Neuroanatomical and physiological evidence that the retrotrapezoid nucleus/parafacial region regulates expiration in adult rats

Neuromedin B-Expressing Neurons in the Retrotrapezoid Nucleus Regulate Respiratory Homeostasis and Promote Stable Breathing in Adult Mice

Respiratory chemoreceptor activity encoding arterial Pco2 and Po2 is a critical determinant of ventilation. Currently, the relative importance of several putative chemoreceptor mechanisms for maintaining eupneic breathing and respiratory homeostasis is debated. Transcriptomic and anatomic evidence suggests that bombesin-related peptide Neuromedin-B (Nmb) expression identifies chemoreceptor neurons in the retrotrapezoid nucleus (RTN) that mediate the hypercapnic ventilatory response, but functional support is missing. In this study, we generated a transgenic Nmb-Cre mouse and used Cre-dependent cell ablation and optogenetics to test the hypothesis that RTN Nmb neurons are necessary for the CO2-dependent drive to breathe in adult male and female mice. Selective ablation of ∼95% of RTN Nmb neurons causes compensated respiratory acidosis because of alveolar hypoventilation, as well as profound breathing instability and respiratory-related sleep disruption. Following RTN Nmb lesion, mice were hypoxemic at rest and were prone to severe apneas during hyperoxia, suggesting that oxygen-sensitive mechanisms, presumably the peripheral chemoreceptors, compensate for the loss of RTN Nmb neurons. Interestingly, ventilation following RTN Nmb -lesion was unresponsive to hypercapnia, but behavioral responses to CO2 (freezing and avoidance) and the hypoxia ventilatory response were preserved. Neuroanatomical mapping shows that RTN Nmb neurons are highly collateralized and innervate the respiratory-related centers in the pons and medulla with a strong ipsilateral preference. Together, this evidence suggests that RTN Nmb neurons are dedicated to the respiratory effects of arterial Pco2/pH and maintain respiratory homeostasis in intact conditions and suggest that malfunction of these neurons could underlie the etiology of certain forms of sleep-disordered breathing in humans.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT Respiratory chemoreceptors stimulate neural respiratory motor output to regulate arterial Pco2 and Po2, thereby maintaining optimal gas exchange. Neurons in the retrotrapezoid nucleus (RTN) that express the bombesin-related peptide Neuromedin-B are proposed to be important in this process, but functional evidence has not been established. Here, we developed a transgenic mouse model and demonstrated that RTN neurons are fundamental for respiratory homeostasis and mediate the stimulatory effects of CO2 on breathing. Our functional and anatomic data indicate that Nmb-expressing RTN neurons are an integral component of the neural mechanisms that mediate CO2-dependent drive to breathe and maintain alveolar ventilation. This work highlights the importance of the interdependent and dynamic integration of CO2- and O2-sensing mechanisms in respiratory homeostasis of mammals.

The integrated brain network that controls respiration

Respiration is a brain function on which our lives essentially depend. Control of respiration ensures that the frequency and depth of breathing adapt continuously to metabolic needs. In addition, the respiratory control network of the brain has to organize muscular synergies that integrate ventilation with posture and body movement. Finally, respiration is coupled to cardiovascular function and emotion. Here, we argue that the brain can handle this all by integrating a brainstem central pattern generator circuit in a larger network that also comprises the cerebellum. Although currently not generally recognized as a respiratory control center, the cerebellum is well known for its coordinating and modulating role in motor behavior, as well as for its role in the autonomic nervous system. In this review, we discuss the role of brain regions involved in the control of respiration, and their anatomical and functional interactions. We discuss how sensory feedback can result in adaptation of respiration, and how these mechanisms can be compromised by various neurological and psychological disorders. Finally, we demonstrate how the respiratory pattern generators are part of a larger and integrated network of respiratory brain regions.

Regulation of blood vessels by ATP in the ventral medullary surface in a rat model of Parkinson's disease

Parkinson's disease (PD) patients often experience impairment of autonomic and respiratory functions. These include conditions such as orthostatic hypotension and sleep apnea, which are highly correlated with dysfunctional central chemoreception. Blood flow is a fundamental determinant of tissue CO₂/H⁺, yet the extent to which blood flow regulation within chemoreceptor regions contributes to respiratory behavior during neurological disease remains unknown. Here, we tested the hypothesis that 6-hydroxydopamine injection to inducing a known model of PD results in dysfunctional vascular homeostasis, biochemical dysregulation, and glial morphology of the ventral medullary surface (VMS). We show that hypercapnia (FiCO₂ = 10%) induced elevated VMS pial vessel constriction in PD animals through a P2-receptor dependent mechanism. Similarly, we found a greater CO₂-induced vascular constriction after ARL67156 (an ectonucleotidase inhibitor) in control and PD-induced animals. In addition, we also report that weighted gene correlational network analysis of the proteomic data showed a protein expression module differentially represented between both groups. This module showed that gene ontology enrichment for components of the ATP machinery were reduced in our PD-model compared to control animals. Altogether, our data indicate that dysfunction in purinergic signaling, potentially through altered ATP bioavailability in the VMS region, may compromise the RTN neuroglial vascular unit in a PD animal model.

Role of DSCAM in the Development of Neural Control of Movement and Locomotion

Locomotion results in an alternance of flexor and extensor muscles between left and right limbs generated by motoneurons that are controlled by the spinal interneuronal circuit. This spinal locomotor circuit is modulated by sensory afferents, which relay proprioceptive and cutaneous inputs that inform the spatial position of limbs in space and potential contacts with our environment respectively, but also by supraspinal descending commands of the brain that allow us to navigate in complex environments, avoid obstacles, chase prey, or flee predators. Although signaling pathways are important in the establishment and maintenance of motor circuits, the role of DSCAM, a cell adherence molecule associated with Down syndrome, has only recently been investigated in the context of motor control and locomotion in the rodent. DSCAM is known to be involved in lamination and delamination, synaptic targeting, axonal guidance, dendritic and cell tiling, axonal fasciculation and branching, programmed cell death, and synaptogenesis, all of which can impact the establishment of motor circuits during development, but also their maintenance through adulthood. We discuss herein how DSCAM is important for proper motor coordination, especially for breathing and locomotion.

Somatostatin-expressing parafacial neurons are CO2/H+ sensitive and regulate baseline breathing

Glutamatergic neurons in the retrotrapezoid nucleus (RTN) function as respiratory chemoreceptors by regulating breathing in response to tissue CO2/H+. The RTN and greater parafacial region may also function as a chemosensing network composed of CO2/H+-sensitive excitatory and inhibitory synaptic interactions. In the context of disease, we showed that loss of inhibitory neural activity in a mouse model of Dravet syndrome disinhibited RTN chemoreceptors and destabilized breathing (Kuo et al., 2019). Despite this, contributions of parafacial inhibitory neurons to control of breathing are unknown, and synaptic properties of RTN neurons have not been characterized. Here, we show the parafacial region contains a limited diversity of inhibitory neurons including somatostatin (Sst)-, parvalbumin (Pvalb)-, and cholecystokinin (Cck)-expressing neurons. Of these, Sst-expressing interneurons appear uniquely inhibited by CO2/H+. We also show RTN chemoreceptors receive inhibitory input that is withdrawn in a CO2/H+-dependent manner, and chemogenetic suppression of Sst+ parafacial neurons, but not Pvalb+ or Cck+ neurons, increases baseline breathing. These results suggest Sst-expressing parafacial neurons contribute to RTN chemoreception and respiratory activity.

Excitatory and inhibitory modulation of parafacial respiratory neurons in the control of active expiration

In order to increase ventilation, the respiratory system engages active expiration through recruitment of abdominal muscles. Here, we reviewed the new advances in the modulation of parafacial respiratory (pF) region to trigger active expiration. In addition, we also made a comprehensive discussion of experiments indicating that the lateral aspect of the pF (pFL) is anatomically and functionally distinct from the adjacent and partially overlapping chemosensitive neurons of the ventral aspect of the pF (pFV) also named the retrotrapezoid nucleus. Recent evidence suggest a complex network responsible for the generation of active expiration and neuromodulatory systems that influence its activity. The activity of the pFL is tonically inhibited by inhibitory inputs and also receives excitatory inputs from chemoreceptors (central x peripheral) as well as from catecholaminergic C1 neurons. Therefore, the modulatory inputs and the physiological conditions under which these mechanisms are used to recruit active expiration and increase ventilation need further investigation.

Oxidative stress in retrotrapezoid nucleus/parafacial respiratory group and impairment of central chemoreception in rat offspring exposed to maternal cigarette smoke

We have reported that smoking during pregnancy is associated with deficit in neonatal central chemoreception. However, the underlying mechanism is not well clarified. In this study, we developed a rat model of maternal cigarette smoke (CS) exposure. Pregnant rats were exposed to CS during gestational day 1-20. Offspring were studied on postnatal day 2. Reactive oxygen species (ROS) content and expressions of antioxidant proteins in retrotrapezoid nucleus/parafacial respiratory group (RTN/pFRG) were examined by fluorogenic dye MitoSOX™ Red and Western blotting, respectively. The response of hypoglossal rootlets discharge to acidification was also detected with micro-injection of H2O2 into RTN/pFRG of offspring brainstem slices in vitro. Results showed that maternal CS exposure led to an increase in ROS production, and brought about decreases in mitochondrial superoxide dismutase and Kelch-like ECH-associated protein-1, and an increase in NF-E2-related factor 2 in offspring RTN/pFRG. Catalase and glutathione reductase expressions were not significantly changed. Moreover, oxidative stress induced by micro-injection of H2O2 into RTN/pFRG in vitro inhibited the discharge response of hypoglossal rootlets to acidification. These findings suggest that maternal CS exposure results in oxidative stress in RTN/pFRG of rat offspring, which might play a role in the impairment of central chemoreception.

Inhibitory mechanisms control active expiration by limiting parafacial expiratory drive

Activity of parafacial neurons that control active expiration is heavily dependent on tonic and CO₂/H⁺-dependent excitatory and inhibitory inputs from yet poorly defined sources. Contrary to the idea that CO₂/H⁺ disinhibits parafacial expiratory neurons, the recent work of J. D. Silva et al. (Silva JD, Oliveira LM, Souza FC, Moreira TS, Takakura AC. J Neurophysiol 123: 1933-1943, 2020) suggests that GABAergic raphe neurons preferentially limit expiratory activity during high CO₂. Here, I discuss these findings and propose a model where GABAergic raphe neurons function as CO₂/H⁺-dependent breaks on expiratory drive.

Differential Contribution of the Retrotrapezoid Nucleus and C1 Neurons to Active Expiration and Arousal in Rats

Collectively, the retrotrapezoid nucleus (RTN) and adjacent C1 neurons regulate breathing, circulation and the state of vigilance, but previous methods to manipulate the activity of these neurons have been insufficiently selective to parse out their relative roles. We hypothesize that RTN and C1 neurons regulate distinct aspects of breathing (e.g., frequency, amplitude, active expiration, sighing) and differ in their ability to produce arousal from sleep. Here we use optogenetics and a combination of viral vectors in adult male and female Th-Cre rats to transduce selectively RTN (Phox2b⁺ /Nmb ⁺) or C1 neurons (Phox2b⁺/Th ⁺) with Channelrhodopsin-2. RTN photostimulation modestly increased the probability of arousal. RTN stimulation robustly increased breathing frequency and amplitude; it also triggered strong active expiration but not sighs. Consistent with these responses, RTN innervates the entire pontomedullary respiratory network, including expiratory premotor neurons in the caudal ventral respiratory group, but RTN has very limited projections to brainstem regions that regulate arousal (locus ceruleus, CGRP⁺ parabrachial neurons). C1 neuron stimulation produced robust arousals and similar increases in breathing frequency and amplitude compared with RTN stimulation, but sighs were elicited and active expiration was absent. Unlike RTN, C1 neurons innervate the locus ceruleus, CGRP⁺ processes within the parabrachial complex, and lack projections to caudal ventral respiratory group. In sum, stimulating C1 or RTN activates breathing robustly, but only RTN neuron stimulation produces active expiration, consistent with their role as central respiratory chemoreceptors. Conversely, C1 stimulation strongly stimulates ascending arousal systems and sighs, consistent with their postulated role in acute stress responses.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT The C1 neurons and the retrotrapezoid nucleus (RTN) reside in the rostral ventrolateral medulla. Both regulate breathing and the cardiovascular system but in ways that are unclear because of technical limitations (anesthesia, nonselective neuronal actuators). Using optogenetics in unanesthetized rats, we found that selective stimulation of either RTN or C1 neurons activates breathing. However, only RTN triggers active expiration, presumably because RTN, unlike C1, has direct excitatory projections to abdominal premotor neurons. The arousal potential of the C1 neurons is far greater than that of the RTN, however, consistent with C1's projections to brainstem wake-promoting structures. In short, C1 neurons orchestrate cardiorespiratory and arousal responses to somatic stresses, whereas RTN selectively controls lung ventilation and arterial Pco₂ stability.

Stimulation of retrotrapezoid nucleus Phox2b-expressing neurons rescues breathing dysfunction in an experimental Parkinson's disease rat model

Emerging evidence from multiple studies indicates that Parkinson's disease (PD) patients suffer from a spectrum of autonomic and respiratory motor deficiencies in addition to the classical motor symptoms attributed to substantia nigra degeneration of dopaminergic neurons. Animal models of PD show a decrease in the resting respiratory rate as well as a decrease in the number of Phox2b-expressing retrotrapezoid nucleus (RTN) neurons. The aim of this study was to determine the extent to which substantia nigra pars compact (SNc) degeneration induced RTN biomolecular changes and to identify the extent to which RTN pharmacological or optogenetic stimulations rescue respiratory function following PD-induction. SNc degeneration was achieved in adult male Wistar rats by bilateral striatal 6-hydroxydopamine injection. For proteomic analysis, laser capture microdissection and pressure catapulting were used to isolate the RTN for subsequent comparative proteomic analysis and Ingenuity Pathway Analysis (IPA). The respiratory parameters were evaluated by whole-body plethysmography and electromyographic analysis of respiratory muscles. The results confirmed reduction in the number of dopaminergic neurons of SNc and respiratory rate in the PD-animals. Our proteomic data suggested extensive RTN remodeling, and that pharmacological or optogenetic stimulations of the diseased RTN neurons promoted rescued the respiratory deficiency. Our data indicate that despite neuroanatomical and biomolecular RTN pathologies, that RTN-directed interventions can rescue respiratory control dysfunction.

GABAergic neurons of the medullary raphe regulate active expiration during hypercapnia

The parafacial respiratory group (pFRG), located in the lateral aspect of the rostroventral lateral medulla, has been described as a conditional expiratory oscillator that emerges mainly in conditions of high metabolic challenges to increase breathing. The convergence of inhibitory and excitatory inputs to pFRG and the generation of active expiration may be more complex than previously thought. We hypothesized that the medullary raphe, a region that has long been described to be involved in breathing activity, is also responsible for the expiratory activity under hypercapnic condition. To test this hypothesis, we performed anatomical and physiological experiments in urethane-anesthetized adult male Wistar rats. Our data showed anatomical projections from serotonergic (5-HT-ergic) and GABAergic neurons of raphe magnus (RMg) and obscurus (ROb) to the pFRG region. Pharmacological inhibition of RMg or ROb with muscimol (60 pmol/30 nL) did not change the frequency or amplitude of diaphragm activity and did not generate active expiration. However, under hypercapnia (9-10% CO₂), the inhibition of RMg or ROb increased the amplitude of abdominal activity, without changing the increased amplitude of diaphragm activity. Depletion of serotonergic neurons with saporin anti-SERT injections into ROb and RMg did not increase the amplitude of abdominal activity during hypercapnia. These results show that the presumably GABAergic neurons within the RMg and ROb may be the inhibitory source to modulate the activity of pFRG during hypercapnia condition.NEW & NOTEWORTHY Medullary raphe has been involved in the inspiratory response to central chemoreflex; however, these reports have never addressed the role of raphe neurons on active expiration induced by hypercapnia. Here, we showed that a subset of GABA cells within the medullary raphe directly project to the parafacial respiratory region, modulating active expiration under high levels of CO₂.

Distinct pathways to the parafacial respiratory group to trigger active expiration in adult rats

Active expiration (AE) is part of the breathing phase; it is conditional and occurs when we increase our metabolic demand, such as during hypercapnia, hypoxia, or exercise. The parafacial respiratory group (pFRG) is involved in AE. Data from the literature suggest that excitatory and the absence of inhibitory inputs to the pFRG are necessary to determine AE. However, the source of the inputs to the pFRG that trigger AE remains unclear. We show in adult urethane-anesthetized Wistar rats that the pharmacological inhibition of the medial aspect of the nucleus of the solitary tract (mNTS) or the rostral aspect of the pedunculopontine tegmental nucleus (rPPTg) is able to generate AE. In addition, direct inhibitory projection from the mNTS or indirect cholinergic projection from the rPPTg is able to contact pFRG to trigger AE. The inhibition of the mNTS or the rPPTg under conditions of high metabolic demand, such as hypercapnia (9–10% CO2), did not affect the AE. The present results suggest for the first time that inhibitory sources from the mNTS and a cholinergic pathway from the rPPTg, involving M2/M4 muscarinic receptors, could be important sources to modulate and sustain AE.

Breathing matters

Breathing is a well-described, vital and surprisingly complex behaviour, with behavioural and physiological outputs that are easy to directly measure. Key neural elements for generating breathing pattern are distinct, compact and form a network amenable to detailed interrogation, promising the imminent discovery of molecular, cellular, synaptic and network mechanisms that give rise to the behaviour. Coupled oscillatory microcircuits make up the rhythmic core of the breathing network. Primary among these is the preBötzinger Complex (preBötC), which is composed of excitatory rhythmogenic interneurons and excitatory and inhibitory pattern-forming interneurons that together produce the essential periodic drive for inspiration. The preBötC coordinates all phases of the breathing cycle, coordinates breathing with orofacial behaviours and strongly influences, and is influenced by, emotion and cognition. Here, we review progress towards cracking the inner workings of this vital core.

Central pattern generators in the brainstem and spinal cord: an overview of basic principles, similarities and differences

Central pattern generators (CPGs) are generally defined as networks of neurons capable of enabling the production of central commands, specifically controlling stereotyped, rhythmic motor behaviors. Several CPGs localized in brainstem and spinal cord areas have been shown to underlie the expression of complex behaviors such as deglutition, mastication, respiration, defecation, micturition, ejaculation, and locomotion. Their pivotal roles have clearly been demonstrated although their organization and cellular properties remain incompletely characterized. In recent years, insightful findings about CPGs have been made mainly because (1) several complementary animal models were developed; (2) these models enabled a wide variety of techniques to be used and, hence, a plethora of characteristics to be discovered; and (3) organizations, functions, and cell properties across all models and species studied thus far were generally found to be well-preserved phylogenetically. This article aims at providing an overview for non-experts of the most important findings made on CPGs in in vivo animal models, in vitro preparations from invertebrate and vertebrate species as well as in primates. Data about CPG functions, adaptation, organization, and cellular properties will be summarized with a special attention paid to the network for locomotion given its advanced level of characterization compared with some of the other CPGs. Similarities and differences between these networks will also be highlighted.

Respiratory disturbances in a mouse model of Parkinson's disease

NEW FINDINGS

What is the central question of this study? Clinical reports have described and suggested central and peripheral respiratory abnormalities in Parkinson's disease (PD) patients; however, these reports have never addressed the occurrence of these abnormalities in an animal model. What is the main finding and its importance? A mouse model of PD has reduced neurokinin-1 receptor immunoreactivity in the pre-Bӧtzinger complex and Phox2b-expressing neurons in the retrotrapezoid nucleus. The PD mouse has impairments of respiratory frequency and the hypercapnic ventilatory response. Lung collagen deposition and ribcage stiffness appear in PD mice.

ABSTRACT

Parkinson's disease (PD) is a neurodegenerative motor disorder characterized by dopaminergic deficits in the brain. Parkinson's disease patients may experience shortness of breath, dyspnoea, breathing difficulties and pneumonia, which can be linked as a cause of morbidity and mortality of those patients. The aim of the present study was to clarify whether a mouse model of PD could develop central brainstem and lung respiratory abnormalities. Adult male C57BL/6 mice received bilateral injections of 6-hydroxydopamine (10 μg μl^-1 ; 0.5 μl) or vehicle into the striatum. Ventilatory parameters were assessed in the 40 days after induction of PD, by whole-body plethysmography. In addition, measurements of respiratory input impedance (closed and opened thorax) were performed. 6-Hydroxydopamine reduced the number of tyrosine hydroxylase neurons in the substantia nigra pars compacta, the density of neurokinin-1 receptor immunoreactivity in the pre-Bӧtzinger complex and the number of Phox2b neurons in the retrotrapezoid nucleus. Physiological experiments revealed a reduction in resting respiratory frequency in PD animals, owing to an increase in expiratory time and a blunted hypercapnic ventilatory response. Measurements of respiratory input impedance showed that only PD animals with the thorax preserved had increased viscance, indicating that the ribcage could be stiff in this animal model of PD. Consistent with stiffened ribcage mechanics, abnormal collagen deposits in alveolar septa and airways were observed in PD animals. Our data showed that our mouse model of PD presented with neurodegeneration in respiratory brainstem centres and disruption of lung mechanical properties, suggesting that both central and peripheral deficiencies contribute to PD-related respiratory pathologies.

Cholinergic neurons in the pedunculopontine tegmental nucleus modulate breathing in rats by direct projections to the retrotrapezoid nucleus

KEY POINTS

Cholinergic projections from the pedunculopontine tegmental nucleus (PPTg) to the retrotrapezoid nucleus (RTN) are considered to be important for sleep-wake state-dependent control of breathing. The RTN also receives cholinergic input from the postinspiratory complex. Stimulation of the PPTg increases respiratory output under control conditions but not when muscarinic receptors in the RTN are blocked. The data obtained in the present study support the possibility that arousal-dependent modulation of breathing involves recruitment of cholinergic projections from the PPTg to the RTN.

ABSTRACT

The pedunculopontine tegmental nucleus (PPTg) in the mesopontine region has important physiological functions, including breathing control. The PPTg contains a variety of cell types, including cholinergic neurons that project to the rostral aspect of the ventrolateral medulla. In addition, cholinergic signalling in the retrotrapezoid nucleus (RTN), a region that contains neurons that regulate breathing in response to changes in CO₂ /H⁺ , has been shown to activate chemosensitive neurons and increase inspiratory activity. The present study aimed to identify the source of cholinergic input to the RTN and determine whether cholinergic signalling in this region influences baseline breathing or the ventilatory response to CO₂ in conscious male Wistar rats. Retrograde tracer Fluoro-Gold injected into the RTN labelled a subset of cholinergic PPTg neurons that presumably project directly to the chemosensitive region of the RTN. In unrestrained awake rats, unilateral injection of the glutamate (10 mm/100 nL) in the PPTg decreased tidal volume (V_T ) but otherwise increased respiratory rate (f_R ) and net respiratory output as indicated by an increase in ventilation (V_E ). All respiratory responses elicited by PPTg stimulation were blunted by prior injection of methyl-atropine (5 mm/50-75 nL) into the RTN. These results show that stimulation of the PPTg can increase respiratory activity in part by cholinergic activation of chemosensitive elements of the RTN. Based on previous evidence that cholinergic PPTg projections may simultaneously activate expiratory output from the pFRG, we speculate that cholinergic signalling at the level of RTN region could also be involved in breathing regulation.

Interaction between the retrotrapezoid nucleus and the parafacial respiratory group to regulate active expiration and sympathetic activity in rats

The retrotrapezoid nucleus (RTN) contains chemosensitive cells that distribute CO₂-dependent excitatory drive to the respiratory network. This drive facilitates the function of the respiratory central pattern generator (rCPG) and increases sympathetic activity. It is also evidenced that during hypercapnia, the late-expiratory (late-E) oscillator in the parafacial respiratory group (pFRG) is activated and determines the emergence of active expiration. However, it remains unclear the microcircuitry responsible for the distribution of the excitatory signals to the pFRG and the rCPG in conditions of high CO₂. Herein, we hypothesized that excitatory inputs from chemosensitive neurons in the RTN are necessary for the activation of late-E neurons in the pFRG. Using the decerebrated in situ rat preparation, we found that lesions of neurokinin-1 receptor-expressing neurons in the RTN region with substance P-saporin conjugate suppressed the late-E activity in abdominal nerves (AbNs) and sympathetic nerves (SNs) and attenuated the increase in phrenic nerve (PN) activity induced by hypercapnia. On the other hand, kynurenic acid (100 mM) injections in the pFRG eliminated the late-E activity in AbN and thoracic SN but did not modify PN response during hypercapnia. Iontophoretic injections of retrograde tracer into the pFRG of adult rats revealed labeled phox2b-expressing neurons within the RTN. Our findings are supported by mathematical modeling of chemosensitive and late-E populations within the RTN and pFRG regions as two separate but interacting populations in a way that the activation of the pFRG late-E neurons during hypercapnia require glutamatergic inputs from the RTN neurons that intrinsically detect changes in CO₂/pH.

Correlation between neuroanatomical and functional respiratory changes observed in an experimental model of Parkinson's disease

NEW FINDINGS

What is the central question of this study? What is the relationship between neuroanatomical and functional respiratory changes in an experimental model of Parkinson's disease? What is the main finding and its importance? Sixty days after induction of Parkinson's disease in a rat model, there are decreases in baseline breathing and in the number of neurons, density of the neurokinin-1 receptor and density of astrocytes in the ventrolateral respiratory region. These results provide the first evidence that neuroanatomical changes occur before functional respiratory deficits in a Parkinson's disease model and that there is a positive correlation between those sets of changes. The neuroanatomical changes impair respiratory activity and are presumably a major cause of the respiratory problems observed in Parkinson's disease.

ABSTRACT

We showed previously that 60 days after the induction of Parkinson's disease (PD) in a rat model, there are decreases in baseline breathing and in the number of phox2b-expressing neurons of the retrotrapezoid nucleus (RTN) and nucleus of the solitary tract (NTS), as well as a reduction in the density of the neurokinin-1 receptor (NK1r) in the pre-Bötzinger complex (preBötC) and rostral ventrolateral respiratory group (rVRG). Here, our aim was to evaluate the correlation between neuroanatomical and functional respiratory changes in an experimental model of PD. Male Wistar rats with bilateral injections of 6-hydroxydopamine (6-OHDA, 24 μg μl^-1 ) or vehicle into the striatum had respiratory parameters assessed by whole-body plethysmography 1 day before and 30, 40 or 60 days after the ablation. From the 30th day after the ablation, we observed a reduction in the number of phox2b neurons in the RTN and NTS and a reduction in the density of astrocytes in the rVRG. At 40 days after the ablation, we observed decreases in the density of NK1r in the preBötC and rVRG and of astrocytes in the RTN region. At 60 days, we observed a reduction in the density of astrocytes in the NTS and preBötC regions. The functional data showed changes in the resting and hypercapnia-induced respiratory rates and tidal volume from days 40-60 after injury. Our data suggest that the neuroanatomical changes impair respiratory activity and are presumably a major cause of the respiratory problems observed in PD.

Orexinergic neurons are involved in the chemosensory control of breathing during the dark phase in a Parkinson's disease model

Parkinson's disease (PD) is a neurodegenerative disorder characterized by loss of dopaminergic neurons in the substantia nigra compacta (SNpc) and the only risk factor is aging. We showed that in 6-hydroxydopamine (6-OHDA)-model of PD there is a reduction in the neuronal profile within the brainstem ventral respiratory column with a decrease in the hypercapnic ventilatory response. Here we tested the involvement of orexin cells from the lateral hypothalamus/perifornical area (LH/PeF) on breathing in a 6-OHDA PD model. In this model of PD, there is a reduction in the total number of orexinergic neurons and in the number of orexinergic neurons that project to the RTN, without changing the number of CO₂-activated orexinergic neurons during the dark phase. The ventilation at rest and in response to hypercapnia (7% CO₂) was assessed in animals that received 6-OHDA or vehicle injections into the striatum and saporin anti-Orexin-B or IgG saporin into the LH/PeF during the sleep and awake states. The experiments showed a reduction of respiratory frequency (f_R) at rest during the light phase in PD animals only during sleep. During the dark phase, there was an impaired f_R response to hypercapnia in PD animals with depletion of orexinergic neurons in awake and sleeping rats. In conclusion, the degeneration of orexinergic neurons in this model of PD can be related to impaired chemoreceptor function in the dark phase.

Distinct parafacial regions in control of breathing in adult rats

Recently, based on functional differences, we subdivided neurons juxtaposed to the facial nucleus into two distinct populations, the parafacial ventral and lateral regions, i.e., pF_V and pF_L. Little is known about the composition of these regions, i.e., are they homogenous or heterogeneous populations? Here, we manipulated their excitability in spontaneously breathing vagotomized urethane anesthetized adult rats to further characterize their role in breathing. In the pF_L, disinhibition or excitation decreased breathing frequency (f) with a concomitant increase of tidal volume (V_T), and induced active expiration; in contrast, reducing excitation had no effect. This result is congruent with pF_L neurons constituting a conditional expiratory oscillator comprised of a functionally homogeneous set of excitatory neurons that are tonically suppressed at rest. In the pF_V, disinhibition increased f with a presumptive reflexive decrease in V_T; excitation increased f, V_T and sigh rate; reducing excitation decreased V_T with a presumptive reflexive increase in f. Therefore, the pF_V, has multiple functional roles that require further parcellation. Interestingly, while hyperpolarization of the pF_V reduces ongoing expiratory activity, no perturbation of pF_V excitability induced active expiration. Thus, while the pF_V can affect ongoing expiratory activity, presumably generated by the pF_L, it does not appear capable of directly inducing active expiration. We conclude that the pF_L contains neurons that can initiate, modulate, and sustain active expiration, whereas the pF_V contains subpopulations of neurons that differentially affect various aspects of breathing pattern, including but not limited to modulation of ongoing expiratory activity.

The parafacial respiratory group and the control of active expiration

Breathing at rest is typically characterized by three phases: active inspiration, post-inspiration (or stage 1 expiration), and passive expiration (or stage 2 expiration). Breathing during periods of increased respiratory demand, on the other hand, engages active expiration through recruitment of abdominal muscles in order to increase ventilation. It is currently hypothesized that different phases of the respiratory rhythm are driven by three coupled oscillators: the preBötzinger Complex, driving inspiration, the parafacial respiratory group (pFRG), driving active expiration and the post-inspiratory Complex, driving post-inspiration. In this paper we review advances in the understanding of the pFRG and its role in the generation of active expiration across different developmental stages and vigilance states. Recent experiments suggest that the abdominal recruitment varies across development depending on the vigilance state, possibly following the maturation of the network responsible for the generation of active expiration and neuromodulatory systems that influence its activity. The activity of the pFRG is tonically inhibited by GABAergic inputs and strongly recruited by cholinergic systems. However, the sources of these modulatory inputs and the physiological conditions under which these mechanisms are used to recruit active expiration and increase ventilation need further investigation. Some evidence suggests that active expiration during hypercapnia is evoked through disinhibition, while during hypoxia it is elicited through activation of catecholaminergic C1 neurons. Finally, a discussion of experiments indicating that the pFRG is anatomically and functionally distinct from the adjacent and partially overlapping chemosensitive neurons of the retrotrapezoid nucleus is also presented.

Inhibition of the hypercapnic ventilatory response by adenosine in the retrotrapezoid nucleus in awake rats

The brain regulates breathing in response to changes in tissue CO₂/H⁺ via a process called central chemoreception. Neurons and astrocytes in the retrotrapezoid nucleus (RTN) function as respiratory chemoreceptors. The role of astrocytes in this process appears to involve CO₂/H⁺-dependent release of ATP to enhance activity of chemosensitive RTN neurons. Considering that in most brain regions extracellular ATP is rapidly broken down to adenosine by ectonucleotidase activity and since adenosine is a potent neuromodulator, we wondered whether adenosine signaling contributes to RTN chemoreceptor function. To explore this possibility, we pharmacologically manipulated activity of adenosine receptors in the RTN under control conditions and during inhalation of 7-10% CO₂ (hypercapnia). In urethane-anesthetized or unrestrained conscious rats, bilateral injections of adenosine into the RTN blunted the hypercapnia ventilatory response. The inhibitory effect of adenosine on breathing was blunted by prior RTN injection of a broad spectrum adenosine receptor blocker (8-PT) or a selective A1-receptor blocker (DPCPX). Although RTN injections of 8PT, DPCPX or the ectonucleotidase inhibitor ARL67156 did not affected baseline breathing in either anesthetized or awake rats. We did find that RTN application of DPCPX or ARL67156 potentiated the respiratory frequency response to CO₂, suggesting a portion of ATP released in the RTN during high CO₂/H⁺ is converted to adenosine and serves to limit chemoreceptor function. These results identify adenosine as a novel purinergic regulator of RTN chemoreceptor function during hypercapnia.

The Dynamic Basis of Respiratory Rhythm Generation: One Breath at a Time

Rhythmicity is a universal timing mechanism in the brain, and the rhythmogenic mechanisms are generally dynamic. This is illustrated for the neuronal control of breathing, a behavior that occurs as a one-, two-, or three-phase rhythm. Each breath is assembled stochastically, and increasing evidence suggests that each phase can be generated independently by a dedicated excitatory microcircuit. Within each microcircuit, rhythmicity emerges through three entangled mechanisms: ( a) glutamatergic transmission, which is amplified by ( b) intrinsic bursting and opposed by ( c) concurrent inhibition. This rhythmogenic triangle is dynamically tuned by neuromodulators and other network interactions. The ability of coupled oscillators to reconfigure and recombine may allow breathing to remain robust yet plastic enough to conform to nonventilatory behaviors such as vocalization, swallowing, and coughing. Lessons learned from the respiratory network may translate to other highly dynamic and integrated rhythmic systems, if approached one breath at a time.

Effects of Cannabinoid Agonists and Antagonists on Sleep and Breathing in Sprague-Dawley Rats

Study Objectives

There are no pharmacological treatments for obstructive sleep apnea syndrome, but dronabinol showed promise in a small pilot study. In anesthetized rats, dronabinol attenuates reflex apnea via activation of cannabinoid (CB) receptors located on vagal afferents; an effect blocked by cannabinoid type 1 (CB1) and/or type 2 (CB2) receptor antagonists. Here, using a natural model of central sleep apnea, we examine the effects of dronabinol, alone and in combination with selective antagonists in conscious rats chronically instrumented to stage sleep and measure cessation of breathing.

Methods

Adult male Sprague-Dawley rats were anesthetized and implanted with bilateral stainless steel screws into the skull for electroencephalogram recording and bilateral wire electrodes into the nuchal muscles for electromyogram recording. Each animal was recorded by polysomnography on multiple occasions separated by at least 3 days. The study was a fully nested, repeated measures crossover design, such that each rat was recorded following each of 8 intraperitoneal injections: vehicle; vehicle and CB1 antagonist (AM 251); vehicle and CB2 antagonist (AM 630); vehicle and CB1/CB2 antagonist; dronabinol; dronabinol and CB1 antagonist; dronabinol and CB2 antagonist; and dronabinol and CB1/CB2 antagonist.

Results

Dronabinol decreased the percent time spent in rapid eye movement (REM) sleep. CB receptor antagonists did not reverse this effect. Dronabinol also decreased apneas during sleep, and this apnea suppression was reversed by CB1 or CB1/CB2 receptor antagonism.

Conclusions

Dronabinol's effects on apneas were dependent on CB1 receptor activation, while dronabinol's effects on REM sleep were CB receptor-independent.

Short-Term Sustained Hypoxia Elevates Basal and Hypoxia-Induced Ventilation but Not the Carotid Body Chemoreceptor Activity in Rats

Exposure to chronic sustained hypoxia (SH), as experienced in high altitudes, elicits an increase in ventilation, named ventilatory acclimatization to hypoxia (VAH). We previously showed that rats exposed to short-term (24 h) SH exhibit enhanced abdominal expiratory motor activity at rest, accompanied by augmented baseline sympathetic vasoconstrictor activity. In the present study, we investigated whether the respiratory and sympathetic changes elicited by short-term SH are accompanied by carotid body chemoreceptor sensitization. Juvenile male Holtzman rats (60-80 g) were exposed to SH (10% O₂ for 24 h) or normoxia (control) to examine basal and hypoxic-induced ventilatory parameters in unanesthetized conditions, as well as the sensory response of carotid body chemoreceptors in artificially perfused in situ preparations. Under resting conditions (normoxia/normocapnia), SH rats (n = 12) exhibited higher baseline respiratory frequency, tidal volume, and minute ventilation compared to controls (n = 11, P < 0.05). SH group also showed greater hypoxia ventilatory response than control group (P < 0.05). The in situ preparations of SH rats (n = 8) exhibited augmented baseline expiratory and sympathetic activities under normocapnia, with additional bursts in abdominal and thoracic sympathetic nerves during late expiratory phase that were not seen in controls (n = 8, P < 0.05). Interestingly, basal and potassium cyanide-induced afferent activity of carotid sinus nerve (CSN) was similar between SH and control rats. Our findings indicate that the maintenance of elevated resting ventilation, baseline sympathetic overactivity, and enhanced ventilatory responses to hypoxia in rats exposed to 24 h of SH are not dependent on increased basal and sensorial activity of carotid body chemoreceptors.

Confocal calcium imaging analysis of respiratory-related burst activity in the parafacial region

The parafacial respiratory group (pFRG) surrounding the ventrolateral part of the facial motor nucleus is one of respiratory rhythm generators that consists of pre-inspiratory (Pre-I) neurons. Previous studies showed that most of the Pre-I neurons locating in the Phox2b cluster of the rostral ventral medulla were also Phox2b positive and intrinsically CO₂ sensitive. However, it is not clear what percentage of Phox2b-expressing cells in the pFRG of the ventral medulla are Pre-I neurons. To address this issue, we analyzed the activity of Phox2b-positive cells by calcium imaging using a confocal laser microscope in transgenic rats in which Phox2b-positive cells expressed EYFP. We found that more than 60% of the EYFP/Phox2b-positive cells showed Pre-I neuron-like rhythmic burst activity in the parafacial region of newborn rat.

The Kölliker-Fuse nucleus orchestrates the timing of expiratory abdominal nerve bursting

Coordination of respiratory pump and valve muscle activity is essential for normal breathing. A hallmark respiratory response to hypercapnia and hypoxia is the emergence of active exhalation, characterized by abdominal muscle pumping during the late one-third of expiration (late-E phase). Late-E abdominal activity during hypercapnia has been attributed to the activation of expiratory neurons located within the parafacial respiratory group (pFRG). However, the mechanisms that control emergence of active exhalation, and its silencing in restful breathing, are not completely understood. We hypothesized that inputs from the Kölliker-Fuse nucleus (KF) control the emergence of late-E activity during hypercapnia. Previously, we reported that reversible inhibition of the KF reduced postinspiratory (post-I) motor output to laryngeal adductor muscles and brought forward the onset of hypercapnia-induced late-E abdominal activity. Here we explored the contribution of the KF for late-E abdominal recruitment during hypercapnia by pharmacologically disinhibiting the KF in in situ decerebrate arterially perfused rat preparations. These data were combined with previous results and incorporated into a computational model of the respiratory central pattern generator. Disinhibition of the KF through local parenchymal microinjections of gabazine (GABA_A receptor antagonist) prolonged vagal post-I activity and inhibited late-E abdominal output during hypercapnia. In silico, we reproduced this behavior and predicted a mechanism in which the KF provides excitatory drive to post-I inhibitory neurons, which in turn inhibit late-E neurons of the pFRG. Although the exact mechanism proposed by the model requires testing, our data confirm that the KF modulates the formation of late-E abdominal activity during hypercapnia. NEW & NOTEWORTHY The pons is essential for the formation of the three-phase respiratory pattern, controlling the inspiratory-expiratory phase transition. We provide functional evidence of a novel role for the Kölliker-Fuse nucleus (KF) controlling the emergence of abdominal expiratory bursts during active expiration. A computational model of the respiratory central pattern generator predicts a possible mechanism by which the KF interacts indirectly with the parafacial respiratory group and exerts an inhibitory effect on the expiratory conditional oscillator.

Neurogenic hypertension and the secrets of respiration

Despite recent advances in the knowledge of the neural control of cardiovascular function, the cause of sympathetic overactivity in neurogenic hypertension remains unknown. Studies from our laboratory point out that rats submitted to chronic intermittent hypoxia (CIH), an experimental model of neurogenic hypertension, present changes in the central respiratory network that impact the pattern of sympathetic discharge and the levels of arterial pressure. In addition to the fine coordination of respiratory muscle contraction and relaxation, which is essential for O₂ and CO₂ pulmonary exchanges, neurons of the respiratory network are connected precisely to the neurons controlling the sympathetic activity in the brain stem. This respiratory-sympathetic neuronal interaction provides adjustments in the sympathetic outflow to the heart and vasculature during each respiratory phase according to the metabolic demands. Herein, we report that CIH-induced sympathetic over activity and mild hypertension are associated with increased frequency discharge of ventral medullary presympathetic neurons. We also describe that their increased frequency discharge is dependent on synaptic inputs, mostly from neurons of the brain stem respiratory network, rather than changes in their intrinsic electrophysiological properties. In perspective, we are taking into consideration the possibility that changes in the central respiratory rhythm/pattern generator contribute to increased sympathetic outflow and the development of neurogenic hypertension. Our experimental evidence provides support for the hypothesis that changes in the coupling of respiratory and sympathetic networks might be one of the unrevealed secrets of neurogenic hypertension in rats.

The Kölliker-Fuse nucleus acts as a timekeeper for late-expiratory abdominal activity

While the transition from the inspiratory to the post-inspiratory (post-I) phase is dependent on the pons, little attention has been paid to understanding the role of the pontine respiratory nuclei, specifically the Kölliker-Fuse nucleus (KF), in transitioning from post-I to the late expiratory (late-E) activity seen with elevated respiratory drive. To elucidate this, we used the in situ working heart-brainstem preparation of juvenile male Holtzman rats and recorded from the vagus (cVN), phrenic (PN) and abdominal nerves (AbN) during baseline conditions and during chemoreflex activation [with potassium cyanide (KCN; n=13) or hypercapnia (8% CO2; n=10)] to recruit active expiration. Chemoreflex activation with KCN increased PN frequency and cVN post-I and AbN activities. The inhibition of KF with isoguvacine microinjections (10mM) attenuated the typical increase in PN frequency and cVN post-I activity, and amplified the AbN response. During hypercapnia, AbN late-E activity emerged in association with a significant reduction in expiratory time. KF inhibition during hypercapnia significantly decreased PN frequency and reduced the duration and amplitude of post-I cVN activity, while the onset of the AbN late-E bursts occurred significantly earlier. Our data reveal a negative relationship between KF-induced post-I and AbN late-E activities, suggesting that the KF coordinates the transition between post-I to late-E activity during conditions of elevated respiratory drive.

Respiratory rhythm generation: triple oscillator hypothesis

Breathing is vital for survival but also interesting from the perspective of rhythm generation. This rhythmic behavior is generated within the brainstem and is thought to emerge through the interaction between independent oscillatory neuronal networks. In mammals, breathing is composed of three phases - inspiration, post-inspiration, and active expiration - and this article discusses the concept that each phase is generated by anatomically distinct rhythm-generating networks: the preBötzinger complex (preBötC), the post-inspiratory complex (PiCo), and the lateral parafacial nucleus (pF L), respectively. The preBötC was first discovered 25 years ago and was shown to be both necessary and sufficient for the generation of inspiration. More recently, networks have been described that are responsible for post-inspiration and active expiration. Here, we attempt to collate the current knowledge and hypotheses regarding how respiratory rhythms are generated, the role that inhibition plays, and the interactions between the medullary networks. Our considerations may have implications for rhythm generation in general.

Non-chemosensitive parafacial neurons simultaneously regulate active expiration and airway patency under hypercapnia in rats

KEY POINTS

Hypercapnia or parafacial respiratory group (pFRG) disinhibition at normocapnia evokes active expiration in rats by recruitment of pFRG late-expiratory (late-E) neurons. We show that hypercapnia simultaneously evoked active expiration and exaggerated glottal dilatation by late-E synaptic excitation of abdominal, hypoglossal and laryngeal motoneurons. Simultaneous rhythmic expiratory activity in previously silent pFRG late-E neurons, which did not express the marker of ventral medullary CO₂ -sensitive neurons (transcription factor Phox2b), was also evoked by hypercapnia. Hypercapnia-evoked active expiration, neural and neuronal late-E activities were eliminated by pFRG inhibition, but not after blockade of synaptic excitation. Hypercapnia produces disinhibition of non-chemosensitive pFRG late-E neurons to evoke active expiration and concomitant cranial motor respiratory responses controlling the oropharyngeal and upper airway patency.

ABSTRACT

Hypercapnia produces active expiration in rats and the recruitment of late-expiratory (late-E) neurons located in the parafacial respiratory group (pFRG) of the ventral medullary brainstem. We tested the hypothesis that hypercapnia produces active expiration and concomitant cranial respiratory motor responses controlling the oropharyngeal and upper airway patency by disinhibition of pFRG late-E neurons, but not via synaptic excitation. Phrenic nerve, abdominal nerve (AbN), cranial respiratory motor nerves, subglottal pressure, and medullary and spinal neurons/motoneurons were recorded in in situ preparations of juvenile rats. Hypercapnia evoked AbN active expiration, exaggerated late-E discharges in cranial respiratory motor outflows, and glottal dilatation via late-E synaptic excitation of abdominal, hypoglossal and laryngeal motoneurons. Simultaneous rhythmic late-E activity in previously silent pFRG neurons, which did not express the marker of ventral medullary CO₂ -sensitive neurons (transcription factor Phox2b), was also evoked by hypercapnia. In addition, hypercapnia-evoked AbN active expiration, neural and neuronal late-E activities were eliminated by pFRG inhibition, but not after blockade of synaptic excitation. On the other hand, pFRG inhibition did not affect either hypercapnia-induced inspiratory increases in respiratory motor outflows or CO₂ sensitivity of the more medial Phox2b-positive neurons in the retrotrapezoid nucleus (RTN). Our data suggest that neither RTN Phox2b-positive nor other CO₂ -sensitive brainstem neurons activate Phox2b-negative pFRG late-E neurons under hypercapnia to produce AbN active expiration and concomitant cranial motor respiratory responses controlling the oropharyngeal and upper airway patency. Hypercapnia produces disinhibition of non-chemosensitive pFRG late-E neurons in in situ preparations of juvenile rats to activate abdominal, hypoglossal and laryngeal motoneurons.

Respiratory and autonomic dysfunction in congenital central hypoventilation syndrome

The developmental lineage of the PHOX2B-expressing neurons in the retrotrapezoid nucleus (RTN) has been extensively studied. These cells are thought to function as central respiratory chemoreceptors, i.e., the mechanism by which brain Pco2 regulates breathing. The molecular and cellular basis of central respiratory chemoreception is based on the detection of CO2 via intrinsic proton receptors (TASK-2, GPR4) as well as synaptic input from peripheral chemoreceptors and other brain regions. Murine models of congenital central hypoventilation syndrome designed with PHOX2B mutations have suggested RTN neuron agenesis. In this review, we examine, through human and experimental animal models, how a restricted number of neurons that express the transcription factor PHOX2B play a crucial role in the control of breathing and autonomic regulation.

Interactions between respiratory oscillators in adult rats

Breathing in mammals is hypothesized to result from the interaction of two distinct oscillators: the preBötzinger Complex (preBötC) driving inspiration and the lateral parafacial region (pF_L) driving active expiration. To understand the interactions between these oscillators, we independently altered their excitability in spontaneously breathing vagotomized urethane-anesthetized adult rats. Hyperpolarizing preBötC neurons decreased inspiratory activity and initiated active expiration, ultimately progressing to apnea, i.e., cessation of both inspiration and active expiration. Depolarizing pF_L neurons produced active expiration at rest, but not when inspiratory activity was suppressed by hyperpolarizing preBötC neurons. We conclude that in anesthetized adult rats active expiration is driven by the pF_L but requires an additional form of network excitation, i.e., ongoing rhythmic preBötC activity sufficient to drive inspiratory motor output or increased chemosensory drive. The organization of this coupled oscillator system, which is essential for life, may have implications for other neural networks that contain multiple rhythm/pattern generators.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.14203.001

Mammals breathe air into and out of their lungs to absorb oxygen into the body and to remove carbon dioxide. The rhythm of breathing is most likely controlled by two groups of neurons in a part of the brain called the brain stem. One group called the preBötzinger Complex drives breathing in (inspiration), and normally, breathing out (expiration) occurs when the muscles responsible for inspiration relax. The other group of neurons – known as the lateral parafacial region – controls extra muscles that allow us to increase our breathing when we need to, such as during exercise.

Huckstepp et al. set out to determine how these two groups of neurons interact with one another in anesthetized rats to produce a reliable and efficient pattern of breathing. The experiments provide further evidence that inspiration is mainly driven by the preBötzinger Complex. Whilst activity from the lateral parafacial region is needed to cause the rats to breathe out more forcefully than normal, a second low level of activity from another source is also required. This source could either be the preBötzinger Complex, or some unknown neurons that change their activity in response to the levels of oxygen and carbon dioxide in the blood or fluid of the brain.

Further investigation is required to identify how these interactions go awry in diseases that affect breathing, such as sleep apneas.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.14203.002