Toilet drain water as a potential source of hospital room-to-room transmission of carbapenemase-producing Klebsiella pneumoniae

Successful termination of a multi-year wastewater-associated outbreak of NDM-5-carrying E. coli in a hemato-oncological center

BACKGROUND

In May 2018, an outbreak of NDM-5-carrying Escherichia coli (NDM-5-EC) was detected at the hemato-oncology department of a tertiary care center in Austria. This report details the outbreak investigation, control measures and the whole genome sequencing (WGS) data of the outbreak isolates.

METHODS

A total of 15 isolates (seven clinical isolates from allogenic stem cell transplant (SCT) recipients and eight wastewater isolates recovered from patients' toilets) were analyzed by whole genome sequencing.

RESULTS

Genome based typing identified two clusters of the high risk clones ST167/CT12607 and ST617/CT2791. Long-read sequencing of selected isolates from both clusters identified two different plasmids, however with a highly similar genetic context of the blaNDM-5 containing region. Genomic analysis revealed the presence of additional resistance genes, including blaCTX-M-15, and blaOXA-1, and virulence factors. Four patients were colonized with NDM-5-EC, two patients suffered bacteremia caused by the outbreak strain and two deaths were associated with an NDM-5-EC infection. The outbreak source was traced to toilet sewage pipes, which remained persistently contaminated despite extensive cleaning and disinfection. Successful eradication of NDM-5-EC from the installations required disassembly, hot water pressure washing of the sewage pipes and complete replacement of all movable parts. Additionally, colonized patients were instructed to use wheeled commodes instead of toilets, and a pre-admission screening strategy was implemented for all patients undergoing hematologic stem cell transplantation. The outbreak was successfully terminated in November 2020.

CONCLUSION

NDM-5-EC, especially high-risk clones such as ST167 and ST617, can persist in hospital wastewater systems despite cleaning and disinfection efforts and can cause prolonged outbreaks. Therefore, a comprehensive bundle of interventions like the ones applied in our study is essential, especially in clinical settings with heavily immunosuppressed patients.

Hospital toilets and drainage systems as a reservoir for a long-term polyclonal outbreak of clinical infections with multidrug-resistant Klebsiella oxytoca species complex

Background

Nosocomial outbreaks with multidrug-resistant bacteria with a probable reservoir in hospital toilets and drainage systems have been increasingly reported.

Aim

To investigate an increase in bacteraemia with extended-spectrum β-lactamase (ESBL)-producing Klebsiella oxytoca at our hospital in 2021; the epidemiology of the outbreak suggested an environmental source.

Methods

Available clinical K. oxytoca isolates from patient with infection or rectal carriage from 2019 to 2022 were collected. Clinical information was gathered from included patients and sampled sinks, shower drains, and toilet water. Short- and long-read whole-genome sequencing (WGS) was performed on patient and environmental isolates to assess phylogenetic relationships, antibiotic resistance genes/mutations, and plasmid profiles.

Results

WGS revealed four clusters and a polyclonal population consisting of ESBL-producing K. oxytoca and Klebsiella michiganensis. All clusters contained both clinical and environmental isolates. The environmental sampling revealed widespread contamination of the outbreak strains in the outbreak ward, and plasmid analyses indicated possible transfer of plasmids between species and clones. Most environmental findings in the outbreak ward were from toilet water, and enhanced cleaning of bathrooms and toilets was introduced. The following year, a decrease in outbreak strains in systemic infections was observed.

Conclusion

This investigation uncovered a polyclonal outbreak of multidrug-resistant K. oxytoca and K. michiganensis and unveiled a persistent reservoir of outbreak clones in the drainage system and toilet water, facilitating exchange of resistance genes. The risk of toilet water as a source of clinical infections warrants further investigation.

Persistence of OXA-48-producing ST-22 Citrobacter freundii in patients and the hospital environment, Paris, France, 2016 to 2022

In 2016-2019, hospital A's haematology ward experienced an outbreak of OXA-48-producing ST-22 Citrobacter freundii strains, with toilets identified as source of transmission. Between 2020 and 2022, 28 strains of OXA-48-producing ST-22 C. freundii were isolated on other wards. This study aimed to determine whether all OXA-48-producing ST-22 C. freundii strains belonged to the same clone and to investigate the persistence of this clone using whole genome sequencing. OXA-48-producing ST-22 C. freundii strains collected from patients (n = 33) and from the hospital environment (n = 20) of seven wards were sequenced using Illumina technology and clonal relationships were determined using single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP). Phylogenetic analyses were performed on 53 strains from hospital A and on 240 epidemiologically unrelated carbapenem-resistant ST-22 C. freundii isolated from elsewhere in France. SNP analysis suggested long-lasting persistence of the same clone for more than 6 years. Phylogenetic analysis showed that 52 of 53 strains isolated in hospital A belonged to the same cluster and were different from the 240 epidemiologically unrelated C. freundii ST-22. Our data suggest that this clone can persist in hospital environments for years, representing a risk for hospital-acquired infections and outbreaks. Reservoir management is essential to prevent further transmission.

Identification of carbapenemase-producing Enterobacteriaceae reservoirs in wet hospital environments as a potential factor in patient acquisition: A cross-sectional study in a French university hospital in 2023

OBJECTIVES

Wet hospital environments have been documented as potential reservoirs for Carbapenemase-producing Enterobacteriaceae (CPE), possibly contributing to outbreaks among inpatients. Our objectives were to assess the prevalence of CPE reservoirs in a hospital's wet environments and to investigate the contamination of adjacent dry surfaces.

METHODS

From March to August 2023, we conducted a cross-sectional study in two hospital wards experiencing ongoing large outbreaks. Sampling of the environment was undertaken in two distinct phases. During phase 1, 38 shower drains and 38 toilet bowls, defined as the wet environment, were sampled using swabs. Phase 2 consisted in sampling adjacent dry surfaces, using wipes in rooms that had tested positive during phase 1. Samples were plated on a selective medium (chromID®CARBASMART, bioMérieux). Species were identified using the matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization-time of flight (MALDI-TOF) technique. Carbapenemases were detected by OKNVI RESIST-5® (CORIS BioConcept).

RESULTS

From the 38 patient rooms, 76 samples were taken during phase 1. All in all, 33 (86.8%) rooms presented at least one CPE reservoir in the wet environment; there were 32 (84.2%) contaminated shower drains and six (15.8%) contaminated toilet bowls. Among 57 identified CPEs, the most frequent strain was Enterobacter cloacae VIM (13, 22.8%). During phase 2, 11 (8.3%) out of 132 samples tested positive for CPE. Enterobacter cloacae complex VIM accounted for six (54.5%) of the CPE strains.

CONCLUSION

These findings suggest that the wet hospital environments were broadly contaminated with CPE, mostly Enterobacter cloacae VIM. The spread of CPE from wet environments to dry surfaces seemed limited.

Genomic epidemiology and longitudinal sampling of ward wastewater environments and patients reveals complexity of the transmission dynamics of bla KPC-carbapenemase-producing Enterobacterales in a hospital setting

Background

Healthcare-associated wastewater and asymptomatic patient reservoirs colonized by carbapenemase-producing Enterobacterales (CPE) contribute to nosocomial CPE dissemination, but the characteristics and dynamics of this remain unclear.

Methods

We systematically sampled wastewater sites (n = 4488 samples; 349 sites) and patients (n = 1247) across six wards over 6-12 months to understand blaKPC-associated CPE (KPC-E) diversity within these reservoirs and transmission in a healthcare setting. Up to five KPC-E-positive isolates per sample were sequenced (Illumina). Recombination-adjusted phylogenies were used to define genetically related strains; assembly and mapping-based approaches were used to characterize antimicrobial resistance genes, insertion sequences (ISs) and Tn4401 types/target site sequences. The accessory genome was evaluated in some of the largest clusters, and those crossing reservoirs.

Results

Wastewater site KPC-E-positivity was substantial [101/349 sites (28.9%); 228/5601 (4.1%) patients cultured]. Thirteen KPC-E species and 109 strains were identified using genomics, and 24% of wastewater and 26% of patient KPC-E-positive samples harboured one or more strains. Most diversity was explained by the individual niche, suggesting localized factors are important in selection and spread. Tn4401 + flanking target site sequence diversity was greater in wastewater sites (P < 0.001), which might favour Tn4401-associated transposition/evolution. Shower/bath- and sluice/mop-associated sites were more likely to be KPC-E-positive (adjusted OR = 2.69; 95% CI: 1.44-5.01; P = 0.0019; and adjusted OR = 2.60; 95% CI: 1.04-6.52; P = 0.0410, respectively). Different strains had different blaKPC dissemination dynamics.

Conclusions

We identified substantial and diverse KPC-E colonization of wastewater sites and patients in this hospital setting. Reservoir and niche-specific factors (e.g. microbial interactions, selection pressures), and different strains and mobile genetic elements likely affect transmission dynamics. This should be considered in surveillance and control strategies.

Outbreak of carbapenemase-producing Citrobacter farmeri in an intensive care haematology department linked to a persistent wastewater reservoir in one hospital room, France, 2019 to 2022

In 2019-2022, a prolonged outbreak of oxacillinase (OXA)-48-producing Citrobacter farmeri due to a persistent environmental contamination, occurred in our haematology intensive care unit. In April 2019, we isolated OXA-48-producing C. farmeri from rectal samples of two patients in weekly screenings. The cases had stayed in the same hospital room but 4 months apart. We screened five patients who had stayed in this room between the two cases and identified a third case. Over the following 3 years, five other cases were detected, the last case in September 2022. In total, eight cases were detected: seven colonised with the bacterium and one infected with a lethal outcome. All cases stayed in the same hospital room. We detected OXA-48-producing C. farmeri from a shower, washbasin drains and wastewater drainage of the bathroom of the hospital room. Molecular typing confirmed that all C. farmeri isolates from the environment and the cases were indistinguishable. Despite bundle measures to control the outbreak, the bacterium persisted in the system, which resulted in transmission to new patients. A design defect in the placement of wastewater drains contributed to the persistence and proliferation of the bacterium. The room was closed after the last case and the bathroom rebuilt.

Hospital-wide healthcare-associated carbapenemase-producing Enterobacterales outbreak: risks of electric floor scrubbers in catering facilities and kitchens

BACKGROUND

Carbapenemase-producing Enterobacterales (CPE) are associated with poor clinical outcomes and can spread rapidly in healthcare settings. Environmental reservoirs are increasingly recognized as playing an important part in some nosocomial outbreaks.

AIM

To describe the investigation and control of a CPE outbreak, lasting several years, across two separate hospital sites within one organization.

METHODS

Investigation of multiple ward-level CPE cross-transmissions with a number of sporadic cases. Environmental sampling of ward environments, catering facilities and electric floor scrubbers was undertaken.

FINDINGS

Eleven patients over a 19-month period were identified as carrying healthcare-associated New Delhi metallo-beta-lactamase (NDM)-producing Enterobacter cloacae, and a further patient carried NDM Escherichia coli. E. cloacae isolates were indistinguishable on pulsed-field gel electrophoresis typing, supporting acquisition with a single point source. Environmental sampling found contamination of the electric floor scrubbers used for cleaning the hospital catering facilities and in the associated toilets. Standard outbreak response measures achieved control of ward outbreaks. Sporadic cases and hospital-wide cross-transmission were controlled after interventions on the central food-handling unit and by decommissioning affected floor scrubbers. Electric floor scrubbers were found to have the potential to disperse Gram-negative bacteria into the surrounding environment under experimental conditions.

CONCLUSION

This outbreak report demonstrates that catering facilities and kitchens can be involved in widespread healthcare outbreaks of enteric organisms. This is also the first report of the potential role of electric floor scrubbers in causing significant environmental contamination with CPE which may indicate a role in nosocomial transmission.

Multidrug-Resistant Bacteria Contaminating Plumbing Components and Sanitary Installations of Hospital Restrooms

Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) poses several issues concerning the management of hospital-acquired infections, leading to increasing morbidity and mortality rates and higher costs of care. Multidrug-resistant (MDR) bacteria can spread in the healthcare setting by different ways. The most important are direct contact transmission occurring when an individual comes into physical contact with an infected or colonized patient (which can involve healthcare workers, patients, or visitors) and indirect contact transmission occurring when a person touches contaminated objects or surfaces in the hospital environment. Furthermore, in recent years, toilets in hospital settings have been increasingly recognised as a hidden source of MDR bacteria. Different sites in restrooms, from toilets and hoppers to drains and siphons, can become contaminated with MDR bacteria that can persist there for long time periods. Therefore, shared toilets may play an important role in the transmission of nosocomial infections since they could represent a reservoir for MDR bacteria. Such pathogens can be further disseminated by bioaerosol and/or droplets potentially produced during toilet use or flushing and be transmitted by inhalation and contact with contaminated fomites. In this review, we summarize available evidence regarding the molecular features of MDR bacteria contaminating toilets of healthcare environments, with a particular focus on plumbing components and sanitary installation. The presence of bacteria with specific molecular traits in different toilet sites should be considered when adopting effective managing and containing interventions against nosocomial infections potentially due to environmental contamination. Finally, here we provide an overview of traditional and new approaches to reduce the spreading of such infections.

Sanitary installations and wastewater plumbing as reservoir for the long-term circulation and transmission of carbapenemase producing Citrobacter freundii clones in a hospital setting

BACKGROUND

Accumulating evidence shows a role of the hospital wastewater system in the spread of multidrug-resistant organisms, such as carbapenemase producing Enterobacterales (CPE). Several sequential outbreaks of CPE on the geriatric ward of the Ghent University hospital have led to an outbreak investigation. Focusing on OXA-48 producing Citrobacter freundii, the most prevalent species, we aimed to track clonal relatedness using whole genome sequencing (WGS). By exploring transmission routes we wanted to improve understanding and (re)introduce targeted preventive measures.

METHODS

Environmental screening (toilet water, sink and shower drains) was performed between 2017 and 2021. A retrospective selection was made of 53 Citrobacter freundii screening isolates (30 patients and 23 environmental samples). DNA from frozen bacterial isolates was extracted and prepped for shotgun WGS. Core genome multilocus sequence typing was performed with an in-house developed scheme using 3,004 loci.

RESULTS

The CPE positivity rate of environmental screening samples was 19.0% (73/385). Highest percentages were found in the shower drain samples (38.2%) and the toilet water samples (25.0%). Sink drain samples showed least CPE positivity (3.3%). The WGS data revealed long-term co-existence of three patient sample derived C. freundii clusters. The biggest cluster (ST22) connects 12 patients and 8 environmental isolates taken between 2018 and 2021 spread across the ward. In an overlapping period, another cluster (ST170) links eight patients and four toilet water isolates connected to the same room. The third C. freundii cluster (ST421) connects two patients hospitalised in the same room but over a period of one and a half year. Additional sampling in 2022 revealed clonal isolates linked to the two largest clusters (ST22, ST170) in the wastewater collection pipes connecting the rooms.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings suggest long-term circulation and transmission of carbapenemase producing C. freundii clones in hospital sanitary installations despite surveillance, daily cleaning and intermittent disinfection protocols. We propose a role for the wastewater drainage system in the spread within and between rooms and for the sanitary installations in the indirect transmission via bioaerosol plumes. To tackle this problem, a multidisciplinary approach is necessary including careful design and maintenance of the plumbing system.

Hospital sanitary facilities on wards with high antibiotic exposure play an important role in maintaining a reservoir of resistant pathogens, even over many years

BACKGROUND

Hospitals with their high antimicrobial selection pressure represent the presumably most important reservoir of multidrug-resistant human pathogens. Antibiotics administered in the course of treatment are excreted and discharged into the wastewater system. Not only in patients, but also in the sewers, antimicrobial substances exert selection pressure on existing bacteria and promote the emergence and dissemination of multidrug-resistant clones. In previous studies, two main clusters were identified in all sections of the hospital wastewater network that was investigated, one K. pneumoniae ST147 cluster encoding NDM- and OXA-48 carbapenemases and one VIM-encoding P. aeruginosa ST823 cluster. In the current study, we investigated if NDM- and OXA-48-encoding K. pneumoniae and VIM-encoding P. aeruginosa isolates recovered between 2014 and 2021 from oncological patients belonged to those same clusters.

METHODS

The 32 isolates were re-cultured, whole-genome sequenced, phenotypically tested for their antimicrobial susceptibility, and analyzed for clonality and resistance genes in silico.

RESULTS

Among these strains, 25 belonged to the two clusters that had been predominant in the wastewater, while two others belonged to a sequence-type less prominently detected in the drains of the patient rooms.

CONCLUSION

Patients constantly exposed to antibiotics can, in interaction with their persistently antibiotic-exposed sanitary facilities, form a niche that might be supportive for the emergence, the development, the dissemination, and the maintenance of certain nosocomial pathogen populations in the hospital, due to antibiotic-induced selection pressure. Technical and infection control solutions might help preventing transmission of microorganisms from the wastewater system to the patient and vice versa, particularly concerning the shower and toilet drainage. However, a major driving force might also be antibiotic induced selection pressure and parallel antimicrobial stewardship efforts could be essential.

Investigation of an Enterobacter hormaechei OXA-436 carbapenemase outbreak: when everything goes down the drain

Over a time period of 18 months an Enterobacter hormaechei sequence type (ST) 90, harboring a bla_OXA-436 carbapenemase gene, was isolated from seven patients at Odense University Hospital, Denmark. The patients were all from the same department, but there was no apparent direct epidemiological link. Whole genome sequencing (WGS) was performed on all clinical isolates as well as on a number of environmental samples including two E. hormaechei ST90 isolates carrying the bla_OXA-436 gene, which were isolated in samples from two shower drains at the department. These drains were suspected to be the source of the outbreak.

Treatment for carbapenem-resistant Enterobacterales infections: recent advances and future directions

Carbapenem-resistant Enterobacterales (CRE) are a growing threat to human health worldwide. CRE often carry multiple resistance genes that limit treatment options and require longer durations of therapy, are more costly to treat, and necessitate therapies with increased toxicities when compared with carbapenem-susceptible strains. Here, we provide an overview of the mechanisms of resistance in CRE, the epidemiology of CRE infections worldwide, and available treatment options for CRE. We review recentlyapproved agents for the treatment of CRE, including ceftazidime-avibactam, meropenem-vaborbactam, imipenem-relebactam, cefiderocol, and novel aminoglycosides and tetracyclines. We also discuss recent advances in phage therapy and antibiotics that are currently in development targeted to CRE. The potential for the development of resistance to these therapies remains high, and enhanced antimicrobial stewardship is imperative both to reduce the spread of CRE worldwide and to ensure continued access to efficacious treatment options.