Fate of intracellular, extracellular polymeric substances-associated, and cell-free antibiotic resistance genes in anaerobic digestion of thermally hydrolyzed sludge

Overlooked role of extracellular polymeric substances in antibiotic-resistance gene transfer within microalgae-bacteria system

Controlling the spread of antibiotic-resistance genes (ARGs) under antibiotic stress has become an increasingly urgent issue. Microalgae possess the capability to remove antibiotics while concurrently inhibiting ARGs. Microalgae-bacteria systems can produce significant quantities of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS). However, the roles of EPS in the spread of ARGs have not been sufficiently explored, resulting in an insufficient understanding of the contribution of each EPS component and a lack of analysis on the complex interactions between EPS and ARGs. This study systematically explored the overlooked role of EPS in the transmission of ARGs within microalgae-bacteria systems. The current results showed that the potential of the microalgae-bacteria system for treating antibiotic wastewater. The tightly bound-EPS (TB-EPS) can acquire the higher absolute abundances of ARGs compared with the loosely bound-EPS (LB-EPS). The correlation coefficient between polysaccharides and TB-EPS ARGs was higher than that between polysaccharides and LB-EPS ARGs. The gene patterns of LB-EPS closely clustered with those of TB-EPS, while intracellular ARG gene patterns differed from both TB-EPS and LB-EPS. Metagenomic analyses indicated that the relative abundances of sul1 and sul2 were considerably higher at the beginning stage compared to the end stage. The abundance of Achromobacter, increased by the end stage, aligning with its potential to produce exopolysaccharide. Additionally, the absolute abundance of genes encoding exopolysaccharides (nagB and galE) and conjugative transfer transcription regulator (traF), increased over time. These findings enhanced our comprehension of the significance of EPS on the fate of ARGs in microalgae-bacteria systems during the treatment of antibiotic-contaminated wastewater.

Antibiotic resistance genes in anaerobic digestion: Unresolved challenges and potential solutions

Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) threatens public health, necessitating urgent efforts to mitigate the global impact of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs). Anaerobic digestion (AD), known for volatile solid reduction and energy generation, also presents a feasible approach for the removal of ARGs. This review encapsulates the existing understanding of ARGs and antibiotic-resistant bacteria (ARB) during the AD process, highlighting unresolved challenges pertaining to their detection and quantification. The questions raised and discussed include: Do current ARGs detection methods meet qualitative and quantitative requirements? How can we conduct risk assessments of ARGs? What happens to ARGs when they come into co-exposure with other emerging pollutants? How can the application of internal standards bolster the reliability of the AD resistome study? What are the potential future research directions that could enhance ARG elimination? Investigating these subjects will assist in shaping more efficient management strategies that employ AD for effective ARG control.

Mechanistic insights into melanoidins-induced hydrophilicity of thermal hydrolyzed sludge and its impact on dewaterability

Although thermal hydrolysis pretreatment enhances disposal efficiency of sludge, it inevitably leads to melanoidins formation, which will negatively impact the subsequent wastewater treatment processes. However, their effect on the dewaterability of thermal hydrolyzed sludge (THS) remains poorly understood. This study aimed to uncover the underlying mechanisms of how melanoidins affecting dewaterability of THS. Using resin-adsorption method to reduce melanoidins content by 50% led to 21% and 6% decreases in capillary suction time and specific resistance to filtration, respectively, and a 14% increase in sludge cake solid content. Conversely, accumulating melanoidins to 200% worsened THS dewaterability, altering surface morphology and reducing floc stability, which increased the content of bound water by 9%. Additionally, a higher melanoidins level increased the hydrophilic components in extracellular polymeric substances while reducing hydrophobic sites and structures. These findings indicate that melanoidins impair THS dewaterability by altering flocs spatial properties and increasing hydrophilic structures and components.

Comparison of the short- and long-term effects of zinc ions on the anaerobic mesophilic co-digestion of food waste and waste activated sludge: Digester performance, antibiotic resistance gene reduction and the microbial community

Heavy metals contained in waste activated sludge (WAS), especially zinc ions, have an inhibitory effect on the anaerobic digestion. However, the effects of zinc ions on digester performance, antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) reduction, and the microbial community involved in the anaerobic mesophilic co-digestion (AcoD) of WAS and food waste (FW) have not been fully characterized. Therefore, batch trials and continuous stirred tank reactors were used under different zinc-ion concentrations. Findings showed that the AcoD system can tolerate a maximum zinc ion of 540 mg/L in a short-term batch and 470 mg/L in a long-term AcoD system, promoting methane production of approximately 1.0-17.0 %. Metagenomic analysis revealed that syntrophic H2 transfer occurred between Syntrophomonas and Methanoculleus and the aceticlastic and hydrogenotrophic methanogenic pathways were both enhanced by 1.18- and 1.16 times, respectively. Moreover, the relative abundance of Methanosarcina increased from 58.4 % to 72.5 % at 470 mg/L to adapt to the high zinc ion concentration during long-term continuous operation. These results revealed that AcoD with a low zinc ion concentration can effectively increase the removal percentage of ARGs. The results provide guidance for biogas recovery and use of mesophilic AcoD with FW and WAS containing high zinc ion concentrations without pretreatment process.

Biofilm formation on microplastics and interactions with antibiotics, antibiotic resistance genes and pathogens in aquatic environment

Microplastics (MPs) in aquatic environments easily support biofilm development, which can interact with other environmental pollutants and act as harbors for microorganisms. Recently, numerous studies have investigated the fate and behavior of MP biofilms in aquatic environments, highlighting their roles in the spread of pathogens and antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) to aquatic organisms and new habitats. The prevalence and effects of MP biofilms in aquatic environments have been extensively investigated in recent decades, and their behaviors in aquatic environments need to be synthesized systematically with updated information. This review aims to reveal the development of MP biofilm and its interactions with antibiotics, ARGs, and pathogens in aquatic environments. Recent research has shown that the adsorption capabilities of MPs to antibiotics are enhanced after the biofilm formation, and the adsorption of biofilms to antibiotics is biased towards chemisorption. ARGs and microorganisms, especially pathogens, are selectively enriched in biofilms and significantly different from those in surrounding waters. MP biofilm promotes the propagation of ARGs through horizontal gene transfer (HGT) and vertical gene transfer (VGT) and induces the emergence of antibiotic-resistant pathogens, resulting in increased threats to aquatic ecosystems and human health. Some future research needs and strategies in this review are also proposed to better understand the antibiotic resistance induced by MP biofilms in aquatic environments.

Fate of intracellular and extracellular antibiotic resistance genes in sewage sludge by full-scale anaerobic digestion

Storage tank (ST) is a promising strategy for solid-liquid separation following anaerobic digestion (AD). However, little is known regarding the effects of ST on antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs), mobile genetic elements (MGEs), and microbial communities. Therefore, this study first investigated eight typical ARGs (sul1, sul2, tetW, tetA, tetO, tetX, ermF, and ermB) and three MGEs (int1, int2, and tnpA) during full-scale AD of sludge and the liquid and biosolids phases of ST. Following that, intracellular ARGs (iARGs), extracellular polymeric substances (EPS)-associated ARGs, and cell-free ARGs removal were quantified in AD process, which is largely unknown for full-scale AD of sludge. The qPCR results showed that both AD and ST significantly removed ARGs, with ST biosolids showing the highest removal efficiency for the total measured relative (82.27 ± 2.09 %) and absolute (92.38 ± 0.89 %) abundance of ARGs compared to the raw sludge. Proteobacteria, Bacteroidota, Firmicutes and Campilobacterota were the main potential ARGs hosts in the sludge. Moreover, the results of different ARGs fractions showed that the total relative and absolute abundance of iARGs decreased by 90.12 ± 0.83 % and 79.89 ± 1.41 %, respectively, following AD. The same trend was observed for the abundance of EPS-associated ARGs, while those of cell-free ARGs increased after AD. These results underscore the risk of extracellular ARGs and provided new insights on extracellular ARGs dissemination evaluation.

Impact of aging of primary and secondary polystyrene nanoplastics on the transmission of antibiotic resistance genes in anaerobic digestion

Sewage sludge is a significant reservoir of nano/microplastics (NPs/MPs) and antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs). Research has revealed that NPs/MPs may exert an inhibitory effect on anaerobic digestion (AD) of sludge. Moreover, NPs/MPs can influence microbial community diversity and composition, potentially increasing ARGs dissemination. The morphological changes to NPs/MPs surface due to aging contribute to modifying hydrophobic properties. To date, there is limited comprehension regarding how various surface properties of NPs influence ARGs dissemination during AD. This study investigated the impact of primary aged/non-aged and secondary aged/non-aged polystyrene nanoplastics (PSNPs) on ARGs and mobile genetic elements (MGEs) propagation during AD. The findings indicated that the UV-aging process resulted in surface oxidation and distinct morphological characteristics in both primary and secondary PSNPs, while the surface oxidation effect was more pronounced in the secondary aged PSNPs. High concentrations (150 μg/L) of primary and secondary PSNPs inhibited methane production, with secondary PSNPs causing greater inhibition by 16 to 20 % compared to control. In contrast, low concentration (25 μg/L) had negligible or slightly positive effects on methane production. PSNPs at 150 μg/L reduced total VFA concentration, indicating an inhibitory effect on the fermentation step in the AD process. Primary and secondary PSNPs exhibited changes in EPS characteristics. ARGs abundance was enriched in reactors amended with PSNPs, with the highest abundance of 8.54 × 105 copies/g sludge observed in the secondary aged PSNPs (150 μg/L) reactor. Reactors exposed to aged PSNPs exhibited a relatively higher abundance of ARGs compared to reactors exposed to non-aged PSNPs. Exposure to PSNPs increased the microbial community diversity within the digesters and triggered the enrichment of Comamonadaceae and Syntrophaceae, belonging to Proteobacteria phylum. On the other hand, archaeal communities tended to shift towards hydrogenotrophic methanogens in PSNPs reactors. The correlation analysis showed that Comamonadaceae were positively correlated with the majority of ARGs and intl1. A positive correlation was observed between MGEs and most ARGs, suggesting that the increased proliferation of ARGs under PSNPs exposure may be linked to the abundance of MGEs, which in turn promotes the growth of hosts carrying ARGs. These findings suggest that aged and non-aged NPs could substantially impact the spread of ARGs and MGEs, which also led to notable alterations in the composition of the microbial community. Overall, this study provides valuable insights into the multifaceted impacts of PSNPs with various characteristics on AD processes, microbial communities, and ARGs proliferation, highlighting the urgent need for comprehensive assessments of NPs pollutants in the environment.

Comprehensive review on recent trends and perspectives of natural exo-polysaccharides: Pioneering nano-biotechnological tools

Exopolysaccharides (EPSs), originating from various microbes, and mushrooms, excel in their conventional role in bioremediation to showcase diverse applications emphasizing nanobiotechnology including nano-drug carriers, nano-excipients, medication and/or cell encapsulation, gene delivery, tissue engineering, diagnostics, and associated treatments. Acknowledged for contributions to adsorption, nutrition, and biomedicine, EPSs are emerging as appealing alternatives to traditional polymers, for biodegradability and biocompatibility. This article shifts away from the conventional utility to delve deeply into the expansive landscape of EPS applications, particularly highlighting their integration into cutting-edge nanobiotechnological methods. Exploring EPS synthesis, extraction, composition, and properties, the discussion emphasizes their structural diversity with molecular weight and heteropolymer compositions. Their role as raw materials for value-added products takes center stage, with critical insights into recent applications in nanobiotechnology. The multifaceted potential, biological relevance, and commercial applicability of EPSs in contemporary research and industry align with the nanotechnological advancements coupled with biotechnological nano-cleansing agents are highlighted. EPS-based nanostructures for biological applications have a bright future ahead of them. Providing crucial information for present and future practices, this review sheds light on how eco-friendly EPSs derived from microbial biomass of terrestrial and aquatic environments can be used to better understand contemporary nanobiotechnology for the benefit of society.

Can low-temperature thermal hydrolysis mitigate the oxidative stress of polystyrene nanoplastics on anaerobic digestion?

The presence of micro/nanoplastics (MPs/NPs) in sewage sludge has sparked considerable apprehensions over their potential negative effects on anaerobic digestion (AD) performance. The occurrence of MPs/NPs can trigger oxidative stress on the anaerobic microbiome, leading to potential inhibition of the AD process. While the thermal hydrolysis process (THP) is an extensively utilized sludge pretreatment method for AD, its impact on stress induced by MPs/NPs during AD remains poorly understood. In this study, we assessed the impacts of low-temperature THP (90 °C, 90 min) on AD of sewage sludge in the presence of 150 μg/L of polystyrene nanoplastics (PsNPs) under different solid retention times (SRTs) of 20, 15, and 10 d. The presence of PsNPs resulted in a higher reactive oxygen species (ROS) production and a higher abundance of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs). Additionally, their presence caused a significant inhibition of methane production by 28.2%, 29.3%, and 38.8% for SRTs of 20, 15, and 10 d, respectively. Introducing low-temperature THP prior to the AD could partially recover methane production by mitigating ROS-induced stress and curbing the propagation of ARGs during the AD process. These results shed light on the potential benefits of THP and further optimization opportunities in alleviating the adverse effects of MPs/NPs-induced stress during sewage sludge AD.

Low-temperature thermal hydrolysis for enhancing sludge anaerobic digestion and antibiotic resistance management: Significance of digester solids retention time

Recently, there has been a growing inclination towards utilizing primary sludge (PS) fermentation prior to anaerobic digestion (AD) in water resource recovery facilities (WRRFs), where sludge liquor containing volatile fatty acids is used for biological nutrient removal. Nevertheless, using a low-temperature thermal hydrolysis process (THP) to improve AD in WRRFs adopting PS fermentation remains an area that has received limited research attention. Here, we studied the impact of THP (90 °C, 90 min) on anaerobic co-digestion of thickened waste activated sludge (TWAS) and fermented primary sludge (FPS) under varying solids retention times (SRTs) in semi-continuous mode. The study involved two THP schemes: scheme 1, where THP was done for both TWAS and FPS, and scheme 2, where THP was applied to TWAS only. The results demonstrated that reducing SRT from 20 to 15 and 10 d leads to decreased methane yield in both schemes. However, THP significantly enhances methane production, showing improvements of up to 37.9 % (scheme 1) and 31.2 % (scheme 2) under a 15-d SRT. Furthermore, while decreasing SRT increased the proliferation of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs), thermal hydrolysis could effectively reduce most ARGs, indicating its potential to mitigate antibiotic resistance in the AD process. Overall, these results provide useful perceptions regarding the potential adoption of low-temperature THP in WRRFs with PS fermentation.

Occurrence characteristics and influencing factors of antibiotic resistance genes in rural groundwater in Henan Province

This study determined the antibiotic-resistant gene (ARG) contents of 34 groundwater samples in Henan Province collected from September to October 2022, then assessed the roles of both water quality parameters and intI1 in ARG propagation in groundwater. The results show that there existed universal ARG pollution in groundwater, and sulfonamides-, β-lactem-, and tetracycline-resistance genes were the most prevalent gene types during the time. Sul1 contributed the majority proportion of the total resistance genes (TARGs). The prevalence of ESBLs gene blaTEM and the occurrence of Carbapenems resistant gene blaOXA-1 suggests the pollution of high-risk ARGs in groundwater demands more attention. IntI1 is prevalent and had a significantly positive correlation with almost 50% ARGs, indicating its contribution to ARG propagation in groundwater. Well types contribute little to ARG propagation in rural groundwater of Henan, which means the protective facilities established by the local government for public wells can effectively prevent contamination from exogenous ARGs. However, the economic level has no impact on the abundance of ARGs in rural groundwater, which suggests the local government should pay greater attention to investment in controlling ARG pollution in Henan rural areas.

Insights into the role of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) in the spread of antibiotic resistance genes

Antibiotic resistance genes (ARG) are prevalent in aquatic environments. Discharge from wastewater treatment plants is an important point source of ARG release into the environment. It has been reported that biological treatment processes may enhance rather than remove ARG because of their presence in sludge. Attenuation of ARG in biotechnological processes has been studied in depth, showing that many microorganisms can secrete complex extracellular polymeric substances (EPS). These EPS can serve as multifunctional elements of microbial communities, involving aspects, such as protection, structure, recognition, adhesion, and physiology. These aspects can influence the interaction between microbial cells and extracellular ARG, as well as the uptake of extracellular ARG by microbial cells, thus changing the transformative capability of extracellular ARG. However, it remains unclear whether EPS can affect horizontal ARG transfer, which is one of the main processes of ARG dissemination. In light of this knowledge gap, this review provides insight into the role of EPS in the transmission of ARGs; furthermore, the mechanism of ARG spread is analyzed, and the molecular compositions and functional properties of EPS are summarized; also, how EPS influence ARG mitigation is addressed, and factors impacting how EPS facilitate ARG during wastewater treatment are summarized. This review provides comprehensive insights into the role of EPS in controlling the transport and fate of ARG during biodegradation processes at the mechanistic level.

Performance of sewage sludge treatment for the removal of antibiotic resistance genes: Status and prospects

Wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) receive wastewater containing antibiotic resistant bacteria (ARB) and antibiotic resistant genes (ARGs), which are predominant contributors to environmental pollution in water and soil. Of these sources, sludge is a more significant contributor than effluent. Knowing how sludge treatment affects the fate of ARGs is vital for managing the risk of these genes in both human and natural environments. This review therefore discusses the sources and transmission of ARGs in the environment and highlights the risks of ARGs in sludge. The effects of co-existing constituents (heavy metals, microplastics, etc.) on sludge and ARGs during treatment are collated to highlight the difficulty of treating sludge with complex constituents in ARGs. The effects of various sludge treatment methods on the abundances of ARGs in sludge and in soil from land application of treated sludge are discussed, pointing out that the choice of sludge treatment method should take into account various potential factors, such as soil and soil biology in subsequent land application. This review offers significant insights and explores the abundances of ARGs throughout the process of sludge treatment and disposal. Unintentional addition of antibiotic residues, heavy metals, microplastics and organic matter in sludge could significantly increase the abundance and reduce the removal efficiency of ARGs during treatment, which undoubtedly adds a barrier to the removal of ARGs from sludge treatment. The complexity of the sludge composition and the diversities of ARGs have led to the fact that no effective sludge treatment method has so far been able to completely eliminate the ecological risk of ARGs. In order to reduce risks resulting by transmission of ARGs, technical and management measures need to be implemented.

Granular activated carbon remediates antibiotic resistance propagation and methanogenic inhibition induced by polystyrene nanoplastics in sludge anaerobic digestion

Nano/microplastics (NPs/MPs) in sewage sludge can induce oxidative stress to the anaerobic digestion (AD) and also proliferate antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs). Recently, granular activated carbon (GAC) has been used as an additive to enhance methane production in AD via direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET); however, its impact on AD exposed to NPs/MPs is yet to be studied. This study examined the effect of GAC (5 and 15 g/L) on sludge AD exposed to 150 µg/L of polystyrene nanoplastics (PsNPs). PsNPs decreased methane yield by 32.3% due to elevated levels of reactive oxygen species. However, GAC addition counteracted this adverse effect and improved methane production, attributed to the potential enrichment of DIET-active microbes and the adsorption of PsNPs by GAC. Moreover, GAC reduced the total abundance of ARGs, which was increased by PsNPs exposure. Thus, GAC can provide dual benefits in mitigating methanogenic inhibition caused by PsNPs and ARG spread.

Antibiotic resistance genes proliferation under anaerobic degradation of polylactic acid and polyhydroxy butyrate bioplastics

As the global concern over plastic pollution grows, efforts are underway to find environmentally friendly alternatives to traditional plastics. Bioplastics are being extensively researched and developed as a possible solution. This study compared the impact of two bioplastics, polylactic acid (PLA) and polyhydroxy butyrate (PHB), on the proliferation of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) and mobile genetic elements (MGEs) during anaerobic digestion (AD). Both bioplastics (250-500 particles) could be degraded to a certain extent over 79 days, as indicated by higher methane production than the control without bioplastic particles. The PHB 500 reactor showed the highest methane yield along with the highest biodegradation efficiency (91 %) than other reactors amended with PHB and PLA particles. The highest ARG and MGE abundances were also observed in PLA 500, and the lowest ARG abundance was in PLA 250. Conversely, PHB reactors showed a relatively lower ARG abundance than the control. The correlation analysis suggested that most ARGs were positively correlated with PLA and negatively correlated with PHB (except for tetA, tetB, and tetX). Moreover, a correlation between MGEs and ARGs in PLA and PHB reactors was revealed by correlation analysis. These results show that AD responds differently to the different types/levels of bioplastics, which can ultimately influence the behavior of ARG proliferation. Thus, bioplastics may also pose a potential risk for spreading antibiotic resistance. These findings can be used as a basis for setting environmental standards for bioplastics and creating monitoring and control measures to prevent potential negative impacts on public health.

In-situ membrane fouling control and performance improvement by adding materials in anaerobic membrane bioreactor: A review

Anaerobic membrane bioreactor (AnMBR) is a promising treatment technique for various types of wastewaters, and is preferred over other conventional aerobic and anaerobic methods. However, membrane fouling is considered a bottleneck in AnMBR system, which technically blocks membrane pores by numerous inorganics, organics, and other microbial substances. Various materials can be added in AnMBR to control membrane fouling and improve anaerobic digestion, and studies reporting the materials addition for this purpose are hereby systematically reviewed. The mechanism of membrane fouling control including compositional changes in extracellular polymeric substances (EPSs) and soluble microbial products (SMPs), materials properties, stimulation of antifouling microbes and alteration in substrate properties by material addition are thoroughly discussed. Nonetheless, this study opens up new research prospects to control membrane fouling of AnMBR, engineered by material, including compositional changes of microbial products (EPS and SMP), replacement of quorum quenching (QQ) by materials, and overall improvement of reactor performance. Regardless of the great research progress achieved previously in membrane fouling control, there is still a long way to go for material-mediated AnMBR applications to be undertaken, particularly for materials coupling, real scale application and molecular based studies on EPSs and SMPs, which were proposed for future researches.