiperda) moths from Puerto Rico, a location reporting continued practical field resistance to Cry1F-producing corn. Targeted sequencing detected a previously reported Cry1F resistance allele (SfABCC2mut), in addition to a resistance allele originally described in S. frugiperda populations from Brazil. Moreover, targeted sequencing detected mutations in SfABCC2 as novel candidate resistance alleles. These results support further development of targeted sequencing for monitoring resistance to Bt crops and provide unexpected evidence for common resistance alleles in S. frugiperda from Brazil and Puerto Rico.