Discordant retinoblastoma in monozygotic twins

Retinoblastoma in twins: Risk assessment of genotypic variants

Purpose

To describe methods of risk assessment in twins with retinoblastoma (RB).

Methods

A case series of four RB probands with a twin sibling. Family status, clinical presentation, and RB1 germline status-based risk assessment were analyzed.

Results

Two pairs had a positive family history (unilateral and bilateral RB in one of the parents (#1 and #2, respectively) and two pairs (#3 and #4) were sporadic. One of the familial twins (#1) had a high risk (90%) of manifesting RB in the twin. The other case (#2) with an absent RB1 germline mutation in the twin had a 0% risk of developing RB. Among sporadic cases of twins (#3), genetic testing did not identify a germline mutation (tumor sample unavailable) in the proband which downgraded the risk of germline mutation from 15% to <1%. The twin never developed RB (5 years of age at last follow-up). Pathogenic mosaicism for germline RB1 mutation (c.1723C>T) could be identified (tumor tissue available) in the proband (# 4). Identical germline mutation (and RB tumor) was also noted in the twin. In each case, there was concordance between the assessed risk and manifestation of RB.

Conclusion

Assessment of risk of RB in a twin presents with a unique challenge. Depending upon the genotype variant, the risk of developing RB can vary from 0% to 90%. In addition to family history, clinical manifestation in the proband, zygosity status, and RB1 germline status are critical in formulating risk-appropriate surveillance guidelines.

Retinoblastoma discordance in families with twins

Retinoblastoma has an increased inheritance risk of germline RB1 mutations in offspring and siblings, especially twins. Three families, each having one retinoblastoma-affected twin, were selected for genetic analysis and DNA profiling. Germline RB1 mutations were found in all probands. DNA profiling carried on similar-looking twins of families I and II, proved them to be fraternal. This study demonstrates the importance of genetic analysis of RB1 gene for risk prediction in retinoblastoma families. It also emphasizes that DNA profiling is a mandate for genetic screening of families with twins, thus adding a new dimension in counseling of retinoblastoma.

Discordant retinoblastoma in monozygotic twins due to deletion of 13q14

PURPOSE

To report discordant retinoblastoma in monozygotic twins, confirmed by GeneScan.

METHODS

One twin presented unilateral retinoblastoma that was treated with enucleation; the other twin had no retinoblastoma. To confirm monozygosity, DNA from leukocytes was analyzed through GeneScan with highly polymorphic markers; to exclude 13q14 deletion, FISH analysis was performed in leukocytes and oral cells of both twins and their parents and in retinal tissue of the affected twin with the cDNA LSI RB1 probe.

RESULTS

GeneScan analysis confirmed monozygosity. 13q14 deletion was observed in homozygous state in retinal tissue and in heterozygous state in oral cells and leukocytes of the affected twin. The nonaffected twin and parents showed no deletion of 13q14.

CONCLUSIONS

These data show unexpected differences in monozygotic twins that could be explained by postzygotic events in embryonic development.

Embryonic left-right separation mechanism allows confinement of mutation-induced phenotypes to one lateral body half of bilaterians

A fundamental question in developmental biology is how a chimeric animal such as a bilateral gynandromorphic animal can have different phenotypes confined to different lateral body halves, and how mutation-induced phenotypes, such as genetic diseases, can be confined to one lateral body half in patients. Here, I propose that embryos of many, if not all, bilaterian animals are divided into left and right halves at a very early stage (which may vary among different types of animals), after which the descendants of the left-sided and right-sided cells will almost exclusively remain on their original sides, respectively, throughout the remaining development. This embryonic left-right separation mechanism allows (1) mutations and the mutation-induced phenotypes to be strictly confined to one lateral body half in animals and humans; (2) mothers with bilateral hereditary primary breast cancer to transmit their disease to their offspring at twofold of the rate compared to mothers with unilateral hereditary breast cancer; and (3) a mosaic embryo carrying genetic or epigenetic mutations to develop into either an individual with the mutation-induced phenotype confined unilaterally, or a pair of twins displaying complete, partial, or mirror-image discordance for the phenotype. Further, this left-right separation mechanism predicts that the two lateral halves of a patient carrying a unilateral genetic disease can each serve as a case and an internal control, respectively, for genetic and epigenetic comparative studies to identify the disease causations.