Dorsal dimelia in patau syndrome: a case report

Distal Dorsal Dimelia: A Disturbance of Dorsal-Ventral Digit Development

PURPOSE

Congenital palmar nail (distal dorsal dimelia [dDD]) of the hand is a rare malformation most commonly affecting the little finger. The purpose of this report was to review the features and associations of this rare disorder and discuss the suspected underlying etiology in light of our current understanding of developmental biology.

METHODS

In this retrospective cohort study from 3 practices, we describe our collective experience and review the reported literature on this disorder both as an isolated condition and in conjunction with other anomalies.

RESULTS

We examined 15 fingers with dDD, 5 of which involved little fingers. We also found dDD in 6 cases with radial polydactyly (preaxial polydactyl type II [PPD2]) and in 1 case of cleft hand involving digits adjacent to the clefted web space (the index and middle fingers). Cases of little finger dDD were also associated with prominent clefting of the adjacent web space in 4 of 5 cases. All cases had stiffness of the interphalangeal joints and loss of palmar creases consistent with dorsalization of the palmar aspect of the digit. When combined with 63 fingers reported in the literature with dDD, 3 patterns were evident. The most common form occurred in little fingers (n = 50; 64%; dDDu). The next most common form was reported in association with cleft hands (n = 16; 21%; dDDc). Radial digits in association with either radial polydactyly (PPD2) or radial longitudinal deficiency were also susceptible to dDD (n = 12; 15%; dDDr).

CONCLUSIONS

Congenital dDD is a disturbance of terminal dorsal-ventral digit patterning. The distribution of this condition with little fingers, clefting, and altered radial digit formation (PPD2 or radial longitudinal deficiency), as well as recent genetic and animal studies, suggests that dDD and altered dorsal-ventral patterning are linked to abnormal apical ectodermal ridge boundary formation.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Diagnostic IV.

Concurrent dorsal dimelia in 160 consecutive patients with congenital anomalies of the hands and feet

This study was designed to investigate the prevalence of dorsal dimelia in a series of 160 consecutive patients with congenital anomalies of the hands and feet, and to investigate the distribution of dorsal dimelia and the concurrent anomalies. Five cases (3.1%) showed evidence of dorsal dimelia and the distribution of dorsal dimelia was similar to the distribution of concurrent anomalies in all five cases. Another 11 cases of concurrent dorsal dimelia with other congenital anomalies have been reported previously with a positive match in the distributions in all cases. This similarity in the distribution in all 16 reported cases (including the five cases in the current study) is statistically significant. It is concluded that dorsal dimelia in humans is not as rare as it is generally thought to be, and that it may be viewed as an error of dorso-ventral patterning, which occurs in the same distribution as other concurrent anomalies.

Classification of dorsal and ventral dimelia in humans

Dorsal dimelia (appearance of dorsal structures on the palmar aspect of the hand) and ventral dimelia (appearance of palmar structures on the dorsal aspect of the hand) are rare congenital hand malformations that occur due to errors of the dorso-ventral axis of development of the limb. The current literature includes numerous cases and there is now sufficient basic science/genetics research on the topic so that a classification of dorsal/ventral dimelia could be proposed. Dorsal dimelia is subclassified into two types: distal (dorsalization of the digits ± distal palm) and proximal (dorsalization of the proximal palm only) types. Ventral dimelia is classified into three types (mild, moderate, and severe) according to the degree of ventralization. The classification is supported by the genetic basis of each subtype.

The first successful lower extremity transplantation: 6-year follow-up and implications for cortical plasticity

Vascularized composite allotransplantation as a viable reconstructive option is gaining recognition and new cases are being reported with increasing frequency including hand, face and laryngeal transplantation. However, only one successful complete lower limb transplantation has been reported to date, in which a functioning limb from one ischiopagus twin with a lethal cardiac anomaly was transplanted to the other. Six years later, the patient is mobilizing well and engaging in sporting activities with her peers in a mainstream school. Clinical evaluation of motor and sensory modalities demonstrated a good functional result. Quality of life was assessed using the short form-36 health survey and lower extremity functional scale disclosing a high level of social and physical capacity. Functional magnetic resonance imaging was performed and showed cortical integration of the limb; the implications of cortical plasticity and vascularized composite allotransplantation for the correction of congenital limb anomalies are presented.

WNT pathways and upper limb anomalies

The various Wnt pathways that are related to upper limb anomalies are reviewed. Abnormalities in the Wnt7a pathway (located in the dorsal ectoderm) produce several clinically relevant conditions such as the palmar duplication syndrome, nail patella syndrome, ulnar ray deficiency, limb hypoplasia, polysyndactyly and the palmar nail syndrome. Abnormalities of the Wnt3/3a pathway (located in the apical ectodermal ridge) include tetra-amelia and loss of the distal phalanges/nails. Abnormalities of the Wnt5/5a pathway (located in the apical ectodermal ridge as well as in the mesoderm) will affect chondrogenesis of the developing limb and experimental Wnt5a(-/-) limbs have terminal adactyly. Chondrogenesis and limb muscle differentiation are both affected by several Wnt pathways and these will be reviewed in details. Abnormalities in LRP 5/6 (a co-receptor for Wnts) lead to congenital bone disease and Wnt4 is specifically involved in joint development. Finally, the relationship between the Wnt pathway and SALL4 (mutations of which cause Okihiro/Duane-radial ray deficiency in humans) are discussed.

Dorsal dimelia: report of two cases with an emphasis on the variation of phenotypic expression and a search for candidate causative genes

Dorsal dimelia is a form of duplication along the dorsoventral axis of the developing limb. Previous authors reporting on this rare entity have stated that the essential feature of the deformity is the presence of double or circumferential nail at the tip of the finger and that the aetiology is probably related to a mutation of Engrailed-1 (En-1). In this paper we report on two cases to demonstrate that the deformity in humans may be fully or partially expressed, with or without the double nail deformity, respectively. We also reviewed reported cases in humans and experimental animals and searched our two cases for candidate causative genes within the En-1 pathway.

Embryology of the upper limb

An increased understanding of embryogenesis has advanced our fundamental knowledge of limb anomalies. Animal models with similar limb patterning have been used to dissect and manipulate crucial signaling centers that affect limb development and orientation. Experimental embryologists can produce limb anomalies that are similar to the human phenotype encountered in clinical practice. The evaluating physician must possess a basic comprehension of embryogenesis and limb formation to comprehend congenital limb anomalies and to communicate relevant knowledge to the family. This Current Concepts article is intended to provide an update of limb development that is germane to the clinical scenario.