Fitness of drug resistant Mycobacterium tuberculosis and the impact on the transmission among household contacts

Concordance of Drug-resistance Profiles Between Persons With Drug-resistant Tuberculosis and Their Household Contacts: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Household contacts of patients with drug-resistant tuberculosis (TB) are at high risk for being infected with Mycobacterium tuberculosis and for developing TB disease. To guide regimen composition for the empirical treatment of TB infection and disease in these household contacts, we estimated drug-resistance profile concordance between index patients with drug-resistant TB and their household contacts.

METHODS

We performed a systematic review and meta-analysis of studies published through 24 July 2018 that reported resistance profiles of drug-resistant TB index cases and secondary cases within their households. Using a random-effects meta-analysis, we estimated resistance profile concordance, defined as the percentage of secondary cases whose M. tuberculosis strains were resistant to the same drugs as strains from their index cases. We also estimated isoniazid/rifampin concordance, defined as whether index and secondary cases had identical susceptibilities for isoniazid and rifampin only.

RESULTS

We identified 33 eligible studies that evaluated resistance profile concordance between 484 secondary cases and their household index cases. Pooled resistance profile concordance was 54.3% (95% confidence interval [CI], 40.7-67.6%; I2 = 85%). Pooled isoniazid/rifampin concordance was 82.6% (95% CI, 72.3-90.9%; I2 = 73%). Concordance estimates were similar in a subanalysis of 16 studies from high-TB-burden countries. There were insufficient data to perform a subanalysis among pediatric secondary cases.

CONCLUSIONS

Household contacts of patients with drug-resistant TB should receive treatment for TB infection and disease that assumes that they, too, are infected with a drug-resistant M. tuberculosis strain. Whenever possible, drug susceptibility testing should be performed for secondary cases to optimize regimen composition.

Heterogeneous Streptomycin Resistance Level Among Mycobacterium tuberculosis Strains From the Same Transmission Cluster

Widespread and frequent resistance to the second-line tuberculosis (TB) medicine streptomycin, suggests ongoing transmission of low fitness cost streptomycin resistance mutations. To investigate this hypothesis, we studied a cohort of 681 individuals from a TB epidemic in Portugal. Whole-genome sequencing (WGS) analyses were combined with phenotypic growth studies in culture media and in mouse bone marrow derived macrophages. Streptomycin resistance was the most frequent resistance in the cohort accounting for 82.7% (n = 67) of the resistant Mycobacterium tuberculosis isolates. WGS of 149 clinical isolates identified 13 transmission clusters, including three clusters containing only streptomycin resistant isolates. The biggest cluster was formed by eight streptomycin resistant isolates with a maximum of five pairwise single nucleotide polymorphisms of difference. Interestingly, despite their genetic similarity, these isolates displayed different resistance levels to streptomycin, as measured both in culture media and in infected mouse bone marrow derived macrophages. The genetic bases underlying this phenotype are a combination of mutations in gid and other genes. This study suggests that specific streptomycin resistance mutations were transmitted in the cohort, with the resistant isolates evolving at the cluster level to allow low-to-high streptomycin resistance levels without a significative fitness cost. This is relevant not only to better understand transmission of streptomycin resistance in a clinical setting dominated by Lineage 4 M. tuberculosis infections, but mainly because it opens new prospects for the investigation of selection and spread of drug resistance in general.

Surveillance and characterization of drug-resistant Mycobacterium tuberculosis isolated in a reference hospital from Argentina during 8 years' period

Background

Argentina is considered a country with a middle tuberculosis (TB) incidence. However, according to the last national epidemiological report released in 2018, since 2013, the trends are steadily increasing. The aims of this study were to determine the drug-resistance (DR), multi-DR and extensively DR (MDR/XDR-TB), and rifampicin resistance (RIF-R) burden as a part of the local TB diagnosis (June 2010-August 2018); to detect the mutations associated to isoniazid (INH) and RIF-R and their geographical distribution; and to analyze the lineage relationship among the genetic patterns of the isolates circulating in the community.

Methods

Respiratory and extrapulmonary specimens were processed by Ziehl-Neelsen stain and cultured on specific media. Drug-susceptibility testing of isolates was performed by the MGIT 960 and a colorimetric micro-method. Mutations conferring DR were detected by Genotype and DNA sequencing.

Results

The study showed a DR-TB prevalence of approximately 20% of the isolated strains, while M/XDR-TB-and particularly RIF-R-affected more than 5.0% of the total amount of cases. DR geographical distribution revealed isolates carrying mutations in the inhA gene promoter region only constrained to three districts where it was also registered two same family relatives' cases with the infrequent rpoB S522 L/Q mutation. The fact that most DR/MDR-TB isolates were not grouped in genetic clusters suggested that these cases may mostly have occurred due to endogenous reactivation rather than recently transmission.

Conclusion

According to the obtained results, it would be convenient, in highly MDR-TB suspected individuals, to confirm phenotypically, the INH and RIF susceptibility detected by molecular tests.

Projecting the impact of variable MDR-TB transmission efficiency on long-term epidemic trends in South Africa and Vietnam

Whether multidrug-resistant tuberculosis (MDR-TB) is less transmissible than drug-susceptible (DS-)TB on a population level is uncertain. Even in the absence of a genetic fitness cost, the transmission potential of individuals with MDR-TB may vary by infectiousness, frequency of contact, or duration of disease. We used a compartmental model to project the progression of MDR-TB epidemics in South Africa and Vietnam under alternative assumptions about the relative transmission efficiency of MDR-TB. Specifically, we considered three scenarios: consistently lower transmission efficiency for MDR-TB than for DS-TB; equal transmission efficiency; and an initial deficit in the transmission efficiency of MDR-TB that closes over time. We calibrated these scenarios with data from drug resistance surveys and projected epidemic trends to 2040. The incidence of MDR-TB was projected to expand in most scenarios, but the degree of expansion depended greatly on the future transmission efficiency of MDR-TB. For example, by 2040, we projected absolute MDR-TB incidence to account for 5% (IQR: 4–9%) of incident TB in South Africa and 14% (IQR: 9–26%) in Vietnam assuming consistently lower MDR-TB transmission efficiency, versus 15% (IQR: 8–27%)and 41% (IQR: 23–62%), respectively, assuming shrinking transmission efficiency deficits. Given future uncertainty, specific responses to halt MDR-TB transmission should be prioritized.

Whole genome sequencing identifies bacterial factors affecting transmission of multidrug-resistant tuberculosis in a high-prevalence setting

Whole genome sequencing (WGS) can elucidate Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) transmission patterns but more data is needed to guide its use in high-burden settings. In a household-based TB transmissibility study in Peru, we identified a large MIRU-VNTR Mtb cluster (148 isolates) with a range of resistance phenotypes, and studied host and bacterial factors contributing to its spread. WGS was performed on 61 of the 148 isolates. We compared transmission link inference using epidemiological or genomic data and estimated the dates of emergence of the cluster and antimicrobial drug resistance (DR) acquisition events by generating a time-calibrated phylogeny. Using a set of 12,032 public Mtb genomes, we determined bacterial factors characterizing this cluster and under positive selection in other Mtb lineages. Four of the 61 isolates were distantly related and the remaining 57 isolates diverged ca. 1968 (95%HPD: 1945-1985). Isoniazid resistance arose once and rifampin resistance emerged subsequently at least three times. Emergence of other DR types occurred as recently as within the last year of sampling. We identified five cluster-defining SNPs potentially contributing to transmissibility. In conclusion, clusters (as defined by MIRU-VNTR typing) may be circulating for decades in a high-burden setting. WGS allows for an enhanced understanding of transmission, drug resistance, and bacterial fitness factors.

THE GROWTH RATE PHENOTYPIC PROPERTY OF MYCOBACTERIUM TUBERCULOSIS CLINICAL STRAINS: DEPENDENCE ON TUBERCULOSIS LOCALIZATION, TREATMENT, DRUG SUSCEPTIBILITY

The phenotypic properties of the M. tuberculosis strains obtained from patients with pulmonary or extra-pulmonary tuberculosis are  determined by a complex set of factors: the genetic characteristics  of the pathogen, its ability to adapt in vivo and in vitro, the influence of the host’s immune system and chemotherapy. The growth rate as  the phenotypic property is the most accessible for the study of the  host-pathogen relationships at the level of host/strain population  interactions. The aim of the study is to assess in vitro of the growth  rate of M. tuberculosis strains isolated from patients with pulmonary  and extra-pulmonary tuberculosis: untreated and treated (with  surgical and non-surgical treatment) and also sensitive and resistant isolates in comparison with the reference strain H37Rv. To estimate  the growth rate of 116 clinical isolates we have used the modified  method originally developed by von Groll and co-authors: to get the  bacteria growth curve the fluorescence intensity of growing strains  (with indicator resazurin) has been measured daily for 8 days in 96- well plate. The growth rate is determined as the slope of the growth  curve. The mean values of the growth rate have been calculated in  the following groups of patients: 1 — untreated patients with  pulmonary tuberculosis (PT), respiratory material; 2 — non-surgical  treated PT patients, respiratory material; 3 — surgical treated PT  patients (mainly with chronic and hyperchronic process), respiratory  material; 4 — patients like in 3rd group, surgical material; 5 — bone  and joint tuberculosis (BJT), surgical material. In addition, groups of  sensitive and resistant strains have been examined, but there are no  significant differences in growth rates. It has been obtained that  the growth rate of strains isolated from the PT patients is higher than in BJT patients: it can be explained less favorable  conditions for the pathogen vegetation in the BJT. In the case of a  closed tuberculous lesion where the pathogen transmission to  another host is impossible, then the selection of strains with the  property to survive in the tissues of the osteoarticular system is  impossible too, therefor it should be observed only an adaptation of  the pathogen strain population to the individual host. The growth  rate of isolates from untreated PT patients is higher than that of the  treated ones. Comparison of the growth parameters of only MDR  strains 1–5 groups to eliminate the influence of the  sensitivity/resistance has resulted in the same conclusions. We  suggest that the decrease in the growth rate of strains from the  treated PT patients is in not only result of the treatment, but also is  conditioned by adaptation of the pathogen to its external  environment, which is the internal environment of the  macroorganism. To confirm this assumption, the bacterial load of  1,083 diagnostic specimens grouped in a similar manner has been  estimated, taking into account only MDR/XDR strains. In the group  of treated patients the frequency of high bacterial load (CFU ≥ 100)  reached 52.5–63.8% that shows the conserved fitness of bacteria in  such patients. The mean values of the growth rate of the strain  H37Rv non-adapted to the macroorganism (due to numerous  passages on artificial media) are higher than in all groups of clinical  strains. Thus, heterogeneity of phenotypic properties of M.  tuberculosis clinical strains on the basis of growth rate has been  obtained. The growth rate of M. tuberculosis clinical strains is  depended on the tuberculosis localization (PT, BJT) and on the joint  effect of patient treatment and pathogen adaptation to the host. 

Strategies for halting the rise of multidrug resistant TB epidemics: assessing the effect of early case detection and isolation

Background

The increasing rates of multidrug resistant TB (MDR-TB) have posed the question of whether control programs under enhanced directly observed treatment, short-course (DOTS-Plus) are sufficient or implemented optimally. Despite enhanced efforts on early case detection and improved treatment regimens, direct transmission of MDR-TB remains a major hurdle for global TB control.

Methods

We developed an agent-based simulation model of TB dynamics to evaluate the effect of transmission reduction measures on the incidence of MDR-TB. We implemented a 15-day isolation period following the start of treatment in active TB cases. The model was parameterized with the latest estimates derived from the published literature.

Results

We found that if high rates (over 90%) of TB case identification are achieved within 4 weeks of developing active TB, then a 15-day patient isolation strategy with 50% effectiveness in interrupting disease transmission leads to 10% reduction in the incidence of MDR-TB over 10 years. If transmission is fully prevented, the rise of MDR-TB can be halted within 10 years, but the temporal reduction of MDR-TB incidence remains below 20% in this period.

Conclusions

The impact of transmission reduction measures on the TB incidence depends critically on the rates and timelines of case identification. The high costs and adverse effects associated with MDR-TB treatment warrant increased efforts and investments on measures that can interrupt direct transmission through early case detection.

Factors Associated with Missed Detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis by Automated BACTEC MGIT 960 System

Despite the demonstration of excellent performance, mycobacterial growth in BACTEC MGIT 960 can go undetected. The aim of this study was to investigate the prevalence of “false-negative” culture sample in Beijing and the potential factors associated with the detection failures by MGIT 960. Of the 577 sputum samples tested, 141 (24.4%) were culture-positive for mycobacteria, of which 133 (94.3%) were automatically determined by MGIT 960 system and 8 (5.7%) were positive for visual growth (false negative by MGIT). Statistical analysis showed that positive grade of specimen had no influence on the false-negative rate by MGIT 960 system (χ² = 2.207, P = 0.820). In addition, the mean time to detection (TTD) was 241.4 (range: 224–261) hours for false-negative group and 186.8 (range: 173–199) hours for positive group. The difference in TTD between false-negative and positive groups was statistically significant (P < 0.01). In conclusion, our data demonstrate that the automatic MGIT missed a small portion of bacteriological mycobacterial patients. In addition, the poor growth rate rather than the low grade of AFB smear is associated with the detection failure by MGIT. Our findings highlight the notion that manual inspection for all instrument-negative MGIT tubes will bring about considerable benefit to patients and clinicians.