Intrarater reliability and agreement of linear encoder derived heel-rise endurance test outcome measures in healthy adults

Early Tendon Morphology as a Biomarker of Long-term Patient Outcomes After Surgical Repair of Achilles Tendon Rupture: A Prospective Cohort Study

Background

Patient outcome after acute Achilles tendon rupture (ATR) varies and is difficult to predict. Whether early variations in healing, visualized with ultrasonography, can predict long-term patient outcome is unclear.

Purpose

To (1) examine the associations of Achilles tendon cross-sectional area (CSA) and elongation (TE) during healing of ATR repair with patient outcomes at 12 months postoperatively and (2) investigate the predictive or diagnostic capacity of the morphological biomarkers.

Study Design

Cohort study; Level of evidence, 2.

Methods

This study was based on previously collected data from 86 patients who underwent acute standardized ATR repair between 2013 and 2018 and who were included in a prior randomized trial investigating early functional mobilization (EFM). In the EFM group, loading was allowed immediately after surgery, while in the comparison group, loading was allowed first at 2 weeks postoperatively. Achilles tendon CSA and length were measured with ultrasound at 6 weeks, 6 months, and 12 months postoperatively. CSA ratio and absolute difference in the length of the healthy and injured tendons were calculated. Patient-reported outcome was registered with the validated Achilles tendon Total Rupture Score and functional outcome with the heel-rise endurance test at 12 months postoperatively. The limb symmetry index (LSI) was calculated for maximum heel-rise height (HRHmax) and total concentric work. Multiple linear regression adjusted for age was used, and the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) was calculated to evaluate predictive capacity.

Results

A larger CSA ratio at 6 weeks was associated with higher LSI HRHmax at 12 months (R2, 0.35; P < .001) and exhibited good predictive capacity (AUC, 0.82). More TE at 12 months was associated with lower LSI total concentric work at 12 months (R2, 0.21; P = .001) and exhibited acceptable predictive capacity (AUC, 0.71).

Conclusion

Greater Achilles tendon CSA seen on ultrasound 6 weeks after surgical repair had good clinical prediction for long-term functional outcome. TE at 12 months was predictive of inferior functional outcome.

Registration

NCT02318472 (ClinicalTrials.gov identifier).

Devices to measure calf raise test outcomes: A narrative review

BACKGROUND

The calf raise test (CRT) is commonly administered without a device in clinics to measure triceps surae muscle function. To standardise and objectively quantify outcomes, researchers use research-grade or customised CRT devices. To incorporate evidence-based practice and apply testing devices effectively in clinics, it is essential to understand their design, applicability, psychometric properties, strengths, and limitations. Therefore, this review identifies, summarises, and critically appraises the CRT devices used in science.

METHODS

Four electronic databases were searched in April 2022. Studies that used devices to measure unilateral CRT outcomes (i.e., number of repetitions, work, height) were included.

RESULTS

Thirty-five studies met inclusion, from which seven CRT devices were identified. Linear encoder (n = 18) was the most commonly used device, followed by laboratory equipment (n = 6) (three-dimensional motion capture and force plate). These measured the three CRT outcomes. Other devices used were electrogoniometer, Häggmark and Liedberg light beam device, Ankle Measure for Endurance and Strength (AMES), Haberometer, and custom-made. Devices were mostly used in healthy populations or Achilles tendon pathologies. AMES, Haberometer, and custom-made devices were the most clinician-friendly, but only quantified repetitions were completed. In late 2022, a computer vision mobile application appeared in the literature and offered clinicians a low-cost, research-grade alternative.

CONCLUSION

This review details seven devices used to measure CRT outcomes. The linear encoder is the most common in research and quantifies all three CRT outcomes. Recent advances in computer-vision provide a low-cost research-grade alternative to clinicians and researchers via a n iOS mobile application.

Reliability and validity of two-dimensional motion capture to assess ankle dorsiflexion motion and heel raise work

OBJECTIVES

To determine the inter-rater reliability and criterion validity of two-dimensional (2D) measures of ankle function in the sagittal plane for participants with Achilles tendinopathy (AT).

DESIGN

Cohort study.

SETTING

University Laboratory, Participants, Adults with AT (N = 18, Women: 72.2%, Age = 43.4 ± 15.8 years, BMI = 28.7 ± 8.9 kg/m2) MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Reliability and validity were determined with intra-class correlation coefficients (ICC), standard error of the measurement (SEM), minimal detectable change (MDC), and Bland-Altman plots for ankle dorsiflexion and positive work during heel raises.

RESULTS

Inter-rater reliability between three raters for all 2D motion analysis tasks was good to excellent (ICC = 0.88 to 0.99). Criterion validity between 2D and 3D motion analyses for all tasks was good to excellent (ICC = 0.76 to 0.98). 2D motion analysis overestimated ankle dorsiflexion motion by 1.0-1.7° (3% of mean sample value) and positive ankle joint work by 76.8 J (9% of mean) compared to 3D motion analysis.

CONCLUSION

Although 2D and 3D measures are not interchangeable, the good to excellent reliability and validity of 2D measures in the sagittal plane support the use of video analysis to quantify ankle function for individuals with foot and ankle pain.

Concurrent validity and reliability of a mobile iOS application used to assess calf raise test kinematics

BACKGROUND

Calf raise test (CRT) is used in rehabilitation and sports medicine to evaluate calf muscle function. The Calf Raise application (CR_app) uses computer-vision algorithms to objectively measure CRT outcomes and replicate laboratory-based metrics that are difficult to measure clinically.

OBJECTIVE

To validate the CR_app by examining its concurrent validity and agreement levels against laboratory-based equipment, and its intra- and inter-rater reliability.

DESIGN

Observational cross-sectional validation study.

METHODS

CRT outcomes (i.e., repetitions, positive work, total height, peak height, fatigue index, and peak power) were assessed in thirteen individuals (6 males, 7 females) on three occasions on both legs using the CR_app, 3D motion capture, and force plate simultaneously. Data were extracted from two markers: below lateral malleolus (n = 77) and on the heel (n = 77). Concurrent validity and agreement were determined from 154 data files using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC_3,k), typical errors expressed as coefficient of variations (CV), and Bland-Altman plots to assess biases and precision. Reliability was assessed using ICC_3,1 and CV values.

RESULTS

Validity of CR_app outcomes was good to excellent across measures for both markers (mean ICC ≥0.878), precision plots showing good agreement and precision. CV ranged from 0% (repetitions) to 33.3% (fatigue index) and were on average better for the lateral malleolus marker. Inter- and intra-rater reliability were excellent (ICC≥0.949, CV ≤ 5.6%).

CONCLUSION

CR_app is valid and reliable within and between users for measuring CRT outcomes in healthy adults. CR_app provides a tool to objectivise CRT outcomes in research and practice, aligning with recent advances in mobile technologies and their increased use in healthcare.

Research protocol to evaluate the effectiveness of shockwave therapy, photobiomodulation and physical therapy in the management of non-insertional Achilles tendinopathy in runners: a randomised control trial with elective cross-over design

Background

Achilles tendinopathy (AT) is a common overuse injury in runners. While the mainstay of treatment for AT is tendon loading exercises (physical therapy and exercise programme (EXER)), some patients have refractory symptoms. Extracorporeal shockwave therapy (ESWT) and photobiomodulation therapy (PBMT) have each been evaluated to facilitate tendon healing; the influence of combining treatments is unknown and limited studies have been completed in runners. This randomised control study, with an elective cross-over at 3 months, will evaluate the efficacy of three forms of treatment of non-insertional AT: (1) EXER (loading programme specific to Achilles tendon combined with physical therapy); (2) EXER and ESWT; (3) EXER, ESWT and PBMT. Sixty runners will be assigned using block randomisation into one of three treatment groups (n=20). After 3 months, each participant may elect a different treatment than previously assigned and will be followed for an additional 3 months. The EXER Achilles loading programme will be standardised using the Silbernagel at-home programme. The primary outcome of interest is treatment group responses using the Victorian Institute of Sports Assessment—Achilles (VISA-A) Score. Secondary outcomes include the Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System—29 questions, the University of Wisconsin Running Injury and Recovery Index, heel raise to fatigue test, hopping test and ultrasound measurements. We will also capture patient preference and satisfaction with treatment. We hypothesise that the cohorts assigned EXER+ESWT+PBMT and EXER+ESWT will see greater improvements in VISA-A than the EXER cohort, and the largest gains are anticipated in combining ESWT+PBMT. The elective cross-over phase will be an exploratory study and will inform us whether patient preference for treatment will impact the treatment response.

Trial registration number

NCT04725513.

Early Tensile Loading in Nonsurgically Treated Achilles Tendon Ruptures Leads to a Larger Tendon Callus and a Lower Elastic Modulus: A Randomized Controlled Trial

BACKGROUND

Early tensile loading improves material properties of healing Achilles tendon ruptures in animal models and in surgically treated human ruptures. However, the effect of such rehabilitation in patients who are nonsurgically treated remains unknown.

HYPOTHESIS

In nonsurgically treated Achilles tendon ruptures, early tensile loading would lead to higher elastic modulus 19 weeks after the injury compared with controls.

STUDY DESIGN

Randomized controlled trial; Level of evidence, 2.

METHODS

Between October 2015 and November 2018, a total of 40 nonsurgically treated patients with acute Achilles tendon rupture were randomized to an early tensile loading (loaded group) or control group. Tantalum bead markers were inserted percutaneously into the tendon stumps 2 weeks after the injury to allow high-precision measurements of callus deformation under mechanical testing. The loaded group used a training pedal twice daily to produce a gradual increase in tensile load during the following 5 weeks. Both groups were allowed full weightbearing in an ankle orthosis and unloaded range of motion exercises. Patients were followed clinically and via roentgen stereophotogrammetric analysis and computed tomography at 7, 19, and 52 weeks after the injury.

RESULTS

The mean ± standard deviation elastic modulus at 19 weeks was 95.6 ± 38.2 MPa in the loaded group and 108 ± 45.2 MPa in controls (P = .37). The elastic modulus increased in both groups, although it was lower in the loaded group at all time points. Tendon cross-sectional area increased from 7 weeks to 19 weeks, from 231 ± 99.5 to 388 ± 142 mm² in the loaded group and from 188 ± 65.4 to 335 ± 87.2 mm² in controls (P < .001 for the effect of time). Cross-sectional area for the loaded group versus controls at 52 weeks was 302 ± 62.4 mm² versus 252 ± 49.2 mm², respectively (P = .03). Gap elongation was 7.35 ± 13.9 mm in the loaded group versus 2.86 ± 5.52 mm in controls (P = .27).

CONCLUSION

Early tensile loading in nonsurgically treated Achilles tendon ruptures did not lead to higher elastic modulus in the healing tendon but altered the structural properties of the tendon via an increased tendon thickness.

REGISTRATION

NCT0280575 (ClinicalTrials.gov identifier).

Validity, reliability, and normative data on calf muscle function in rugby union players from the Calf Raise application

We examined the validity and reliability of biomechanical outcomes extracted using the Calf Raise application of three calf muscle tests. We then established normative calf muscle function values for male rugby union players accounting for rugby-related factors (position, level) alone and together with clinical factors (age, leg dominance, BMI, previous injury). In total, 120 athletes performed three single-leg calf muscle tests. Twenty athletes participated in application validation; 18 in test-retest reliability; and all in establishing normative equations. Validity of application outcomes against 3D motion and force plate data was good-to-excellent (CV ≤ 6.6%, ICC ≥0.84). Test-retest reliability was good across outcomes following familiarisation (CV < 10%, ICC ≥0.83). Forwards produced superior power than backs during the bodyweight (59 W, p = 0.007) and weighted (73 W, p < 0.001) power tests. Playing level influenced power outcomes (p < 0.009). Super Rugby players were more powerful than Club (both power tests), Provincial (both power tests), and International (bodyweight power). Backs completed more repetitions (3 repetitions, p = 0.001) and positive displacement (30 cm, p = 0.001) than forwards during endurance testing. When accounting for clinical factors; BMI, age, and previous injury explained some of the differences observed between positions and levels. This study provides initial benchmark values of calf muscle function in rugby union.

The heel-raise test for ankle plantarflexor strength: a scoping review and meta-analysis of studies providing norms

[Purpose] The heel-raise test (HRT) is sometimes used to quantify ankle plantarflexion strength. However, descriptions of the test vary and normative values are limited. This paper, therefore was generated to summarize procedures and provide normative values for the HRT in a younger and older age group of adults. [Methods] Electronic and hand searches were conducted to identify relevant literature. Meta-analysis was used to provide norms. [Results] Among 439 nonduplicative articles identified, 13 qualifying articles were ultimately included. Procedures for the HRT described in the studies varied considerably. The mean number of HRT repetitions was 28.7 for adults with a mean age less than 40 years and 11.8 for adults with a mean age greater than 60 years. [Conclusion] This study provides information on HRT performance and norms derived with them for younger and older adults.

The Impact of the Degree of Kinesiophobia on Recovery in Patients With Achilles Tendinopathy

OBJECTIVE

Kinesiophobia has been proposed to influence recovery in individuals with Achilles tendinopathy. However, whether there are differences in outcomes in individuals with different levels of kinesiophobia is unknown. The purpose of this study was to compare the characteristics of patients at baseline and recovery over time in individuals with Achilles tendinopathy and various levels of kinesiophobia.

METHODS

This study was a secondary analysis of a prospective observational cohort study of 59 individuals with Achilles tendinopathy. The participants were divided into 3 groups on the basis of scores on the Tampa Scale for Kinesiophobia (TSK) (those with low TSK scores [≤33; low TSK group], those with medium TSK scores [34-41; medium TSK group], and those with high TSK scores [≥42; high TSK group]). All participants were evaluated with self-reported outcomes, clinical evaluation, tendon morphology, viscoelastic property measurements, and a calf muscle endurance test at baseline, 6 months, and 12 months. No treatment was provided throughout the study period.

RESULTS

There were 16 participants (8 women) in the low TSK group (age = 51.9 [SD = 15.3] years, body mass index [BMI] = 24.3 [22.3-25.4]), 28 participants (13 women) in the medium TSK group (age = 52.7 [SD = 15.2] years, BMI = 26.4 [22.5-30.8]), and 15 participants (8 women) in the high TSK group (age = 61.1 [SD = 11.1] years, BMI = 28.1 [25.2-33.6]). Among the groups at baseline, the high TSK group had significantly greater BMI and symptom severity and lower quality of life. All groups showed significant improvement over time for all outcomes except tendon viscoelastic properties and tendon thickening when there was an adjustment for baseline BMI. The high and medium TSK groups saw decreases in kinesiophobia at 6 months, but there was no change for the low TSK group.

CONCLUSION

Despite the high TSK group having the highest BMI and the worse symptom severity and quality of life at baseline, members of this group showed improvements in all of the outcome domains similar to those of the other groups over 12 months.

IMPACT

Evaluating the degree of kinesiophobia in individuals with Achilles tendinopathy might be of benefit for understanding how they are affected by the injury. However, the degree of kinesiophobia at baseline does not seem to affect recovery; this finding could be due to the patients receiving education about the injury and expectations of recovery.

Analysis of the Results of Heel-Rise Test with Sensors: A Systematic Review

Strokes are a constant concern for people and pose a major health concern. Tests that allow detection and the rehabilitation of patients have started to become more important and essential. There are several tests used by physiotherapists to speed up the recovery process of patients. This article presents a systematic review of existing studies using the Heel-Rise Test and sensors (i.e., accelerometers, gyroscopes, pressure and tilt sensors) to estimate the different levels and health statuses of individuals. It was found that the most measured parameter was related to the number of repetitions, and the maximum number of repetitions for a healthy adult is 25 repetitions. As for future work, the implementation of these methods with a simple mobile device will facilitate the different measurements on this subject.

Tendon Morphology and Mechanical Properties Are Associated With the Recovery of Symptoms and Function in Patients With Achilles Tendinopathy

Background:

Achilles tendinopathy is a debilitating overuse injury characterized by pain, altered Achilles tendon structure, and impaired functional performance. Evaluating tendon structure as part of the physical examination may help establish a well-defined prognosis. However, the usefulness of measuring tendon structure for developing a prognosis has been questioned since structural abnormalities can exist without symptoms.

Purpose:

To determine whether initial measures of tendon morphology and mechanical properties were associated with patient-reported symptoms and calf muscle endurance at baseline, 6-month follow-up, and 1-year follow-up by prospectively following a cohort of individuals with Achilles tendinopathy.

Study Design:

Cohort study; Level of evidence, 2.

Methods:

A total of 59 participants with midportion or insertional Achilles tendinopathy completed an initial assessment and follow-up assessments at 6 months and 1 year. At the initial assessment, patient-reported symptoms, calf muscle endurance, and Achilles tendon thickening were evaluated, and Achilles tendon mechanical properties were estimated. At the 6-month and 1-year follow-up assessments, patient-reported symptoms and calf muscle endurance were reevaluated.

Results:

Greater Achilles tendon thickening at the initial assessment was consistently associated with worse patient-reported symptoms and calf muscle endurance at each assessment. Changes in symptoms over the year were moderated by the initial shear modulus of the tendon, with a lower shear modulus associated with less improvement in symptoms. Lower viscosity at the initial assessment was also associated with worse calf muscle endurance at each assessment.

Conclusion:

Measures of tendon morphology and mechanical properties appear to be associated with patient-reported symptoms and calf muscle function for patients with Achilles tendinopathy.

Current Clinical Concepts: Conservative Management of Achilles Tendinopathy

Achilles tendinopathy is a painful overuse injury that is extremely common in athletes, especially those who participate in running and jumping sports. In addition to pain, Achilles tendinopathy is accompanied by alterations in the tendon's structure and mechanical properties, altered lower extremity function, and fear of movement. Cumulatively, these impairments limit sport participation and performance. A thorough evaluation and comprehensive treatment plan, centered on progressive tendon loading, is required to ensure full recovery of tendon health and to minimize the risk of reinjury. In this review, we will provide an update on the evidence-based evaluation, outcome assessment, treatment, and return-to-sport planning for Achilles tendinopathy. Furthermore, we will provide the strength of evidence for these recommendations using the Strength of Recommendation Taxonomy system.

Achilles tendon cross-sectional area at 12 weeks post-rupture relates to 1-year heel-rise height

PURPOSE

Achilles tendon rupture leads to long-term plantar flexor deficits, but some patients recover functional performance better than others. Early indicators of tendon healing could be helpful in establishing patient prognosis and making individualized decisions regarding rehabilitation progression. The purpose of this study was to investigate relationships between early tendon morphology and mechanical properties to long-term heel-rise and jumping function in individuals after Achilles tendon rupture.

METHODS

Individuals after Achilles tendon rupture were assessed at 4, 8, 12, 24, and 52 weeks post-injury. Tendon cross-sectional area, length, and mechanical properties were measured using ultrasound. Heel-rise and jump tests were performed at 24 and 52 weeks. Correlation and regression analysis were used to identify relationships between tendon structural variables in the first 12 weeks to functional outcomes at 52 weeks, and determine whether the addition of tendon structural characteristics at 24 weeks strengthened relationships between functional performance at 24 and 52 weeks. Functional outcomes of individuals with < 3 cm of elongation were compared to those with > 3 cm of elongation using a Mann-Whitney U test.

RESULTS

Twenty-two participants [mean (SD) age = 40 (11) years, 17 male] were included. Tendon cross-sectional area at 12 weeks was the strongest predictor of heel-rise height (R² = 0.280, p = 0.014) and work symmetry (R² = 0.316, p = 0.008) at 52 weeks. Jumping performance at 52 weeks was not significantly related to any of the tendon structural measures in the first 12 weeks. Performance of all functional tasks at 24 weeks was positively related to performance on the same task at 52 weeks (r = 0.456-0.708, p < 0.05). The addition of tendon cross-sectional area improved the model for height LSI (R² = 0.519, p = 0.001). Tendon elongation > 3 cm significantly reduced jumping symmetry (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

Tendon cross-sectional area and excessive elongation related to plantar flexor performance on functional testing after Achilles tendon rupture. Once an individual is able to perform function-based testing, tendon structural measures may inform long-term prognosis. Ultrasound-based measures of tendon structure early in recovery seem to relate to later performance on functional testing. Clinically, assessing tendon structure has the potential to be used as a biomarker of tendon healing early in recovery and better predict patients at risk of negative functional outcome.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

II.