Long-term persistence of vaccination and HAART to human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)

Evaluating the efficacy of therapeutic HIV vaccines through analytical treatment interruptions

INTRODUCTION

The development of an effective therapeutic HIV vaccine that induces immunologic control of viral replication, thereby eliminating or reducing the need for antiretroviral therapy (ART), would be of great value. Besides the obvious challenges of developing a therapeutic vaccine that would generate effective, sustained anti-HIV immunity in infected individuals is the issue of how to best assess the efficacy of vaccine candidates.

DISCUSSION

This review discusses the various outcome measures assessed in therapeutic HIV vaccine clinical trials involving individuals receiving suppressive ART, with a particular focus on the role of analytical treatment interruption (ATI) as a way to assess the virologic control induced by an immunotherapy. This strategy is critical given that there are otherwise no readily available measures to determine the ability of a vaccine-induced immune response to effectively control HIV replication. The various outcome measures that have been used to assess vaccine efficacy in published therapeutic HIV vaccine clinical trials will also be discussed. Outcome measures have included the kinetics of viral rebound, the new viral set point and changes in the size of the viral reservoir. Clinically relevant outcomes such as the CD4 decline, the time to resume therapy or the time to meet the criterion to resume therapy, the proportion of participants who resume therapy and/or the development of clinical symptoms such as acute retroviral syndrome are also measures of vaccine efficacy.

CONCLUSIONS

Given the lack of consistency between therapeutic HIV vaccine trials in how efficacy is assessed, comparing vaccines has been difficult. It would, therefore, be beneficial to determine the most clinically relevant measure for use in future studies. Other recommendations for future clinical trials also include studying compartments in addition to blood and replacing ATIs with single-copy assays in situations in which the use of an ATI is not ideal.

Immune interventions in HIV infection

Immune-based therapy (IBT) interventions have found a window of opportunity within some limitations of the otherwise successful combined antiretroviral therapy (cART). Two major paradigms drove immunotherapeutic research to combat human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection. First, IBTs were proposed either to help restore CD4(+) T-cell counts in cases of therapeutic failures with cytokines, interleukin-2 (IL-2) or IL-7, or to better control HIV and disease progression during treatment interruptions with anti-HIV therapeutic candidate vaccines. The most widely used candidates were HIV-recombinant live vector-based alone or combined with other vaccine compounds and dendritic cell (DC) therapies. A more recent and current paradigm aims at achieving HIV cure by combining IBT with cART using either cytokines to reactivate virus production in latently infected cells and/or therapeutic immunization to boost HIV-specific immunity in a 'shock and kill' strategy. This review summarizes the rationale, hopes, and mechanisms of successes and failures of these cytokine-based and vaccine-based immune interventions. Results from these first series of IBTs have been so far somewhat disappointing in terms of clinical relevance, but have provided lessons that are discussed in light of the future combined strategies to be developed toward an HIV cure.

Human Immunodeficiency Virus-Type 1 Specific Cellular Immunity in Chronic Infected Patients on Prolonged Highly Active Antiretroviral Treatment and on Structured Treatment Interruption

We have followed 15 HIV-1 chronically infected patients during prolonged highly active antiretroviral treatment (HAART) and subsequent long term structured treatment interruption (STI). We analyzed Nef, Tat, and p24 specific cellular immunity using IFN-gamma enzyme-linked immunospot assays and T cell proliferation assays. Eight HAART patients showed IFN-gamma responses to at least one antigen, but no positive responses were seen during STI. We observed retained or increased p24 specific IFN-gamma responses in most patients during HAART with viral suppression. These results showed persisting HIV-1 specific cellular immunity during HAART; however, in prolonged STI with viral rebound this immunity declined.

Vaccination against drug resistance in HIV infection

HIV-1 resistance to currently employed antiretroviral drugs and drug-associated adverse reactions and toxicity point to a need for additional measures to control HIV-1 replication in HIV-infected patients. The immune system of HIV-infected individuals mount an immune response against the regions harboring drug-resistance mutations, sometimes stronger than that against the parental wild-type sequences. A potent cross-reactive immune response against drug-resistant pol proteins can suppress the replication of drug-escaping HIV. This suggests the possibility for a vaccination against existing and anticipated drug-resistant HIV variants. If successful, therapeutic vaccines against drug resistance would ease the therapeutic modalities and limit the spread of drug-resistant HIV. A better understanding of the complex interactions between patterns of drug-resistance mutations, immune responses against these mutations and their antigen presentation by particular human lymphocyte antigen alleles could help to tailor these vaccines after new drugs/new mutations. In this review, we describe the developments in the field of immunization against mutations conferring drug resistance and evaluate their prospects for human vaccination.

Greater viral rebound and reduced time to resume antiretroviral therapy after therapeutic immunization with the ALVAC-HIV vaccine (vCP1452)

OBJECTIVE

Evaluate immunogenicity and clinical efficacy of two immunization strategies with the ALVAC-HIV-recombinant canarypox vaccine (vCP1452) in treated HIV-infected patients.

DESIGN

Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, phase II study of vCP1452 immunization in chronically HIV-infected patients on therapy with CD4 T-cell count more than 350 cells/microl, CD4 nadir less than 400 cells/microl and pHIV-RNA less than 400 copies/ml. Patients were equally randomized to four injections at weeks 0, 4, 8, 20; three injections at weeks 4, 8, 20; and placebo. The primary endpoint was vaccine immunogenicity at week 24 measured by enzyme-linked immunospot-interferon-gamma against the HIV-gag-reverse transcriptase-nef vaccine sequences. Secondary endpoints included time to treatment resumption and viral quantitation following treatment interruption at week 24. Criteria to resume therapy included CD4 T-cell count decline less than 250 cells/microl or 50% decrease from baseline or pHIV-RNA more than 50,000 copies/ml.

RESULTS

Sixty-five patients enrolled. Changes from baseline in HIV-specific T cells in the four injection arms (+480 spot-forming cells/M-peripheral blood mononuclear cell) were significant compared to placebo (+8; P = 0.014), but not in the three injection arms (+322). The week 36 pHIV-RNA (log10 copies/ml) after treatment interruption was higher in the four (4.71; P = 0.023) and three (4.82; P = 0.009) injection arms compared to placebo (4.40). Percentages of patients reaching treatment resumption criteria by week 48 were 74, 55 and 23% in the three respective arms (P = 0.013). Two independent factors influenced time to therapy resumption: immunization (hazards ratio = 2.7, P = 0.048 for three injections; hazards ratio = 4.1, P = 0.003 for four injections) and CD4 nadir (hazards ratio = 0.4, P = 0.002).

CONCLUSIONS

Significant immunogenicity was induced by vCP1452; however, this strategy was independently associated with a shorter time to resume therapy and higher viral rebound.

Therapeutic immunization for HIV

Vaccines have entered into human clinical trials against infectious diseases and as therapies against cancer. The HIV virus establishes a latent infection at a very early stage and the T cell memory of the infected patient is rapidly destroyed. However, results of immunotherapy after DNA and protein immunization show that vaccine-induced immune responses might be present for a long period of time. Patients subjected to therapeutic immunization appear to do well, and to have a small immunological advantage, which, however, will have to be improved. The vaccine therapy should start early, while adequate reservoirs of appropriate T helper cells are available and still inducible. The DNA vaccines induce a relatively long-lived immunological memory, and gene-based immunization is effective in inducing cytotoxic CD8(+) T cells and CD4+ helper cells. Protein vaccines, on the other hand, primarily give T cell help. It thus appears that DNA and protein approaches to HIV immunization complement each other. A surprisingly broad reactivity to peptides from different subtypes of HIV was identified in individuals infected with several subtypes of HIV.

Peptide-loaded dendritic-cell vaccination followed by treatment interruption for chronic HIV-1 infection: a phase 1 trial

Immune response enhanced by therapeutic HIV-1 vaccine may control viral proliferation after discontinuation of highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART). Although which strategies for therapeutic vaccination are feasible remains controversial, application of dendritic cells (DCs) as a vaccine adjuvant represents a promising approach to improving deteriorated immune function in HIV-1-infected individuals. The safety and efficacy of DC-based vaccine loaded with HIV-1-derived cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) peptides were thus investigated in this study. Autologous DCs loaded with seven CTL peptides with HLA-A*2402 restriction were immunized to four HIV-1-infected individuals under HAART. In terms of safety, peptide-loaded DCs were well tolerated, and only mild local and general symptoms were observed during vaccine administration. ELISPOT assays to detect IFN-gamma production in CD8(+) lymphocytes revealed a limited breadth of responses to immunized peptides in two of four participants, but no response in the remaining two participants. Differences in immunological response might be attributable to the fact that responders displayed higher nadir CD4 counts before starting HAART and were immunized with a larger number of DCs per reactive peptide than non-responders. Discontinuation of HAART after vaccination failed to lower viral set points compared to those before starting HAART. This early outcome warrants further exploration to elucidate the therapeutic value of vaccination with DCs in HIV-1 infection.

Elevated levels of serum perforin in chronic HIV-1 and acute SIV/SHIV infection

The impaired functional activity of cytotoxic T lymphocytes and natural killer cells during HIV-1 infection has recently been attributed to decreased intracellular levels of perforin and granzyme B. In sera from individuals chronically infected with HIV-1 we report increased levels of extracellular perforin compared with uninfected individuals. Increased perforin was also observed during experimental SIV/SHIV infection. The combination of reduced intracellular perforin levels and an increased serum level indicates that HIV infection induces aberrant perforin secretion.

Reduced viral burden amongst high responder patients following HIV-1 p24 peptide-based therapeutic immunization

We have previously shown that HIV p24-like peptides (Vacc-4x) via activation of skin dendritic cells induced immune responses in 90% of HIV patients on highly active antiretroviral treatment (HAART). These patients (n=38) were here subjected to a final 14-week interruption of HAART. Patients with the highest delayed type hypersensitivity (DTH) responses to Vacc-4x-peptides before treatment interruption tended to achieve lower actual HIV RNA levels at the end of the study compared to Vacc-4x DTH low-responders (p=0.08) and significantly so in terms of viral loads relative to their individual pre-HAART HIV RNA set-points (p=0.04). CD4+ lymphocyte counts were maintained only among DTH high responders but decreased in the other patients during recurrent viremia (p</=0.02). No other pre-study differences in HIV history or p24-responses were found.

Therapeutic role of CD8+ T cells in HIV-1 infection: targets and suppressors of viral replication

CD8+ T cells are pivotal in controlling viral replication in HIV-1-infected subjects. However, in chronic infection, HIV-1-specific CD8+ T cells fail to adequately control infection, presenting incomplete maturation and more severe functional impairment with advanced disease. Accumulating evidence has shown that CD8+ T cells can also be productively infected by HIV-1. Whether HIV-1 infection of CD8+ T lymphocytes impacts on their antiviral activity remains to be determined. This review explores the potential mechanisms of HIV-1 infection of CD8+ T cells, its likely contribution to the immunopathogenesis of HIV-1 infection and potential therapeutic interventions.

Therapeutic HIV vaccines: An update

The goal of therapeutic immunization in HIV infection is to induce strong and sustained immune responses against HIV. Several arguments suggest that the immune system may contain HIV replication in the long term before declining. The potency on new antiviral regimens in clinic has provided an opportunity to improve the control of the virus replication by the immune system. In clinical terms, this might allow patients to delay or to stop antiviral therapy and to minimize the duration of the exposition to antiviral drugs.

Evaluating therapeutic vaccines in patients infected with HIV

Long-term survival of HIV infection can mean decades of treatment for a patient, with major side effects and costs that limit their efficacy and accessibility. Although antiretroviral therapy remains the only standard of care, alternative therapeutic strategies must be found to ensure efficient and safe clinical management of the disease in the long term. Therapeutic immunization against HIV might be a significant approach to enhancing immune control of the virus and limiting disease progression and thus the requirement for medication. Several anti-HIV vaccines are currently being evaluated in attempts to prolong periods of treatment interruption in HIV patients. The design and end-points of clinical trials, and the clinical settings in which these new strategies should be evaluated and will be of benefit, have yet to be defined and are the focus of this review.