DNA sequence context greatly affects the accuracy of bypass across an ultraviolet light 6-4 photoproduct in mammalian cells

5-Formylcytosine mediated DNA-peptide cross-link induces predominantly semi-targeted mutations in both Escherichia coli and human cells

Histone proteins can become trapped on DNA in the presence of 5-formylcytosine (5fC) to form toxic DNA-protein conjugates. Their repair may involve proteolytic digestion resulting in DNA-peptide cross-links (DpCs). Here, we have investigated replication of a model DpC comprised of an 11-mer peptide (NH2-GGGKGLGK∗GGA) containing an oxy-lysine residue (K∗) conjugated to 5fC in DNA. Both CXG and CXT (where X = 5fC-DpC) sequence contexts were examined. Replication of both constructs gave low viability (<10%) in Escherichia coli, whereas TLS efficiency was high (72%) in HEK 293T cells. In E. coli, the DpC was bypassed largely error-free, inducing only 2 to 3% mutations, which increased to 4 to 5% with SOS. For both sequences, semi-targeted mutations were dominant, and for CXG, the predominant mutations were G→T and G→C at the 3'-base to the 5fC-DpC. In HEK 293T cells, 7 to 9% mutations occurred, and the dominant mutations were the semi-targeted G → T for CXG and T → G for CXT. These mutations were reduced drastically in cells deficient in hPol η, hPol ι or hPol ζ, suggesting a role of these TLS polymerases in mutagenic TLS. Steady-state kinetics studies using hPol η confirmed that this polymerase induces G → T and T → G transversions at the base immediately 3' to the DpC. This study reveals a unique replication pattern of 5fC-conjugated DpCs, which are bypassed largely error-free in both E. coli and human cells and induce mostly semi-targeted mutations at the 3' position to the lesion.

The accurate bypass of pyrimidine dimers by DNA polymerase eta contributes to ultraviolet-induced mutagenesis

Human xeroderma pigmentosum variant (XP-V) patients are mutated in the POLH gene, responsible for encoding the translesion synthesis (TLS) DNA polymerase eta (Pol eta). These patients suffer from a high frequency of skin tumors. Despite several decades of research, studies on Pol eta still offer an intriguing paradox: How does this error-prone polymerase suppress mutations? This review examines recent evidence suggesting that cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPDs) are instructional for Pol eta. Consequently, it can accurately replicate these lesions, and the mutagenic effects induced by UV radiation stem from the deamination of C-containing CPDs. In this model, the deamination of C (forming a U) within CPDs leads to the correct insertion of an A opposite to the deaminated C (or U)-containing dimers. This intricate process results in C>T transitions, which represent the most prevalent mutations detected in skin cancers. Finally, the delayed replication in XP-V cells amplifies the process of C-deamination in CPDs and increases the burden of C>T mutations prevalent in XP-V tumors through the activity of backup TLS polymerases.

Beyond the Lesion: Back to High Fidelity DNA Synthesis

High fidelity (HiFi) DNA polymerases (Pols) perform the bulk of DNA synthesis required to duplicate genomes in all forms of life. Their structural features, enzymatic mechanisms, and inherent properties are well-described over several decades of research. HiFi Pols are so accurate that they become stalled at sites of DNA damage or lesions that are not one of the four canonical DNA bases. Once stalled, the replisome becomes compromised and vulnerable to further DNA damage. One mechanism to relieve stalling is to recruit a translesion synthesis (TLS) Pol to rapidly synthesize over and past the damage. These TLS Pols have good specificities for the lesion but are less accurate when synthesizing opposite undamaged DNA, and so, mechanisms are needed to limit TLS Pol synthesis and recruit back a HiFi Pol to reestablish the replisome. The overall TLS process can be complicated with several cellular Pols, multifaceted protein contacts, and variable nucleotide incorporation kinetics all contributing to several discrete substitution (or template hand-off) steps. In this review, we highlight the mechanistic differences between distributive equilibrium exchange events and concerted contact-dependent switching by DNA Pols for insertion, extension, and resumption of high-fidelity synthesis beyond the lesion.

Synthesis and polymerase bypass studies of DNA-peptide and DNA-protein conjugates

DNA-peptide (DpCs) and DNA-protein cross-links (DPCs) are DNA lesions formed when polypeptides and nuclear proteins become covalently trapped on DNA strands. DNA-protein cross-links are of enormous size and hence pose challenges to cell survival by blocking DNA replication, transcription, and repair. However, DPCs can undergo proteolytic degradation via various pathways to give shorter polypeptide chains (DpCs). The resulting DpC lesions are efficiently bypassed by translesion synthesis (TLS) DNA polymerases like κ, η, δ, etc., although polymerase bypass efficiency as well as correct base insertion depends heavily on size, sequence context, and position of peptides in DpCs. This chapter explores various synthetic methods to generate these lesions including detailed experimental procedures for the construction of DpCs and DPCs via reductive amination and oxime ligation. Further we describe biochemical experiments to investigate the effects of these lesions on DNA polymerase activity and fidelity.

Sequence context effects of replication of Fapy•dG in three mutational hot spot sequences of the p53 gene in human cells

Fapy•dG and 8-OxodGuo are formed in DNA from a common N7-dG radical intermediate by reaction with hydroxyl radical. Although cellular levels of Fapy•dG are often greater, its effects on replication are less well understood than those of 8-OxodGuo. In this study plasmid DNA containing Fapy•dG in three mutational hotspots of human cancers, codons 248, 249, and 273 of the p53 tumor suppressor gene, was replicated in HEK 293T cells. TLS efficiencies for the Fapy•dG containing plasmids varied from 72 to 89%, and were further reduced in polymerase-deficient cells. The mutation frequency (MF) of Fapy•dG ranged from 7.3 to 11.6%, with G→T and G→A as major mutations in codons 248 and 249 compared to primarily G→T in codon 273. Increased MF in hPol ι-, hPol κ-, and hPol ζ-deficient cells suggested that these polymerases more frequently insert the correct nucleotide dC opposite Fapy•dG, whereas decreased G→A in codons 248 and 249 and reduction of all mutations in codon 273 in hPol λ-deficient cells indicated hPol λ's involvement in Fapy•dG mutagenesis. In vitro kinetic analysis using isolated translesion synthesis polymerases and hPol λ incompletely corroborated the mutagenesis experiments, indicating codependence on other proteins in the cellular milieu. In conclusion, Fapy•dG mutagenesis is dependent on the DNA sequence context, but its bypass by the TLS polymerases is largely error-free.

Translesion Synthesis Past 5-Formylcytosine-Mediated DNA-Peptide Cross-Links by hPolη Is Dependent on the Local DNA Sequence

DNA-protein cross-links (DPCs) are unusually bulky DNA lesions that form when cellular proteins become trapped on DNA following exposure to ultraviolet light, free radicals, aldehydes, and transition metals. DPCs can also form endogenously when naturally occurring epigenetic marks [5-formyl cytosine (5fC)] in DNA react with lysine and arginine residues of histones to form Schiff base conjugates. Our previous studies revealed that DPCs inhibit DNA replication and transcription but can undergo proteolytic cleavage to produce smaller DNA-peptide conjugates. We have shown that 5fC-conjugated DNA-peptide cross-links (DpCs) placed within the CXA sequence (X = DpC) can be bypassed by human translesion synthesis (TLS) polymerases η and κ in an error-prone manner. However, the local nucleotide sequence context can have a strong effect on replication bypass of bulky lesions by influencing the geometry of the ternary complex among the DNA template, polymerase, and the incoming dNTP. In this work, we investigated polymerase bypass of 5fC-DNA-11-mer peptide cross-links placed in seven different sequence contexts (CXC, CXG, CXT, CXA, AXA, GXA, and TXA) in the presence of human TLS polymerase η. Primer extension products were analyzed by gel electrophoresis, and steady-state kinetics of the misincorporation of dAMP opposite the DpC lesion in different base sequence contexts was investigated. Our results revealed a strong impact of nearest neighbor base identity on polymerase η activity in the absence and presence of a DpC lesion. Molecular dynamics simulations were used to structurally explain the experimental findings. Our results suggest a possible role of local DNA sequence in promoting TLS-related mutational hot spots in the presence and absence of DpC lesions.

Evaluation and modulation of DNA lesion bypass in an SV40 large T antigen-based in vitro replication system

DNA damage removal by nucleotide excision repair (NER) and replicative bypass via translesion synthesis (TLS) and template switch (TSw) are important in ensuring genome stability. In this study, we tested the applicability of an SV40 large T antigen‐based replication system for the simultaneous examination of these damage tolerance processes. Using both Sanger and next‐generation sequencing combined with lesion‐specific qPCR and replication efficiency studies, we demonstrate that this system works well for studying NER and TLS, especially its one‐polymerase branch, while it is less suited to investigations of homology‐related repair processes, such as TSw. Cis‐syn cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer photoproducts were replicated with equal efficiency to lesion‐free plasmids in vitro, and the majority of TLS on this lesion could be inhibited by a peptide (PIR) specific for the polη‐PCNA interaction interface. TLS on 6–4 pyrimidine–pyrimidone photoproduct proved to be inefficient and was slightly facilitated by PIR as well as by a recombinant ubiquitin‐binding zinc finger domain of polη in HeLa extract, possibly by promoting polymerase exchange. Supplementation of the extract with recombinant PCNA variants indicated the dependence of TLS on PCNA ubiquitylation. In contrast to active TLS and NER, we found no evidence of successful TSw in cellular extracts. The established methods can promote in vitro investigations of replicative DNA damage bypass.

Impact of the Nucleosome Histone Core on the Structure and Dynamics of DNA-Containing Pyrimidine-Pyrimidone (6-4) Photoproduct

The pyrimidine-pyrimidone (6-4) photoproduct (64-PP) is an important photoinduced DNA lesion constituting a mutational signature for melanoma. The structural impact of 64-PP on DNA complexed with histones affects the lesion mutagenicity and repair but remains poorly understood. Here we investigate the conformational dynamics of DNA-containing 64-PP within the nucleosome core particle by atomic-resolution molecular dynamics simulations and multiscale data analysis. We demonstrate that the histone core exerts important mechanical restraints that largely decrease global DNA structural fluctuations. However, the local DNA flexibility at the damaged site is enhanced due to imperfect structural adaptation to restraints imposed by the histone core. If 64-PP faces the histone core and is therefore not directly accessible by the repair protein, the complementary strand facing the solvent is deformed and exhibits higher flexibility than the corresponding strand in a naked, undamaged DNA. This may serve as an initial recognition signal for repair. Our simulations also pinpoint the structural role of proximal residues from the truncated histone tails.

Effect of sequence context on Polζ-dependent error-prone extension past (6-4) photoproducts

The (6-4) pyrimidine-pyrimidone photoproduct [(6-4)PP] is a major DNA lesion induced by ultraviolet radiation. (6-4)PP induces complex mutations opposite its downstream bases, in addition to opposite 3' or 5' base, as has been observed through a site-specific translesion DNA synthesis (TLS) assay. The mechanism by which these mutations occur is not well understood. To elucidate the mechanisms underlying mutagenesis induced by (6-4)PP, we performed an intracellular TLS assay using a replicative vector with site-specific T(thymidine)-T (6-4)PP. Rev3^-/-p53^-/- mouse embryonic fibroblast (MEF) cells (defective in Polζ) were almost completely defective in bypassing T-T (6-4)PP, whereas both Rev1^-/- and Polh^-/-Poli^-/-Polk^-/- MEF cells (defective in Polη, Polι, and Polκ) presented bypassing activity comparable to that of wild-type cells, indicating that Y-family TLS polymerases are dispensable for bypassing activity, whereas Polζ plays an essential role, probably at the extension step. Among all cells tested, misincorporation occurred most frequently just beyond the lesion (position +1), indicating that the Polζ-dependent extension step is crucial for (6-4)PP-induced mutagenesis. We then examined the effects of sequence context on T-T (6-4)PP bypass using a series of T-T (6-4)PP templates with different sequences at position +1 or -1 to the lesion, and found that the dependency of T-T (6-4)PP bypass on Polζ is not sequence specific. However, the misincorporation frequency at position +1 differed significantly among these templates. The misincorporation of A at position +1 occurred frequently when a purine base was located at position -1. These results indicate that Polζ-dependent extension plays a major role in inducing base substitutions in (6-4)PP-induced mutagenesis, and its fidelity is affected by sequence context surrounding a lesion.

Macroenvironment-gene-microenvironment interactions in ultraviolet radiation-induced melanomagenesis

Cutaneous malignant melanoma is one of the few major cancers that continue to exhibit a positive rate of increase in the developed world. A wealth of epidemiological data has undisputedly implicated ultraviolet radiation (UVR) from sunlight and artificial sources as the major risk factor for melanomagenesis. However, the molecular mechanisms of this cause-and-effect relationship remain murky and understudied. Recent efforts on multiple fronts have brought unprecedented expansion of our knowledge base on this subject and it is now clear that melanoma is caused by a complex interaction between genetic predisposition and environmental exposure, primarily to UVR. Here we provide an overview of the effects of the macroenvironment (UVR) on the skin microenvironment and melanocyte-specific intrinsic (mostly genetic) landscape, which conspire to produce one of the deadliest malignancies.

Eukaryotic Translesion DNA Synthesis on the Leading and Lagging Strands: Unique Detours around the Same Obstacle

During S-phase, minor DNA damage may be overcome by DNA damage tolerance (DDT) pathways that bypass such obstacles, postponing repair of the offending damage to complete the cell cycle and maintain cell survival. In translesion DNA synthesis (TLS), specialized DNA polymerases replicate the damaged DNA, allowing stringent DNA synthesis by a replicative polymerase to resume beyond the offending damage. Dysregulation of this DDT pathway in human cells leads to increased mutation rates that may contribute to the onset of cancer. Furthermore, TLS affords human cancer cells the ability to counteract chemotherapeutic agents that elicit cell death by damaging DNA in actively replicating cells. Currently, it is unclear how this critical pathway unfolds, in particular, where and when TLS occurs on each template strand. Given the semidiscontinuous nature of DNA replication, it is likely that TLS on the leading and lagging strand templates is unique for each strand. Since the discovery of DDT in the late 1960s, most studies on TLS in eukaryotes have focused on DNA lesions resulting from ultraviolet (UV) radiation exposure. In this review, we revisit these and other related studies to dissect the step-by-step intricacies of this complex process, provide our current understanding of TLS on leading and lagging strand templates, and propose testable hypotheses to gain further insights.

Y-family DNA polymerase-independent gap-filling translesion synthesis across aristolochic acid-derived adenine adducts in mouse cells

Translesion DNA synthesis (TLS) operates when replicative polymerases are blocked by DNA lesions. To investigate the mechanism of mammalian TLS, we employed a plasmid bearing a single 7-(deoxyadenosine-N⁶-yl)-aristolactam I (dA-AL-I) adduct, which is generated by the human carcinogen, aristolochic acid I, and genetically engineered mouse embryonic fibroblasts. This lesion induces A to T transversions at a high frequency. The simultaneous knockouts of the Polh, Poli and Polk genes did not influence the TLS efficiency or the coding property of dA-AL-I, indicating that an unknown DNA polymerase(s) can efficiently catalyze the insertion of a nucleotide opposite the adduct and subsequent extension. Similarly, knockout of the Rev1 gene did not significantly affect TLS. However, knockout of the Rev3l gene, coding for the catalytic subunit of polζ, drastically suppressed TLS and abolished dA-AL-I to T transversions. The results support the idea that Rev1 is not essential for the cellular TLS functions of polζ in mammalian cells. Furthermore, the frequency of dA-AL-I to T transversion was affected by a sequence context, suggesting that TLS, at least in part, contributes to the formation of mutational hot and cold spots observed in aristolochic acid-induced cancers.

Germline MC1R status influences somatic mutation burden in melanoma

The major genetic determinants of cutaneous melanoma risk in the general population are disruptive variants (R alleles) in the melanocortin 1 receptor (MC1R) gene. These alleles are also linked to red hair, freckling, and sun sensitivity, all of which are known melanoma phenotypic risk factors. Here we report that in melanomas and for somatic C>T mutations, a signature linked to sun exposure, the expected single-nucleotide variant count associated with the presence of an R allele is estimated to be 42% (95% CI, 15-76%) higher than that among persons without an R allele. This figure is comparable to the expected mutational burden associated with an additional 21 years of age. We also find significant and similar enrichment of non-C>T mutation classes supporting a role for additional mutagenic processes in melanoma development in individuals carrying R alleles.

High-resolution genomic assays provide insight into the division of labor between TLS and HDR in mammalian replication of damaged DNA

The multitude of DNA lesions that continuously form in DNA cannot all be detected and removed prior to replication. Thus, encounters of the replication fork with DNA damage become inevitable. Such encounters inhibit fork progression, leading to replication fork arrest or to replication re-priming downstream of the damage site. Either of these events will result in the formation of gap-lesion structures, in which a damaged base is located in a single stranded stretch of DNA, that is vulnerable to subsequent nicking. The double strand break that would ensue if ssDNA becomes nicked constitutes escalation of the damage from nucleotide(s)-specific to chromosomal scale. Cells employ two universal DNA damage tolerance (DDT) strategies to resolve these situations, by converting the gap-lesion structures into dsDNA without repairing the damage. The first is translesion DNA synthesis (TLS), in which a specialized low-fidelity DNA polymerase inserts a nucleotide opposite the damaged one. TLS is inherently mutagenic, due to the miscoding nature of most damaged nucleotides. The second strategy is homology-dependent repair (HDR), which relies on the presence of an identical intact sister chromatid. The molecular mechanisms that regulate the division of labor between these pathways are poorly understood. This review focuses on the balance between TLS and HDR in mammalian cells, discussing recent findings that were made possible thanks to newly developed high resolution genomic assays, and highlighting the role of the DNA lesion's properties in DDT pathway choice.