Impact Stress in Water Resistance Voice Therapy: A Physical Modeling Study

Water Resistance Therapy in Individuals with Parkinson's Disease: A Session-by-Session Analysis of the Vocal Quality

OBJECTIVES

Verify session-by-session effects of the water resistance therapy (WRT) on the vocal quality of individuals with Parkinson's disease (PD).

METHODS

This is a retrospective analytical study. Then, the samples were acquired from a database composed of 10 men aged between 50 and 90 years old diagnosed with PD. The participants underwent WRT with a resonance tube; then, they were guided to perform the following phonatory tasks: comfortable pitch and loudness, high pitch, low pitch, ascending and descending glissandos, and sentence uttering. Furthermore, tube depth ranged from 2 cm to 9 cm. Finally, WRT was implemented twice per week, totaling eight sessions, each lasting 45 minutes. Participants were assessed before and after each therapy session. Hence, the data were assessed with spectrographic analysis, vocal intensity, cepstral peak prominence-smoothed, alpha ratio, L1-L0, oscillatory frequency, and auditory-perceptual assessment of overall degree, roughness, breathiness, and instability. One-way repeated measures analysis of variance and Friedman tests were applied (P < 0.05). Furthermore, Holm-Sidak and Tukey tests were used as posthoc tests.

RESULTS

After the sixth session, the spectrographic analysis revealed that the tracing color intensity of medium frequencies darkened, whereas a better result could be observed after the eighth session. Regarding vocal intensity, the improvement could be observed from the third session. Additionally, L1-L0 followed the same results. The overall degree auditory-perceptual assessment revealed the best results only after the second, third, and fourth sessions; however, after the eighth session, the instability increased.

CONCLUSIONS

WRT allowed better results from the third session, with some improvements in the sixth session. However, the instability increased after the eighth session; thus, it is important to review the phonatory tasks and session numbers to avoid an overload in the phonatory system.

Extrinsic Laryngeal Muscle Activity With Different Diameters and Water Depths in a Semi-Occluded Vocal Tract Exercise

PURPOSE

Surface electromyography (sEMG) has been used to evaluate extrinsic laryngeal muscle activity during swallowing and phonation. In the current study, sEMG amplitudes were measured from the infrahyoid and suprahyoid muscles during phonation through a tube submerged in water.

METHOD

The sEMG amplitude values measured from the extrinsic laryngeal muscles and the electroglottographic contact quotient (CQ) were obtained simultaneously from 62 healthy participants (31 men, 31 women) during phonation through a tube at six different depths (2, 4, 7, 10, 15, and 20 cm) while using two tubes with different diameters (1 and 0.5 cm).

RESULTS

With increasing depth, the sEMG amplitude for the suprahyoid muscles increased in men and women. However, sEMG amplitudes for the infrahyoid muscles increased significantly only in men. Tube diameter had a significant effect on the suprahyoid sEMG amplitudes only for men, with higher sEMG amplitudes when phonating with a 1.0-cm tube. CQ values increased with submerged depth for both men and women. Tube diameter affected results such than CQ values were higher for men when using the wider tube and for women with the narrower tube.

CONCLUSIONS

Vocal fold vibratory patterns changed with the depth of tube submersion in water for both men and women, but the patterns of muscle activation differed between the sexes. This suggests that men and women use different strategies when confronted with increased intraoral pressure during semi-occluded vocal tract exercises. In this study, sEMG provided insight into the mechanism for differences between vocally normal individuals and could help detect compensatory muscle activation during tube phonation in water for people with voice disorders.

Acoustic, Aerodynamic, Morphometric, and Perceptual Changes During and After Semi-Occluded Vocal Tract Exercise: An Integrative Review

OBJECTIVE

The body of literature discussing the acoustic, aerodynamic, perceptual, and morphometric changes that occur during and after semi-occluded vocal tract exercise (SOVTE) has dramatically expanded within the past 20 years. The current study integrates the literature on SOVTE from the 1990s onward, reviewing the technique's clinically relevant effects in vocally untrained adults both with and without dysphonia. The study aims to give clinicians actionable information on how SOVTEs alter vocal function in both normal and pathological states.

METHODS

The author queried the MEDLINE database for combinations of search terms related to semi-occluded vocal tract exercise. To improve article identification, the author also performed iterative citation webbing in which the reference lists of each article selected for full-text screening were cross-referenced against the articles returned in the initial MEDLINE search. Articles identified by iterative citation webbing that did not appear in the initial MEDLINE search were then screened individually. The second author independently verified adherence to the review's inclusion and exclusion criteria in both the initial search and data extraction phases.

RESULTS

The initial MEDLINE search returned 869 articles, 111 of which passed the title and abstract screening phase. Iterative citation webbing returned an additional 20 studies, resulting in a total of 131 articles that qualified for full-text screening. 53 articles passed full-text screening and were included in the current review.

DISCUSSION

Semi-occluded vocal tract exercise increases the inertive reactance of the glottis, vocal tract, and air column, as well as introducing flow resistance at the level of the lips or velopharyngeal port. Each of these mechanisms yields downstream acoustic, aerodynamic, morphometric, and perceptual changes, including reductions in phonation threshold pressure and perceived phonatory effort, improved spectral characteristics of the acoustic signal, attenuation of vocal fold impact stress as indexed by various metrics such as maximum area declination rate, and alterations to the physical dimensions of the vocal tract. Although few studies examined the duration of these changes post exercise, several RCTs support the assertion that SOVTE's effects can be sustained with regular practice over weeks or months, regardless of current vocal health status.

The Role of the Vocal Tract's Acousto-Mechanical Resonance on the Mechanism of Bubble Release From Tubes Used in SOVTE

AND OBJECTIVES

Semi-occluded vocal tract exercises involving a tube with a distal end immersed in water have been used as a voice rehabilitation technique for nearly 60 years. Advantages of this technique include a constant flow resistance, which is mainly dependent on the tube's immersion depth, and an oscillatory component of the back pressure due to bubble release, which is assumed to provide relief of muscle hypertension around the laryngeal and pharyngeal regions. The goal of this study is twofold. First, to shed more light on the contribution of geometrical parameters, such as tube inner diameter and inclination, on the amplitude of the back pressure oscillation and on the bubble release frequency (BRF). The second goal aims to understand the role of vocal tract compliance on the mechanism of bubble release. We hypothesize that the low-frequency acousto-mechanical resonance of a real compliant vocal tract becomes strongly coupled with the mechanism of bubble release, thereby augmenting the back pressure oscillation and dictating the BRF.

METHODS

The BRF and the back pressure are assessed experimentally as a function of flow rate for tubes with a non-compliant upstream condition, considering different diameters and inclinations. These results are compared with theoretical predictions and the experimental data obtained with six adult subjects, from which the vocal tract acousto-mechanical resonance frequencies are also assessed.

RESULTS

The results obtained with tubes involving a non-compliant upstream condition agreed well with the theoretical results and did not indicate a significant influence of the inclination nor the inner diameter on the BRF and on the oscillatory component of the back pressure. Despite the good agreement with the theory, the results obtained from the tube with a non-compliant upstream termination diverged significantly from those obtained with human subjects. In the latter case, the back pressure fluctuation was considerably higher and the BRF measured for each subject coincided with the frequency associated their respective vocal tract acousto-mechanical resonance.

CONCLUSIONS

Results indicate that the BRF is essentially driven by the acousto-mechanical resonance of the vocal tract. Furthermore, the substantial increase on the amplitude of the oscillatory component of the back pressure suggests a strong feedback loop between the source of pressure (bubble release mechanism) and the resonator (vocal tract). The high-pressure fluctuations within the oral cavity implies that subjects need a considerable extra effort to adjust their vocal tract in order to achieve an adequate impedance match between vocal folds and vocal tractsd to produce voice.

The effects of vocal tract constrictions on aerodynamic measures in a synthetic vocal fold model

According to nonlinear source-filter theory, as the strength of the coupling between the source and filter increases, typically by a decrease in the vocal tract cross-sectional area, the resultant increase in the inertance of the vocal tract yields an increase in the interactions between acoustic pressures within the vocal tract and the changing glottal airflow and/or the vibratory pattern of the vocal folds as noted in Titze [(2008). J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 123(4), 1902-1915]. The purpose of the current research was to examine the effects of parametric vocal tract constrictions mimicking epilaryngeal tube and lip narrowing on aerodynamic measures in a dynamic self-oscillating physical model of the vocal folds and vocal tract. Multilayered silicone vocal fold models were created based on Murray and Thomson [(2011). J. Visualized Exp. 58, e3498] and Murray and Thomson [(2012). J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 132(5), 3428-3438] and mounted to a simple synthetic trachea and supraglottal vocal tract model. Four constriction cross-sectional areas were examined at two locations (i.e., at the epilarynx and lip regions). Phonation threshold pressure and flow were measured at phonation onset and offset using four M5-CONV vocal fold models. Results indicated that both constriction magnitude and location are relevant factors in determining glottal aerodynamics. In general, a narrow epilarynx tube or lip constriction resulted in the lowest onset pressures and airflows while the no vocal tract condition resulted in the highest onset pressures and airflows.

High-Speed Image Analysis Comparing Loading of Vocal Folds During Coughing and Phonation: A Case Study

PURPOSE

Coughing is related to voice problems, since it involves firm glottal closure, fast glottal opening, and high subglottic pressure and flow rate. In this study, the glottal area variation and movements of laryngeal structures during coughing and phonation are compared.

METHODS

High-speed laryngoscopy recordings were made of a normophonic male participant with a healthy larynx producing a neutral vowel and coughing. Oral air pressure was registered in a mouthpiece, through which an endoscope was inserted into the pharynx. Electroglottography, acoustic, and pressure signals were recorded simultaneously. The glottal width variation at the membranous and cartilaginous parts of the glottis was derived from the high-speed images, and the strong vibration of the false vocal folds was also registered.

RESULTS

In coughing, compared to ordinary vowel phonation in nearly the same sound pressure level (93-94 dB_6cm), the glottal width was 25% larger at the middle of the vocal folds, the maximum glottal opening velocity was 39% higher, and the maximum glottal width declination rate during glottal closing was up to three times higher. The maximum acceleration was 40% higher, and the maximum deceleration was 47% higher. Fundamental frequency f₀ was the highest (ca. 400 Hz) at the beginning of the first phase of a typical coughing process. During the last part of the coughing process, f₀ decreased from ca. 250 Hz to ca. 85 Hz at the phonation offset.

CONCLUSIONS

The remarkable increase in maximum glottal width declination rate implies much higher vocal fold loading in coughing compared to phonation.

Do Flexible Silicone Tubes Immersed in Water Combined With Vocalise Improve the Immediate Effect on Voice?

PURPOSE

This study aimed to analyze the immediate effect on a singer's voice of a flexible silicone tube immersed in water combined with ascending and descending vocalise scales compared with ascending and descending vocalise scales alone.

METHOD

A pre- and post-intervention quasi-experimental study was conducted. Thirty adult singers between 18 and 45 years old with no laryngeal disorders performed the two techniques for 3 min each on different days. Acoustic measurements of frequency, jitter, shimmer, glottal-to-noise excitation ratio, noise, smoothed cepstral peak prominence (CPPS), maximum phonation time (MPT), voice range profile, and self-perceived vocal effort (Borg Category Ratio 10-BR Scale adapted for vocal effort) were assessed before and after performing the techniques.

RESULTS

The results indicated an increase in singers' CPPS and MPT values and a decrease in shimmer and noise when performing with a flexible silicone tube immersed in water combined with vocalise. The singers reported a perception of decreased vocal effort after both methods. However, the diminished perceived vocal effort became more pronounced with the tube phonation technique combined with vocalise.

CONCLUSIONS

Phonation in tubes combined with vocalise improved the vocal acoustic parameters (including cepstral measurements), increased MPT, and diminished perceived vocal effort. Although using vocalise alone diminished perceived vocal effort, this decrease was more pronounced in the tube phonation technique combined with vocalise.

Multidimensional voice assessment: the immediate effects of Lax Vox® in singers with voice complaints

ABSTRACT Purpose: to multidimensionally assess the effect of the Lax Vox® vocal technique on singers with voice complaints. Methods: a comparative intrasubject study that assessed 30 singers - 13 males and 17 females, aged 18 to 55 years - who self-reported voice complaints and had voice problems symptoms. The participants were submitted to voice assessment with perceptive-auditory, acoustic, aerodynamic, and electroglottographic voice analysis, as well as laryngeal assessment with high-speed videolaryngoscopy. The participants were assessed at two moments: 1) at the beginning of the data collection; and 2) five minutes after performing the Lax Vox® vocal technique. The groups were compared with appropriate statistical tests, with a 5% significance level. Results: in the acoustic analysis, there was an increase in the fundamental frequency for males, after using the Lax Vox® vocal technique. In the aerodynamic assessment, there was an increase in the airflow mean values during vocalization, as well as in aerodynamic power after using the Lax Vox® vocal technique in both groups. Conclusion: the Lax Vox® vocal technique, in the studied singers with a complaint of dysphonia, promoted an increase in the fundamental frequency, for males. In the aerodynamic parameters, in both sexes, it promoted an increase in the airflow and aerodynamic power.

Immediate effects of water resistance therapy on patients with vocal fold mass lesions

Introduction

Semi-occluded vocal tract exercises, such as water resistance therapy (WRT), are widely used in voice therapy. However, the potential positive effects of such a therapy on vocal fold oscillation patterns in patients indicating a need for phonomicrosurgery have not yet been explored. The presented study aims to analyze the effect of WRT in patients suffering from vocal fold mass lesions.

Materials and methods

Eight participants with vocal fold mass lesions were asked to sustain a phonation on the vowel /i/ at a comfortable loudness and a fundamental frequency of 250 Hz (females) or 125 Hz (males). During phonation the subjects were simultaneously recorded with transnasal high-speed videoendoscopy (HSV, 20.000 fps), electroglottography, and audio signals. These subjects then performed a WRT (phonation in a silicone tube of 30 cm length, 5 cm below the water surface) for 10 min. Repeated measurements of sustained phonation were performed 0, 10, and 30 min after exercising. From the HSV data the glottal area waveform (GAW) was segmented and GAW parameters were computed.

Results

During WRT there was an increase of the GAW related open quotient and closing quotient. Immediately after WRT, there was a drop of both values followed by a rise of these parameters up to 30 min after the intervention. Furthermore, there was no correlation between GAW and electroglottographical open quotients.

Conclusions

The effects observed after a single session of WRT on participants with vocal fold mass lesions showed a similar pattern to vocal fatigue.

Applicability of Resonance Tube Phonation in Water for Semi-Occluded Vocal Tract Voice Training and Therapy

BACKGROUND

Exercises involving tube phonation in water (TPW) have emerged as an alternative to conventional voice therapy techniques. The objective was to determine whether the results of these techniques were comparable to each other for the treatment of voice pathology, as well as to compare the costs implicated in the delivery of each treatment.

METHODS

A retrospective, descriptive, and observational study was performed that included all patients evaluated in our voice unit in 2015 who received vocal rehabilitation treatments. They were divided into two groups depending on the treatment technique used. The patients' voice was evaluated subjectively using the GRBAS scale. We compared the clinical results and the specific costs of each technique.

RESULTS

A total of 55 patients were studied, of which 28 followed TPW exercises, and 27 underwent supervised vocal rehabilitation (SVR). Most of the patients who received TPW therapy were diagnosed with functional dysphonia, whereas functional-organic dysphonia was the most common pathology in the SVR group. Significant differences were evident when the total GRBAS scores were compared before and after the treatments, yet not when the GRBAS scores were compared between the two rehabilitation techniques. The incremental cost-effectiveness analysis revealed that TPW was less expensive than SVR, with both techniques proving to be equally effective in improving the pathological problems.

CONCLUSIONS

TPW is similarly effective as SVR techniques in treating voice pathologies, yet it is significantly cheaper in terms of healthcare costs.