Developing a Pictorial Sisterhood Method in collaboration with illiterate Maasai traditional birth attendants in northern Tanzania

Approaches to improve and adapt maternal mortality estimations in low- and middle-income countries: A scoping review

BACKGROUND

In the absence of robust vital registration systems, many low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) rely on national surveys or routine surveillance systems to estimate the maternal mortality ratio (MMR). Although the importance of MMR estimates in ending preventable maternal deaths is acknowledged, there is limited research on how different approaches are used and adapted, and how these adaptations function.

OBJECTIVES

To assess methods for estimating maternal mortality in LMICs and the rationale for these modifications.

SEARCH STRATEGY

A literature search with the terms "maternal death", "surveys" and "low- and middle-income countries" was performed in Medline, Embase, Web of Science, Scopus, CINAHL, APA PsycINFO, ERIC, and IBSS from January 2013 to March 17, 2023.

SELECTION CRITERIA

Studies were eligible if their main focus was to compare, adapt, or assess methods to estimate maternal mortality in LMICs.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

Titles and abstracts were screened using Rayyan. Relevant articles were independently reviewed by two reviewers against inclusion criteria. Data were extracted on mortality measurement methods, their context, and results.

MAIN RESULTS

Nineteen studies were included, focusing on data completeness, subnational estimates, and community involvement. Routinely generated MMR estimates are more complete when multiple data sources are triangulated, including data from public and private health facilities, the community, and local authorities (e.g. vital registration, police reports). For subnational estimates, existing (e.g. the sisterhood method and reproductive-age mortality surveys [RAMOS]) and adapted methods (e.g. RAMOS 4 + 2 and Pictorial Sisterhood Method) provided reliable confidence intervals. Community engagement in data collection increased community awareness of maternal deaths, provided local ownership, and was expected to reduce implementation costs. However, most studies did not include a cost-effectiveness analysis.

CONCLUSION

Household surveys with community involvement and RAMOS can be used to increase data validity, improve local awareness of maternal mortality estimates, and reduce costs in LMICs.

Health interventions among mobile pastoralists: a systematic review to guide health service design

OBJECTIVE

Mobile pastoralists are one of the last populations to be reached by health services and are frequently missed by health campaigns. Since health interventions among pastoralists have been staged across a range of disciplines but have not yet been systematically characterised, we set out to fill this gap.

METHODS

We conducted a systematic search in PubMed/MEDLINE, Scopus, Embase, CINAL, Web of Science, WHO Catalog, AGRICOLA, CABI, ScIELO, Google Scholar and grey literature repositories to identify records that described health interventions, facilitators and barriers to intervention success, and factors influencing healthcare utilisation among mobile pastoralists. No date restrictions were applied. Due to the heterogeneity of reports captured in this review, data were primarily synthesised through narrative analysis. Descriptive statistical analysis was performed for data elements presented by a majority of records.

RESULTS

Our search yielded 4884 non-duplicate records, of which 140 eligible reports were included in analysis. 89.3% of reports presented data from sub-Saharan Africa, predominantly in East Africa (e.g. Ethiopia, 30.0%; Kenya, 17.1%). Only 24.3% of reports described an interventional study, while the remaining 75.7% described secondary data of interest on healthcare utilisation. Only two randomised controlled trials were present in our analysis, and only five reports presented data on cost. The most common facilitators of intervention success were cultural sensitivity (n = 16), community engagement (n = 12) and service mobility (n = 11).

CONCLUSION

Without adaptations to account for mobile pastoralists' unique subsistence patterns and cultural context, formal health services leave pastoralists behind. Research gaps, including neglect of certain geographic regions, lack of both interventional studies and diversity of study design, and limited data on economic feasibility of interventions must be addressed to inform the design of health services capable of reaching mobile pastoralists. Pastoralist-specific delivery strategies, such as combinations of mobile and 'temporary fixed' services informed by transhumance patterns, culturally acceptable waiting homes, community-directed interventions and combined joint human-animal One Health design as well as the bundling of other health services, have shown initial promise upon which future work should build.

Development and Implementation of a Culturally Appropriate Education Program to Increase Cervical Cancer Screening among Maasai Women in Rural Tanzania

Background:

In Tanzania, the incidence of cervical cancer is nearly ten times that found in the US. Tanzanian women of the traditional Maasai tribe are financially and educationally marginalized and face a language barrier that reduces access to health care. While cervical cancer (CACX) screening programs are available locally, in our experience, Maasai women were less likely to use these services compared to local women of other tribal backgrounds.

Objectives:

A novel patient education program was designed to teach Maasai women about the natural history of cervical cancer and available screening and treatment. The program addressed the importance of preventative health and informed consent. Additionally, we sought to better understand the specific barriers Maasai women face in accessing and utilizing CACX screening services.

Methods:

The program used simple, scripted language translated into Maa language, the Maasai native language, with accompanying culturally appropriate 3D models. The effectiveness of the program was evaluated through pre and post-intervention surveys administered to Maasai and non-Maasai women as well as local healthcare providers, assessing knowledge of cervical cancer, screening, and treatment. Paired t-test analyses were used to analyze significance. Extensive question and answer sessions followed the education sessions from which additional barriers to screening were identified.

Findings:

Maasai women had minimal understanding of preventative health services prior to the intervention. While all groups showed an increase in knowledge following the education program, Maasai women demonstrated the greatest statistically significant improvement in knowledge. The proportion of Maasai women in attendance to CACX screening clinics increased by 18% after the intervention.

Conclusions:

Through a culturally sensitive and accessible patient education program, Maasai women gained knowledge of cervical cancer screening and treatment. This program serves as an adaptable model for other marginalized populations to increase patient understanding and informed consent, and to address issues that pertain to underutilization of health care services.