Minimally invasive, nonendoscopic thyroidectomy: A cosmetic alternative to robotic-assisted thyroidectomy

Modified version of minimally invasive open thyroidectomy using an unilateral incision

BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVE

Open thyroidectomy has been the standard approach for patients undergoing thyroidectomy. However, this approach leads to prominent scars, hypesthesia, paresthesia, and uncomfortable sensations. We aimed to describe our modified technique of minimally invasive open thyroidectomy (MIT) and to compare the results with those of conventional thyroidectomy.

METHODS

This study included 880 patients who underwent surgery between January 2016 and December 2016. Modified MIT was performed in 249 patients (28.3%), and conventional thyroidectomy was performed in the remaining 631 patients.

RESULTS

Lobectomy was performed in the majority of cases (MIT 204 [81.9%] vs. conventional 429 [67.9%]). There were no significant differences in complications between the two approaches (6 [2.4%] vs. 8 [1.3%]). Patients who underwent surgery using the minimally invasive approach had a shorter operative time (77.99 ± 34.5 vs. 91.23 ± 36.58 min) and were discharged earlier (2.4 ± 0.8 vs. 3.2 ± 0.8) than those who underwent conventional thyroidectomy.

CONCLUSION

Modified MIT is a safe alternative to standard open thyroidectomy and allows the performance of bilateral total thyroidectomy with proper central compartment neck dissection.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

2b.

The natural neck crease as an anatomic landmark for thyroid surgery incision

BACKGROUND

The anatomical relations between the neck skin crease and the thyroid gland isthmus and cricoid cartilage are important for surgical planning.

METHODS

Between 2016 and 2018 anatomical measurements were performed on 118 participants during a presurgical ultrasound exam and were verified during surgery. The data were stratified according to age, sex, patient's body mass index (BMI), and height.

FINDINGS

The cricoid cartilage was found to be lower than the second skin neck crease by 0.2 ± 0.9 cm on average and the thyroid isthmus lower by 0.9 ± 1 cm from the second neck crease. No correlation was found to subjects' age, BMI, or height. Patient satisfaction, measured by the dermatologic life quality index, was high.

CONCLUSIONS

A surgical incision made along the second neck crease will allow for a predicted and proper exposure in thyroid surgeries. The possibility of concealing the surgical scar in the natural neck skin crease can increase patients' aesthetic satisfaction.

[Alternative approaches in thyroid surgery]

In thyroid surgery multiple different cervical minimally invasive (partly endoscopically assisted) and extracervical endoscopic (partly robot-assisted) approaches have been developed in the last 20 years. The aim of all these alternative approaches to the thyroid gland is optimization of the cosmetic result. The indications for the use of alternative and conventional approaches are principally the same. Important requirements for the use of alternative methods are nevertheless a broad experience in conventional thyroid operations of the thyroid and adequate patient selection under consideration of the size of the thyroid and the underlying pathology. Contraindications for the use of alternative approaches are a large size of the thyroid gland including local symptoms, advanced carcinomas, reoperations and previous radiations of the anterior neck. The current article gives an overview of the clinically implemented alternative approaches for thyroid surgery. Of those the majority must still be considered as experimental. The alternative approaches to the thyroid gland can be divided in cervical minimally invasive, extracervical endosopic (robot-assisted) and transoral operations (natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery, NOTES). Since conventional thyroid operations are standardized procedures with low complication rates, alternative approaches to the thyroid gland are considered critically in Germany. The request for a perfect cosmetic result should not overweigh patients' safety. Only a few alternative approaches (e. g. MIVAT, RAT) can yet be considered as a safe addition in experienced hands in highly selected patients.

Ethical issues in robotic-assisted transaxillary thyroidectomy

Like many new techniques in surgery, the use of robotic-assisted transaxillary thyroidectomy is an innovative approach to a common surgical treatment. However, the increased risks associated with the operation along with the increased costs make robotic-assisted transaxillary thyroidectomy an ethically problematic procedure to be utilized in contemporary health systems.