Variability of biogenic amine and free amino acid concentrations in regionally produced goat milk cheeses

Molecular Characteristics and Processing Technologies of Dairy Products from Non-Traditional Species

Non-bovine dairy animals, commonly referred to as non-traditional dairy species, include goats, sheep, yaks, buffalo, donkeys, alpacas, llamas, and other less commonly farmed species. These animals have been integral to livestock systems since ancient times, providing milk and other essential products. Despite their historical significance, dairy production from many of these species remains predominantly confined to rural areas in developing countries, where scientific advancements and technical improvements are often limited. As a consequence of this, the scientific literature and technological developments in the processing and characterization of dairy products from these species have lagged behind those for cow's milk. This review aims to compile and analyze existing research on dairy products derived from non-traditional animals, focusing on their molecular characteristics, including proteins (alpha, beta, kappa, and total casein), fats (cholesterol and total fat), lactose, albumin, ash, total solids, and somatic cell count, among others, for each of these species. Additionally, we discuss emerging technologies employed in their processing, encompassing both non-thermal methods (such as high-pressure processing, pulsed electric fields, ultrasound processing, UV-C irradiation, gamma radiation, microfiltration, and cold plasma processing) and thermal methods (such as ohmic heating). This review also explores the specific potential applications and challenges of implementing these technologies. By synthesizing recent findings, we aim to stimulate further research into innovative technologies and strategies that can enhance the quality and yield of non-bovine dairy products. Understanding the unique properties of milk from these species may lead to new opportunities for product development, improved processing methods, and increased commercialization in both developing and developed markets.

A Comprehensive Review on the Biogenic Amines in Cheeses: Their Origin, Chemical Characteristics, Hazard and Reduction Strategies

Most of the biogenic amines are naturally found in fermented foods as a consequence of amino acid decarboxylation. Their formation is ascribable to microorganisms (starters, contaminants and autochthonous) present in the food matrix. The concentration of these molecules is important for food security reasons, as they are involved in food poisoning illnesses. The most frequent amines found in foods are histamine, putrescine, cadaverine, tyramine, tryptamine, phenylethylamine, spermine and spermidine. One of the most risk-prone foods are cheeses, mostly ripened ones, which could easily accumulate amines due to their peculiar manufacturing process and ripening. Cheeses represent a pivotal food in our diet, providing for nutrients such as amino acids, calcium, vitamins and others; thus, since they are widely consumed, it is important to evaluate the presence of toxic molecules to avoid consumers' poisoning. This review aimed to gather general information on the role of biogenic amines, their formation, the health issues and the microorganisms and processes that produce/reduce them, with a focus on their content in different types of cheese (from soft to hard cheeses) and the biotic and abiotic factors that influence their formation or reduction and concentration. Finally, a multivariate analysis was performed on the biogenic amine content, derived from data available in the literature, to obtain more information about the factors influencing their presence in cheeses.

Tyramine, a biogenic agent in cheese: amount and factors affecting its formation, a systematic review

Tyramine is one of the most important biological amines in food, which leads to food poisoning if consumed in high amounts. In addition to food poisoning, tyramine leads to drug interactions. Foods high in tyramine can cause high blood pressure and migraines in people taking monoamine oxidase (MAO) inhibitors. Therefore, people taking MAO inhibitors should avoid foods high in tyramine. Cheese provides ideal conditions for the production of tyramine. Some cheeses contain high amounts of tyramine and lead to unwanted effects in people taking MAO inhibitors. These unwanted effects are called the cheese effect or tyramine interaction. Considering the importance of the subject, a systematic study was designed with the aim of determining the amount of tyramine in cheeses and the effect of effective factors on the amount of tyramine production. The search was done in three databases, including Scopus, PubMed, and Science Direct. The study was conducted in two phases. In the first stage, the amount of tyramine reported in cheeses, the analytical method, measurement, and characteristics of cheese were discussed. In the second phase, the influencing factors in its formation were investigated. Based on the extracted data, tyramine levels ranged from 3.23 to 1398 mg/kg. The most analytical method for measuring tyramine in the studies was the HPLC method. According to a detailed review of the literature, the influencing factors included bacterial species, animal species, the effect of storage conditions (time and temperature), pH, moisture, salt, and the number of somatic cells. Basically, by identifying the factors affecting the amount of tyramine in cheeses, it is possible to control the production of tyramine.

Graphical Abstract

Ambient 1,2-propanediol exposure accelerates the degradation of lipids and amino acids in milk via allosteric effects and affects the utilization of nutrients containing amide bond

The scandal of detecting 1, 2-propanediol (PL) in milk brought a crisis to the trust of consumers in the dairy industry, and the potential toxicity of PL has aroused the public concern about dietary exposure. A total of 200 pasteurized milk samples were collected from 15 regions, and the quantity of PL ranged between 0 and 0.31 g kg^-1. Pseudo-targeted quantitative metabolomics integrated with proteomics demonstrated that PL enhanced the reduction of κ-casein, β-casein, and 107 substances (41 amines and 66 amides) containing amide bonds. Pathway enrichment and topological analysis indicated that PL induced the metabolism of lipids, amino acids, oligosaccharide nucleotides, and alkaloids by accelerating the rate of nucleophilic reaction, and acetylcholinesterase, sarcosine oxidase, and prolyl 4-hydroxylase were determined as the vital enzymes related to the degradation of above nutrients. The results of molecular simulation calculation illustrated that the number of hydrogen bonds between acetylcholinesterase, sarcosine oxidase, and substrate increased to 2 and 3, respectively, while the position of hydrogen bonds between prolyl 4-hydroxylase and proline was shifted, indicating the change of conformation and the enhancement of hydrogen bond force were essential factors for the up-regulation of enzyme activity. This study first revealed the mechanism of deposition and transformation of PL in milk, which contributed to the knowledge of the quality control of milk and provided vital indicators to evaluate the adverse risks of PL in dairy products.

Proteolytic Development and Volatile Compounds Profile of Domiati Cheese under Modified Atmosphere Packaging

This study explored the impacts of modified atmosphere packaging (MAP) treatment on the proteolytic development and volatile compounds of Domiati cheese during storage. Domiati cheese samples were kept for 75 days at refrigerator temperature, under aerobic packaging (C1) or vacuum (C2). In parallel, other Domiati cheese samples were kept under MAP, at different levels of CO2 and N2, as follows: 10% CO2/90% N2 (D1), 15% CO2/85% N2 (D2), 25% CO2/75% N2 (D3), 100% CO2 (D4), and 100% N2 (D5). The normal control (C1) treatment showed the highest reduction in pH from 6.64 at zero time to 6.23 and 6.01 after 40 and 75 days of storage, respectively. On the other hand, the under-vacuum samples (C2) showed the lowest reduction in pH, from 6.64 at zero time to 6.49 and 6.28 after 40 and 75 days of storage, respectively. Proteolysis during cheese storage was lower in MAP of cheeses than in the C1 treatment. Total free amino acids (FAAs) were higher in C1 treatment than other cheeses during the whole storage period. The lowest level of total FAA was detected in D4 treatment after 75 days of storage. Volatile acids, aldehydes, ketones, and esters compounds were detected in all treatments during storage, but particularly higher in aerobic packaging than the other treatments after 75 days. The level of each acid compound increased with storage period, and the increases were particularly clear in pentanoic acid, hexanoic acid, heptanoic acid, benzoic acid, and n-decanoic acid. The normal control (C1) showed high contents of the different volatile ketone compounds. However, the samples packaged under 100% N2 (D5) showed the significantly highest levels of all the volatile ketones after 75 days of storage, particularly 2-pentanone, acetoin, methyl isobutyl ketone, 2-heptanone, 2-nonanone, and 2-undecanone. Some important compounds contributing to the good flavor of the cheese are acetic acid, butanoic acid, pentanal, benzaldehyde, acetoin, and 2,3-butanedione. The CO2 and N2 treatments exerted significant changes in all groups during the storage of cheese. All cheese samples showed gradual increases in CO2 co-occurring with parallel decreases in N2 during refrigerated storage periods, except for D4 treatment (100% CO2), which showed a decrease. A significant decrease in O2 level occurred in C1 treatment during cold storage.

Analytical strategies for the determination of biogenic amines in dairy products

Biogenic amines (BA) are mainly produced by the decarboxylation of amino acids by enzymes from microorganisms that emerge during food fermentation or due to incorrectly applied preservation processes. The presence of these compounds in food can lead to a series of negative effects on human health. To prevent the ingestion of high amounts of BA, their concentration in certain foods needs to be controlled. Although maximum legal levels have not yet been established for dairy products, potential adverse effects have given rise to a substantial number of analytical and microbiological studies: they report concentrations ranging from a few mg/kg to several g/kg. This article provides an overview of the analytical methods for the determination of biogenic amines in dairy products, with particular focus on the most recent and/or most promising advances in this field. We not only provide a summary of analytical techniques but also list the required sample pretreatments. Since high performance liquid chromatography with derivatization is the most widely used method, we describe it in greater detail, including a comparison of derivatizing agents. Further alternative techniques for the determination of BA are likewise described. The use of biosensors for BA in dairy products is emerging, and current results are promising; this paper thus also features a section on the subject. This review can serve as a helpful guideline for choosing the best option to determine BA in dairy products, especially for beginners in the field.

Evaluation of antigenicity and nutritional properties of enzymatically hydrolyzed cow milk

While enzymatic hydrolysis is an effective method for lowering the antigenicity of cow milk (CM), research regarding the antigenicity and nutritional traits of CM hydrolysate is limited. Here, we evaluated the protein content, amino acid composition, sensory traits, color, flow behavior, and antigenicity of CM following enzymatic hydrolysis. The results showed that enzymatic hydrolysis increased the degree of hydrolysis, destroyed allergenic proteins, including casein, β-lactoglobulin, and ɑ-lactalbumin, and significantly increased the content of free amino acids and nutritional quality. In particular, the antigenicity of CM was significantly reduced from 44.05 to 86.55% (P < 0.5). Simultaneously, the taste, color, and flow behavior of CM were altered, the sweetness and richness intensity decreased significantly (P < 0.5), and astringency and bitterness were produced. A slightly darker and more yellow color was observed in CM hydrolysate. In addition, apparent viscosity decreased and shear stress significantly increased with increasing shear rate intensity. The results will provide a solid theoretical foundation for the development of high-quality hypoallergenic dairy products.

Conventional Processing Affects Nutritional and Antinutritional Components and In Vitro Protein Digestibility in Kabau (Archidendron bubalinum)

Kabau, an unexplored crop, was analyzed to determine its nutrition and antinutrition components and in vitro protein digestibility (IVPD). Some conventional processes, such as steaming, frying, and boiling, were carried out to study their effect. The results indicated that all of the techniques reduced carbohydrate content. Frying significantly increased the fat content of Kabau and reduced other nutritional components. In general, all the methods significantly reduced phytic acid, tannin, and trypsin inhibitors, as much as 94.95–96.26%, 20–35%, and 89.22–92.88%, respectively. The reduction of antinutritional components resulted in higher IVPD on boiled and steamed Kabau, 69.47% and 61.48%, respectively.

Effect of forage type, season, and ripening time on selected quality properties of sheep milk cheese

The aim of this research was to study changes in the microbial populations, free AA profile, biogenic amine content, and sensory characteristics of ripened cheeses (100 and 180 d) produced in different seasons (summer, autumn, winter, and spring) from pasteurized sheep milk from 8 commercial flocks fed hay or silage diets. Twenty-one individual AA and 6 biogenic amines were determined by ultra-high performance liquid chromatography. Type of conserved forage for sheep feeding did not affect the variables studied, which is of great interest because hay and silage are low-cost ingredients for sheep feeding. Proteolysis led total free AA concentrations ranging between 35,179.26 and 138,063.71 mg/kg of cheese at 180 d of ripening. γ-Aminobutyric acid, which has been associated with beneficial effects on human health, was the second most abundant AA in all cheese samples, accounting for 15% of total free AA. Spring cheeses showed 2-fold higher concentrations of γ-aminobutyric acid than summer and autumn cheeses at the end of ripening. Overall, spring, winter, and autumn cheeses had lower average concentration of biogenic amines (431.99 mg/kg of cheese) than summer cheeses (825.70 mg/kg of cheese) as well as better sensory characteristics. Therefore, this study could provide the dairy industry with useful information for producing cheeses with valuable nutritional and sensory quality for consumers.

Quantitative Analysis of Biogenic Amines in Different Cheese Varieties Obtained from the Korean Domestic and Retail Markets

To evaluate the safety and risk assessment of cheese consumption in the Republic of Korea, sixty cheese samples purchased from the farmstead and retails markets (imported) were analyzed for their biogenic amine (BA) contents. The BA profiles and quantities of eight amines (tryptamine, 2-phenylethylamine, putrescine, cadaverine, histamine, tyramine, spermidine, and spermine) were determined using high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). Spermine was the only amine detectable in all the samples. The BAs of fresh cheeses from both farmstead and retail markets were mostly undetectable, and comparatively at lower levels (<125 mg/kg) than ripened samples. Putrescine was undetectable in all the domestic ripened cheeses. The sum of BA levels in the imported ripened cheeses of Pecorino Romano (1889.75 mg/kg) and Grana Padano (1237.80 mg/kg) exceeds >1000 mg/kg, of which histamine accounts nearly 86 and 77% of the total levels, respectively. The tolerable limits of the potential toxic amines, histamine and tyramine surpassed in four and three imported ripened samples, respectively. Furthermore, the presence of potentiators (putrescine and cadaverine) together in samples even with a lower level of toxic amines alarms the risk in consumption. Therefore, adoption of strict hygienic practices during the entire chain of cheese production, along with obligatory monitoring and regulation of BA in cheeses seems to be mandatory to ensure the safety of the consumers.

Bioactive characteristics of a semi-hard non-starter culture cheese made from raw or pasteurized sheep's milk

In this study, the effect of pasteurization and use of starter cultures on physicochemical, microbiological and functional properties of a traditional Iranian semi-hard cheese (Lighvan cheese) was evaluated during stages of ripening (1, 60, 120 days). Profiles of polar metabolites were analyzed by gas-chromatography mass-spectrometry (GC-MS). Considerable free amino acids such as gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) were found in samples that have higher microbial communities i.e. raw sheep's milk without use of starter cultures and pasteurized sheep's milk cheese with co-culture. However, GABA was not found in pasteurized sheep's milk cheese without starter culture during ripening. Conclusively, the application of the starter culture could reduce the ripening time of sheep's milk cheese and could be an appropriate approach to increase the functionality of the sheep's milk cheese.

Neuroactive compounds in foods: Occurrence, mechanism and potential health effects

Neuroactive compounds are synthesized by certain plants and microorganisms by undertaking different tasks, especially as a stress response. Most common neuroactive compounds in foods are gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA), serotonin, melatonin, kynurenine, kynurenic acid, dopamine, norepinephrine, histamine, tryptamine, tyramine and β-phenylethylamine. Fermented foods contain some of these compounds, which can affect human health and mood. Moreover, food processing such as roasting and malting alter amount and profile of neuroactive compounds in foods. In addition to plant-origin and microbially-formed neuroactive compounds in foods, these substances are also formed by gut microbiota, which is the most attractive subject to assess the interaction between gut microbiota and mental health. The discovery of microbiota-gut-brain axis calls for the investigation of the effects of diet on the formation of neuroactive compounds in the gut. Furthermore, probiotics and prebiotics are indispensable elements for the understanding of the food-mood relationship. The focus of this comprehensive review is to investigate the neuroactive compounds found naturally in foods or formed during fermentation. Their formation pathways in humans, plants and microorganisms, potential health effects, effects of diet on the formation of microbial metabolites including neuroactive compounds in the gut are discussed throughout this review. Furthermore, the importance of gut-brain axis, probiotics and prebiotics are discussed.

Biogenic amines in smear ripened cheeses

Cheeses belong to high protein foods in which enzymatic and microbial activities form amino acids, which are then converted into biogenic amines (BAs) by the activity of bacterial decarboxylases. The most important conditions for BA formation include the presence of microorganisms, the availability of substrate, temperature and storage period, water activity, salt concentration, and the hygiene of the manufacturing process. Tyramine, histamine, 2-phenylethylamine, tryptamine, cadaverine, putrescine, spermidine and spermine were detected in smear ripened cheeses stored in different temperature regimes. The highest (p < 0.05) total BA content was found when storing the cheeses at the end of BBD (best before date) after 35 days in storage regime (A) or (C). During storage in regime (B), the total BA content (p < 0.05) after 49 days of storage was higher than on the production date (B/0). During storage, the tyramine content in regime (B) did not change (p > 0.05), while in the temperature regimes (A) and (C), the highest levels of tyramine and putrescine content were recorded in cheeses at the end of BBD after 35 days ripening. The content of polyamines in cheeses was higher (p < 0.05) at the end of storage than at the beginning, in all temperature regimes.

Quantitative analysis of amino acids in human and bovine colostrum milk samples through iTRAQ labeling

BACKGROUND

The types and quantity of proteins vary widely between bovine and human milk, with corresponding differences in free and hydrolytic amino acids. In this study, the free and hydrolytic amino acids of bovine and human colostrum were for the first time qualitatively and quantitatively determined using isobaric tags for relative and absolute quantification technology combined with liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry detection.

RESULTS

Total free amino acid content was 0.32 g L^-1 and 0.63 g L^-1 in bovine and human colostrum respectively, with free amino acid content in human colostrum twice that of bovine colostrum. However, total hydrolytic amino acid content was 4.2 g L^-1 and 2.2 g L^-1 in bovine and human colostrum respectively. We found that the hydrolytic amino acid content in bovine colostrum was higher than that in human colostrum; however, the amount of free amino acids and the overall amino acid content in human colostrum were respectively substantially higher and more varied than in bovine colostrum.

CONCLUSION

Our findings revealed differences between bovine and human colostrum, with these data providing the basis for further research into amino acid metabolomics and infant formula. © 2018 Society of Chemical Industry.

Production of sheep milk cheese with high γ-aminobutyric acid and ornithine concentration and with reduced biogenic amines level using autochthonous lactic acid bacteria strains

Consumer demand for health-promoting foods is generating the need to develop biofunctional dairy products. Lactic acid bacteria are employed in cheese-making and some of them are able to produce beneficial compounds on human health such as γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA) and ornithine but also to synthetize biogenic amines. The aim was to investigate the effect of four selected autochthonous co-cultures on the free amino acid profile, with special emphasis on GABA and ornithine, and on the biogenic amine content of pasteurized sheep milk cheese during ripening. High average concentrations of GABA (1296.75 mg/kg cheese) and ornithine (2355.76 mg/kg cheese) were found in all the cheese batches at 240 days of ripening. Batch 2, manufactured with the co-culture containing autochthonous Lactococcus lactis strains as starter and Lactobacillus plantarum TAUL1588 as adjunct, showed 2.37 fold reduced biogenic amines concentration with respect to the batch 1 made with the starter during the ripening time. The microstructure and microbiological counts of cheeses were affected (P ≤ 0.001) by the ripening time, without appreciating differences (P ≥ 0.05) in the physico-chemical composition between batches. This study could be a good approach to the development of functional sheep milk cheese.

High Hydrostatic Pressure as a Tool to Reduce Formation of Biogenic Amines in Artisanal Spanish Cheeses

Two artisanal varieties of cheese made in Spain, one made of ewes' raw milk and the other of goats' raw milk were selected to evaluate the effect of a high hydrostatic pressure (HHP) treatment at 400 MPa during 10 min at 2 °C on the formation of biogenic amines (BA). These conditions were applied at the beginning of the ripening (before the 5th day; HHP1) and in the case of ewes' milk cheeses also after 15th days (HHP15). BA formation was greatly influenced by HHP treatments in both types of cheese. HHP1 treatments significantly reduced the amounts of BA after ripening, being tyramine and putrescine the most affected BA in goats' milk cheeses and tyramine and cadaverine in ewes' milk cheeses. The BA reduction in the HHP1 samples could be explained by the significant decrease in microbiological counts, especially in the LAB, enteroccocci and enterobacteria groups at the beginning of ripening. The proteolysis in these samples was also affected reducing the amount of free amino acids. Although proteolysis in ewes' milk cheeses HHP15 was similar than in control samples a reduction of BA was observed probably because the decrease caused on microbial counts.

Effects of Proteolytic and Lipolytic Enzyme Supplementations on Lipolysis and Proteolysis Characteristics of White Cheeses

Effects of proteolytic (Neutrase, Bacillus subtilis-originate, 0.20 (P1) and 0.40 g 100 L-¹ (P2)) and lipolytic (Piccantase A, Mucor miehei-originated, 0.05 (L1) and 0.10 g 100 L-¹ (L2)) enzyme supplementations to cheese milk on lipolysis and proteolysis characteristics of 90-day ripened cheese samples were investigated in this study. While enzyme supplementation did not have significant effects on titratable acidity, fat and protease-peptone nitrogen ratios of cheese samples, dry matter, salt, protein, water soluble nitrogen, 12% trichloroacetic acid soluble nitrogen ratio (TCA-SN), 5% phosphotungstic acid soluble nitrogen (PTA-SN), casein nitrogen ratios, penetrometer value, total free fatty acids (TFFA) and total free amino acids (TFAA) were significantly influenced by enzyme supplementations. Individual free amino acids (15 of them) were also determined. Free amino acid contents of enzyme-supplemented cheeses were higher than the control cheese and the values increased in all cheese samples with the progress of ripening (p < 0.05). The highest amino acids in all periods of ripening were identified as glutamic acid, lysine, proline and aspartic acid. The major (Ca, P, Na, K, Mg) and minor (Zn, Fe, Cu, Mn) mineral levels of cheeses decreased with the progress of ripening and the effects of enzyme supplementations on these attributes (except for magnesium and manganese) were found to be significant (p < 0.01). As to conclude, enzyme supplementations increased proteolysis and lipolysis and accelerated ripening and thus reduced ripening durations. Especially the enzyme ratios in P1 and L1 cheeses were found to be suitable for reducing the ripening period in White cheese without any adverse effects.