Biomechanical and clinical implications of distraction osteogenesis in craniofacial surgery

Ilizarov method combined with accordion technique for treating long bone defects in the lower limbs: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

Bone defects and nonunion following initial treatment remain significant clinical challenges. The Ilizarov method constitutes a fundamental approach for addressing bone defects, and its integration with adjunctive techniques, such as the accordion maneuver, antibiotic spacers, or internal fixation, has become increasingly widespread. Despite this, limited research exists on the clinical outcomes specifically related to the use of the Ilizarov method combined with the accordion technique for treating long bone defects in the lower limbs.

OBJECTIVE

This study seeks to systematically review the application of the Ilizarov method in combination with the accordion technique for addressing long bone deficiencies in the lower limbs.

STUDY DESIGN

Systematic review; Level of evidence, 4.

METHODS

A systematic review was performed in alignment with the PRISMA guidelines (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses), involving searches of Medline, Embase, Web of Science, and the Cochrane Library, with the search process concluding on August 20, 2024. The study population consisted of patients with bone defects who underwent treatment using the Ilizarov method in conjunction with the accordion technique. The methodological quality of the included studies was evaluated using the MINORS (Methodological Index for Non-Randomized Studies) scoring system. This study recorded and analyzed the participant count for each study that met the inclusion criteria, along with the number of patients who achieved bone healing, the bone and functional outcomes, and complications such as pin infections, pain, and refracture.

RESULTS

Drawing from eight studies involving 80 patients with bone defects treated through the Ilizarov method combined with the accordion technique, this systematic review evaluated the method's impact on bone regeneration. Of these patients, 24% presented with femoral defects, while 76% had tibial defects. The mean patient age was 32.8 years, with an average follow-up of 25.2 months. The accordion technique involved daily distraction and compression adjustments ranging from 0.25 to 1 mm, typically in more than two cycles, effectively promoting bone healing. The bone healing rate was high, with the majority of patients rated as having excellent or good functional recovery, according to standards such as ASAMI and Paley. Common complications included superficial pin tract infections (33.75%) and deep pin tract infections (6.25%), both of which were generally manageable with routine treatment. The accordion technique showed promising results in shortening healing time and enhancing the quality of bone healing.

CONCLUSION

This systematic review demonstrates that despite variations in parameter settings across studies, the Ilizarov method combined with the accordion technique consistently shows strong efficacy and safety in promoting bone regeneration and functional recovery. While some complications may arise, they are generally well-managed with standard care. This approach represents a reliable option for complex bone reconstruction, with future research needed to optimize parameters and further enhance clinical outcomes.

The fabrication of the chitosan-based bioink for in vitro tissue repair and regeneration: A review

The repair and regeneration of the injured tissues or organs is a major challenge for biomedicine, and the emerging 3D bioprinting technology as a class of promising techniques in biomedical research for the development of tissue engineering and regenerative medicine. Chitosan-based bioinks, as the natural biomaterials, are considered as ideal materials for 3D bioprinting to design and fabricate the various scaffold due to their unique dynamic reversibility and fantastic biological properties. Our review aims to provide an overview of chitosan-based bioinks for in vitro tissue repair and regeneration, starting from modification of chitosan that affect these bioprinting processes. In addition, we summarize the advances in chitosan-based bioinks used in the various 3D printing strategies. Moreover, the biomedical applications of chitosan-based bioinks are discussed, primarily centered on regenerative medicine and tissue modeling engineering. Finally, current challenges and future opportunities in this field are discussed. The combination of chitosan-based bioinks and 3D bioprinting will hold promise for developing novel biomedical scaffolds for tissue or organ repair and regeneration.

Histologic features of bone regenerated by means of negative pressure in the context of odontogenic keratocyst

PURPOSE

The objective of the present research is to describe the histologic features of the bone regenerated by means of negative pressure (sugosteogenesis) in a group of patients diagnosed with odontogenic keratocyst (OKC) who underwent active decompression and distraction sugosteogenesis (ADDS) at our institution.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The authors designed a retrospective case series study. The population included patients with a histologic diagnosis of odontogenic keratocyst in whom active decompression and distraction sugosteogenesis followed by enucleation was performed. All patients were seen and followed from July 2019 to January 2021. The investigation was approved by the Institutional Review Board, and it observed the Declaration of Helsinki on medical protocol. Variables of this study included age, gender, anatomic location (mandible or maxilla), and histologic characteristics of the bone regenerated by means of negative pressure. Histologic features were defined as being consistent or inconsistent with viable mature bone.

RESULTS

Bone biopsies of 6 patients were considered. In total, 83.33% of patients were males and 16.66% females. One hundred percent of the bone samples subjected to negative pressure showed features of viable mature bone.

CONCLUSIONS

In this study, the histological features of the bone subjected to negative pressure demonstrated the normal characteristics of the mature, normal bone.

Fronto-orbito-nasal advancement a surgical approach based on skull development in treatment of craniofacial deformities

The classical treatment of craniosynostosis is based on the fundamental work by Tessier. However, developmental aspects suggest modified osteotomy lines like fronto orbito nasal advancement combined with a modified midfacial distraction. This also makes it possible to take assess the different distances of the anterior displacement of the individual parts of the skull. Pioneering in therapy is less the syndrome itself than the accompanying symptoms such as respiration and intracranial pressure. For brain release we recommended (Joos 1998) the osteoclastic procedure according to Powiertowsky (1974) within the first 6 months of life. For further treatment frontoorbito-nasal advancement and modified midface distraction seem to achieve better results in enlarging the inner nose and a more harmonious profile.

Biomechanical validation of a modified genioplasty distractor

PURPOSE

Genioplasty is a surgical procedure that is used to enhance the shape and appearance of the chin. It can be performed alone or in combination with other jaw-related surgeries either for medical or cosmetic purposes. Recently many studies have been reported for mandibular reconstruction with distraction osteogenesis. However, these distractors can cause some complications such as incorrect prolongation of hard tissues due to the lack of guiding section. The purpose of this study is to manufacture a novel genioplasty distractor and measure its biomechanical stability and reliability for different activation lengths in mandibular bone.

METHODS

The modified genioplasty distractor was manufactured from grade 2 and grade 5 (Ti6AI4V) titanium alpha + beta alloy which was biocompatible and adequately rigid for possible in situ application in the future and a sample holder was manufactured for compressive strength testing.

RESULTS

Test results showed that our modified genioplasty distractors withstood 300 N compression force for activation lengths from 0 to 11 mm. Recorded stress values were in the range of 0.110 MPa to 0.389 MPa.

CONCLUSION

The modified genioplasty distractor developed and tested here is a promising surgical tool that has the potential to reduce genioplasty related complications especially in demanding cases.

A Histomorphometric Analysis of Radiation Damage in an Isogenic Murine Model of Distraction Osteogenesis

PURPOSE

The devastation radiation therapy (XRT) causes to endogenous tissue in patients with head and neck cancer can be a prohibitive obstacle in reconstruction of the mandible, demanding a better understanding of XRT-induced damage and options for reconstruction. This study investigated the cellular damage caused by radiation in an isogenic murine model of mandibular distraction osteogenesis (DO). The authors posited that radiation would result in fewer osteocytes, with increased empty lacunae and immature osteoid.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twenty Lewis rats were randomly assigned to a DO group (n = 10) or a XRT/DO group (n = 10). These groups underwent an osteotomy and mandibular DO across a 5.1-mm gap. XRT was administered to the XRT/DO group at a fractionated human equivalent dose of 35 Gy before surgery. Animals were sacrificed on postoperative day 40 and mandibles were harvested and sectioned for histologic analysis.

RESULTS

Bone that underwent radiation showed a significantly decreased osteocyte count and complementary increase in empty lacunae compared with non-XRT bone (P = .019 and P = .000). In addition, XRT bone exhibited increased immature osteoid and decreased mature woven bone compared with nonradiated bone (P = .001 and P = .003, respectively). Furthermore, analysis of the ratio of immature osteoid to woven bone volume exhibited a significant increase in the XRT bone, further showing the devastating damage from XRT (P = .001).

CONCLUSION

These results clearly show the cellular diminution that occurs as a result of radiation. This foundational study provides the groundwork on which to investigate cellular therapies in an immuno-privileged model of mandibular DO.

Biomechanical analysis of a curvilinear distractor device for correcting mandibular symphyseal defects

PURPOSE

The local mechanical environment is a determinant of successful transport disc distraction osteogenesis. This study assessed the biomechanics of a curvilinear distractor device for correcting mandibular symphyseal defects.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The finite element method was used to analyze an intact mandible, mandibular distractor bodies with different rail thicknesses (4, 6, 8, and 10 mm), and mandibular distractor bodies with rails and auxiliary lingual brackets.

RESULTS

Rail thickness was positively correlated with maximum von Mises stress in the distractor and negatively correlated with maximum displacement of the mandibular distractor bodies. The maximum von Mises stress occurred at the junction of the rails and fixed arms. It also exceeded the yield strength of the titanium material. Compared with the maximum displacement of the intact mandible, that of the mandibular distractor bodies was visibly increased.

CONCLUSION

An auxiliary lingual bracket can effectively decrease stress in such devices and displacement of mandibular distractor bodies. Rail fixation alone cannot achieve stability for distraction osteogenesis. Using an auxiliary lingual bracket effectively prevents distractor breakage and exposure.

EFFECTS OF AGING ON THE LATENCY PERIOD IN MANDIBULAR DISTRACTION OSTEOGENESIS: A COMPUTATIONAL MECHANOBIOLOGICAL ANALYSIS

Mandibular symphyseal distraction osteogenesis is a clinical procedure utilized in orthodontics for solving problems of dental overcrowding on the mandibular arch. A critical issue is to evaluate the optimal duration of the latency period between the osteotomy and the first aperture of distraction device. In fact, the latency period should change with the patient's age. To this end, a computational mechanobiological model has been developed in order to find optimal durations of latency period for young, adult, and elder patients. The model is implemented in a finite element framework simulating the process of tissue differentiation in the bone callus formed after osteotomy. The biophysical stimulus regulating the tissue differentiation process is hypothesized to be a function of the octahedral shear strain and interstitial fluid flow velocity. The resulting spatial distribution of stiffness properties in the callus region is analyzed in order to assess the risk of premature bone union of osteotomy edges. The three-dimensional (3D) finite element model (FEM) of human mandible is reconstructed from computed tomography (CT) scans and also includes a tooth-borne device. Under unilateral occlusion, the mandible is submitted to full mastication loading or to mastication forces reduced by 70%. The results show that optimal durations of the latency period for preventing premature bone union are about 5–6 days for the young patient, 7–8 days for the adult patient, and 9–10 days for the elder patient. These durations seem rather insensitive to the magnitude of mastication forces. Finally, distraction force values predicted by the present mechanobiological model are in good agreement with data reported in the literature.

[Autologous tissue engineering by means of distraction osteogenesis: Biomechanical considerations]

Tissue engineering consists in producing functional replacement tissue. Distraction osteogenesis is a tissue engineering technique that uses the mechanical environment of cells to induce tissue regeneration, without need for exogenous biochemical factors. A better understanding of the optimal mechanical conditions of distraction callus stretching may reduce the duration, discomfort, and even social impact of distraction protocols, and complications and failures. We present the current state of knowledge in this field by addressing the fundamentals of elongating bone tissue biomechanics, the influence of rhythm and rate of distraction, and that of vectors and stability. Finally, we present the innovations currently studied, which may modify our clinical protocol in the short term.

Analysis of the performance of different orthodontic devices for mandibular symphyseal distraction osteogenesis

The aim of this study was to investigate the performance of different orthodontic devices for mandibular symphyseal distraction osteogenesis (MSDO). Two performance parameters were analysed, the first of which concerned the stability guaranteed by a distractor in the fracture gap under mastication loads and the second the level of reliability with which a distractor transfers a given expansion to the mandibular bone, inasmuch as the more reliable the device the smaller the difference between the degree of expansion provided to the device and the displacement achieved on the mandibular arch. Hence, a non-linear finite element (FE) model of a human mandible with different devices (tooth-borne, bone-borne, and hybrid) was constructed and then utilized to assess the structural behaviour of the mandibular bone under distraction and mastication loads. An ad hoc algorithm was developed to simulate progressive expansion of the devices; a distraction protocol comprising a 10 day latency period and a 6 day distraction period was hypothesized. The first hypothetical expansion given to the device was 2 mm, and the five subsequent expansions were 1 mm. The results showed that the hybrid device was the most stable appliance under mastication loads, followed by the tooth- and bone-borne devices. However, parasitic rotations of the mandibular arms caused by mastication might counteract the benefits of distraction. The tooth-borne device was found to have the highest reliability in transferring expansion to the mandibular bone. For this device, mandibular expansion was less than the nominal aperture of the distractor by no more than 15 per cent. Lower values of reliability were achieved with the bone-borne device. As the values of the aperture of the appliances increased, the stability guaranteed in the fracture gap increased while the reliability in transferring expansion to the mandibular arch decreased.

Osteogenesis distraction and platelet-rich plasma: combined use in restoration of severe atrophic mandible. Long-term results

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this paper is to report long-term results on the use of autologous bone graft and platelet-rich plasma in alveolar distraction osteogenesis (DO) for restoration of severe atrophic mandible. We tested the efficacy as to reabsorption of bone volume, peri-implant reabsorption, implant survival and success rate.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twelve patients were treated. The surgical procedure consisted in mixing autologous bone, harvested from the iliac crest, with autologous platelet concentrate (APC) and in filling the distraction gap with this graft. After a latency of 15 days, a distraction rate of 0.5 mm/day was followed. After a 60-day period of consolidation, the distraction device was removed and implants were placed simultaneously. The abutment connection was accomplished after 6 months. In addition, every patient was evaluated clinically and radiographically annually for 5 years.

RESULTS

Planned alveolar height was reached in 11 out of 12 patients. The total number of implants positioned was 47. At the time of implant positioning, the mean decrease of total bone volume was 2.3%. The mean peri-implant resorption was 0.40 mm at the time of abutment connection, 0.61 mm 1 year after implant loading and 1.51 mm after 5 years. After 5 years of follow-up, the mean rate of vertical bone loss was 18.7%. Instead, the implant survival and success rates were 97.9% and 91.5%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Long-term results allow us to confirm the combination of autologous bone-platelet gel with alveolar DO as an effective and predictable procedure in restoration of severe atrophic mandible.

Tissue differentiation and bone regeneration in an osteotomized mandible: a computational analysis of the latency period

Mandibular symphyseal distraction osteogenesis is a common clinical procedure to modify the geometrical shape of the mandible for correcting problems of dental overcrowding and arch shrinkage. In spite of consolidated clinical use, questions remain concerning the optimal latency period and the influence of mastication loading on osteogenesis within the callus prior to the first distraction of the mandible. This work utilized a mechano-regulation model to assess bone regeneration within the callus of an osteotomized mandible. A 3D model of the mandible was reconstructed from CT scan data and meshed using poroelastic finite elements (FE). The stimulus regulating tissue differentiation within the callus was hypothesized to be a function of the strain and fluid flow computed by the FE model. This model was then used to analyse tissue differentiation during a 15-day latency period, defined as the time between the day of the osteotomy and the day when the first distraction is given to the device. The following predictions are made: (1) the mastication forces generated during the latency period support osteogenesis in certain regions of the callus, and that during the latency period the percentage of progenitor cells differentiating into osteoblasts increases; (2) reducing the mastication load by 70% during the latency period increases the number of progenitor cells differentiating into osteoblasts; (3) the stiffness of new tissue increases at a slower rate on the side of bone callus next to the occlusion of the mandibular ramus which could cause asymmetries in the bone tissue formation with respect to the middle sagittal plane. Although the model predicts that the mastication loading generates such asymmetries, their effects on the spatial distribution of callus mechanical properties are insignificant for typical latency periods used clinically. It is also predicted that a latency period of longer than a week will increase the risk of premature bone union across the callus.

The Influence of Expansion Rates on Mandibular Distraction Osteogenesis: A Computational Analysis

Mandibular distraction osteogenesis is a clinical procedure used for modifying the mandibular geometry when problems of dental overcrowding and arch shrinkage occur. The objective of this study is to use a computational model of tissue differentiation to examine the influence of the rate of distraction on bone re-growth within the fracture callus of a human mandible submitted to symphyseal distraction osteogenesis. A 3D model of the mandible is reconstructed from CT scan data and meshed into finite elements. Two different mastication loadings have been investigated: a 'full' mastication load and a 'reduced' mastication load where the action of each muscle was reduced by 70%. Four different distraction rates were analyzed: 0.6, 1.2, 2, and 3 mm/day, allowing a total displacement of 6 mm. In the early stages of the distraction process it is predicted that there is a decrease in the amount of bone tissue forming within the center of the fracture gap for all distraction rates. After the initial phases of expansion, the bone tissue within the callus increases for the slower rate of distraction or continues to decrease at the faster rates of distraction. At the end of the simulated maturation period, 47% of the distracted callus was predicted to consist of bone tissue for a distraction rate of 0.6 mm/day, decreasing to 22% for a distraction rate of 3 mm/day. Significantly higher amounts of bone formation were predicted for all distraction rates for the case of reduced mastication loading. Disparities between the model predictions and what is observed in vivo were found. For instance, during the latency period, the distraction period and beyond, the model is predicting larger than expected amounts of cartilage tissue formation within the callus. This and other limitations of the proposed model are discussed and possible specific explanations for these disparities are provided in the paper. The model predicts a distraction rate of around 1.2 mm/day to be optimal as higher rates produce less bone tissue while the risk of a premature bone union is greater at slower rates of distraction because in the latter stages of the distraction process bone tissue is predicted to form between the left and right side of the bone callus.

Regenerative approaches in the craniofacial region: manipulating cellular progenitors for oro-facial repair

This review aims to highlight the potential for regeneration that resides within the bony tissues of the craniofacial region. We examine the five main cues which determine osteogenic differentiation: heritage of the cell, mechanical cues, the influence of the matrix, growth factor stimulation and cell-to-cell contact. We review how successful clinical procedures, such as guided tissue regeneration and distraction osteogenesis exploit this resident ability. We explore the developmental origins of the flat bones of the skull to see how such programmes of differentiation may inform new therapies or regenerative techniques. Finally we compare and contrast existing approaches of hard tissue reconstruction with future approaches inspired by the regenerative medicine philosophy, with particular emphasis on the potential for using chondrocyte-inspired factors and replaceable scaffolds.