Mechanical and fatigue behaviour of artificial ligaments (ALs)

Assessment of the advantages and limitations of an innovative silk fibroin scaffold for the reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament with preclinical in vitro and in vivo evaluations

The gold standard treatment in anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction involves autologous tissue transplantation, but this can have complications. Artificial grafts are an alternative, but the best option is debated. This study aimed to assess the biocompatibility and integration of a silk fibroin textile prosthesis (SF-TP) with peri-implant bone tissue and the native ACL. Twenty-six sheep underwent ACL reconstruction with SF-TP or autologous femoral fascia lata (FFL). Sheep were divided into two groups (3 and 6 months) and retrieved joints processed for histological, morphometrical and mechanical analysis. In vitro, SF-TP showed no cytotoxicity and good cell interaction up to 14 days. Histology revealed fibro-vascular tissue around SF-TP, with a progressive attempt of ligamentous-like tissue formation at 6 months. However, SF-TP group had higher joint damage scores. Micro-CT showed tunnel enlargement in SF-TP group, while FFL group had a decrease. SF-TP reconstructions had lower stiffness and strength (44 % and 64 % decrease) than those of autologous FFL reconstruction and often failed by pull-out from the bone tunnel due to tunnel enlargement. These results indicate poor osteointegration and graft motion with SF-TP, leading to joint damage/bone resorption and reduced mechanical competence. These results do not support the use of SF-TP for ACL reconstruction.

A machine learning system for artificial ligaments with desired mechanical properties in ACL reconstruction applications

The anterior cruciate ligament is one of the important tissues to maintain the stability of the human knee joint, but it is difficult for this ligament to self-heal after injury. Consequently, transplantation of artificial ligaments (ALs) has gained widespread attention as an important alternative treatment method in recent years. However, accurately predicting the intricate mechanical properties of ALs remains a formidable challenge, particularly when employing theoretical frameworks such as braiding theory. This obstacle presents a significant impediment to achieving optimal AL design. Therefore, in this study, a high-precision machine learning model based on an artificial neural network was developed to rapidly and accurately predict the mechanical properties of ALs. The results showed that the proposed model achieved a reduction of 45.22% and 50.17% in the normalized root mean square error on the testing set when compared to traditional machine learning models (Random Forest and Support Vector Machine), demonstrating its higher accuracy. In addition, the design of ALs with desired mechanical properties was achieved by optimizing the braiding parameters, and its effectiveness was verified through experiments. The mechanical properties of the prepared ALs were able to fully meet the desired targets and were at least 2% higher. Finally, the influence weights of different braiding parameters on the mechanical properties of ALs were analyzed by feature importance.

Toward the Improvement of the Mechanical and Tribological Properties of Braided Ligament for ACL Reconstruction: A "Carrot and Stick" Strategy

Bone tunnel enlargement has been troubling the clinical adoption of braided artificial ligaments for decades, to which mechanical and tribological performance promotion shall be an effective and promising approach. Herein, a "carrot and stick" strategy has been introduced with two types of polyethylene terephthalate (PET) fibers to fabricate hybrid textures, which is expected to advance fatigue and tribological performance without yielding essential mechanical strength and biocompatibility. Owing to advancements in such a "carrot and stick" strategy, the obtained grafts present three promising properties: i) enhancement of mechanical strength; ii) coefficient of friction (COF) reduction of 25% at the greatest extent, thus lowering the risk of bone tunnel enlargement; iii) final displacement shrinkage of graft length after cyclic loadings, favored in the clinic for isometric reconstruction. The results obtained in this study show that the "carrot and stick" strategy can be a creative and convenient method to optimize the service life, saving the complication rate of artificial ligaments for clinical applications.

High-Performance Artificial Ligament Made from Helical Polyester Fibers Wrapped with Aligned Carbon Nanotube Sheets

Repairing high-load connective tissues, such as ligaments, by surgically implanting artificial grafts after injury is challenging because they lack biointegration with host bones for stable interfaces. Herein, a high-performance helical composite fiber (HCF) ligament by wrapping aligned carbon nanotube (CNT) sheets around polyester fibers is proposed. Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction surgery shows that HCF grafts could induce effective bone regeneration, thus allowing the narrowing of bone tunnel defects. Such repair of the bone tunnel is in strong contrast to the tunnel enlargement of more than 50% for commercial artificial ligaments made from bare polyester fibers. Rats reconstructed with this HCF ligament show normal jumping, walking, and running without limping. This work allows bone regeneration in vivo through a one-step surgery without seeding cells or transforming growth factors, thereby opening an avenue for high-performance artificial tissues.

Hierarchical helical carbon nanotube fibre as a bone-integrating anterior cruciate ligament replacement

High rates of ligament damage require replacements; however, current synthetic materials have issues with bone integration leading to implant failure. Here we introduce an artificial ligament that has the required mechanical properties and can integrate with the host bone and restore movement in animals. The ligament is assembled from aligned carbon nanotubes formed into hierarchical helical fibres bearing nanometre and micrometre channels. Osseointegration of the artificial ligament is observed in an anterior cruciate ligament replacement model where clinical polymer controls showed bone resorption. A higher pull-out force is found after a 13-week implantation in rabbit and ovine models, and animals can run and jump normally. The long-term safety of the artificial ligament is demonstrated, and the pathways involved in integration are studied.

Phytic acid/magnesium ion complex coating on PEEK fiber woven fabric as an artificial ligament with anti-fibrogenesis and osteogenesis for ligament-bone healing

Development of an artificial ligament possessing osteogenic activity to enhance ligament-bone healing for reconstruction of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) is a great challenge. Herein, polyetheretherketone fibers (PKF) were coated with phytic acid (PA)/magnesium (Mg) ions complex (PKPM), which were woven into fabrics as an artificial ligament. The results demonstrated that PKPM with PA/Mg complex coating exhibited optimized surface properties with improved hydrophilicity and surface energy, and slow release of Mg ions. PKPM significantly enhanced responses of rat bone marrow stem cells in vitro. Moreover, PKPM remarkably promoted M2 macrophage polarization that upregulated production of anti-inflammatory cytokine while inhibited M1 macrophage polarization that downregulated production of pro-inflammatory cytokine in vitro. Further, PKPM inhibited fibrous encapsulation by preventing M1 macrophage polarization while promoted osteogenesis for ligament-bone healing by triggering M2 macrophage polarization in vivo. The results suggested that the downregulation of M1 macrophage polarization for inhibiting fibrogenesis and upregulation of M2 macrophage polarization for improving osteogenesis of PKPM were attributed to synergistic effects of PA and sustained release of Mg ions. In summary, PKPM with PA/Mg complex coating upregulated pro-osteogenic macrophage polarization that supplied a profitable anti-inflammatory environments for osteogenesis and ligament-bone healing, thereby possessing tremendous potential for reconstruction of ACL.