Contact-dependent inhibition: bacterial brakes and secret handshakes

Contact-Dependent Growth Inhibition in Bacteria: Do Not Get Too Close!

Over millions of years of evolution, bacteria have developed complex strategies for intra-and interspecies interactions and competition for ecological niches and resources. Contact-dependent growth inhibition systems (CDI) are designed to realize a direct physical contact of one bacterial cell with other cells in proximity via receptor-mediated toxin delivery. These systems are found in many microorganisms including clinically important human pathogens. The main purpose of these systems is to provide competitive advantages for the growth of the population. In addition, non-competitive roles for CDI toxin delivery systems including interbacterial signal transduction and mediators of bacterial collaboration have been suggested. In this review, our goal was to systematize the recent findings on the structure, mechanisms, and purpose of CDI systems in bacterial populations and discuss the potential biological and evolutionary impact of CDI-mediated interbacterial competition and/or cooperation.

Identification of a contact-dependent growth inhibition system in the probiotic Escherichia coli Nissle 1917

Contact-dependent growth inhibition (CDI) is a type of competitive mechanisms and has been identified in various strains including Burkholderia, Dickeya, E. coli and Yersinia. Classical CDI systems contain three genes, cdiB, cdiA and cdiI. CdiB encoded by cdiB gene is a conserved β-barrel protein and required for export of CdiA. CdiA protein encoded by cdiA gene includes a conserved N-terminal domain and variable C-terminal toxic domain (CdiA-CT). Immunity protein CdiI binds and inactivates toxin protein CdiA-CT. Here, we identified two CDI systems, an intact cdiBAI operon with a truncated CdiB due to an unexpected mutation and an 'orphan' cdiA-CT/cdiI module in the probiotic Escherichia coli Nissle 1917 (EcN) genome. Both CdiA-CTs from EcN showed auto-inhibition activity when transferring into E. coli DH5α, as well the sequential deletion of amino acid residues resulted in the generation of the most potent mutant of CdiA-CT. CdiI neutralized the toxicity activity of CdiA and was immunity protein as previous report. In conclusion, this is the first report that the functional CDI system is in probiotic EcN and might provide a potential competitive mechanism for probiotic EcN in intestinal microenvironment.

Genome reannotation of Escherichia coli CFT073 with new insights into virulence

Background

As one of human pathogens, the genome of Uropathogenic Escherichia coli strain CFT073 was sequenced and published in 2002, which was significant in pathogenetic bacterial genomics research. However, the current RefSeq annotation of this pathogen is now outdated to some degree, due to missing or misannotation of some essential genes associated with its virulence. We carried out a systematic reannotation by combining automated annotation tools with manual efforts to provide a comprehensive understanding of virulence for the CFT073 genome.

Results

The reannotation excluded 608 coding sequences from the RefSeq annotation. Meanwhile, a total of 299 coding sequences were newly added, about one third of them are found in genomic island (GI) regions while more than one fifth of them are located in virulence related regions pathogenicity islands (PAIs). Furthermore, there are totally 341 genes were relocated with their translational initiation sites (TISs), which resulted in a high quality of gene start annotation. In addition, 94 pseudogenes annotated in RefSeq were thoroughly inspected and updated. The number of miscellaneous genes (sRNAs) has been updated from 6 in RefSeq to 46 in the reannotation. Based on the adjustment in the reannotation, subsequent analysis were conducted by both general and case studies on new virulence factors or new virulence-associated genes that are crucial during the urinary tract infections (UTIs) process, including invasion, colonization, nutrition uptaking and population density control. Furthermore, miscellaneous RNAs collected in the reannotation are believed to contribute to the virulence of strain CFT073. The reannotation including the nucleotide data, the original RefSeq annotation, and all reannotated results is freely available via http://mech.ctb.pku.edu.cn/CFT073/.

Conclusion

As a result, the reannotation presents a more comprehensive picture of mechanisms of uropathogenicity of UPEC strain CFT073. The new genes change the view of its uropathogenicity in many respects, particularly by new genes in GI regions and new virulence-associated factors. The reannotation thus functions as an important source by providing new information about genomic structure and organization, and gene function. Moreover, we expect that the detailed analysis will facilitate the studies for exploration of novel virulence mechanisms and help guide experimental design.

Competition triggers plasmid-mediated enhancement of substrate utilisation in Pseudomonas putida

Competition between species plays a central role in the activity and structure of communities. Stable co-existence of diverse organisms in communities is thought to be fostered by individual tradeoffs and optimization of competitive strategies along resource gradients. Outside the laboratory, microbes exist as multispecies consortia, continuously interacting with one another and the environment. Survival and proliferation of a particular species is governed by its competitive fitness. Therefore, bacteria must be able to continuously sense their immediate environs for presence of competitors and prevailing conditions. Here we present results of our investigations on a novel competition sensing mechanism in the rhizosphere-inhabiting Pseudomonas putida KT2440, harbouring gfpmut3b-modified Kan(R) TOL plasmid. We monitored benzyl alcohol (BA) degradation rate, along with GFP expression profiling in mono species and dual species cultures. Interestingly, enhanced plasmid expression (monitored using GFP expression) and consequent BA degradation were observed in dual species consortia, irrespective of whether the competitor was a BA degrader (Pseudomonas aeruginosa) or a non-degrader (E. coli). Attempts at elucidation of the mechanistic aspects of induction indicated the role of physical interaction, but not of any diffusible compounds emanating from the competitors. This contention is supported by the observation that greater induction took place in presence of increasing number of competitors. Inert microspheres mimicking competitor cell size and concentration did not elicit any significant induction, further suggesting the role of physical cell-cell interaction. Furthermore, it was also established that cell wall compromised competitor had minimal induction capability. We conclude that P. putida harbouring pWW0 experience a competitive stress when grown as dual-species consortium, irrespective of the counterpart being BA degrader or not. The immediate effect of this stress is a marked increase in expression of TOL, leading to rapid utilization of the available carbon source and massive increase in its population density. The plausible mechanisms behind the phenomenon are hypothesised and practical implications are indicated and discussed.

Generational coexistence and ancestor's inhibition in bacterial populations

Generational coexistence in structured environments raises the possibility of a competition between ancestors and descendents. This type of kin competition, and in particular, the possibility that descendents might actively repress the ancestor's dominance, has been rarely considered in microbial evolutionary ecology. The recent discovery of the phenomenon of stationary-phase contact-dependent inhibition of bacterial ancestor cells by late descendents provides a new theoretical perspective to analyze intrapopulational evolutionary changes. The ancestor's inhibition effect might accelerate such changes, particularly when the descendents have acquired small adaptive advantages that are insufficient to rapidly displace the well-settled ancestors in a complex niche. Besides this effect of triggering selection of small genetic differences, the opportunities for intergenerational coexistence in bacteria, where ancestor's inhibition might occur, are reviewed in this work. A theoretical analysis is provided about the explanatory possibilities of the ancestor's inhibition effect in the controversies about intraspecific (in a large sense, including intrapopulational) genetic diversification, and the discontinuities observed in such processes, giving rise to the emergence of individualities and therefore differential units of selection.

Contact-dependent growth inhibition causes reversible metabolic downregulation in Escherichia coli

Contact-dependent growth inhibition (CDI) is a mechanism identified in Escherichia coli by which bacteria expressing two-partner secretion proteins encoded by cdiA and cdiB bind to BamA in the outer membranes of target cells and inhibit their growth. A third gene in the cluster, cdiI, encodes a small protein that is necessary and sufficient to confer immunity to CDI, thereby preventing cells expressing the cdiBA genes from inhibiting their own growth. In this study, the cdiI gene was placed under araBAD promoter control to modulate levels of the immunity protein and thereby induce CDI by removal of arabinose. This CDI autoinhibition system was used for metabolic analyses of a single population of E. coli cells undergoing CDI. Contact-inhibited cells showed altered cell morphology, including the presence of filaments. Notably, CDI was reversible, as evidenced by resumption of cell growth and normal cellular morphology following induction of the CdiI immunity protein. Recovery of cells from CDI also required an energy source. Cells undergoing CDI showed a significant, reversible downregulation of metabolic parameters, including aerobic respiration, proton motive force (Deltap), and steady-state ATP levels. It is unclear whether the decrease in respiration and/or Deltap is directly involved in growth inhibition, but a role for ATP in the CDI mechanism was ruled out using an atp mutant. Consistent with the observed decrease in Deltap, the phage shock response was induced in cells undergoing CDI but not in recovering cells, based on analysis of levels of pspA mRNA.

Network relationships of bacteria in a stable mixed culture

We investigated the network relationships of bacteria in a structurally stable mixed culture degrading cellulose. The mixed culture consists of four bacterial strains (a cellulose-degrading anaerobe [strain S], a saccharide-utilizing anaerobe [strain F], a peptide- and acetate-utilizing aerobe [strain 3] and a peptide-, glucose-, and ethanol-utilizing aerobe [strain 5]). Interspecies interactions were examined by analyzing the effects of culture filtrates on the growth of the other strains and by comprehensively analyzing population dynamics in the mixed-culture systems with all possible combinations of the four bacterial strains. The persistence of strain S depends on the effects of strain 5. However, strain 5 is a disadvantaged strain because strain 3 has bacteriocidal activity on strain 5. The extinction of strain 5 is indirectly prevented by strain F that suppresses the growth of strain 3. Although strain F directly has suppressive effects on the growth of strain S, strain F is essential for the persistence of strain S, considering the indirect effects (maintaining strain 5, which is essential for the survival of strain S, by inhibiting strain 3). These indirect relationships form a bacterial network in which all the relationships including suppressive effects were well balanced to maintain the structural stability. In addition to direct metabolite interactions, such kind of indirect relationships could have a great impact on microbial community structure in the natural environment.