An evolving strategy for surgical care

Spiritual dimensions of surgical palliative care

The spiritual dimensions of surgical palliative care encompass recognition of mortality (physician and patient); knowledge of moral and ethical dilemmas of medical decision making; respect for each individual and for all belief systems; responsibility to remain physically and psychologically present for the patient and family; and knowledge of when chaplains, palliative care professionals, or social workers should be consulted. Certain aspects of surgical palliative care distinguish it from palliative care in other medical disciplines such as the 2 definitions (palliative procedure and palliative care), treating a disproportionate share of patients who suffer unforeseen tragic events, and the surgical system.

Changing indications for surgery in patients with stage IV breast cancer: a current perspective

BACKGROUND

Evolving concepts of cancer biology and emerging evidence of a potential survival benefit from local surgery have raised the question of an expanded role for surgery in select patients with metastatic breast cancer (MBC). To determine whether such developments have influenced clinical practice, the authors evaluated surgical practice patterns in the study institution over the last 15 years.

METHODS

Two institutional databases were screened to identify patients with MBC who underwent breast surgery (1990-2005). Retrospective review was conducted to assess trends over time and to evaluate the role of surgery in the more modern era (1995-2005).

RESULTS

The overall frequency of mastectomy remained stable over time (1.7%); however, between early (1990-1995) and late (2000-2005) periods the rate of 'symptom control' mastectomy decreased (41% to 25%), whereas the rate of 'local control' mastectomy increased (34% to 66%). Conversely, the overall frequency of wide-local excision (WLE) increased over time (1995-2001), from 1% to 9% (P< .001) with no differences noted between rates of symptom control or local control procedures. In the modern era (1995-2005), 256 of 12,529 patients (2%) with MBC underwent breast surgery (33% mastectomy, 52% WLE); most frequently to 'optimize local control' (50%) and primarily in the setting of limited/stable distant disease. Surgery was performed for palliation in only 19% of patients. At a median follow-up of 33.9 months (range, 0-198.7 months), 136 of 256 patients (53%) in this cohort remained alive; 88% were free of local disease.

CONCLUSIONS

Although surgery in MBC has historically been reserved for palliation, the authors observed a decreasing rate of traditional 'toilet mastectomy' and a broadened surgical approach to the asymptomatic patient. When viewed in parallel with evolving concepts in cancer biology, these data reflect a change in the traditional approach to patients with MBC and warrant further investigation.

Clinical characteristics and outcomes in patients with advanced rectal cancer: a national prospective cohort study

PURPOSE

At the time of diagnosis, approximately one third of patients with rectal cancer present with advanced disease. In this study we focus on a group of patients with primary advanced rectal cancer considered as not operable. We address various clinical aspects relevant for decision-making in a group of patients in need of palliative care.

METHODS

Between January 1997 and December 2001, 4831 consecutive patients with rectal cancer were prospectively registered in the Norwegian Rectal Cancer Registry. In this national population-based cohort, 386 patients (8 percent) without surgical interventions were identified. These patients comprise the study population. Clinical characteristics and survivals were addressed.

RESULTS

Patients not surgically treated were significantly older compared with other treatment groups (median age, 80 years; interquartile range, 72-86 vs. median age, 71 years; interquartile range, 62-79 years) (P<0.001). Median survival time was 4.5 (range, 3.5-5.4) months, regardless of age, gender, or hospital category. Patients who received radiotherapy had a significantly increased survival (P<0.001) compared with patients not treated with radiation, with a median survival time of 10.2 (range, 7.3-12.1) months vs. 2.8 (range, 2.1-3.6) months, respectively. Use of chemotherapy was not associated with improved survival. In multivariate analysis, only stage of disease and radiotherapy were independent predictors of better survival.

CONCLUSION

Higher age and comorbidity seem to influence choice of treatment in this subgroup of patients with advanced rectal cancer disease. In nonsurgically treated patients, radiotherapy was associated with an improved survival. Our prospective, population-based cohort study emphasizes the dismal prognosis of these patients, which also should challenge our efforts and clinical approaches in palliative care.

Ethics of palliative surgery in patients with cancer

BACKGROUND

Surgery is an important palliative method for patients with advanced malignant disease. In addition to concerns related to clinical decision making, various moral challenges are encountered in palliative surgery. Some of these relate to the patients and their illness, others to the surgeons, their attitudes, skills and knowledge base.

METHOD AND RESULTS

Pertinent moral challenges are addressed and analysed with respect to prevailing perspectives in normative ethics. The vulnerability of patients with non-curable cancer calls for moral awareness. Demands regarding sensibility and precaution in this clinical setting represent substantial challenges with regard to the 'duty to help', benevolence, respect of autonomy and proper patient information. Moreover, variations in definition of palliative surgery as well as limited scientific evidence with respect to efficacy, effectiveness and efficiency pose methodological and moral problems. Therefore, a definition of palliative surgery that addresses these issues is provided.

CONCLUSION

Both surgical skill and much moral sensibility are required to improve palliative care in surgical oncology. This should be taken into account not only in clinical practice but also in education and research.

Surgical Palliative Care: An Enduring Framework for Surgical Care

Thomas R. Russell [49], Executive Director of the ACS pointed out ina recent editorial that the culture of surgery is changing and evolving, along with long-held values. He notes, "No longer is it 'my' patient, but it is 'our'patient." This shared responsibility for the surgical patient is not without peril, although this ethic has a positive application in the interdisciplinary model of palliative care. The principle of autonomy suggests that the patient, himself, shares some responsibility for a good QOL outcome. Although the focus of his remarks is fundamental change in residency training, his comments apply equally to the norms of surgical practice,especially palliative care: "We can start by building a sense of mutual respect for the broad range of individuals [including the patient and his family] involved in the care of our surgical patients, from nurses to allied health care professionals, from anesthesiologists to environmental service workers. As surgeons we must improve our communication and leadership skills, so these individuals will view us in a more positive light." Surgical palliative care is a philosophy of care that can answer this challenge. Surgeons have always been up to the challenges of their era. They never have disappointed those whom they serve in their degree of courage,practicality, and innovation, but the changing landscape of illness and culture offer new opportunities for other insights and strengths to emerge.