Surgical treatment of Graves' disease

Changing trends in surgery for Graves' disease: a cohort comparison of those having surgery intended to preserve thyroid function with those having ablative surgery

Background

Surgery for Graves’ disease may be performed with the intent of preserving thyroid function (subtotal thyroidectomy) or ablating thyroid function (total thyroidectomy). This study examines the evolving practice in a specialist endocrine surgical unit.

Method

Longitudinal cohort study of patients undergoing surgery for Graves’ disease between 1986 and 2008. Outcome measures were thyroid failure, recurrent toxicity, recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN) palsy, early reoperation and hypocalcaemia. Time to thyroid failure was analysed by potential predictors.

Results

Of 149 patients (129 female), 78 (52.3 percent) underwent subtotal thyroidectomy with the intention to preserve function (PF) and 71 (47.6 percent) total thyroidectomy with the intention to ablate thyroid function (AF). Mean duration of follow-up was 11.1 years; 14.8 years and 7.0 years respectively. Of 78 PF procedures: six (7.7 percent) patients suffered recurrent toxicity; 68 (87.2 percent) developed thyroid failure (four after treatment for recurrent toxicity); and eight (10 percent) remained euthyroid without replacement. Male gender and remnant gland weight were significant predictors of failure (P = 0.021 and 0.022 respectively). One patient developed permanent RLN palsy and one permanent hypocalcaemia. Of 71 AF procedures: one developed acute airway obstruction; one permanent RLN palsy; four permanent hypocalcaemia; and none developed recurrent toxicity. There were no deaths within a year of surgery. There was no statistically significant difference in complication rates.

Conclusion

Most PF resections resulted in eventual thyroid failure. The shift to ablative surgery virtually eliminated the need for lifelong specialist follow-up, albeit with an insignificant rise in permanent hypocalcaemia.

Morbidity After Total Thyroidectomy for Benign Thyroid Disease: Comparison of Graves' Disease and Non-Graves' Disease

The purpose of this study was to review the safety of total thyroidectomies for benign thyroid disease, with special emphasis on the comparison between Graves' disease and non-Graves' disease. In this study, 107 patients who underwent total thyroidectomies for clinically benign thyroid disease performed by the same surgeon between January 1987 and December 2004 were enrolled; 48 had Graves' disease and 59 had non-Graves' disease. The rates of temporary vs. permanent hypoparathyroidism, hematoma requiring surgical intervention, and temporary vs. permanent recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy (RLNP) after total thyroidectomy for benign thyroid disease were 34.6% vs. 3.7%, 6.5%, and 6.5% vs. 1.85%, respectively. The rates of permanent hypoparathyroidism and temporary RLNP in the Graves' disease group were significantly different when compared with the non-Graves' disease group (8.3% vs. 0% and 11.5% vs. 2.5%, respectively). However, comparing the rates of temporary hypoparathyroidism, permanent RLNP, and postoperative hematoma, there was no statistically significant difference. Compared with total lobectomy, the rates of postoperative hematoma increased significantly for total thyroidectomy (6.5% vs. 0.48%). Total thyroidectomy for non-Graves' benign thyroid disease may be performed with minimal morbidity as has been advocated by many authors. For patients with Graves' disease in this study, however, the complication rates of permanent hypoparathyroidism and temporary RLNP were significantly increased. Therefore, we suggest that total thyroidectomy for Graves' disease should be performed by an experienced surgeon.

Subtotal Thyroidectomy: A Reliable Method to Achieve Euthyroidism in Graves’ Disease. Prognostic Factors

BACKGROUND

Subtotal thyroidectomy is a widely accepted surgical procedure for Graves' disease. The purpose of this work is to evaluate functional long-term results and determine predictive prognostic factors of postoperative thyroid function.

STUDY DESIGN

This is a retrospective study conducted on 202 patients with Graves' disease undergoing subtotal thyroidectomy during the period 1979-2002. Predictive prognostic factors of final thyroid status were investigated by logistic ordinal regression, and probability of hypothyroidism during the years of follow-up was obtained by the Kaplan-Meier method.

RESULTS

Surgery controlled hyperthyroidism in 196 out of 202 patients (97%). The probability of hypo-, eu-, and hyperthyroidism at 5 years was 62.1%, 35.5%, and 2.4%, respectively. No statistical change in thyroid function occurred in the follow-up after 60 months. Multivariate analysis by a logistic ordinal regression analysis showed that weight of the remnant, age, and gender seemed to influence long-term thyroid function. The higher rates of euthyroidism were obtained when the remnant weight was between 6 and 8 g. No recurrence or persistence of hyperthyroidism occurred with remnant weights under 5 g.

CONCLUSIONS

Subtotal thyroidectomy controlled hyperfunction symptoms in 97% of our patients. Cure (euthyroidism) of Graves' disease patients should be attempted by leaving a thyroid tissue remnant between 6 and 8 g. Even more significant, our results suggest that euthyroidism rates could be improved by leaving a smaller remnant in elderly women and greater remnants in young men.

Total thyroidectomy is now the preferred option for the surgical management of Graves' disease

PURPOSE

Subtotal thyroidectomy has been advocated as the standard treatment for Graves' disease because of the possibility of avoiding thyroxine therapy as well as the assumed lower risk of complications compared to total thyroidectomy. However, the long-term results of subtotal thyroidectomy are not as good as they were previously believed to be, as evidenced by the increasing incidence of hypothyroidism. If the risk of complications from total thyroidectomy is no higher,then that procedure offers significant advantages in the surgical management of Graves' disease. The aim of this study therefore was to compare the complication rate of the two procedures in patients with Graves' disease.

METHODS

This was a retrospective case control study in a tertiary referral hospital. Information was obtained from an endocrine surgery database over the study period from January 1957 to December 2000. During that period 1246 patients with Graves' disease underwent subtotal thyroidectomy and 119 patients underwent total thyroidectomy.

RESULTS

Prior to 1987 total thyroidectomy was rarely if ever performed whereas in the last 12 months total thyroidectomy comprised 95% of all procedures. There was no significant difference in the rate of permanent complications between the two procedures although temporary hypocalcaemia was significantly more common following total thyroidectomy. Permanent hypoparathyroidism resulted in one patient each who underwent total thyroidectomy (0.8%) and subtotal thyroidectomy (0.1%). Permanent recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy occurred in one patient who underwent total thyroidectomy (0.8%) and 5 patients undergoing subtotal thyroidectomy (0.4%).

CONCLUSION

Given that subtotal thyroidectomy provides an unpredictable outcome and that the risk of permanent complications is no greater than with total thyroidectomy, there appears little logical reason to continue to recommend subtotal thyroidectomy for the surgical management of Graves' disease. We believe that Graves' disease should join the increasing list of thyroid conditions for which total thyroidectomy is the preferred option.

[Is subtotal bilateral thyroidectomy still indicated in patients with Grave's disease?]

AIM OF THE STUDY

To evaluate the morbidity and the functional results of subtotal bilateral thyroidectomy in patients (TST) with Graves' disease.

PATIENTS AND METHOD

A retrospective study was performed in 128 patients. They were 23 males and 105 females with a median age of 34 years (range: 14-68). Weight of remnant tissue was between 4 and 5 g. Thyroid functional status was evaluated, at 3 months and after a follow-up period ranged from 1 to 5 years, by measurement of serum concentration of free T4 and/or free T3 and TSH.

RESULTS

They were no post-operative death. Surgical complications were 2 vocal cord palsies and 17 hypocalcemia (inf. to 2 mmol/L). After a median follow-up of 2 years, they were no longer any cases of vocal cord dysfunction and no case of permanent hypoparathyroidism. Functional results were established in 118 patients: 46 patients had clinical hypothyroidism (39%), 64 patients had latent hypothyroidism or euthyroidism (54.2%), and 8 had recurrent hyperthyroidism (6.8%).

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that TST with a remnant mass inferior to 5 g provides a low level of recurrent hyperthyroidism and allows to give no drug therapy to half patients. In our opinion, TST is still indicated in Graves' disease.

Surgical treatment of hyperthyroidism: a ten-year experience

Hyperthyroidism is treated either by antithyroid drugs, radioiodine (I131) or surgery. In Sweden, surgery is often performed in patients with large goiter or severe hyperthyroidism with infiltrative endocrine ophthalmopathy. To evaluate indications and results of surgical treatment, data from 380 patients operated on for hyperthyroidism at our department during 1986-1995 were analyzed. Twenty-six percent were referred for surgery because of failure of treatment with antithyroid drugs or I131. Ninety-one percent were subjected to subtotal thyroidectomy with a median remnant weight of less than 2 g. In the remaining patients, total thyroidectomy was performed. Transient vocal cord affection occurred in 2.6%, none of which was permanent. Prolonged postoperative hypocalcemia occurred in 3.1%, and permanent hypoparathyroidism in 1%. There was no difference in complication rate between subtotal or total thyroidectomy. In patients with Graves' disease, 5% worsened with regard to ophthalmopathy initially after surgery but later improved. Recurrent disease occurred in 2% of the patients, all of whom had undergone subtotal thyroidectomy. Surgery is not first-line therapy in all patients with hyperthyroidism. However, in experienced hands, surgery is a good therapeutic alternative that can be carried out with no mortality, few complications, and, provided that a minimal remnant is left, very few recurrences.

The efficacy of thyroidectomy for Graves' disease: A meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Surgery for Graves' disease was largely replaced in the mid-1900s by radioiodine and antithyroid drugs, due to the belief that they were more safe and effective. Since then, thyroid surgery has improved with preoperative drug therapy and modern operative techniques. Recent clinical studies of thyroidectomy for Graves' disease may not reflect outcomes accurately because of small sample size, especially when estimating ideal thyroid remnant size. The purpose of this study was to combine modern clinical trials and use meta-analysis to determine the overall efficacy of both total (TT) and subtotal thyroidectomy (ST) for Graves' disease, compare thyroid function and complications rates of TT and ST, and determine ideal thyroid remnant size.

METHODS

Meta-analysis was performed on published studies in which patients underwent either TT or ST for Graves' disease. Meta-analysis was performed by weighted least-squares linear regression. P < 0.05 was considered significant.

RESULTS

There were 35 studies comprising 7241 patients. Mean follow-up was 5.6 years. Overall, persistent or recurrent hyperthyroidism occurred in 7.2% of patients. TT was performed on 538 patients and hypothyroidism occurred in all cases. ST was performed in 6703 patients, 59.7% of whom achieved euthyroidism, 25. 6% became hypothyroid, and 7.9% had either persistent or recurrent hyperthyroidism. Permanent recurrent laryngeal nerve injury occurred in 0.9% of TT patients and 0.7% of ST patients (P = NS). Permanent hypoparathyroidism occurred in 1.6% of TT patients and 1.0% of ST patients (P = NS). There was an 8.9% decrease in hypothyroidism and 6.9% increase in euthyroidism for each gram of thyroid remnant (P < 0.0001 each).

CONCLUSIONS

Overall, thyroidectomy successfully treated hyperthyroidism in 92% of patients with Graves' disease. There were no cases of hyperthyroidism following TT. ST achieved a euthyroid state in almost 60% of patients with an 8% rate of persistent or recurrent hyperthyroidism. There was no significant difference in complication rates between TT and ST.

Results of subtotal thyroidectomy for Graves' disease

The objective of this study was to find the factors responsible for hypothyroidism after subtotal thyroidectomy for Graves' disease. Two hundred five patients who were operated on from July 1989 to December 1997 were studied. The mean age of patients was 33.4+/-11.0 (mean +/- SD) years, and 175 (85.4%) were female. Patients were prepared with an antithyroid drug and Lugol's solution preoperatively. Triiodothyronine (T3), thyroxine (T4), thyrotropin (TSH), thyrotropin-binding immunoglobulins (TBII) antimicrosomal antibodies (AMA = 100x 4(M-1)), and antithyroglobulin antibodies (ATA = 100x4(T-1)) were measured 1 week before patients were operated on. Operations were performed according to the standard procedure with 2.5x1x1 cm of thyroid tissue remaining on each side before approximating the thyroid capsule and pretracheal fascia. Hypothyroidism was defined by patients with overt hypothyroidism in laboratory data, and or with T4 to maintain T3 and T4. Two hundred two patients were checked 3 months after being operated on. Latent hyperthyroidism was found in 22, euthyroidism in 55, latent hypothyroidism in 91, hypothyroidism in 34 (16.8%) and none were in overt hyperthyroidism. After a follow-up period of 26.9+/-15 (mean +/- SD) months, 199 patients were reevaluated. Overt hyperthyroidism was found in 2 patients, latent hyperthyroidism in 12, euthyroidism in 97, latent hypothyroidism in 72, and hypothyroidism in 16 (8%). Factors having possible effects on hypothyroidism after longterm follow-up were analyzed. Patient's age, gender, body surface, premedicative T3 and T4, preoperative ATA, and TBII, and the weight of removed thyroid had no effect on the occurrence of hypothyroidism. Preoperative AMA levels, and finding more than 10 lymphoid infiltrations per 10 low-power fields (x40) were significantly different between the hypothyroid and nonhypothyroid groups. A high level of preoperative AMA was the only factor independently causing overt hypothyroidism in the follow-up period. Patients with high preoperative AMA levels have a higher risk of hypothyroidism if only 2.5x1x1 cm remnants are left on each side.

Factors affecting thyroid function after subtotal thyroidectomy for Graves' disease: case control study by remnant-weight matched-pair analysis

In order to determine whether there are any predictive factors, other than the amount of remnant thyroid tissue, for subsequent thyroid function after subtotal thyroidectomy for Graves' disease, thyroid function was assessed in 329 patients 3 years after surgery, and a case control study was carried out in euthyroid, hyperthyroid, and hypothyroid groups by remnant-weight matched-pair analysis. Factors that affected thyroid function 3 years after surgery were thyroid gland infiltration by lymphocytes and the thyrotropin binding inhibiting immunoglobulin (TBII) value in the hyperthyroid and euthyroid groups, and the free triiodothyronine (FT3) value at the time of surgery and lymph follicle formation in the thyroid gland in the hypothyroid and euthyroid groups. It is concluded that no single factor studied at surgery, other than the amount of remnant tissue, can predict thyroid function after subtotal thyroidectomy for Graves' disease.

Total thyroidectomy for Graves' disease

BACKGROUND

Therapeutic options for treatment of hyperthyroidism caused by Graves' disease remain controversial. There are three main options: thiourea drugs, radioactive iodine ablation, and thyroidectomy. Each treatment has significant advantages and potential problems.

METHODS

The present study is a retrospective analysis of our experience with total thyroidectomy in Graves' disease. Sixty-two patients underwent this procedure in 11 years' time and were followed for a minimum of 2 years after surgery. All had measurement of total thyroxine, T3 uptake, and radioactive iodine (RAI) uptake and scanning. Sixty-three percent of all patients had some element of hyperthyroid eye signs. All patients were rendered euthyroid with pharmacologic therapy prior to surgery. Postoperatively, the patients were evaluated for improvement in eye signs, incidence of recurrent laryngeal nerve injury, and hypoparathyroidism.

RESULTS

None of the patients in this study have developed recurrent hyperthyroidism. All patients are maintained on levothyroxine. None of our patients incurred bilateral vocal cord paralysis. One patient (1.6%) demonstrated an immobile vocal cord more than 1 year following surgery. Ten patients (16%) demonstrated impaired mobility of one vocal cord in the immediate postoperative period. Nine of these patients recovered full vocal cord mobility within 6 months after surgery. Only one patient (1.6%) still required calcium and vitamin D therapy 1 year following surgery. However, in the immediate postoperative period, 23 patients (37%) required supplemental calcium and vitamin D. In 12 patients, calcium and vitamin D was discontinued within 1 month. In an additional 6 patients, calcium and vitamin D were discontinued within 4 months; 3 patients, within 6 months; and 1 patient, within 12 months after surgery. Incidental papillary carcinoma was found in 3 patients (5%).

CONCLUSIONS

Total thyroidectomy for Graves' disease is an effective and safe therapy. When performed by an experienced head and neck surgeon, it carries a low morbidity rate. It should be presented to patients as a therapeutic option within the context of a comprehensive discussion of the risks and benefits of radioactive iodine, pharmacologic therapy, and surgery.

Early recurrence of hyperthyroidism in patients with Graves' disease treated by subtotal thyroidectomy

Prerequisites for surgical treatment of Graves' disease are that it can be done safely and that it is associated with a low incidence of recurrent hyperthyroidism. Early recurrence is especially undesirable. We studied 728 patients with Graves' disease treated by subtotal thyroidectomy using multivariate analysis in order to determine the factors related to early recurrence. The following factors were analyzed: age, sex, duration of medical treatment, weight of resected thyroid tissue, thyroid remnant size, preoperative level of thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) binding inhibitory immunoglobulin (TBII), and antimicrosomal hemagglutination antibody (MCHA). "Early recurrence" was defined as TSH suppression observed within the first year after surgery and continuing for at least 6 months. A total of 106 patients (14.6%) had early recurrence. Statistical analyses were performed by the chi-square test for univariate analysis and a logistic model for multivariate analysis. Significant factors were thyroid remnant size, MCHA, and TBII. These results indicated that TBII and MCHA are related to early recurrence of hyperthyroidism, and smaller remnant size is recommended for patients with a high MCHA titer or a high TBII level (or both) in order to avoid early recurrence.

Hypothyroidism: a comprehensive review

Hypothyroidism is a common clinical entity encountered frequently in most adult primary care settings. The reported prevalence in the general population is approximately 3% in men, but as high as 10% in women (Sawin, Geller, Hershman, Castelli, & Bacharach, 1989). The disease process affects every major organ system, contributing to a broad range of symptoms. Clinicians need to be familiar with the signs, the symptoms, and the appropriate laboratory studies, so that timely and accurate diagnoses can be made. This article reviews normal thyroid physiology and thyroid pathophysiology, as well as the diagnosis and treatment of several important clinical entities resulting in hypothyroidism. Research findings are included insofar as they relate to current clinical practice.

Retrospective analysis of prognostic factors affecting the thyroid functional status after subtotal thyroidectomy for Graves' disease

To determine the factors causing thyroid dysfunction after surgery for Graves' disease, we studied 321 patients who underwent subtotal thyroidectomy during the 7-year period from 1981 to 1987. Thyroid functional status was evaluated biochemically and the patients were divided into four categories: recurrent hyperthyroidism, euthyroidism, latent hypothyroidism, and hypothyroidism. The following factors were analyzed: sex, age at onset of the disease, indication for surgery, serum titer of antimicrosomal hemagglutination antibody (MCHA), weight of resected thyroid tissue, size of remnant thyroid relative to body surface area, pathological findings of lymphoid follicles, and lymphocytic infiltration in the thyroid tissue. Probabilities of failure (recurrent hyperthyroidism and hypothyroidism) were estimated by the Kaplan-Meier method. Prognostic factors for failure were identified by using Cox's proportional hazards model. The incidence of hyperthyroidism and hypothyroidism 5 years after subtotal thyroidectomy was 16.2% and 9.6%, respectively. Significant factors for hyperthyroidism were relatively large thyroid remnant, high serum titer of MCHA (greater than or equal to 1:3200), and age at onset of the disease less than 20 years. The significant factor for hypothyroidism was severe lymphocytic infiltration. The level of postoperative thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH)-binding inhibition immunoglobulins (TBII) in patients with recurrence was significantly higher than in patients in remission. It is reasonable to determine the amount of remnant thyroid tissue in relation to patient body surface area. Although subtotal thyroidectomy can induce immunological remission by reduction of antigen, if the remission disappears, that is if TBII increases, recurrence of hyperthyroidism may develop even in patients without the unfavorable factors.

Hyperthyroidism: a comprehensive review

Hyperthyroidism is an endocrine disorder encountered in adult primary care clinics. This article reviews normal thyroid physiology as well as the pathophysiology, diagnosis, clinical signs and symptoms, and diagnostic tests and treatment for the most common clinical hyperthyroid entities. Current research is also discussed as it relates to clinical practice.

Endemic goiter and endemic thyroid disorders

The primary role of iodine deficiency in goitrogenesis and the prevention and treatment of endemic goiter by iodine supplementation is firmly established. Unfortunately, implementation of iodine prophylaxis programs has met with considerable technical and socioeconomic difficulties. Besides, lack of knowledge concerning some of the other causative factors of endemic goiter has prevented development of appropriate measures for its complete eradication in those areas where goiter persists in spite of prolonged and adequate iodine supplementation. At present, no less than 5% of the world's population have goiters and associated disorders, resulting in a public health and socioeconomic problem of major proportions. Seventy-five percent of people with goiter live in less developed countries where iodine deficiency is prevalent. Goiter prevalence rates of more than 50% and the highest frequency of severe cases of iodine deficiency disorders, namely, cretinism, congenital hypothyroidism, and various degrees of impairment of growth and mental development are found in endemic areas with extreme iodine deficiency. Goiters are usually multinodular and of very large size, producing, on occasion, signs of compression that require surgery. Recurrence rates are as high as 25-30% and second surgery accounts for 16% of all thyroidectomies. Unfortunately, most of these goiters occur in areas with highly restricted medical and surgical facilities. Twenty-five percent of people with goiters live in more developed countries where goiter continues to occur in certain areas despite iodine prophylaxis. Iodine-sufficient goiters are associated with autoimmune thyroiditis, hypothyroidism, hyperthyroidism, and thyroid carcinoma. Goiter is of considerable surgical significance in iodine-sufficient endemic areas and, to a lesser degree, in nonendemic areas where it is called "sporadic" goiter. Recurrence rates of iodine-sufficient goiter are 10-19% following thyroidectomy. Since most of these goiters grow by mechanisms other than increased thyrotropin (TSH) stimulation, treatment with suppressive doses of L-thyroxine is inefficient and, because of possible complications, not recommended. Although Graves' hyperthyroidism is not directly related to endemic goiter, it does relate adversely with ingestion or administration of iodine. At present, Graves' disease is treated with 131I or antithyroid drugs in more than 90% of the cases. The incidence rates of papillary, follicular, and anaplastic thyroid carcinomas appear to be related to endemic goiter and iodine supplementation, with surgery being required in essentially all of these cases.