Responses of methanotrophic activity, community and EPS production to CH4 and O2 concentrations in waste biocover soils

Iron oxides act as an alternative electron acceptor for aerobic methanotrophs in anoxic lake sediments

Conventional aerobic CH₄-oxidizing bacteria (MOB) are frequently detected in anoxic environments, but their survival strategy and ecological contribution are still enigmatic. Here we explore the role of MOB in enrichment cultures under O₂ gradients and an iron-rich lake sediment in situ by combining microbiological and geochemical techniques. We found that enriched MOB consortium used ferric oxides as alternative electron acceptors for oxidizing CH₄ with the help of riboflavin when O₂ was unavailable. Within the MOB consortium, MOB transformed CH₄ to low molecular weight organic matter such as acetate for consortium bacteria as a carbon source, while the latter secrete riboflavin to facilitate extracellular electron transfer (EET). Iron reduction coupled to CH₄ oxidation mediated by the MOB consortium was also demonstrated in situ, reducing 40.3% of the CH₄ emission in the studied lake sediment. Our study indicates how MOBs survive under anoxia and expands the knowledge of this previously overlooked CH₄ sink in iron-rich sediments.

Characterization of methanotrophic community and activity in landfill cover soils under dimethyl sulfide stress

Landfill cover soil is the environmental interface between landfills and the atmosphere and plays an important role in mitigating CH₄ emission from landfills. Here, stable isotope probing microcosms with CH₄ or CH₄ and dimethyl sulfide (DMS) were carried out to characterize activity and community structure of methanotrophs in landfill cover soils under DMS stress. The CH₄ oxidation activity in the landfill cover soils was not obviously influenced at the DMS concentration of 0.05%, while it was inhibited at the DMS concentrations of 0.1% and 0.2%. DMS-S was mainly oxidized to sulfate (SO₄^2-) in the landfill cover soils. In the landfill cover soils, DMS could inhibit the expression of bacteria and decrease the abundances of pmoA and mmoX genes, while it could prompt the expression of pmoA and mmoX genes. γ-Proteobacteria methanotrophs including Methylocaldum, Methylobacter, Crenothrix and unclassified Methylococcaceae and α-Proteobacteria methanotrophs Methylocystis dominated in assimilating CH₄ in the landfill cover soils. Of them, Methylobacter and Crenothrix had strong tolerance to DMS or DMS could promote the growth and activity of Methylobacter and Crenothrix, while Methylocaldum had weak tolerance to DMS and showed an inhibitory effect. Metagenomic analyses showed that methanotrophs had the genes of methanethiol oxidation and could metabolize CH₄ and methanethiol simultaneously in the landfill cover soils. These findings suggested that methanotrophs might metabolize sulfur compounds in the landfill cover soils, which may provide the potential application in engineering for co-removal of CH₄ and sulfur compounds.

Synergy effects of Methylomonas koyamae and Hyphomicrobium methylovorum under methanethiol stress

Methanotrophs are able to metabolize volatile organic sulfur compounds (VOSCs), excrete organic carbon during CH₄ oxidation, and influence microbial community structure and function of the ecosystem. In return, microbial community structure and environmental factors can affect the growth metabolism of methanotrophs. In this study, Methylomonas koyamae and Hyphomicrobium methylovorum were used for model organisms, and methanethiol (MT) was chosen for a typical VOSC to investigate the synergy effects under VOSC stress. The results showed that when Hyphomicrobium methylovorum was co-cultured with Methylomonas koyamae in the medium with CH₄ used as the carbon source, the co-culture had better MT tolerance relative to Methylomonas koyamae and oxidized all CH₄ within 120 h, even at the initial MT concentration of 2000 mg m^-3. The optimal co-culture ratios of Methylomonas koyamae to Hyphomicrobium methylovorum were 4:1-12:1. Although MT could be converted spontaneously to dimethyl disulfide (DMDS), H₂S, and CS₂ in air, faster losses of MT, DMDS, H₂S, and CS₂ were observed in each strain mono-culture and the co-culture. Compared with Hyphomicrobium methylovorum, MT was degraded more quickly in the Methylomonas koyamae culture. During the co-culture, the CH₄ oxidation process of Methylomonas koyamae could provide carbon and energy sources for the growth of Hyphomicrobium methylovorum, while Hyphomicrobium methylovorum oxidized MT to help Methylomonas koyamae detoxify. These findings are helpful to understand the synergy effects of Methylomonas koyamae and Hyphomicrobium methylovorum under MT stress and enrich the role of methanotrophs in the sulfur biogeochemical cycle. KEY POINTS: • The co-culture of Methylomonas and Hyphomicrobium has better tolerance to CH₃SH. • Methylomonas can provide carbon sources for the growth of Hyphomicrobium. • The co-culture of Methylomonas and Hyphomicrobium enhances the removal of CH₄ and CH₃SH.

CS2 increasing CH4-derived carbon emissions and active microbial diversity in lake sediments

Lakes are important methane (CH₄) sources to the atmosphere, especially eutrophic lakes with cyanobacterial blooms accompanied by volatile sulfur compound (VSC) emissions. CH₄ oxidation is a key strategy to mitigate CH₄ emission from lakes. In this study, we characterized the fate of CH₄-derived carbon and active microbial communities in lake sediments with CS₂ used as a typical VSC, based on the investigation of CH₄ and VSC fluxes from Meiliang Bay in Lake Taihu. Stable isotope probing microcosm incubation showed that the efficiency of CH₄-derived carbon incorporated into organic matter was 21.1% in the sediment with CS₂ existence, which was lower than that without CS₂ (27.3%). SO₄^2--S was the main product of CS₂ oxidation under aerobic condition, accounting for 59.3-62.7% of the input CS₂-S. CS₂ and CH₄ coexistence led to a decrease of methanotroph and methylotroph abundances and stimulated the production of extracellular polymeric substances. CS₂ and its metabolites including total sulfur, SO₄^2- and acid volatile sulfur acted as the main drivers influencing the active microbial community structure in the sediments. Compared with α-proteobacteria methanotrophs, γ-proteobacteria methanotrophs Methylomicrobium, Methylomonas, Crenothrix and Methylosarcina were more dominant in the sediments. CH₄-derived carbon mainly flowed into methylotrophs in the first stage. With CH₄ consumption, more CH₄-derived carbon flowed into non-methylotrophs. CS₂ could prompt more CH₄-derived carbon flowing into non-methanotrophs and non-methylotrophs, such as sulfur-metabolizing bacteria. These findings can help elucidate the influence of VSCs on microorganisms and provide insights to carbon fluxes from eutrophic lake systems.

Effect of mixed primary and secondary sludge for two-stage anaerobic digestion (AD)

As an energy-efficient and eco-friendly sludge treatment process, two-stage anaerobic digestion (AD) is widely employed to recovery biomass energy from waste sludge. However, the effect of primary and secondary sludge for two-stage AD was not clear. In this study, two-stage AD of mixed sludge in different volume ratio was investigated. The maximum cumulative H₂ yield (100.5 ml) and CH₄ yield (2643.6 ml) were obtained in volume ratio of 1:3 (primary sludge: secondary sludge). In two-phase AD, mixed sludge could induce positive effect on both organics releasing in extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) and the utilization of volatile fatty acids (VFAs). By investigating the compositional characteristics of dissolved organic matters (DOM) through excitation-emission matrix (EEM) coupling with fluorescence regional integration (FRI), it revealed more degradable substances utilization in mixture of sludge. Results from this work suggest that two-phase AD with mixed sludge is efficient for renewable energy recovery.

Validation and optimization of key biochar properties through iron modification for improving the methane oxidation capacity of landfill cover soil

Knowledge of various BC properties in stimulating the methane (CH₄) oxidation capacity of landfill cover soil (LCS) is still limited, restricting the optimization of BC performance. To validate key BC properties and seek a feasible way for enhancing BC performance, this study prepared BCs with distinctly varying characteristics through iron (Fe) modification. Then, batch incubation experiments under different CH₄ and oxygen concentrations were conducted. Pore volume, cation exchange capacity (CEC), and surface area of BC collectively accounted for 78.5% of the variances in the microbial community structures, with pore volume being the most important factor. These correlated well with the differences in the CH₄ oxidation capacities among the different BC-amended LCS. At a low ratio of 15% (v/v) in LCS, BCs' pH not affected their performance but homogeneity could be a limiting factor. Fe modification proved a promising approach to more efficiently improve the three key BC properties (especially pore volume) and thus optimize BC performance than increasing pyrolysis temperature did. Fe-modified BCs encouraged a bacterial consortium (methanotroph, methylotrophs, and nitrogen-fixing bacteria) in the soil with significantly improved CH₄ oxidation capacities by up to 26%-74% compared to that of pristine BC.

Stable-isotopic and metagenomic analyses reveal metabolic and microbial link of aerobic methane oxidation coupled to denitrification at different O2 levels

Aerobic methane (CH₄) oxidation coupled to denitrification (AME-D) can not only mitigate CH₄ emission into the atmosphere, but also potentially alleviate nitrogen pollution in surface waters and engineered ecosystems, and it has attracted substantial research interest. O₂ concentration plays a key role in AME-D, yet little is understood about how it impacts microbial interactions. Here, we applied isotopically labeled K¹⁵NO₃ and ¹³CH₄ and metagenomic analyses to investigate the metabolic and microbial link of AME-D at different O₂ levels. Among the four experimental O₂ levels of 21%,10%, 5% and 2.5% and a CH₄ concentration of 8% (i.e., the O₂/CH₄ ratios of 2.62, 1.26, 0.63 and 0.31), the highest NO₃^--N removal occurred in the AME-D system incubated at the O₂ concentration of 10%. Methanol and acetate may serve as the trophic linkage between aerobic methanotrophs and denitrifers in the AME-D systems. Methylotrophs including Methylophilus, Methylovorus, Methyloversatilis and Methylotenera were abundant under the O₂-sufficient condition with the O₂ concentration of 21%, while denitrifiers such as Azoarcus, Thauera and Thiobacillus dominated in the O₂-limited environment with the O₂ concentration of 10%. The competition of denitrifiers and methylotrophs in the AME-D system for CH₄-derived carbon, such as methanol and acetate, might be influenced by chemotactic responses. More methane-derived carbon flowed into methylotrophs under the O₂-sufficient condition, while more methane-derived carbon was used for denitrification in the O₂-limited environment. These findings can aid in evaluating the distribution and contribution of AME-D and in developing strategies for mitigating CH₄ emission and nitrogen pollution in natural and engineered ecosystems.

Sulfide restrains the growth of Methylocapsa acidiphila converting renewable biogas to single cell protein

Methane-oxidizing bacteria (MOB) that can use biogas and recycled nitrogen from wastewater as a sustainable feedstock for single cell protein (SCP) synthesis are receiving increasing attention. Though promising, limited knowledge is available on the alternative strains especially the ones that can tolerant to strict environments such as acidic conditions. Furthermore, how would the hydrogen sulfide affect the MOB (especially the alternative strains) for SCP synthesis when crude biogas is used as feedstock is still unknown. In this study, the capability of an acidic-tolerant methanotrophic bacterium Methylocapsa acidiphila for SCP production using raw biogas and the associated inhibitory effect of sulfide on the bioconversion was for the first time investigated. Results showed that the inhibitory effect of sulfide on the growth of M. acidiphila was observed starting from 8.13 mg L^-1 Na₂S (equivalent to approximately 1000 ppm of H₂S in crude biogas). The total amino acid content in the dry biomass decreased more than two times due to sulfide inhibition compared with the control samples without the presence of sulfide (585.96 mg/g dry biomass), while the proportion of essential amino acids in the total amino acid was not affected when the concentration of Na₂S was lower than 5.73 mg L^-1. The performance of M. acidiphila in a sulfide-rich environment was further studied at different operational conditions. The feeding gas with a CH₄/O₂ ratio of 6:4 could help to alleviate the sulfide inhibition, compared with other ratios (4:6 and 8:2). Moreover, the sequential supply of the feed gas could also alleviate sulfide inhibition. In addition, the MOB's growth rate was higher when applying a higher mixing rate of 120 rpm, compared with 70 rpm and 0, due to a better gas-liquid mass transfer. The inoculum size of 20% and 10% resulted in a faster growth rate compared with the 5%. Furthermore, M. acidiphila could assimilate either NH₄⁺ or NO₃^- as nitrogen source with a similar growth rate, giving it the potential to recycle nitrogen from a wide range of wastewaters. The results will not only create new knowledge for better understanding the role of hydrogen sulfide in the assimilation of raw biogas by acid-tolerant M. acidiphila but also provide technical insights into the development of an efficient and robust process for the waste-to-protein conversion.

Effects of oxygen tension on the microbial community and functional gene expression of aerobic methane oxidation coupled to denitrification systems

Aerobic CH₄ oxidation coupled to denitrification (AME-D) can not only mitigate the emission of greenhouse gas (e.g., CH₄) to the atmosphere, but also reduce NO₃^- and/or NO₂^- and alleviate nitrogen pollution. The effects of O₂ tension on the community and functional gene expression of methanotrophs and denitrifiers were investigated in this study. Although higher CH₄ oxidation occurred in the AME-D system with an initial O₂ concentration of 21% (i.e., the O₂-sufficient condition), more NO₃^--N was removed at the initial O₂ concentration of 10% (i.e., the O₂-limited environment). Type I methanotrophs, including Methylocaldum, Methylobacter, Methylococcus, Methylomonas, and Methylomicrobium, and type II methanotrophs, including Methylocystis and Methylosinus, dominated in the AME-D systems. Compared with type II methanotrophs, type I methanotrophs were more abundant in the AME-D systems. Proteobacteria and Actinobacteria were the main denitrifiers in the AME-D systems, and their compositions varied with the O₂ tension. Quantitative PCR of the pmoA, nirS, and 16S rRNA genes showed that methanotrophs and denitrifiers were the main microorganisms in the AME-D systems, accounting for 46.4% and 24.1% in the O₂-limited environment, respectively. However, the relative transcripts of the functional genes including pmoA, mmoX, nirK, nirS, and norZ were all less than 1%, especially the functional genes involved in denitrification under the O₂-sufficient condition, likely due to the majority of the denitrifiers being dormant or even nonviable. These findings indicated that an optimal O₂ concentration should be used to optimize the activity and functional gene expression of aerobic methanotrophs and denitrifiers in AME-D systems.

Low O2 level enhances CH4-derived carbon flow into microbial communities in landfill cover soils

CH₄ oxidation in landfill cover soils plays a significant role in mitigating CH₄ release to the atmosphere. Oxygen availability and the presence of co-contaminants are potentially important factors affecting CH₄ oxidation rate and the fate of CH₄-derived carbon. In this study, microbial populations that oxidize CH₄ and the subsequent conversion of CH₄-derived carbon into CO₂, soil organic C and biomass C were investigated in landfill cover soils at two O₂ tensions, i.e., O₂ concentrations of 21% ("sufficient") and 2.5% ("limited") with and without toluene. CH₄-derived carbon was primarily converted into CO₂ and soil organic C in the landfill cover soils, accounting for more than 80% of CH₄ oxidized. Under the O₂-sufficient condition, 52.9%-59.6% of CH₄-derived carbon was converted into CO₂ (CE_CO2-C), and 29.1%-39.3% was converted into soil organic C (CE_organic-C). A higher CE_organic-C and lower CE_CO2-C occurred in the O₂-limited environment, relative to the O₂-sufficient condition. With the addition of toluene, the carbon conversion efficiency of CH₄ into biomass C and organic C increased slightly, especially in the O₂-limited environment. A more complex microbial network was involved in CH₄ assimilation in the O₂-limited environment than under the O₂-sufficient condition. DNA-based stable isotope probing of the community with ¹³CH₄ revealed that Methylocaldum and Methylosarcina had a higher relative growth rate than other type I methanotrophs in the landfill cover soils, especially at the low O₂ concentration, while Methylosinus was more abundant in the treatment with both the high O₂ concentration and toluene. These results indicated that O₂-limited environments could prompt more CH₄-derived carbon to be deposited into soils in the form of biomass C and organic C, thereby enhancing the contribution of CH₄-derived carbon to soil community biomass and functionality of landfill cover soils (i.e. reduction of CO₂ emission).

Enrichments of methanotrophic-heterotrophic cultures with high poly-β-hydroxybutyrate (PHB) accumulation capacities

Methanotrophic-heterotrophic communities were selectively enriched from sewage sludge to obtain a mixed culture with high levels of poly-β-hydroxybutyrate (PHB) accumulation capacity from methane. Methane was used as the carbon source, N₂ as sole nitrogen source, and oxygen and Cu content were varied. Copper proved essential for PHB synthesis. All cultures enriched with Cu could accumulate high content of PHB (43.2%-45.9%), while only small amounts of PHB were accumulated by cultures enriched without Cu (11.9%-17.5%). Batch assays revealed that communities grown with Cu and a higher O₂ content synthesized more PHB, which had a wider optimal CH₄:O₂ range and produced a high PHB content (48.7%) even though in the presence of N₂. In all methanotrophic-heterotrophic communities, both methanotrophic and heterotrophic populations showed the ability to accumulate PHB. Although methane was added as the sole carbon source, heterotrophs dominated with abundances between 77.2% and 85.6%. All methanotrophs detected belonged to type II genera, which formed stable communities with heterotrophs of different PHB production capacities.

Technologies for the bioconversion of methane into more valuable products

Methane, with a global warming potential twenty five times higher than that of CO₂ is the second most important greenhouse gas emitted nowadays. Its bioconversion into microbial molecules with a high retail value in the industry offers a potential cost-efficient and environmentally friendly solution for mitigating anthropogenic diluted CH₄-laden streams. Methane bio-refinery for the production of different compounds such as ectoine, feed proteins, biofuels, bioplastics and polysaccharides, apart from new bioproducts characteristic of methanotrophic bacteria, has been recently tested in discontinuous and continuous bioreactors with promising results. This review constitutes a critical discussion about the state-of-the-art of the potential and research niches of biotechnologies applied in a CH₄ biorefinery approach.

Response of methanotrophic activity to extracellular polymeric substance production and its influencing factors

The accumulation of extracellular polymeric substance (EPS) is speculated to be related with the decrease of CH₄ oxidation rate after a peak in long-term laboratory landfill covers and biofilters. However, few data have been reported about EPS production of methanotrophs and its feedback effects on methanotrophic activity. In this study, Methylosinus sporium was used asa model methanotroph to investigate EPS production and its influencing factors during CH₄ oxidation. The results showed that methanotrophs could secret EPS into the habits during CH₄ oxidation and had a negative feedback effect on CH₄ oxidation. The EPS amount fitted well with the CH₄ oxidation activity with the exponential model. The environmental factors such as pH, temperature, CH₄, O₂, NO₃^--N and NH₄⁺-N could affect the EPS production of methanotrophs. When pH, temperature, CH₄, O₂ and N concentrations (including NO₃^--N and NH₄⁺-N) were 6.5-7.5, 30-40°C, 10-15%, 10% and 20-140mgL^-1, respectively, the high cell growth rate and CH₄ oxidation activity of Methylosinus sporium occurred in the media with the low EPS production, which was beneficial to sustainable and efficient CH₄ oxidation. In practice, O₂-limited condition such as the O₂ concentration of 10% might be a good way to control EPS production and enhance CH₄ oxidation to mitigate CH₄ emission from landfills.

Statistical assessment of dumpsite soil suitability to enhance methane bio-oxidation under interactive influence of substrates and temperature

Biocovers are considered as the most effective and efficient way to treat methane (CH₄) emission from dumpsites and landfills. Active methanotrophs in the biocovers play a crucial role in reduction of emissions through microbiological methane oxidation. Several factors affecting methane bio-oxidation (MOX) have been well documented, however, their interactive effect on the oxidation process needs to be explored. Therefore, the present study was undertaken to investigate the suitability of a dumpsite soil to be employed as biocover, under the influence of substrate concentrations (CH₄ and O₂) and temperature at variable incubation periods. Statistical design matrix of Response Surface Methodology (RSM) revealed that MOX rate up to 69.58μgCH₄g^-1_dwh^-1 could be achieved under optimum conditions. MOX was found to be more dependent on CH₄ concentration at higher level (30-40%, v/v), in comparison to O₂ concentration. However, unlike other studies MOX was found in direct proportionality relationship with temperature within a range of 25-35°C. The results obtained with the dumpsite soil biocover open up a new possibility to provide improved, sustained and environmental friendly systems to control even high CH₄ emissions from the waste sector.

Response of mixed methanotrophic consortia to different methane to oxygen ratios

Methane (CH₄) and oxygen (air) concentrations affect the CH₄ oxidation capacity (MOC) and mixed methanotrophic community structures in compost (fresh) and landfill (age old) top cover soils. A change in the mixed methanotrophic community structure in response has implications for landfill CH₄ bio-filter remediation and possible bio-product outcomes (i.e., fatty acid methyl esters (FAME) content and profiles and polyhydroxybutyrate (PHB) contents). Therefore the study aimed to evaluate the effect of variable CH₄ to oxygen ratios (10-50% CH₄ in air) on mixed methanotrophic community structures enriched from landfill top cover (LB) and compost soils (CB) and to quantify flow on impacts on MOC, total FAME contents and profiles, and PHB accumulation. A stable consortium developed achieving average MOCs of 3.0±0.12, 4.1±0.26, 6.9±0.7, 7.6±1.3 and 9.2±1.2mgCH₄g^-1DW_biomassh^-1 in LB and 2.9±0.04, 5.05±0.32, 6.7±0.31, 7.9±0.61 and 8.6±0.48mgCH₄g^-1DW_biomassh^-1 in CB for a 20day cultivation period at 10, 20, 30, 40 and 50% CH₄, respectively. CB at 10% CH₄ had a maximal FAME content of 40.5±0.8mgFAMEg^-1DW_biomass, while maximal PHB contents (25mgg^-1DW_biomass) was observed at 40% CH₄ in LB. Despite variable CH₄/O₂ ratios, the mixed methanotrophic community structures in both LB and CB were relatively stable, dominated by Methylosarcina sp., and Chryseobacterium, suggesting that a resilient consortium had formed which can now be tested in bio-filter operations for CH₄ mitigations in landfills.