Synchronous detoxification and reduction treatment of tannery sludge using Cr (VI) resistant bacterial strains

Modern-Day Green Strategies for the Removal of Chromium from Wastewater

Chromium is an essential element in various industrial processes, including stainless steel production, electroplating, metal finishing, leather tanning, photography, and textile manufacturing. However, it is also a well-documented contaminant of aquatic systems and agricultural land, posing significant economic and health challenges. The hexavalent form of chromium [Cr(VI)] is particularly toxic and carcinogenic, linked to severe health issues such as cancer, kidney disorders, liver failure, and environmental biomagnification. Due to the high risks associated with chromium contamination in potable water, researchers have focused on developing effective removal strategies. Among these strategies, biosorption has emerged as a promising, cost-effective, and energy-efficient method for eliminating toxic metals, especially chromium. This process utilizes agricultural waste, plants, algae, bacteria, fungi, and other biomass as adsorbents, demonstrating substantial potential for the remediation of heavy metals from contaminated environments at minimal cost. This review paper provides a comprehensive analysis of various strategies, materials, and mechanisms involved in the bioremediation of chromium, along with their commercial viability. It also highlights the advantages of biosorption over traditional chemical and physical methods, offering a thorough understanding of its applications and effectiveness.

Biostabilization of fecal sludge and tannery liming sludge: A novel approach

Fecal sludge and tannery liming sludge management is essential for humans and the environment. The emitted amount of waste from two industries is reduced in composting leading to value-added products. This research focused on the effectiveness and feasibility of co-composting fecal sludge and hair-burning liming sludge from tannery. Fecal sludge was intermittently mixed with hair-burning liming sludge which also consisted of chicken manure and sawdust. Five piles (Pile 1, Pile 2, Pil3, Pile 4, and Pile 5) indicated respectively as P#1, P#2, P#3, P#4, and P#5, contained various ratios of composting materials were mixed, piled onto a horizontal bamboo frame, and observed for 120 days. To ensure a suitable oxygen supply, the composting piles were turned on in the thermophilic stage so that pathogens could not survive. The highest temperatures in the thermophilic stage were 39.0°C, 49.2°C, 55.7°C, 41.7°C, and 51.3°C. These referred to the respective piles P#1, P#2, P#3, P#4, and P#5. The Dewar stability index confirmed the stability of each composting pile, and the maximum degradation was found for P#3. The metals chromium (Cr), zinc (Zn), lead (Pb), iron (Fe), and nickel (Ni) in the final compost were found to be 38.1, 144.7, 15.1, 450.5, and 22.7 mg/kg, respectively. TCLP results reveal only an insignificant amount of metal leaching. Fecal coliform of the compost was below the standard level; Helminth eggs and Salmonella spp. were absent. SEM micrographs reflect the decomposition of composting materials. The maximum germination index and germination capacity of compost pile P#3 for compost-soil ratio 1:0 and 1:1 were 90%-92.8% and 100%, respectively. The present approach produced nutrient-enriched compost from fecal sludge and hair-burning liming sludge from a tannery emerges as a suitable solution for reducing solid wastes.

Phenotypic characterization for bioremediation suitability of isolates from Southern Tunisian tannery effluent

Effluents from the leather tanning industry contain diverse pollutants, including hazardous heavy metals, posing threats to public health and the surrounding environment. Indigenous bacterial isolates can represent an eco-friendly approach for tannery wastewater treatment; however, phenotypic characterization is necessary to determine whether these strains are suitable for bioremediation. In the present study, we analyzed seven new Enterococcus faecium strains and two new Bacillus subtillis strains isolated from effluents from the Southern Tunisian Tannery (ESTT). We evaluated phenotypic features beneficial for bioremediation, including biofilm formation, hydrophobicity, and exoenzyme activities. Additionally, we examined characteristics naturally occurring in environmental bacteria but less desirable in strains selected for bioremediation, such as antibiotic resistances and pathogenicity indicators. The observed phenotypes were then compared with whole-genome analysis. We observed biofilm production in two slime-producing bacteria, B. licheniformis RLT6, and E. faecium RLT8. Hydrophobicity of E. faecium strains RLT1, RLT5, RLT8, and RLT9, as well as B. licheniformis RLT6 correlated positively with increasing ESTT concentration. Exoenzyme activities were detected in E. faecium strains RLT2, RLT4, and RLT7, as well as B. licheniformis RLT6. As anticipated, all strains exhibited common resistances to antibiotics and hemolysis, which are widespread in nature and do not hinder their application for bioremediation. Importantly, none of the strains exhibited the pathogenic hypermucoviscosity phenotype. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report consolidating all these phenotypic characteristics concurrently, providing a complete overview of strains suitability for bioremediation. IMPORTANCE: The study evaluates the bioremediation potential of seven Enterococcus faecium strains and two Bacillus subtillis strains isolated from the effluents from the Southern Tunisian tannery (ESTT), which pose threats to public health and environmental integrity. The analysis primarily examines the phenotypic traits crucial to bioremediation, including biofilm formation, hydrophobicity, and exoenzyme activities, as well as characteristics naturally occurring in environmental bacteria related to heavy metal resistance, such as antibiotic resistances. Several strains were found to have high bioremediation potential and exhibit only antibiotic resistances commonly found in nature, ensuring their application for bioremediation remains uncompromised. The results of the exhaustive phenotypic analysis are contrasted with the whole genome sequences of the nine strains, underscoring the appropriateness of these bacterial strains for eco-friendly interventions in tannery wastewater treatment.

A review on chromium health hazards and molecular mechanism of chromium bioremediation

Living beings have been devastated by environmental pollution, which has reached its peak. The disastrous pollution of the environment is in large part due to industrial wastes containing toxic pollutants. The widespread use of chromium (Cr (III)/Cr (VI)) in industries, especially tanneries, makes it one of the most dangerous environmental pollutants. Chromium pollution is widespread due to ineffective treatment methods. Bioremediation of chromium (Cr) using bacteria is very thoughtful due to its eco-friendly and cost-effective outcome. In order to counter chromium toxicity, bacteria have numerous mechanisms, such as the ability to absorb, reduce, efflux, or accumulate the metal. In this review article, we focused on chromium toxicity on human and environmental health as well as its bioremediation mechanism.

Health risk study of cadmium, chromium, lead and arsenic in reservoir water of Changzhou, China

Accurately assessing the health risks of human exposure to heavy metals via water is of great importance for performing targeted health risk prevention measures. To better understand the concentration characteristics and potential harm to human health of cadmium, chromium, lead and arsenic in the main drinking water-type reservoirs of Changzhou city, we collected samples from the Haidi Reservoir, Dongjin Reservoir, Xinfushan Reservoir, Maodong Reservoir and Xiangyang Reservoir of Changzhou in the summer of 2019. The results showed that the daily average comprehensive exposure level of metals was much lower than the provisional tolerated daily intake (PTDI), i.e., Cd: 1 µg kg^-1 d^-1; Cr: 3 µg kg^-1 d^-1; Pb: 3.57 µg kg^-1 d^-1; and As: 2.14 µg kg^-1 d^-1. The comprehensive non-carcinogenic risk levels of four metals under water-drinking exposure and water-skin exposure routes ranged from 4.68E - 3 to 1.69E - 1, and the carcinogenic risk ranged from 2.09E - 5 to 7.30E - 5, which were all at acceptable risk levels. Although lead and chromium were present at acceptable health risk levels, they still represented the main pollutants of potential health risk in the local water environment from a non-carcinogenic or carcinogenic perspective, and they should be listed as the primary targets for water environmental risk management.

Characterization of the simultaneous degradation of pyrene and removal of Cr(VI) by a bacteria consortium YH

Microorganisms that can simultaneously remediate organic pollutants and heavy metal contamination are great significance in bioremediation. Nevertheless, reports of such microorganisms are still scarce. Here, Pseudomonas sp. YH-1 and Rhodococcus sp. YH-3 were isolated and identified, and they showed greater tolerance to hexavalent (VI) (750 and 800 mg·L^-1). The constructed bacteria consortium YH (YH-1:YH-3 = 1:1) could simultaneously degrade 41.69% of pyrene (50 mg·L^-1) and remove 76.67% of Cr(VI) (30 mg·L^-1) within 5 days. The potential mechanism of Cr(VI) tolerance of YH was further explored by genomic and microscopic analysis. The results showed that YH responded to Cr(VI) stress mainly through efflux of Cr(VI) by chrA and copZ, chromate reduction, DNA-repaired proteases reduces ROS damage, and biosorption by carboxyl, hydroxyl, amino functional groups. Strains YH-1 and YH-3 also contained a variety of genes associated with resistance to other heavy metals, such as cadmium (czcBD), mercury (merAPTR), manganese (mntABC) and copper (copAC, cusABRF and pcoBD). Based on GC-MS and genomic analysis, pyrene was degraded via salicylic acid and phthalic acid pathways. Moreover, a great number of genes related to aromatic hydrocarbon catabolism were identified in the genomes of YH-1 and YH-3. These results confirmed the potential application of the bacteria consortium YH in the bioremediation of water and soil co-contaminated with PAHs-heavy metals.

Bacterial Biosorbents, an Efficient Heavy Metals Green Clean-Up Strategy: Prospects, Challenges, and Opportunities

Rapid industrialization has led to the pollution of soil and water by various types of contaminants. Heavy metals (HMs) are considered the most reactive toxic contaminants, even at low concentrations, which cause health problems through accumulation in the food chain and water. Remediation using conventional methods, including physical and chemical techniques, is a costly treatment process and generates toxic by-products, which may negatively affect the surrounding environment. Therefore, biosorption has attracted significant research interest in the recent decades. In contrast to existing methods, bacterial biomass offers a potential alternative for recovering toxic/persistent HMs from the environment through different mechanisms for metal ion uptake. This review provides an outlook of the advantages and disadvantages of the current bioremediation technologies and describes bacterial groups, especially extremophiles with biosorbent potential for heavy metal removal with relevant examples and perspectives.

Solidification of chromium-containing sludge with attapulgite combined alkali slag

To solve the harm caused by hazardous chromium-containing sludge (CCS, chromium-containing sludge) waste to humans and the environment, this study used attapulgite to strengthen alkali slag to prepare cementitious materials to solidify/stabilize CCS. Single-factor and orthogonal experiments were used to optimize the preparation parameters of alkali slag cementitious materials. The compressive strength, heavy metal leaching toxicity, and microscopic characterization of a CCS solidified body were tested to investigate the solidification effect and mechanism of CCS formation. The best attapulgite content was 4%; the solidified body after the treatment of chromium-containing sludge had a good performance of heavy metal leaching and mechanical properties. The addition of attapulgite enhanced the compressive strength. Compared with the original CCS, the leaching concentration of heavy metals in the solidified body was significantly reduced. Among them, the solidified efficiency of chromium is stable above 90%. The changes in the results of XRD and FTIR for each component were studied. It indicated that the solidified body may solidify/stabilize heavy metals through physical encapsulation of the amorphous form and chemical immobilization. This research recognized the use of waste to treat waste, realized the combined effect of solidification/adsorption, and indicated the possibility of application of attapulgite and its solidified products in construction.

A high-efficiency Klebsiella variicola H12-CMC-FeS@biochar for chromium removal from aqueous solution

In polluted groundwater, surface water, and industrial sites, chromium is found as one of the most common heavy metals, and one of the 20 main pollutants in China, which poses a great threat to the ecological environment and human health. Combining biological and chemical materials to treat groundwater contaminated by heavy metals is a promising restoration technology. In this research, Klebsiella variicola H12 (abbreviated as K. variicola) was found to have Cr(VI) reduction ability. A high-efficiency Klebsiella variicola H12-carboxymethyl cellulose (abbreviated as CMC)-FeS@biochar system was established for Cr(VI) removal from aqueous solution. The Scanning Electron Microscope-Energy Dispersive Spectrometer (SEM-EDS), X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) results indicated that CMC-FeS was successfully loaded onto the surface of biochar, and K. variicola H12 grew well in the presence of CMC-FeS@biochar with microbial biomass up to 4.8 × 108 cells mL-1. Cr(VI) removal rate of CMC-FeS@biochar system, K. variicola H12 system and K. variicola H12 + CMC-FeS@biochar system were 61.8%, 82.2% and 96.6% respectively. This study demonstrated K. variicola H12-CMC-FeS@biochar system have potential value for efficient removal of Cr(VI) from Cr(VI)-polluted groundwater.

Chemical-Assisted Microbially Mediated Chromium (Cr) (VI) Reduction Under the Influence of Various Electron Donors, Redox Mediators, and Other Additives: An Outlook on Enhanced Cr(VI) Removal

Chromium (Cr) (VI) is a well-known toxin to all types of biological organisms. Over the past few decades, many investigators have employed numerous bioprocesses to neutralize the toxic effects of Cr(VI). One of the main process for its treatment is bioreduction into Cr(III). Key to this process is the ability of microbial enzymes, which facilitate the transfer of electrons into the high valence state of the metal that acts as an electron acceptor. Many underlying previous efforts have stressed on the use of different external organic and inorganic substances as electron donors to promote Cr(VI) reduction process by different microorganisms. The use of various redox mediators enabled electron transport facility for extracellular Cr(VI) reduction and accelerated the reaction. Also, many chemicals have employed diverse roles to improve the Cr(VI) reduction process in different microorganisms. The application of aforementioned materials at the contaminated systems has offered a variety of influence on Cr(VI) bioremediation by altering microbial community structures and functions and redox environment. The collective insights suggest that the knowledge of appropriate implementation of suitable nutrients can strongly inspire the Cr(VI) reduction rate and efficiency. However, a comprehensive information on such substances and their roles and biochemical pathways in different microorganisms remains elusive. In this regard, our review sheds light on the contributions of various chemicals as electron donors, redox mediators, cofactors, etc., on microbial Cr(VI) reduction for enhanced treatment practices.

Advances in microbial remediation for heavy metal treatment: a mini review

Abstract

In recent years, microbiological treatment to remediate contamination by heavy metals has aroused public attention as such pollution has seriously threatens ecosystems and human health and impedes sustainable development. However, the aspect of actual industrial wastewater and solid waste remediation by microorganisms is not explored sufficiently. And what we focus on is technical field of microbial remediation. Therefore, in this review, we discuss and summarize heavy metal treatment via microbiological approaches in different media, including wastewater, solid waste from industrial factories and polluted sites. We also clarify the technical applicability from the perspective of biosorption, bioleaching, biominerization, etc. In particular, the exploration of the combination of microbiological approaches with chemical methods or phytoextraction are scrutinized in this review relative to real waste heavy metal remediation. Furthermore, we highlight the importance of hyperaccumulator endophytes.

Graphical abstract

Study on detoxification and removal mechanisms of hexavalent chromium by microorganisms

Extensive industrial activities have led to an increase of the content of chromium in the environment, which causes serious pollution to the surrounding water, soil and atmosphere. The enrichment of chromium in the environment through the food chain ultimately affects human health. Therefore, the remediation of chromium pollution is crucial to development of human society. A lot of scholars have paid attention to bioremediation technology owing to its environmentally friendly and low-cost. Previous reviews mostly involved pure culture of microorganisms and rarely discussed the optimization of bioreduction conditions. To make up for these shortcomings, we not only introduced in detail the conditions that affect microbial reduction but also innovatively introduced consortium which may be the cornerstone for future treatment of complex field environments. The aim of this study is to summary chromium toxicity, factors affecting microbial remediation, and methods for enhancing bioremediation. However, the actual application of bioremediation technology is still facing a major challenge. This study also put forward the current research problems and proposed future research directions, providing theoretical guidance and scientific basis for the application of bioremediation technology.

Dual resource utilization for tannery sludge: Effects of sludge biochars (BCs) on volatile fatty acids (VFAs) production from sludge anaerobic digestion

Resource utilization of organic matters in tannery sludge has drawn great attention. In this paper, the influences of sludge biochars (BCs) on volatile fatty acids (VFAs) production from the anaerobic digestion of sludge supernatant (SST) were investigated. Experimental results demonstrated that the VFAs yields improved in the presence of BCs with rich functional groups. The maximum yield of VFAs was 1037.5 mg/g SCOD with the addition of BC-1 biochar (zeta potential -50.42 mV). BCs decreased ammonia nitrogen concentration, thus reducing inhibition for bacteria during the anaerobic digestion. Microbial community analysis indicated that the BCs affected microbial community structures and contributed to a favorable environment for bacteria. Especially, the BC-1 biochar with rich functional groups enhanced the relative abundance of acid-forming bacteria (Clostridiales). A dual strategy was proposed to improve the resource utilization efficiency for tannery sludge.

An overview on heavy metal resistant microorganisms for simultaneous treatment of multiple chemical pollutants at co-contaminated sites, and their multipurpose application

Anthropogenic imbalance of chemical pollutants in environment raises serious threat to all life forms. Contaminated sites often possess multiple heavy metals and other types of pollutants. Elimination of chemical pollutants at co-contaminated sites is imperative for the safe ecosystem functions, and simultaneous removal approach is an attractive scheme for their remediation. Different conventional techniques have been applied as concomitant treatment solution but fall short at various parameters. In parallel, use of microorganisms offers an innovative, cost effective and ecofriendly approach for simultaneous treatment of various chemical pollutants. However, microbiostasis due to harmful effects of heavy metals or other contaminants is a serious bottleneck facing remediation practices in co-contaminated sites. But certain microorganisms have unique mechanisms to resist heavy metals, and can act on different noxious wastes. Considering this significant, my review provides information on different heavy metal resistant microorganisms for bioremediation of different chemical pollutants, and other assistance. In this favour, the integrated approach of simultaneous treatment of multiple heavy metals and other environmental contaminants using different heavy metal resistant microorganisms is summarized. Further, the discussion also intends toward the use of heavy metal resistant microorganisms associated with industrial and environmental applications, and healthcare. PREFACE: Simultaneous treatment of multiple chemical pollutants using microorganisms is relatively a new approach. Therefore, this subject was not well received for review before. Also, multipurpose application of heavy metal microorganisms has certainly not considered for review. In this regard, this review attempts to gather information on recent progress on studies on different heavy metal resistant microorganisms for their potential of treatment of co-contaminated sites, and multipurpose application.

Chromium Pollution in European Water, Sources, Health Risk, and Remediation Strategies: An Overview

Chromium is a potentially toxic metal occurring in water and groundwater as a result of natural and anthropogenic sources. Microbial interaction with mafic and ultramafic rocks together with geogenic processes release Cr (VI) in natural environment by chromite oxidation. Moreover, Cr (VI) pollution is largely related to several Cr (VI) industrial applications in the field of energy production, manufacturing of metals and chemicals, and subsequent waste and wastewater management. Chromium discharge in European Union (EU) waters is subjected to nationwide recommendations, which vary depending on the type of industry and receiving water body. Once in water, chromium mainly occurs in two oxidation states Cr (III) and Cr (VI) and related ion forms depending on pH values, redox potential, and presence of natural reducing agents. Public concerns with chromium are primarily related to hexavalent compounds owing to their toxic effects on humans, animals, plants, and microorganisms. Risks for human health range from skin irritation to DNA damages and cancer development, depending on dose, exposure level, and duration. Remediation strategies commonly used for Cr (VI) removal include physico-chemical and biological methods. This work critically presents their advantages and disadvantages, suggesting a site-specific and accurate evaluation for choosing the best available recovering technology.

Role of bacterial cell surface sulfhydryl sites in cadmium detoxification by Pseudomonas putida

Understanding bacterial metal detoxification systems is crucial for determining the environmental impacts of metal pollution and for developing advanced bioremediation and water disinfection strategies. Here, we explore the role of cell surface sulfhydryl sites in bacterial detoxification of Cd, using Pseudomonas putida with surface sulfhydryl sites mostly on its EPS molecules as a model organism. Our results show that 5 and 20 ppm Cd in LB growth medium affects the lag phase of P. putida, but not the overall extent of cell growth at stationary phase, indicating that P. putida can detoxify Cd at these concentrations. EXAFS analysis of Cd bound to biomass from the different growth stages indicates that Cd binds to both sulfhydryl and non-sulfhydryl sites, but that the importance of Cd-sulfhydryl binding increases from early exponential to stationary phase. Cell growth is positively correlated to the measured sulfhydryl concentration on different biomass samples, but is independent of the measured non-sulfhydryl binding site concentration on the cell surfaces. Taken together, our results demonstrate that the sulfhydryl binding sites on EPS molecules can play an important role in binding and detoxifying toxic metals, significantly decreasing the bioavailability of the metal by sequestering it away from the bacterial cells.

Enhancement of Chromium (VI) Reduction in Microcosms Amended with Lactate or Yeast Extract: A Laboratory-Scale Study

A laboratory-scale study was carried out to evaluate the groundwater bioremediation potential of hexavalent chromium (Cr(VI)), taking into account the chromate pollution of an industrial site located in Southern Italy (Apulia Region). The reduction of Cr(VI) was studied on laboratory microcosms, set up in different experimental conditions, namely: ABIO (soil and water sterilized), BIO (soil and water not sterilized), LATT (with the addition of lactate), and YE (with the addition of yeast extract). Control test lines, set up by using sterilized matrices and amendments, were employed to assess the occurrence of the pollutant reduction via chemical processes. By combining molecular (microbial abundance, specific chromate reductase genes (ChR) and the Shewanella oinedensis bacterial strain) with chemical analyses of chromium (VI and III) in the matrices (water and soil) of each microcosm, it was possible to investigate the response of microbial populations to different experimental conditions, and therefore, to assess their bioremediation capability in promoting Cr(VI) reduction. The overall results achieved within this work evidenced the key role of amendments (lactate and yeast extract) in enhancing the biological reduction of hexavalent chromium in the contaminated aqueous phase of laboratory microcosms. The highest value of Cr(VI) removal (99.47%) was obtained in the YE amended microcosms at seven days.