Removal efficiency, kinetic, and behavior of antibiotics from sewage treatment plant effluent in a hybrid constructed wetland and a layered biological filter

Removal of metals and emergent contaminants from liquid digestates in constructed wetlands for agricultural reuse

Given the increasing pressure on water bodies, it is imperative to explore sustainable methodologies for wastewater treatment and reuse. The simultaneous presence of multiples contaminants in complex wastewater, such as the liquid effluents from biogas plants, can compromise biological treatment effectiveness for reclaiming water. Vertical subsurface flow constructed wetlands were established as low-cost decentralized wastewater treatment technologies to treat the liquid fraction of digestate from municipal organic waste with metals, antibiotics, and antibiotic resistance genes, to allow its reuse in irrigation. Twelve lab-scale planted constructed wetlands were assembled with gravel, light expanded clay aggregate and sand, testing four different treating conditions (liquid digestate spiked with oxytetracycline, sulfadiazine, or ofloxacin, at 100 μg/ L, or without dosing) during 3 months. Physicochemical parameters (pH, chemical oxygen demand (COD), nutrients, metals, and antibiotics), the microbial communities dynamics (through 16S high-throughput sequencing) and antibiotic resistance genes removal (qPCR) were monitored in influents and effluents. Systems removed 85.8%-96.9% of organic matter (as COD), over 98.1% of ammonium and phosphate ions, and 69.3%-99.4% of nitrate and nitrite ions, with no significant differences between the presence or absence of antibiotics. Removal of Fe, Mn, Zn, Cu, Pb and Cr exceeded 82% in all treatment cycles. The treatment also removed oxytetracycline, sulfadiazine and ofloxacin over 99%, and decreased intl1, tetA, tetW, sul1 and qnrS gene copies. Nonetheless, after 3 months of ofloxacin dosing, qnrS gene started being detected. Removal processes relied on high HRT (14 days) and various mechanisms including sorption, biodegradation, and precipitation. Microbial community diversity in liquid digestate changed significantly after treatment in constructed wetlands with a decrease in the initial Firmicutes dominance, but with no clear effect of antibiotics on the microbial community structure. Removals above 85% and 94% were observed for Streptococcus and Clostridium, respectively. Results suggest that vertical subsurface flow constructed wetlands were a suitable technology for treating the liquid digestate to reuse it in irrigation agricultural systems, contributing to the circular bioeconomy concept. However, a more profound understanding of effective wastewater treatment strategies is needed to avoid antibiotic resistance genes dissemination.

Purification of the secondary treatment tail water for wastewater reclamation by integrated subsurface-constructed wetlands

A whole-year investigation of full-scale integrated subsurface-constructed wetlands (ISCWs) was carried out to purify the tail water from a wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) for wastewater reclamation under four plant species, four hydraulic loading rates (HLRs), and four seasons. The results showed that ISCWs were effective for the purification of WWTP discharge, with the average removal efficiencies of COD, NH4+-N, TN, and TP being 48%, 49%, 9%, and 30%, respectively. Typical pollutant concentrations in the treated effluent of ISCWs were 8.19 mg/L COD, 1.76 mg/L NH4+-N, 11.57 mg/L TN, and 0.36 mg/L TP, which met most of the water quality standards for reusing recycling water. Emergent plants with well-developed root systems may be capable of promoting the decontamination of ISCWs. Seasonal change played an important role in the treatment process: the removal of phosphorus by plant uptake and microbial utilization was more active in the warm season and the co-occurrence of organic degradation and nitrification, whereas the cold season is conducive to exothermic adsorption process of pollutants to substrates. Properly increasing the HLRs may improve the availability of ISCWs according to the requirement of effluent quality. Furthermore, the C/N ratio might be the key factor for the purification effect of ISCWs, because the COD level of WWTP discharge may change the process of NH4+-N biotransformation.

Response of biofilm-based systems for antibiotics removal from wastewater: Resource efficiency and process resiliency

Biofilm-based systems have efficient stability to cope-up influent shock loading with protective and abundant microbial assemblage, which are extensively exploited for biodegradation of recalcitrant antibiotics from wastewater. The system performance is subject to biofilm types, chemical composition, growth and thickness maintenance. The present study elaborates discussion on different type of biofilms and their formation mechanism involving extracellular polymeric substances secreted by microbes when exposed to antibiotics-laden wastewater. The biofilm models applied for estimation/prediction of biofilm-based systems performance are explored to classify the application feasibility. Further, the critical review of antibiotics removal efficiency, design and operation of different biofilm-based systems (e.g. rotating biological contactor, membrane biofilm bioreactor etc.) is performed. Extending the information on effect of various process parameters (e.g. hydraulic retention time, pH, biocarrier filling ratio etc.), the microbial community dynamics responsible of antibiotics biodegradation in biofilms, the technological problems, related prospective and key future research directions are demonstrated. The biofilm-based system with biocarriers filling ratio of ∼50-70% and predominantly enriched with bacterial species of phylum Proteobacteria protected under biofilm thickness of ∼1600 μm is effectively utilized for antibiotic biodegradation (>90%) when operated at DO concentration ≥3 mg/L. The C/N ratio ≥1 is best suitable condition to eliminate antibiotic pollution from biofilm-based systems. Considering the significance of biofilm-based systems, this review study could be beneficial for the researchers targeting to develop sustainable biofilm-based technologies with feasible regulatory strategies for treatment of mixed antibiotics-laden real wastewater.

The efficiency of full-scale subsurface constructed wetlands with high hydraulic loading rates in removing pharmaceutical and personal care products from secondary effluent

Constructed wetlands (CWs) are usually operated at low hydraulic load rates (HLRs) of < 0.5 m³/m²/d, and can efficiently remove pharmaceuticals and personal care products (PPCPs) from wastewaters. They however often occupy a large area of land, especially when treating the secondary effluent from wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) in megacities. High-load CWs (HCWs) with an HLR ≥ 1 m³/m²/d, requiring smaller land areas, are a good option for urban areas. However, their performance for PPCP removal is not clear. In this study, we evaluated the performance of three full-scale HCWs (HLR: 1.0-1.3 m³/m²/d) to remove 60 PPCPs, and found they had a stable removal performance and a higher areal removal capacity than the previously reported CWs operated at low HLRs. We verified the advantages of HCWs by testing the efficiency of two identical CWs at a low HLR (0.15 m³/m²/d) and a high HLR (1.3 m³/m²/d) fed with the same secondary effluent. The areal removal capacity during the high-HLR operation was 6-9 times higher than that during the low-HLR operation. A high dissolved oxygen content, and low COD and NH₄-N concentrations in the secondary effluent were critical for the robust PPCP removal by tertiary treatment HCWs.

Screening of pharmaceutical and personal care products (PPCPs) along wastewater treatment system equipped with root zone treatment: A potential model for domestic waste leachate management

We present the use of root zone treatment (RZT) based system for the removal of pharmaceutical and personal care products (PPCPs) from domestic wastewater. The occurrence of more than a dozen PPCPs were detected in an academic institution wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) at three specific locations, i.e., influent, root treatment zone, and effluents. The comparisons of observed compounds detected at various stages of WWTP suggest that the presence of PPCPs, like homatropine, cytisine, carbenoxolone, 4,2',4',6'-tetrahydroxychalcone, norpromazine, norethynodrel, fexofenadine, indinavir, dextroamphetamine, 3-hydroxymorphinan, phytosphingosine, octadecanedioic acid, meradimate, 1-hexadecanoyl-sn-glycerol, and 1-hexadecylamine, are unusual than the usual reported PPCPs in the WWTPs. In general, carbamazepine, ibuprofen, acetaminophen, trimethoprim, sulfamethoxazole, caffeine, triclocarban, and triclosan are often reported in wastewater systems. The normalized abundances of PPCPs range between 0.037-0.012, 0.108-0.009, and 0.208-0.005 in main influent, root zone effluent, and main effluents, respectively, of the WWTP. In addition, the removal rates of PPCPs were observed from -200.75% to ∼100% at RZT phase in the plant. Interestingly, we observed several PPCPs at later stages of treatment which were not detected in the influent of the WWTP. This is probably owing to the presence of conjugated metabolites of various PPCPs present in the influent, which subsequently got deconjugated to reform the parent compounds during the biological wastewater treatment. In addition, we suspect the potential release of earlier absorbed PPCPs in the system, which were absent on that particular day of sampling but have been part of earlier influents. In essence, RZT-based WWTP was found to be effective in removing the PPCPs and other organic contaminants in the study but results in stress the need for further comprehensive research on RZT system to conclude the exact removal efficacy and fate of PPCPs during treatment in the system. As a current research gap, the study also recommended RZT to be appraised for PPCPs in-situ remediation from landfill leachates, an underestimated source of PPCPs intrusion in the environment.

Occurrence, fate, and risk assessment of antibiotics in typical pharmaceutical manufactories and receiving water bodies from different regions

This study aimed to investigate the presence and persistence of antibiotics in wastewater of four typical pharmaceutical manufactories in China and receiving water bodies and suggest the removal of antibiotics by the wastewater treatment process. It also evaluated the environmental impact of antibiotic residues through wastewater discharge into receiving water bodies. The results indicated that thirteen antibiotics were detected in wastewater samples with concentrations ranging from 57.03 to 726.79 ng/L. Fluoroquinolones and macrolides were the most abundant antibiotic classes found in wastewater samples, accounting for 42.5% and 38.7% of total antibiotic concentrations, respectively, followed by sulfonamides (16.4%) and tetracyclines (2.4%). Erythromycin-H2O, lincomycin, ofloxacin, and trimethoprim were the most frequently detected antibiotics; among these antibiotics, the concentration of ofloxacin was the highest in most wastewater samples. No significant difference was found in different treatment processes used to remove antibiotics in wastewater samples. More than 50% of antibiotics were not completely removed with a removal efficiency of less than 70%. The concentration of detected antibiotics in the receiving water bodies was an order of magnitude lower than that in the wastewater sample due to dilution. An environmental risk assessment showed that lincomycin and ofloxacin could pose a high risk at the concentrations detected in effluents and a medium risk in their receiving water bodies, highlighting a potential hazard to the health of the aquatic ecosystem. Overall, The investigation was aimed to determine and monitor the concentration of selected antibiotics in 4 typical PMFs and their receiving water bodies, and to study the removal of these substances in PMFs. This study will provide significant data and findings for future studies on antibiotics-related pollution control and management in water bodies.

Seasonal variability of the correlation network of antibiotics, antibiotic resistance determinants, and bacteria in a wastewater treatment plant and receiving water

Sewage treatment plants are an essential source of antibiotics, antibiotic resistance determinants, and bacteria in environmental waters. However, it is still unclear whether they can maintain a relatively stable relationship in wastewater and environmental waters. This study analyzed the removal capacity of the above three pollutants in the sewage treatment plant in summer and their impact on environmental waters, and then examines the relationship between the three contaminants in the wastewater and environmental waters in summer and winter based on our previous study. The results found that the removal capacity of bacteria in summer was poor, the concentration of fluoroquinolone in the effluent was higher than that in influent, and the abundance of intI1, tetW, qnrB, and ermB increased after wastewater treatment. Proteobacteria and Bacteroides were the main bacteria that constitute the correlation network between bacteria, and they existed stably in summer and winter. However, fluoroquinolones occupied a significant position in the determinant network of antibiotics and antibiotic resistance in summer and winter. There are fewer correlation between antibiotics and antibiotics resistance determinants in winter. Interestingly, the relationship between bacteria, antibiotics, and antibiotic resistance determinants was a mainly positive correlation in summer and negative correlation in winter. This study analyzed the relationship between bacteria, antibiotics, and antibiotic resistance determinants that were stable in the wastewater and environmental waters and pointed out the direction for subsequent targeted seasonal control of novel pollutants in wastewater and environmental waters.

Study on visible light photocatalytic performance of MIL-100(Fe) modified by carbon nanodots

The emerging porous material metal organic framework (MOFs) has caught researchers' attention in the field of photocatalysis. In this study, a visible light-driven carbon nanodots/MIL-100(Fe) photocatalytic material was prepared by in situ synthesis method. The study found that the composite material loaded with 2.5 mg C-dots (2.5-carbon nanodots/MIL-100(Fe)) showed the best tetracycline degradation efficiency with 4.2 times higher than that of MIL-100(Fe) materials in a neutral environment. The superiority of 2.5-carbon nanodots/MIL-100(Fe) in degrading tetracycline is attributed to the fact that C-dots have the ability to act as acceptors and donors of electrons, thus promoting electron transfer and inhibiting electron-hole recombination. Moreover, the 2.5-carbon nanodots/MIL-100(Fe) also showed high stability after five cycles of the photodegradation reaction. The quenching experiment proved that the main active substances that degrade tetracycline were O₂^- and h⁺. The study of carbon nanodots /MIL-100(Fe) composite materials provides new thoughts and methods for the removal of organic pollutants.

Synthetic organic antibiotics residues as emerging contaminants waste-to-resources processing for a circular economy in China: Challenges and perspective

Synthetic antibiotics have been known for years to combat bacterial antibiotics. But their overuse and resistance have become a concern recently. The antibiotics reach the environment, including soil from the manufacturing process and undigested excretion by cattle and humans. It leads to overburden and contamination of the environment. These organic antibiotics remain in the environment for a very long period. During this period, antibiotics come in contact with various flora and fauna. The ill manufacturing practices and inadequate wastewater treatment cause a severe problem to the water bodies. After pretreatment from pharmaceutical industries, the effluents are released to the water bodies such as rivers. Even after pretreatment, effluents contain a significant number of antibiotic residues, which affect the living organisms living in the water bodies. Ultimately, river contaminated water reaches the ocean, spreading the contamination to a vast environment. This review paper discusses the impact of synthetic organic contamination on the environment and its hazardous effect on health. In addition, it analyzes and suggests the biotechnological strategies to tackle organic antibiotic residue proliferation. Moreover, the degradation of organic antibiotic residues by biocatalyst and biochar is analyzed. The circular economy approach for waste-to-resource technology for organic antibiotic residue in China is analyzed for a sustainable solution. Overall, the significant challenges related to synthetic antibiotic residues and future aspects are analyzed in this review paper.

Systematically assess the advancing and limiting factors of using the multi-soil-layering system for treating rural sewage in China: From the economic, social, and environmental perspectives

Solving the problem of rural sewage is considered an essential task in China's rural revitalization strategy. Based on the yearbook data of sewage treatment in rural areas between 2014 and 2019, although the rate of sewage treatment in rural areas of China showed an upward trend, it was still below 35%, mainly due to the lack of suitable sewage treatment technologies. Here, we discuss the multi-soil-layering (MSL) system, which is an emerging technology suitable for rural sewage treatment. It was deemed to overcome the shortcomings of current biological and ecological treatment technologies, such as complex operation, large area, and high operating costs. We used system dynamics to evaluate the advancing and limiting factors of MSL application for rural sewage treatment from the social, environmental, and economic dimensions. The results illustrated a complete causal loop diagram in which essential variables and relationships were concentrated in the technology, operation and maintenance, and satisfaction of farmers. The efficiency of MSL is the key variable affecting the final decision of the MSL application. Overall, using MSL to treat rural sewage could be an option to improve the rural environment in China. However, the scientific technological model for MSL should be further explored. This review provides guidance on how to promote MSL systems in rural areas.

Occurrence, Distribution, and Risk Assessment of Antibiotics in the Aquatic Environment of the Karst Plateau Wetland of Yangtze River Basin, Southwestern China

In this study, the occurrence, distribution, and ecological risk of 40 commonly used antibiotics, including 15 sulfonamides (SAs), 9 fluoroquinolones (FQs), 7 macrolides (MCs), 3 tetracyclines (TCs), 2 chloramphenicols (CAPs), and 4 other categories, in the aquatic environment of the karst plateau wetland Caohai of the Yangtze River basin in southwestern China are reported. In total, 27 antibiotics were detected, with the detection rate ranging from 5% to 100%. The total concentration at each site ranged from 21.8 ng/L to 954 ng/L, with the average concentration being 189 ng/L. FQs and MCs were the most predominant categories, contributing 29.3% and 25.0% of the total antibiotic burden. The five most commonly detected antibiotics were ciprofloxacin (CIP), oxytetracycline (OTC), acetyl sulfamethoxazole (ASMZ), norfloxacin (NOR), and florfenicol (FF). The spatial distribution of the total concentration at each site demonstrated a decreasing trend from the southeastern area upstream adjoining the main counties to the northwestern area downstream, indicating that human activities have a great impact. Meanwhile, the natural attenuation rates of different types of antibiotics in the direction of flow ranged from 17.6% to 100%, which implied the natural purification potential of the wetland for antibiotics. The cluster analysis results indicated that domestic sewage and wastewater from agriculture and animal husbandry were the main sources of contamination in the surrounding wetland. Risk quotients (RQs) assessment showed that most of the individuals were at low to medium risk and that the adverse risks posed by mixtures of antibiotics were higher than those posed by the individual antibiotics.

Changes of antibiotic resistance genes and bacterial communities in the advanced biological wastewater treatment system under low selective pressure of tetracycline

Effluents of conventional wastewater treatment systems contain antibiotic residues at concentrations below the minimal inhibitory concentrations (MIC), which nevertheless could still select for antibiotic-resistant bacteria. This work focuses on evaluating the changes of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) and bacterial communities in a planted advanced biological wastewater treatment system (ABWWTS) under long-term exposure to sub-MIC tetracycline. In the ABWWTS, the removal rates of tetracycline ranged from 97.9% to 99.9%, and a 17.2% decrease in the average removal rates of NH₄⁺-N was observed after the addition of tetracycline. Although the background of ABWWTS contributed to the ARGs in effluents, the concentration of 283 targeted ARGs (ΣARGs) was 83.5% lower in effluents than in influents after sub-MIC tetracycline exposure, and the concentrations of ΣARGs in the ABWWTS were, on average, 30.0% lower than those in an unplanted biological wastewater treatment system (UBWWTS) after a performance of 130 days. The relative abundance of tetracycline resistance genes increased within ABWWTS and UBWWTS under tetracycline exposure. After tetracycline exposure, bacterial diversity in ABWWTS and UBWWTS increased on average by 36.2% and 42.7%, respectively, and the abundances of Nitrosomonas and Nitrospira in the aerobic zone were more than 10-times higher in the ABWWTS than in the UBWWTS. Sub-MIC tetracycline concentrations were linearly correlated with the relative abundance of tetracycline resistance genes in Escherichia coli (E. coli). Long-term exposure to tetracycline at the same concentration increased abundances of the same ARGs (i.e., tetR-02 and tetM-01) in E. coli and the microflora of the ABWWTS, revealing that sub-MIC tetracycline could increase the abundance of ARGs in the ABWWTS by facilitating the vertical transfer of tetracycline resistance genes. These findings demonstrated that planted ABWWTS played a positive role in removing ARGs under low antibiotic selective pressure, which was in accompany with increasing levels of corresponding ARGs within the system.