Spiroplasma infection in Drosophila melanogaster: what is the advantage of killing males?

Evolution of reproductive parasites with direct fitness benefits

Maternally inherited symbionts such as Wolbachia have long been seen mainly as reproductive parasites, with deleterious effects on host fitness. It is becoming clear, however, that, frequently, these symbionts also have beneficial effects on host fitness, either along with reproductive parasitism or not. Using the examples of cytoplasmic incompatibility (CI) and male-killing (MK), we here analyze the effect of direct fitness benefits on the evolution of reproductive parasites. By means of a simple theoretical framework, we synthesize and extend earlier modeling approaches for CI and MK, which usually ignore fitness benefits. Moreover, our framework is not restricted to a particular mechanism underlying the fitness benefit (e.g., protection against pathogens). We derive invasion conditions and equilibrium frequencies for the different infection scenarios. Our results demonstrate the importance of a symbiont's "effective fecundity" (i.e., the product of the relative fecundity of an infected female and her transmission efficiency) for a symbiont's invasion success. In particular, we adopt the concept of effective fecundity to scenarios where CI and MK co-occur in one host population. We confirm that direct fitness benefits substantially facilitate the invasion and spread of infections (for example, by lowering or removing the invasion threshold) or even make invasion possible in the first place (for example, if reproductive parasitism is weak or absent). Finally, we discuss the role of direct fitness benefits in long-term evolutionary dynamics of reproductive phenotypes and highlight their potential to resolve genetic conflicts between maternally inherited symbionts and their hosts.

Superparasitism Drives Heritable Symbiont Epidemiology and Host Sex Ratio in a Wasp

Heritable microbial symbionts have profound impacts upon the biology of their arthropod hosts. Whilst our current understanding of the dynamics of these symbionts is typically cast within a framework of vertical transmission only, horizontal transmission has been observed in a number of cases. For instance, several symbionts can transmit horizontally when their parasitoid hosts share oviposition patches with uninfected conspecifics, a phenomenon called superparasitism. Despite this, horizontal transmission, and the host contact structures that facilitates it, have not been considered in heritable symbiont epidemiology. Here, we tested for the importance of host contact, and resulting horizontal transmission, for the epidemiology of a male-killing heritable symbiont (Arsenophonus nasoniae) in parasitoid wasp hosts. We observed that host contact through superparasitism is necessary for this symbiont's spread in populations of its primary host Nasonia vitripennis, such that when superparasitism rates are high, A. nasoniae almost reaches fixation, causes highly female biased population sex ratios and consequently causes local host extinction. We further tested if natural interspecific variation in superparasitism behaviours predicted symbiont dynamics among parasitoid species. We found that A. nasoniae was maintained in laboratory populations of a closely related set of Nasonia species, but declined in other, more distantly related pteromalid hosts. The natural proclivity of a species to superparasitise was the primary factor determining symbiont persistence. Our results thus indicate that host contact behaviour is a key factor for heritable microbe dynamics when horizontal transmission is possible, and that 'reproductive parasite' phenotypes, such as male-killing, may be of secondary importance in the dynamics of such symbiont infections.

Independent origins of resistance or susceptibility of parasitic wasps to a defensive symbiont

Insect microbe associations are diverse, widespread, and influential. Among the fitness effects of microbes on their hosts, defense against natural enemies is increasingly recognized as ubiquitous, particularly among those associations involving heritable, yet facultative, bacteria. Protective mutualisms generate complex ecological and coevolutionary dynamics that are only beginning to be elucidated. These depend in part on the degree to which symbiont‐mediated protection exhibits specificity to one or more members of the natural enemy community. Recent findings in a well‐studied defensive mutualism system (i.e., aphids, bacteria, parasitoid wasps) reveal repeated instances of evolution of susceptibility or resistance to defensive bacteria by parasitoids. This study searched for similar patterns in an emerging model system for defensive mutualisms: the interaction of Drosophila, bacteria in the genus Spiroplasma, and wasps that parasitize larval stages of Drosophila. Previous work indicated that three divergent species of parasitic wasps are strongly inhibited by the presence of Spiroplasma in three divergent species of Drosophila, including D. melanogaster. The results of this study uncovered two additional wasp species that are susceptible to Spiroplasma and two that are unaffected by Spiroplasma, implying at least two instances of loss or gain of susceptibility to Spiroplasma among larval parasitoids of Drosophila.

Insect endosymbiont proliferation is limited by lipid availability

Spiroplasma poulsonii is a maternally transmitted bacterial endosymbiont that is naturally associated with Drosophila melanogaster. S. poulsonii resides extracellularly in the hemolymph, where it must acquire metabolites to sustain proliferation. In this study, we find that Spiroplasma proliferation specifically depletes host hemolymph diacylglyceride, the major lipid class transported by the lipoprotein, Lpp. RNAi-mediated knockdown of Lpp expression, which reduces the amount of circulating lipids, inhibits Spiroplasma proliferation demonstrating that bacterial proliferation requires hemolymph-lipids. Altogether, our study shows that an insect endosymbiont acquires specific lipidic metabolites from the transport lipoproteins in the hemolymph of its host. In addition, we show that the proliferation of this endosymbiont is limited by the availability of hemolymph lipids. This feature could limit endosymbiont over-proliferation under conditions of host nutrient limitation as lipid availability is strongly influenced by the nutritional state.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.02964.001

All animals host a large number of harmless microbes. Often the two partners involved in these interactions will depend on each other to thrive: microbes support important host functions and in return the host provides a safe place to live and a continuous supply of food. Many microbes that are intimately associated with animals have lost the ability to gain nutrients from sources other than their host and are unable to survive on their own. However, in many cases, the source and the type of nutrients provided to the microbes are unknown.

One of the most common microbial species found in insects is Spiroplasma. This microbe lives in very large numbers in the fluid that fills the body cavities of insects, called the hemolymph. The microbes are transmitted from mother to offspring, and in some circumstances can provide benefits to the insects; for instance, Spiroplasma-infested flies appear to be protected against infection by some parasites. Unfortunately, as it is difficult to study insect–microbe relationships, little else is known about the physiological interactions between these two species.

Herren et al. studied the association between Spiroplasma and the fly Drosophila melanogaster. Under normal conditions, Spiroplasma only reduces the life span of the infested fly. This indicates that Spiroplasma has a low impact on the general fitness of its host, only negatively affecting the survival and egg laying ability of old flies. When flies had limited access to nutrients, the number of Spiroplasma they carried was reduced, without the flies losing fitness. This suggests that Spiroplasma growth is dependent on something in the flies' diet.

To understand which nutrients are important for the growth of Spiroplasma in Drosophila, Herren et al. analyzed the hemolymph of flies and found that there are fewer fatty-molecules, called lipids, when nutrients are limited. Healthy flies carrying Spiroplasma also have fewer lipids in their hemolymph, suggesting that these are what Spiroplasma feed on. Indeed, inactivating a protein required by the fly to transport lipids to the hemolymph reduced the growth of Spiroplasma in these flies.

Herren et al. concluded that the growth of Spiroplasma inside its host is limited by the availability of lipids in the hemolymph. Since this is dependent on diet, the dependence on lipids couples the growth of Spiroplasma to the nutritional state of its host. Herren et al. speculate that this mechanism reduces the fitness cost of harboring the microbes and prevents the damaging consequence of an uncontrolled proliferation of the microbes. Moreover, Spiroplasma's preference for lipids may explain why it helps to protect flies against parasitic infection, as many parasites also rely on lipids for their growth. Herren et al. suggest this strategy could also be used in other animal–microbe associations.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.02964.002

Low temperature reveals genetic variability against male-killing Spiroplasma in Drosophila melanogaster natural populations

Spiroplasma endosymbionts are maternally inherited microorganisms which infect many arthropod species. In some Drosophila species, it acts as a reproductive manipulator, spreading in populations by killing the sons of infected mothers. Distinct Drosophila melanogaster populations from Brazil exhibit variable male-killing Spiroplasma prevalences. In this study, we investigated the presence of variability for the male-killing phenotype among Drosophila and/or Spiroplasma strains and verified if it correlates with the endosymbiont prevalence in natural populations. For that, we analyzed the male-killing expression when Spiroplasma strains from different populations were transferred to a standard D. melanogaster line (Canton-S) and when a common Spiroplasma strain was transferred to different wild-caught D. melanogaster lines, both at optimal and challenging temperatures for the bacteria. No variation was observed in the male-killing phenotype induced by different Spiroplasma strains. No phenotypic variability among fly lines was detected at optimal temperature (23 °C), as well. Conversely, significant variation in the male-killing expression was revealed among D. melanogaster lines at 18.5 °C, probably caused by imperfect transmission of the endosymbiont. Distinct lines differed in their average sex ratios as well as in the pattern of male-killing expression as the infected females aged. Greater variation occurred among lines from one locality, although there was no clear correlation between the male-killing intensity and the endosymbiont prevalence in each population. Imperfect transmission or male killing may also occur in the field, thus helping to explain the low or intermediate prevalences reported in nature. We discuss the implications of our results for the dynamics of male-killing Spiroplasma in natural populations.

Male killing Spiroplasma protects Drosophila melanogaster against two parasitoid wasps

Maternally transmitted associations between endosymbiotic bacteria and insects are diverse and widespread in nature. Owing to imperfect vertical transmission, many heritable microbes have evolved compensational mechanisms to enhance their persistence in host lineages, such as manipulating host reproduction and conferring fitness benefits to host. Symbiont-mediated defense against natural enemies of hosts is increasingly recognized as an important mechanism by which endosymbionts enhance host fitness. Members of the genus Spiroplasma associated with distantly related Drosophila hosts are known to engage in either reproductive parasitism (i.e., male killing) or defense against natural enemies (the parasitic wasp Leptopilina heterotoma and a nematode). A male-killing strain of Spiroplasma (strain Melanogaster Sex Ratio Organism (MSRO)) co-occurs with Wolbachia (strain wMel) in certain wild populations of the model organism Drosophila melanogaster. We examined the effects of Spiroplasma MSRO and Wolbachia wMel on Drosophila survival against parasitism by two common wasps, Leptopilina heterotoma and Leptopilina boulardi, that differ in their host ranges and host evasion strategies. The results indicate that Spiroplasma MSRO prevents successful development of both wasps, and confers a small, albeit significant, increase in larva-to-adult survival of flies subjected to wasp attacks. We modeled the conditions under which defense can contribute to Spiroplasma persistence. Wolbachia also confers a weak, but significant, survival advantage to flies attacked by L. heterotoma. The host protective effects exhibited by Spiroplasma and Wolbachia are additive and may provide the conditions for such cotransmitted symbionts to become mutualists. Occurrence of Spiroplasma-mediated protection against distinct parasitoids in divergent Drosophila hosts suggests a general protection mechanism.

The direct effects of male killer infection on fitness of ladybird hosts (Coleoptera: Coccinellidae)

Male killing bacteria are common in insects and are thought to persist in host populations primarily by indirect fitness benefits to infected females, whereas direct fitness effects are generally assumed to be neutral or deleterious. Here, we estimated the effect of male killer infection on direct fitness (number of eggs laid, as a measure of fecundity, together with survival) and other life-history traits (development time and body size) in seven ladybird host/male killer combinations. Effects of male killers on fecundity ranged, as expected, from costly to neutral; however, we found evidence of reduced development time and increased survival and body size in infected strains. Greater body size in Spiroplasma-infected Harmonia axyridis corresponded to greater ovariole number and therefore higher potential fecundity. To our knowledge, this is the first report of direct benefits of male killer infection after explicitly controlling for indirect fitness effects. Neutral or deleterious fitness effects of male killer infection should not therefore be automatically assumed.

Spiroplasma in Drosophila melanogaster populations: prevalence, male-killing, molecular identification, and no association with Wolbachia

Spiroplasma endosymbionts are maternally transmitted bacteria that may kill infected sons resulting in the production of female-biased broods. The prevalence of male killers varies considerably both between and within species. Here, we evaluate the spatial and temporal status of male-killing and non-male-killing Spiroplasma infection in three Brazilian populations of Drosophila melanogaster, nearly a decade after the first occurrence report for this species. The incidence of the male-killing Spiroplasma ranged from close to 0 to 17.7 % (so far the highest estimate for a Drosophila species) with a suggestion of temporal decline in a population. We also found non-male-killing Spiroplasma coexisting in one population at lower prevalence (3-5 %), and we did not detect it in the other two. This may be taken as a suggestion of a spreading advantage conferred by the male-killing strategy. Sequencing two loci, we identified the phylogenetic position of Spiroplasma strains from the three localities, showing that all strains group closely in the poulsonii clade. Due to intensive sampling effort, we were able to test the association between Spiroplasma infections and another widespread endosymbiont, Wolbachia, whose prevalence ranged from 81.8 to 100 %. The prevalence of Wolbachia did not differ between Spiroplasma-infected and uninfected strains in our largest sample nor were the prevalences of the two endosymbionts associated across localities.

The potential role of the X chromosome in the emergence of male-killing from mutualistic endosymbionts

Endosymbionts infect most arthropods and cause a wide variety of phenotypes in their hosts, ranging from obligate mutualists to reproductive parasites. One of the most dramatic forms of reproductive parasitism is male-killing which involves the endosymbiont killing all of the sons of infected females. A phenotype with such a dramatic effect on host fitness is expected to provide strong selection for suppressors of male-killing, yet in many well-studied male-killer/arthropod systems, no suppressors have been found. Plausible explanations for a lack of resistance exist and include cryptic cytoplasmic incompatibility (males that survive male-killing are therefore infected and matings with uninfected females are incompatible) and deleterious pleiotropic effects of altering early embryonic development--the precise time when male-killing often occurs. Here I describe another possible scenario that sidesteps the problem: male killing may arise through an epistatic interaction between an endosymbiont and a paternally acting locus on the X chromosome. Since paternal X chromosomes never find themselves in sons, they never suffer from male-killing and instead enjoy any benefits (decreased sibling competition, inbreeding avoidance) caused by killing males. This scenario allows for the possibility that male-killing arose recently, even if there is no evidence for evolution in the endosymbiont genotype.

Maintenance of a male-killing Wolbachia in Drosophila innubila by male-killing dependent and male-killing independent mechanisms

Many maternally inherited endosymbionts manipulate their host's reproduction in various ways to enhance their own fitness. One such mechanism is male killing (MK), in which sons of infected mothers are killed by the endosymbiont during development. Several hypotheses have been proposed to explain the advantages of MK, including resource reallocation from sons to daughters of infected females, avoidance of inbreeding by infected females, and, if transmission is not purely maternal, the facilitation of horizontal transmission to uninfected females. We tested these hypotheses in Drosophila innubila, a mycophagous species infected with MK Wolbachia. There was no evidence of horizontal transmission in the wild and no evidence Wolbachia reduced levels of inbreeding. Resource reallocation does appear to be operative, as Wolbachia-infected females are slightly larger, on average, than uninfected females, although the selective advantage of larger size is insufficient to account for the frequency of infection in natural populations. Wolbachia-infected females from the wild-although not those from the laboratory-were more fecund than uninfected females. Experimental studies revealed that Wolbachia can boost the fecundity of nutrient-deprived flies and reduce the adverse effect of RNA virus infection. Thus, this MK endosymbiont can provide direct, MK-independent fitness benefits to infected female hosts in addition to possible benefits mediated via MK.

Spiroplasma as a model insect endosymbiont

Members of the genus Spiroplasma are actively motile and helical bacteria of the class Mollicutes, which are associated with a variety of arthropods and plants. Some spiroplasmas cause female-biased sex ratios of their host insects as a result of selective death of the male offspring during embryogenesis. Several strains of male-killing spiroplasmas have been successfully transfected into Drosophila melanogaster by haemolymph injection and maintained in laboratory fly stocks. Spiroplasma-Drosophila endosymbiosis represents an ideal model system for analysing the molecular mechanisms underlying host-symbiont interactions. The infection dynamics exhibited by the symbiont within the host, the effects of external and environmental factors on the symbiotic association and symbiont interactions with the host's immune system have been investigated using this system. Comparisons between a male-killing Spiroplasma strain and its non-male-killing variant revealed that, in addition to different male-killing abilities, they also differed in infection dynamics and resistance to host innate immunity. It is currently unclear whether these different phenotypes are interconnected to each other. However, if so, such pleiotropy could facilitate our understanding of the genetic and molecular mechanisms of the endosymbiotic system.