Economic burden of multiple sclerosis in France estimated from a regional medical registry and national sick fund claims

Management of patients with active relapsing-remitting or secondary progressive multiple sclerosis: A French real-world study based on claims data linked to a phase IV study

BACKGROUND

PRO-MSactive is a French phase-IV study evaluating ocrelizumab efficacy in active relapsing-remitting or secondary progressive multiple sclerosis (RRMS or SPMS). By linking clinical data to the national claims database (SNDS), the objective of this study was to obtain an overview of RRMS and SPMS burden.

METHODS

All RRMS and SPMS patients included in the PRO-MSactive study between July 2018 and July 2019 and followed for 48 weeks were linked to MS patients from SNDS. Healthcare Resource Utilization and costs were described in RRMS patients, in the two years prior to ocrelizumab initiation, by 12 months period (n-1 and n-2), according to EDSS score (< 4 versus ≥4).

RESULTS

291/371 patients (78.7 %) were included: 257 RRMS and 34 SPMS patients. Different costs according to disability status (year n-2: 9,103€ versus 16,441€; year n-1: 9,813€ versus 19,999€, for patients with score EDSS <4 versus ≥4, respectively) and relapse activity (+1,358€ between year n-2 and n-1) were observed.

CONCLUSION

This study is the first to combine clinical data from a phase-IV study with a claims database allowing to distinguish costs according to disease type. We objectified a greater economic burden in RRMS patients with higher levels of disability and showed an increase in costs associated with relapse activity in the 2 years before enrolling in the phase IV study.

The socioeconomic impact of multiple sclerosis in France: Results from the PETALS study

Background

Multiple sclerosis (MS) places a considerable financial burden on the society. However, data quantifying the contemporary cost burden in France are lacking.

Objective

This cost-of-illness study aimed to estimate the direct and indirect costs associated with MS in France.

Methods

Between October 2020-November 2020, 208 French adults with a confirmed diagnosis of MS were recruited via MSCopilot^® (a new MS self-assessment digital solution) and several MS patient networks. Indirect costs were estimated using a combination of top-down and bottom-up approaches. Direct costs were retrieved from Assurance Maladie (i.e. national system of health insurance) publications. Out-of-pocket expenses (OOPEs) incurred by MS patients were also reported. All costs were expressed in €2020. Data from the survey were extrapolated to the overall French MS population.

Results

MS exerted an annual cost burden of €2.7 billion on the French society (indirect costs: €1.3 billion; direct costs: €1.4 billion). Mean annual costs were €27,164.7 per-patient, with indirect and direct costs accounting for 48.1% and 51.9% of the total annual costs, respectively. OOPEs contributed over €90 million to the total annual costs.

Conclusions

MS imposes a substantial cost burden on the French society, with approximately half of the total annual costs driven by indirect costs.

Age-period-cohort analysis of the incidence of multiple sclerosis over twenty years in Lorraine, France

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a neurodegenerative disease of the central nervous system. An increase in MS incidence over time is reported in several regions of the world. We aimed to describe the evolution of the annual MS incidence in the Lorraine region, France, from 1996 to 2015 and to analyze potential components of a possible change by a temporal effect of age at MS onset, MS onset period, and birth cohort, overall and for each sex. Cases were identified from ReLSEP, a population-based registry of MS cases living in Lorraine, northeastern France, with MS onset between 1996 and 2015. Age-period-cohort modeling was used to describe trends in MS incidence. Annual age- and sex-standardized incidences were relatively stable: 6.76/100 000 population (95%CI [5.76-7.91]) in 1996 and 6.78/100 000 (95%CI [5.72-7.97]) in 2015. The incidence ratio between women and men was 2.4. For all time periods, the peak incidence occurred between ages 25 and 35 years. Age-period-adjusted cohort and age-cohort-adjusted period analyses did not reveal a period or cohort effect. The incidence of MS remained stable over the study period in Lorraine, and we could not identify any particular effect of disease onset period or birth period on this evolution.

Cost of illness in multiple sclerosis by disease characteristics - A review of reviews

Introduction: In light of the increasing number of economic burden studies and heterogeneity in methodology and reporting standards, there is a need for robust evidence synthesis on an umbrella review level.Areas covered: We performed the first review of reviews of cost-of-illness studies in multiple sclerosis. Focusing on disaggregated costs by disease characteristics (disability level, relapse, disease course), we also characterized the underlying methodological evidence base of individual (primary) studies.Expert Commentary: We identified 17 reviews encompassing 111 unique primary studies, and a high degree of overlap across reviews. Costs were substantial, rising with disability level, relapse episodes, and disease progression. Disability was the key cost driver. Compared to mild disability, total costs for moderate disability were 1.4-2.3-fold higher and 1.8-2.9-fold higher for severe disability. With escalating disability, the share of costs outside the health system (indirect costs, informal care) increasingly outweighed the share of direct medical costs. Of all 111 primary studies, 72% gathered resource use/loss data by patient self-report. Associated costs were mostly reported by disability level (75%), followed by relapse (48%) and disease course (21%). In conclusion, although heterogeneity can make in-depth comparisons of costs across studies impossible, important patterns are broadly apparent.

Economic burden of highly active relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis patients in the French national health insurance database

BACKGROUND

As healthcare management of highly active-relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis (HA-RRMS) patients is more complex than for the whole multiple sclerosis (MS) population, this study assessed the related economic burden from a National Health Insurance's (NHI's) perspective.

RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS

Study based on French NHI databases, using individual data on billing and reimbursement of outpatient and hospital healthcare consumption, paid sick leave and disability pension, over 2010-2017.

RESULTS

Of the 9,596 HA-RRMS adult patients, data from 7,960 patients were analyzed with at least 2 years of follow-up. Mean annual cost/patient was €29,813. Drugs represented 40% of the cost, hospital care 33%, disability pensions 9%, and all healthcare professionals' visits combined 8%. Among 3,024 patients under 60 years-old with disability pension, disability pension cost €7,168/patient/year. Among 3,807 patients with paid sick leave, sick leave cost €1,956/patient/year. Mean costs were €2,246/patient higher the first year and increased by €1,444 between 2010 and 2015, with a €5,188 increase in drug-related expenditures and a €634 increase in healthcare professionals' visits expenditures but a €4,529 decrease in hospital care expenditures.

CONCLUSIONS

The cost of health care sick leaves, and disability pensions of HA-RRMS patients was about twice as high as previously reported cost of MS patients.

System-Level Variation in Multiple Sclerosis Care Outcomes: Initial Findings from the Multiple Sclerosis Continuous Quality Improvement Research Collaborative

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a "3C" (complex, chronic, costly) condition that is a common and disabling neurological illness affecting approximately 1 million adults in the United States. MS has been studied at the basic science, individual, and population levels, but not at the system level to assess small-area variation effects on MS population health outcomes. System-level effects have been observed in other 3C conditions including cystic fibrosis, rheumatoid arthritis, and inflammatory bowel disease. The authors report here on system-level variation findings from the baseline period during the first year of the Multiple Sclerosis Continuous Quality Improvement (MS-CQI) study. Stepwise binary logistic regression analyses were conducted to investigate system-level (small-area variation) effects on MS relapses (exacerbations), disease-modifying therapy (DMT) utilization, and brain MRI utilization, controlling for demographics (age and sex) and other potential confounders. Significant differences were observed in people with MS (PwMS) between centers for a number of demographic and disease characteristics, including sex, age, and MS subtype. Controlling for these factors, significant system-level effects were observed on outcomes, including DMT utilization, MRI utilization, and relapses. Significant relationships also were observed between outcomes and urgent care utilization, including emergency department visits and hospitalizations. This initial study provides evidence establishing the presence of system-level variation effects on MS outcomes in a multicenter population study - where PwMS get their care can influence their outcomes. Results support continued systems-level research and improvement initiatives to optimize MS population health outcomes in this challenging and costly complex chronic condition.

Secondary progressive multiple sclerosis: a systematic review of costs and health state utilities

Objective: To identify evidence in the literature presenting the economic and humanistic (based on health state utility values [HSUVs]) burden of multiple sclerosis (MS) and report the incremental burden of secondary progressive MS (SPMS) compared with relapsing-remitting MS (RRMS).Methods: Electronic databases (Embase, MEDLINE, MEDLINE In-Process, Cochrane Library) and other relevant repositories were systematically searched from the date of inception until November 2019 for evidence on the economic burden of MS, or HSUVs in patients with MS. Data were extracted from studies investigating cost data or HSUVs for patients with SPMS compared with RRMS.Results: In total, 25 studies were identified that reported data on the economic and HSUV burden of SPMS versus RRMS: 18 studies reported cost data and nine presented HSUVs. Overall, costs associated with SPMS were consistently higher than those for RRMS. Major cost drivers appeared to shift following transition from RRMS to SPMS, with higher direct medical costs associated with RRMS than with SPMS, while the opposite was true for direct non-medical costs and indirect costs. In all studies presenting HSUVs specifically in patients with SPMS, the disease burden was greater (indicated by lower HSUV scores or a negative regression coefficient vs RRMS) for patients with SPMS than for those with RRMS. Fatigue and psychological stress (including depression) were identified as key drivers of this reduced health-related quality of life (HRQoL).Conclusions: Our findings indicate that SPMS is associated with higher costs and more substantial HRQoL decrements than RRMS. These results highlight the substantial unmet need for effective treatments that can slow disease progression in patients with SPMS, which, in turn, would reduce the rate of HRQoL deterioration and increasing healthcare costs.

Real-World Treatment of Patients with Multiple Sclerosis per MS Subtype and Associated Healthcare Resource Use: An Analysis Based on 13,333 Patients in Germany

INTRODUCTION

The aim of this study was to describe the real-word treatment and associated healthcare resource use (HCRU) of multiple sclerosis (MS) patients, as stratified by different MS subtypes.

METHODS

All patients with MS continuously insured by two German statutory healthcare insurance funds from 2011 to 2015 were enrolled. These patients were categorized into four subgroups according to their MS type as follows: clinically isolated syndrome (CIS); relapsing remittent MS (RRMS); primary progressive MS (PPMS); and secondary progressive MS (SPMS). Sociodemographic characteristics, treatments, and HCRU for 2015 were analyzed. Treatment cascades for treatment-naïve patients were also determined.

RESULTS

A total of 13,333 patients with MS were identified. The largest proportion of patients had RRMS (41.9%), followed by PPMS (17.1%). Mean age of the enrolled patients was 50.2 years, and 70.7% were female. Among all patients, 38.3% of those with CIS, 22.4% with PPMS, 69.6% with RRMS, and 33.9% with SPMS received a prescription of a disease-modifying immunomodulatory agent, with interferon beta-1a being the most frequently prescribed agent. Likewise, 14.5, 18.5, 19.9, and 21.5% of patients with CIS, PPMS, RRMS, and SPMS, respectively, received a flare-up treatment with glucocorticoids. MS-associated overall costs, including indirect costs for MS-associated days absent from work, were € 16,433, with costs related to MS medication (€ 8770; 53.4%) being the main driver of costs in all subgroups. MS-associated costs according to MS subtypes were € 12,427 for CIS patients, € 14,459 for PPMS patients, € 20,583 for RRMS patients, and € 17,554 for SPMS patients.

CONCLUSION

Among the four MS subtypes, RRMS patients most often received a disease-modifying immunomodulatory treatment. Consequently, healthcare costs were highest for patients with this MS subtype. Contrary to the treatment guideline, a substantial percentage of patients with CIS, RRMS, and SPMS did not receive any disease-modifying immunomodulatory treatment.