Study on the theories and methods of ecological flow guarantee rate index under different time scales

Joint guarantee rate index assessment of the contribution of agricultural water-saving measures to river ecological flow in water shortage areas

Reconciling higher ecological water demands and economic purposes with finite freshwater resources remains one of the great management dilemmas. Low water efficiency and large water consumption in agricultural irrigation hinder the protection of river ecological flow in the water shortage areas of Northwest China. By analyzing the surplus and shortage of river ecological protection targets, the intensity guarantee rate index is innovatively proposed to quantitatively evaluate the important contribution of improved water-saving measures for river flow restoration. It compensates for the shortcomings of the duration guarantee rate index in evaluation that may mask ecological problems. Considering ecological baseflow, fish species, and landscape water demand, the ecological flow interval (6.00-12.42 m3/s) was determined. Three scenarios are highlighted for different typical years and irrigation regimes in combination with planting structure adjustment and irrigation water utilization coefficient. In 75 %, 90 %, and 95 % typical years, the maximum total annual water-savings (Scenario 3) are 57.3, 57.1, and 87.2 million m3 (sufficient irrigation); 32.2, 33.9, and 35.5 million m3 (deficit irrigation) respectively. The guarantee degree of river ecological flow under both irrigation regimes increased from the previous 65.6 % to a maximum of 91.7 % and 81.2 %. The increase in the daily guarantee rate and decrease in the intensity guarantee rate under the aforementioned three scenarios indicate a reduction of damage depth and duration of ecological flow. By using a quantitative study, it is pointed out that improving agricultural water-saving is a reasonable and necessary way to protect the river flow.

Coupling hydrological, habitat and water supply indicators to improve the management of environmental flows

Highly regulated basins have traditionally required management practices to mitigate the negative environmental impacts and ensure human well-being. This paper proposes and assesses environmental and water supply deficit indicators to assist in the management of environmental flows (e-flows). For that, a water allocation model is applied, and hydrological alteration, habitat alteration and water supply indicators are quantified, normalized and integrated into a general basin management indicator. This basin management indicator is analyzed for four management approaches and seven e-flow scenarios in the Júcar River Basin (eastern Spain). Hydrological alteration indicators show a less pronounced alteration in the river sections located upstream of the basin while a higher alteration in the downstream sections. As for the habitat indicators, they experience an improvement compared to the natural regime. Based on the values of the basin management indicator, the best e-flow scenario to adopt in the Júcar River Basin is selected. The indicators proposed in this work are useful for supporting decision-making regarding the planning and management of e-flows in regulated river basins worldwide.

Calculation and evaluation of suitable ecological flows for eco-environmental recovery of cascade-developed rivers

River cascade development affects the hydrological and habitat characteristics of the region and disrupts the dynamic balance of stable river ecosystems. The most profound impact of river cascade development is on the resident fish species. River ecosystem restoration for maximum river habitat improvement is generally based on water security and environment improvement and effectively embodies the nature-based solutions (NbS) concept of naturalized restoration. Yuanjiang (Y.J.) River is an international river in southwest China seriously affected by cascade development. By determining the response of the river ecosystem and using the key performance indicator method, Yuanjiang carp (Cyprinus carpio rubrofuscus) and red giant catfish (Bagarius rutilus) were identified as the key species in the main stream of the Y.J. River., and the ecological effects of river cascade development on them were studied by applying two-dimensional hydrodynamic physical habitat simulation and multi-objective ecological scheduling models. Based on the calculation results for ecological operation optimization of cascade reservoirs, an improved progressive optimality algorithm was used to calculate the ecological flows required to maintain the stability of the river ecosystem. With the increasing extent of cascade development in the river, important indicators, such as the intra-annual, extreme, high, and low flows have changed significantly, and the hydrological characteristics of the main stream have changed rapidly and comprehensively. Habitat suitability curves were used to determine the appropriate water depth and delineate the weighted usable area required for the spawning, nursing, and growing periods of the key fish species. The suitable ecological flows required for the three life-cycle stages of the C. carpio rubrofuscus accounted for 34, 45, and 62 %, respectively, of the multi-year mean natural water inflow at the Qiaotou (Q.T.) cascade, whereas those required for the three respective periods of B. rutilus accounted for 47, 98, and 27 %, respectively, of the multi-year mean natural water inflow at the Madushan (M.D·S.) cascade. Considering the physiological lifecycle demands of the indicator/key fish species and the upper limit of water resources development and utilization in the key river section, the ecological flow precipitation frequency in the Q.T.-Luodie (Q.T.-L.D.) and M.D·S.-Xinjie (M.D·S.-X.J.) sections (currently at 25, 50, and 75 %, respectively) can be increased to 100 % under optimal operating conditions (cascade hydropower station optimal operation). After implementing the multi-objective ecological operation at the Y.J. River main-stream cascade reservoirs, the suitable habitat area for C. carpio rubrofuscus and B. rutilus increased significantly (>10 % and 15 %, respectively). In general, the NbS-based ecological flow calculation method for cascade-developed rivers has a wide range of applications, which can be useful for the eco-environment restoration of rivers and improving the living habitats of waterway organisms.

Spatial and Temporal Patterns of Ecological Connectivity in the Ethnic Areas, Sichuan Province, China

With ongoing economic and social development, natural habitats are becoming increasingly fragmented, blocking habitat connections and reducing landscape connectivity. The study of changes in ecological connectivity can provide valuable information for habitat and landscape restoration, which are necessary for sustainable regional development. Despite the growing interest in this issue, studies that reveal the change in ecological connectivity in the compounded areas of ecological vulnerability and deep poverty are still lacking. In this paper, one of the most underdeveloped and ecologically fragile southwestern ethnic regions of China, the Sanzhou region of Sichuan Province, was the study area. Based on a vector map of current land-use status and vector data on ecosystem factors and nature reserves in 2010 and 2015, the change in ecological connectivity was analyzed using the minimum cumulative resistance model using GIS spatial analysis method. Firstly, ecological sources were identified based on the distribution of ecological functional areas. Secondly, the ecological resistance surface based on ecosystem service value is revised by integrating the three dimensions of topography and hydrology, ecological environment and development, and utilization intensity. Finally, the ecological connectivity of ethnic areas in southwest China in 2010 and 2015 was compared and analyzed through the perspective of ecological resistance. The results show that: (1) From 2010 to 2015, the overall ecological connectivity decreased. (2) There were six areas of high ecological resistance featuring human activity and ecological degradation: the Anning River Valley in Liangshan Prefecture, Ganzi, Dege and Luho counties in Ganzi Prefecture, and Ruoergai and Hongyuan counties in Aba Prefecture. (3) Low ecological resistance areas were more numerous and widely distributed, forming an ecological protection barrier for the three autonomous prefectures, and regulating and protecting their natural environments. It is necessary to maintain and strengthen this protection; accordingly, measures are proposed to improve ecological connectivity. This study provides a reference for achieving ecological security and harmonious coexistence between humans and nature in this region.

Habitat alteration assessment for the management of environmental flows in regulated basins

The management of environmental flows is of paramount importance in regulated water resources systems to preserve river ecosystems. This work proposes a methodology to assess habitat alteration in river basins altered by management activities. The methodology is based on the joint application of a basin management model (SIMGES, AQUATOOL) and a model to estimate habitat time series (CAUDECO). CAUDECO is based on the weighted useable areas of the species in their different vital stages that, in turn, depend on the flows in each river stretch and the biological periods of the species. The final output is an indicator of habitat alteration, which is defined ad hoc for this work to relate the habitat suitability under regulated and natural regimes. The methodology was applied to a case study in north-western Spain: the Órbigo River basin. The results in the current management scenario highlight that the ecological flows improve the habitat suitability of several species with respect to natural regime conditions. For instance, the mean values of the habitat time series in the Órbigo River for the brown trout and bermejuela under regulated conditions are 69.6% and 88%; whereas in natural regime they are equal to 55.1% and 72.9%, respectively. Based on these results, eight additional scenarios of ecological flows were tested and their effects on both habitat alteration and water demand reliability were quantified and discussed. It was found that increases in the ecological flows up to 30% do not affect the reliability of water demands and reduce habitat alteration (i.e., lead to values of the habitat alteration indicator closer to 1) for all species present in the river basin. These results highlight that the methodology and indicator of habitat alteration proposed in this paper are useful to support the management of regulated river basins, since they allow assessing the implications of ecological flows on both habitat suitability and reliability of water demands.

Effects of environmental flows on hydrological alteration and reliability of water demands

This paper presents a methodology to assess the effects of management strategies of environmental flows on the hydrological alteration of river basins on a daily scale. It comprises the collection and analysis of data, the implementation and calibration of a water allocation model; the computation of the natural flow regime; and the estimation, normalization, and aggregation of hydrological alteration indicators to obtain a global indicator of the hydrological alteration. The methodology was applied to a case study in the Iberian Peninsula: The Orbigo River basin, which belongs to the Duero River basin district. For that, three management scenarios were defined: the current scenario, a scenario without any environmental flow and the scenario with the environmental flows initially projected for the period 2022-2027. These scenarios were modelled with the SIMGES water allocation model, which is calibrated in the study site, and the hydrological alterations in four river stretches with different locations and characteristics were assessed. The implications of each environmental flow scenario on the demand reliabilities were also analysed. The global indicator of hydrological alteration obtained in the projected scenario was greater (better) than those of the other two scenarios, but the reliabilities of the water demands were worse. The methodology proposed in this work can be helpful to design environmental flow regimes considering both the effects on the hydrological alteration and the implication on the water demand reliabilities.

Study of spatial distribution characteristics of river eco-environmental values based on emergy-GeoDa method

River eco-environmental value assessment is indispensable for the optimal allocation of watershed water resources. In this study, river eco-environmental values were divided into the values inside and outside the river based on the energy transfer and transformation of the water cycle. Their spatial distribution characteristics (spatial distribution map, spatial autocorrelation, and spatial aggregation) of 67 regions (states, leagues, and cities) in the Yellow River Basin (YRB) were analysed by combining emergy theory and GeoDa 1.14 software (emergy-GeoDa), and the significance of the results was tested. The results showed that: (1) the eco-environmental values inside the river were higher than those outside in the YRB, proving that eco-environmental water inside the river should be guaranteed and water consumption outside the river should not occupy water inside the river from the perspective of value; (2) the spatial distributions of eco-environmental values inside and outside the river were uneven, but obvious spatial aggregations were observed; (3) high- and low-value aggregations of eco-environmental values were observed inside the river in the lower and upper reaches of the YRB, respectively; (4) high- and low-value aggregations of eco-environmental values were observed outside the river in the middle and upper reaches of the YRB, respectively. It was suggested that ecological conservation and high-quality development should be considered as the goals for consolidating the river eco-environmental values in high-value areas and promoting in low-value areas, and low-value areas should be improved by high-value areas while allocating water resources in the YRB. These results provide suggestions for the sustainable development of river eco-environmental system in the YRB from a spatial perspective. In addition, the analysis method is also applicable for studying the spatial distribution characteristics of the values generated by the water and energy cycles of other regions.