Comparative analysis of the efficacy of early and late surgical intervention for acute spinal cord injury: A systematic review and meta-analysis based on 16 studies

Economic Optimization Through Adherence to Best Practice Guidelines: A Decision Analysis of Traumatic Spinal Cord Injury Care Pathways in Australia

Traumatic spinal cord injuries (TSCIs) have significant health, economic, and social effects on individuals, families, and society. In this economic analysis modeling study, we used record-linked administrative patient data from New South Wales, Australia, to construct a decision tree model to compare the economic cost of acute care for patients with TSCI under current clinical pathways with an optimal care (consensus guidelines-informed) modeled pathway. The optimal care pathway included direct transfer to a specialist SCI Unit (SCIU) or indirect transfer to SCIU within 24 h of injury, surgical intervention within 12 h of injury, and subsequent inpatient rehabilitation. Propensity score matching with inverse probability of treatment weighting (IPTW) was used to reduce potential confounding from baseline differences in patient characteristics. A generalized linear model regression with gamma distribution and log link, weighted with IPTW scores, was used for cost and length of stay (LoS) estimations to reduce any residual bias. Sensitivity analyses quantified the sensitivity of the findings to key model parameters. From the healthcare payer perspective, our economic analysis found acute TSCI care at an SCIU was more expensive, with delayed patient transfer pathways, surgery, and timing of surgery driving higher per-patient costs ($14,322 at specialist centers). Probabilistic sensitivity analysis (PSA) using 10,000 Monte Carlo iterations showed the modeled optimal pathway as the expensive option in the majority (86%) of stimulations. However, the modeled direct transfer care pathway demonstrated economic improvements compared to current care pathways, despite a higher upfront cost ($25,428 per patient), the modeled pathway reduced the episode LoS by 5 days (23 days vs. 28 days) on average, generating system-level savings of $20,628 per patient. In PSA, increasing the proportion of patients directly transferred to SCIU by 25%, the optimized pathway was preferred in 28.3% of the simulations. Furthermore, adopting this pathway lowered the incremental per patient cost to $17,157 while preserving a 5-day LoS benefit compared to current pathways (22 days vs. 27 days), which could generate potential savings of $3,471 per patient. Our findings show that guideline-based acute care management is initially resource-intensive but efficient in terms of patient LoS, with a higher proportion of direct transfers resulting in cost savings of $3,471 per patient, which represent system-level benefits from adopting the modeled pathway, rather than episode-level savings. Following consensus guidelines for acute care can provide an economically sustainable approach to resource-intensive patient needs while improving outcomes, as demonstrated in previous studies. In summary, while more intensive, adhering to clinical guidelines of direct transfer to SCIU demonstrates value for patients and health systems. Standardization to optimize time to surgery can achieve improved outcomes through earlier access to rehabilitation and substantial care efficiencies. These findings highlight the economic case for adherence to best practice care guidelines at the healthcare system level to inform future healthcare planning for patients with TSCI.

Advances and New Therapies in Traumatic Spinal Cord Injury

Recovery from traumatic spinal cord injury (tSCI) is challenging due to the limited regenerative capacity of the central nervous system to restore cells, myelin, and neural connections. At the clinical level, the fundamental pillars of treatment are the reduction in secondary damage (neuroprotection) and rehabilitation; these are the tools we have to mitigate the disability caused by spinal cord injury (SCI). To date, the treatments on which neuroprotection has been based are the prevention of acute respiratory failure to avoid hypoxia, early hemodynamic control, neuroprotective drugs and surgical management. Optimizing early hemodynamic control to ensure adequate spinal cord perfusion may be key to the management of SCI. While neuroprotective agents like methylprednisolone have fallen into disuse, several promising therapies are currently being tested in clinical trials. In terms of surgical treatment, although their impact on neurological recovery remains debated, appropriate early bone decompression followed by duroplasty in selected cases is increasingly recommended. Advances in cell therapies hold significant potential for enhancing both clinical and functional outcomes in SCI patients. Moreover, emerging neuromodulation techniques, such as transcutaneous and epidural stimulation, along with innovations in rehabilitation technologies-such as robotic systems and exoskeletons-are becoming indispensable tools for improving locomotion and overall mobility in individuals with SCI. This article provides an update on the advances in neuroprotection against secondary damage caused by tSCI, in cellular therapies, and in new rehabilitation therapies.

Evolution of Real-World Clinical Practice in Time to Surgery Following Thoracolumbar Spinal Cord Injury: An Observational Study of North American Trauma Centers from 2010 to 2020

This study aims to estimate real-world clinical practice trends in time to surgery following thoracolumbar spinal cord injury (SCI) in trauma centers across North America over the last decade (2010-2020). A multi-center retrospective observational study was conducted using Trauma Quality Improvement Program data from 2010 to 2020. All surgically treated patients with thoracic and lumbar SCI were included. Descriptive plots and a multivariable Poisson regression model with time to spine surgery as the primary outcome were constructed. This study included 4350 adult patients with complete SCI surgically treated across 449 trauma centers. Within this group, 3978 (91.4%) patients were diagnosed with thoracic SCI and 372 (8.6%) patients were diagnosed with lumbar SCI. The overall mean time to surgery was 31.6 h (±34.1). Early surgery (≤24 h) was performed in 2599 patients (59.7%). An estimated annual reduction of 1.6 h in time to surgery was demonstrated over the study period, starting initially at a mean of 47.6 h (±40.6) in 2010, and reaching a mean of 25.3 h (±30) in 2020. Multivariable Poisson regression adjusting for patient, injury, and institution confounders, demonstrated a significant decrease in time to surgery by 5% per year over the study period (incidence rate ratios [IRR] = 0.95, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.93-0.96). Moreover, in a secondary analysis including 3270 patients with incomplete thoracolumbar SCI, a comparable significant annual reduction in time to surgery was demonstrated (IRR = 0.93, 95% CI: 0.91-0.94). This study provides real-world data on practice pattern trends with respect to time to spine surgery following traumatic thoracolumbar SCI. Over the years from 2010 to 2020, we found a significant reduction in time to surgery across trauma centers in North America.

Targeted microbiota dysbiosis repair: An important approach to health management after spinal cord injury

Current research primarily focuses on the pathological mechanisms of spinal cord injury (SCI), seeking to promote spinal cord repair and restore motorial and sensory functions by elucidating mechanisms of cell death or axonal regeneration. However, SCI is almost irreversible, and patients often struggle to regain mobility or self-care abilities after injuries. Consequently, there has been significant interest in modulating systemic symptoms following SCI to improve patients' quality of life. Neuron axonal disconnection and substantial apoptotic events following SCI result in signal transmission loss, profoundly impacting various organ and systems, including the gastrointestinal tract. Dysbiosis can lead to severe bowel dysfunction in patients, substantially lowering their quality of life and significantly reducing life expectancy of them. Therefore, researches focusing on the restoration of the gut microbiota hold promise for potential therapeutic strategies aimed at rehabilitation after SCI. In this paper, we explore the regulatory roles that dietary fiber, short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs), probiotics, and microbiota transplantation play in patients with SCI, summarize the potential mechanisms of post-SCI dysbiosis, and discuss possible strategies to enhance long-term survival of SCI patients. We aim to provide potential insights for future research aimed at ameliorating dysbiosis in SCI patients.

Operative Timing in Cervical Spine Trauma

STUDY DESIGN

Narrative review.

OBJECTIVE

To review existing literature regarding surgical timing in cervical trauma with a focus on acute traumatic central cord syndrome.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Traumatic central cord syndrome is the most common incomplete spinal cord injury. Substantial basic science literature has proposed ischemic and secondary injury-driven mechanisms underpinning the urgency of operative intervention. However, only recently has a relative consensus emerged in the clinical literature regarding the safety, efficacy, and necessity of early operative intervention for acute traumatic central cord syndrome.

METHODS

A literature search was conducted of studies in PubMed Central and Cochrane Database related to timing in cervical spine trauma.

CONCLUSIONS

Recently, several major systematic reviews and consensus statements have endorsed the importance and safety of early (<24 h) operative decompression in the setting of traumatic spinal cord injury. Despite decades of conflicting data, a similar trend appears to be emerging for traumatic central cord syndrome. These clinical developments join a large body of basic science work regarding the importance of early decompressive surgery in relieving acute ischemic insult and minimizing the effects of secondary injury. However, further work is needed to delineate optimal surgical timing, especially regarding "ultra-early" (<8 h) protocols, and to aid in creating accelerated screening pathways.

Tracing the evolving dynamics and research hotspots of spinal cord injury and surgical decompression from 1975 to 2024: a bibliometric analysis

Background

Exploration of the benefits and timing of surgical decompression in spinal cord injury (SCI) has been a research hotspot. However, despite the higher volume and increasing emphasis on quality there remains no bibliometric view on SCI and surgical decompression. In this study, we aimed to perform bibliometric analysis to reveal the core countries, affiliations, journals, authors, and developmental trends in SCI and surgical decompression across the past 50 years.

Methods

Articles and reviews were retrieved from web of science core collection between 1975 and 2024. The bibliometrix package in R was used for data analysis and visualizing.

Results

A total of 8,688 documents were investigated, indicating an ascending trend in annual publications. The USA and China played as the leaders in scientific productivity. The University of Toronto led in institutional productions. Core authors, such as Michael G. Fehlings, showed high productivity, and occasional authors showed widespread interests. Core journals like Spine and Spinal Cord served as beacons in this field. The interaction of core authors and international collaboration accentuated the cross-disciplinary feature of the field. Prominent documents emphasized the clinical significance of early decompression in 24 h post SCI.

Conclusion

Based on comprehensive bibliometric analysis and literature review, we identified the hotspots and future directions of this field: (1) further investigation into the molecular and cellular mechanisms to provide pre-clinical evidence for biological effects of early surgical decompression in SCI animal models; (2) further evaluation and validation of the optimal time window of surgical decompression based on large cohort, considering the inherent heterogeneity of subpopulations in complicated immune responses post SCI; (3) further exploration on the benefits of early decompression on the neurological, functional, and clinical outcomes in acute SCI; (4) evaluation of the optimal surgical methods and related outcomes; (5) applications of artificial intelligence-based technologies in spinal surgical decompression.

Prognosis and conditional nomogram of cervical spine fracture in patients with severe spinal cord injury: a multicenter retrospective study

INTRODUCTION

Cervical spine fractures with severe spinal cord injury (SCI) are common following cervical spine trauma and are associated with a high mortality rate. Understanding the mortality patterns of patients with cervical spine fractures and severe SCI can offer valuable evidence to surgeons and family members who are required to make critical healthcare decisions. The authors aimed to evaluate the instantaneous death risk and conditional survival (CS) of such patients and developed conditional nomograms to account for different periods of survivors and predict the survival rates.

METHODS

Their instantaneous death risks were calculated using the hazard function, and the Kaplan-Meier method was used to evaluate the survival rates. Cox regression was used to choose the variables for the construction of the nomograms. The area under the receiver operating characteristic curve and calibration plots were used to validate the performance of the nomograms.

RESULTS

The authors finally included 450 patients with cervical spine fractures and severe SCI using propensity score matching. The instantaneous death risk was the highest during the first 12 months after injury. Surgical treatment can help decrease the instantaneous death risk quickly, especially in early-term surgery. The 5-year CS increased constantly from 73.3% at baseline to 88.0% after 2 years of survival. Conditional nomograms were constructed at baseline and in those who survived for 6 and 12 months. The area under the receiver operating characteristic curve and calibration curves indicated that the nomograms had a good performance.

CONCLUSION

Their results improve our understanding of the instantaneous death risk of patients in different periods following injury. CS demonstrated the exact survival rate among medium-term and long-term survivors. Conditional nomograms are suitable for different survival periods in predicting the probability of survival. Conditional nomograms help in understanding the prognosis and improve the shared decision-making approaches.

Early Decompression in Acute Spinal Cord Injury : Review and Update

Spinal cord injury (SCI) has a significant negative effect on the quality of life due to permanent neurologic damage and economic burden by continuous treatment and rehabilitation. However, determining the correct approach to ensure optimal clinical outcomes can be challenging and remains highly controversial. In particular, with the introduction of the concept of early decompression in brain pathology, the discussion of the timing of decompression in SCI has emerged. In addition to that, the concept of "time is spine" has been added recently, and the mortality and complications caused by SCI have been reduced by providing timely and professional treatment to patients. However, there are many difficulties in establishing international clinical guidelines for the timing of early decompression in SCI because policies for each country and medical institution differ according to the circumstances of medical infrastructure and economic conditions in the surgical treatment of SCI. Therefore, we aim to provide a current review of timing of early decompression in patient with SCI.

Established and Emerging Therapies in Acute Spinal Cord Injury

Acute spinal cord injury (SCI) is devastating for patients and their caretakers and has an annual incidence of 20–50 per million people. Following initial assessment with appropriate physical examination and imaging, patients who are deemed surgical candidates should undergo decompression with stabilization. Earlier intervention can improve neurological recovery in the post-operative period while allowing earlier mobilization. Optimized medical management is paramount to improve outcomes. Emerging strategies for managing SCI in the acute period stem from an evolving understanding of the pathophysiology of the injury. General areas of focus include ischemia prevention, reduction of secondary injury due to inflammation, modulation of the cytotoxic and immune response, and promotion of cellular regeneration. In this article, we review established, emerging, and novel experimental therapies. Continued translational research on these methods will improve the feasibility of bench-to-bedside innovations in treating patients with acute SCI.

EFFECT OF TIME UNTIL DECOMPRESSION ON NEUROLOGIC RECOVERY AFTER SPINAL CORD INJURY

ABSTRACT Spinal cord injuries can have serious consequences for the individual, such as loss of motor function, sensory impairment, and alteration of physiological systems functions. Treatments for spinal cord injuries involve the use of drugs and surgical approaches. In the surgical field, there is a question about the ideal time after the trauma to perform the surgical procedure. The studies divide the time until surgery after the injury into two categories: “early” and “late”. To review the scientific literature on this topic, and to assess the relative effectiveness of early versus late decompressive surgery, we considered early intervention up to 24 hours and late intervention from 24 hours after the injury. For this, we performed a literature review and selected retrospective, prospective observational studies, clinical studies, and reviews with meta-analysis that compared the recovery time of patients with spinal cord injury after surgeries performed within 24 hours (early) and after 24 hours (late). The results showed potential for neurological improvement with early or even ultra-early surgical decompression (up to 12 hours) in patients with traumatic cervical spinal cord injury. On the other hand, reports about the advantage of early decompression when there is a thoracic injury are scarce. In addition to the time to decompression, the concomitant use of some drugs seems to play an important role in patients’ recovery. Level of Evidence II; Literature review.