β-amyloid PET harmonisation across longitudinal studies: Application to AIBL, ADNI and OASIS3

Quantitative Brain Amyloid PET

Since the development of amyloid tracers for PET imaging, there has been interest in quantifying amyloid burden in the brains of patients with Alzheimer disease. Quantitative amyloid PET imaging is poised to become a valuable approach in disease staging, theranostics, monitoring, and as an outcome measure for interventional studies. Yet, there are significant challenges and hurdles to overcome before it can be implemented into widespread clinical practice. On November 17, 2022, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, Society of Nuclear Medicine and Molecular Imaging, and Medical Imaging and Technology Alliance cosponsored a public workshop comprising experts from academia, industry, and government agencies to discuss the role of quantitative brain amyloid PET imaging in staging, prognosis, and longitudinal assessment of Alzheimer disease. The workshop discussed a range of topics, including available radiopharmaceuticals for amyloid imaging; the methodology, metrics, and analytic validity of quantitative amyloid PET imaging; its use in disease staging, prognosis, and monitoring of progression; and challenges facing the field. This report provides a high-level summary of the presentations and the discussion.

Investigating reliable amyloid accumulation in Centiloids: Results from the AMYPAD Prognostic and Natural History Study

INTRODUCTION

To support clinical trial designs focused on early interventions, our study determined reliable early amyloid-β (Aβ) accumulation based on Centiloids (CL) in pre-dementia populations.

METHODS

A total of 1032 participants from the Amyloid Imaging to Prevent Alzheimer's Disease-Prognostic and Natural History Study (AMYPAD-PNHS) and Insight46 who underwent [18F]flutemetamol, [18F]florbetaben or [18F]florbetapir amyloid-PET were included. A normative strategy was used to define reliable accumulation by estimating the 95th percentile of longitudinal measurements in sub-populations (NPNHS = 101/750, NInsight46 = 35/382) expected to remain stable over time. The baseline CL threshold that optimally predicts future accumulation was investigated using precision-recall analyses. Accumulation rates were examined using linear mixed-effect models.

RESULTS

Reliable accumulation in the PNHS was estimated to occur at >3.0 CL/year. Baseline CL of 16 [12,19] best predicted future Aβ-accumulators. Rates of amyloid accumulation were tracer-independent, lower for APOE ε4 non-carriers, and for subjects with higher levels of education.

DISCUSSION

Our results support a 12-20 CL window for inclusion into early secondary prevention studies. Reliable accumulation definition warrants further investigations.

Impact of simulated reduced injected dose on the assessment of amyloid PET scans

PURPOSE

To investigate the impact of reduced injected doses on the quantitative and qualitative assessment of the amyloid PET tracers [18F]flutemetamol and [18F]florbetaben.

METHODS

Cognitively impaired and unimpaired individuals (N = 250, 36% Aβ-positive) were included and injected with [18F]flutemetamol (N = 175) or [18F]florbetaben (N = 75). PET scans were acquired in list-mode (90-110 min post-injection) and reduced-dose images were simulated to generate images of 75, 50, 25, 12.5 and 5% of the original injected dose. Images were reconstructed using vendor-provided reconstruction tools and visually assessed for Aβ-pathology. SUVRs were calculated for a global cortical and three smaller regions using a cerebellar cortex reference tissue, and Centiloid was computed. Absolute and percentage differences in SUVR and CL were calculated between dose levels, and the ability to discriminate between Aβ- and Aβ + scans was evaluated using ROC analyses. Finally, intra-reader agreement between the reduced dose and 100% images was evaluated.

RESULTS

At 5% injected dose, change in SUVR was 3.72% and 3.12%, with absolute change in Centiloid 3.35CL and 4.62CL, for [18F]flutemetamol and [18F]florbetaben, respectively. At 12.5% injected dose, percentage change in SUVR and absolute change in Centiloid were < 1.5%. AUCs for discriminating Aβ- from Aβ + scans were high (AUC ≥ 0.94) across dose levels, and visual assessment showed intra-reader agreement of > 80% for both tracers.

CONCLUSION

This proof-of-concept study showed that for both [18F]flutemetamol and [18F]florbetaben, adequate quantitative and qualitative assessments can be obtained at 12.5% of the original injected dose. However, decisions to reduce the injected dose should be made considering the specific clinical or research circumstances.

A ROI-based quantitative pipeline for 18F-FDG PET metabolism and pCASL perfusion joint analysis: Validation of the 18F-FDG PET line

In Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI), the study of brain metabolism, provided by 18F-FluoroDeoxyGlucose Positron Emission Tomography (18F-FDG PET) can be integrated with brain perfusion through pseudo-Continuous Arterial Spin Labeling Magnetic Resonance sequences (MR pCASL). Cortical hypometabolism identification generally relies on wide control group datasets; pCASL control groups are instead not publicly available yet, due to lack of standardization in the acquisition parameters. This study presents a quantitative pipeline to be applied to PET and pCASL data to coherently analyze metabolism and perfusion inside 16 matching cortical regions of interest (ROIs) derived from the AAL3 atlas. The PET line is tuned on 36 MCI patients and 107 healthy control subjects, to agree in identifying hypometabolic regions with clinical reference methods (visual analysis supported by a vendor tool and Statistical Parametric Mapping, SPM, with two parametrizations here identified as SPM-A and SPM-B). The analysis was conducted for each ROI separately. The proposed PET analysis pipeline obtained accuracy 78 % and Cohen's к 60 % vs visual analysis, accuracy 79 % and Cohen's к 58 % vs SPM-A, accuracy 77 % and Cohen's к 54 % vs SPM-B. Cohen's к resulted not significantly different from SPM-A and SPM-B Cohen's к when assuming visual analysis as reference method (p-value 0.61 and 0.31 respectively). Considering SPM-A as reference method, Cohen's к is not significantly different from SPM-B Cohen's к as well (p-value = 1.00). The complete PET-pCASL pipeline was then preliminarily applied on 5 MCI patients and metabolism-perfusion regional correlations were assessed. The proposed approach can be considered as a promising tool for PET-pCASL joint analyses in MCI, even in the absence of a pCASL control group, to perform metabolism-perfusion regional correlation studies, and to assess and compare perfusion in hypometabolic or normo-metabolic areas.

Evaluation of novel data-driven metrics of amyloid β deposition for longitudinal PET studies

PURPOSE

Positron emission tomography (PET) provides in vivo quantification of amyloid-β (Aβ) pathology. Established methods for assessing Aβ burden can be affected by physiological and technical factors. Novel, data-driven metrics have been developed to account for these sources of variability. We aimed to evaluate the performance of four of these amyloid PET metrics against conventional techniques, using a common set of criteria.

METHODS

Three cohorts were used for evaluation: Insight 46 (N=464, [18F]florbetapir), AIBL (N=277, [18F]flutemetamol), and an independent test-retest data (N=10, [18F]flutemetamol). Established metrics of amyloid tracer uptake included the Centiloid (CL) and where dynamic data was available, the non-displaceable binding potential (BPND). The four data-driven metrics computed were the amyloid load (Aβ load), the Aβ-PET pathology accumulation index (Aβ index), the Centiloid derived from non-negative matrix factorisation (CLNMF), and the amyloid pattern similarity score (AMPSS). These metrics were evaluated using reliability and repeatability in test-retest data, associations with BPND and CL, variability of the rate of change and sample size estimates to detect a 25% slowing in Aβ accumulation.

RESULTS

All metrics showed good reliability. Aβ load, Aβ index and CLNMF were strong associated with the BPND. The associations with CL suggest that cross-sectional measures of CLNMF, Aβ index and Aβ load are robust across studies. Sample size estimates for secondary prevention trial scenarios were the lowest for CLNMF and Aβ load compared to the CL.

CONCLUSION

Among the novel data-driven metrics evaluated, the Aβ load, the Aβ index and the CLNMF can provide comparable performance to more established quantification methods of Aβ PET tracer uptake. The CLNMF and Aβ load could offer a more precise alternative to CL, although further studies in larger cohorts should be conducted.

A universal neocortical mask for Centiloid quantification

INTRODUCTION

The Centiloid (CL) project was developed to harmonize the quantification of amyloid beta (Aβ) positron emission tomography (PET) scans to a unified scale. The CL neocortical mask was defined using 11C Pittsburgh compound B (PiB), overlooking potential differences in regional distribution among Aβ tracers. We created a universal mask using an independent dataset of five Aβ tracers, and investigated its impact on inter-tracer agreement, tracer variability, and group separation.

METHODS

Using data from the Alzheimer's Dementia Onset and Progression in International Cohorts (ADOPIC) study (Australian Imaging Biomarkers and Lifestyle + Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative + Open Access Series of Imaging Studies), age-matched pairs of mild Alzheimer's disease (AD) and healthy controls (HC) were selected: 18F-florbetapir (N = 147 pairs), 18F-florbetaben (N = 22), 18F-flutemetamol (N = 10), 18F-NAV (N = 42), 11C-PiB (N = 63). The images were spatially and standardized uptake value ratio normalized. For each tracer, the mean AD-HC difference image was thresholded to maximize the overlap with the standard neocortical mask. The universal mask was defined as the intersection of all five masks. It was evaluated on the Global Alzheimer's Association Interactive Network (GAAIN) head-to-head datasets in terms of inter-tracer agreement and variance in the young controls (YC) and on the ADOPIC dataset comparing separation between HC/AD and HC/mild cognitive impairment (MCI).

RESULTS

In the GAAIN dataset, the universal mask led to a small reduction in the variance of the YC, and a small increase in the inter-tracer agreement. In the ADOPIC dataset, it led to a better separation between HC/AD and HC/MCI at baseline.

DISCUSSION

The universal CL mask led to an increase in inter-tracer agreement and group separation. Those increases were, however, very small, and do not provide sufficient benefits to support departing from the existing standard CL mask, which is suitable for the quantification of all Aβ tracers.

HIGHLIGHTS

This study built an amyloid universal mask using a matched cohort for the five most commonly used amyloid positron emission tomography tracers.There was a high overlap between each tracer-specific mask.Differences in quantification and group separation between the standard and universal mask were small.The existing standard Centiloid mask is suitable for the quantification of all amyloid beta tracers.

Probabilistic estimation for across-batch compatibility enhancement for amyloid PET

INTRODUCTION

It is necessary to accurately account for systematic differences due to variability in scanners, radiotracers, and acquisition protocols in multisite studies combining amyloid imaging data.

METHODS

We propose Probabilistic Estimation for Across-batch Compatibility Enhancement (PEACE), a fully Bayesian multimodal extension of the widely used ComBat harmonization model, and we apply it to harmonize regional amyloid positron emission tomography data from two scanners.

RESULTS

Simulations show that PEACE recovers true harmonized values better than ComBat, even for unimodal data. PEACE harmonization of multiscanner regional amyloid imaging data yields results that agree better with longitudinal data compared to ComBat, without removing the known biological effects of age or apolipoprotein E genotype.

DISCUSSION

PEACE outperforms ComBat in both unimodal and bimodal contexts, is applicable to multisite amyloid imaging data, and holds promise for the harmonization of other neuroimaging data over ComBat.

HIGHLIGHTS

We introduce PEACE, a fully Bayesian multimodal extension of ComBat harmonization.Simulations show that PEACE recovers true harmonized values better than ComBat.PEACE accurately harmonizes multiscanner regional amyloid imaging data.

Operationalizing the centiloid scale for [18F]florbetapir PET studies on PET/MRI

INTRODUCTION

The Centiloid scale aims to harmonize amyloid beta (Aβ) positron emission tomography (PET) measures across different analysis methods. As Centiloids were created using PET/computerized tomography (CT) data and are influenced by scanner differences, we investigated the Centiloid transformation with data from Insight 46 acquired with PET/magnetic resonanceimaging (MRI).

METHODS

We transformed standardized uptake value ratios (SUVRs) from 432 florbetapir PET/MRI scans processed using whole cerebellum (WC) and white matter (WM) references, with and without partial volume correction. Gaussian-mixture-modelling-derived cutpoints for Aβ PET positivity were converted.

RESULTS

The Centiloid cutpoint was 14.2 for WC SUVRs. The relationship between WM and WC uptake differed between the calibration and testing datasets, producing implausibly low WM-based Centiloids. Linear adjustment produced a WM-based cutpoint of 18.1.

DISCUSSION

Transformation of PET/MRI florbetapir data to Centiloids is valid. However, further understanding of the effects of acquisition or biological factors on the transformation using a WM reference is needed.

HIGHLIGHTS

Centiloid conversion of amyloid beta positron emission tomography (PET) data aims to standardize results.Centiloid values can be influenced by differences in acquisition.We converted florbetapir PET/magnetic resonance imaging data from a large birth cohort.Whole cerebellum referenced values could be reliably transformed to Centiloids.White matter referenced values may be less generalizable between datasets.

Orthogonal latent space learning with feature weighting and graph learning for multimodal Alzheimer's disease diagnosis

Recent studies have shown that multimodal neuroimaging data provide complementary information of the brain and latent space-based methods have achieved promising results in fusing multimodal data for Alzheimer's disease (AD) diagnosis. However, most existing methods treat all features equally and adopt nonorthogonal projections to learn the latent space, which cannot retain enough discriminative information in the latent space. Besides, they usually preserve the relationships among subjects in the latent space based on the similarity graph constructed on original features for performance boosting. However, the noises and redundant features significantly corrupt the graph. To address these limitations, we propose an Orthogonal Latent space learning with Feature weighting and Graph learning (OLFG) model for multimodal AD diagnosis. Specifically, we map multiple modalities into a common latent space by orthogonal constrained projection to capture the discriminative information for AD diagnosis. Then, a feature weighting matrix is utilized to sort the importance of features in AD diagnosis adaptively. Besides, we devise a regularization term with learned graph to preserve the local structure of the data in the latent space and integrate the graph construction into the learning processing for accurately encoding the relationships among samples. Instead of constructing a similarity graph for each modality, we learn a joint graph for multiple modalities to capture the correlations among modalities. Finally, the representations in the latent space are projected into the target space to perform AD diagnosis. An alternating optimization algorithm with proved convergence is developed to solve the optimization objective. Extensive experimental results show the effectiveness of the proposed method.