Treatment of endolymphatic sac tumour (Papillary adenocarcinoma) of the temporal bone

Surgical management of endolymphatic sac tumor: classification, outcomes and strategy. A single institution's experience

PURPOSE

To review the resections of endolymphatic sac tumor (ELST) and describe our experience in the surgical management of ELST.

METHODS

Retrospective investigation of consecutive patients who underwent resection of ELSTs at our hospital between 1999 and 2019. The symptoms, diagnosis, surgical findings, and outcomes were analyzed to develop a tumor staging system and corresponding surgical strategy.

RESULTS

Retrospective review revealed the surgical treatment of 22 ELSTs. Based on intraoperative findings of tumor extent and size, ELSTs were classified into two types. Type-I (n = 6) referred to the small tumors that were locally confined with limited invasion of semicircular canals and dura; type-II (n = 16) referred to the large tumors that presented extensive erosion of at least one anatomic structure apart from the semicircular canals and the dura around endolymphatic sac. In this case series, Type-I ELST is amenable to resection through a transmastoidal approach, and subtotal petrosectomy is appropriate for the resection of type-II ELST. Sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) is the most commonly preoperative symptom in both two types of cases. Five type-II ELSTs experienced recurrence and underwent reoperation, whereas all type-I ELSTs did not.

CONCLUSION

ELST usually results in SNHL (95%) at the time of diagnosis. The surgical strategy and prognosis of ELST resections are different between type-I and type-II: type-I ELST is amenable to transmastoidal approach with the preservation of facial nerve, whereas type-II ELST increase the surgical difficulty and the risk of recurrence, and subtotal petrosectomy is the basic requirement for the resection of type-II ELST.

Symptoms and clinical features in patients affected by endolymphatic sac tumor: a systematic review and meta-analysis

PURPOSE

Most ELST data in the literature are case studies or limited to small cohorts (< 16 patients). We evaluated the main clinical signs observed at endolymphatic sac tumor (ELST) diagnosis in patients with or without Von Hippel-Lindau disease.

METHODS

We conducted a comprehensive literature search in PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science. We included studies with at least 1 patient, of any age, affected by sporadic or VHL-related ELSTs reporting levels of hearing loss and facial nerve function and a comprehensive description of presenting symptoms at ELST diagnosis. We combined data for proportional meta-analysis. p values of 0.05 were considered statistically significant. Methodological quality was evaluated. Analyses were performed with MedCalc 14.8.1 software.

RESULTS

A total of 26 studies, including 113 patients and 118 cases of ELSTs were included. Pooled proportion rates (95% CI) of overall hearing loss was 88.7%, (82.4-93.4), severe hearing loss was 21.6% (12.8-32.1) profound hearing loss was 39.8% (28.7-51.5), vertigo/imbalance was 42.0% (33.8-50.5), tinnitus was 61.8% (53.4-69.8) and facial nerve palsy was 30.6% (23.2-38.9). Generally, symptoms were homogeneous or moderately heterogeneous among included studies.

CONCLUSION

This is the first systematic review of clinical presentations at ELST diagnosis. The most serious clinical events include profound hearing loss and facial impairment. Fluctuating hearing loss, tinnitus and vertigo are frequently reported and may confound correct and prompt ELST diagnosis.

Endolymphatic sac tumor: single-institution series of seven cases with updated review of literature

BACKGROUND

Endolymphatic sac tumour (ELST) is a rare low-grade locally aggressive neoplasm arising from the endolymphatic duct or sac. It presents mostly with vestibulo-cochlear symptoms either sporadically or as part of von Hippel-Lindau (VHL) syndrome. Micro-neurosurgical excision remains the cornerstone of therapy with the role of radiotherapy (RT) being controversial. This is a clinico-pathological analysis of consecutive ELST patients presenting to a single-institution in India.

METHODS

Neuropathology database of a tertiary-care comprehensive cancer centre was searched electronically to identify consecutive patients with histopathological diagnosis of ELST registered at the institute over last one decade. Data regarding demographic profile, clinical presentation, histopathological features, treatment details and outcomes were retrieved from electronic medical records for this retrospective analysis.

RESULTS

Electronic search identified seven unique patients with biopsy-proven ELST registered at the institute between 2009 and 2020. Median age of the study cohort was 39 years (range 24-65 years) with strong male predilection (5:2 ratio) and left-sided preponderance (71%). Most common presenting symptoms were hearing loss (86%) and earache (71%) on affected side followed by headache (43%). All patients underwent maximal safe resection at initial diagnosis and were followed-up closely with periodic surveillance imaging. Two patients underwent salvage RT using high-precision conformal techniques at recurrence/progression.

CONCLUSION

ELST is a rare low-grade locally aggressive neoplasm that arises generally as part of VHL syndrome or sometimes sporadically. Gross total resection provides the best chance of cure with RT being reserved for unresectable disease, large residue, medical inoperability, or as salvage therapy for recurrent/progressive tumor.

Papillary Mucinous Adenocarcinoma of the Endolymphatic Sac: A Rare Middle Ear Neoplasm

Glandular neoplasms of the temporal-mastoid region and endolymphatic sac (ELS) are rare, and it is quite challenging to differentiate between an adenoma and an adenocarcinoma. ELS tumors (ELST) usually present with papillary, follicular, or solid patterns and can be further distinguished histologically and through immunohistochemistry. The microscopic features and clinical course of this neoplasm have been comprehensively explained by Heffner, who considered it "low-grade adenocarcinoma of likely ELS origin." The papillary form more commonly affects females, and it is a more aggressive form of ELST that is destructive and exhibits extensive local spread. The tumor usually has a close association with von Hippel-Lindau (VHL) disease, but 11%-30% of the ELST cases develop in individuals without a VHL mutation. ELSTs manifest with headaches, hearing loss, ear discharge, and cranial nerve palsies. Currently, the only available curative therapeutic intervention consists of wide local excision and long-term follow-up. Because of the sensitive location of this tumor, the adjuvant radiotherapy options are still questionable. In this case report, the author presents a 74-year-old woman with a past medical history of Schneiderian papilloma and was diagnosed with papillary mucinous adenocarcinoma of the ELS not associated with VHL disease.

The endolymphatic sac tumor: challenges in the eradication of a localized disease

OBJECTIVE

Identify the critical points that lead to recurrences and lack of radicality in endolymphatic sac tumors (ELSTs).

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective case study and review of the literature.

SETTING

Tertiary referral center.

PATIENTS

Thirteen cases of ELST were included in the study and their preoperative, intraoperative and postoperative data were analyzed and compared to a review of the literature.

INTERVENTION(S)

Therapeutical.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Prevalence of recurrent and residual tumors, comparison to the literature and analysis of ELST characteristics.

RESULTS

Diagnosis was made 26 ± 17 months after the onset of symptomatology, and an ELST was preoperatively suspected in only six cases. At the time of surgery, 10 patients suffered from hearing loss. Preoperative symptoms or audiometry could not predict labyrinth infiltration, although speech discrimination scores were significantly associated with labyrinth infiltration (p = 0.0413). The labyrinth was infiltrated in 8 cases (57.1%), and in 7 cases (46.7%) the tumor eroded the carotid canal, whereas 6 cases (40%) presented an intradural extension. A gross total resection was achieved in 11 cases. There were two residual tumors, one of which because of profuse bleeding, and one recurrence (23.1%). A mean of 22.8% of recurrent or residual tumors are described in the literature based on 242 published cases, in more than half of the cases as a consequence of subtotal tumor resection (STR).

CONCLUSIONS

Recurrence derives mostly from the difficulty to identify the extension of the tumor due to the extensive bone infiltration. Accurate diagnosis and correct preoperative planning, with embolization when possible, will facilitate surgery and avoid STR due to intraoperative bleeding. Long follow-ups are important in order to avoid insidious recurrences.

Case Series and Systematic Review of Radiation Outcomes for Endolymphatic Sac Tumors

OBJECTIVE

Surgery is the primary treatment modality for endolymphatic sac tumors (ELST). Two case examples are presented to highlight some rare instances when radiation therapy may be used. The outcomes following radiation therapy for ELST are controversial. This report systematically reviews those outcomes and compares results between external beam radiation and stereotactic radiosurgery.

DATA SOURCE

In accordance with PRISMA guidelines a systematic literature search of the Ovid Medline, Embase, Scopus, Cochrane library, and clinicaltrails.gov databases was performed in August 2017.

STUDY SELECTION

Twenty-two studies met inclusion criteria and report ELST outcomes following radiation therapy. Additional data on tumor size, previous surgery, radiation modality, and radiation dosing was collected.

DATA EXTRACTION

The methodological quality was independently assessed by three reviewers. The included studies were small, heterogeneous case reports with a low level of evidence, and several sources of bias.

DATA SYNTHESIS

The primary outcome was tumor control following radiation, defined as no growth. A comparative analysis of external beam versus stereotactic radiation was performed.

CONCLUSION

Forty-six tumors from 42 patients were independently analyzed. The overall tumor control rate was 67.4%. When analyzing patients in which tumor was present at the time of radiation, external beam radiation controlled 9 of 19 tumors (47.4%) while stereotactic radiosurgery controlled 14 of 18 tumors (77.8%). The effect size of 30.4% favors stereotactic radiosurgery, but the wide confidence interval (-4.4 to 57.4%) limits what conclusions can be drawn. Radiation for ELST remains controversial and more long-term data is needed.

Current Treatment of Endolymphatic Sac Tumor of the Temporal Bone

An endolymphatic sac tumor (ELST) is a rare, indolent but locally aggressive tumor arising in the posterior petrous ridge. Patients present with sensorineural hearing loss and tinnitus. As the tumor progresses, patients may experience vertigo, ataxia, facial nerve paresis, pain and otorrhea. Most patients present in their 4th or 5th decade with a wide age range. Patients with von Hippel-Lindau disease have an increased likelihood of developing ELST. Histologically, ELST is a low-grade adenocarcinoma. As it progresses, it destroys bone and extends into adjacent tissues. The likelihood of regional or distant metastases is remote. The optimal treatment is resection with negative margins. Patients with positive margins, gross residual disease, or unresectable tumor are treated with radiotherapy or radiosurgery. Late recurrences are common, so long follow-up is necessary to assess efficacy. The likelihood of cure depends on tumor extent and is probably in the range of 50-75%.

Gamma knife radiosurgery in the management of endolymphatic sac tumors

Background

Although widely regarded as rare epithelial tumors with a low grade of malignancy, endolymphatic sac tumors (ELST) often lead to disabling petrous bone destruction and significantly impairing symptoms at the time of primary diagnosis and/or recurrence. ELST is not uncommon in von Hippel Lindau (VHL) patients. Although open surgery is regarded as the best treatment option, recurrence remains a challenge, particularly when gross tumor resection (GTR) is deemed unachievable due to topographic conditions. Tumor recurrence successfully treated with fractionated radiotherapy and radiosurgery have been reported in selected cases. We present the case of a patient with recurrent ELST treated with salvage gamma knife radiosurgery (GKRS) adding a review of current literature.

Case Description

A 65-year-old patient underwent GKRS of an unresectable, recurrent ELST. Tumor volumetric analysis showed almost 15% increase in tumor volume in the 4 months between the pre-GKRS magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and the stereotactic MRI (s-MRI) at treatment. Follow-up MRI at 12 and 20 months showed significant decrease in local tumor volume, decreased contrast enhancement and no perifocal edema. The patient's general and neurological status remains stable to the present day.

Conclusion

In the present case, GKRS was effective in the management of a recurrent ELST over the course of 20 months. Because of ELSTs recurrence potential, long-term follow up is required. The present case as well as previous reports might suggest a possible salvage/adjunctive role of radiosurgery in the management of ELST. Further studies are deemed necessary.