Organic fouling control through magnetic ion exchange‐nanofiltration (MIEX‐NF) in water treatment

Removal of strontium by nanofiltration: Role of complexation and speciation of strontium with organic matter

Strontium (Sr) removal from water is required because excessive naturally occurring Sr exposure is hazardous to human health. Climate and seasonal changes cause water quality variations, in particular quality and quantity of organic matter (OM) and pH, and such variations affect Sr removal by nanofiltration (NF). The mechanisms for such variations are not clear and thus OM complexation and speciation require attention. Sr removal by NF was investigated with emphasis on the role of OM (type and concentration) and pH (2-12) on possible removal mechanisms, specifically size and/or charge exclusion as well as solute-solute interactions. The filtration results show that the addition of various OM (10 types) and an increase of OM concentration (2-100 mgC.L-1) increased Sr removal by 10-15%. The Sr-OM interaction was enhanced with increasing OM concentration, implying enhanced size exclusion via Sr-OM interaction as the main mechanism. Such interactions were quantified by asymmetric flow field-flow fractionation (FFFF) coupled with an inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer (ICP-MS). Both extremely low and high pH increased Sr removal due to the enhanced charge exclusion and Sr-OM interactions. This work elucidated and verified the mechanism of OM and pH on Sr removal by NF membranes.

Chromium (III) and chromium (VI) removal and organic matter interaction with nanofiltration

Chromium (Cr) is a toxic inorganic contaminant for drinking water, in which the concentration has to be controlled for human health and safety. Cr retention was investigated with stirred cell experiments using sulphonated polyethersulfone nanofiltration (NF) membranes of different molecular weight cut-off (MWCO). Cr(III) and Cr(VI) retention follow the order of the MWCO of the studied NF membranes; HY70-720 Da > HY50-1000 Da > HY10-3000 Da with a pH dependency, especially for Cr(III). The importance of the charge exclusion was highlighted when Cr(OH)₄^- (for Cr(III)) and CrO₄^2- (for Cr(VI)) was the predominant species in the feed solution. In presence of organic matter, namely humic acid (HA), Cr(III) retention increased by 60 %, while no influence of HA was observed for Cr(VI). HA did not induce major modifications on the membrane surface charge for these membranes. Solute-solute interaction, in particular Cr(III)-HA complexation, was the responsible mechanism for the increase in Cr(III) retention. This was confirmed by asymmetric flow field-flow fractionation, coupled with inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (FFFF-ICP-MS) analysis. Cr(III)-HA complexation was significant at HA concentrations as low as 1 mgC/L. The chosen NF membranes were able to achieve the EU guideline (25 μg/L) for Cr in drinking water for a feed concentration of 250 μg/L.

Existing Filtration Treatment on Drinking Water Process and Concerns Issues

Water is one of the main sources of life's survival. It is mandatory to have good-quality water, especially for drinking. Many types of available filtration treatment can produce high-quality drinking water. As a result, it is intriguing to determine which treatment is the best. This paper provides a review of available filtration technology specifically for drinking water treatment, including both conventional and advanced treatments, while focusing on membrane filtration treatment. This review covers the concerns that usually exist in membrane filtration treatment, namely membrane fouling. Here, the parameters that influence fouling are identified. This paper also discusses the different ways to handle fouling, either based on prevention, prediction, or control automation. According to the findings, the most common treatment for fouling was prevention. However, this treatment required the use of chemical agents, which will eventually affect human health. The prediction process was usually used to circumvent the process of fouling development. Based on our reviews up to now, there are a limited number of researchers who study membrane fouling control based on automation. Frequently, the treatment method and control strategy are determined individually.

A review of long-term change in surface water natural organic matter concentration in the northern hemisphere and the implications for drinking water treatment

Reduced atmospheric acid deposition has given rise to recovery from acidification - defined as increasing pH, acid neutralization capacity (ANC), or alkalinity in surface waters. Strong evidence of recovery has been reported across North America and Europe, driving chemical responses. The primary chemical responses identified in this review were increasing concentration and changing character of natural organic matter (NOM) towards predominantly hydrophobic nature. The concentration of NOM also influenced trace metal cycling as many browning surface waters also reported increases in Fe and Al. Further, climate change and other factors (e.g., changing land use) act in concert with reductions in atmospheric deposition to contribute to widespread browning and will have a more pronounced effect as deposition stabilizes. The observed water quality trends have presented challenges for drinking water treatment (e.g., increased chemical dosing, poor filter operations, formation of disinfection by-products) and many facilities may be under designed as a result. This comprehensive review has identified key research areas to be addressed, including 1) a need for comprehensive monitoring programs (e.g., larger timescales; consistency in measurements) to assess climate change impacts on recovery responses and NOM dynamics, and 2) a better understanding of drinking water treatment vulnerabilities and the transition towards robust treatment technologies and solutions that can adapt to climate change and other drivers of changing water quality.

Application of magnetic carbon nanocomposite from agro-waste for the removal of pollutants from water and wastewater

Water pollution has significant impact on water usage, and various contaminants, such as organic and inorganic compounds, heavy metals, dyes, pharmaceuticals compounds, pathogens and radioactive compounds, are implicated. The quest for globalisation, structural developments and other related anthropogenic activities promote the release of contaminants that induce water pollution. Hence, treatment and remediation options that can remove pollutants from watercourses and wastewater have been developed. Applied nanotechnology using carbon nanocomposites has recently drawn attention because it has the advantages of low preparation cost, high surface area, pore volume and environmental stability. Magnetic carbon nanocomposites usually exhibit excellent performance in adsorbing contaminants from aqueous solutions, and thus expanding the use of nanotechnology in water treatment is of great importance. Therefore, this review explores the geographical outlook of water pollution, sources of water pollution and types of contaminants found in water and discusses the use of carbon nanocomposites as an emerging sustainable technology for water pollutant removal. The various properties of carbon-based composites influence the extent of pollutant adsorption during water treatment processes. Most carbon-based nanocomposites are generated from biomass produced by agro-waste materials. Magnetic activated carbon nanocomposites produced from walnut shells and rice husk waste can remove 78% of Cd(II) from contaminated aqueous systems. Magnetic nanocomposites from peanut shell, tea waste, curcumin nanoparticles, sunflower head waste, rice husk, hydrophyte biomass, palm waste and sugarcane bagasse facilitate hydrothermal carbonisation, chemical precipitation, co-precipitation, chemical activation, calcination and fast pyrolysis. These nanocomposites have benefitted wastewater treatment by increasing efficiency in removing pharmaceutical, dye and organic contaminants, such as promazine, ciprofloxacin, amoxicillin, rhodamine 6G, methyl blue, phenol and phenanthrene. Hence, this review discusses the relatively low costs, good biocompatibility, large surface-to-volume ratio, magnetic separation capability and reusability carbon materials and highlights the advantages of using magnetic carbon nanocomposites in the removal of contaminants from water or wastewater through adsorption mechanisms.

Renewable energy powered membrane technology: Implications of adhesive interaction between membrane and organic matter on spontaneous osmotic backwash cleaning

Organic matter (OM) in surface and ground waters may cause membrane fouling that is laborious to clean once established. Spontaneous osmotic backwash (OB) induced by solar irradiance fluctuation has been demonstrated for early mineral scaling/organic fouling control in decentralised small-scale photovoltaic powered-nanofiltration/reverse osmosis (PV-NF/RO) membrane systems. However, various OM types will interact differently with membranes which in turn affects the effectiveness of OB. This work evaluates the suitability of spontaneous OB cleaning for eleven OM types (covering low-molecular-weight organics (LMWO), humic substances, polyphenolic compounds and biopolymers) regarding adhesive interactions with NF/RO membranes. The adhesive interactions were quantified by an asymmetric flow field-flow fractionation coupled with an organic carbon detector (FFFF-OCD). The underlying mechanism of OM-membrane adhesive interactions affecting OB cleaning was elucidated. The results indicate that humic acid (a typical humic substance) and tannic acid (a typical polyphenolic compound) induced stronger adhesive interaction with NF/RO membranes than biopolymers and LMWO. When the mass loss of an OM due to adhesion was below a critical range, the spontaneous OB is most effective (>85% flux recovery); and above this range, the OB becomes ineffective (<50% flux recovery). Polyphenolic compounds and humic substances resulted in lower OB cleaning efficiency, due to their higher aromatic content, enhancing hydrophobic interactions and hydrogen bonding. Calcium-facilitated adhesion of some OM types (such as humic substances, polyphenolics and biopolymers) increased irreversible organic fouling potential and weakened OB cleaning, which was verified by both FFFF-OCD and membrane filtration results. This work provides a guidance to formulate strategies to enhance spontaneous OB cleaning, such as first identifying the adhesion of OM in feedwater (surface and ground waters) using FFFF-OCD, and then removing "sticky" OM using suitable pre-treatment processes.

Selenium species removal by nanofiltration: Determination of retention mechanisms

Selenium (Se) is a dissolved oxyanion drinking water contaminant requiring appropriate removal technologies. The removal of selenite (Se^IV) and selenite (Se^VI) with nanofiltration (NF) was investigated with an emphasis on the role of Se speciation and membrane charge screening on the retention mechanisms. The pH (2 to 12) showed strong pH dependence of Se retention, which was due to the speciation. No significant impact of salinity was observed by increasing NaCl concentration from 0.58 to 20 g/L. Application of the Donnan steric pore partitioning model with dielectric exclusion (DSPM-DE) showed that Donnan exclusion was the dominant retention mechanism for the oxyanions Se species. Nine different organic matter (OM) types were investigated at 10 mgC/L to determine if OM affects Se retention. Only OM characterised by negatively charged fractions, such as humic acid (HA), enhanced Se retention with NF270 of up to 20% for Se^IV and 10% for Se^VI. This was explained by enhanced Donnan exclusion. NF270 was effective in removing Se from real water (Gahard groundwater, Ille et Vilaine, France). The EU guideline (20 μg/L) of Se in drinking water was achieved with comparable performance to OM-free experiments using synthetic waters.

Enthalpic and Entropic Selectivity of Water and Small Ions in Polyamide Membranes

While polyamide reverse osmosis and nanofiltration membranes have been extensively utilized in water purification and desalination processes, the molecular details governing water and solute permeation in these membranes are not fully understood. In this study, we apply transition-state theory for transmembrane permeation to systematically break down the intrinsic permeabilities of water and small ions in loose and tight polyamide nanofiltration membranes into enthalpic and entropic components using an Eyring-type equation. We analyze trends in these components to elucidate molecular phenomena that induce water-salt, monovalent-divalent, and monovalent-monovalent selectivity at different pH values. Our results suggest that in pores that are either too small or contain an electrostatically repelling mouth, the thermal activation of ions in the form of ion dehydration is less likely, promoting entropically driven selectivity with steric exclusion of hydrated ions. Instead, larger uncharged pores enable ion dehydration, inducing enthalpic selectivity that is driven by differences in the ion hydration properties. We also demonstrate that electrostatic interactions between cations and intrapore carboxyl groups hinder salt permeability, increasing the enthalpic barrier of the transport. Last, permeation tests of monovalent cations in the loose and tight polyamide membranes expose opposite rejection trends that further support the phenomenon of ion dehydration in large subnanopores.

Chemicals-free approach control interface characteristics of nanofiltration membrane: Feasibility and mechanism insight into CEM electrolysis

The combined fouling effect prevalent in the nanofiltration (NF) process severely limits its use. In this study, cation exchange membrane (CEM) electrolysis was performed to alleviate NF membrane fouling by controlling interface characteristics. The results revealed that CEM electrolysis (hydraulic retention time with 0.24 or 0.36 h) effectively improved NF membrane permeability by 201%-211% and achieved a stability of > 8 LMH/bar. The divalent cations were removed through CEM electrolysis, with a decrease in Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ by approximately 68.8% and 30.9%, respectively, which was related to scaling potential reduction. This softening function reduced the possibility of bridging of organics with divalent cations, which contributed to the lower molecular weight of organic matter (mainly humic substances) distributed in 1.4-23 kDa. The improved organic indicators of the NF membrane permeate quality implied that the membrane interface characteristics improved. The foulant layer on the NF membrane dominated humic substances, and biopolymers exhibited hydrophobic, smooth, and porous characteristics. The self-aggregation of foulants on the NF membrane surface stimulated the interface characteristics with high water permeability. Energy consumption confirmed the feasibility of CEM electrolysis on NF application. Thus, CEM electrolysis as a chemical-free approach that can be combined with NF and can provide guidance for NF membrane fouling in urban water treatment and water reclamation.

Efficacy of selected pretreatment processes in the mitigation of low-pressure membrane fouling and its correlation to their removal of microbial DOM

Membrane fouling by dissolved organic matter (DOM), especially microbially-derived DOM, is a major challenge for ultrafiltration (UF) membranes in water purification. Fouling may be mitigated by pretreating feed waters; however, there are no comprehensive studies that compare the fouling reduction efficacies across different pretreatment processes. Further, there is a limited understanding of the relationship between fouling reduction efficacy and microbially-derived DOM removal from source waters. Accordingly, the objectives of this study were to: (i) evaluate and compare the efficacies of five pretreatment processes in reducing UF membrane fouling by DOM; and (ii) investigate whether a relationship exists between membrane fouling reduction and microbially-derived DOM removal by pretreatment processes. We investigated seven water sources and a polyvinylidene fluoride hollow-fiber UF membrane using bench-scale fouling tests. Dissolved organic carbon content, ultraviolet absorbance and fluorescence excitation-emission matrix spectroscopy were used to assess DOM concentration and composition. Alum and ferric chloride coagulation were the most effective pretreatment processes in reducing membrane fouling, anion exchange was moderately effective, and PAC adsorption and chlorine pre-oxidation were the least effective. Consistent with previous studies, microbially-derived DOM was the major contributor to UF membrane fouling regardless of water source or pretreatment type. Fouling reduction was strongly correlated with the reduction of microbially-derived DOM in foulant layers but not from source waters. This result indicates that a fraction of the total microbially-derived DOM in feed waters was responsible for UF fouling. Overall, pretreatment processes that remove microbially-derived DOM are well-suited for UF membrane fouling reduction.

Study of Turbulence Promoters in Prolonging Membrane Life

Nanofiltration membrane technology is an effective method for secondary treated sewage purification. However, membrane fouling, which is inevitable in the membrane-separation process, can reduce membrane performance and shorten membrane life. Installing a turbulence promoter is a promising means of improving the hydraulic conditions inside the membrane chamber. In this study, the effect of turbulence promoter on prolonging membrane life was studied for the first time. Flat-sheet polyethersulfone nanofiltration membrane was used to filter humic acid solution, used for simulating secondary treated sewage. By comparing photographs and SEM images of the membrane before and after the simulated secondary treated sewage filtration, it was found that humic acid tended to be deposited on the low-velocity region, which was reflected by COMSOL simulation. After incorporating a turbulence promoter, the reduction of the humic acid deposition area and membrane fouling resistance indicated that the turbulence promoter could reduce membrane fouling due to the improved hydraulic conditions. Additionally, the turbulence promoter also increased the flux and reduced the flux decay rate. The turbulence promoter was then place in the crossflow flat-sheet membrane filtration module, and the variation of flux with time was tested in simulated secondary treated sewage with different concentrations. The results showed that the membrane life for the filtration of simulated secondary treated sewage comprising 50, 250, and 500 ppm humic acid increased by 23.1%, 80.4%, and 85.7%, respectively. The results of this article can serve as a reference for the prediction of membrane life and the performance enhancement mechanism of membranes containing a turbulence promoter.

Assessment of C-DBP and N-DBP formation potential and its reduction by MIEX® DOC and MIEX® GOLD resins using fluorescence spectroscopy and parallel factor analysis

This study investigated the applicability of parallel factor analysis (PARAFAC) of fluorescence excitation-emission matrices (EEM) spectra to assess the formation potentials (FP) of carbonaceous and nitrogenous disinfection byproducts (C-DBP and N-DBP) and the FP reduction by the magnetic ion exchange resins, MIEX® DOC and MIEX® GOLD. Two source waters of different nature - a surface water and a secondary treated wastewater effluent - were studied. The samples were analyzed for formation potentials of trihalomethanes (THM4), haloacetonitriles (HAN4), haloketones (HK2), and chloropicrin (CPN). A 4-component PARAFAC model was developed from 150 EEM samples generated from the raw source waters and their treatment with MIEX® resins. Components C1, C2, and C3 corresponded to humic-like dissolved organic matter (DOM) while C4 corresponded to protein-like DOM. Both MIEX® resins preferentially removed components C1, C2, and C3 over C4, indicating affinity with humic materials. MIEX® resins were shown to be more effective to treat surface water than secondary effluent, including effective removal of DBP precursors with extended bed volume treatment. Among all parameters investigated, THM4-FP strongly correlated with humic-like component C3, while HAN4-FP strongly correlated with protein-like component C4 (ρ > 0.89 and p < 0.01); CPN-FP and HK2-FP both correlated with anthropogenic DOM C2 (ρ > 0.89 and p < 0.01). Our results indicate that EEM-PARAFAC was valuable for assessing DBP formation potentials and removal of their precursors by MIEX® resins in different water sources.

Applicability of electro-osmotic flow for the analysis of the surface zeta potential

The analysis of the surface zeta potential (SZP) opens up new possibilities in the characterization of various materials used for scientific or industrial applications. It provides at the same time insight into the material surface chemistry and elucidates the interactions with charged species in the aqueous test solution. For this purpose, an accurate, reliable and repeatable analysis of the SZP is the key factor. This work focuses on a detailed and systematic comparison of two electrokinetic techniques, i.e. the mapping of the electro-osmotic flow (EOF) and the measurement of the streaming potential (SP), for the surface zeta potential (SZP) determination of several materials with varying properties. Both techniques have advantages as well as drawbacks. The applicability of latex polymer material and inorganic tracer particles at varying ionic strength, the interaction between oppositely charged tracer particles and solid surfaces, the assessment of the pH dependence of the SZP and the isoelectric point (IEP), and the effects of sample porosity and conductance have been investigated. Although in some cases the EOF method gives a SZP similar to the streaming potential measurement, especially when the tracer particle exhibits the same charge as the solid surface, it was revealed that reliable results were only obtained with the streaming potential and streaming current method. Several obstacles such as elevated conductivity at higher ionic strength, the applied voltage for the EM measurement, and the nature of tracer particles lower the accuracy and reliability of the SZP determined by the EOF method. It was shown that the EOF method is not applicable to oppositely charged surface and tracer particles and also limited to low salinity conditions especially when using polymeric tracer particles. Although the EOF method does not require the formation of a capillary flow channel, it disables a non-destructive SZP of fragile or valuable samples, such as QCM-D sensors, in comparison to the SP approach.

Detail comparison of two different electrokinetic phenomena EOF and SP method for the SZP determination with taking into account various materials with different surface and bulk properties.

Effect of pH on effluent organic matter removal in hybrid process of magnetic ion-exchange resin adsorption and ozonation

It is essential to mitigate the risk of exposure to effluent organic matter (EfOM) in aquatic environments to ensure safe wastewater recycling. Magnetic ion-exchange (MIEX) resin adsorption combined with ozonation could provide EfOM removal. However, the poor understanding of the influences of the parameters and mechanisms in the hybrid process has restricted the applications. In this study, the response surface methodology was used to reveal the interactions of the major operation parameters. The degradation behaviour of the EfOM was investigated by using spectroscopy combined with mathematical methods. The effect of the pH on the EfOM removal was also analysed. The maximum efficiency of the removal of dissolved organic carbon (DOC) was 59.77% at the optimal MIEX resin dosage of 7.97 mL/L, ozone concentration of 8 mg/L, agitation speed of 199.84 r/min, and pH of 9.98. The ozonation was superior to resin adsorption in the removal of 1054-Da compounds, while the resin adsorption was advantageous in the removal of 4168-Da compounds. Three fluorescent components (C1, C2, and C3) were more easily subjected to external perturbation than the DOC and ultraviolet absorbance at 254 nm in the oxidation processes. The MIEX resin exhibited low efficiencies of removal of the fluorescent substances. A synchronous fluorescence analysis coupled with a two-dimensional correlation analysis revealed that the variation in EfOM followed the order of fulvic-to humic-like substances in the hybrid process of MIEX and the following ozonation. The pH was the most significant influencing factor in the hybrid process.

Physico-chemical processes

The review scans research articles published in 2018 on physico-chemical processes for water and wastewater treatment. The paper includes eight sections, that is, membrane technology, granular filtration, flotation, adsorption, coagulation/flocculation, capacitive deionization, ion exchange, and oxidation. The membrane technology section further divides into six parts, including microfiltration, ultrafiltration, nanofiltration, reverse osmosis/forward osmosis, and membrane distillation. PRACTITIONER POINTS: Totally 266 articles on water and wastewater treatment have been scanned; The review is sectioned into 8 major parts;  Membrane technology has drawn the widest attention from the research community.

Effect of turbidity on micropollutant removal and membrane fouling by MIEX/ultrafiltration hybrid process

Effect of turbidity on the removal of organic micropollutant (carbamazepine, CBZ) through magnetic ion exchange (MIEX) resin combined with ultrafiltration (UF) was investigated in this study. The purification behaviors of the MIEX/UF processes were studied through scanning electron microscopy, high-performance liquid chromatography, zeta potential and particle size distribution analyses. The experimental results show that 64-74% of CBZ in different turbidities could be removed by MIEX resin under the optimum dose and contact time, while water sample with turbidity of 20 ± 1.1 NTU present minimum CBZ removal rate of 64% and turbidity of 60 ± 1.0 NTU led to maximum removal efficiency of 74%. The results of UF experiments showed that UF could not efficiently remove CBZ. Alternatively, UF was more suitable for removing turbidity than MIEX resin. In a separate UF system, the turbidity (20 ± 1.1 NTU) led to a flux reduction of 60% at the first filtration cycle, while the reduction for 1.0 ± 0.1 NTU, 40 ± 1.0 NTU and 60 ± 1.0 NTU were 48%, 52% and 45%, respectively. For the water samples with different turbidities, obvious decrease in membrane fouling was observed after MIEX pretreatment, meanwhile the CBZ/turbidity removal could be improved. The UF membrane was used four times after backwashing to research the reusability of membrane. The integrated processes combining MIEX resin with UF could significantly improve membrane recycling effect and prevent secondary pollution caused by resin.

The use of combined treatments for reducing parabens in surface waters: Ion-exchange resin and nanofiltration

In this study, the removal of parabens from waters, using a combined treatment of magnetic ion exchange resins and subsequent filtration through nanofiltration membranes, was investigated. The selected parabens were methylparaben, ethylparaben, propylparaben and butylparaben. Two different magnetic anionic exchanger resins, MIEX® DOC and MIEX® GOLD, and two nanofiltration membranes (NF), NF-90 and DESAL-HL, were tested. The study was carried out using mono and multicomponent systems, using deionized water and natural waters sampled from two different rivers. In this way, competitive and matrix effects could be evaluated. The results showed, that with the combined treatments, higher elimination rates were obtained. The best removal efficiencies were obtained when the DOC resin was combined with both NF-90 and DESAL-HL membranes. Thus, butylparaben and propylparaben reached removal yields around 100% with both membranes, whereas the corresponding values for methylparaben were 91%, when the NF-90 membrane was employed, or 92% when DESAL-HL membrane was utilized. The elimination rates of ethylparaben with the same treatments were 96% with the NF-90 and 97% when the DESAL-HL membrane was combined with the DOC resin. The elimination percentages were higher as the paraben alkyl chain length increased. In addition, no competitiveness or matrix effects were detected. When the MIEX® GOLD resin was used for pre-treatment, membrane fouling worsened which indicated that resin selection needs to be carefully considered to achieve the best results.

Solar Photocatalytic Degradation of Trace Organic Pollutants in Water by Bi(0)-Doped Bismuth Oxyhalide Thin Films

Herein, we demonstrate the fabrication of Bi(0)-doped bismuth oxyhalide solid solution films for the removal of trace organic pollutants (TrOPs) in water. With the advantage of a viscous AlOOH sol, very high loadings (75 wt %) of bismuth oxyhalides were embedded within the thin films and calcined at 500 °C to develop porous alumina composite coatings. Various concentrations of Bi(0) doping were tested for their photocatalytic activity. Seven TrOPs including iopromide (IPRM), iohexol (IHX), iopamidol (IPMD), sulfamethoxazole (SMX), carbamazepine, venlafaxine, and bezafibrate (BZF) were selected for this study based on their occurrence and detection in effluents and surface waters worldwide. In all tests, with the exception of IPRM, 3% Bi(0)-doped BiOCl_0.875Br_0.125 showed highest activity, which can be attributed to its unique, highly organized, and compact morphology besides its well-matched energy band positions. Although IPMD, IHX, IPRM, and SMX are susceptible to photolysis, still the photocatalytic activity significantly augmented the removal of all tested compounds. In addition, analysis of the surface charge excluded electrostatic interactions and confirmed the ion-exchange adsorption mechanism for the high degradation rate of BZF in the presence of bismuth oxyhalides.