Surgical palliation or primary transplantation for aortic valve atresia

Research Enterprise of the Congenital Heart Surgeons' Society 2018 to 2023: History, Accomplishments, Transformation, and Challenges

The history of the research arm of the Congenital Heart Surgeons' Society (CHSS) through 2017 was contained within two prior publications that covered CHSS history in general. The present article is the first to focus explicitly on the research enterprise, with emphasis on the period 2018 to 2023. During this time, the challenges of continuing to build multiple cohorts with lifelong follow-up and to transform the enterprise to a premiere research organization became manifest. Although continuing its commitment to produce impactful research results and to educate the Kirklin/Ashburn Fellow, the research team devoted considerable effort to defining the problems of cohort relevance, workflow, data management, long-term patient follow-up, CHSS member engagement, and the regulatory burden. The team wrote a proposal outlining ways to solve the challenges. A major change from a single-institution "Data Center" to a two-institution Center for Research & Quality (CRQ) was made, assuring increased faculty members and resources. The proposed changes to structure and process began execution in mid-2022. A second Kirklin/Ashburn Fellowship position was created. Between 2018 and 2022, the CRQ produced 17 publications and launched five new research initiatives. This article chronicles the exciting five-year period in which the CHSS research enterprise began a transformation with the intent to become the premiere research organization in the world in the specialty of congenital cardiac surgery.

The Academic Impact of Congenital Heart Surgeons' Society (CHSS) Studies

PURPOSE

We reviewed all 64 articles ever published by The Congenital Heart Surgeons' Society (CHSS) Data Center to estimate the academic impact of these peer-reviewed articles.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The Congenital Heart Surgeons' Society has performed research based on 12 Diagnostic Inception Cohorts. The first cohort (Transposition) began enrolling patients on January 1, 1985. We queried PubMed to determine the number of publications that referenced each of the 64 journal articles generated by the datasets of the 12 Diagnostic Inception Cohorts that comprise the CHSS Database. Descriptive summaries of the data were tabulated using mean with standard deviation and median with range.

RESULTS

Sixty-four peer-reviewed papers have been published based on the CHSS Database. Fifty-nine peer-reviewed articles have been published based on the 12 Diagnostic Inception Cohorts, and five additional articles have been published based on Data Science. Excluding the recently established Diagnostic Inception Cohort for patients with Ebstein malformation of tricuspid valve, the number of papers published per cohort ranged from 1 for coarctation to 11 for transposition of the great arteries. The 11 articles generated from the CHSS Transposition Cohort were referenced by a total of 111 articles (median number of references per journal article = 9 [range = 0-22, mean = 10.1]). Overall, individual articles were cited by an average of 11 (mean), and a maximum of 41 PubMed-listed publications. Overall, these 64 peer-reviewed articles based on the CHSS Database were cited 692 times in PubMed-listed publications. The first CHSS peer-reviewed article was published in 1987, and during the 35 years from 1987 to 2022, inclusive, the annual number of CHSS publications has ranged from 0 to 7, with a mean of 1.8 publications per year (median = 1, mode = 1).

CONCLUSION

Congenital Heart Surgeons' Society studies are widely referenced in the pediatric cardiac surgical literature, with over 10 citations per published article. These cohorts provide unique information unavailable in other sources of data. A tool to access this analysis is available at: [https://data-center.chss.org/multimedia/files/2022/CAI.pdf].

A Single-Institutional Experience with 36 Children Smaller Than 5 Kilograms Supported with the Berlin Heart Ventricular Assist Device (VAD) over 12 Years: Comparison of Patients with Biventricular versus Functionally Univentricular Circulation

OBJECTIVES

We reviewed outcomes in all 36 consecutive children <5 kg supported with the Berlin Heart pulsatile ventricular assist device (VAD) at the University of Florida, comparing those with univentricular circulation (n  =  23) to those with biventricular circulation (n  =  13).

METHODS

The primary outcome was mortality. Kaplan-Meier methods and log-rank tests were used to assess group differences in long-term survival after VAD insertion. T-tests using estimated survival proportions and standard errors were used to compare groups at specific time points.

RESULTS

Of all 82 patients ever supported with Berlin Heart at our institution, 49 (49/82  =  59.76%) weighed <10 kg and 36 (36/82  =  43.90%) weighed <5 kg. Of these 36 patients who weighed <5 kg, 26 (26/36  =  72.22%) were successfully bridged to transplantation. Of these 36 patients who weighed <5 kg, 13 (13/36  =  36.1%) had biventricular circulation and were supported with 12 biventricular assist devices (BiVADs) and 1 left ventricular assist device (LVAD) (Age [days]: median  =  67, range  =  17-212; Weight [kilograms]: median  =  4.1, range  =  3.1-4.9), while 23 (23/36  =  63.9%) had univentricular circulation and were supported with 23 single ventricle-ventricular assist devices (sVADs) (Age [days]: median  =  25, range  =  4-215; Weight [kilograms]: median  =  3.4, range  =  2.4-4.9). Of 13 biventricular patients who weighed <5 kg, 12 (12/23  =  92.3%) were successfully bridged to cardiac transplantation. Of 23 functionally univentricular patients who weighed <5 kg, 14 (14/23  =  60.87%) were successfully bridged to cardiac transplantation. For all 36 patients who weighed <5 kg: 1-year survival estimate after VAD insertion  =  62.7% (95% confidence interval [CI]  =  48.5%-81.2%) and 5-year survival estimate after VAD insertion  =  58.5% (95% CI  =  43.8%-78.3%). One-year survival after VAD insertion: 84.6% (95% CI  =  67.1%-99.9%) in biventricular patients and 49.7% (95% CI  =  32.3%-76.4%) in univentricular patients, P  =  0.018. Three-year survival after VAD insertion: 84.6% (95% CI  =  67.1%-99.9%) in biventricular patients and 41.4% (95% CI  =  23.6%-72.5%) in univentricular patients, P  =  0.005.

CONCLUSION

Pulsatile VAD facilitates bridge to transplantation in neonates and infants weighing <5 kg; however, survival after VAD insertion in these small patients is less in those with univentricular circulation in comparison to those with biventricular circulation.

Support with Single Ventricle-Ventricular Assist Device (sVAD) in Patients with Functionally Univentricular Circulation Prior to Fontan Operation

Some patients with functionally univentricular circulation develop cardiac failure refractory to maximal management and are supported with a ventricular assist device (VAD). The purpose of this manuscript is to summarize our previous publications related to single ventricle-ventricular assist device (sVAD) support in patients with functionally univentricular circulation and to describe our current institutional approach at University of Florida to sVAD support in neonates, infants, and children prior to Fontan. Our programmatic philosophy at University of Florida is to strive to identify the minority of neonates with functionally univentricular circulation who are extremely high-risk prior to initiating staged palliation and to stabilize these neonates with primary preemptive sVAD in preparation for cardiac transplantation; our rationale for this approach is related to the challenges associated with failed staged palliation and subsequent bail-out sVAD support and transplantation. A subset of extremely high-risk neonates and infants with functionally univentricular ductal-dependent circulation undergo primary preemptive sVAD insertion and subsequent cardiac transplantation. Support with VAD clearly facilitates survival on the waiting list during prolonged wait times and optimizes outcomes after Norwood (Stage 1) by providing an alternative pathway for extremely high-risk patients. Therefore, the selective utilization of sVAD in extremely high-risk neonates facilitates improved outcomes for all patients with functionally univentricular ductal-dependent circulation. At University of Florida, our programmatic approach to utilizing sVAD support as a bridge to transplantation in the minority of neonates with functionally univentricular circulation who are extremely high-risk for staged palliation is associated with Operative Mortality after Norwood (Stage 1) Operation of 2.9% (2/68) and a one-year survival of 91.1% (82/90) for all neonates presenting with hypoplastic left heart syndrome (HLHS) or HLHS-related malformation with functionally univentricular ductal-dependent systemic circulation. Meanwhile, at University of Florida, for all 82 consecutive neonates, infants, and children supported with pulsatile paracorporeal VAD: Kaplan-Meier survival estimated one year after VAD insertion = 73.3% (95% confidence interval [CI] = 64.1-83.8%), and Kaplan-Meier survival estimated five years after VAD insertion = 68.3% (95% CI = 58.4-79.8%). For all 48 consecutive neonates, infants, and children at University of Florida with biventricular circulation supported with pulsatile paracorporeal VAD: Kaplan-Meier survival estimated one year after VAD insertion = 82.7% (95% CI = 72.4-94.4%), and Kaplan-Meier survival estimated five years after VAD insertion = 79.7% (95% CI = 68.6-92.6%). For all 34 consecutive neonates, infants, and children at University of Florida with functionally univentricular circulation supported with pulsatile paracorporeal sVAD: Kaplan-Meier survival estimated one year after VAD insertion = 59.7% (95% CI = 44.9-79.5%), and Kaplan-Meier survival estimated five years after VAD insertion = 50.5% (95% CI = 35.0-73.0%). These Kaplan-Meier survival estimates for patients supported with pulsatile paracorporeal VAD are better in patients with biventricular circulation in comparison to patients with functionally univentricular circulation both one year after VAD insertion (P=0.026) and five years after VAD insertion (P=0.010). Although outcomes after VAD support in functionally univentricular patients are worse than in patients with biventricular circulation, sVAD provides a reasonable chance for survival. Ongoing research is necessary to improve the outcomes of these challenging patients, with the goal of developing strategies where outcomes after sVAD support in functionally univentricular patients are equivalent to the outcomes achieved after VAD support in patients with biventricular circulation.

Assessment of Current STS Data Elements for Adults with Congenital Heart Disease

BACKGROUND

To identify opportunities for enhanced ACHD data collection, a structured review of existing variables in the STS Congenital Heart Surgery Database (CHSD) and the STS Adult Cardiac Surgery Database (ACSD) was conducted.

METHODS

A working group was assembled representing multiple STS Workforces and Task Forces. The ACSD was reviewed systematically over eight 90 minute calls. ACSD version 4.20.2 and CHSD version 3.41 were used, and the ACSD was approached in sections. ACSD variables were classified as either: 1) represented in identical form in the CHSD (no further discussion), 2) represented in similar form in the CHSD (discussed for potential harmonization of definitions), or 3) not represented in the CHSD (discussed for potential inclusion). Variables felt to be relevant to ACHD were noted, and special consideration was given to STS required fields and variables utilized in existing STS adult risk models. Other factors that were examined were the frequency, utilization, and capture of existing ACSD variables.

RESULTS

Over 22 weeks (8 calls), the existing 1069 variables in version 4.20.2 of the ACSD were discussed. Ultimately, 539 total variables were found to be both 1) relevant to ACHD and 2) not currently collected in the CHSD. These were recommended for inclusion in the next CHSD upgrade for patients older than 18 years.

CONCLUSIONS

For adult patients having case records entered into the CHSD, the inclusion of a limited set of additional data fields from the ACSD should enhance capture of co-morbidities and other clinical data relevant to the ACHD population.

Failures of the Fontan System in Univentricular Hearts and Mortality Risk in Heart Transplantation: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

The Fontan procedure (FP) is the standard surgical treatment for Univentricular heart diseases. Over time, the Fontan system fails, leading to pathologies such as protein-losing enteropathy (PLE), plastic bronchitis (PB), and heart failure (HF). FP should be considered as a transitional step to the final treatment: heart transplantation (HT). This systematic review and meta-analysis aims to establish the risk of death following HT according to the presence of FP complications. There was a total of 691 transplanted patients in the 18 articles, immediate survival 88% (n = 448), survival from 1 to 5 years of 78% (n = 427) and survival from 5.1 to 10 years of 69% (n = 208), >10 years 61% (n = 109). The relative risk (RR) was 1.12 for PLE (95% confidence interval [CI] = 0.89-1.40, p = 0.34), 1.03 for HF (0.7-1.51, p = 0.88), 0.70 for Arrhythmias (0.39-1.24, p = 0.22), 0.46 for PB (0.08-2.72, p = 0.39), and 5.81 for CKD (1.70-19.88, p = 0.005). In patients with two or more failures, the RR was 1.94 (0.99-3.81, p = 0.05). After FP, the risk of death after HT is associated with CKD and with the presence of two or more failures.

The Society of Thoracic Surgeons Congenital Heart Surgery Database: 2021 Update on Outcomes and Research

The Society of Thoracic Surgeons Congenital Heart Surgery Database is a comprehensive clinical outcomes registry that captures almost all pediatric cardiac surgical operations in the United States. It is the platform for all activities of The Society of Thoracic Surgeons related to the analysis of outcomes and improvement of quality in this subspecialty. This report summarizes current aggregate national outcomes in congenital and pediatric cardiac surgery performed between July 1, 2016, and June 30, 2020. The reported data on aggregate national outcomes are exemplified by an analysis of 10 prespecified benchmark operation groups performed. This report further reviews related activities in the areas of data collection and analysis, quality measurement, performance improvement, and research.

Combined Hybrid Procedure and VAD insertion in 9 High-Risk Neonates and Infants with HLHS

BACKGROUND

We report nine high-risk neonates and infants with HLHS stabilized with a Hybrid Approach + VAD insertion (Hybrid+VAD) in preparation for transplantation.

METHODS

Nine patients with HLHS (7 neonates, 2 infants) presented with anatomical and/or physiological features associated with increased risk for conventional univentricular palliation with the Norwood Operation (large coronary sinusoids/fistulas, severe tricuspid regurgitation, cardiogenic shock, restrictive atrial septum). These patients underwent combined VAD insertion (Berlin EXCOR) and stage 1 hybrid palliation (application of bilateral pulmonary bands, stent placement in the PDA, and atrial septectomy if needed). During this same era, at our institution, 41 neonates underwent Norwood Operation, three neonates underwent Hybrid Approach "Stage 1" without VAD, and three HLHS patients were supported with prostaglandin while awaiting transplantation.

RESULTS

At Hybrid+VAD insertion, median age = 20 days (range = 13-143) and median weight = 3.25 kilograms (range = 2.43-4.2). Six patients survive (67%) and three patients died (33%). Five survivors are at home doing well after successful transplantation and one survivor is doing well in the ICU on VAD support awaiting transplantation. Only one of six survivors (16.7%) required intubation more than 10 days after Hybrid+VAD insertion. In eight patients no longer on VAD, median length of VAD support was 119.5 days (range = 56-196 days).

CONCLUSIONS

High-risk patients with HLHS who are suboptimal candidates for Norwood palliation can be successfully stabilized with pulsatile VAD insertion along with hybrid palliation while awaiting cardiac transplantation; these patients may be extubated and optimized for transplantation while on VAD.

Current opinion in pediatric heart transplantation

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Cardiac transplant remains the most effective therapy for children with end-stage heart disease. Outcomes remain better than any alternative therapy for this condition, but its use is limited by donor organ availability. As a result, waitlist times and mortality on the waiting list remain unacceptably high. Novel approaches are necessary to address this problem.

RECENT FINDINGS

Organ Procurement and Transplant Network/United Network for Organ Sharing readjusted the pediatric heart allocation system in 2016 to prioritize children at highest risk of mortality, encourage judicious listing, and improve appropriate donor organ utilization. Subsequent studies have aligned with these priorities to help risk-stratify patients at the time of listing and identify the importance that should be assigned to donor-specific factors. In addition, many authors are advocating for increased utilization of hearts donated after cardiac death. Pediatric Ventricular Assist Device (VAD) application has also been increasing to help decrease waitlist mortality. Although results have significantly improved, there remain important limitations to widespread use of VADs in the pediatric population. This has prompted novel techniques such as pulmonary artery banding to improve cardiac function and, in some cases, promote recovery. The demand for cardiac replacement continues to increase with an ageing population of patients with congenital heart disease, presenting new challenges and stressors to the system.

SUMMARY

Pediatric cardiac transplant outcomes are excellent but remain plagued by the limited supply of donor organs. Recent strategies to combat this problem have focused on judicious listing, maximal utilization of available donor organs, and safely extending the lives of patients on the waitlist. New demands on the organ supply chain will continue to stress the system, making these efforts of the highest importance.Clinical Trial Registry Number not applicable.

WITHDRAWN: Commentary: Unicorns and leprechauns

The Publisher regrets that this article is an accidental duplication of an article that has already been published, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtcvs.2019.12.017. The duplicate article has therefore been withdrawn. The full Elsevier Policy on Article Withdrawal can be found at https://www.elsevier.com/about/our-business/policies/article-withdrawal