Differences in disease presentation between men and women with sarcoidosis: A cohort study

Screening tools for the detection of clinically silent cardiac sarcoidosis

BACKGROUND

clinically silent cardiac sarcoidosis (CS) may be associated with adverse outcomes, hence the rationale for screening patients with extracardiac sarcoidosis. The optimal screening strategy has not been clearly defined.

METHODS

patients with extra-cardiac sarcoidosis were prospectively included and underwent screening consisting of symptom history, electrocardiography (ECG), transthoracic echocardiogram, Holter, and signal-averaged ECG (SAECG). Cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR) was performed in all patients. Clinically silent CS was defined as CMR demonstrating late gadolinium enhancement (LGE) in a pattern compatible with CS according to a majority of independent and blinded CMR experts. Significant cardiac involvement was defined as the presence of LGE ≥6% and/or a positive fluorodeoxyglucose-positron emission tomography.

RESULTS

among the 129 patients included, clinically silent CS was diagnosed in 29/129 (22.5%), and 19/129 patients (14.7%) were classified as CS with significant cardiac involvement. There was a strong association between hypertension and CS (p < 0.05). Individual screening tools provided low diagnostic yield; however, combination of tests performed better, for example, a normal Holter and a normal SAECG had negative predictive values of 91.7%. We found consistently better diagnostic accuracy for the detection of CS with significant cardiac involvement.

CONCLUSION

clinically silent CS and CS with significant cardiac involvement were found in 22.5% and 14.7% of patients with extra-cardiac sarcoidosis. The association with hypertension raises the possibility that some cases of hypertensive cardiomyopathy may be mistaken for CS. Screening with readily available tools, for example Holter and SAECG, may help identifying patients without CS where additional CMR is not needed.

Epidemiology of Sarcoidosis

Sarcoidosis is a systemic, granulomatous disease with variable presentation earning it the term "the great mimicker." The current epidemiology confirms that the disease occurs worldwide, affecting both sexes, and all races, ethnicities, and ages. To date, no causal exposure or agent has been identified. The organ systems most frequently affected by sarcoidosis are also those with greatest exposure to the natural world suggesting environmental and lifestyle contributions to the disease. These include particulate matter, microorganisms, nicotine, and obesity. In this article, we review the epidemiology of sarcoidosis and discuss these non-genetic risk factors in the hope of providing important insight into sarcoidosis and stimulating future research.

Health-Related Quality of Life Assessment in Sarcoidosis

Health-related quality of life (HRQoL) is of major concern to patients with sarcoidosis. HRQoL impairment is the most common reason to treat the disease. Advances in patient-reported outcome (PRO) methodology offer the promise to use these instruments to follow quality of life in individual patients with sarcoidosis over time. Several HRQoL issues will be highlighted including their clinical importance, common causes in patients with sarcoidosis, the construction and use of PROs in clinical sarcoidosis trials, methods to adapt PROs to monitor HRQoL in individual patients with sarcoidosis, and the approach to improving HRQoL in this disease.

Cardiac Screening and Disease Characteristics of Patients with Ocular Sarcoidosis

PURPOSE

This is a retrospective nonrandomized cohort study investigating the prevalence, timing, and type of cardiac sarcoidosis indications on electrocardiogram in patients with diagnosed or suspected ocular sarcoidosis.

METHODS

Medical histories of individuals seen from 2005 to 2020 at two centers with diagnosed or suspected ocular sarcoidosis were searched, and statistical methods were used to evaluate the relevance of each aspect obtained.

RESULTS

Approximately 16% of the individuals in our cohort showed signs of cardiac sarcoidosis on ECG, primarily bundle branch blocks, and premature ventricular contractions, close to the time of their initial ocular sarcoidosis documentation. Males exhibited higher rates of clinically significant extra-pulmonary sarcoidosis. No other demographic differences were found.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings highlight the importance for further differentiation of non-infectious sarcoidosis and the utility of electrocardiogram screening. Studies with larger cohorts of ocular sarcoidosis might be needed to elucidate demographic differences within this patient population.

Peripheral blood lymphopenia in sarcoidosis associates with HLA-DRB1 alleles but not with lung immune cells and organ involvement

Different human leukocyte antigen (HLA) alleles associate with disease phenotypes in sarcoidosis. Peripheral blood (PB) lymphopenia is reported as more common in sarcoidosis patients with worse prognosis. The mechanisms behind are unrecognized but a PB depletion due to lymphocytes migrating to lung and/or extra pulmonary organs has been suggested. Insights into associations between HLA alleles, lung immune cells, clinical phenotype including extra pulmonary manifestations (EPM), and PB lymphopenia may provide mechanistic clues and enable adequate intervention in this patient group. In this situdy,141 treatment naïve, newly diagnosed patients were retrospectively identified in a Swedish cohort of sarcoidosis patients. Data on HLA-DRB1 alleles, lung immune cells from bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BALF), PB lymphocytes and clinical parameters including treatment and disease course (chronic vs. resolving) were collected. The patients were followed for 2 years. PB lymphopenia associated with male sex, development of non-resolving disease, a need for first- and second-line systemic immunosuppressant treatment and HLA- DRB1*07. No correlation between BALF and PB lymphocytes, and no difference in EPM was detected between patients with and without PB lymphopenia. In conclusion, PB lymphopenia is associated with a more severe disease phenotype and carriage of the HLA-DRB1*07 allele. The results do not lend support to the hypothesis about sarcoidosis PB lymphopenia being due to a migration of PB lymphocytes to other organs. Rather, they provide a basis for future studies on the connection between HLA-DRB1*07 and PB lymphopenia mechanisms.

Sarcoidosis and its relation to other immune-mediated diseases: Epidemiological insights

Several epidemiological studies show a co-occurrence of sarcoidosis with other immune-mediated diseases (IMD). There are many similarities between sarcoidosis and IMDs in their geographical distribution and risk factors. Understanding these similarities and identifying the differences can help us to better understand sarcoidosis and put it into context with other IMDs. In this review, we present the current knowledge about the overlap between sarcoidosis and other IMDs derived from epidemiological studies. Epidemiologic methods utilize study design and statistical analysis to describe the patterns in data and, ideally, identify causal relationships between an exposure and a health outcome. We discuss how study design and analysis may affect the interpretation of epidemiological studies on this topic and highlight some theories that attempt to explain the relation between sarcoidosis and other IMDs.

[Imaging diagnostics of cardiac sarcoidosis]

Cardiac involvement is clinically apparent in approximately 5% of all patients with systemic sarcoidosis, whereas evidence of cardiac involvement by imaging studies can be found in approximately 20% of cases. Occasionally, isolated cardiac sarcoidosis is encountered and is the only sign of the disease. The most frequent cardiac manifestations of the multifocal granulomatous inflammation include atrioventricular (AV) blocks and other conduction disorders, ventricular arrhythmias, sudden cardiac death and left and right ventricular wall disorders. Accordingly, symptoms that should raise suspicion include palpitations, lightheadedness and syncope. The diagnostic approach to cardiac sarcoidosis is not straightforward. Typical echocardiographic findings include regional thinning and contraction abnormalities particularly in basal, septal and lateral locations. Infrequently, myocardial hypertrophy may be present; however, the sensitivity of echocardiography is low and cardiac sarcoidosis can be present even when an echocardiogram is unrevealing. Cardiac magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) frequently shows late gadolinium enhancement (LGE) in a multifocal pattern often involving the basal septum and lateral walls. The sensitivity and specificity of MRI for detecting cardiac sarcoidosis are high. Fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission tomography (FDG-PET) plays an important role in the diagnostic algorithm due to its ability to visualize focal inflammatory activity both in the myocardium and in extracardiac locations. This may help target the optimal location for biopsy in order to obtain histologic proof of sarcoidosis and can also be used to follow the response to anti-inflammatory treatment. Notably, the sensitivity of endomyocardial biopsy is poor due to the patchy nature of myocardial involvement. In clinical practice, either histologic evidence of noncaseating granulomas from the myocardium or evidence from extracardiac tissue in combination with typical cardiac imaging findings are required to establish the diagnosis.

Sex differences in the genetics of sarcoidosis across European and African ancestry populations

Background

Sex differences in the susceptibility of sarcoidosis are unknown. The study aims to identify sex-dependent genetic variations in two clinical sarcoidosis phenotypes: Löfgren's syndrome (LS) and non-Löfgren's syndrome (non-LS).

Methods

A meta-analysis of genome-wide association studies was conducted on Europeans and African Americans, totaling 10,103 individuals from three population-based cohorts, Sweden (n = 3,843), Germany (n = 3,342), and the United States (n = 2,918), followed by an SNP lookup in the UK Biobank (UKB, n = 387,945). A genome-wide association study based on Immunochip data consisting of 141,000 single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) was conducted in the sex groups. The association test was based on logistic regression using the additive model in LS and non-LS sex groups independently. Additionally, gene-based analysis, gene expression, expression quantitative trait loci (eQTL) mapping, and pathway analysis were performed to discover functionally relevant mechanisms related to sarcoidosis and biological sex.

Results

We identified sex-dependent genetic variations in LS and non-LS sex groups. Genetic findings in LS sex groups were explicitly located in the extended Major Histocompatibility Complex (xMHC). In non-LS, genetic differences in the sex groups were primarily located in the MHC class II subregion and ANXA11. Gene-based analysis and eQTL enrichment revealed distinct sex-specific gene expression patterns in various tissues and immune cell types. In LS sex groups, a pathway map related to antigen presentation machinery by IFN-gamma. In non-LS, pathway maps related to immune response lectin-induced complement pathway in males and related to maturation and migration of dendritic cells in skin sensitization in females were identified.

Conclusion

Our findings provide new evidence for a sex bias underlying sarcoidosis genetic architecture, particularly in clinical phenotypes LS and non-LS. Biological sex likely plays a role in disease mechanisms in sarcoidosis.

From Karl Wurm and Guy Scadding's staging to 18F-FDG PET/CT scan phenotyping and far beyond: perspective in the evading history of phenotyping in sarcoidosis

Sarcoidosis is an inflammatory granulomatous disease of unknown etiology involving any organ or tissue along with any combination of active sites, even the most silent ones clinically. The unpredictable nature of the sites involved in sarcoidosis dictates the highly variable natural history of the disease and the necessity to cluster cases at diagnosis based on clinical and/or imaging common characteristics in an attempt to classify patients based on their more homogeneous phenotypes, possibly with similar clinical behavior, prognosis, outcome, and therefore with therapeutic requirements. In the course of the disease's history, this attempt relates to the availability of a means of detection of the sites involved, from the Karl Wurm and Guy Scadding's chest x-ray staging through the ACCESS, the WASOG Sarcoidosis Organ Assessment Instruments, and the GenPhenReSa study to the 18F-FDG PET/CT scan phenotyping and far beyond to new technologies and/or the current "omics." The hybrid molecular imaging of the 18F-FDG PET/CT scan, by unveiling the glucose metabolism of inflammatory cells, can identify high sensitivity inflammatory active granulomas, the hallmark of sarcoidosis-even in clinically and physiologically silent sites-and, as recently shown, is successful in identifying an unexpected ordered stratification into four phenotypes: (I) hilar-mediastinal nodal, (II) lungs and hilar-mediastinal nodal, (III) an extended nodal supraclavicular, thoracic, abdominal, inguinal, and (IV) all the above in addition to systemic organs and tissues, which is therefore the ideal phenotyping instrument. During the "omics era," studies could provide significant, distinct, and exclusive insights into sarcoidosis phenotypes linking clinical, laboratory, imaging, and histologic characteristics with molecular signatures. In this context, the personalization of treatment for sarcoidosis patients might have reached its goal.

Sarcoidosis: Epidemiology and clinical insights

Sarcoidosis is characterized by noncaseating granulomas which form in almost any part of the body, primarily in the lungs and/or thoracic lymph nodes. Environmental exposures in genetically susceptible individuals are believed to cause sarcoidosis. There is variation in incidence and prevalence by region and race. Males and females are almost equally affected, although disease peaks at a later age in females than in males. The heterogeneity of presentation and disease course can make diagnosis and treatment challenging. Diagnosis is suggestive in a patient if one or more of the following is present: radiologic signs of sarcoidosis, evidence of systemic involvement, histologically confirmed noncaseating granulomas, sarcoidosis signs in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BALF), and low probability or exclusion of other causes of granulomatous inflammation. No sensitive or specific biomarkers for diagnosis and prognosis exist, but there are several that can be used to support clinical decisions, such as serum angiotensin-converting enzyme levels, human leukocyte antigen types, and CD4 Vα2.3+ T cells in BALF. Corticosteroids remain the mainstay of treatment for symptomatic patients with severely affected or declining organ function. Sarcoidosis is associated with a range of adverse long-term outcomes and complications, and with great variation in prognosis between populations. New data and technologies have moved sarcoidosis research forward, increasing our understanding of the disease. However, there is still much left to be discovered. The pervading challenge is how to account for patient variability. Future studies should focus on how to optimize current tools and develop new approaches so that treatment and follow-up can be targeted to individuals with more precision.

RISK FACTORS FOR GC-RESISTANT PULMONARY SARCOIDOSIS

OBJECTIVE

The aim: The study aimed to conduct a retrospective analysis of unfavorable outcome rate and to search for clinical and anamnestic criteria for predicting glucocorticoid-resistant pulmonary sarcoidosis.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Materials and methods: There were examined 37 women and 31 men with stage II to III pulmonary sarcoidosis from 2018-2022. The mean patients' age was (35.7±6.6) years. All patients underwent a chest computed tomography scan on the Toshiba Aquilion Prime CT scanner before the start of treatment and after the three-month glucocorticoid therapy. Anamnestic, age- and gender related factors of unfavorable treatment outcomes were studied.

RESULTS

Results: Dyspnea (86%), coughing (67%), general weakness and fatigue (29%) on the background of maintaining the indicators of lung tissue density at the level of -893.5 Hounsfield units and above according to the chest computed tomography imaging represented the three-month treatment failure. Glucocorticoid-resistant sarcoidosis was most diagnosed in patients with stage III disease; the mean patients' age was (44.3±3.2) years; B positive men prevailed; 85% of patients developed extrapulmonary manifestations; in 43% of cases, concomitant cardiovascular pathology was diagnosed.

CONCLUSION

Conclusions: Age, gender, comorbid conditions, extrapulmonary lesions, and blood type can be used as predictive criteria for GC-resistant sarcoidosis.

Clinical phenotyping in sarcoidosis using cluster analysis

Background

Most phenotyping paradigms in sarcoidosis are based on expert opinion; however, no paradigm has been widely adopted because of the subjectivity in classification. We hypothesized that cluster analysis could be performed on common clinical variables to define more objective sarcoidosis phenotypes.

Methods

We performed a retrospective cohort study of 554 sarcoidosis cases to identify distinct phenotypes of sarcoidosis based on 29 clinical features. Model-based clustering was performed using the VarSelLCM R package and the Integrated Completed Likelihood (ICL) criteria were used to estimate number of clusters. To identify features associated with cluster membership, features were ranked based on variable importance scores from the VarSelLCM model, and additional univariate tests (Fisher’s exact test and one-way ANOVA) were performed using q-values correcting for multiple testing. The Wasfi severity score was also compared between clusters.

Results

Cluster analysis resulted in 6 sarcoidosis phenotypes. Salient characteristics for each cluster are as follows: Phenotype (1) supranormal lung function and majority Scadding stage 2/3; phenotype (2) supranormal lung function and majority Scadding stage 0/1; phenotype (3) normal lung function and split Scadding stages between 0/1 and 2/3; phenotype (4) obstructive lung function and majority Scadding stage 2/3; phenotype (5) restrictive lung function and majority Scadding stage 2/3; phenotype (6) mixed obstructive and restrictive lung function and mostly Scadding stage 4. Although there were differences in the percentages, all Scadding stages were encompassed by all of the phenotypes, except for phenotype 1, in which none were Scadding stage 4. Clusters 4, 5, 6 were significantly more likely to have ever been on immunosuppressive treatment and had higher Wasfi disease severity scores.

Conclusions

Cluster analysis produced 6 sarcoidosis phenotypes that demonstrated less severe and severe phenotypes. Phenotypes 1, 2, 3 have less lung function abnormalities, a lower percentage on immunosuppressive treatment and lower Wasfi severity scores. Phenotypes 4, 5, 6 were characterized by lung function abnormalities, more parenchymal abnormalities, an increased percentage on immunosuppressive treatment and higher Wasfi severity scores. These data support using cluster analysis as an objective and clinically useful way to phenotype sarcoidosis subjects and to empower clinicians to identify those with more severe disease versus those who have less severe disease, independent of Scadding stage.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12931-022-01993-z.