Sustainable upgrading of biological municipal wastewater treatment based on anammox: From microbial understanding to engineering application

Integrating network and in-silico simulation insights into the ecological interactions shaped by carbon sources in partial denitrification and anammox system

The underlying ecological mechanism of microbial communities shaped by carbon source in partial denitrification and anammox (PDA) systems remains poorly understood, despite the potential of multiple carbon sources to support the partial denitrification process. Herein, the integrated network and in-silico simulation methods were used to evaluate the considerable impact of carbon sources on the dynamics of ecological interactions. The fluctuation of carbon source (from acetate to glucose and ethanol) significantly destabilized the performance of PDA system (total nitrogen removal efficiency decreased from 96.8% to 69.1%). Glucose simultaneously altered the composition of denitrifying bacteria, resulting in a significant enrichment of the genus Elstera (from 0% to 12.7%). By contrast, genus Thauera re-dominated for partial denitrification with ethanol as carbon source. Importantly, heterotrophic bacteria (e.g., genus Calditrichia) gradually enriched by utilizing ethanol. The presence of acetate in phase IV further enhanced the competitive advantage of heterotrophic bacteria over denitrifying bacteria, thereby resulting in the deteriorated performance of the PDA system. The in-silico simulation of co-culture further revealed that the overgrowth of auxotrophic species Calditrichia utilized amounts of nutrients and limited other functional bacteria. Additionally, the whole co-occurrence network indicated that positive interactions likely improved the adaptability of anammox bacteria under the unsteady conditions. This study provides profound insights into the ecological interactions shaped by carbon sources in PDA systems and underscores the necessity of comprehensive review of the external carbon source to ensure optimal performance.

Advanced nitrogen removal from extremely low carbon/nitrogen ratio municipal wastewater by optimizing multiple pathways based on step-feed and intermittent aeration

The advantages of step-feed and intermittent aeration have been well-documented, however, combining them to enhance nitrogen removal in anaerobic/oxic/anoxic systems has been rarely explored. This study established the non-single-form anoxic stages by step-feed and intermittent aeration and finally enhanced the nitrogen removal of real municipal wastewater with step-feed anaerobic/oxic/anoxic/oxic/anoxic operation mode. Results revealed that Candidatus_Brocadia increased from 0.00 % to 0.21 % in the suspended sludge system, contributing 54.7 % of the nitrogen removal. Partial nitrification (PN) and endogenous partial denitrification (EPD) supplied nitrite for Anammox. A comprehensive multi-pathway nitrogen removal system, encompassing PN, nitrification, partial denitrification, Anammox, EPD/Anammox, and denitrification was constructed. The system effectively reduced total inorganic nitrogen concentration to 3.6 ± 1.2 mg/L at a carbon/nitrogen ratio of 3.0 ± 0.3, achieving a nitrogen removal efficiency of 95.3 ± 1.5 %. This study provides a novel approach for the advanced treatment of municipal wastewater and enrichment of anaerobic ammonia-oxidizing bacteria.

Pilot-scale implementation of mainstream anammox for municipal wastewater treatment against cold temperature

Applying anammox to municipal wastewater treatment promises enormous energy and resource savings; however, seasonally cold conditions pose a considerable challenge, impeding its future applications towards non-tropical regions. In this study, we establish a pilot-scale wastewater treatment plant (50 m3/d) in northern China and implement the partial denitrification coupling anammox process on actual municipal wastewater. Despite seasonal cooling, the nitrogen removal efficiency remains high, ranging from 75.0 ± 4.6% at 27.8-20.0 °C to 70.4 ± 4.5% at 10-7.5 °C. This process exhibits remarkable low-temperature tolerance, achieving an in-situ anammox rate of 32.7 ± 4.7 g-N/(m3·d) at 10-7.5 °C and contributing up to 39.7 ± 6.7% to nitrogen removal. Further 15N stable isotope tracing and kinetic tests reveal that the partial denitrification is capable of supplying increasingly abundant NO2- to anammox with decreasing temperature, enabling robust mainstream anammox against seasonal cooling. From 27.8 °C to 7.5 °C, anammox bacteria not only survive but thrive under mainstream conditions, with absolute and relative abundances increasing by 429.1% and 343.5%, respectively. This pilot-scale study sheds fresh light on extending mainstream anammox towards non-tropical regions, taking a necessary step forward toward the sustainability goals of the wastewater treatment sector.

Stable continuous flow CANDAN process transitioning from anammox UASB reactor by facilitating indigenous nitrite-producing denitrification community

The emerging nitrogen removal process known as CANDAN (Complete Ammonium and Nitrate removal via Denitratation-Anammox over Nitrite) has been developed in Sequencing Batch Reactors (SBRs). Yet, starting up and maintaining stability in continuous-flow reactors remain challenging. This study explores the feasibility of transitioning the CANDAN process from an anammox-dominated process by introducing appropriate external organics to facilitate indigenous nitrite-producing denitrification community in an Upflow Anaerobic Sludge Blanket (UASB) reactor. 150-day operation results indicate that under feeding rates of domestic wastewater at 0.54 L/h and nitrate-containing wastewater at 1.08 L/h, excellent N removal was achieved, with effluent TN below 10.0 mg N/L. Adding external sodium acetate at a COD/NO3--N = 2.0 triggered denitratation, ex-situ denitrification activity tests showed increased nitrite production rates, maintaining the nitrate-to-nitrite transformation ratio (NTR) above 90 %. Consequently, anammox activity was consistently maintained, dominating Total Nitrogen (TN) removal with a contribution as high as 78.3 ± 8.0 %. Anammox functional bacteria, Brocadia and Kuenenia were identified and showed no decrease throughout the operation, indicating the robustness of the anammox process. Notably, the troublesome of sludge flotation, did not occur, also contributing to sustained outstanding performance. In conclusion, this study advances our understanding of the synergistic interplay between anammox and denitrifying bacteria in the Anammox-UASB system, offering technical insights for establishing a stable continuous-flow CANDAN process for simultaneous ammonium and nitrate removal.

S0-driven partial denitrification coupled with anammox (S0PDA) enables highly efficient autotrophic nitrogen removal from wastewater

This study proposed a novel strategy that integrates S0 particles (diameter: 2-3 mm) and granular sludge to establish S0-driven partial denitrification coupled with anammox (S0PDA) process for autotrophic nitrogen removal from NH4+- and NO3--containing wastewaters. This process was evaluated using an up-flow anoxic sludge bed bioreactor, operating continuously for 240 days. The influent concentrations of NH4+ and NO3- were 29.9 ± 2.7 and 50.2 ± 2.7 mg-N/L, respectively. Throughout the operation, the hydraulic retention time was shortened from 4.0 h to 2.0 h, while the effluent concentrations of NH4+ and NO3- were maintained at a desirable level of 1.45-1.51 mg-N/L and 4.46-6.52 mg-N/L, respectively. Despite an autotrophic process, the nitrogen removal efficiency and rate reached up to 88.5 ± 2.0 % and 1.75 ± 0.07 kg-N/(m3·d), respectively, indicating the remarkable robustness of the S0PDA process. Autotrophic anammox and sulfur-oxidizing bacteria (Candidatus Brocadia and Thiobacillus) were the predominant bacterial genera involved in the S0PDA process. Candidatus Brocadia was primarily enriched in the granular sludge, with a relative abundance of 6.70 %. Thiobacillus occupied a unique niche on the S0 particles, with a relative abundance as high as 57.6 %, of which Thiobacillus thioparus with partial denitrification function (reducing NO3- to NO2- without further reduction to N2) accounted for 78.0 %. These findings challenge the stereotype of low efficiency in autotrophic nitrogen removal from wastewater, shedding fresh light on the applications of autotrophic processes.

Micro-aeration and low influent C/N are key environmental factors for achieving ANAMMOX in livestock farming wastewater treatment plants

Anaerobic ammonium oxidation (ANAMMOX)-mediated system is a cost-effective green nitrogen removal process. However, there are few examples of successful application of this advanced wastewater denitrification process in wastewater treatment plants, and the understanding of how to implement anaerobic ammonia oxidation process in full-scale is still limited. In this study, it was found that the abundance of anaerobic ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AnAOB) in the two livestock wastewater plants named J1 and J2, respectively, showed diametrically opposed trends of waxing and waning with time. The microbial communities of the activated sludge in the two plants at different time were sampled and analyzed by high-throughput sequencing of 16S rRNA genes. Structural equation models (SEMs) were used to reveal the key factors affecting the realization of the ANAMMOX. Changes in the concentration of dissolved oxygen and C/N had a significant effect on the relative abundance of anaerobic ammonia oxidation bacteria (AnAOB). The low concentration of DO (0.2∼0.5 mg/L) could inhibit the activity of nitrifying bacteria (NOB) to achieve partial oxidation of ammonia nitrogen and provide sufficient substrate for the growth of AnAOB, similar to the CANON (Completely Autotrophic Nitrogen removal Over Nitrite). Unlike CANON, heterotrophic denitrification is also a particularly critical part of the livestock wastewater treatment, and a suitable C/N of about 0.6 could reduce the competition risk of heterotrophic microorganisms to AnAOB and ensure a good ecological niche for AnAOB. Based on the results of 16S rRNA and microbial co-occurrence networks, it was discovered that microorganisms in the sludge not only had a richer network interaction, but also achieved a mutually beneficial symbiotic interaction network among denitrifying bacteria (Pseudomonas sp., Terrimonas sp., Dokdonella sp.), AnAOB (Candidatus Brocadia sp.) at DO of 0.2∼0.5 mg/L and C/N of 0.6. Among the top 20 in abundance of genus level, AnAOB had a high relative abundance of 27.66%, followed by denitrifying bacteria of 3.67%, AOB of 0.64% and NOB of 0.26%, which is an essential indicator for the emergence of an AnAOB-dominated nitrogen removal cycle. In conclusion, this study highlights the importance of dissolved oxygen and C/N regulation by analyzing the mechanism of ANAMMOX sludge extinction and growth in two plants under anthropogenic regulation of AnAOB in full-scale wastewater treatment systems.

The role of the combined nitrogen-sulfur-carbon cycles for efficient performance of anammox-based systems

The combined anammox/mixotrophic denitrification process was conducted in two granular sequencing batch reactors (SBRs) during a 200-day operation. Both reactors were fed with synthetic medium, but SBR2 was enriched with additional sulfate (SO42-) which influenced sulfate reduction ammonium oxidation (SRAO) and heterotrophic reduction of SO42- by sulfate reducing bacteria. It was hypothesized that the addition of SO42- could positively impact the removal rates of N-S-C compounds. A low C/N ratio (0.4-1.6) was maintained to prevent inhibition of anaerobic ammonium oxidizing bacteria (AnAOB), and alternating chemical oxygen demand (COD) on/off conditions were used to regenerate AnAOB during COD-off phases and heterotrophic denitrifiers during COD-on phases. Stoichiometric analysis showed that introducing SO42- in SBR2 enhanced the ammonium utilization rate, which was approximately 10 % higher compared to SBR1 in the final stage of the experiment (25.8 vs. 22.8 mg N/(g VSS·h)). The total nitrogen removal efficiencies ranged from 62 % to 99 % in both reactors, with SBR2 consistently exhibiting approximately 4 % higher efficiency than SBR1. In SBR2, the maximum overall SO42- utilization efficiency reached 27 % under COD-off conditions, while overall COD utilization was almost complete under COD-on conditions. A strong correlation (R2 = 0.98) was observed between SO42- production and COD utilization. The key players responsible for N and S transformations in response to SO42- addition were Candidatus Brocadia and Chloroflexi - Anaerolineae. This study highlights the potential to enhance the overall efficiency of N-S-C removal by implementing an integrated anammox/mixotrophic denitrification process. The combination of cycles emerges as a sustainable approach for treating wastewater rich in N-S-C compounds.

Mechanism of gel immobilization driving efficient anammox in mainstream partial nitritation/anammox process: Structural characterization and multi-perspective microbial analysis

Here, the mechanism of encapsulated anammox bacteria (AnAOB) driving efficient nitrogen removal in the mainstream partial nitritation/anammox process is revealed. The results show that a high nitrogen removal rate (1.21±0.02 kgN·(m3·d)-1) was achieved due to the abundant micropore structure inside the anammox immobilized filler, ensuring good connectivity, and a stable aggregation capacity, reducing dependence on extracellular polymeric substances. AnAOB were uniformly distributed throughout all regions of the immobilized filler, and their abundance was higher than that of the control anammox granular sludge (AnGS). Conversely, cracks appeared on the surface of the AnGS, and hollows formed inside. The metagenome analysis revealed that the immobilized filler supported the coexistence of multiple AnAOB, and the appropriate niche enhanced coordination between the AnAOB and dominant companion microorganisms. In contrast, AnGS exhibited stronger NH4+-N and NO2--N loops, potentially reducing the total nitrogen removal efficiency. This study promotes the mainstream application of anammox.

Ultra-stable mixotrophic denitrification coupled with anammox under organic stress for mainstream municipal wastewater treatment

Sulfur-based autotrophic denitrification (SAD) coupled with anammox is a promising process for autotrophic nitrogen removal in view of the stable nitrite accumulation during SAD. In this study, a mixotrophic nitrogen removal system integrating SAD, anammox and heterotrophic denitrification was established in a single-stage reactor. The long-term nitrogen removal performance was investigated under the intervention of organic carbon sources in real municipal wastewater. With the shortening of hydraulic retention time, the nitrogen removal rate of the mixotrophic system dominated by the autotrophic subsystem reached 0.46 Kg N/m³/d at an organic loading rate of 0.57 Kg COD/m³/d, with COD and total nitrogen removal efficiencies of 82.5 % and 94 %, respectively, realizing an ideal combination of autotrophic and heterotrophic systems. The 15NO3--N isotope labeling experiments indicated that thiosulfate-driven autotrophic denitrification was the main pathway for nitrite supply accounting for 80.6 %, while anammox exhibited strong competitiveness for nitrite under the dual electron supply of sulfur and organic carbon sources and contributed to 65.1 % of nitrogen removal. Sludge granulation created differential functional distributions in different forms of sludge, with SAD showing faster reaction rate as well as higher nitrite accumulation rate in floc sludge, while anammox was more active in granular sludge. Real-time quantitative PCR, RT-PCR and high-throughput sequencing results revealed a dynamically changing community composition at the gene and transcription levels. The decrease in heterotrophic denitrification bacteria abundance indicated the effectiveness of the operational strategy for introduction of thiosulfate and maintaining the dominance of SAD in denitrification process in suppressing the excessive growth of heterotrophic bacteria in the mixotrophic system. The high transcriptional expression of sulfur-oxidizing bacteria (SOB) (Thiobacillus and Sulfurimonas) and anammox bacteria (Candaditus_Brocadia and Candidatus_Kuenenia) played a crucial role in the stable nitrogen removal.

Advanced nitrogen removal from municipal wastewater through partial nitrification-denitrification coupled with anammox in step-feed continuous system

Combined partial nitrification-denitrification/anammox (PN-PD/A) processes have attracted great attention from researchers in recent years to achieve high nitrogen removal from low carbon /nitrogen (C/N) municipal wastewater. In this context, a step-feed anoxic/oxic (A/O) process was conducted in this study through the combination of the partial nitrification-anammox (PN/A) and partial denitrification-anammox (PD/A) to remove N from municipal wastewater with low C/N. The enhancement of the PN-PD/A process resulted in N removal efficiency of 85.6% at C/N of 2.8. The contributions of the anammox reached 36.4 and 8.8% in the anoxic and oxic chambers, respectively. The biocarriers added to the anoxic and oxic chambers increased the relative abundance of the anammox bacteria in biofilms from 0.61% to 1.51% and 1.02%, respectively. This study demonstrated that employing the step-feed A/O process can create optimal conditions for the anammox bacteria growth, thereby ensuring advanced N removal from low C/N municipal wastewater.

How to Provide Nitrite Robustly for Anaerobic Ammonium Oxidation in Mainstream Nitrogen Removal

Innovation in decarbonizing wastewater treatment is urgent in response to global climate change. The practical implementation of anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) treating domestic wastewater is the key to reconciling carbon-neutral management of wastewater treatment with sustainable development. Nitrite availability is the prerequisite of the anammox reaction, but how to achieve robust nitrite supply and accumulation for mainstream systems remains elusive. This work presents a state-of-the-art review on the recent advances in nitrite supply for mainstream anammox, paying special attention to available pathways (forward-going (from ammonium to nitrite) and backward-going (from nitrate to nitrite)), key controlling strategies, and physiological and ecological characteristics of functional microorganisms involved in nitrite supply. First, we comprehensively assessed the mainstream nitrite-oxidizing bacteria control methods, outlining that these technologies are transitioning to technologies possessing multiple selective pressures (such as intermittent aeration and membrane-aerated biological reactor), integrating side stream treatment (such as free ammonia/free nitrous acid suppression in recirculated sludge treatment), and maintaining high activity of ammonia-oxidizing bacteria and anammox bacteria for competing oxygen and nitrite with nitrite-oxidizing bacteria. We then highlight emerging strategies of nitrite supply, including the nitrite production driven by novel ammonia-oxidizing microbes (ammonia-oxidizing archaea and complete ammonia oxidation bacteria) and nitrate reduction pathways (partial denitrification and nitrate-dependent anaerobic methane oxidation). The resources requirement of different mainstream nitrite supply pathways is analyzed, and a hybrid nitrite supply pathway by combining partial nitrification and nitrate reduction is encouraged. Moreover, data-driven modeling of a mainstream nitrite supply process as well as proactive microbiome management is proposed in the hope of achieving mainstream nitrite supply in practical application. Finally, the existing challenges and further perspectives are highlighted, i.e., investigation of nitrite-supplying bacteria, the scaling-up of hybrid nitrite supply technologies from laboratory to practical implementation under real conditions, and the data-driven management for the stable performance of mainstream nitrite supply. The fundamental insights in this review aim to inspire and advance our understanding about how to provide nitrite robustly for mainstream anammox and shed light on important obstacles warranting further settlement.

Carbon-Restricted Anoxic Zone as an Overlooked Anammox Hotspot in Municipal Wastewater Treatment Plants

The anoxic zone serves as the core functional unit in municipal wastewater treatment plants (MWWTPs). Unfortunately, in most cases, the downstream range of the anoxic zone is severely lacking in available organic carbon and thus contributes little to the removal of nutrients. This undesirable range is termed the "carbon-restricted anoxic zone", representing an insurmountable drawback for traditional MWWTPs. This study uncovers a previously overlooked role for the carbon-restricted anoxic zone: a hotspot for anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox). In a continuous-flow pilot-scale plant treating municipal wastewater (55 m3/d), virgin biocarriers were introduced into the carbon-restricted anoxic zone (downstream 25% of the anoxic zone with BOD5 of 5.9 ± 2.3 mg/L). During the 517-day monitoring, anammox bacteria highly self-enriched within the biofilms, with absolute and relative abundance reaching up to (9.4 ± 0.1) × 109 copies/g-VSS and 6.17% (Candidatus Brocadia), respectively. 15N isotopic tracing confirmed that anammox overwhelmingly dominated nitrogen metabolism, responsible for 92.5% of nitrogen removal. Following this upgrade, the contribution ratio of the carbon-restricted anoxic zone to total nitrogen removal increased from 9.2 ± 4.1% to 19.2 ± 4.2% (P < 0.001), while its N2O emission flux decreased by 84.5% (P < 0.001). These findings challenge stereotypes about the carbon-restricted anoxic zone and highlight the multiple environmental implications of this newfound anammox hotspot.

Efficient nitrogen removal from municipal wastewater by an autotrophic-heterotrophic coupled anammox system: The up-regulation of key functional genes

The metabolic pathways based on key functional genes were innovatively revealed in the autotrophic-heterotrophic coupled anammox system for real municipal wastewater treatment. The nitrogen removal performance of the system was stabilized at 88.40 ± 3.39 % during the treatment of real municipal wastewater. The relative abundances of the nitrification functional genes ammonia oxidase (amoA/B/C), hydroxylamine oxidoreductase (hao), and nitrite oxidoreductases (nxrA/B) were increased by 1.2-2.4 times, and these three nitrification functional genes were mostly contributed by Nitrospira that dominated the efficient nitrification of the system. The relative abundance of anammox bacteria Candidatus Brocadia augmented from 0.35 % to 0.75 %, accompanied with the increased expression of hydrazine synthase (hzs) and hydrazine dehydrogenase (hdh), resulting in the major role of anammox (81.24 %) for nitrogen removal. The expression enhancement of the functional genes nitrite reductase (narG/H, napA/B) that promoted partial denitrification (PD) of the system weakened the adverse effects of the sharp decline in the population of PD microbe Thauera (from 5.7 % to 2.2 %). The metabolic module analysis indicated that the carbon metabolism pathways of the system mainly included CO2 fixation and organic carbon metabolism, and the stable enrichment of autotrophic bacteria ensured stable CO2 fixation. Furthermore, the enhanced expression of the glucokinases (glk, GCK, HK, ppgk) and the abundant pyruvate kinase (PK) achieved stable hydrolysis ability of organic carbon metabolism function of the system. This study offers research basics to practical application of the mainstream anammox process.

Metagenomics insights into high-rate nitrogen removal from municipal wastewater by integrated nitrification, partial denitrification and Anammox at an extremely short hydraulic retention time

To achieve high-rate nitrogen removal in municipal wastewater treatment through anaerobic ammonia oxidation (Anammox), the nitrification, partial denitrification, and Anammox processes were integrated by a step-feed strategy. An exceptional nitrogen removal load of 0.224 kg N/(m3·d) was achieved by gradient-reducing the hydraulic retention time (HRT) to 5 h. Metagenomic analysis demonstrated that Nitrosospira could express all genes encoding ammonia oxidation under low nitrogen and dissolved oxygen conditions (less than 0.5 mg/L), enabling complete nitrification. With the short of HRT, the relative abundance of Thauera increased from 2.8 % to 6.4 %. Frequent substrate exchanges at such extremely short HRT facilitated enhanced synergistic interactions among Nitrosospira, Thauera, and Candidatus Brocadia. These findings provide a comprehensive understanding of the utilization of Anammox combined processes for high-speed nitrogen removal in municipal wastewater treatment and the microbial interactions involved.

Chlorine-mediated electrochemical advanced oxidation process for ammonia removal: Mechanisms, characteristics and expectation

Chlorine-Mediated Electrochemical Advanced Oxidation (Cl-EAO) technology is a promising approach for ammonia removal from wastewater due to its numerous advantages, including small infrastructure, short processing time, easy operation, high security, and high nitrogen selectivity. This paper provides a review of the ammonia oxidation mechanisms, characteristics, and anticipated applications of Cl-EAO technology. The mechanisms of ammonia oxidation encompass breakpoint chlorination and chlorine radical oxidation, although the contributions of active chlorine, Cl, and ClO remain uncertain. This study critically examines the limitations of existing research and suggests that a combination of determining free radical concentration and simulating a kinetic model would help elucidate the contributions of active chlorine, Cl, and ClO to ammonia oxidation. Furthermore, this review comprehensively summarizes the characteristics of ammonia oxidation, including kinetic properties, influencing factors, products, and electrodes. The amalgamation of Cl-EAO technology with photocatalytic and concentration technologies has the potential to enhance ammonia oxidation efficiency. Future research should concentrate on clarifying the contributions of active chlorine, Cl, and ClO to ammonia oxidation, the production of chloramines and other byproducts, and the development of more efficient anodes for the Cl-EAO process. The main objective of this review is to enhance the understanding of the Cl-EAO process. The findings presented herein contribute to the advancement of Cl-EAO technology and provide a foundation for future studies in this field.

Nitrogen removal performance of aerobic denitrifying bacteria enhanced by an iron-anode pulsed electric field

Pulsed electric field (PEF) technology has attracted considerable attention because it can efficiently treat pollutants that are difficult to degrade. In this study, a PEF system using iron as the electrode was constructed to investigate the effect of PEF-Fe on the growth and metabolism of aerobic denitrifying bacteria and the effectiveness of wastewater nitrogen removal. The chemical oxygen demand, NO3--N and nitrate removal rates were 98.93%, 97.60% and 24.40 mg·L-1·h-1, respectively, under optimal conditions. As confirmed in this study, PEF-Fe could improve the key enzyme activities of W207-14. Scanning electron microscopy revealed that the surface of PEF-Fe-treated W207-14 was intact and smooth without any irreversible deformation. Flow cytometry combined with fluorescence staining analysis also confirmed reversible electroporation on the cell membrane surface of PEF-Fe-treated W207-14. Differentially expressed gene enrichment analysis showed that PEF-Fe activated the transmembrane transport function of ATP-binding cassette transporte (ABC) transport proteins and enhanced the cell membrane permeability of aerobic denitrifying bacteria. The significant differential expression of iron-sulphur cluster proteins facilitated the regulation of electron transport and maintenance of the dynamic balance of iron ions within the PEF-Fe system.

Advanced nitrogen removal from low carbon nitrogen ratio domestic sewage via continuous plug-flow anaerobic/oxic/anoxic system: Enhanced by endogenous denitrification

An anaerobic/oxic/anoxic continuous plug-flow biorereactor was established to derive stable advanced nitrogen removal of oligotrophic domestic wastewater by setting a sludge dual-reflux system and a mixed liquid cross-flow system, while extending the hydraulic retention time in anoxic section. The effluent total inorganic nitrogen was 7.9 ± 2.2 mg N/L, with removal efficiency of 84 ± 3.9%. Results of nitrogen balance calculations indicated that the contribution of simultaneous nitrification and denitrification to total inorganic nitrogen loss in oxic region was 15% during stable stage, and the total inorganic nitrogen removal by endogenous-denitrification and enhanced exogenous-denitrification in the anoxic region was 39.9%. Prolongation of hydraulic retention time in anoxic segment is the critical reason for enhancing endogenous-denitrification, and cross-flow system is an important measure to improve exogenous-denitrification. This study provides new insights into bridging the gap between energy-saving and high-level nitrogen removal from municipal wastewater with low carbon to nitrogen ratios.

From hybrid process to pure biofilm anammox process: Suspended sludge biomass management contributing to high-level anammox enrichment in biofilms

The application of mainstream anammox is highly desirable for municipal wastewater treatment. However, enrichment of anammox bacteria (AnAOB) is challenging, particularly given the vicious competition from denitrifying bacteria (DB). Here, suspended sludge biomass management, a novel operational strategy for hybrid process (suspended sludge/biofilm), was investigated for 570 days based on a modified anaerobic-anoxic-oxic system treating municipal wastewater. By successively decreasing the suspended sludge concentration, the traditional hybrid process was successfully upgraded to a pure biofilm anammox process. During this process, both the nitrogen removal efficiency (NRE) and rate (NRR) were significantly improved (P < 0.001), from 62.1 ± 4.5% to 79.2 ± 3.9% and from 48.7 ± 9.7 to 62.3 ± 9.0 g N/(m³·d), respectively. Mainstream anammox was improved in the following: Candidatus Brocadia was enriched from 0.70% to 5.99% in anoxic biofilms [from (9.94 ± 0.99) × 10⁸ to (1.16 ± 0.01) × 10¹⁰ copies/g VSS, P < 0.001]; the in situ anammox reaction rate increased from 8.8 ± 1.9 to 45.5 ± 3.2 g N/(m³·d) (P < 0.001); the anammox contribution to nitrogen removal rose from 9.2 ± 2.8% to 67.1 ± 8.3% (P < 0.001). Core bacterial microbiome analysis, functional gene quantification, and a series of ex situ batch experiments demonstrated that the stepwise decreases in suspended sludge concentration effectively mitigated the vicious competition of DB against AnAOB, enabling high-level AnAOB enrichment. This study presents a straightforward and effective strategy for enriching AnAOB in municipal wastewater, shedding fresh light on the application and upgradation of mainstream anammox.

Robustness and stability of acetate-driven partial denitrification (PD) in response to high COD/NO3--N

Partial Denitrification (PD) producing nitrite for anammox may face the issue of relatively high chemical oxygen demand (COD) loading (i.e., COD/NO₃^--N) due to real wastewater being changed in substrate concentration and flowrate. In this study, three PD systems (R1, R2, R3) with sodium acetate providing electrons were developed to investigate the influence of the relatively high COD/NO₃^--N ratios (4.0, 6.0, and 8.0) on NO₂^--N production and the subsequent recoverability. It was found that a relatively high NO₂^--N production with nitrate-to-nitrite transformation ratio (NTR) of 74.0% could be still obtained despite COD/NO₃^--N even improving to 8.0 under limited reaction time (10 min) with small nitrate remaining. However, a deteriorated nitrite production was observed with sufficient reaction time (15 min) with NTR being lowered to 19.2%. Delightedly, when reducing influent COD/NO₃^--N to a normal level of 3.0, PD with high nitrite production was rapidly achieved after suffering from a relatively high COD/NO₃^--N (4.0-8.0) for 130 cycles. Besides, it was found the relatively high COD/NO₃^--N had a minor influence on the recoverability of PD, as evidenced by the close NTRs. Microbial analysis revealed the relative abundance of PD functional bacteria, Thauera, decreased under high COD/NO₃^--N, while it is still highly dominated in the systems, varying from 75.1% in R1 to 62.8% in R3 after around 110-cycles recovery. Furthermore, it appeared that the high pH (9.1-9.2) induced by sodium acetate also likely played a role in maintaining the excellent PD. Overall, this study demonstrated the robustness and stability of acetate-driven PD in response to high COD/NO₃^--N, further informing the technological superiority of PD in supplying stable and efficient nitrite, which provided solid technical support to apply it with anammox for high-efficient N removal.

In a quest for high-efficiency mainstream partial nitritation-anammox (PN/A) implementation: One-stage or two-stage?

Partial nitritation-anammox (PN/A) process is known as an energy-efficient technology for wastewater nitrogen removal, which possesses a great potential to bring wastewater treatment plants close to energy neutrality with reduced carbon footprint. To achieve this goal, various PN/A processes implemented in a single reactor configuration (one-stage system) or two separately dedicated reactors configurations (two-stage system) were explored over the past decades. Nevertheless, large-scale implementation of these PN/A processes for low-strength municipal wastewater treatment has a long way to go owing to the low efficiency and effectiveness in nitrogen removal. In this work, we provided a comprehensive analysis of one-stage and two-stage PN/A processes with a focus on evaluating their engineering application potential towards mainstream implementation. The difficulty for nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB) out-selection was revealed as the critical operational challenge to achieve the desired effluent quality. Additionally, the operational strategies of low oxygen commonly adopted in one-stage systems for NOB suppression and facilitating anammox bacteria growth results in a low nitrogen removal rate (NRR). Introducing denitrification into anammox system was found to be necessary to improve the nitrogen removal efficiency (NRE) by reducing the produced nitrate with in-situ utilizing the organics from wastewater itself. However, this may lead to part of organics oxidized with additional oxygen consumed in one-stage system, further compromising the NRR. By applying a relatively high dissolved oxygen in PN reactor with residual ammonium control, and followed by a granules-based anammox reactor feeding with a small portion of raw municipal wastewater, it appeared that two-stage system could achieve a good effluent quality as well as a high NRR. In contrast to the widely studied one-stage system, this work provided a unique perspective that more effort should be devoted to developing a two-stage PN/A process to evaluate its application potential of high efficiency and economic benefits towards mainstream implementation.

Double-edged sword effects of dissimilatory nitrate reduction to ammonium (DNRA) bacteria on anammox bacteria performance in an MBR reactor

Dissimilatory nitrate reduction to ammonium (DNRA) bacteria imposing double-edged sword effects on anammox bacteria were investigated in an anammox-membrane bioreactor (MBR) experiencing an induced crash-recovery event. During the experiment, the anammox-MBR was loaded with NH₄⁺-N:NO₂^--N ratios (RatioNH₄⁺-N: NO₂^--N) of 1.20-1.60. Initially, the anammox-MBR removed over 95% of 100 mg/L NH₄⁺-N and 132 mg/L NO₂^--N (RatioNH₄⁺-N: NO₂^--N = 0.76, the well accepted stoichiometric RatioNH₄⁺-N: NO₂^--N for anammox) in the influent (Stage 0). Then, we induced a system crash-recovery event via nitrite shock loadings to better understand responses from different guilds of bacteria in anammox-MBR, loaded with 1.60 RatioNH₄⁺-N: NO₂^--N with 100 mg/L NO₂^--N in the influent (Stage 1). Interestingly, the nitrogen removal by anammox bacteria was maintained for about 20 days before starting to decrease significantly. In Stage 2, we further increased influent nitrite concentration to 120 mg/L (1.33 RatioNH₄⁺-N: NO₂^--N) to simulate a high nitrite toxicity scenario for a short period of time. As expected, nitrogen removal efficiency dropped to only 16.8%. After the induced system crash, anammox-MBR performance recovered steadily to 93.2% nitrogen removal with a 1.25 RatioNH₄⁺-N:NO₂^--N and a low nitrite influent concentration of 80 mg/L NO₂^--N. Metagenomics analysis revealed that a probable causality of the decreasing nitrogen removal efficiency in Stage 1 was the overgrowth of DNRA-capable bacteria. The results showed that the members within the Ignavibacteriales order (21.7%) out competed anammox bacteria (17.0%) in the anammox-MBR with elevated nitrite concentrations in the effluent. High NO₂^--N loading (120 mg N/L) further caused the predominant Candidatus Kuenenia spp. were replaced by Candidatus Brocadia spp. Therefore, it was evident that DNRA bacteria posed negative effects on anammox with 1.60 RatioNH₄⁺-N: NO₂^--N. Also, when 120 mg/L NO₂^--N fed to anammox-MBR (RatioNH₄⁺-N: NO₂^--N = 1.33), canonical denitrification became the primary nitrogen sink with both DNRA and anammox activities decreased. They probably fed on lysed microbial cells of anammox and DNRA. In Stage 3, a low RatioNH₄⁺-N: NO₂^--N (1.25) with 80 mg/L NO₂^--N was used to rescue the system, which effectively promoted DNRA-capable bacteria growth. Although anammox bacteria's abundance was only 7.7% during this stage, they could be responsible for about 90% of the total nitrogen removal during this stage.

Potential causes of partial-denitrification (PD) granular sludge breakdown under high nitrate loading rates

The granule instability has been frequently reported during the operation of high loading rates. While, there no research was performed on the recently developed anoxic partial-denitrification (PD) granules, a novel pathway in producing nitrite from nitrate for anammox process. Herein, this work, for the first time, investigated the influence of nitrate loading rates on the instability of PD granules and identified the key causes. Two lab-scale sequencing batch reactors (SBRs) were operated with nitrate loading rates (NLR) increased from 0.48 to 3.84 kg N/m³/d (R1, 8 cycles/d), and 0.96 to 7.68 kg N/m³/d (R2, 16 cycles/d) by gradually elevating the influent nitrate concentration. Results showed that nitrite production rates increased with the NLRs, with a maximal value of 5.26 kg N/m³/d obtained. However, the compact regular PD granules were not stable and broke down when NLR was above 3.84 kg N/m³/d, which resulted in serious sludge washing out from SBR. The high NLRs led to the extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) transformation in terms of its composition and structure, which the protein content in the EPS and the tightly bound EPS (T-EPS) fraction was significantly decreased, this was supposed to be the major reason causing the breakdown of PD granules. Besides, it was found the PD granule in R2 was more deteriorated than that in R1 under the same high NLR, suggesting the short starvation (idle) times in SBR cycle was likely another reason impairing the stability of PD granules. Overall, this research provides useful information in development of granule-based PD systems and sheds light on achieving high-rate nitrite production in SBR with great stability.

Heterotrophic anodic denitrification coupled with cathodic metals recovery from on-site smelting wastewater with a bioelectrochemical system inoculated with mixed Castellaniella species

Although Castellaniella species are crucial for denitrification, there is no report on their capacity to carry out denitrification and anode respiration simultaneously in a bioelectrochemical system (BES). Herein, the ability of a mixed inoculum of electricigenic Castellaniella species to perform simultaneous denitrification and anode respiration coupled with cathodic metals recovery was investigated in a BES. Results showed that 500 mg/L NO₃^--N significantly decreased power generation, whereas 100 and 250 mg/L NO₃^--N had a lesser impact. The single-chamber MFCs (SCMFCs) fed with 100 and 250 mg/L NO₃^--N concentrations achieved a removal efficiency higher than 90% in all cycles. In contrast, the removal efficiency in the SCMFCs declined dramatically at 500 mg/L NO₃^--N, which might be attributable to decreased microbial viability as revealed by SEM and CLSM. EPS protein content and enzymatic activities of the biofilms decreased significantly at this concentration. Cyclic voltammetry results revealed that the 500 mg/L NO₃^--N concentration decreased the redox activities of anodic biofilms, while electrochemical impedance spectroscopy showed that the internal resistance of the SCMFCs at this concentration increased significantly. In addition, BES inoculated with the Castellaniella species was able to simultaneously perform heterotrophic anodic denitrification and cathodic metals recovery from real wastewater. The BES attained Cu²⁺, Hg²⁺, Pb²⁺, and Zn²⁺ removal efficiencies of 99.86 ± 0.10%, 99.98 ± 0.014%, 99.98 ± 0.01%, and 99.17 ± 0.30%, respectively, from the real wastewater. Cu²⁺ was bio-electrochemically reduced to Cu⁰ and Cu₂O, whereas Hg⁰ and HgO constituted the Hg species recovered via bioelectrochemical reduction and chemical deposition, respectively. Furthermore, Pb²⁺ and Zn²⁺ were bio-electrochemically reduced to Pb⁰ and Zn⁰, respectively. Over 89% of NO₃^--N was removed from the BES anolyte during the recovery of the metals. This research reveals promising denitrifying exoelectrogens for enhanced power generation, NO₃^--N removal, and heavy metals recovery in BES.

Recent Research on Municipal Sludge as Soil Fertilizer in China: a Review

Due to the annual increase in wastewater treatment in most Chinese cities, a major environmental issue has arisen: safe treatment, disposal, and recycling of municipal sludge. Municipal sludge has a high content of carbon and essential nutrients for plant growth; hence, it has gained interest among researchers as a soil fertilizer. This study discusses the potential usage of municipal sludge as soil fertilizer (indicators include nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P), and trace elements) along with its shortcomings and drawbacks (potentially toxic elements (PTEs), organic matter (OM), pathogens, etc.) as well as reviews the latest reports on the role of municipal sludge in land use. The use of municipal sludge as a soil fertilizer is a sustainable management practice and a single application of sludge does not harm the environment. However, repeated use of sludge may result in the accumulation of harmful chemicals and pathogens that can enter the food chain and endanger human health. Therefore, long-term field studies are needed to develop ways to eliminate these adverse effects and make municipal sludge available for agricultural use.

Extending reaction duration has minor influence on nitrite production in partial-denitrification process

Partial denitrification (PD) is another important pathway producing nitrite for anammox, however, whether its performance is affected by overlong reaction time, a situation that often takes place is still unknown. Three sequencing batch reactors were operated for PD to evaluate this factor on nitrite production. Results indicated effluent nitrite was very close despite reaction time even extending to four times longer than control (i.e., nitrate-to-nitrite transformation ratio (NTR) of 94.4%-89.8%). Meanwhile, it was found PD could recover to the normal after suffering from high organics shocking. Cycle studies suggested produced nitrite would not be further reduced with prolonged time, as indicated by changing trend of pH and alkalinity. Microbial analysis revealed PD functional bacteria, Thauera, slightly decreased with prolonged reaction, while it was always predominated. Taken together, this study indicated overlong reaction time had minor influence on PD, demonstrating its robustness with great technological superiority in supplying nitrite for anammox.

Mechanism of suspended sludge impact on anammox enrichment in anoxic biofilm through long term operation and microbial analysis

The basic premise of anammox-technical application reliability in municipal wastewater treatment is substantially enriched anammox bacteria. To enrich the anammox, the special interaction mechanism between the suspended sludge (SS) and anoxic biofilm was investigated over three months in a partial denitrification/anammox biosystem subjected to dynamic changes in SS (absence→ presence→ absence). Results show that the introduction of SS significantly decreased the anammox nitrogen removal efficiency (83.8 ± 6.5%→ 48.7 ± 17.0%). With the presence or absence of SS, the spatial distribution of anammox bacteria within the anoxic biofilm gradually changed between the inner and outer layers, as detected by CLSM-FISH. qPCR and metagenomic sequencing show that changes in the presence and absence status of SS significantly reduced the abundance of the NO reducing functional gene, while the NO supply capacity (NO₃^-→NO) was improved, further favoring the anammox process. Batch tests and typical cycles further demonstrated that the anammox bacteria can stably acquire NO₂^-, and anammox bacteria in the anoxic biofilm competed far more NO₂^- than denitrifying bacteria according to the typical pH curve. Accordingly, the abundance of Candidatus Brocadia, as detected by high throughput sequencing, decreased in the anoxic biofilms with the introduction of SS, but greatly increased (0.82%→2.22%) after SS discharge. This study sheds new light on the high in-situ enrichment of anammox in mainstream.

A critical review on microbial ecology in the novel biological nitrogen removal process: Dynamic balance of complex functional microbes for nitrogen removal

The novel biological nitrogen removal process has been extensively studied for its high nitrogen removal efficiency, energy efficiency, and greenness. A successful novel biological nitrogen removal process has a stable microecological equilibrium and benign interactions between the various functional bacteria. However, changes in the external environment can easily disrupt the dynamic balance of the microecology and affect the activity of functional bacteria in the novel biological nitrogen removal process. Therefore, this review focuses on the microecology in existing the novel biological nitrogen removal process, including the growth characteristics of functional microorganisms and their interactions, together with the effects of different influencing factors on the evolution of microbial communities. This provides ideas for achieving a stable dynamic balance of the microecology in a novel biological nitrogen removal process. Furthermore, to investigate deeply the mechanisms of microbial interactions in novel biological nitrogen removal process, this review also focuses on the influence of quorum sensing (QS) systems on nitrogen removal microbes, regulated by which bacteria secrete acyl homoserine lactones (AHLs) as signaling molecules to regulate microbial ecology in the novel biological nitrogen removal process. However, the mechanisms of action of AHLs on the regulation of functional bacteria have not been fully determined and the composition of QS system circuits requires further investigation. Meanwhile, it is necessary to further apply molecular analysis techniques and the theory of systems ecology in the future to enhance the exploration of microbial species and ecological niches, providing a deeper scientific basis for the development of a novel biological nitrogen removal process.

Sustainable Removal of Ammonia from the Anaerobic Digester Supernatant Line Using a Prussian Blue Analogue (PBA) Composite Adsorbent

This paper reports on the physico-chemical removal of NH4+ from the supernatant line in municipal wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs), using zinc-hexa-cyano-ferrate (ZnHCF) beads. The work is divided into three parts: First, the characteristics of three (Zn-, Co-, Ni-) types of HCF beads were determined, with a finding that ZnHCF was the most suitable for the purpose of this work. Second, synthetic and actual supernatant wastewater was passed through a ZnHCF column for many cycles until apparent steady-state results were attained. Due to the very high affinity of the beads toward NH4+ and the much lower affinity toward competing cations, the same regeneration solution could be used for many cycles (20 cycles in this work) without affecting the following adsorption breakthrough curve efficiency and the operational capacity, which was >88% at the end of all adsorption steps. Finally, a cost analysis was performed, revealing that the cost of removing ~500 mg/L of ammonia from the supernatant line is ~$0.02 per m3 of raw wastewater flowing into the plant if the ammonia is recaptured and sold as NH4Cl. This may be cost-effective when the WWTP receives a higher-than-planned load, and an incentive exists for alleviating the ammonia load on the oxidation reactor.

Revealing the effect of biofilm formation in partial nitritation-anammox systems: Start-up, performance stability, and recovery

Successful application of partial nitritation-anammox (PNA) processes is currently and primarily associated with biofilm systems. Biofilm characteristics significantly influence start-up, performance stability, and recovery. Here, two PNA systems with and without carriers were implemented simultaneously for treating wastewater containing 50 mg-NH₄/L. The performance characteristics of these two PNA systems were compared. Stable nitrogen removal efficiencies of 76.3 ± 2.8% and 72.9 ± 1.6% were obtained for suspended sludge and biofilm systems, respectively. The slow process of biofilm colonization resulted in a long start-up time in the biofilm system. Biofilm enrichment and protection conferred stable performance when exposed to aeration shock. The suspended sludge system displayed good elasticity during performance recovery after shock compared to the slow recovery in the biofilm system. Moreover, suitable control of dissolved oxygen could improve the activity and abundance of the functional microbes. This study provides new insights into the operation and control of PNA systems for treating mainstream wastewater.

Integrated thermal hydrolysis pretreated anaerobic digestion centrate and municipal wastewater treatment via partial nitritation/anammox process: A promising approach to alleviate inhibitory effects and enhance nitrogen removal

Two-stage Partial nitritation/Anammox (PN/A) was firstly performed for recalcitrant organics (RO)-rich thermal hydrolysis pretreated anaerobic digestion (THP-AD) centrate treatment with municipal wastewater (MW) as co-substrate. Results indicated the inhibitory effects of RO was alleviated and high nitrate issue in PN/A effluent was addressed by cotreatment strategy. Stable PN with nitrite accumulation ratio of 95% and N removal efficiency of 97.1% were well maintained at MW of 80%. Nevertheless, nitrate accumulation and anammox activity loss were observed with lowering MW proportion owing to the weakened denitrification activity and aggravated inhibitory effect. Microbial analysis revealed Nitrosomonas was the major ammonium oxidizing bacteria and the ideal PN performance was due to the effective out-selection of nitrite oxidizing bacteria. Candidatus Kuenenia was identified as the primary bacteria for nitrogen removal (82.7%), and the controlled abundance of heterotrophic denitrifiers in anammox system ensured the enhanced nitrogen removal regardless of high COD loading from THP-AD centrate.

Beyond an Applicable Rate in Low-Strength Wastewater Treatment by Anammox: Motivated Labor at an Extremely Short Hydraulic Retention Time

The application of anammox technology in low-strength wastewater treatment is still challenging due to unstable nitrite (NO₂^--N) generation. Partial denitrification (PD) of nitrate (NO₃^--N) reduction ending with NO₂^--N provides a promising solution. However, little is known about the feasibility of accelerating nitrogen removal toward the practical application of anammox combined with heterotrophic denitrification. In this work, an ultrafast, highly stable, and impressive nitrogen removal performance was demonstrated in the PD coupling with an anammox (PD/A) system. With a low-strength influent [50 mg/L each of ammonia (NH₄⁺-N) and NO₃^--N] at a low chemical oxygen demand/NO₃^--N ratio of 2.2, the hydraulic retention time could be shortened from 16.0 to 1.0 h. Remarkable nitrogen removal rates of 1.28 kg N/(m³ d) and excellent total nitrogen removal efficiency of 94.1% were achieved, far exceeding the applicable capacity for mainstream treatment. Stimulated enzymatic reaction activity of anammox was obtained due to the fast NO₂^--N jump followed by a famine condition with limited organic carbon utilization. This high-rate PD/A system exhibited efficient renewal of bacteria with a short sludge retention time. The 16S rRNA sequencing unraveled the rapid growth of the genus Thauera, possibly responsible for the incomplete reduction of NO₃^--N to NO₂^--N and a decreasing abundance of anammox bacteria. This provides new insights into the practical application of the PD/A process in the energy-efficient treatment of low-strength wastewater with less land occupancy and desirable effluent quality.

Recent Advances in Autotrophic Biological Nitrogen Removal for Low Carbon Wastewater: A Review

Due to carbon source dependence, conventional biological nitrogen removal (BNR) processes based on heterotrophic denitrification are suffering from great bottlenecks. The autotrophic BNR process represented by sulfur-driven autotrophic denitrification (SDAD) and anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) provides a viable alternative for addressing low carbon wastewater. Whether for low carbon municipal wastewater or industrial wastewater with high nitrogen, the SDAD and anammox process can be suitably positioned accordingly. Herein, the recent advances and challenges to autotrophic BNR process guided by SDAD and anammox are systematically reviewed. Specifically, the present applications and crucial operation factors were discussed in detail. Besides, the microscopic interpretation of the process was deepened in the viewpoint of functional microbial species and their physiological characteristics. Furthermore, the current limitations and some future research priorities over the applications were identified and discussed from multiple perspectives. The obtained knowledge would provide insights into the application and optimization of the autotrophic BNR process, which will contribute to the establishment of a new generation of efficient and energy-saving wastewater nitrogen removal systems.