Cell death and the developing enteric nervous system

Cutting-edge regenerative therapy for Hirschsprung disease and its allied disorders

Hirschsprung disease (HSCR) and its associated disorders (AD-HSCR) often result in severe hypoperistalsis caused by enteric neuropathy, mesenchymopathy, and myopathy. Notably, HSCR involving the small intestine, isolated hypoganglionosis, chronic idiopathic intestinal pseudo-obstruction, and megacystis-microcolon-intestinal hypoperistalsis syndrome carry a poor prognosis. Ultimately, small-bowel transplantation (SBTx) is necessary for refractory cases, but it is highly invasive and outcomes are less than optimal, despite advances in surgical techniques and management. Thus, regenerative therapy has come to light as a potential form of treatment involving regeneration of the enteric nervous system, mesenchyme, and smooth muscle in affected areas. We review the cutting-edge regenerative therapeutic approaches for managing HSCR and AD-HSCR, including the use of enteric nervous system progenitor cells, embryonic stem cells, induced pluripotent stem cells, and mesenchymal stem cells as cell sources, the recipient intestine's microenvironment, and transplantation methods. Perspectives on the future of these treatments are also discussed.

Cerebral dopamine neurotrophic factor-deficiency leads to degeneration of enteric neurons and altered brain dopamine neuronal function in mice

Cerebral dopamine neurotrophic factor (CDNF) is neuroprotective for nigrostriatal dopamine neurons and restores dopaminergic function in animal models of Parkinson’s disease (PD). To understand the role of CDNF in mammals, we generated CDNF knockout mice (Cdnf^−/−), which are viable, fertile, and have a normal life-span. Surprisingly, an age-dependent loss of enteric neurons occurs selectively in the submucosal but not in the myenteric plexus. This neuronal loss is a consequence not of increased apoptosis but of neurodegeneration and autophagy. Quantitatively, the neurodegeneration and autophagy found in the submucosal plexus in duodenum, ileum and colon of the Cdnf^−/− mouse are much greater than in those of Cdnf^+/+ mice. The selective vulnerability of submucosal neurons to the absence of CDNF is reminiscent of the tendency of pathological abnormalities to occur in the submucosal plexus in biopsies of patients with PD. In contrast, the number of substantia nigra dopamine neurons and dopamine and its metabolite concentrations in the striatum are unaltered in Cdnf^−/− mice; however, there is an age-dependent deficit in the function of the dopamine system in Cdnf^−/− male mice analyzed. This is observed as D-amphetamine-induced hyperactivity, aberrant dopamine transporter function, and as increased D-amphetamine-induced dopamine release demonstrating that dopaminergic axon terminal function in the striatum of the Cdnf^−/− mouse brain is altered. The deficiencies of Cdnf^−/− mice, therefore, are reminiscent of those seen in early stages of Parkinson’s disease.

Arundic Acid Prevents Developmental Upregulation of S100B Expression and Inhibits Enteric Glial Development

S100B is expressed in various types of glial cells and is involved in regulating many aspects of their function. However, little is known about its role during nervous system development. In this study, we investigated the effect of inhibiting the onset of S100B synthesis in the development of the enteric nervous system, a network of neurons and glia located in the wall of the gut that is vital for control of gastrointestinal function. Intact gut explants were taken from embryonic day (E)13.5 mice, the day before the first immunohistochemical detection of S100B, and cultured in the presence of arundic acid, an inhibitor of S100B synthesis, for 48 h. The effects on Sox10-immunoreactive enteric neural crest progenitors and Hu-immunoreactive enteric neurons were then analyzed. Culture in arundic acid reduced the proportion of Sox10+ cells and decreased cell proliferation. There was no change in the density of Hu+ enteric neurons, however, a small population of cells exhibited atypical co-expression of both Sox10 and Hu, which was not observed in control cultures. Addition of exogenous S100B to the cultures did not change Sox10+ cell numbers. Overall, our data suggest that cell-intrinsic intracellular S100B is important for maintaining Sox10 and proliferation of the developing enteric glial lineage.

Combination of exogenous cell transplantation and 5-HT4 receptor agonism induce endogenous enteric neural crest-derived cells in a rat hypoganglionosis model

Enteric neural crest-derived cells (ENCCs) can migrate into endogenous ganglia and differentiate into progeny cells, and have even partially rescued bowel function; however, poor reliability and limited functional recovery after ENCC transplantation have yet to be addressed. Here, we investigated the induction of endogenous ENCCs by combining exogenous ENCC transplantation with a 5-HT₄ receptor agonist mosapride in a rat model of hypoganglionosis, established by benzalkonium chloride treatment. ENCCs, isolated from the gut of newborn rats, were labeled with a lentiviral eGFP reporter. ENCCs and rats were treated with the 5-HT₄ receptor agonist/antagonist. The labeled ENCCs were then transplanted into the muscular layer of benzalkonium chloride-treated colons. At given days post-intervention, colonic tissue samples were removed for histological analysis. ENCCs and neurons were detected by eGFP expression and immunoreactivity to p75^NTR and peripherin, respectively. eGFP-positive ENCCs and neurons could survive and maintain levels of fluorescence after transplantation. With longer times post-intervention, the number of peripherin-positive cells gradually increased in all groups. Significantly more peripherin-positive cells were found following ENCCs plus mosapride treatment, compared with the other groups. These results show that exogenous ENCCs combined with the 5-HT₄ receptor agonist effectively induced endogenous ENCCs proliferation and differentiation in a rat hypoganglionosis model.

Geminin prevents DNA damage in vagal neural crest cells to ensure normal enteric neurogenesis

Background

In vertebrate organisms, the neural crest (NC) gives rise to multipotential and highly migratory progenitors which are distributed throughout the embryo and generate, among other structures, the peripheral nervous system, including the intrinsic neuroglial networks of the gut, i.e. the enteric nervous system (ENS). The majority of enteric neurons and glia originate from vagal NC-derived progenitors which invade the foregut mesenchyme and migrate rostro-caudally to colonise the entire length of the gut. Although the migratory behaviour of NC cells has been studied extensively, it remains unclear how their properties and response to microenvironment change as they navigate through complex cellular terrains to reach their target embryonic sites.

Results

Using conditional gene inactivation in mice we demonstrate here that the cell cycle-dependent protein Geminin (Gem) is critical for the survival of ENS progenitors in a stage-dependent manner. Gem deletion in early ENS progenitors (prior to foregut invasion) resulted in cell-autonomous activation of DNA damage response and p53-dependent apoptosis, leading to severe intestinal aganglionosis. In contrast, ablation of Gem shortly after ENS progenitors had invaded the embryonic gut did not result in discernible survival or migratory deficits. In contrast to other developmental systems, we obtained no evidence for a role of Gem in commitment or differentiation of ENS lineages. The stage-dependent resistance of ENS progenitors to mutation-induced genotoxic stress was further supported by the enhanced survival of post gut invasion ENS lineages to γ-irradiation relative to their predecessors.

Conclusions

Our experiments demonstrate that, in mammals, NC-derived ENS lineages are sensitive to genotoxic stress in a stage-specific manner. Following gut invasion, ENS progenitors are distinctly resistant to Gem ablation and irradiation in comparison to their pre-enteric counterparts. These studies suggest that the microenvironment of the embryonic gut protects ENS progenitors and their progeny from genotoxic stress.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12915-016-0314-x) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Stress, sex, and the enteric nervous system

Made up of millions of enteric neurons and glial cells, the enteric nervous system (ENS) is in a key position to modulate the secretomotor function and visceral pain of the gastrointestinal tract. The early life developmental period, through which most of the ENS development occurs, is highly susceptible to microenvironmental perturbation. Over the past decade, accumulating evidence has shown the impact of stress and early life adversity (ELA) on host gastrointestinal pathophysiology. While most of the focus has been on alterations in brain structure and function, limited experimental work in rodents suggest that the enteric nervous system can also be directly affected, as shown by changes in the number, phenotype, and reactivity of enteric nerves. The work of Medland et al. in the current issue of this journal demonstrates that such alterations also occur in pigs, a larger mammalian species with high translational value to human. This work also highlights a sex-differential susceptibility of the ENS to the effect of ELA, which could contribute to the higher prevalence of GI disorders in women. In this mini-review, we will discuss the development and composition of the ENS and related gastrointestinal sensory motor and secretory functions. We will then focus on the influence of stress on the enteric nervous system, with a particular emphasis on neurodevelopmental changes. Finally, we will discuss the influence of sex on those parameters.

Early life adversity in piglets induces long-term upregulation of the enteric cholinergic nervous system and heightened, sex-specific secretomotor neuron responses

BACKGROUND

Early life adversity (ELA) is a risk factor for the later-life onset of gastrointestinal (GI) diseases such as irritable bowel syndrome (IBS); however, the mechanisms are poorly understood. Here, we utilized a porcine model of ELA, early weaning stress (EWS), to investigate the influence of ELA on the development and function of the enteric nervous system (ENS).

METHODS

Female and castrated male (Male-C) piglets were weaned from their sow either at 15 days of age (EWS) or 28 days of age (late weaning control, LWC). At 60 and 170 days of age, ileal mucosa-submucosa preparations were mounted in Ussing chambers and veratridine- and corticotropin releasing factor (CRF)-releasing factor-evoked short circuit current (Isc ) responses were recorded as indices of secretomotor neuron function. Enteric neuron numbers and the expression of select neurotransmitters and their receptors were also measured.

KEY RESULTS

Compared with LWC pigs, female, but not Male-C EWS, pigs exhibited heightened veratridine-induced Isc responses at 60 and 170 days of age that were inhibited with tetrodotoxin and atropine. Ileum from EWS pigs had higher numbers of enteric neurons that were choline acetyltransferase positive. Markers of increased cholinergic signaling (increased acetylcholinesterase) and downregulated mucosal muscarinic receptor 3 gene expression were also observed in EWS pigs.

CONCLUSIONS & INFERENCES

This study demonstrated that EWS in pigs induces lasting and sex-specific hypersensitivity of secretomotor neuron function and upregulation of the cholinergic ENS. These findings may represent a mechanistic link between ELA and lifelong susceptibility to GI diseases such as IBS.

Detection of autophagy in Hirschsprung's disease: implication for its role in aganglionosis

Hirschsprung's disease (HD) is a common congenital gastrointestinal malformation, characterized by the lack of ganglion cells from the distal rectum to the proximal bowel, but the pathogenesis is not well understood. This paper evaluates the effects of autophagy in HD. Using electron microscopy, the autophagosomes were detected in three segments: narrow segment (NS), transitional segment (TS), and dilated segment (DS). Typical autophagosome structures are found in the Auerbach plexus of both NS and TS. Real-time PCR results showed that Beclin1 (NS vs. TS, P<0.01) and LC3 (NS vs. TS, P<0.05) mRNA were the highest in the NS, but p75 (NS vs. TS, P<0.01) was the highest in the DS. Correlation analysis results showed a positive correlation between Beclin1 and LC3 mRNA levels (R=0.736, P=0.000), whereas inverse correlations were found between p75 and Beclin1/LC3 mRNA levels (p75 vs. Beclin1: R=-0.714, P=0.000; p75 vs. LC3: R=-0.619, P=0.000). Immunohistochemistry analyses indicated a consistent result with mRNA levels, by increased Beclin1-positive and LC3-positive neurons, but reduced p75-positive neurons in the Auerbach plexus of TS compared with DS. These findings indicated that autophagy exists in the bowel of patients with HD. On the basis of the detection of the highest expression of the autophagy genes in NS, autophagy may additionally cause the lack of neurons.

Nontoxicity of lentiviral vector infection to viability, migration, apoptosis, and differentiation of postnatal rat enteric neural crest-derived cells

Lentiviral vector infection of enhanced green fluorescent protein fluorescence reporter genes in enteric neural crest-derived cells maintained efficient, stable, long-term labeling and the infected enteric neural crest-derived cells could survive, proliferate, and express fluorescent reporter genes. However, the method does not show whether there is some defined or undefined toxicity to the enteric neural crest-derived cells, which may affect enteric neural crest-derived cells' properties. Here, we evaluated the enteric neural crest-derived cells properties under the influence of lentivirus infection of enhanced green fluorescent protein fluorescence reporter genes. This study used the cell count kit-8 for measurement of vitality, transwell for cell migration, immunocytochemistry for cell count and identification, and tested the apoptosis of the enteric neural crest-derived cells with flow cytometry. The enteric neural crest-derived cells with or without lentivirus and their derivative enteric neural crest-derived cells could form characteristic neurospheres, and maintain their level of fluorescent label steady. When cultured under inducing conditions, enteric neural crest-derived cells differentiated into neurons and glia. The results showed that the enteric neural crest-derived cells with or without lentivirus showed no significant difference in viability, migration, apoptosis, neuronal, and glial ratio. The study identified that lentivirus can be used in a nontoxic manner for infection of enhanced green fluorescent protein fluorescence reporter genes into enteric neural crest-derived cells.

Early-life stress origins of gastrointestinal disease: animal models, intestinal pathophysiology, and translational implications

Early-life stress and adversity are major risk factors in the onset and severity of gastrointestinal (GI) disease in humans later in life. The mechanisms by which early-life stress leads to increased GI disease susceptibility in adult life remain poorly understood. Animal models of early-life stress have provided a foundation from which to gain a more fundamental understanding of this important GI disease paradigm. This review focuses on animal models of early-life stress-induced GI disease, with a specific emphasis on translational aspects of each model to specific human GI disease states. Early postnatal development of major GI systems and the consequences of stress on their development are discussed in detail. Relevant translational differences between species and models are highlighted.

Why are enteric ganglia so small? Role of differential adhesion of enteric neurons and enteric neural crest cells

The avian enteric nervous system (ENS) consists of a vast number of unusually small ganglia compared to other peripheral ganglia. Each ENS ganglion at mid-gestation has a core of neurons and a shell of mesenchymal precursor/glia-like enteric neural crest (ENC) cells. To study ENS cell ganglionation we isolated midgut ENS cells by HNK-1 fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS) from E5 and E8 quail embryos, and from E9 chick embryos. We performed cell-cell aggregation assays which revealed a developmentally regulated functional increase in ENS cell adhesive function, requiring both Ca ²⁺ -dependent and independent adhesion. This was consistent with N-cadherin and NCAM labelling. Neurons sorted to the core of aggregates, surrounded by outer ENC cells, showing that neurons had higher adhesion than ENC cells. The outer surface of aggregates became relatively non-adhesive, correlating with low levels of NCAM and N-cadherin on this surface of the outer non-neuronal ENC cells. Aggregation assays showed that ENS cells FACS selected for NCAM-high and enriched for enteric neurons formed larger and more coherent aggregates than unsorted ENS cells. In contrast, ENS cells of the NCAM-low FACS fraction formed small, disorganised aggregates.  This suggests a novel mechanism for control of ENS ganglion morphogenesis where i) differential adhesion of ENS neurons and ENC cells controls the core/shell ganglionic structure and ii) the ratio of neurons to ENC cells dictates the equilibrium ganglion size by generation of an outer non-adhesive surface.

Spatial and temporal dynamics of cell generations within an invasion wave: a link to cell lineage tracing

Mathematical models of a cell invasion wave have included both continuum partial differential equation (PDE) approaches and discrete agent-based cellular automata (CA) approaches. Here we are interested in modelling the spatial and temporal dynamics of the number of divisions (generation number) that cells have undergone by any time point within an invasion wave. In the CA framework this is performed from agent lineage tracings, while in the PDE approach a multi-species generalized Fisher equation is derived for the cell density within each generation. Both paradigms exhibit qualitatively similar cell generation densities that are spatially organized, with agents of low generation number rapidly attaining a steady state (with average generation number increasing linearly with distance) behind the moving wave and with evolving high generation number at the wavefront. This regularity in the generation spatial distributions is in contrast to the highly stochastic nature of the underlying lineage dynamics of the population. In addition, we construct a method for determining the lineage tracings of all agents without labelling and tracking the agents, but through either a knowledge of the spatial distribution of the generations or the number of agents in each generation. This involves determining generation-dependent proliferation probabilities and using these to define a generation-dependent Galton-Watson (GDGW) process. Monte-Carlo simulations of the GDGW process are used to determine the individual lineage tracings. The lineages of the GDGW process are analyzed using Lorenz curves and found to be similar to outcomes generated by direct lineage tracing in CA realizations. This analysis provides the basis for a potentially useful technique for deducing cell lineage data when imaging every cell is not feasible.

Expression and possible role of IGF-IR in the mouse gastric myenteric plexus and smooth muscles

Insulin-like growth factor-I (IGF-I) and its receptor (IGF-IR) have tremendous trophic effects on the central, peripheral and enteric neurons. The loss of IGF-IR contributes to the development of diabetic gastroparesis. However, the nature and the function of the IGF-IR(+) cells in the gastric myenteric plexus remain unclear. In this study, anti-ChAT, anti-S100β or anti-c-KIT antibodies were used to co-label IGF-IR(+) cells and neurons, glial cells or interstitial cells of Cajal (ICCs), respectively. We also generated type 1 diabetic mice (DM) to explore the influence of impaired IGF-I/IGF-IR in the myenteric neurons. Results showed that IGF-IR was expressed in the epithelium, smooth muscles and myenteric plexi of the mouse stomach. Most of the IGF-IR(+) cells in the myenteric plexi were ChAT(+) cholinergic neurons, but not enteric glial cells and there were more IGF-IR(+) neurons and fibers in the gastric antrum than in the corpus. The IGF-IR(+)/ChAT(+) neurons and ICCs were closely juxtaposed, but distinctly distributed in the myenteric plexus, indicating a possible role for the IGF-IR(+)/ChAT(+) neurons in the mediation of gastric motility through ICCs. Moreover, the decrease of IGF-IR and cholinergic neurons in the myenteric plexi and smooth muscles of DM mice suggested that IGF-I/IGF-IR signaling might play a role in neuron survival and neurite outgrowth, as well as stem cell factor (SCF) production, which is required for the development of ICCs. Our results provide insights into the effects of IGF-I/IGF-IR signaling on the development of gastrointestinal motility disorders.

GDNF and GFRα co-receptor family in the developing feline gut

Glial cell-line derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF) and the GFRα co-receptors play a role in the developing enteric nervous system. The co-receptors elicit their action by binding receptor tyrosine kinase RET. This immunohistochemical study reports the presence of GDNF and its specific co-receptor GFRα1 in the cat gastrointestinal apparatus during development, from stage 9 to 22. At stage 9 and 11, immunoreactivity (IR) to GDNF was observed in the cells of mesenchyme of the anterior gut. From stage 14 to 22, GDNF IR was detected in nervous plexuses; moreover, GDNF and GFRα1 IR appeared localized in gastrointestinal endocrine cells. The presence of GDNF in the enteric nervous system and in the endocrine cells suggests an involvement of this neurotrophic factor in the gastrointestinal development. Moreover, the presence of the co-receptor GFRα1 in endocrine cells and its absence in the enteric nervous system seems to indicate a different mode of transduction of GDNF signal. GFRα2 and GFRα3 co-receptors were not detected.

Cell lineage tracing in the developing enteric nervous system: superstars revealed by experiment and simulation

Cell lineage tracing is a powerful tool for understanding how proliferation and differentiation of individual cells contribute to population behaviour. In the developing enteric nervous system (ENS), enteric neural crest (ENC) cells move and undergo massive population expansion by cell division within self-growing mesenchymal tissue. We show that single ENC cells labelled to follow clonality in the intestine reveal extraordinary and unpredictable variation in number and position of descendant cells, even though ENS development is highly predictable at the population level. We use an agent-based model to simulate ENC colonization and obtain agent lineage tracing data, which we analyse using econometric data analysis tools. In all realizations, a small proportion of identical initial agents accounts for a substantial proportion of the total final agent population. We term these individuals superstars. Their existence is consistent across individual realizations and is robust to changes in model parameters. This inequality of outcome is amplified at elevated proliferation rate. The experiments and model suggest that stochastic competition for resources is an important concept when understanding biological processes which feature high levels of cell proliferation. The results have implications for cell-fate processes in the ENS.

Enteric nervous system development: migration, differentiation, and disease

The enteric nervous system (ENS) provides the intrinsic innervation of the bowel and is the most neurochemically diverse branch of the peripheral nervous system, consisting of two layers of ganglia and fibers encircling the gastrointestinal tract. The ENS is vital for life and is capable of autonomous regulation of motility and secretion. Developmental studies in model organisms and genetic studies of the most common congenital disease of the ENS, Hirschsprung disease, have provided a detailed understanding of ENS development. The ENS originates in the neural crest, mostly from the vagal levels of the neuraxis, which invades, proliferates, and migrates within the intestinal wall until the entire bowel is colonized with enteric neural crest-derived cells (ENCDCs). After initial migration, the ENS develops further by responding to guidance factors and morphogens that pattern the bowel concentrically, differentiating into glia and neuronal subtypes and wiring together to form a functional nervous system. Molecules controlling this process, including glial cell line-derived neurotrophic factor and its receptor RET, endothelin (ET)-3 and its receptor endothelin receptor type B, and transcription factors such as SOX10 and PHOX2B, are required for ENS development in humans. Important areas of active investigation include mechanisms that guide ENCDC migration, the role and signals downstream of endothelin receptor type B, and control of differentiation, neurochemical coding, and axonal targeting. Recent work also focuses on disease treatment by exploring the natural role of ENS stem cells and investigating potential therapeutic uses. Disease prevention may also be possible by modifying the fetal microenvironment to reduce the penetrance of Hirschsprung disease-causing mutations.

The developmental genetics of Hirschsprung's disease

Hirschsprung's disease (HSCR), also known as aganglionic megacolon, derives from a congenital malformation of the enteric nervous system (ENS). It displays an incidence of 1 in 5000 live births with a 4:1 male to female sex ratio. Clinical signs include severe constipation and distended bowel due to a non-motile colon. If left untreated, aganglionic megacolon is lethal. This severe congenital condition is caused by the absence of colonic neural ganglia and thus lack of intrinsic innervation of the colon due in turn to improper colonization of the developing intestines by ENS progenitor cells. These progenitor cells are derived from a transient stem cell population called neural crest cells (NCC). The genetics of HSCR is complex and can involve mutations in multiple genes. However, it is estimated that mutations in known genes account for less than half of the cases of HSCR observed clinically. The male sex bias is currently unexplained. The objective of this review is to provide an overview of the pathophysiology and genetics of HSCR, within the context of our current knowledge of NCC development, sex chromosome genetics and laboratory models.

Diabetes-related alterations in the enteric nervous system and its microenvironment

Gastric intestinal symptoms common among diabetic patients are often caused by intestinal motility abnormalities related to enteric neuropathy. It has recently been demonstrated that the nitrergic subpopulation of myenteric neurons are especially susceptible to the development of diabetic neuropathy. Additionally, different susceptibility of nitrergic neurons located in different intestinal segments to diabetic damage and their different levels of responsiveness to insulin treatment have been revealed. These findings indicate the importance of the neuronal microenvironment in the pathogenesis of diabetic nitrergic neuropathy. The main focus of this review therefore was to summarize recent advances related to the diabetes-related selective nitrergic neuropathy and associated motility disturbances. Special attention was given to the findings on capillary endothelium and enteric glial cells. Growing evidence indicates that capillary endothelium adjacent to the myenteric ganglia and enteric glial cells surrounding them are determinative in establishing the ganglionic microenvironment. Additionally, recent advances in the development of new strategies to improve glycemic control in type 1 and type 2 diabetes mellitus are also considered in this review. Finally, looking to the future, the recent and promising results of metagenomics for the characterization of the gut microbiome in health and disease such as diabetes are highlighted.