Dicyclanil resistance in the Australian sheep blowfly, Lucilia cuprina, substantially reduces flystrike protection by dicyclanil and cyromazine based products

In vitro insecticide resistance patterns in field strains of the sheep blowfly, Lucilia cuprina

The control of the sheep blowfly relies on the use of insecticides. There have been several reports of in vitro and in vivo resistance to the most widely-used flystrike control chemical, dicyclanil. A recent report also described in vitro resistance to imidacloprid in a strain collected from a single property over three consecutive seasons that also showed resistance to dicyclanil. The present study aimed to use in vitro assays to examine five field-collected blowfly strains to determine if this co-occurrence of resistance to dicyclanil and imidacloprid was present more widely in field strains and to also measure resistance patterns to the other currently-used flystrike control chemicals. Each of the strains showed significant levels of resistance to both dicyclanil and imidacloprid: resistance factors at the IC50 of 9.1-23.8 for dicyclanil, and 8.7-14.1 for imidacloprid. Resistance factors at the IC95 ranged from 16.5 to 53.7, and 14.6-24.3 for dicyclanil and imidacloprid, respectively. Resistance factors were up to 8.5 for cyromazine at the IC95. Resistance to dicyclanil and imidacloprid was suppressed by co-treatment with the cytochrome P450 inhibitor, aminobenzotriazole, implicating this enzyme system in the observed resistances. We discuss the implications of the co-occurrence of resistance to dicyclanil and imidacloprid on insecticide rotation strategies for blowfly control. We also discuss the roles of insecticide resistance, environmental factors (e.g. rainfall), operational factors (e.g. insecticide application technique) and other animal health issues (e.g. scouring / diarrhoea) that together will impact on the likelihood of flystrike occurring at an earlier time point than expected after insecticide application.

The current status and outlook for insecticide, acaricide and anthelmintic resistances across the Australian ruminant livestock industries: assessing the threat these resistances pose to the livestock sector

The Australian ruminant livestock industries are faced with the need to control parasitic infectious diseases that can seriously impact the health of animals. However, increasing levels of resistance to insecticides, anthelmintics and acaricides are substantially reducing the ability to control some of these parasites. Here we review the current situation with regard to chemical resistances in parasites across the various sectors of the Australian ruminant livestock industries and assess the level of threat that these resistances pose to the sustainability of these sectors in the short to long terms. We also look at the extent to which testing for resistance occurs across the various industry sectors, and hence how well-informed these sectors are of the extent of chemical resistance. We examine on-farm management practices, breeding of parasite-resistant animals, and non-chemical therapeutics that may act as short to long term means to reduce the current reliance on chemicals for parasite control. Finally, we look at the balance between the prevalence and magnitude of current resistances and the availability and adoption rates of management, breeding and therapeutic alternatives in order to assess the parasite control outlook for the various industry sectors.

Reduced synergistic efficacy of piperonyl butoxide in combination with alpha-cypermethrin in vitro in an insecticide-resistant strain of the sheep blowfly, Lucilia cuprina

Control of flystrike on sheep relies on the use of insecticides. The present study used in vitro assays to examine the potential for increasing the efficacy of synthetic pyrethroids against sheep blowfly larvae using the synergist piperonyl butoxide (PBO). We examined the potency of alpha-cypermethrin (ACP) / PBO combinations against a reference insecticide-susceptible strain (LS) and a field-derived strain showing resistance to dicyclanil and imidacloprid. Co-treatment of the insecticide-susceptible strain with ACP/PBO resulted in increasing levels of synergism as the PBO concentration was increased, with synergism ratios (SRs) of up to 114-fold. Treatment with PBO/ACP combinations at ratios of 20:1 and 5:1 resulted in significant levels of synergism: SRs of 13.5- and 7.6-fold, respectively. However, the levels of synergism were significantly less for the insecticide-resistant strain: SRs of 4.6- and 2.6-fold for the 20:1 and 5:1 ratios, respectively. The resistant strain showed no resistance to ACP when administered alone, however, was 2-fold less sensitive than the LS strain to the toxic effects of PBO alone. This insensitivity to PBO was removed by co-treatment with the P450 inhibitor aminobenzotriazole, suggesting an increased level of P450-mediated metabolism of the PBO in this strain compared to the LS strain, and hence providing a likely explanation for the reduced synergistic efficacy of PBO on ACP toxicity in the resistant strain. While PBO was able to synergise ACP with both of the blowfly strains examined here, the reduced synergistic efficacy observed with the field-derived insecticide-resistant strain lessens the potential usefulness of such a combination for blowfly control in the field.

Resistance to dicyclanil and imidacloprid in the sheep blowfly, Lucilia cuprina, in Australia

BACKGROUND

The sheep blowfly, Lucila cuprina, is a myiasis-causing parasite responsible for significant production losses and welfare issues for the Australian sheep industry. Control relies largely on the use of insecticides. The pyrimidine compound, dicyclanil, is the predominant control chemical, although other insecticides also are used, including imidacloprid, ivermectin, cyromazine and spinosad. We investigated in vitro resistance patterns and mechanisms in field-collected blowfly strains.

RESULTS

The Walgett 2019 strain showed significant levels of resistance to both dicyclanil and imidacloprid, with resistance factors at the IC₅₀ of 26- and 17-fold, respectively, in in vitro bioassays. Co-treatment with the cytochrome P450 inhibitor, aminobenzotriazole, resulted in significant levels of synergism for dicyclanil and imidacloprid (synergism ratios of 7.2- and 6.1-fold, respectively), implicating cytochrome P450 in resistance to both insecticides. Cyp12d1 transcription levels were increased up to 40-fold throughout the larval life stages in the resistant strain compared to a reference susceptible strain, whereas transcription levels of some other cyp genes (6g1, 4d1, 28d1) did not differ between the strains. Similar resistance levels also were observed in flies collected from the same property in two subsequent years.

CONCLUSION

This study indicates that in vitro resistance to both dicyclanil and imidacloprid in this field-collected blowfly strain is likely mediated by cytochrome P450, with Cyp12d1 implicated as the enzyme responsible; however, it remains possible that another P450 also may be involved. A common resistance mechanism for the two drugs has important implications for drug rotation strategies designed to prolong the useful life of flystrike control chemicals. © 2022 The Authors. Pest Management Science published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of Society of Chemical Industry.

Australian surveys on incidence and control of blowfly strike in sheep between 2003 and 2019 reveal increased use of breeding for resistance, treatment with preventative chemicals and pain relief around mulesing

Blowfly strike or cutaneous myiasis, caused principally by the Australian sheep blowfly Lucilia cuprina is endemic to Australian sheep producing areas and is a major cause of suffering and economic loss. This article reports incidence and control practices as determined by three cross-sectional surveys of Australian sheep farmers covering the years 2003 (n = 1365), 2011 (n = 575) and 2018 (n = 354) with more questions relating to blowfly strike in the latter two surveys. Breech strike was reported at a higher rate than body strike in all survey years. Reported annual incidence of breech strike ranged from 2.2 to 4.7% of sheep nationally with minor differences between ewes and lambs. The incidence of body strike ranged from 1.0 to 7.1% with higher incidence in younger sheep in all years. The use of fixed time routine preventative chemical treatments increased during the survey period (43%, 46% and 66%, in 2003, 2011 and 2018 respectively) with dicyclanil (54%-58%) and cyromazine (23-36%) the main insecticides used for control since 2011. The use of the Mules operation (mulesing) to remove skin wrinkles from the breech area as a preventative modification did not change between 2011 and 2018 (47% in both), however, the use of pain relief at mulesing of replacement ewe lambs increased substantially between 2011 (59%) and 2018 (87%). The most commonly used methods to assist with flystrike control were timing of crutching (clipping of wool from susceptible areas) and shearing, with few respondents destroying maggots from treated sheep (21-26%) and very low use of fly traps (5-8%). Phenotypic selection of ewes for reduced susceptibility to flystrike based on visual traits was practiced by 61% of respondents in 2011 and 56% in 2018. Selection of rams for reduced susceptibility using estimated breeding values increased from 10% in 2011 to 17% in 2018. Breeding for resistance was the most commonly nominated (21%) most important change made to flystrike management in 2018. The results indicate that concern for sheep welfare has increased with almost universal use of pain relief at mulesing. Increased use of selection for blowfly resistance indicates farmer commitment to planning for a future without mulesing, although the practice remains prevalent. An increase in the reliance on preventative chemical treatments increases the risk of insecticide resistance.

Fleece rot and dermatophilosis (lumpy wool) in sheep: opportunities and challenges for new vaccines

During prolonged wetting of the fleece, proliferation of bacterial flora often dominated by Pseudomonas aeruginosa or Dermatophilus congolensis can induce dermatitis and fleece damage termed fleece rot and dermatophilosis respectively, which predispose sheep to blowfly strike. A large research effort in the 1980s and 1990s on vaccines to control fleece rot and dermatophilosis met with limited success. This review examines theoretical and technological advances in microbial ecology, pathogenesis, immunology, vaccine development and the characterisation of microbial virulence factors that create new opportunities for development of vaccines against these diseases. Genomic technologies have now created new opportunities for examining microbial dynamics and pathogen virulence in dermatitis. An effective vaccine requires the combination of appropriate antigens with an adjuvant that elicits a protective immune response that ideally provides long-lasting protection in the field. A clinical goal informed by epidemiological, economic and animal welfare values is needed as a measure of vaccine efficacy. Due to dependence of fleece rot and dermatophilosis on sporadic wet conditions for their expression, vaccine development would be expedited by in vitro correlates of immune protection. The efficacy of vaccines is influenced by genetic and phenotypic characteristics of the animal. Advances in understanding vaccine responsiveness, immune defence in skin and immune competence in sheep should also inform any renewed efforts to develop new fleece rot and dermatophilosis vaccines. The commercial imperatives for new vaccines are likely to continue to increase as the animal welfare expectations of society intensify and reliance on pharmacotherapeutics decrease due to chemical resistance, market pressures and societal influences. Vaccines should be considered part of an integrated disease control strategy, in combination with genetic selection for general immune competence and resistance to specific diseases, as well as management practices that minimise stress and opportunities for disease transmission. The strategy could help preserve the efficacy of pharmacotherapeutics as tactical interventions to alleviate compromised welfare when adverse environmental conditions lead to a break down in integrated strategic disease control. P. aeruginosa and D. congolensis are formidable pathogens and development of effective vaccines remains a substantial challenge.

Control of sheep flystrike: what's been tried in the past and where to from here

Flystrike remains a serious financial and animal welfare issue for the sheep industry in Australia despite many years of research into control methods. The present paper provides an extensive review of past research on flystrike, and highlights areas that hold promise for providing long-term control options. We describe areas where the application of modern scientific advances may provide increased impetus to some novel, as well as some previously explored, control methods. We provide recommendations for research activities: insecticide resistance management, novel delivery methods for therapeutics, improved breeding indices for flystrike-related traits, mechanism of nematode-induced scouring in mature animals. We also identify areas where advances can be made in flystrike control through the greater adoption of well-recognised existing management approaches: optimal insecticide-use patterns, increased use of flystrike-related Australian Sheep Breeding Values, and management practices to prevent scouring in young sheep. We indicate that breeding efforts should be primarily focussed on the adoption and improvement of currently available breeding tools and towards the future integration of genomic selection methods. We describe factors that will impact on the ongoing availability of insecticides for flystrike control and on the feasibility of vaccination. We also describe areas where the blowfly genome may be useful in providing impetus to some flystrike control strategies, such as area-wide approaches that seek to directly suppress or eradicate sheep blowfly populations. However, we also highlight the fact that commercial and feasibility considerations will act to temper the potential for the genome to act as the basis for providing some control options.

Genetic parameters of breech strike, neck wrinkles, dags and breech cover over the lifetime of crutched Merino ewes in a Mediterranean environment

Aims This study was undertaken to estimate the genetic parameters of breech strike and its indicator traits over the lifetime of crutched Merino ewes in a Mediterranean environment. Methods Breech strike records were collected on 3993 ewes over their lifetime where they were annually crutched. The ewes were scored at different times of the year for neck wrinkle, dag score and breech cover over their lifetime. A total of 13 577 breech strike records from birth up to 5 years of age were generated between 2006 and 2017. Face cover was only scored mid-year. Mixed model methodologies were used to estimate the genetic parameters of the different traits at different ages. Key results Breech strike was heritable (h2) and repeatable (t) on the observed scale (h2 = 0.07 ± 0.01; t = 0.13 ± 0.01), and as a binary trait on a logistic scale (h2 = 0.51 ± 0.10; t = 0.68 ± 0.10). Breech strike was genetically positively correlated across ages. Positive genetic correlations were found between breech strike and the indicator traits of neck wrinkle, face cover, breech cover and dags. Neck wrinkle and face cover, as well as breech cover and dag scored at different times of the year, were heritable and repeatable. Although high genetic correlations were found between different ages for neck wrinkle and post-shearing breech cover, these traits are not genetically the same traits at different ages. However, breech cover scored mid-year, before shearing and after shearing are genetically the same trait. The genetic relationship between dag at different ages is unclear as a moderate positive genetic correlation (rg = 0.25 ± 0.12) was found between hoggets and 2-year-old ewes, whereas a moderate negative correlation (rg = –0.30 ± 0.14) was found between 3- and 4-year-old ewes. The genetic correlations amongst the dag traits in older age groups were not significantly different from zero. Conclusions Breech strike and its indicator traits (i.e. neck wrinkle, breech cover, face cover and dags) were all heritable. Breech strike appears to be genetically strongly correlated across ages, however, the correlations had large standard errors. It was positively correlated with the indicator traits. Moderate to strong genetic correlations were found between ages for neck wrinkle and for breech cover. Dags, however, were poorly correlated across ages, indicating that dags are not genetically the same trait in mature ewes at different ages. Implications This study shows that selecting ewes for low breech strike, and for reduced neck wrinkle, lower breech cover and less dags will reduce breech strike in mature Merino ewes in future generations. However, as the phenotypic correlations were relatively low, culling ewes on these indicator traits will result in little gain in the current generation. It appears that dags at different ages is not genetically the same trait. Thus the benefit of selecting or culling ewes on dags will not be carried over to subsequent ages.