Cost-effectiveness of spinal muscular atrophy newborn screening based on real-world data in Belgium

Cost-utility analysis of newborn screening for spinal muscular atrophy in Japan

AIMS

Spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) is a rare genetic disorder characterized by progressive muscle weakness, atrophy, respiratory failure, and in severe cases, infantile death. Early detection and treatment before symptom onset may substantially improve outcomes, allowing patients to achieve age-appropriate motor milestones and longer survival. We assessed the cost-utility of newborn screening (NBS) for SMA in Japan.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A cost-utility model (decision tree and Markov model) compared lifetime health effects and costs between "NBS" for SMA (presymptomatic treatment) or "no NBS" (treatment initiated at symptom onset). Model inputs were sourced from literature, local data, and expert opinion. Sensitivity and scenario analyses were conducted to assess model robustness and data validity.

RESULTS

Based on the 1:10,000 SMA incidence, it was estimated that 43 newborns/year would have SMA, and a total of 39 patients with SMA would initiate presymptomatic treatment after NBS. An estimated 736 quality-adjusted life-years were gained per annual birth cohort with NBS. NBS for SMA was dominant compared with no NBS (i.e. less costly and more effective), with ¥8,856,960,096 reduced total costs with NBS versus no NBS (base-case). Sensitivity and scenario analyses supported cost effectiveness of NBS for SMA versus no NBS. A greater percentage of patients was estimated to enjoy longer survival and be without permanent assisted ventilation with NBS versus no NBS.

LIMITATIONS

Real-world observations may differ from single-arm clinical trial outcomes. It was assumed that patients with SMA identified via NBS were asymptomatic and would receive treatment prior to symptoms. Best supportive care was not considered, and Japan-specific variations in gene replacement therapy protocol were not fully reflected.

CONCLUSION

NBS for SMA allows for early identification of patients with SMA and treatment initiation before symptom onset, improving health outcomes and reducing total costs than without NBS.

Newborn screening facilitates early theranostics and improved spinal muscular atrophy outcome: five-year real-world evidence from Taiwan

BACKGROUND

Recent findings indicate that infants with spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) treated early through newborn screening (NBS) have better outcomes. This study aimed to investigate the long-term outcomes of a 5-year SMA NBS program in Taiwan.

RESULTS

From September 2017 to August 2022, two NBS centers screened patients for SMN1 homozygous deletion using quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) or the Sequenom MassARRAY platform and subsequently confirmed the findings using multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification (MLPA). Implementation of SMA NBS using RT-PCR or MassARRAY platform efficiently led to the detection of neonates with homozygous survival motor neuron 1 (SMN1) deletions at a median age of 9 (range 4-14) days. Among the 446,966 newborns screened, 22 were detected to have a homozygous deletion of SMN1, followed by MLPA confirmation. One patient initially showed negative screening results but was later confirmed to have a compound heterozygous mutation. Among the 23 confirmed cases, 8 patients had two SMN2 copies (all classified as SMA type 1), 11 patients had three SMN2 copies (including 4 with SMA type 1, 2 with SMA type 2, 3 with SMA type 3, and 2 asymptomatic cases), and 4 patients had four SMN2 copies (all asymptomatic). The mean (median) follow-up duration for 19 survivors was 4.2 (5.0) years. All patients with two SMN2 copies developed symptoms within 62 days; those with three SMN2 copies experienced disease onset within 1 year. After diagnosis, most patients were on a watch and wait to receive disease-modifying therapy (DMT) due to initial lack of insurance coverage and limitations on indications after coverage was granted. Of the 19 children who received DMT, the outcomes included 12 walkers, 1 walker requiring support, 3 sitters, 1 non-sitter, and 2 patients with SMA type 1b with two SMN2 copies who succumbed to acute respiratory failure.

CONCLUSIONS

This 5-year SMA NBS study using RT-PCR or the MassARRAY platform, along with an extended follow-up, demonstrates that early diagnosis and prompt treatment can enhance SMA clinical outcomes and change its natural progression in the therapeutic era. Infants with NBS who received presymptomatic DMT had better clinical outcomes than those who received symptomatic DMT.

Results of the Hungarian Newborn Screening Pilot Program for Spinal Muscular Atrophy

The growing need to identify spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) patients as early as possible has shifted attention to newborn screening (NBS). The aim of the present study was to evaluate the possibility of including the SMA-NBS in the Hungarian screening panel. As the first step, a government-funded pilot program started in November 2022 and continued until the end of 2023. Evaluation of the first 14 months was followed by the decision to lengthen the program until the end of 2024, which was further supported by the needs of society. Screening tests were performed in both Hungarian national screening laboratories uniformly using the combined EONIS SCID-SMA real-time PCR assay kit by Revvity, for the newborns whose parents gave written consent for the analysis. Altogether, 155,985 newborns were screened during the 26 months of the program, which was 87% of all newborns involved in the national neonatal screens of the same period. All 19 newborns identified on the screen were diagnosed with SMA, confirmed by a multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification assay (MLPA). The favorable results of the pilot study support the inclusion of the SMA in the national screening panel at the earliest possible date.

X-linked myotubular myopathy: an untreated treatable disease

INTRODUCTION

X-linked myotubular myopathy (XLMTM) is a life-threatening congenital disorder characterized by severe respiratory and motor impairment. This disease presents significant therapeutic challenges, with various strategies being explored to address its underlying pathology. Among these approaches, gene replacement therapy has demonstrated substantial functional improvements in clinical trials. However, safety issues emerged across different therapeutic approaches, highlighting the need for further research.

AREAS COVERED

This review provides a comprehensive analysis of the data gathered from natural history studies, preclinical models and clinical trials, with a particular focus on gene replacement therapy for XLMTM. The different therapeutic strategies are addressed, including their outcomes and associated safety concerns.

EXPERT OPINION

Despite the encouraging potential of gene therapy for XLMTM, the occurrence of safety challenges emphasizes the urgent need for a more comprehensive understanding of the disease's complex phenotype. Enhancing preclinical models to more accurately mimic the full spectrum of disease manifestations will be crucial for optimizing therapeutic strategies and reducing risks in future clinical applications.

Why should a 5q spinal muscular atrophy neonatal screening program be started?

Spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) is a genetic neuromuscular progressive disorder that is currently treatable. The sooner the disease-modifying therapies are started, the better the prognosis. Newborn screening for SMA, which is already performed in many countries, has been scheduled to begin in the near future. The development of a well-organized program is paramount to achieve favorable outcomes for the child who is born with the disease and for the costs involved in health care. We herein present a review paper hoping to point out that SMA neonatal screening is urgent and will not increase the cost of its care.

Treatment Options in Spinal Muscular Atrophy: A Pragmatic Approach for Clinicians

Spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) is a rare neurodegenerative neuromuscular disorder with a wide phenotypic spectrum of severity. SMA was previously life limiting for patients with the most severe phenotype and resulted in progressive disability for those with less severe phenotypes. This has changed dramatically in the past few years with the approvals of three disease-modifying treatments. We review the evidence supporting the use of currently approved SMA treatments (nusinersen, onasemnogene abeparvovec, and risdiplam), focusing on mechanisms of action, side effect profiles, published clinical trial data, health economics, and pending questions. Whilst there is robust data from clinical trials of efficacy and side effect profile for individual drugs in select SMA populations, there are no comparative head-to-head clinical trials. This presents a challenge for clinicians who need to make recommendations on the best treatment option for an individual patient and we hope to provide a pragmatic approach for clinicians across each SMA profile based on current evidence.

Current Status of Newborn Bloodspot Screening Worldwide 2024: A Comprehensive Review of Recent Activities (2020-2023)

Newborn bloodspot screening (NBS) began in the early 1960s based on the work of Dr. Robert "Bob" Guthrie in Buffalo, NY, USA. His development of a screening test for phenylketonuria on blood absorbed onto a special filter paper and transported to a remote testing laboratory began it all. Expansion of NBS to large numbers of asymptomatic congenital conditions flourishes in many settings while it has not yet been realized in others. The need for NBS as an efficient and effective public health prevention strategy that contributes to lowered morbidity and mortality wherever it is sustained is well known in the medical field but not necessarily by political policy makers. Acknowledging the value of national NBS reports published in 2007, the authors collaborated to create a worldwide NBS update in 2015. In a continuing attempt to review the progress of NBS globally, and to move towards a more harmonized and equitable screening system, we have updated our 2015 report with information available at the beginning of 2024. Reports on sub-Saharan Africa and the Caribbean, missing in 2015, have been included. Tables popular in the previous report have been updated with an eye towards harmonized comparisons. To emphasize areas needing attention globally, we have used regional tables containing similar listings of conditions screened, numbers of screening laboratories, and time at which specimen collection is recommended. Discussions are limited to bloodspot screening.