The effects of sterilization and storage treatments on the stress-strain behavior of aortic valve leaflets

Materials and manufacturing perspectives in engineering heart valves: a review

Valvular heart diseases (VHD) are a major health burden, affecting millions of people worldwide. The treatments for such diseases rely on medicine, valve repair, and artificial heart valves including mechanical and bioprosthetic valves. Yet, there are countless reports on possible alternatives noting long-term stability and biocompatibility issues and highlighting the need for fabrication of more durable and effective replacements. This review discusses the current and potential materials that can be used for developing such valves along with existing and developing fabrication methods. With this perspective, we quantitatively compare mechanical properties of various materials that are currently used or proposed for heart valves along with their fabrication processes to identify challenges we face in creating new materials and manufacturing techniques to better mimick ​the performance of native heart valves.

3D Biofabrication of Thermoplastic Polyurethane (TPU)/Poly-l-lactic Acid (PLLA) Electrospun Nanofibers Containing Maghemite (γ-Fe₂O₃) for Tissue Engineering Aortic Heart Valve

Valvular dysfunction as the prominent reason of heart failure may causes morbidity and mortality around the world. The inability of human body to regenerate the defected heart valves necessitates the development of the artificial prosthesis to be replaced. Besides, the lack of capacity to grow, repair or remodel of an artificial valves and biological difficulty such as infection or inflammation make the development of tissue engineering heart valve (TEHV) concept. This research presented the use of compound of poly-l-lactic acid (PLLA), thermoplastic polyurethane (TPU) and maghemite nanoparticle (γ-Fe₂O₃) as the potential biomaterials to develop three-dimensional (3D) aortic heart valve scaffold. Electrospinning was used for fabricating the 3D scaffold. The steepest ascent followed by the response surface methodology was used to optimize the electrospinning parameters involved in terms of elastic modulus. The structural and porosity properties of fabricated scaffold were characterized using FE-SEM and liquid displacement technique, respectively. The 3D scaffold was then seeded with aortic smooth muscle cells (AOSMCs) and biological behavior in terms of cell attachment and proliferation during 34 days of incubation was characterized using MTT (3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide) assay and confocal laser microscopy. Furthermore, the mechanical properties in terms of elastic modulus and stiffness were investigated after cell seeding through macro-indentation test. The analysis indicated the formation of ultrafine quality of nanofibers with diameter distribution of 178 ± 45 nm and 90.72% porosity. In terms of cell proliferation, the results exhibited desirable proliferation (109.32 ± 3.22% compared to the control) of cells over the 3D scaffold in 34 days of incubation. The elastic modulus and stiffness index after cell seeding were founded to be 22.78 ± 2.12 MPa and 1490.9 ± 12 Nmm², respectively. Overall, the fabricated 3D scaffold exhibits desirable structural, biological and mechanical properties and has the potential to be used in vivo.

Quantification and comparison of the mechanical properties of four human cardiac valves

OBJECTIVE

Although having the same ability to permit unidirectional flow within the heart, the four main valves-the mitral valve (MV), aortic (AV), tricuspid (TV) and pulmonary (PV) valves-experience different loading conditions; thus, they exhibit different structural integrity from one another. Most research on heart valve mechanics have been conducted mainly on MV and AV or an individual valve, but none quantify and compare the mechanical and structural properties among the four valves from the same aged patient population whose death was unrelated to cardiovascular disease.

METHODS

A total of 114 valve leaflet samples were excised from 12 human cadavers whose death was unrelated to cardiovascular disease (70.1±3.7years old). Tissue mechanical and structural properties were characterized by planar biaxial mechanical testing and histological methods. The experimental data were then fitted with a Fung-type constitutive model.

RESULTS

The four valves differed substantially in thickness, degree of anisotropy, and stiffness. The leaflets of the left heart (the AV leaflets and the anterior mitral leaflets, AML) were significantly stiffer and less compliant than their counterparts in the right heart. TV leaflets were the most extensible and isotropic, while AML and AV leaflets were the least extensible and the most anisotropic. Age plays a significant role in the reduction of leaflet stiffness and extensibility with nearly straightened collagen fibers observed in the leaflet samples from elderly groups (65years and older).

CONCLUSIONS

Results from 114 human leaflet samples not only provided a baseline quantification of the mechanical properties of aged human cardiac valves, but also offered a better understanding of the age-dependent differences among the four valves. It is hoped that the experimental data collected and the associated constitutive models in this study can facilitate future studies of valve diseases, treatments and the development of interventional devices.

STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE

Most research on heart valve mechanics have been conducted mainly on mitral and aortic valves or an individual valve, but none quantify and compare the mechanical and structural properties among the four valves from the same relatively healthy elderly patient population. In this study, the mechanical and microstructural properties of 114 leaflets of aortic, mitral, pulmonary and tricuspid valves from 12 human cadaver hearts were mechanically tested, analyzed and compared. Our results not only provided a baseline quantification of the mechanical properties of aged human valves, but a age range between patients (51-87years) also offers a better understanding of the age-dependent differences among the four valves. It is hoped that the obtained experimental data and associated constitutive parameters can facilitate studies of valve diseases, treatments and the development of interventional devices.

In Vitro Model of a Fibrosa Layer of a Heart Valve

The fibrosa layer of a cardiac aortic valve is composed mostly of a dense network of type I collagen fibers oriented in circumferential direction. This main layer bears the tensile load and responds to the high stress on a leaflet. The inner fibrosa layer is also the site of pathophysiologic changes that result in valvular dysfunction, including stenosis and regurgitation. In vitro studies of these changes are limited by the absence of a substrate that mimics the circumferentially oriented structure of the fibrosa layer. In heart valve tissue engineering, generation of this layer is challenging. This study aimed to develop an artificial fibrosa layer of a native aortic leaflet. A unique morphologically biomimicked, pliable, but standalone substrate with circumferentially oriented nanofibers was fabricated by electrospinning on a novel collector designed for this study. The substrate had low-bulk tensile stiffness and ultimate strength; thus, cultured valvular interstitial cells (VICs) showed a fibroblast phenotype that is generally observed in a healthy aortic leaflet. Furthermore, gene and protein expression and morphology of VICs in substrates were close to those in the fibrosa layer of a native aortic leaflet. This artificial fibrosa layer can be useful for in vitro studies of valvular dysfunctions.

Glutaraldehyde as a fixative in bioprostheses and drug delivery matrices

The use of glutaraldehyde as a fixative in bioprostheses and drug delivery matrices is reviewed. The chemistry of glutaraldehyde cross-linking and its effect on the biological performance of a number of bioprostheses such as tissue heart valves, vascular grafts, pericardial patches, tendon grafts and drug delivery matrices are examined.

An approach to the optimization of preparation of bioprosthetic heart valves

The stress and strain states of the valve leaflets during fixation with glutaraldehyde affect their final mechanical parameters. Comparative studies of the stress-strain relationships of aortic valve leaflet strips from fresh, statically and dynamically fixed porcine and human valves were made. Static pressures of 5 mmHg, 16 mmHg, and 95 mmHg result in stress-strain relationships which are in a region between that of fresh porcine and fresh human leaflet strips in the circumferential direction, while they are far from that of fresh porcine tissue (larger strains) in the radial direction. Leaflet strips, fixed under dynamic loading between zero and a predefined maximum load, set at an early post-transition state, give parameters not significantly different from those of human valves.

The bovine pericardial xenograft: I. Effect of fixation in aldehydes without constraint on the tensile viscoelastic properties of bovine pericardium

Tensile testing of tissue strips has been used to examine the effect of simple fixation in glutaraldehyde and formaldehyde on the viscoelastic properties of bovine pericardium. To assess tissue anisotropy, tissue strips were cut at 0 degree, 30 degrees, 60 degrees, and 90 degrees relative to the base-to-apex direction. Fresh anterior pericardium was modestly anisotropic, being least extensible in the base-to-apex direction; however, fixation removed this anisotropy. Fixation also produced a marked change in the response of the material to initial cyclic loading during preconditioning. Overall extensibility of the fixed material was significantly greater than that for the fresh tissue, consistent with a 10.7% shrinkage in aldehydes calculated from strain at fracture data. Reductions in stress relaxation and creep after fixation were noted as well, consistent with intrafibrillar crosslinking. Cyclic hysteresis and ultimate tensile strength were unaffected. Since the observed changes in the stress-strain response were largely attributable to shrinkage, control of shrinkage by physical means would allow for engineering modification of bovine pericardial mechanics for controlled anisotropy.

Relationship between mechanical and hydrodynamic properties of bioprosthesis produced from canine aortic valve

Static tensile, stress relaxation, and hydrodynamic tests were carried out to investigate the relationships between the mechanical deformation or stiffness of heart valve leaflets and the opening behavior of bioprosthetic valves. The specimens used were fresh and glutaraldehyde (GA)-treated canine aortic valves. The tensile strength depended on the fiber orientation in the leaflet. The deformability of fresh and 0.05% GA-treated tissues was significantly larger than that induced by 0.1-5.0% GA concentrations according to the stress-strain curves. The stress relaxation function, which expresses the viscoelastic property, did not show significant differences in the 0.05-5.0% range of GA concentrations. In the hydrodynamic tests, the opening resistance of fresh and 0.05% GA-treated valves was less than that of 0.1-5.0% GA-treated valves. Thus, it was shown that the hydrodynamic valve functions were closely related to the material properties of aortic valve leaflets.

The glutaraldehyde-stabilized porcine aortic valve xenograft. I. Tensile viscoelastic properties of the fresh leaflet material

The tensile viscoelastic properties of radial and circumferential strips of fresh porcine aortic valve leaflets have been examined and compared with the fiber architecture of the leaflets as seen in the scanning electron microscope. The leaflet material showed nonlinear viscoelasticity, largely independent of strain rate, and dependent on the degree of preconditioning by cyclic loading. Preconditioning to a stable stress-strain response could only be accomplished on 1-cm-long strips above a minimum width of 4 mm (circumferential) and 6 mm (radial). Preconditioning yielded a more elastic and extensible material with reduced hysteresis. The leaflets were markedly anisotropic. Circumferential strips were up to 8 times stronger and stiffer than radial strips, and displayed greater stress relaxation and less creep. The circumferential mechanical properties were due to well-aligned circumferential collagen bundles reinforcing the composite structure, while radial properties were due to a more random collagenous support throughout the leaflet. Despite the presence of a septal shelf on the right coronary leaflet, no mechanical differences could be discerned between leaflets.

The glutaraldehyde-stabilized porcine aortic valve xenograft. II. Effect of fixation with or without pressure on the tensile viscoelastic properties of the leaflet material

We have examined the tensile viscoelastic properties of circumferential and radial strips of porcine aortic valve leaflets following fixation in glutaraldehyde and formaldehyde, with or without pressure. After aldehyde treatment, the radial strips remained weaker and less stiff than circumferential strips and responded slightly differently to the treatment. After fixation, with or without pressure, the radial strips showed large changes in stress-strain and hysteresis responses due to initial loading, and there was a twofold reduction in tensile strength and final stiffness. For strips in both directions, fixation without pressure produced doubled extensibility and a ramping stress-strain curve. Permanent (plastic) deformation of 5-20% occurred as a result of cyclic loading, stress relaxation, and creep experiments. Pressure fixation, however, produced little change in stress-strain results other than a simple shift to lower strain and produced no plasticity. Both methods of fixation reduced stress relaxation and creep. Mechanical test results are consistent with a loss of ground substance matrix during fixation. Reductions in tensile strength after fixation may be due to "riveting" of collagen geometry, producing local stress concentrations.

Stress analysis of porcine bioprosthetic heart valves in vivo

During the normal functioning of aortic porcine bioprosthetic valves, the leaflets undergo complex configurational changes which can produce stresses large enough to damage the leaflets. Stress analyses of these valves in vivo have not been performed before. We investigated the behavior of aortic bioprostheses in vivo in calves by placing radiopaque markers on the valves and observing them under x-ray. Based upon the behavior of the leaflets, a method of stress analysis is proposed. Membrane stresses were associated with a pressure gradient across the leaflet and bending stresses with a change in the leaflet curvature. Total stresses were obtained by summation of the two stresses. A model of leaflet deformation at its attachment is proposed and the stresses determined. In diastole, the total stresses in the leaflet were tensile. In systole, the total stresses at the leaflet attachment were large and compressive on the aortic surface. Since the leaflet is unable to sustain compressive stresses, it is concluded that large compressive stresses cause structural damage at the leaflet attachment. This may explain the clinical observation that bioprosthetic leaflets detach or calcify in this region.

The elastic modulus of canine aortic valve leaflets in vivo and in vitro

Aortic valve leaflets undergo extraordinary flexion due to the complete reversal of their curvature during billions of cardiac cycles. The flexion stresses in the leaflet depend on its elastic modulus which we investigated in vivo and in vitro. In six dogs, we placed radiopaque markers on an aortic leaflet. Leaflet length was calculated from the marker positions recorded fluoroscopically. Aortic and ventricular pressures were recorded. Dogs were killed and leaflet stress-strain curves determined in vitro. Leaflet length in vivo decreased 10.4 +/- 4.7% from diastole to systole in each cardiac cycle. Using the law of LaPlace, pressure gradients across the leaflets were converted into the stresses in the leaflets. The leaflets had an initial "elastic phase" of low modulus in systole followed by an "inelastic phase" of high modulus in diastole. The elastic modulus was 2.4 +/- 0.7 x 10(6) dynes/cm2 in systole and 5.2 +/- 1.7 x 10(7) dynes/cm2 in diastole. These results were similar to those obtained in vitro. Since flexion rigidity is proportional to (elastic modulus) x (thickness)3, the lower modulus in systole greatly reduces flexion stresses in the leaflet and increases leaflet longevity. The higher elastic modulus in diastole prevents excessive bulging or prolapse of the leaflet while it is subjected to the diastolic pressure gradient. We conclude that a natural or prosthetic leaflet which is thickened or has a high elastic modulus throughout the cardiac cycle will have a greater flexion stress that could cause early failure.

Simultaneous morphological and stress-strain studies of the fibrous components in wet heart valve leaflet tissue

Simultaneous morphological and stress-strain studies have been carried out on heart valve leaflet tissue maintained in its unaltered functional condition. A microtensile tissue testing device is described which inserts directly into the stage of an optical microscope fitted with a Nomarski interference contrast facility. Glutaraldehyde fixation of tissue subjected to different levels of loading reveals that the current stressed state of the collagen fibers is "frozen" in by crosslinking process, and as a consequence marked alterations in the preserved tissue properties are produced. This is shown to be relevant to the preparation of the glutaraldehyde treated heterograft heart valve. The mechanical roles of the collagen and elastin components are investigated and a "complementation" mechanism is postulated whereby the widely different mechanical properties of the two types of fibers are combined in a non-competing manner to produce a diversity of composite tissue characteristics.