Calciphylaxis in Patients With Normal Renal Function: A Case Series and Systematic Review

New therapeutic perspectives for vascular and valvular calcifications in chronic kidney disease

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Vascular and valvular calcification are associated with cardiovascular morbidity and mortality in people with chronic kidney disease (CKD). Uncertainty exists regarding therapeutic strategies to attenuate calcification. This review outlines the pathophysiological mechanisms contributing to vascular and valvular calcification, considers the mechanisms of action of therapeutic interventions, and reports the latest outcomes from interventional studies.

RECENT FINDINGS

Conventional therapies targeted at CKD-mineral and bone disorder (MBD) modulation have yielded conflicting or inconclusive results. Magnesium and vitamin K supplementation appear to offer attenuation of coronary artery calcification but inconsistent findings justify the need for further studies. Strategies targeting hydroxyapatite formation such as sodium thiosulphate and hexasodium fytate show promise and are worthy of further evaluation. The serum calcification propensity assay (T50) correlates with severity and progression; it holds promise as a potential future clinical tool for screening monitoring calcification risk.

SUMMARY

Whilst knowledge of the pathophysiology of vascular calcification has grown and therapeutic approaches appear promising, as yet no medication has been approved to treat vascular or valvular calcification, or calciphylaxis.

Non-chronic kidney disease-induced calciphylaxis: a rare case report

Calciphylaxis is a disorder causing ischemic skin necrosis, typically associated with end-stage renal disease or those receiving dialysis. Occurrence is rare in those without end-stage renal disease, and treatment options are limited. This case report describes a patient with calciphylaxis without end-stage renal disease or history of dialysis. Treatment with sodium thiosulfate, a first line option, had to be stopped due to metabolic derangements, limiting the healing process. Diagnosis and treatment of this rare disorder are important to prevent further complications that may result.

Calciphylaxis during the course of psoriatic arthritis patient. Is it coincidence? A case report

Introduction and importance

Calciphylaxis manifests clinically by skin ischemia and necrosis and histologically by calcification of dermal arterioles. Usually, it occurs in patients with end-stage renal disease on dialysis or in patients who had a kidney transplant. Here, the authors present a case of calciphylaxis occurring in a patient with psoriasis and psoriatic arthritis.

Case presentation

A 66-year-old Syrian male with a history of psoriatic arthritis presented for evaluation of 2-month nonpainful ulcers on his feet and hands that were treated with warfarin. Biopsies confirmed the diagnosis of calciphylaxis. The patient received sodium thiosulfate, zoledronic acid, intralesional sodium thiosulfate injections, and an intravenous infusion of vitamin K with dramatic improvement. At the 3-month follow-up, his wounds had been completely remitted.

Discussion

Nonuremic calciphylaxis occurs in many cases, like vitamin D administration, vitamin K antagonists' administration, chronic inflammation, and others. The association between calciphylaxis and psoriasis was reported only in four cases in the literature; meanwhile, this was the first case that described calciphylaxis in the setting of psoriatic arthritis.

Conclusion

A suspicion of calciphylaxis should be maintained in patients with underlying inflammatory mechanism diseases.

Refractory wounds induced by normal-renal calciphylaxis: An under-recognised calcific arteriolopathy

BACKGROUND

Normal-renal calciphylaxis (NRC) is a devastating calcific vasculopathy characterised by refractory wounds. It is more likely to be misdiagnosed because of the absence of renal insufficiency. Failure to effectively control may lead to rapid deterioration and ultimately death. However, current knowledge of it is still inadequate.

OBJECTIVES

To provide a relatively comprehensive review of NRC.

METHODS

Nine electronic medical databases including PubMed, Web of Science, Embase, the Cochrane Library and so on were searched from inception to April 1, 2022. Articles in which calciphylaxis was diagnosed in patients with normal renal function were included.

RESULTS

Totally 140 articles were retrieved with 187 patients (median age, 62 years [IQR, 49.63 ~ 75.70 years]; 83.42% female; 84.5% Caucasian). Vitamin K antagonism (43.32%) and diabetes (39.57%) accounted for most of the concomitant factors. Cutaneous presentations were the most common. Pathological confirmation was made in 97.86% of patients with an accuracy of 99.45%. Multidisciplinary therapeutic strategies were usually implemented while the final prognosis was not ideal, with a 6-month mortality rate of 21.10% and a 1-year mortality rate of 27.52%.

CONCLUSION

NRC is an under-recognised disease caused by a variety of factors; meanwhile, multidisciplinary efforts are required to inform diagnostic and therapeutic decisions.

Perioperative Management of Calciphylaxis: Literature Review and Treatment Recommendations

Calciphylaxis is a serious and rare medical condition that leads to substantial clinical manifestations including pain, creating perioperative and treatment challenges. No standard treatment protocol exists nor are comprehensive guidelines available for perioperative management of patients with calciphylaxis. In this review, we evaluate existing literature (January 2000 to May 2021) with the aim to offer guidance for treating patients with this challenging disease through the perioperative period. Although no therapies are currently considered standard for treating calciphylaxis, multiple interventions are available for improving symptoms. Preoperative and intraoperative management involves monitoring and optimizing patient comorbid conditions and any possible electrolyte imbalances. Postoperative management can be challenging when potential calciphylaxis triggers are indicated, such as warfarin and corticosteroids. In addition, poor wound healing and difficult pain control are common. Therefore, a multifactorial approach to controlling postoperative pain is recommended that includes the use of nerve blocks, renal-sparing opioids, benzodiazepines, and/or ketamine. We present preoperative, intraoperative, and postoperative recommendations for treating calciphylaxis with levels of evidence when appropriate.

Calciphylaxis: Part I. Diagnosis and pathology

Calciphylaxis is an uncommon but devastating disorder characterized by vascular calcification and subsequent cutaneous tissue necrosis. This results in exquisitely painful and slow healing wounds that portend exceptionally high morbidity and mortality. The diagnosis of this condition can be complicated because there are no conclusive serologic, radiographic or visual signs that this disease is manifesting. The differential of tissue necrosis is broad, and identifying calciphylaxis requires an adroit understanding of the risk factors and physical signs that should raise suspicion of this condition. Reviews on this subject are uncommon and lack directed commentary from disease experts on the best diagnostic approach for patients suffering from this disease. The goal of this article is to update practicing dermatologists on the current standard of care for calciphylaxis.

Chronic inflammation and calciphylaxis

Calciphylaxis also known as calcific uraemic arteriolopathy is a rare condition mostly seen in patients with end-stage kidney disease. We report a case of a simultaneous-kidney-pancreas transplant patient with functioning grafts developing biopsy-proven calciphylaxis in the setting of chronic inflammation. Despite several modalities of management, the patient developed progression of her disease leading to multiple amputations. This case illustrates chronic inflammation driven by persistent infection as a probable contributing factor to the development and progression of calciphylaxis in a simultaneous kidney-pancreas recipient. Calciphylaxis should be considered in the differential for a painful, non-healing ulcer even in the absence of common risk factors.

Calciphylaxis after Kidney Transplantation: a rare but life-threatening disorder

Calciphylaxis is a rare disorder characterized by vascular calcification and thrombosis of the subcutaneous microcirculation, leading to painful necrotic skin lesions and bearing a dreadfully high mortality rate. This syndrome is frequently also termed uraemic calcific arteriolopathy, since most cases are observed in patients with kidney failure. However, it is increasingly clear that calciphylaxis may also affect patients with normal or only slightly impaired renal function, including kidney transplant recipients. A precise definition of the characteristics and risk factors of calciphylaxis developing after kidney transplantation has been hindered by the extreme rarity of this condition, which also hampered the development of effective therapeutic strategies. In the present issue of CKJ, Guillén and colleagues report the largest case series of calciphylaxis in kidney transplant recipients to date, outlining several features that are apparently specific to this population. In this editorial, we briefly present the epidemiology and pathogenesis of calciphylaxis in different patient populations and discuss recent findings for its therapeutic management.

Nonuremic Calciphylaxis Associated With Hypercalcemia and Rheumatologic Diseases

Calcific uremic arteriolopathy, termed calciphylaxis, was previously considered a condition that developed mostly in patients requiring dialysis. It has now been described in kidney transplant patients, in advanced chronic kidney disease (CKD) patients not requiring dialysis, and in individuals with maintained kidney function. We describe an individual with CKD stage 3b with hypercalcemia who presented with features highly specific for calciphylaxis based on results of a skin biopsy. The condition has high morbidity and mortality, and thus prompts immediate cessation of the offending agents or treatment of the cause. The following case and literature review demonstrates a need for a detailed assessment of patients’ risks and exposures and expanding the differential diagnosis to include calciphylaxis in nonuremic patients with necrotic ulcers with a plan for early imaging and possible biopsy.

Non-Uremic Calciphylaxis: An Unexpected Complication With Recombinant Human Parathyroid Hormone

Calciphylaxis is a rare syndrome of calcific microvascular occlusion, whereas non-uremic calciphylaxis (NUC) is a subset of this disease in which renal impairment is not observed. Recombinant human parathyroid hormone (rhPTH) (1-84) is a medication approved for the management of hypocalcemia in patients with hypoparathyroidism. We present a case report of a 38-year-old woman with postoperative hypoparathyroidism treated with rhPTH who subsequently developed calciphylactic lesions on her abdomen. Multidisciplinary interventions included intravenous and intralesional sodium thiosulfate therapy, laboratory monitoring, dermatological wound care, and pain management. Calciphylaxis can rarely be precipitated by rhPTH due to its effect on calcium and phosphorus balance even in the setting of normal renal function. The use of calcium and calcitriol supplementation, complicated by factors such as female sex and obesity, may have contributed in this patient’s case. Hence, regular follow-up with tapering off of calcium and calcitriol supplementation is important in patients receiving rhPTH.

Calciphylaxis: Risk Factors and Histologic Findings in a Case Series From a Tertiary Care Referral Hospital

Recent years have seen important advances in our understanding of calciphylaxis, especially regarding newly identified risk factors and histologic findings that may aid diagnosis. This retrospective study of cases of calciphylaxis treated in our hospital in the last 13 years focuses on newly revealed aspects of this disease. We describe 16 patients (62.5% women; mean age, 67.9 years). In addition to advanced kidney disease (in 75% of our patients), other factors associated with the presence of calciphylaxis were a history of treatments related to phosphorus and calcium metabolism (75%) and anticoagulation (62.5%), usually with vitamin-K antagonists. Histology showed alterations in elastic fibers in only 25% of the biopsy specimens. Eleven of the patients died: sepsis was most often the cause.

Beneficial Effects of Amnion-Chorion Stem Cell Grafting in the Long Term Management of Nonuremic Calciphylaxis Wounds

Calciphylaxis is a poorly understood disease with high morbidity and mortality. The current primary literature on treatment is lacking; however, disease management often involves a multifaceted approach with a primary focus on consistent wound care. This report describes a case outlining the long-term management of nonuremic calciphylaxis wounds in a patient with severe malnutrition with the use of human amniotic membrane grafts, aggressive surgical debridement, nutritional therapy, and advanced wound healing techniques. A 38-year-old African American female with a history of non-uremic calciphylaxis presented from a transitional facility with numerous non-healing wounds in the setting of severe malnutrition secondary to bariatric surgery. Biweekly wound debridement was initiated utilizing an amniotic stem cell skin graft, dry applicable absorbent dressing, high-frequency ultrasonic ablation, and wound vacuum-assisted closure (VAC) over the course of approximately nine months. Nutritional supplementation was given in the form of jejunostomy tube feed due to a gastric bypass and a perforated viscus. At the current date, the patient demonstrates significant improvement in pain and wound healing. The patient is also able to ambulate with care and has begun steps towards independent management of wounds. Future goals of care include independent bedside wound management, placement of allograft, and discharge to a long-term care facility. Most patients with refractory pain, widespread necrotic wounds, and dangerous comorbidities will inevitably be referred to palliative care. This case creates a framework for the long term management of medically complex patients with nonuremic calciphylaxis using human amniotic membrane stem cell grafts and appropriate advanced wound care techniques. 

Management of Cutaneous Calciphylaxis

Calciphylaxis is a deadly, painful disease with a 1-year mortality of up to 50%. The disease is commonly associated with patients with end-stage kidney disease (ESKD), but it can manifest in non-uremic patients as well. In patients who are undergoing dialysis, the incidence of calciphylaxis can range from 0.04% to 4%. The progressive arterial calcification seen in calciphylaxis can affect multiple body organs, including the skin, brain, lungs, and muscle. In cutaneous calciphylaxis, painful and non-healing nodules, plaques, and ulcers may appear, increasing morbidity for patients. Diagnosis can be difficult, and the condition can clinically appear similar to other dermatological diseases, especially in non-uremic patients. Currently, skin biopsy with histological analysis is the most reliable method to help diagnose the condition. In certain cases, the use of medical imaging may be helpful. Treatment of pain in this condition can be difficult and should be multimodal and include wound care as well as modification of risk factors. Analgesic options include opioids, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), as well as analgesic options that are targeted for specific patients. There are currently multiple clinical trials underway that are studying targeted therapies for this condition.

Assessment of outcomes of calciphylaxis

BACKGROUND

Calciphylaxis is a rare thrombotic vasculopathy characterized by high morbidity and mortality. There is a paucity of studies examining longitudinal outcomes.

OBJECTIVE

To assess mortality, days spent in the hospital, and amputations in patients with calciphylaxis.

METHODS

A retrospective medical record review was conducted in 145 patients diagnosed with calciphylaxis at an urban tertiary care hospital from January 2006 to December 2018.

RESULTS

Six-month mortality was 37.2%, and 1-year mortality was 44.1%. Patients with nephrogenic calciphylaxis had worse survival than those with nonnephrogenic calciphylaxis (P = .007). This difference in survival disappeared when limiting mortality to deaths due to calciphylaxis. Age (P = .003) and end-stage renal disease (P = .01) were risk factors associated with 1-year mortality. Diabetes mellitus was associated with greater total hospitalization days (coefficient, 1.1; 95% confidence interval, 1.01-1.4); bedside debridement was associated with fewer hospitalization days (coefficient, 0.8; 95% confidence interval, 0.7-0.9). Amputations were not associated with any of the examined risk factors. The use of warfarin followed by a transition to nonwarfarin anticoagulation was associated with decreased hazard of death (P = .01).

LIMITATIONS

Retrospective nature.

CONCLUSIONS

Calciphylaxis remains a complex, heterogeneous disease. Mortality is lower in patients with nonnephrogenic disease. These findings may be incorporated during discussions regarding the goals of care to facilitate informed shared decision making.

Calciphylaxis epidemiology, risk factors, treatment and survival among French chronic kidney disease patients: a case-control study

Background

Calcific Uremic Arteriolopathy (CUA) is a rare disease, causing painful skin ulcers in patients with end stage renal disease. Recommendations for CUA management and treatment are lacking.

Methods

We conducted a retrospective cohort study on CUA cases identified in western France, in order to describe its management and outcome in average clinical practices. Selection was based on the Hayashi diagnosis criteria (2013) extended to patients with eGFR < 30 mL/min/1.73m². Dialyzed CUA cases were compared with 2 controls, matched for age, gender, region of treatment and time period.

Results

Eighty-nine CUA cases were identified between 2006 and 2016, including 19 non dialyzed and 70 dialyzed patients. Females with obesity (55.1%) were predominant. Bone mineral disease abnormalities, inflammation and malnutrition (weight loss, serum albumin decrease) preceded CUA onset for 6 months. The multimodal treatment strategy included wound care (98.9%), antibiotherapy (77.5%), discontinuation of Vitamin K antagonists (VKA) (70.8%) and intravenous sodium thiosulfate (65.2%). 40.4% of the patients died within the year after lesion onset, mainly under palliative care. Surgical debridement, distal CUA, localization to the lower limbs and non calcium-based phosphate binders were associated with better survival. Risks factors of developing CUA among dialysis patients were obesity, VKA, weight loss, serum albumin decrease or high serum phosphate in the 6 months before lesion onset.

Conclusion

CUA involved mainly obese patients under VKA. Malnutrition and inflammation preceded the onset of skin lesions and could be warning signs among dialysis patients at risk.

Trial registration

ClinicalTrials.gov identifier NCT02854046, registered August 3, 2016.

Common and critical inflammatory dermatoses every pathologist should know

Inflammatory dermatopathology remains a challenging area for surgical pathologists. Yet every surgical pathologist encounters inflammatory dermatoses as part of routine practice. This review will focus on selected diagnoses that are either commonly encountered in the routine practice of surgical pathology or are critically important. The following entities will be covered: spongiotic dermatoses, lichen simplex chronicus, and early lichen sclerosus in the setting of vulvar biopsies, as well as graft versus host disease, Stevens-Johnson syndrome/toxic epidermal necrolysis, granuloma anulare, pyoderma gangrenosum, and calciphylaxis. Practical points and key histologic features will be emphasized.

Calciphylaxis: Approach to Diagnosis and Management

Calciphylaxis is a rare disorder of poor prognosis that can lead to intense, painful lesions involving the skin and subcutaneous tissue. Although mostly described in dialysis patients, it can affect patients with normal kidney function. The diagnosis of calciphylaxis is complicated by the absence of a gold standard marker of disease such as a clear histopathological finding. Late diagnosis and advanced lesions can significantly shorten life expectancy. Calciphylaxis wounds can have a major influence on the quality of life of patients, usually due to the immense unbearable pain these patients suffer from. The management of calciphylaxis mainly comprises aggressive wound care and symptomatic management. Therapeutic options are few and far between and are limited to off-label uses. Recent understanding of the pathogenesis of lesions has enabled development of novel therapeutic options, some of which are being studied in clinical trials (sodium thiosulfate, vitamin K). Vascular calcification and thrombosis underlie development of these lesions and research has been aimed at studying drugs that counteract such processes. Future research is required to establish clear causal pathways and improve on the treatment options currently available to patients.

Correlation between clinical and pathological features of cutaneous calciphylaxis

Calciphylaxis is a rare and life-threatening disease that classically manifests with painful skin lesions. It occurs mainly in patients with end-stage renal disease (ESRD) treated with dialysis, has poor outcomes, and has no FDA-approved treatment. Our cohort study aims to examine the clinical and pathological features of calciphylaxis and investigates the correlation between cutaneous clinical manifestations and histopathological findings. Data from 70 calciphylaxis patients who were evaluated at the Massachusetts General Hospital between January 2014 and April 2018 were collected from the institutional electronic database. The median age was 58 years (interquartile range [IQR]: 49–69 years), 60% were women, and 73% were of white race. Most (74%) patients reported severe pain at the time of calciphylaxis diagnosis with a median pain intensity score of 8/10 (IQR: 6–10) on a 0–10 pain scale. The median time from symptom onset to clinical diagnosis was 9 weeks (IQR: 6–16 weeks). The majority (87%) of patients presented with open necrotic wounds (advanced stage lesion) at the time of diagnosis. Common cutaneous clinical features included ulceration (79%), induration (57%), and erythema (41%), while common pathological features included cutaneous microvascular calcification (86%) and necrosis (73%). The presence of fibrin thrombi in skin biopsies was associated with pain severity (p = 0.04). The stage of a skin lesion positively correlated with the presence of necrosis on histological analyses (p = 0.02). These findings have implications for improving understanding of calciphylaxis origins and for developing novel treatments.

Review: update on the management of calciphylaxis

Calciphylaxis is a disease of significant morbidity and mortality, predominantly affecting dialysis patients. The term 'calciphylaxis' was coined by Seyle et al. in 1961 to describe calcium deposition in the skin and subcutaneous soft tissue of uremic rats in response to 'triggers' (e.g. trauma, metallic salts) after exposure to 'sensitizing agents' (e.g. vitamin D and parathyroid hormone). In humans, calciphylaxis, however, is not a disorder of induced hypersensitivity. Instead, it is a disorder of cutaneous microvascular occlusion caused by thrombosis and calcification. Progressive, excruciatingly painful, non-healing wounds develop in these patients, pre-disposing them to high risk of sepsis and death. Calciphylaxis has no approved therapies. Increased awareness and research in this field have facilitated identification of risk factors and causation pathways. Development of therapeutic options and wound care management, however, are still at a nascent stage. Certain therapies have shown a promise that needs evaluation in prospective clinical trials. It is hoped that ongoing research will help us better understand the pathogenesis of this complex disease and develop efficacious treatment options. In this review, we outline the components involved in calciphylaxis diagnosis and treatment.