Crystal morphology tuning and green post-synthetic modification of metal organic framework for HPLC enantioseparation

Theoretical Calculations in Separation Science for Analytical Chemistry: Applications and Insights

Separation and enrichment are critical steps in analytical detection, necessitating advanced materials with high selectivity and adsorption capacity for target compounds. In order to improve separation efficiency and selectivity, computational simulation could elucidate interaction mechanisms and analyze potential adsorption/desorption processes, providing a theoretical foundation for the optimization and design of separation materials. Recently, computational simulation has become an indispensable and crucial mean in separation science for analytical chemistry. Using various simulation software, researchers could investigate the structures, properties, and performance of separation materials at multiple levels and scales. In this review, we summarize the applications of computational simulations in the field of separation science, focusing on the separation of polar molecules, geometric isomers, enantiomer compounds, and post-translationally modified peptides. These calculation methods include quantum chemistry, molecular docking, molecular dynamics simulations, high-throughput screening, and machine learning. Finally, we discuss the current challenges and potential breakthroughs in computational simulation, aiming to offer valuable insights for researchers dedicated to computational simulation, material development, and separation applications.

Deep eutectic solvent-based ionogel: Innovative potential as a promising chromatographic separation material

BACKGROUND

Ionogels, composed of cross-linked polymer networks with abundant anions and cations as dispersion media, have emerged as promising materials. The superior properties of ionogels suggest that they may offer valuable contributions to the development of novel chromatographic stationary phase. However, the potential application of ionogels as the charming materials in liquid chromatography has been limited, primarily due to the hydrophilic nature, leading to swelling and increased column pressure. To address this issue, a paradigm-shifting innovation was proposed by incorporating deep eutectic solvent (DES) to facilitate the formation of robust hydrogen bond networks, thereby reducing the swelling tendency of ionogel.

RESULTS

In this study, an environmentally friendly DES was selected as the optimal alternative to the traditional ionic liquid for the formation of a DES-based ionogel. By combining the ionogel with the silica gel matrix, a DES-Ionogel@SiO2 stationary phase was prepared. The whole synthesis process of DES-Ionogel@SiO2 was conducted in the green DES. The swelling tendency of ionogel as a functionalized chromatographic material was significantly reduced, thereby mitigating the risk of undue column pressure. This innovation results in a DES-based stationary phase with enhanced stability and durability in aqueous media, which is pivotal for maintaining the performance and longevity of chromatographic column. The DES-Ionogel@SiO2 stationary phase exhibits a distinctive mixed-mode retention mechanism, which is a highly desirable attribute in diverse chromatographic applications. This endows the developed chromatographic column with a broad applicability for the separation of complex samples, such as nucleosides, phenyl ketones, phthalates, alkylphenols, steroid hormones and position isomers.

SIGNIFICANCE

This work presents an innovative approach and green in-situ growth strategy for the development of a versatile ionogel stationary phase, and marks the first time that DES-based ionogel has been synthesized and used to modify silica gel as a promising chromatographic separation material, showcasing the revolutionary potential of DES-based ionogel in the field of liquid chromatography.

Michael and Schiff-Base Reactions-Assisted Fluorescence Sensor Based on the MOF Nanosheet Microspheres for the Effective Discrimination and Detection of Hydroquinone and Catechol

A novel sensing platform was constructed for the recognition and identification of dihydroxybenzene isomers based on the MOF-0.02TEA fluorescence sensor with the morphology of nanosheet microspheres through coordination modulation. Based on the sensing principle that the amino group on the MOF-0.02TEA can make the Michael reaction with o-benzoquinone and p-benzoquinone, which were individually the oxidation intermediate of catechol and hydroquinone, the fluorescence intensity of MOF-0.02TEA could be quenched through the inner filter effect (IFE) without the interference from resorcinol. Besides, catechol and hydroquinone could be further distinguished with the assistance of the Schiff-base reaction by introducing o-phenylenediamine (OPD) to the detection system. The MOF-0.02TEA sensor exhibited good selectivity, and the detection limits for catechol and hydroquinone were 90.5 nmol/L and 0.52 μmol/L (S/N = 3), respectively. Moreover, the sensor could be used for the determination of dihydroxybenzene isomers in tap water and lake water.

Regulating Catalytic Oxidation Enantiomers Behavior by Imparting Chiral Microenvironment in Zr-Based Metal-Organic Frameworks

Chiral inversions of enantiomers have significantly different biological activities, so it is important to develop simple and effective methods to efficiently identify optically pure compounds. Inspired by enzyme catalysis, the construction of chiral microenvironments resembling enzyme pockets in the pore space structure of metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) to achieve asymmetric enantioselective recognition and catalysis has become a new research hotspot. Here, a super-stable porphyrin-containing material PCN-224 is constructed by solvothermal method and a chiral microenvironment around the existing catalytic site of the material is created by post-synthesis modifications of the histidine (His) enantiomers. Experimental and theoretical calculations results show that the modulation of chiral ligands around Zr oxide clusters produces different spatial site resistances, which can greatly affect the adsorption and catalytic level of the enantiomeric molecules of tryptophan guests, resulting in a good enantioselective property of the material. It provides new ideas and possibilities for future chiral recognition and asymmetric catalysis.

Robust Homochiral Polycrystalline Metal-Organic Framework Membranes for High-Performance Enantioselective Separation

Homochiral MOF membranes offer a promising route to efficient chiral separation, but their fabrication remains challenging. Here, we report for the first time the design and preparation of homochiral polycrystalline MOF-808 membranes for the first time. The membrane exhibits a high integrity and thin membrane thickness. Achieving homochirality through chiral amino acid postsynthetic modification, MOF-808 membranes demonstrate remarkable solvent stability. Notably, they successfully separated racemic naproxen enantiomers, achieving enantiomeric excess (ee) values of up to ∼95.0%. This work paves the way for turning achiral polycrystalline MOF membranes into high-performance chiral membranes for enantioselective separation.

Chiral hydroxyl-controlled covalent organic framework-modified stationary phase for chromatographic enantioseparation

Chiral covalent organic frameworks (CCOFs) possess a superior chiral recognition environment, abundant pore configuration, and favorable physicochemical stability. In the post-synthetic chiral modification of COFs, research usually focused on increasing the density of chiral sites as much as possible, and little attention has been paid to the influence of the density of chiral sites on the spatial structure and chiral separation performance of CCOFs. In this article, 1,3,5-tris(4-aminophenyl) benzene (TPB), 2,5-dihydroxyterephthalaldehyde (DHTP), and 2,5-dimethoxyterephthalaldehyde (DMTP) served as the platform molecules to directly establish hydroxyl-controlled COFs through Schiff base condensation reactions. Then the novel chiral selectors 6-deoxy-6-[1-(2-aminoethyl)-3-(4-(4-isocyanatobenzyl)phenyl)urea]-β-cyclodextrin (UB-β-CD) were pended into the micropore structures of COFs via covalent bond for further construction the [UB-β-CD]x-TPB-DMTP COFs (x represents the density of chiral sites). The chiral sites density on [UB-β-CD]x-TPB-DMTP COFs was regulated by changing the construction proportion of DHTP to obtain a satisfactory CCOFs and significantly improve the ability of chiral separation. [UB-β-CD]x-TPB-DMTP COFs were coated on the inner wall of a capillary via a covalently bonding strategy. The prepared open tubular capillary exhibited strong and broad enantioselectivity toward a variety of chiral analytes, including sixteen racemic amino acids and six model chiral drugs. By comparing the outcomes of chromatographic separation, we observed that the density of chiral sites in CCOFs was not positively correlated with their enantiomeric separation performance. The mechanism of chiral recognition [UB-β-CD]x-TPB-DMTP COFs were further demonstrated by molecular docking simulation. This study not only introduces a new high-efficiency member of the COFs-based CSPs family but also demonstrates the enantioseparation potential of CCOFs constructed with traditional post-synthetic modification (PSM) strategy by utilizing the inherent characteristics of porous organic frameworks.

A free carboxyl-decorated metal-organic framework with 3D helical chirality for highly enantioselective recognition

With the judicious selection of a designed polycarboxylate derived from L-phenylalanine, (S)-5-(((1-carboxy-2-phenylethyl)amino)methyl)isophthalic acid (H3L), a novel homochiral metal-organic framework decorated with a free carboxyl, {[Cu2(HL)2(bipy)]∙2H2O}n (Cu-MOF), has been designed and synthesized in a solvothermal process. The result of single crystal X-ray diffraction analysis showed that Cu-MOF had the character of a three-dimensional structure with helical chirality. As we expected, in Cu-MOF, one accessible free carboxylic acid group on H3L pointed toward the spiral channels, and the other two -COOH groups were utilized in bonding. The enantioseparation performance of Cu-MOF was thoroughly investigated and the results showed that Cu-MOF can specifically recognize S-1-(1-naphthyl) ethanol (S-NE) with enantiomeric excess (ee) value of 99.35 %, which was much higher than the other three racemates. The appropriate size together with suitable interaction sites played an important role in enantioseparations. Inspired by the excellent chiral recognition effects towards S-NE, the chiral recognition mechanism was experimentally clarified. A fully agreement observed in 13C CP MAS NMR analysis as well as the X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) determination revealed that a strong hydrogen bonding interaction forces existed between the hydroxyl of the optical S-NE and the decorated -COOH in the chiral framework. The control experiment further identified the decisive role of the uncoordinated carboxyl group in Cu-MOF. In addition, the strong intermolecular off-set π-π interactions between the phenyl ring involved with the coordinated COO- groups in Cu-MOF and the naphthyl ring of S-NE, was the another important factor for the specifical enantioseparation of S-enantiomer. On the basis of strong intermolecular hydrogen bonding, NE racemates were enantioselective discriminated and enantiomeric purity can be determined by means of Raman scattering spectroscopy.

Graft copolymerization of anion and cation onto silica and application in mixed-mode of reversed phase/ hydrophilic interaction/ ion exchange chromatography

Ionic liquids (ILs) have turned out to be one of the best choices to fabricate mixed-mode stationary phases, this work aimed to investigate the possibility and merit of copolymerizing cations and anions as modifications. We prepared two ILs stationary phases, one of which was constructed by copolymerizing cation and anion (p-vinylbenzene sulfonate). Two stationary phases were characterized and comprehensively evaluated. The stationary phases showed great repeatability (RSD <0.87%) and high efficiency (up to 83,810 plate/m). Both stationary phases can operate under a mixed mode of reversed phase/hydrophilic interaction/ion exchange chromatography (RPLC/HILIC/IEC). Chromatographic evaluation results revealed that copolymerized anions endow stationary phase superior selectivity under RPLC and HILIC modes, so hydrophobic terphenyls isomer (under ACN/H2O = 35/65) and hydrophilic nucleotides and bases (under ACN/100 mM NH4FA buffer = 90/10) are better separated. Organic and inorganic anions showed entirely different retention behaviors on two stationary phases, and the mechanism was investigated by linear solvation energy relationship (LSER) and thermodynamic analysis. This work proved that copolymerizing cations and anions of ILs could be a promising method to prepare stationary phases, the retention property and mechanism need further research.

Engineering thiol-ene click chemistry for the preparation of a chiral stationary phase based on a [4+6]-type homochiral porous organic cage for enantiomeric separation in normal-phase and reversed-phase high performance liquid chromatography

In this study, a new chiral stationary phase (CSP) was fabricated by covalent bonding of a [4+6]-type homochiral porous organic cage (POC) CC19-R onto thiolated silica via a thiol-ene click reaction. The CC19-R was synthesized via Schiff-base reaction between 2-hydroxybenzene-1,3,5-tricarbaldehyde and (1R, 2R)-(-)-1,2-diaminocyclohexane. The enantioseparation capability of the resulting CC19-R-based CSP was systematically evaluated upon separating various chiral compounds or chiral pharmaceuticals in normal phase HPLC (NP-HPLC) and reversed phase HPLC (RP-HPLC), including alcohols, organic acids, ketones, diols, esters, and amines. Fifteen racemates were enantioseparated in NP-HPLC and 11 racemates in RP-HPLC. Some racemates have been well separated, such as 4-chlorobenzhydrol, cetirizine (in the form of dihydrochloride), 1,2-diphenyl-1,2-ethanediol, and 3-(benzyloxy)propane-1,2-diol whose resolution values reached 3.66, 4.23, 6.50, and 3.50, respectively. When compared with a previously reported chiral POC-based column (NC1-R column), eight racemates were not separated on the NC1-R column in NP-HPLC and five racemates were not separated in RP-HPLC, but were well resolved on this column, revealing that the enantioselectivity and separable range of chiral POCs-type columns could be significantly widened using this fabricated CC19-R column. Moreover, the resolution performance of the CC19-R column was also compared with commercial Chiralpak AD-H [CSP: Amylose tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate)] and Chiralcel OD-H [CSP: Cellulose tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate)] columns. The column also can separate some racemates that could not be separated or not well be separated by the two commercial columns, showing its good complementarity to the two commercial columns on chiral separation. In addition, the column also had good stability and reproducibility with the relative standard deviation (n = 5) of the retention time and resolution lower than 1.0% and 1.8%, respectively, after it had undergone multiple injections (100, 200, 300, and 400 times). This work indicated that the features of good resolution ability and simple synthesis methods using with this POC-based CSP provided chiral POCs with potential application prospects in HPLC racemic separation.

Recent advances in chiral liquid chromatography stationary phases for pharmaceutical analysis

Chirality is a common phenomenon in nature. Different enantiomers of chiral drug compounds have obvious differences in their effects on the human body. Therefore, the separation of chiral drugs plays an extremely important role in the safe utilization of drugs. High-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) is an effective tool for the separation and analysis of compounds, in which the chromatographic packing plays a key role in the separation. Chiral pharmaceutical separation and analysis in HPLC rely on chiral stationary phases (CSPs). Thus, various CSPs are being developed to meet the needs of chiral drug separation and analysis. In this review, recent developments in CSPs, including saccharides (cyclodextrin, cellulose, amylose and chitosan), macrocycles (macrocyclic glycopeptides, pillar[n]arene and polyamide) and porous organic materials (metal-organic frameworks, covalent organic frameworks, and porous organic cages), for pharmaceutical analysis in HPLC were summarized, the advantages and disadvantages of various stationary phases were introduced, and their development prospects were discussed.

The development of chiral metal-organic frameworks for enantioseparation of racemates

MIL-101(Cr), an achiral metal-organic framework, made up of a terephthalic acid ligand and a metal chromium ion was selected as a template. Its structural features are unsaturated Lewis acid sites that can be easily activated and it has an extremely high specific surface area, big pore size, and good thermal/chemical/water stability. This achiral framework was modified to introduce chirality within the structure to develop chiral metal-organic frameworks (CMOFs). Here, natural chiral ligands, amino acids (l-proline, l-thioproline and l-tyrosine), were selected for post synthetic modification (PSM) of MIL-101(Cr). This is a very simple, clean and facile methodology with respect to the reactants and reaction conditions. CMOFs 1-3 abbreviated as MIL-101-l-proline (CMOF-1), MIL-101-l-thioproline (CMOF-2) and MIL-101-l-tyrosine (CMOF-3) were prepared by introducing l-proline, l-thioproline and l-tyrosine as chiral moieties within the framework of (Cr). These CMOFs were characterized by FTIR, PXRD, SEM, and thermo gravimetric analysis. Chirality within these CMOFs 1-3 was established by circular dichroism (CD) and polarimetric methods. These three CMOFs 1-3 showed enantioselectivity towards RS-ibuprofen, RS-mandelic acid and RS-1-phenylethanol to varying extents. Their enantioselectivity towards racemates was studied by chiral HPLC and polarimetry.

Chiral metal-organic frameworks and their composites as stationary phases for liquid chromatography chiral separation: A minireview

Chiral metal organic frameworks (CMOFs) are a kind of crystal porous framework material that has attracted increasing attention due to the customizable combination of metal nodes and organic ligands. In particular, the highly ordered crystal structure and rich adjustable chiral structure make it a promising material for developing new chiral separation material systems. In this review, the progress of CMOFs and their different types of composites used as chiral stationary phases (CSPs) in liquid chromatography for enantioseparation are discussed. The characteristics of CMOFs and their composites are summarized, aiming to provide new ideas for the development of CMOFs with better performance and further promote the application of CMOFs materials in enantioselective high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC).

A chiral metal-organic framework synthesized by the mixture of chiral and non-chiral organic ligands for enantioseparation of drugs by open-tubular capillary electrochromatography

A chiral metal-organic framework L-Histidine-Zeolitic imidazolate framework-67 (L-His-ZIF-67) was synthesized by the mixture of chiral organic ligand L-histidine and non-chiral organic ligand 2-methylimidazole directly, and to the author's knowledge, the chiral L-His-ZIF-67 coated capillary column we prepared has still not been reported to date in the field of capillary electrophoresis. This chiral metal-organic frameworks material was used as the chiral stationary phase for enantioseparation of drugs by open-tubular capillary electrochromatography. The separation conditions such as pH value, buffer concentration and proportion of organic modifier were optimized. Under optimal conditions, the established enantioseparation system achieved good separation effect, and the resolution of five chiral drugs: esmolol (7.93), nefopam (3.03), salbutamol (2.42), scopolamine (1.08) and sotalol (0.81). In addition, the chiral recognition mechanism of L-His-ZIF-67 was elucidated by a series of mechanism experiments, and the specific interaction force was preliminarily speculated.

Grafting (S)-2-Phenylpropionic Acid on Coordinatively Unsaturated Metal Centers of MIL-101(Al) Metal-Organic Frameworks for Improved Enantioseparation

Chiral metal-organic frameworks (cMOFs) are emerging chiral stationary phases for enantioseparation owing to their porosity and designability. However, a great number of cMOF materials show poor separation performance for chiral drugs in high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). The possible reasons might be the irregular shapes of MOFs and the low grafting degree of chiral ligands. Herein, MIL-101-Ppa@SiO₂ was synthesized by a simple coordination post-synthetic modification method using (S)-(+)-2-Phenylpropionic acid and applied as the chiral stationary phase to separate chiral compounds by HPLC. NH₂-MIL-101-Ppa@SiO₂ prepared via covalent post-synthetic modification was used for comparison. The results showed that the chiral ligand density of MIL-101-Ppa@SiO₂ was higher than that of NH₂-MIL-101-Ppa@SiO₂, and the MIL-101-Ppa@SiO₂ column exhibited better chiral separation performance and structural stability. The binding affinities between MIL-101-Ppa@SiO₂ and chiral compounds were simulated to prove the mechanism of the molecular interactions during HPLC. These results revealed that cMOFs prepared by coordination post-synthetic modification could increase the grafting degree and enhance the separation performance. This method can provide ideas for the synthesis of cMOFs.

Enhanced Chiral Recognition Abilities of Cyclodextrin Covalent Organic Frameworks via Chiral/Achiral Functional Modification

β-Cyclodextrin covalent organic frameworks (β-CD COFs) show great potential in enantioseparation due to their uniformly distributed chiral recognition sites and good chemical stability. The hydroxyl and amino groups of β-CD COFs enable facile post-modification to introduce the desired functionality into the frameworks. In this study, we perform post-modification of β-CD COF_BPDA with 1,4-butane sultone and [(3R,4R)-4-acetyloxy-2,5-dioxooxolan-3-yl] acetate to construct two kinds of novel functional β-CD COFs. The capillary columns prepared with these two functional β-CD COFs separated chiral dihydropyridines and fluoroquinolones with excellent selectivity and repeatability in capillary electrochromatography, while β-CD COF_BPDA-modified capillary columns did not present the chiral recognition ability for these drugs. The mechanism of chiral recognition and the enhanced enantioselectivity of functional β-CD COFs were further demonstrated by molecular docking simulation. The divergent chiral separation performances of β-CD COFs suggest that the introduction of functional groups enables the modification of β-CD COF properties and tuning of its chiral recognition abilities for the diversity of enantioseparation.