Comparison of effectiveness of hyaluronan gel, intrauterine device and their combination for prevention adhesions in patients after intrauterine surgery: systematic review and meta-analysis

The Effects of Filgrastim and Hyaluronic Acid on the Endometrium in Experimentally Induced Asherman Syndrome Rat Models: A Prospective Laboratory Study

Background/Objectives: The aim of the present study was to explore the histopathological effects and tissue Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor (VEGF) levels of filgrastim and hyaluronic acid treatment in a rat model with experimentally induced Asherman syndrome. Methods: In this study, 26 female Sprague Dawley rats were used. First, a rat model of Asherman syndrome was established in two rats, and the remaining rats were randomly divided into three groups. A total of 0.1 mL trichloroacetic acid was applied to the right uterine horns of all groups to induce adhesion formation.Group I received no treatment, Group II received intrauterine hyaluronic acid treatment (0.01), Group III received subcutaneous Filgrastim treatment (50 μg/kg/day), and Group IV received both intrauterine hyaluronic acid and subcutaneous Filgrastim treatment. Histopathological analysis of uterine horns in the rats with and without Asherman syndrome, inflammation, glandular count, and fibrosis levels were examined. Tissue VEGF levels were investigated immunohistochemically. Results: Hyaluronic acid treatment resulted in an increase only in uterine lumen diameter and VEGF levels, while Filgrastim treatment led to an increase in uterine wall diameter, lumen diameter, gland count, and VEGF levels, as well as a decrease in fibrosis and inflammation scores. Combined treatment with filgrastim and hyaluronic acid showed an increase in lumen diameter, gland count, and VEGF levels, along with a decrease in inflammation and fibrosis scores (p < 0.05). Filgrastim treatment resulted in better effects for Asherman syndrome compared to hyaluronic acid treatment. There were no beneficial effects seen with the combined therapy. Conclusions: Filgrastim treatment resulted in better outcomes for Asherman syndrome compared to hyaluronic acid treatment. The combined therapy did not show additional benefits beyond what was achieved with Filgrastim treatment alone.

The application of tissue engineering strategies for uterine regeneration

Uterine injuries, particularly damages to endometrium, are usually associated with abnormal menstruation, recurrent miscarriage, pregnancy complications, and infertility. Tissue engineering using cell-based, biomolecule-based, or biomaterial and scaffold-based strategies has emerged as a novel and promising approach for uterine regeneration. Stem cells, biomolecules, and porous scaffolds used alone or, very often, used in combination as a more effective treatment means have shown great potential in promoting uterine regeneration. The reported preclinical studies have indicated that appropriate tissue engineering strategies could safely and effectively reconstruct not only endometrium but also partial or even the whole uterine structure. However, the progress in the uterine regeneration area is slow in comparison to that of regenerating many other body tissues and hence it still remains a great challenge to apply uterine tissue engineering for clinical applications. In this review, conventional treatments for uterine-related diseases are briefly reviewed and discussed first. Subsequently, tissue engineering strategies (cell-based, biomolecule-based, biomaterial and scaffold-based, or their combinations) for uterine repair in preclinical studies and clinical trials are presented and analyzed. Finally, the challenges and perspectives in uterine regeneration are pointed and discussed. Despite various limitations and obstacles, the tissue engineering approach is viable and holds high promise for uterine regeneration.

4DryField vs. hyalobarrier gel for preventing the recurrence of intrauterine adhesions - a pilot study

INTRODUCTION

This was a single-center pilot study that sought to describe an innovative use of 4DryField® PH (premix) for preventing the recurrence of intrauterine adhesions (IUAs) after hysteroscopic adhesiolysis in patients with Asherman's syndrome (AS).

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Twenty-three patients with AS were enrolled and 20 were randomized (1:1 ratio) to intrauterine application of 4DryField® PH (n = 10) or Hyalobarrier® gel (n = 10) in a single-blind manner. We evaluated IUAs (American Fertility Society [AFS] score) during initial hysteroscopy and second-look hysteroscopy one month later. Patients completed a follow-up symptoms questionnaire three and reproductive outcomes questionnaire six months later.

RESULTS

The demographic and clinical characteristics, as well as severity of IUAs, were comparable in both groups. The mean initial AFS score was 9 and 8.5 in the 4DryField® PH and Hyalobarrier® gel groups, respectively (p = .476). There were no between-group differences in AFS progress (5.9 vs. 5.6, p = .675), need for secondary adhesiolysis (7 vs. 7 patients, p = 1), and the follow-up outcomes.

CONCLUSION

4DryField® PH could be a promising antiadhesive agent for preventing the recurrence of IUAs, showing similar effectiveness and safety to Hyalobarrier® gel. Our findings warrant prospective validation in a larger clinical trial.

CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRY NUMBER

ISRCTN15630617.

Yangmo decoction versus hyaluronic acid gel in women with intrauterine re-adhesion after hysteroscopic adhesiolysis: a retrospective efficacy and safety analysis

BACKGROUND

Hysteroscopic adhesiolysis is the preferred primary method for intrauterine adhesion. However, there is about a 60% of chance of re-adhesion after surgery. The objectives of the study were to evaluate the efficacy and safety of Yangmo decoction as a secondary treatment in preventing intrauterine re-adhesion against those of hyaluronic acid gel.

METHODS

Women received oral Yangmo decoction (YD cohort, n = 105) or intrauterine hyaluronic acid gel (HA cohort, n = 125) or did not receive secondary re-adhesion prevention treatments (EP cohort, n = 165) after hysteroscopic adhesiolysis for 6 months. In addition, all women have received 3 mg of oral estrogen and 20 mg oral progesterone combination after hysteroscopic adhesiolysis for 3 months. Intrauterine re-adhesion after hysteroscopic adhesiolysis after 6 months with or without secondary treatment(s) was detected using hysteroscopy. The extent of the cavity, type of adhesion, and the menstrual pattern were included to define the American Fertility Society classification of intrauterine re-adhesions (AFS) score.

RESULTS

Fewer numbers of women suffered from intrauterine re-adhesion after hysteroscopic adhesiolysis in the YD cohort than those of the HA (15(14%) vs. 40(32%), p = 0.0019) and the EP (15(14%) vs. 58(35%). p = 0.0001) cohorts. Among women who developed intrauterine re-adhesion, AFS score was fewer for women of the YD cohort than those of HA (2(2-1) vs. 4(4-3), p < 0.001) and the EP (2(2-1) vs. 4(4-4), p < 0.001) cohorts. AFS score after surgery was fewer for women of the HA cohort than those of the EP cohort (p < 0.05). Higher numbers of women of the YD cohort retained pregnancies after 6-months of treatment than those of the HA (55(52%) vs. 45(36%), p = 0.0161) and EP (55(52%) vs. 35(21%), p < 0.0001) cohorts. Among women who develop re-adhesion, 10(10%) women of the YD cohort only had successful pregnancies.

CONCLUSIONS

Yangmo decoction for 6 months after hysteroscopic adhesiolysis can reduce AFS score, prevent intrauterine re-adhesion, and increases the chances of successful pregnancies of women.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV.

TECHNICAL EFFICACY

Stage 5.