Placental Diversity in Malagasy Tenrecs: Placentation in Shrew Tenrecs (Microgale spp.), The Mole-Like Rice Tenrec (Oryzorictes hova) and The Web-Footed Tenrec (Limnogale mergulus)

Genomics, the diversification of mammals, and the evolution of placentation

When and why did variations in placental structure and function evolve? Such questions cannot be addressed without a reliable version of mammalian phylogeny. Twenty-five years ago, the mammalian tree was reshaped by molecular phylogenetics. Soon it was shown, in contrast to prevailing theories, that the common ancestor of placental mammals had invasive placentation. Subsequently, evolution of many other features of extraembryonic membranes was addressed. This endeavour stimulated research to fill gaps in our knowledge of placental morphology. Last year the mammalian tree was again revised based on a large set of genomic data. With that in mind, this review provides an update on placentation in the nineteen orders of placental mammals, incorporating much recent data. The principal features such as shape, interdigitation, the interhaemal barrier and the yolk sac are summarized in synoptic tables. The evolution of placental traits and its timing is then explored by reference to the revised mammalian tree. Examples are the early appearance of epitheliochorial placentation in the common ancestor of artiodactyls, perissodactyls, pangolins and carnivores (with reversion to invasive forms in the latter) and later refinements such as the binucleate trophoblast cells and placentomes of ruminants. In primates, the intervillous space gradually evolved from the more basic labyrinth whereas trophoblast invasion of the decidua was a late development in humans and great apes. Only seldom can we glimpse the "why" of placental evolution. The best examples concern placental hormones, including some striking examples of convergent evolution such as the chorionic gonadotropins of primates and equids. In concluding, I review current ideas about what drives placental evolution and identify significant gaps in our knowledge of placentation, including several relevant to the evolution of placentation in primates.

Evolutionary Patterns of Maternal Recognition of Pregnancy and Implantation in Eutherian Mammals

The implantation of the embryo into the maternal endometrium is a complex process associated with the evolution of viviparity and placentation in mammals. In this review, we provide an overview of maternal recognition of pregnancy signals and implantation modes in eutherians, focusing on their diverse mechanisms and evolutionary patterns. Different pregnancy recognition signals and implantation modes have evolved in eutherian mammals, reflecting the remarkable diversity of specializations in mammals following the evolution of viviparity. Superficial implantation is the ancestral implantation mode in Eutheria and its major clades. The other modes, secondary, partially, and primary interstitial implantation have each independently evolved multiple times in the evolutionary history of eutherians. Although significant progress has been made in understanding pregnancy recognition signals and implantation modes, there is still much to uncover. Rodents and chiropterans (especially Phyllostomidae) offer valuable opportunities for studying the transitions among implantation modes, but data is still scarce for these diverse orders. Further research should focus on unstudied taxa so we can establish robust patterns of evolutionary changes in pregnancy recognition signaling and implantation modes.

IFPA Senior Award Lecture: Mammalian fetal membranes

BACKGROUND

Fetal membrane development varies greatly across mammals with significant implications for models of human placentation.

METHOD

Therefore the major patterns of fetal membrane development are reviewed with special focus on functions of the inverted yolk sac in murine rodents.

FINDINGS

In most mammals, yolk sac and chorion form a choriovitelline placenta to support the early embryo, although this soon is supplanted by a chorioallantoic placenta. Human and haplorrhine primates follow a second pattern where precocious development of the extraembryonic mesoderm leads to formation of a secondary yolk sac within the exocoelom. In rodents there is an inverted visceral yolk sac that encloses the embryo and amnion and functions as an accessory to the chorioallantoic placenta through term. Where present, the inverted yolk sac performs a number of functions that in human are assumed by the syncytiotrophoblast of the chorioallantoic placenta. These include transfer of passive immunity, iron, cobalamin and lipoprotein; protein and lipid synthesis; haematopoiesis; and germ cell storage. Most mammals have a large, fluid-filled allantoic cavity. This is not the case in human and haplorrhine primates where there is an allantoic stalk but no allantoic cavity. Some rodents have a small allantoic cavity, but the mouse and other murine rodents do not. The evolution of amnion, yolk sac and allantois is explored.

CONCLUSIONS

Fetal membranes deserve close attention. In particular, the mouse model is incomplete unless the yolk sac is studied along with the chorioallantoic placenta.

Placental Evolution within the Supraordinal Clades of Eutheria with the Perspective of Alternative Animal Models for Human Placentation

Here a survey of placental evolution is conducted. Placentation is a key factor for the evolution of placental mammals that had evolved an astonishing diversity. As a temporary organ that does not allow easy access, it is still not well understood. The lack of data also is a restriction for better understanding of placental development, structure, and function in the human. Animal models are essential, because experimental access to the human placenta is naturally restricted. However, there is not a single ideal model that is entirely similar to humans. It is particularly important to establish other models than the mouse, which is characterised by a short gestation period and poorly developed neonates that may provide insights only for early human pregnancy. In conclusion, current evolutionary studies have contributed essentially to providing a pool of experimental models for recent and future approaches that may also meet the requirements of a long gestation period and advanced developmental status of the newborn in the human. Suitability and limitations of taxa as alternative animal models are discussed. However, further investigations especially in wildlife taxa should be conducted in order to learn more about the full evolutionary plasticity of the placenta system.

Retroviral envelope syncytin capture in an ancestrally diverged mammalian clade for placentation in the primitive Afrotherian tenrecs

Syncytins are fusogenic envelope (env) genes of retroviral origin that have been captured for a function in placentation. Syncytins have been identified in Euarchontoglires (primates, rodents, Leporidae) and Laurasiatheria (Carnivora, ruminants) placental mammals. Here, we searched for similar genes in species that retained characteristic features of primitive mammals, namely the Malagasy and mainland African Tenrecidae. They belong to the superorder Afrotheria, an early lineage that diverged from Euarchotonglires and Laurasiatheria 100 Mya, during the Cretaceous terrestrial revolution. An in silico search for env genes with full coding capacity within a Tenrecidae genome identified several candidates, with one displaying placenta-specific expression as revealed by RT-PCR analysis of a large panel of Setifer setosus tissues. Cloning of this endogenous retroviral env gene demonstrated fusogenicity in an ex vivo cell-cell fusion assay on a panel of mammalian cells. Refined analysis of placental architecture and ultrastructure combined with in situ hybridization demonstrated specific expression of the gene in multinucleate cellular masses and layers at the materno-fetal interface, consistent with a role in syncytium formation. This gene, which we named "syncytin-Ten1," is conserved among Tenrecidae, with evidence of purifying selection and conservation of fusogenic activity. To our knowledge, it is the first syncytin identified to date within the ancestrally diverged Afrotheria superorder.

Review: The evolving placenta: different developmental paths to a hemochorial relationship

The way in which maternal blood is associated with trophoblast prior to the formation of the different types of hemochorial placenta may be conveniently grouped into four main patterns: a transitory endotheliochorial condition; maternal blood released into a mass of trophoblast; maternal blood confined to lacunae; and fetal villi entering preexisting maternal blood sinuses. Although it might be considered logical that developing placentas would pass through an endotheliochorial stage to become hemochorial, this developmental pattern is seen only as a transient stage in several species of bats and sciuromorph rodents. More commonly a mass of trophoblast at the junction with the endometrium serves as a meshwork through which maternal blood passes, with subsequent organization of a labyrinth when the fetal vascular component is organized. The initial trophoblast meshwork may be cellular or syncytial, often leading to a similar relationship in the spongy zone and labyrinth. Old World monkeys, apes and humans have a lacunar stage prior to establishing a villous hemochorial condition. New World monkeys lack a true lacunar stage, retaining portions of maternal vessels for some time and initially forming a trabecular arrangement similar to though differently arrived at than that in the tarsier. In armadillos, preexisting maternal venous sinuses are converted into an intervillous blood space by intruding fetal villi. Variations from the major patterns of development also occur. The way in which the definitive placental form is achieved developmentally should be considered when using placental structure to extrapolate evolution of placentation.

Phylogenetic evidence for early hemochorial placentation in eutheria

The eutherian placenta is remarkable for its structural and functional variability. In order to construct and test comparative hypotheses relating ecological, behavioral and physiological traits to placental characteristics it is first necessary to reconstruct the historical course of placental evolution. Previous attempts to do so have yielded inconsistent results, particularly with respect to the early evolution of structural relationships between fetal and maternal circulatory systems. Here, we bring a battery of phylogenetic methods - including parsimony, likelihood and Bayesian approaches - to bear on the question of placental evolution. All of these approaches are consistent in indicating that highly invasive hemochorial placentation, as found in human beings and numerous other taxa, was an early evolutionary innovation present in the most ancient ancestors of the living placental mammals.

Placentation in the Hottentot golden mole, Amblysomus hottentotus (Afrosoricida: Chrysochloridae)

The placentation of the Hottentot golden mole (Amblysomus hottentotus) has been examined using light and electron microscopy and lectin histochemistry of nine specimens at both mid and late gestation. The placentae were lobulated towards the allantoic surface and the lobules contained roughly parallel arrays of labyrinthine structures converging on a central spongy zone. At mid gestation, the arrays were composed of an inner cellular and outer syncytial trophoblast layer, the inner layer enclosing scant connective tissue and fetal capillaries. Maternal blood spaces coursed through the outer trophoblast and were lined by trophoblastic microvilli; the blood spaces were narrow in mid gestation but enlarged near term, while the inner trophoblast layer became thinner and seemed to be syncytial. These features were confirmed by transmission electron microscopy. The microvillous surfaces and dispersed cytoplasmic particles were heavily glycosylated, as shown by lectin histochemistry, and exhibited changes with maturation, particularly a loss in N-acetyl glucosamine oligomers bound by Phytolacca americana lectin on the microvilli lining the maternal blood spaces and outer trophoblast particles. A substantial yolk sac was present both in mid and late gestation stages. It was clearly unattached to the uterus in the later stages. These morphological features are discussed in relation to the phylogenetic position of Amblysomus with respect to other members of Afrosoricida and Afrotheria.

Reasons for diversity of placental structure

Many early embryonic stages are nearly indistinguishable in different Eutheria. However, implantation stages and placental morphological types vary tremendously. A number of factors favor this conflicting diversity. 1. Whereas embryo development takes place in the isolation of the amniotic cavity, the extraembryonic membranes of the conceptus develop in close association with the uterus of a genetically different organism. 2. Early conditions for the developing conceptus are anaerobic whereas later in development efficient aerobic conditions are essential for continued growth of the fetus. 3. Developing extraembryonic membranes have the potential to form two partially sequential placentas. The yolk sac can participate in forming a choriovitelline placenta, including an interhemal region, and can be adapted to various non-respiratory functions as gestation proceeds. Development of the chorioallantoic placenta begins later than the choriovitelline placenta but can overlap with this before supplanting it. The original development of the extraembryonic membranes occurs when the conceptus is sufficiently small that neither its nutritional requirements nor its respiratory needs are the burden to the maternal organism that they are later in gestation. Despite these developmental factors promoting different methods of forming the definitive placenta, the placental type is consistent within most families indicating that the divergence in placental structure accompanied evolution of differences between groups.

Sources for comparative studies of placentation I. embryological collections

A rich source of material for comparative studies of the placenta is the collections made by pioneers in the field such as H.W. Mossman, A.A.W. Hubrecht and J.P. Hill. This overview gives a brief description of collections known to be available and information on how each can be accessed. Included are some of the major series of human and animal embryos, such as the Boyd and Carnegie collections, as these also house placental material.