Cleavage activation and functional comparison of Manduca sexta serine protease homologs SPH1a, SPH1b, SPH4, and SPH101 in conjunction with SPH2

Innate Immunity in Insects: The Lights and Shadows of Phenoloxidase System Activation

Melanogenesis and melanin deposition are processes essential for the effective immune response of insects to various invaders. Phenoloxidase (PO), produced in specialized cells as an inactive precursor prophenoloxidase (proPO), is the key enzyme for melanin formation. The precursor is activated via limited proteolysis by a dedicated serine proteinase, which is the final element in the cascade of serine proteinases (SPs) that make up the PO system. Melanogenesis provides different cytotoxic molecules active in fighting infections, as well as melanin, which is important for sequestration of invaders. However, since the cytotoxic reactive compounds generated during melanization also pose a threat to host cells, strict control of the PO system is necessary for host self-protection. Different pathogens and parasites influence the PO system and melanization through various strategies, which allow them to survive and develop in the host insect body. In this review, we characterize "the lights and shadows" of PO system activation, indicating, on one hand, its advantages as an efficient and effective mechanism of the insect immune response and, on the other hand, the dangers for the insect host associated with the improper functioning of this system and selected strategies for regulating its activity by entomopathogenic organisms.

CLIPA protein pairs function as cofactors for prophenoloxidase activation in Anopheles gambiae

Insect prophenoloxidases (proPO) are activated during immune responses by a proPO activating protease (PAP) in the presence of a high molecular weight cofactor assembled from serine protease homologs (SPH) that lack proteolytic activity. PAPs and the SPHs have a similar architecture, with an amino-terminal clip domain and a carboxyl-terminal protease domain. The SPHs belong to CLIPA subfamily of SP-related proteins. In Manduca sexta, a well characterized biochemical model system for insect immunity, the functional SPH cofactor contains one molecule each from two SPH subfamilies, SPH-I and SPH-II. In Anopheles gambiae, three SPHI-SPHII pairs (CLIPs A4-A6, A4-A7Δ, and A4-A12) were previously reported as cofactors for CLIPB9-mediated activation of proPO2 and proPO7. In this study, we produced recombinant proteins for two splicing variants of CLIPA7, proCLIPA7s (s for short), proCLIPA7f (f for full-length) and proCLIPA14. We cleaved each along with proCLIPA4 using M. sexta PAP3 and found that the CLIPA pairs A4-A7s and A4-A14 are better than A4-A7f in generating highly active PO2 or PO7. CLIPA7f and CLIPA7s, products of alternative splicing, have different strengths as cofactors in combination with CLIPA4. Because mRNA for CLIPA7f is expressed at a significantly higher level than CLIPA7s, cofactors with the weaker combination A4-A7f may predominate in hemolymph, resulting in a potential dampening effect on proPO activation as a regulatory mechanism for altering the strength of the melanization response. A. gambiae CLIPB10xa is involved in proPO activation but its role as a PAP was not established using mosquito proPOs. Here we showed that factor Xa-treated proCLIPB10Xa activated proCLIPs A7s, A7f, A14, A4 (poorly), and proPO2. At higher concentrations, CLIPB10xa efficiently activated proPO2 in the absence of a cofactor, but at low concentrations it required a CLIPA cofactor, suggesting that highly active PO2 can be generated at low concentration of CLIPB10 in cooperation with an SPH cofactor in vivo. Using cofactors generated by PAP3, we demonstrated the order of efficacy for proPO2 activation by B10Xa is A4-A6 > A4-A14 or A4-A7s > A4-A7f > A4-A12. This agrees with their relative strengths as cofactors for proPO2 and proPO7 activation by M. sexta PAP3. In summary, we further developed an in vitro assay system to elucidate biochemical details of the complex process of proPO activation in A. gambiae.

The Aedes aegypti mosquito evolves two types of prophenoloxidases with diversified functions

Insect phenoloxidase, presented as an inactive precursor prophenoloxidase (PPO) in hemolymph, catalyzes melanin formation, which is involved in wound healing, pathogen killing, reversible oxygen collection during insect respiration, and cuticle and eggshell formation. Mosquitoes possess 9 to 16 PPO members across different genera, a number that is more than that found in other dipteran insects. However, the reasons for the redundancy of these PPOs and whether they have distinct biochemical properties and physiological functions remain unclear. Phylogenetic analysis confirmed that Aedes aegypti PPO6 (Aea-PPO6) is an ortholog to PPOs in other insect species, classified as the classical insect type, while other Aea-PPOs are unique to Diptera, herein referred to as the dipteran type here. We characterized two Aea-PPO members, Aea-PPO6, the classical insect type, and Aea-PPO10, a dipteran type, which exhibit distinct substrate specificities. By resolving Aea-PPO6's crystal structure and creating a chimera protein (Aea-PPO6-cm) with Motif 1 (217GDGPDSVVR225) from Aea-PPO10, we identified the motif that determines PPO substrate specificity. In vivo, loss of Aea-PPO6 led to larval lethality, while Aea-PPO10 was involved in development, pigmentation, and immunity. Our results enhance the understanding of the functional diversification of mosquito PPOs.

Hemolymph protease-17b activates proHP6 to stimulate melanization and Toll signaling in Manduca sexta

Manduca sexta hemolymph protease-6 (HP6) plays a central role in coordinating antimicrobial responses, such as prophenoloxidase (PPO) activation and Toll signaling. Our previous studies indicated that HP5 and GP6 activate proHP6 in larval hemolymph and extraembryonic tissues, respectively. Here, we report the characterization of HP17b as another HP6 activating enzyme and its regulation by multiple serpins in hemolymph. The precursor of HP17b expressed in baculovirus infected Sf9 cells became spontaneously cleaved at two sites, and these products were purified together in one preparation named HP17b', a mixture of proHP17b, a 35 kDa intermediate, and HP17b. HP17b' converted proHP6 to HP6. As reported before, HP6 converted precursors of PPO activating protease-1 (PAP1) and HP8 to their active forms. HP8 activates proSpӓtzle-1 to turn on Toll signaling. We found HP17b' directly activated proSPHI and II to form a cofactor for PPO activation by PAP1. Supplementation of larval hemolymph with HP17b', HP17b, or proHP17b significantly increased PPO activation. Adding Micrococcus luteus to the reactions did not enhance PPO activation in the reactions containing HP17b', HP17b, or proHP17b. Using HP17b antibodies, we isolated from induced plasma HP17b fragments and associated proteins (e.g., serpin-4). Serpin-1A, 1J, 1J', 4, 5, or 6 reduced the activation of proHP6 by HP17b' through formation of covalent complexes with active HP17b. We detected an activity for proHP17b cleavage in hemolymph from bar-stage pharate pupae but failed to purify the protease due to its high instability. Other known HPs did not activate proHP17b in vitro. Together, these results suggest that HP17b is a clip-domain protease activated by an unknown endopeptidase in response to a danger signal and regulated by multiple serpins.

Identification of immunity-related genes distinctly regulated by Manduca sexta Spӓtzle-1/2 and Escherichia coli peptidoglycan

The immune system of Manduca sexta has been well studied to understand molecular mechanisms of insect antimicrobial responses. While evidence supports the existence of major immune signaling pathways in this species, it is unclear how induced production of defense proteins is specifically regulated by the Toll and Imd pathways. Our previous studies suggested that diaminopimelic acid-type peptidoglycans (DAP-PG) from Gram-negative and some Gram-positive bacteria, more than Lys-type peptidoglycans (Lys-PG) from other Gram-positive bacteria, triggers both pathways through membrane-bound receptors orthologous to Drosophila Toll and PGRP-LC. In this study, we produced M. sexta proSpätzle-1 and proSpätzle-2 in Sf9 cells, identified their processing enzymes, and used prophenoloxidase activating protease-3 to activate the cytokine precursors. After Spätzle-1 and -2 were isolated from the reaction mixtures, we separately injected the purified cytokines into larval hemocoel to induce gene transcription in fat body through the Toll pathway solely. On the other hand, we treated a M. sexta cell line with E. coli DAP-PG to only induce the Imd pathway and target gene expression. RNA-Seq analysis of the fat body and cultured cells collected at 0, 6, and 24 h after treatment indicated that expression of diapausin-4, -10, -12, -13, cecropin-2, -4, -5, attacin-5, -11, and lebocin D is up-regulated predominantly via Toll signaling, whereas transcription of cecropin-6, gloverin, lysozyme-1, and gallerimycin-2 is mostly induced by DAP-PG via Imd signaling. Other antimicrobial peptides are expressed in response to both pathways. Transcripts of most Toll-specific genes (e.g., lebocin D) peaked at 6 h, contrasting the gradual increase and plateauing of drosomycin mRNA level at 24-48 h in Drosophila. We also used T (oll)-I (md) ratios to estimate relative contributions of the two pathways to transcriptional regulation of other components of the immune system. The differences in pathway specificity and time course of transcriptional regulation call for further investigations in M. sexta and other insects.

Serine protease homolog pairs CLIPA4-A6, A4-A7Δ, and A4-A12 act as cofactors for proteolytic activation of prophenoloxidase-2 and -7 in Anopheles gambiae

Phenoloxidase (PO) catalyzed melanization and other insect immune responses are mediated by serine proteases (SPs) and their noncatalytic homologs (SPHs). Many of these SP-like proteins have a regulatory clip domain and are called CLIPs. In most insects studied so far, PO precursors are activated by a PAP (i.e., PPO activating protease) and its cofactor of clip-domain SPHs. Although melanotic encapsulation is a well-known refractory mechanism of mosquitoes against malaria parasites, it is unclear if a cofactor is required for PPO activation. In Anopheles gambiae, CLIPA4 is 1:1 orthologous to Manduca sexta SPH2; CLIPs A5-7, A12-14, A26, A31, A32, E6, and E7 are 11:4 orthologous to M. sexta SPH1a, 1b, 4, and 101, SPH2 partners in the cofactors. Here we produced proCLIPs A4, A6, A7Δ, A12, and activated them with CLIPB9 or M. sexta PAP3. A. gambiae PPO2 and PPO7 were expressed in Escherichia coli for use as PAP substrates. CLIPB9 was mutated to CLIPB9Xa by including a Factor Xa cleavage site. CLIPA7Δ was a deletion mutant with a low complexity region removed. After PAP3 or CLIPB9Xa processing, CLIPA4 formed a high Mr complex with CLIPA6, A7Δ or A12, which assisted PPO2 and PPO7 activation. High levels of specific PO activity (55-85 U/μg for PO2 and 1131-1630 U/μg for PO7) were detected in vitro, indicating that cofactor-assisted PPO activation also occurs in this species. The cleavage sites and mechanisms for complex formation and cofactor function are like those reported in M. sexta and Drosophila melanogaster. In conclusion, these data suggest that the three (and perhaps more) SPHI-II pairs may form cofactors for CLIPB9-mediated activation of PPOs for melanotic encapsulation in A. gambiae.

An evolutionarily conserved serine protease network mediates melanization and Toll activation in Drosophila

Melanization and Toll pathway activation are essential innate immune mechanisms in insects, which result in the generation of reactive compounds and antimicrobial peptides, respectively, to kill pathogens. These two processes are mediated by phenoloxidase (PO) and Spätzle (Spz) through an extracellular network of serine proteases. While some proteases have been identified in Drosophila melanogaster in genetic studies, the exact order of proteolytic activation events remains controversial. Here, we reconstituted the serine protease framework in Drosophila by biochemical methods. This system comprises 10 proteases, i.e., ModSP, cSP48, Grass, Psh, Hayan-PA, Hayan-PB, Sp7, MP1, SPE and Ser7, which form cascade pathways that recognize microbial molecular patterns and virulence factors, and generate PO1, PO2, and Spz from their precursors. Furthermore, the serpin Necrotic negatively regulates the immune response progression by inhibiting ModSP and Grass. The biochemical approach, when combined with genetic analysis, is crucial for addressing problems that long stand in this important research field.

Insight into the structural hierarchy of the protease cascade that regulates the mosquito melanization response

Serine protease cascades regulate important insect immune responses, including melanization and Toll pathway activation. In the context of melanization, central components of these cascades are clip domain serine proteases (CLIPs) including the catalytic, clip domain serine proteases (cSPs) and their non-catalytic homologs (cSPHs). Here, we define partially the structural hierarchy of An. gambiae cSPs of the CLIPB family, central players in melanization, and characterize their relative contributions to bacterial melanization and to mosquito susceptibility to bacterial infections. Using in vivo genetic analysis we show that the protease cascade branches downstream of the cSPs CLIPB4 and CLIPB17 into two branches one converging on CLIPB10 and the second on CLIPB8. We also show that the contribution of key cSPHs to melanization in vivo in response to diverse microbial challenges is more significant than any of the individual cSPs, possibly due to partial functional redundancy among the latter. Interestingly, we show that the key cSPH CLIPA8 which is essential for the efficient activation cleavage of CLIPBs in vivo is efficiently cleaved itself by several CLIPBs in vitro, suggesting that cSPs and cSPHs regulate signal amplification and propagation in melanization cascades by providing positive reinforcement upstream and downstream of each other.

Two clip-domain serine protease homologs, cSPH35 and cSPH242, act as a cofactor for prophenoloxidase-1 activation in Drosophila melanogaster

Insect phenoloxidases (POs) catalyze phenol oxygenation and o-diphenol oxidation to form reactive intermediates that kill invading pathogens and form melanin polymers. To reduce their toxicity to host cells, POs are produced as prophenoloxidases (PPOs) and activated by a serine protease cascade as required. In most insects studied so far, PPO activating proteases (PAPs) generate active POs in the presence of a high Mr cofactor, comprising two serine protease homologs (SPHs) each with a Gly residue replacing the catalytic Ser of an S1A serine protease (SP). These SPHs have a regulatory clip domain at the N-terminus, like most of the SP cascade members including PAPs. In Drosophila, PPO activation and PO-catalyzed melanization have been examined in genetic analyses but it is unclear if a cofactor is required for PPO activation. In this study, we produced the recombinant cSPH35 and cSPH242 precursors, activated them with Manduca sexta PAP3, and confirmed their predicted role as a cofactor for Drosophila PPO1 activation by MP2 (i.e., Sp7). The cleavage sites and mechanisms for complex formation and cofactor function are highly similar to those reported in M. sexta. In the presence of high Mr complexes of the cSPHs, PO at a high specific activity of 260 U/μg was generated in vitro. To complement the in vitro analysis, we measured hemolymph PO activity levels in wild-type flies, cSPH35, and cSPH242 RNAi lines. Compared with the wild-type flies, only 4.4% and 18% of the control PO level (26 U/μl) was detected in the cSPH35 and cSPH242 knockdowns, respectively. Consistently, percentages of adults with a melanin spot at the site of septic pricking were 82% in wild-type, 30% in cSPH35 RNAi, and 53% in cSPH242 RNAi lines; the survival rate of the control (45%) was significantly higher than those (30% and 15%) of the two RNAi lines. These data suggest that Drosophila cSPH35 and cSPH242 are components of a cofactor for MP2-mediated PPO1 activation, which are indispensable for early melanization in adults.

CLIPB4 Is a Central Node in the Protease Network that Regulates Humoral Immunity in Anopheles gambiae Mosquitoes

Insect humoral immune responses are regulated in part by protease cascades, whose components circulate as zymogens in the hemolymph. In mosquitoes, these cascades consist of clip-domain serine proteases (cSPs) and/or their non-catalytic homologs, which form a complex network, whose molecular make-up is not fully understood. Using a systems biology approach, based on a co-expression network of gene family members that function in melanization and co-immunoprecipitation using the serine protease inhibitor (SRPN)2, a key negative regulator of the melanization response in mosquitoes, we identify the cSP CLIPB4 from the African malaria mosquito Anopheles gambiae as a central node in this protease network. CLIPB4 is tightly co-expressed with SRPN2 and forms protein complexes with SRPN2 in the hemolymph of immune-challenged female mosquitoes. Genetic and biochemical approaches validate our network analysis and show that CLIPB4 is required for melanization and antibacterial immunity, acting as a prophenoloxidase (proPO)-activating protease, which is inhibited by SRPN2. In addition, we provide novel insight into the structural organization of the cSP network in An. gambiae, by demonstrating that CLIPB4 is able to activate proCLIPB8, a cSP upstream of the proPO-activating protease CLIPB9. These data provide the first evidence that, in mosquitoes, cSPs provide branching points in immune protease networks and deliver positive reinforcement in proPO activation cascades.

CLIPB4 is a central node in the protease network that regulates humoral immunity in Anopheles gambiae mosquitoes

Insect humoral immune responses are regulated in part by protease cascades, whose components circulate as zymogens in the hemolymph. In mosquitoes, these cascades consist of clip domain serine proteases (cSPs) and/or their non-catalytic homologs (cSPHs), which form a complex network, whose molecular make-up is not fully understood. Using a systems biology approach, based on a co-expression network of gene family members that function in melanization and co-immunoprecipitation using the serine protease inhibitor (SRPN)2, a key negative regulator of the melanization response in mosquitoes, we identify the cSP CLIPB4 from the African malaria mosquito Anopheles gambiae as a central node in this protease network. CLIPB4 is tightly co-expressed with SRPN2 and forms protein complexes with SRPN2 in the hemolymph of immune-challenged female mosquitoes. Genetic and biochemical approaches validate our network analysis and show that CLIPB4 is required for melanization and antibacterial immunity, acting as a prophenoloxidase (proPO)-activating protease, which is inhibited by SRPN2. In addition, we provide novel insight into the structural organization of the cSP network in An. gambiae, by demonstrating that CLIPB4 is able to activate proCLIPB8, a cSP upstream of the proPO-activating protease CLIPB9. These data provide the first evidence that, in mosquitoes, cSPs provide branching points in immune protease networks and deliver positive reinforcement in proPO activation cascades.

Serine Protease Networks Mediate Immune Responses in Extra-Embryonic Tissues of Eggs in the Tobacco Hornworm, Manduca sexta

The melanization and Toll pathways, regulated by a network of serine proteases and noncatalytic serine protease homologs (SPHs), have been investigated mostly in adult and larval insects. However, how these innate immune reactions are regulated in insect eggs remains unclear. Here we present evidence from transcriptome and proteome analyses that extra-embryonic tissues (yolk and serosa) of early-stage Manduca sexta eggs are immune competent, with expression of immune effector genes including prophenoloxidase and antimicrobial peptides. We identified gene products of the melanization and Toll pathways in M. sexta eggs. Through in vitro reconstitution experiments, we demonstrated that constitutive and infection-induced serine protease cascade modules that stimulate immune responses exist in the extra-embryonic tissues of M. sexta eggs. The constitutive module (HP14b-SP144-GP6) may promote rapid early immune signaling by forming a cascade activating the cytokine Spätzle and regulating melanization by activating prophenoloxidase (proPO). The inducible module (HP14a-HP21-HP5) may trigger enhanced activation of Spätzle and proPO at a later phase of infection. Crosstalk between the two modules may occur in transition from the constitutive to the induced response in eggs inoculated with bacteria. Examination of data from two other well-studied insect species, Tribolium castaneum and Drosophila melanogaster, supports a role for a serosa-dependent constitutive protease cascade in protecting early embryos against invading pathogens.

CLIPA7 Exhibits Pleiotropic Roles in the Anopheles gambiae Immune Response

Clip domain serine proteases and clip domain serine protease homologs (cSPHs) are key components of serine protease cascades that drive the melanization response. Despite lacking catalytic activity, cSPHs play essential roles in regulating melanization, but the spectrum of functions they catalyze within and outside these cascades is not fully understood. Aside from their classical role as cofactors for PPO activation, we have previously revealed an unprecedented complexity in the function and molecular organization of these cSPHs in the immune response of the malaria vector Anopheles gambiae. Here, we add yet another dimension to the complex roles underpinning the contributions of cSPHs to mosquito immunity by showing that CLIPA7, a member of the expanded cSPH family, defines a novel branch within the cSPH network that is essential for the melanization of Escherichia coli but not Plasmodium ookinetes or Gram-positive bacteria. Despite its dispensability for the melanization of Gram-positive bacteria, we show that CLIPA7 is required for the clearance of systemic infections with Staphylococcus aureus. CLIPA7 is produced by hemocytes and associates with the surfaces of live E. coli and S. aureus cells in vivo as well as with those of melanized cells. Based on its RNAi phenotypes and its unique domain architecture among A. gambiae cSPHs including the presence of an RGD motif, we propose that CLIPA7 exhibits pleiotropic roles in mosquito immunity that extend beyond the regulation of melanization to microbial clearance.

Dual roles and evolutionary implications of P26/poxin in antagonizing intracellular cGAS-STING and extracellular melanization immunity

P26, a homolog of the viral-encoded nuclease poxin that neutralizes the cGAS-STING innate immunity, is widely distributed in various invertebrate viruses, lepidopteran insects, and parasitoid wasps. P26/poxin from certain insect viruses also retains protease activity, though its biological role remains unknown. Given that many P26s contain a signal peptide, it is surmised that P26 may possess certain extracellular functions. Here, we report that a secretory baculoviral P26 suppresses melanization, a prominent insect innate immunity against pathogen invasion. P26 targets the cofactor of a prophenoloxidase-activating protease, and its inhibitory function is independent of nuclease activity. The analysis of P26/poxin homologs from different origins suggests that the ability to inhibit the extracellular melanization pathway is limited to P26s with a signal peptide and not shared by the homologs without it. These findings highlight the independent evolution of a single viral suppressor to perform dual roles in modulating immunity during virus-host adaptation.

Proteomics reveals the hemolymph components of partially fed Hyalomma asiaticum ticks

Hemolymph infection facilitates pathogen invasion of internal tick tissues. However, the overall protein composition of the hemolymph has not been analyzed for any tick species. Here, a gel based liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry method was used to characterize the hemolymph proteome of Hyalomma asiaticum females during blood feeding. A total of 311 proteins were identified. Hemelipoglyco-carrier proteins, apolipophorin-like proteins, and intracellular proteins were the most abundant proteins. Thirteen immunity-related proteins were identified, including peptidoglycan recognition protein (PGRP), Thioester-containing proteins (TEPs), clip‑serine proteinases, serpins and Dome. The presence of hemocytin, proclotting enzyme homologs, serpins, TEPs, factor D-like protein and the lack of coagulin, hemocyanin, and prophenoloxidase suggest ticks may possess a unique coagulation system, which is largely different from that of insects. Taken together, the study revealed the constitution, level, and possible functions of global hemolymph proteins in H. asiaticum and could facilitate the discovery of new targets for control of tick-borne pathogens.

The Micrococcus luteus infection activates a novel melanization pathway of cSP10, cSP4, and cSP8 in Helicoverpa armigera

Melanization is a key immune response mediated by serine protease (SP) cascade in insects. Multiple SP pathways exist in different species and it is unclear how conserved these cascades are. The cotton bollworm Helicoverpa armigera is a major worldwide agricultural pest. We reported a conserved melanization pathway in this species, which consists of SP41, cSP1, and cSP6. In this study, we attempted to identify an insect pathogen that elicits the cascade and test whether or not there are other SP cascades in H. armigera. After Micrococcus luteus, Enterobacter cloacae, Beauveria bassiana, or Helicoverpa armigera nucleopolyhedrovirus were injected into larvae, pathogen-induced hemolymph samples were collected for in vitro biochemical assays, which failed to detect proSP41 or procSP1 activation. In contrast, we found that procSP4, a protein proposed to participate in H. armigera melanization, was activated in M. luteus infected hemolymph. We further revealed that cSP8 was a prophenoloxidase (PPO) activating protease downstream of cSP4, and cSP4 was activated by cSP10. The pathway of cSP10-cSP4-cSP8 activated PPO in vitro. Efficiently cleaved procSPH11 and procSPH50 by cSP8 substantially enhanced phenoloxidase activity, suggesting they work together as a cofactor for cSP8 mediated PPO activation. Hemolymph from larvae challenged with M. luteus or its peptidoglycan effectively activated procSP10. Collectively, these results revealed a new PPO activation cascade specifically triggered by the bacterium. In addition, we found that the PPO activation cascades in H. armigera and Manduca sexta are conserved.