Extending the folding nucleus of ubiquitin with an independently folding beta-hairpin finger: hurdles to rapid folding arising from the stabilisation of local interactions

Thermodynamic and kinetic analysis of the LAO binding protein and its isolated domains reveal non-additivity in stability, folding and function

Substrate-binding proteins (SBPs) are used by organisms from the three domains of life for transport and signalling. SBPs are composed of two domains that collectively trap ligands with high affinity and selectivity. To explore the role of the domains and the integrity of the hinge region between them in the function and conformation of SBPs, here, we describe the ligand binding, conformational stability and folding kinetics of the Lysine Arginine Ornithine (LAO) binding protein from Salmonella thiphimurium and constructs corresponding to its two independent domains. LAO is a class II SBP formed by a continuous and a discontinuous domain. Contrary to the expected behaviour based on their connectivity, the discontinuous domain shows a stable native-like structure that binds l-arginine with moderate affinity, whereas the continuous domain is barely stable and shows no detectable ligand binding. Regarding folding kinetics, studies of the entire protein revealed the presence of at least two intermediates. While the unfolding and refolding of the continuous domain exhibited only a single intermediate and simpler and faster kinetics than LAO, the folding mechanism of the discontinuous domain was complex and involved multiple intermediates. These findings suggest that in the complete protein the continuous domain nucleates folding and that its presence funnels the folding of the discontinuous domain avoiding nonproductive interactions. The strong dependence of the function, stability and folding pathway of the lobes on their covalent association is most likely the result of the coevolution of both domains as a single unit.

A pH Switch for β-Sheet Protein Folding

Protein design advancements have led to biotechnological strategies based on more stable and more specific structures. Herein we present a 6-residue sequence (HPATGK) that acts as a stable structure-nucleating turn at physiological and higher pH but is notably unfavorable for chain direction reversal at low pH. When placed into the turn of a β-sheet, this leads to a pH switch of folding. Using a standard 3-stranded β-sheet model, the WW domain, it was found that the pH switch sequence insertion caused minimal change at pH 8 but a ca. 50 °C drop in the melting temperature (Tm ) was observed at pH 2.5: ΔΔGF ≥11.3 kJ mol-1 . Using the strategies demonstrated in this article, the redesign of β-sheets to contain a global, or local, pH-dependent conformational switch should be possible.

Long range Trp-Trp interaction initiates the folding pathway of a pro-angiogenic β-hairpin peptide

HPLW, a designed VEGF (Vascular Endothelium Growth Factor) receptor-binding peptide, assumes a well folded β-hairpin conformation in water and is able to induce angiogenesis in vivo. In this study, we investigated at atomic resolution the thermal folding/unfolding pathway of HPLW by means of an original multi-technique approach combining DSC, NMR, MD and mutagenesis analyses. In particular, careful NMR investigation of the single proton melting temperatures together with DSC analysis accurately delineate the peptide folding mechanism, which is corroborated by computational folding/unfolding simulations. The HPLW folding process consists of two main events, which are successive but do not superimpose. The first folding step initiates at 320 K upon the hydrophobic collapse of the Trp5 and Trp13 side-chains which stabilizes the concurrent β-turn formation, whose COi-HNi + 3 hydrogen bond (Asp10 → Arg7) appears particularly stable. At 316 K, once the β-turn is completely formed, the two β-strands pair, very likely starting by Trp5 and Trp13, which thus play a key role also in the final step of the β-hairpin folding. Overall, here we describe a multi-state hierarchical folding pathway of a highly structured β-hairpin, which can be classified as a broken-zipper mechanism.

Mutational effects on the folding dynamics of a minimized hairpin

The fold stabilities and folding dynamics of a series of mutants of a model hairpin, KTW-NPATGK-WTE (HP7), are reported. The parent system and the corresponding DPATGK loop species display submicrosecond folding time constants. The mutational studies revealed that ultrafast folding requires both some prestructuring of the loop and a favorable interaction between the chain termini in the transition state. In the case of YY-DPETGT-WY, another submicrosecond folding species [Davis, C. M., Xiao, S., Raleigh, D. P., and Dyer, R. B. (2012) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 134, 14476-14482], a hydrophobic cluster provides the latter. In the case of HP7, the Coulombic interaction between the terminal NH3(+) and CO2(-) units provides this; a C-terminal Glu to amidated Ala mutation results in a 5-fold retardation of the folding rate. The effects of mutations within the reversing loop indicate the balance between loop flexibility (favoring fast conformational searching) and turn formation in the unfolded state is a major factor in determining the folding dynamics. The -NAAAKX- loops examined display no detectable turn formation propensity in other hairpin constructs but do result in stable analogues of HP7. Peptide KTW-NAAAKK-WTE displays the same fold stability as HP7, but both the folding and unfolding time constants are greater by a factor of 20.

Visualizing transient protein-folding intermediates by tryptophan-scanning mutagenesis

To understand how proteins fold, assemble and function, it is necessary to characterize the structure and dynamics of each state they adopt during their lifetime. Experimental characterization of the transient states of proteins remains a major challenge because high-resolution structural techniques, including NMR and X-ray crystallography, cannot be directly applied to study short-lived protein states. To circumvent this limitation, we show that transient states during protein folding can be characterized by measuring the fluorescence of tryptophan residues, introduced at many solvent-exposed positions to determine whether each position is native-like, denatured-like or non-native-like in the intermediate state. We use this approach to characterize a late-folding-intermediate state of the small globular mammalian protein ubiquitin, and we show the presence of productive non-native interactions that suggest a 'flycatcher' mechanism of concerted binding and folding.

Investigating diproline segments in proteins: occurrences, conformation and classification

The covalent linkage between the side-chain and the backbone nitrogen atom of proline leads to the formation of the five-membered pyrrolidine ring and hence restriction of the backbone torsional angle ϕ to values of -60 °± 30° for the L-proline. Diproline segments constitute a chain fragment with considerably reduced conformational choices. In the current study, the conformational states for the diproline segment (( L) Pro-( L) Pro) found in proteins has been investigated with an emphasis on the cis and trans states for the Pro-Pro peptide bond. The occurrence of diproline segments in turns and other secondary structures has been studied and compared to that of Xaa-Pro-Yaa segments in proteins which gives us a better understanding on the restriction imposed on other residues by the diproline segment and the single proline residue. The study indicates that P(II) -P(II) and P(II) -α are the most favorable conformational states for the diproline segment. The analysis on Xaa-Pro-Yaa sequences reveals that the Xaa-Pro peptide bond exists preferably as the trans conformer rather than the cis conformer. The present study may lead to a better understanding of the behavior of proline occurring in diproline segments which can facilitate various designed diproline-based synthetic templates for biological and structural studies.

Roles of beta-turns in protein folding: from peptide models to protein engineering

Reverse turns are a major class of protein secondary structure; they represent sites of chain reversal and thus sites where the globular character of a protein is created. It has been speculated for many years that turns may nucleate the formation of structure in protein folding, as their propensity to occur will favor the approximation of their flanking regions and their general tendency to be hydrophilic will favor their disposition at the solvent-accessible surface. Reverse turns are local features, and it is therefore not surprising that their structural properties have been extensively studied using peptide models. In this article, we review research on peptide models of turns to test the hypothesis that the propensities of turns to form in short peptides will relate to the roles of corresponding sequences in protein folding. Turns with significant stability as isolated entities should actively promote the folding of a protein, and by contrast, turn sequences that merely allow the chain to adopt conformations required for chain reversal are predicted to be passive in the folding mechanism. We discuss results of protein engineering studies of the roles of turn residues in folding mechanisms. Factors that correlate with the importance of turns in folding indeed include their intrinsic stability, as well as their topological context and their participation in hydrophobic networks within the protein's structure.

Nonstereogenic alpha-aminoisobutyryl-glycyl dipeptidyl unit nucleates type I' beta-turn in linear peptides in aqueous solution

The use of alpha,alpha-disubstituted amino acids represents a valuable strategy to exercise conformational control in peptides. Incorporation of the nonstereogenic alpha-aminoisobutyryl-glycyl (Aib-Gly) dipeptidyl sequence into i+1 and i+2 positions of an acyclic peptide sequence, originally designed and investigated by Gellman and coworkers, [H-Arg-Tyr-Val-Glu-Val-Yyy-Xxx-Orn-Lys-Ile-Leu-Gln-NH2] nucleates a stable [2:4] left-handed type I' beta-turn in water. NMR spectra show that this newly designed beta-hairpin does not aggregate in water up to a concentration of approximately 1 mM, and that its backbone conformation is superimposable on corresponding hairpins containing the DPro-Gly (literature) and Aib-DAla (this work) sequences. The Aib-Gly turn-inducer sequence eliminates complications because of cis-trans isomerization of Zzz-Pro bonds, and constitutes an attractive alternative to the proteogenic Asn-Gly and nonproteogenic DPro-Gly motifs previously suggested as turn-inducer sequences. These design principles could be exploited to prepare water-soluble beta-hairpin peptides with robust structures and novel function.

Multiple tryptophan probes reveal that ubiquitin folds via a late misfolded intermediate

Much of our understanding of protein folding mechanisms is derived from experiments using intrinsic fluorescence of natural or genetically inserted tryptophan (Trp) residues to monitor protein refolding and site-directed mutagenesis to determine the energetic role of amino acids in the native (N), intermediate (I) or transition (T) states. However, this strategy has limited use to study complex folding reactions because a single fluorescence probe may not detect all low-energy folding intermediates. To overcome this limitation, we suggest that protein refolding should be monitored with different solvent-exposed Trp probes. Here, we demonstrate the utility of this approach by investigating the controversial folding mechanism of ubiquitin (Ub) using Trp probes located at residue positions 1, 28, 45, 57, and 66. We first show that these Trp are structurally sensitive and minimally perturbing fluorescent probes for monitoring folding/unfolding of the protein. Using a conventional stopped-flow instrument, we show that ANS and Trp fluorescence detect two distinct transitions during the refolding of all five Trp mutants at low concentrations of denaturant: T(1), a denaturant-dependent transition and T(2), a slower transition, largely denaturant-independent. Surprisingly, some Trp mutants (Ub(M1W), Ub(S57W)) display Trp fluorescence changes during T(1) that are distinct from the expected U-->N transition suggesting that the denaturant-dependent refolding transition of Ub is not a U-->N transition but represents the formation of a structurally distinct I-state (U-->I). Alternatively, this U-->I transition could be also clearly distinguished by using a combination of two Trp mutations Ub(F45W-T66W) for which the two Trp probes that display fluorescence changes of opposite sign during T(1) and T(2) (Ub(F45W-T66W)). Global fitting of the folding/unfolding kinetic parameters and additional folding-unfolding double-jump experiments performed on Ub(M1W), a mutant with enhanced fluorescence in the I-state, demonstrate that the I-state is stable, compact, misfolded, and on-pathway. These results illustrate how transient low-energy I-states can be characterized efficiently in complex refolding reactions using multiple Trp probes.

Stabilization of the N-terminal β-hairpin of ubiquitin by a terminal hydrophobic cluster

Study of model beta-hairpin peptides allows for better understanding of the factors involved in the formation of beta-sheet secondary structure in proteins. It is known that turn sequence, sidechain-sidechain interactions, interstrand hydrogen bonding, and beta-sheet propensity of residues are all important for beta-hairpin stability in aqueous solution. However, interactions of the sidechains of the terminal residues of hairpins are thought to contribute little to overall hairpin stability since these residues are typically frayed. Here, the authors report a stabilizing hydrophobic cluster of residues at the termini of the naturally occurring excised N-terminal beta-hairpin of Ubiquitin that folds autonomously in aqueous solution. Our data show that deletion of Met1 and Val17 from this hairpin destabilized the folded state in both aqueous solution and in aqueous-methanol solutions. These results suggest that interactions of terminal residues which are usually frayed can nonetheless contribute significantly to overall stability of beta-hairpin.

The Effect of Increasing the Stability of Non-native Interactions on the Folding Landscape of the Bacterial Immunity Protein Im9

How stabilising non-native interactions influence protein folding energy landscapes is currently not well understood: such interactions could speed folding by reducing the conformational search to the native state, or could slow folding by increasing ruggedness. Here, we examine the influence of non-native interactions in the folding process of the bacterial immunity protein Im9, by exploiting our ability to manipulate the stability of the intermediate and rate-limiting transition state (TS) in the folding of this protein by minor alteration of its sequence or changes in solvent conditions. By analysing the properties of these species using Phi-value analysis, and exploration of the structural properties of the TS ensemble using molecular dynamics simulations, we demonstrate the importance of non-native interactions in immunity protein folding and demonstrate that the rate-limiting step involves partial reorganisation of these interactions as the TS ensemble is traversed. Moreover, we show that increasing the contribution to stability made by non-native interactions results in an increase in Phi-values of the TS ensemble without altering its structural properties or solvent-accessible surface area. The data suggest that the immunity proteins fold on multiple, but closely related, micropathways, resulting in a heterogeneous TS ensemble that responds subtly to mutation or changes in the solvent conditions. Thus, altering the relative strength of native and non-native interactions influences the search to the native state by restricting the pathways through the folding energy landscape.

Model systems for β-hairpins and β-sheets

beta-Sheets and alpha-helices are the two principal secondary structures in proteins. However, our understanding of beta-sheet structure lags behind that of alpha-helices, largely because, until recently, there was no model system to study the beta-sheet secondary structure in isolation. With the development of well-folded beta-hairpins, this is changing rapidly. Recent advances include: increased understanding of the relative contributions of turn, strand and sidechain interactions to beta-hairpin and beta-sheet stability, with the role of aromatic residues as a common subtheme; experimental and theoretical kinetic and thermodynamic studies of beta-hairpin and beta-sheet folding; de novo protein design, including all-beta structures, mixed alpha/beta motifs and switchable systems; and the creation of functional beta-hairpins.

Population of On-pathway Intermediates in the Folding of Ubiquitin

The role that intermediate states play in protein folding is the subject of intense investigation and in the case of ubiquitin has been controversial. We present fluorescence-detected kinetic data derived from single and double mixing stopped-flow experiments to show that the F45W mutant of ubiquitin (WT*), a well-studied single-domain protein and most recently regarded as a simple two-state system, folds via on-pathway intermediates. To account for the discrepancy we observe between equilibrium and kinetic stabilities and m-values, we show that the polypeptide chain undergoes rapid collapse to an intermediate whose presence we infer from a fast lag phase in interrupted refolding experiments. Double-jump kinetic experiments identify two direct folding phases that are not associated with slow isomerisation reactions in the unfolded state. These two phases are explained by kinetic partitioning which allows molecules to reach the native state from the collapsed state via two possible competing routes, which we further examine using two destabilised ubiquitin mutants. Interrupted refolding experiments allow us to observe the formation and decay of an intermediate along one of these pathways. A plausible model for the folding pathway of ubiquitin is presented that demonstrates that obligatory intermediates and/or chain collapse are important events in restricting the conformational search for the native state of ubiquitin.

Ubiquitin: a small protein folding paradigm

For the past twenty years, the small, 76-residue protein ubiquitin has been used as a model system to study protein structure, stability, folding and dynamics. In this time, ubiquitin has become a paradigm for both the experimental and computational folding communities. The folding energy landscape is now uniquely characterised with a plethora of information available on not only the native and denatured states, but partially structured states, alternatively folded states and locally unfolded states, in addition to the transition state ensemble. This Perspective focuses on the experimental characterisation of ubiquitin using a comprehensive range of biophysical techniques.

Local kinetic measures of macromolecular structure reveal partitioning among multiple parallel pathways from the earliest steps in the folding of a large RNA molecule

At the heart of the RNA folding problem is the number, structures, and relationships among the intermediates that populate the folding pathways of most large RNA molecules. Unique insight into the structural dynamics of these intermediates can be gleaned from the time-dependent changes in local probes of macromolecular conformation (e.g. reports on individual nucleotide solvent accessibility offered by hydroxyl radical (()OH) footprinting). Local measures distributed around a macromolecule individually illuminate the ensemble of separate changes that constitute a folding reaction. Folding pathway reconstruction from a multitude of these individual measures is daunting due to the combinatorial explosion of possible kinetic models as the number of independent local measures increases. Fortunately, clustering of time progress curves sufficiently reduces the dimensionality of the data so as to make reconstruction computationally tractable. The most likely folding topology and intermediates can then be identified by exhaustively enumerating all possible kinetic models on a super-computer grid. The folding pathways and measures of the relative flux through them were determined for Mg(2+) and Na(+)-mediated folding of the Tetrahymena thermophila group I intron using this combined experimental and computational approach. The flux during Mg(2+)-mediated folding is divided among numerous parallel pathways. In contrast, the flux during the Na(+)-mediated reaction is predominantly restricted through three pathways, one of which is without detectable passage through intermediates. Under both conditions, the folding reaction is highly parallel with no single pathway accounting for more than 50% of the molecular flux. This suggests that RNA folding is non-sequential under a variety of different experimental conditions even at the earliest stages of folding. This study provides a template for the systematic analysis of the time-evolution of RNA structure from ensembles of local measures that will illuminate the chemical and physical characteristics of each step in the process. The applicability of this analysis approach to other macromolecules is discussed.

Engineering Diverse Changes in β-Turn Propensities in the N-Terminal β-Hairpin of Ubiquitin Reveals Significant Effects on Stability and Kinetics but a Robust Folding Transition State

Using the N-terminal 17-residue beta-hairpin of ubiquitin as a "host" for mutational studies, we have investigated the influence of the beta-turn sequence on protein stability and folding kinetics by replacing the native G-bulged turn (TLTGK) with more flexible analogues (TG3K and TG5K) and a series of four-residue type I' beta-turn sequences, commonly found in beta-hairpins. Although a statistical analysis of type I' turns demonstrates residue preferences at specific sites, the frequency of occurrence appears to only broadly correlate with experimentally determined protein stabilities. The subsequent engineering of context-dependent non-native tertiary contacts involving turn residues is shown to produce large changes in stability. Relatively few point mutations have been described that probe secondary structure formation in ubiquitin in a manner that is independent of tertiary contacts. To this end, we have used the more rigorous rate-equilibrium free energy relationship (Leffler analysis), rather than the two-point phi value analysis, to show for a family of engineered beta-turn mutants that stability (range of approximately 20 kJ/mol) and folding kinetics (190-fold variation in refolding rate) are linearly correlated (alpha(f) = 0.74 +/- 0.08). The data are consistent with a transition state that is robust with regard to a wide range of statistically favored and disfavored beta-turn mutations and implicate a loosely assembled beta-hairpin as a key template in transition state stabilization with the beta-turn playing a central role.

Design of a Peptide Hairpin Containing a Central Three-Residue Loop

The construction of a designed beta-hairpin structure, containing a central three-residue loop has been successfully achieved in the synthetic nonapeptide Boc-Leu-Phe-Val-(D)Pro-(L)Pro-(D)Ala-Leu-Phe-Val-OMe (2). The design is based on expanding the two-residue loop established in the peptide beta-hairpin Boc-Leu-Phe-Val-(D)Pro-(L)Pro-Leu-Phe-Val-OMe (1). Characterization of the registered beta-hairpins in peptides 1 and 2 is based on the observation of key nuclear Overhauser effects (NOEs) in CDCl(3) and CD(3)OH. Solvent titration and temperature dependence of NH chemical shifts establish the identity of NH groups involved in interstrand hydrogen bonding. In peptide 2, the antiparallel registry is maintained, with the formation of a (D)Pro-(L)Pro-(D)Ala loop, stabilized by a 5-->1 hydrogen bond between Val3 CO and Leu7 NH groups (C(13), alpha-turn) and a 3-->1 hydrogen bond between (D)Pro4 CO and (d)Ala6 NH groups (C(7), gamma-turn). NMR derived structures suggest that in peptide 2, (d)Ala(6) adopts an alpha(L) conformation. In peptide 1, the (D)Pro-(L)Pro segment adopts a type II' beta-turn. Replacement of (D)Ala (6) in peptide 2 by (L)Ala in peptide 3 yields a beta-hairpin conformation, with a central (D)Pro-(L)Pro two-residue loop. Strand slippage at the C-terminus results in altered registry of the antiparallel strands.

Hairpin folding rates reflect mutations within and remote from the turn region

Hairpins play a central role in numerous protein folding and misfolding scenarios. Prior studies of hairpin folding, many conducted with analogs of a sequence from the B1 domain of protein G, suggest that faster folding can be achieved only by optimizing the turn propensity of the reversing loop. Based on studies using dynamic NMR, the native GB1 sequence is a slow folding hairpin (k(F)(278)=1.5 x 10(4)/s). GB1 hairpin analogs spanning a wide range of thermodynamic stabilities (DeltaG(U)(298)=-3.09 to+3.25 kJ/mol) were examined. Fold-stabilizing changes in the reversing loop can act either by accelerating folding or retarding unfolding; we present examples of both types. The introduction of an attractive side-chain/side-chain Coulombic interaction at the chain termini further stabilizes this hairpin. The 1.9-fold increase in folding rate constant observed for this change at the chain termini implies that this Coulombic interaction contributes before or at the transition state. This observation is difficult to rationalize by "zipper" folding pathways that require native turn formation as the sole nucleating event; it also suggests that Coulombic interactions should be considered in the design of systems intended to probe the protein folding speed limit.

Engineering Stabilising β-Sheet Interactions into a Conformationally Flexible Region of the Folding Transition State of Ubiquitin

Protein engineering studies suggest that the transition state for the folding of ubiquitin is highly polarised towards the N-terminal part of the sequence and involves a nucleus of residues within the beta-hairpin (residues 1-17) and main alpha-helix (residues 23-34). In contrast, the observation of small phi-values for residues in the C-terminal portion of the sequence (residues 35-76), coupled with a folding topology that results in a much higher contact order, suggests that fast folding of ubiquitin is dependent upon configurational flexibility in the C-terminal part of the polypeptide chain to ensure passage down a relatively smooth folding funnel to the native state. We show that the introduction of a small mini-hairpin motif as an extension of the native 43-50 hairpin stabilises local interactions in the C-terminal part of the sequence, resulting largely in a deceleration of the unfolding kinetics without perturbing the apparent two-state folding mechanism. However, a single-point Leu-->Phe substitution within the engineered hairpin sequence leads to the premature collapse of the denatured ensemble through the stabilisation of non-native interactions and the population of a compact intermediate. Non-linear effects in the kinetic data at low concentrations of denaturant suggest that the collapsed state, which is further stabilised in the presence of cosmotropic salts, may subsequently fold directly to the native state through a "triangular" reaction scheme involving internal rearrangement rather than unfolding and refolding.