Mechanism and role of divalent cation binding of bacteriorhodopsin

Brighter than the sun: Rajni Govindjee at 80 and her fifty years in photobiology

We celebrate distinguished photobiologist Rajni Govindjee for her pioneering research in photosynthesis and retinal proteins on the occasion of her 80th birthday.

On the molecular mechanisms of the Schiff base deprotonation during the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle

Using optical flash photolysis and time-resolved Raman methods, we examined intermediates formed during the photocycle of bacteriorhodopsin (bR), as well as the bR color change, as a function of pH (in the 7.0-1.5 region) and as a function of the number of bound Ca(2+) ions. It is found that at a pH just below 3 or with less than two bound Ca(2+) per bR, the deprotonation (the L(550) --> M(412)) step ceases, yet the K(610) and L(550) analogues are still formed as in native bR. The lack of deprotonation in the photocycle of both acid blue and deionized blue bR and the similarity of their Raman spectra as well as of their K(610) and L(550) analogues strongly suggest that both blue samples have nearly the same retinal active site. It is suggested that in both blue species, bound cations are removed via a proton-cation exchange equilibrium, either on the cation exchange column for the deionized sample or in solution for the acid blue sample. The proton-cation exchange equilibrium is found to quantitatively account for the pH dependence of the purple-to-blue color change. The different mechanisms responsible for the large reduction ( approximately 11 units) of the pK(a) value of the protonated Schiff base (PSB) during the photocycle are discussed. The absence of the L(550) --> M(412) deprotonation process in both blue species is discussed in terms of the previously proposed cation model for the deprotonation of the PSB during the photocycle of native bR. The extent of the deprotonation and the blue-to-purple color change are found to follow the same dependence on either the pH or the amount of cations added to deionized blue bR. This observed correlation is briefly discussed.

Evidence for the involvement of more than one metal cation in the Schiff base deprotonation process during the photocycle of bacteriorhodopsin

The removal of metal cations inhibits the deprotonation process of the protonated Schiff base during the photocycle of bacteriorhodopsin. To understand the nature of the involvement of these cations, a spectroscopic and kinetic study was carried out on bacteriorhodopsin samples in which the native Ca(2+) and Mg(2+) were replaced by Eu(3+), a luminescent cation. The decay of Eu(3+) emission in bacteriorhodopsin can be fitted to a minimum of three decay components, which are assigned to Eu(3+) emission from three different sites. This is supported by the response of the decay components to the presence of (2)H(2)O and to the changes in the Eu(3+)/bR molar ratio. The number of water molecules coordinated to Eu(3+) in each site is determined from the change in its emission lifetime when (2)H(2)O replaces H(2)O. Most of the emission originates from two "wet" sites of low crystal-field symmetry-e.g., surface sites. Protonated Schiff base deprotonation has no discernable effect on the emission decay of protein-bound Eu(3+), suggesting an indirect involvement of metal cations in the deprotonation process. Adding Eu(3+) to deionized bacteriorhodopsin increases the emission intensity of each Eu(3+) site linearly, but the extent of the deprotonation (and color) changes sigmoidally. This suggests that if only the emitting Eu(3+) ions cause the deprotonation and bacteriorhodopsin color change, ions in more than one site must be involved-e.g., by inducing protein conformation changes. The latter could allow deprotonation by the interaction between the protonated Schiff base and a positive field of cations either on the surface or within the protein.

The pink membrane: the stable photoproduct of deionized purple membrane

When cations are removed from the purple membrane of Halobacterium halobium it turns blue (lambda(max) = 603 nm); continuous irradiation with intense red light (lambda's >/= 630 nm) converts this deionized blue membrane into a pink membrane (lambda(max) approximately 491 nm). The rate and extent of the transformation from the blue to the pink membrane is facilitated by the removal of the last twenty COOH-terminal amino acids of bacteriorhodopsin. While the chromophore of the blue membrane is a 32:68 mixture of the 13-cis and all-trans isomers of retinal, the chromophore of the pink membrane is 9-cis rectinal. The quantum efficiency of the pink to blue membrane photoconversion is relatively high compared with that of the blue to pink membrane photoconversion. Proton release is observed when the pink membrane is converted to the blue form, and proton uptake occurs during the reverse transition. Unlike the blue membrane, the absorbance maximum of the pink membrane is only slightly affected by cation addition at low pH and ionic strength.

Nature of the individual Ca binding sites in Ca-regenerated bacteriorhodopsin

The binding constants, K(1) and K(2), and the number of Ca(2+) ions in each of the two high affinity sites of Ca(2+)-regenerated bacteriorhodopsin (bR) are determined potentiometrically at different pH values in the range of pH 3.5-4.5 by using the Scatchard plot method. From the pH dependence of K(1) and K(2), it was found that two hydrogen ions are released for each Ca(2+) bound to each of the two high affinity sites. Furthermore, we have measured by a direct spectroscopic method the association constant, K(s), for the binding of Ca(2+) to deionized bR, which is responsible for producing the blue to purple color change. Comparing the value of K(s) and its pH dependence with those of K(1) and K(2) showed that the site corresponding to K(s) is to be identified with that of K(2). This is in agreement with the conclusion reached previously, using a different approach, which showed that it is the second Ca(2+) that causes the blue to purple color change.Our studies also show that in addition to the two distinct high affinity sites, there are about four to six sites with lower binding constants. These are attributed to the nonspecific binding in bR.

Sugar-induced blue membrane: release of divalent cations during phase transition of purple membranes observed in sugar-derived glasses

The formation of blue membrane from purple membranes (PM) has been observed in glassy films made from PM and various sugars. The phase transition of PM at about 70 degrees C causes the complexation of divalent cations to be weakened. The vicinal diol structures in sugars are capable to complex divalent cations and delocalize them throughout the matrix as long as its glass transition temperature is lower than the phase transition temperature of PM. The loss of divalent cations from bacteriorhodopsin (BR), the only protein in PM, causes the formation of blue membrane (BM), which is accompanied by a loss of beta-sheet structure observable in the infrared spectrum. Glassy sugars are particular useful to observe this transition, as sugar entrapment does not restrict conformational changes of BR but rather retards them. The material obtained was named sugar-induced blue membrane (SIBM). The formation of SIBM is inhibited by the addition of divalent cations. Furthermore, SIBM is reverted immediately to PM by addition of water. A characteristic time dependence of the thermal reversion of SIBM to PM proves that the phase transition of PM triggers the release and uptake of divalent cations and the corresponding color change.

X-ray absorption and molecular dynamics study of cation binding sites in the purple membrane

The present work describes the results of a study aimed at identifying candidate cation binding sites on the extracellular region of bacteriorhodopsin, including a site near the retinal pocket. The approach used is a combined effort involving computational chemistry methods (computation of cation affinity maps and molecular dynamics) together with the Extended X-Ray Absorption Fine Structure (EXAFS) technique to obtain relevant information about the local structure of the protein in the neighborhood of Mn(2+) ions in different affinity binding sites. The results permit the identification of a high-affinity binding site where the ion is coordinated simultaneously to Asp212(-) and Asp85(-). Comparison of EXAFS data of the wild type protein with the quadruple mutant E9Q/E74Q/E194Q/E204Q at pH 7.0 and 10.0 demonstrate that extracellular glutamic acid residues are involved in cation binding.

Two-photon absorption of bacteriorhodopsin: formation of a red-shifted thermally stable photoproduct F620

By means of high-intensity 532 nm laser pulses, a photochemical conversion of the initial B(570) state of bacteriorhodopsin (BR) to a stable photoproduct absorbing maximally at approximately 620 nm in BR suspensions and at approximately 610 nm in BR films is induced. This state, which we named F(620), is photochemically further converted to a group of three products with maximal absorptions in the wavelength range from 340 nm to 380 nm, which show identical spectral properties to the so-called P(360) state reported in the literature. The photoconversion from B(570) to F(620) is most likely a resonant two-photon absorption induced step. The formation of F(620) and P(360) leads to a distinguished photo-induced permanent optical anisotropy in BR films. The spectral dependence of the photo-induced anisotropy and the anisotropy orientations at the educt (B(570)) and product (F(620)) wavelengths are strong indicators that F(620) is formed in a direct photochemical step from B(570). The chemical nature of the P(360) products probably is that of a retro-retinal containing BR, but the structural characteristics of the F(620) state are still unclear. The photo-induced permanent anisotropy induced by short laser pulses in BR films helps to better understand the photochemical pathways related to this transition, and it is interesting in view of potential applications as this feature is the molecular basis for permanent optical data storage using BR films.

Proton transfer reactions in native and deionized bacteriorhodopsin upon delipidation and monomerization

We have investigated the role of the native lipids on bacteriorhodopsin (bR) proton transfer and their connection with the cation-binding role. We observe that both the efficiency of M formation and the kinetics of M rise and decay depend on the lipids and lattice but, as the lipids are removed, the cation binding is a much less important factor for the proton pumping function. Upon 75% delipidation using 3-[(cholamidopropyl)dimethylammonio]-propanesulfonate (CHAPS), the M formation and decay kinetics are much slower than the native, and the efficiency of M formation is approximately 30%-40% that of the native. Upon monomerization of bR by Trition X-100, the efficiency of M recovers close to that of the native (depending on pH), M formation is approximately 10 times faster, and M decay kinetics are comparable to native at pH 7. The same results on the M intermediate are observed if deionized blue bR (deI bbR) is treated with these detergents (with or without pH buffers present), even though deionized blue bR containing all the lipids has no photocycle. This suggests that the cation(s) has a role in native bR that is different than in delipidated or monomerized bR, even so far as to suggest that the cation(s) becomes unimportant to the function as the lipids are removed.

The role of the native lipids and lattice structure in bacteriorhodopsin protein conformation and stability as studied by temperature-dependent Fourier transform-infrared spectroscopy

We report the effect of partial delipidation and monomerization on the protein conformational changes of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) as a function of temperature. Removal of up to 75% of the lipids is known to have the lattice structure of the purple membrane, albeit as a smaller unit cell, whereas treatment by Triton monomerizes bR into micelles. The effects of these modifications on the protein secondary structure is analyzed by monitoring the protein amide I and amide II bands in the Fourier transform-infrared (FT-IR) spectra. It is found that removal of the first 75% of the lipids has only a slight effect on the secondary structure at physiological temperature, whereas monomerizing bR into micelles alters the secondary structure considerably. Upon heating, the bR monomer is found to have a very low thermal stability compared with the native bR with its melting point reduced from 97 to 65 degrees C, and the pre-melting transition in which the protein changes conformation in native bR at 80 degrees C could not be observed. Also, the N[bond]H to N[bond]D exchange of the amide II band is effectively complete at room temperature, suggesting that there are no hydrophobic regions that are protected from the aqueous medium, possibly explaining the low thermal stability of the monomer. On the other hand, 75% delipidated bR has its melting temperature close to that of the native bR and does have a pre-melting transition, although the pre-melting transition occurs at significantly higher temperature than that of the native bR (91 degrees C compared with 80 degrees C) and is still reversible. Furthermore, we have also observed that the reversibility of this pre-melting transition of both native and partially delipidated bR is time-dependent and becomes irreversible upon holding at 91 degrees C between 10 and 30 min. These results are discussed in terms of the lipid and lattice contribution to the protein thermal stability of native bR.

Effect of metal ion exchange on the photocurrent response from bacteriorhodopsin on tin oxide electrodes

The transient photocurrent response from bacteriorhodopsin (bR) on tin oxide electrodes was strongly influenced by metal ions bound to bR molecules. The photocurrent polarity reversal pH, which corresponded to the pH value for the reversal of the proton release/uptake sequence in the bR photocycle, of cation-substituted purple membrane (PM) was shifted to lower pH with the increase in the cation affinities to carboxyl groups and a close correlation was noted between the two values. This suggests that the metal ion present in the extracellular region of a bR molecule modulates the pK(a) of proton release groups of bR by stabilizing the ionized state of the proton-releasing glutamic acids. The behavior of photocurrents at light-off in alkaline media, reflecting the proton uptake by bR, was unchanged by binding monovalent (Na(+) and K(+)) or divalent cations (Mg(2+) and Ca(2+)), but was drastically changed by binding La(3+) ions. This can be explained by invoking a substantial slowing of the proton uptake process in the presence of La(3+).

Contribution of extracellular Glu residues to the structure and function of bacteriorhodopsin. Presence of specific cation-binding sites

Single and multiple mutants of extracellular Glu side chains of bacteriorhodopsin were analyzed by acid and calcium titration, differential scanning calorimetry, and thermal difference spectrophotometry. Acid titration spectra show that the second group protonating with Asp(85) is revealed in E204Q in the absence of Cl(-) but is not observed in the triple mutant E9Q/E194Q/E204Q or in the quadruple mutant E9Q/E74Q/E194Q/E204Q. The results point to Glu(9) as the second group protonating cooperatively with Asp(85). Comparison of the apparent pK(a) of Asp(85) protonation in water and in the deionized forms and results of calcium titration suggest that cation-binding sites are of low affinity in the multiple Glu mutants. Like for deionized wild type bacteriorhodopsin, differential scanning calorimetry reveals a lack of the pretransition in the multiple mutants, whereas in E9Q it appears at lower temperature and with lower cooperativity. Additionally, at neutral pH the band at 630 nm arising from cation release upon temperature increase is absent for the multiple mutants. Based on these results, we propose the presence of two cation-binding sites in the extracellular region of bacteriorhodopsin having as ligands Glu(9), Glu(194), Glu(204), and water molecules.

Effects of pH and acetylation on Hg(2+)-induced purple to blue transition in bacteriorhodopsin

Effects of Hg(2+) ions on the absorption spectrum of bacteriorhodopsin have been measured at different pH values and after acetylation. UV-difference spectroscopy and CD spectra show that Hg(2+)-induced color change is essentially similar to that caused by removal of cations or acidification. The ability of Hg(2+)-induced purple-to-blue transition is pH-dependent and exhibits a maximum at pH 5.5. Acetylation influences the absorption in the same way as Hg(2+) ions and accelerates Hg(2+)-induced purple to blue transition. All these results strongly suggest that the Hg(2+) effect is not a specific binding but just a replacement of intrinsic cations on the membrane surface, where they form a double layer. The composition of the double layer determines the surface pH on the membrane, which affects the color of the bacteriorhodopsin.

Tryptophan fluorescence quenching by alkaline earth metal cations in deionized bacteriorhodopsin

Tryptophan quenching by the addition of alkaline earth metal cations to deionized bacteriorhodopsin suspensions was determined. The results show that the addition of cation primarily quenches fluorescence from surface tryptophan residues. The quenched intensity exhibits a 1/R dependence, where R is the ionic radius of the corresponding metal ion. This observation results from a stronger energy transfer coupling between the tryptophan and the retinal. The membrane curvature may be involved as a result of cations motion and correlated conformational changes.

The titrations of Asp-85 and of the cation binding residues in bacteriorhodopsin are not coupled

An outstanding problem relating to the structure and function of bacteriorhodopsin (bR), which is the only protein in the purple membrane of the photosynthetic microorganism Halobacterium salinarium, is the relation between the titration of Asp-85 and the binding/unbinding of metal cations. An extensively accepted working hypothesis has been that the two titrations are coupled, namely, protonation of Asp-85 (located in the vicinity of the retinal chromophore) and cation unbinding occur concurrently. We have carried out a series of experiments in which the purple blue equilibrium and the binding of Mn2+ ions (monitored by electron spin resonance) were followed as a function of pH for several (1-4) R = [Mn2+]/[bR] molar ratios. Data were obtained for native bR, bR mutants, artificial bR and chemically modified bR. We find that in the native pigment the two titrations are separated by more than a pKa unit [delta pKa = pKa(P/B)-pKa(Mn2+) = (4.2-2.8) = 1.4]. In the non-native systems, delta pKa values as high as 5 units, as well as negative delta pKas, are observed. We conclude that the pH titration of cation binding residues in bR is not directly related to the titration of Asp-85. This conclusion is relevant to the nature of the high affinity cation sites in bR and to their role in the photosynthetic function of the pigment.

Location of a cation-binding site in the loop between helices F and G of bacteriorhodopsin as studied by 13C NMR

The high-affinity cation-binding sites of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) were examined by solid-state 13C NMR of samples labeled with [3-13C]Ala and [1-13C]Val. We found that the 13C NMR spectra of two kinds of blue membranes, deionized (pH 4) and acid blue at pH 1.2, were very similar and different from that of the native purple membrane. This suggested that when the surface pH is lowered, either by removal of cations or by lowering the bulk pH, substantial change is induced in the secondary structure of the protein. Partial replacement of the bound cations with Na+, Ca2+, or Mn2+ produced additional spectral changes in the 13C NMR spectra. The following conclusions were made. First, there are high-affinity cation-binding sites in both the extracellular and the cytoplasmic regions, presumably near the surface, and one of the preferred cation-binding sites is located at the loop between the helix F and G (F-G loop) near Ala196, consistent with the 3D structure of bR from x-ray diffraction and cryoelectron microscopy. Second, the bound cations undergo rather rapid exchange (with a lifetime shorter than 3 ms) among various types of cation-binding sites. As expected from the location of one of the binding sites, cation binding induced conformational alteration of the F-G interhelical loop.

Photochemistry in dried polymer films incorporating the deionized blue membrane form of bacteriorhodopsin

The preparation and photochemical properties of dried deionized blue membrane (dIbR600; lambdamax approximately 600 nm, epsilon approximately 54, 760 cm-1 M-1, f approximately 1.1) in polyvinyl alcohol films are studied. Reversible photoconversion from dIbR600 to the pink membrane (dIbR485; lambdamax approximately 485 nm) is shown to occur in these films under conditions of strong 647-nm laser irradiation. The pink membrane analog, dIbR485, has a molar extinction coefficient of approximately 39,000 cm-1 M-1 (f approximately 1.2). The ratio of pink --> blue and blue --> pink quantum efficiencies is 33 +/- 5. We observe an additional blue-shifted species (dIbR455, lambdamax approximately 455 nm) with a very low oscillator strength (f approximately 0.6, epsilon approximately 26,000 cm-1 M-1). This species is the product of fast thermal decay of dIbR485. Molecular modeling indicates that charge/charge and charge/dipole interactions introduced by the protonation of ASP85 are responsible for lowering the excited-state all-trans --> 9-cis barrier to approximately 6 kcal mol-1 while increasing the corresponding all-trans --> 13-cis barrier to approximately 4 kcal mol-1. Photochemical formation of both 9-cis and 13-cis photoproducts are now competitive, as is observed experimentally. We suggest that dIbR455 may be a 9-cis, 10-s-distorted species that partially divides the chromophore into two localized conjugated segments with a concomitant blue shift and decreased oscillator strength of the lambdamax absorption band.

Experimental and theoretical characterization of the high-affinity cation-binding site of the purple membrane

Binding of Mn2+ or Mg2+ to the high-affinity site of the purple membrane from Halobacterium salinarium has been studied by superconducting quantum interference device magnetometry or by ab initio quantum mechanical calculations, respectively. The binding of Mn2+ cation, in a low-spin state, to the high-affinity site occurs through a major octahedral local symmetry character with a minor rhombic distortion and a coordination number of six. A molecular model of this binding site in the Schiff base vicinity is proposed. In this model, a Mg2+ cation interacts with one oxygen atom of the side chain of Asp85, with both oxygen atoms of Asp212 and with three water molecules. One of these water molecules is hydrogen bonded to both the nitrogen of the protonated Schiff base and the Asp85 oxygen. It could serve as a shuttle for the Schiff base proton to move to Asp85 in the L-M transition.

Titration kinetics of Asp-85 in bacteriorhodopsin: exclusion of the retinal pocket as the color-controlling cation binding site

The spectrum (the purple blue transition) and function of the light-driven proton pump bacteriorhodopsin are determined by the state of protonation of the Asp-85 residue located in the vicinity of the retinal chromophore. The titration of Asp-85 is controlled by the binding/unbinding of one or two divalent metal cations (Ca2+ or Mg2+). The location of such metal binding site(s) is approached by studying the kinetics of the cation-induced titration of Asp-85 using metal ions and large molecular cations, such as quaternary ammonium ions, R4N+ (R = Et, Pr, a divalent 'bolaform ion' [Et3N+-(CH2)4-N+Et3] and the 1:3 molecular complex formed between Fe2+ and 1,10-phenanthroline (OP). The basic multi-component kinetic features of the titration, extending from 10(-2) to 10(4) s, are unaffected by the charge and size of the cation. This indicates that cation binding to bR triggers the blue --> purple titration in a fast step, which is not rate-determining. In view of the size of the cations involved, these observations indicate that the cation binding site is in an exposed location on, or close to, the membrane surface. This excludes previous models, which placed the color-controlling Ca2+ ion in the retinal binding pocket.

Studies of cation binding in ZnCl2-regenerated bacteriorhodopsin by x-ray absorption fine structures: effects of removing water molecules and adding Cl- ions

The binding of Zn2+ in Zn2+-regenerated bacteriorhodopsin (bR) was studied under various conditions by x-ray absorption fine structures (XAFS). The 0.9:1 and 2:1 Zn2+:bR samples gave similar XAFS spectra, suggesting that Zn2+ might have only one strong binding site in bR. It was found that in aqueous bR solution, Zn2+ has an average of six oxygen or nitrogen ligands. Upon drying, two ligands are lost, suggesting the existence of two weakly bound water ligands near the cation-binding site in bacteriorhodopsin. When excess Cl- ions were present before drying in the Zn2+-regenerated bR samples, it was found that two of the ligands were replaced by Cl- ions in the dried film, whereas two remain unchanged. The above observations suggest that Zn2+ has three types of ligands in regenerated bR (referred to as types I, II, and III). Type I ligands are strongly bound. These ligands cannot be removed by drying or by exchanging with Cl- ions. Type II ligands cannot be removed by drying, but can be replaced by Cl- ligands. Type III ligands are weakly bound to the metal cation and are most likely water molecules that can be removed by evaporation under vacuum or by drying with anhydrous CaSO4. The results are discussed in terms of the possible structure of the strongly binding site of Zn2+ in bR.

An extended x-ray absorption fine structure study of the high-affinity cation-binding site in the purple membrane

The structure of the high-affinity cation-binding site of bacteriorhodopsin was studied using extended x-ray absorption fine structure techniques. The results obtained for Mn2+ in aqueous solution and for the complex BR-Mn2+ (1:1 molar ratio) show great similarities, suggesting that Mn2+, when bound to this site, is coordinated with six atoms of oxygen, forming an octahedral disposition. The interatomic distance between the atoms of oxygen and the Mn2+ was found to be 2.17 A for the complex BR-Mn2+, similar to Mn2+ in solution (2.15 A). In addition, the absence of any other peak at greater distances in the Fourier-transformed spectrum indicates that neither phosphorus nor sulphur atoms are present in the second coordination shell. This suggests that this binding site is located in the protein, discarding the proximity of lipid polar headgroups.

The Ca2+ binding to deionized monomerized and to retinal removed bacteriorhodopsin

In our continuing effort to characterize the metal cation binding in bacteriorhodopsin (bR) using Ca(2+)-specific electrodes, potentiometric titration was carried out on deionized solubilized bR (containing monomeric units) and deionized bacterioopsin (bR with its retinal removed). Scatchard plots were analyzed. The monomer was found to have plots similar to those of the trimer, suggesting that the binding sites in bR are localized within the protein monomer unit and not between the molecules within the trimer structure. This also supports the previous assumption that the curvature in the Scatchard plot of regenerated bR is not due to cooperativity of metal cation within the trimer, but rather due to multiple sites. Recent studies further support the finding that the curved Scatchard plot is not due to the cooperativity between the metal ions in the two high affinity sites, wherever they are. The results of the analysis of the Scatchard plot for deionized bacterioopsin have shown a change in the binding characteristics of the high affinity but not the low affinity sites from that observed in bR. This result supports previous conclusions that metal cations in the high affinity sites are not far from the retinal cavity.

Effects of genetic replacements of charged and H-bonding residues in the retinal pocket on Ca2+ binding to deionized bacteriorhodopsin

Metal cations are known to be required for proton pumping by bacteriorhodopsin (bR). Previous studies found that bR has two high-affinity and four to six low-affinity Ca(2+)-binding sites. In our efforts to find the location of these Ca2+ sites, the effects of replacing charged (Asp-85, Asp-212, and Arg-82) and H-bonding (Tyr-185) residues in the retinal pocket on the color control and binding affinity of Ca2+ ions in Ca(2+)-regenerated bR were examined. The important results are as follows: (i) The removal of Ca2+ from recombinant bR in which charged residues were replaced by neutral ones shifted the retinal absorption to the blue, opposite to that observed in wild-type bR or in recombinant bR in which the H-bonding residue, Tyr-185, was replaced by a non-H-bonding amino acid (Phe). (ii) Similar to the observation in wild-type bR, the binding of Ca2+ to the second site gave the observed color change in the recombinant bR samples in which charged residues were replaced by neutral ones. (iii) The residue replacements had no effect on the affinity constants of the four to six weakly bound Ca2+. (iv) The two high-affinity sites exhibited reduced affinity with substitutions; while the extent of the reduction depended on the specific substitution, each site was reduced by the same factor for each of the charged residue substitutions but by different factors for the mutant where Tyr-185 was replaced with Phe(Y185F). The above results suggest that the two Ca2+ ions in the two high-affinity sites are within interaction distance with one another and with the charged residues in the retinal pocket. The results further suggest that, while the interaction between Tyr-185 and the high-affinity Ca2+ ions is relatively short range and specific (with more coupling to the Ca2+ ion in the second affinity site), between the charged residues and Ca2+ ions it seems to be of the electrostatic (e.g., ion-ion) long range, nonspecific type. Although neither Asp-85, Asp-212, nor Arg-82 is individually directly involved in the binding of Ca2+ in these two sites, they might all participate in it. Together with the protonated Schiff base, the charged residues along with Tyr-185 and one or two Ca2+ ions (and probably a few water molecules) seem to form an electrostatically coupled system that is part of a cavity that controls the color and function of bR.

Influence of cation binding on the electro-optically determined electric moments of purple membranes

Analysis of the electro-optically determined permanent dipole moment and electric polarizability of purple membrane fragments reveals the complex nature of the membrane electric moments. The problem to distinguish between the contribution of the membrane structural charges (charged groups of the polypeptide chain and polar lipid headgroups), bound cations and the electric double layer structure deserves particular attention not only because of its importance for electro-optics but also in respect to the relation of the membrane surface electric properties to the membrane transport function. The removal of divalent cations (Ca2+ and Mg2+) bound to purple membrane in the native state induces a cation-free species of purple membrane (deionized--blue membrane) with drastically changed spectroscopic properties and function. The present paper summarizes our study on the electric moments of blue membrane and their changes during the blue to purple transition. We intended to provide an insight into the possible regulation of this reversible transition (purple-to-blue and blue-to-purple) through changes of the asymmetric charge distribution and the importance of the asymmetric interfacial charge distribution for the proton transfer in purple membranes. The changes in the electric moments (permanent and induced dipole moments) of purple membrane fragments upon di- and trivalent cations binding to cation-depleted purple membranes were studied by electric light scattering (rotational electrokinetics) in d.c. and a.c. electric fields, and by electric pulses with reversing polarity. The results show a recovery of the membrane charge asymmetry (permanent dipole moment) though not of the induced dipole moment.

Protein-chromophore interactions in bacteriorhodopsin: the effects of a change in surface potential

The chromophore retinal is bound to bacteriorhodopsin via a protonated Schiff base linkage. The retinal binding site is reported to be buried in the transmembrane portion of the protein, distant from the membrane surfaces. When bound to bacteriorhodopsin, the absorption maximum of retinal is red-shifted from 366 nm to 568 nm producing a purple color. This color persists across a wide pH range. However, when the pH is raised above 12.0, the membranes become pink in color, while at pH values of 3.0 or below, a blue color is produced. The blue color can also be obtained by removing the divalent cations bound to the surface of the protein. In this study, bacteriorhodopsin was examined by circular dichroism and absorption spectroscopy to determine if protein conformational changes were associated with the color shifts. It was found that although the retinal chromophore can be completely removed by bleaching with hydroxylamine with no significant influence on the secondary structure of the protein, a change in the surface charge of bacteriorhodopsin results in measurable conformational change in the protein, which apparently affects the nature of the retinal binding site.

The binding site of the strongly bound Eu3+ in Eu(3+)-regenerated bacteriorhodopsin

A Scatchard plot for the strongly bound Eu3+ to deionized bacteriorhodopsin (bR) was made using a method based on measuring the concentration of unbound Eu3+ from its fluorescence intensity. The results suggest that the first mole of Eu3+ added to a mole of bR is strongly bound by displacing 2-3 protons. In order to reconcile this result with the previous time-resolved fluorescence studies on Eu(3+)-regenerated bR, which showed the presence of 3 sites of comparable binding constants, one is forced to conclude that the emission from the strongly bound Eu3+ is completely quenched, e.g. by energy transfer to the retinal. For this to take place, the Eu3+ must be within a few A from the retinal, i.e. within the retinal pocket (the active site). The possible importance of this conclusion to the deprotonation mechanism of the protonated Schiff base, the switch of the proton pump in bR, is discussed.

Binding of a single divalent cation directly correlates with the blue-to-purple transition in bacteriorhodopsin

We have characterized a unique divalent cation binding site on bacteriorhodopsin which controls the blue-to-purple transition in the purple membrane of Halobacterium halobium. To identify this site we first showed the correlation between the binding of one Ca2+ per bacteriorhodopsin and the amount of blue membrane converted to purple membrane. When the free Ca2+ was reduced below 1 microM, and the pH was set below 5.0 with 0.5 mM citrate, only binding to this high-affinity site was observed, and we could separate its effect from the effect of other divalent cations binding to the membrane under other conditions. Second, the titration of purple membrane showed that protons are taken up in two distinct steps, about 13 with a pKa of 4-5 and an additional 2 protons with a pKa of 2.75, in 5 mM MgSO4. The latter is identical to the pKa for the purple-to-blue transition in 5 mM MgSO4. Taken together, these observations strongly suggest a direct role for cations in the regulation of the bacteriorhodopsin color under normal conditions. We have also found that the intrinsic pKa for the purple-to-blue transition is about 2.05, suggesting this is the pKa of the group or groups that, when protonated, lead to the blue membrane. Previously published data can now be interpreted to suggest that the cation regulates an active site near the retinal chromophore. A binding site for the divalent cation that includes Asp-212 and interactions with the protonated Schiff base, Asp-85, Tyr-57, Tyr-185, and Arg-82 is proposed.

Influence of the surface potential on the purple membrane structure and activity

The role of the divalent cations in the purple membrane is generally understood as the release mechanism of the blue form appearance. The reconstitution by cation addition leads to the recovery of the initial spectral properties. Numerous data are available in the literature on this matter but they are scattered, so that synthetic understanding is not easy. The role of divalent cations was studied through spectrophotometric titrations and electrophoretic mobility measurements, i.e., zeta potential valuations. Thus, correlations between the bacteriorhodopsin (bR) state and the whole membrane in equilibrium with a definite medium could be made. Deionization was not a fully reversible process. The absence of cations affect neither the rate of the M412 formation nor its lifetime but the yield of M412/bR was 50% lower. The number of protons involved in the blue to purple transition of both membranes was different and the reconstitution did not erase this difference. It was observed that the number of protons dissociated upon cation addition corresponded approximately to the number of positive charges removed by deionization. Electrophoretic mobility titrations showed large differences between the membranes, illustrating the influence of the surface charge density on the pK of the transition. Taking advantage of the reversible light adaptation process, the reciprocal influence of the charge density of the membrane surface and the retinal state in bR was shown. Specificity of the divalent cations was questioned by a direct substitution of them by imidazol, which left the membrane intact. The partial reversibility of the deionization, the decrease of the M412 yield, the differences in the titratable protons, and the nonstrict specificity toward divalent cations suggested that another unknown factor could be removed from the membrane.

Effect of a light-induced pH gradient on purple-to-blue and purple-to-red transitions of bacteriorhodopsin

Bacteriorhodopsin-containing vesicles that were able to alkalize the extravesicular medium by greater than 1.5 pH units under illumination, i.e., inside-out vesicles, were reconstituted by reverse-phase evaporation with Halobacterium halobium polar lipids or exogenous phospholipids. Acid titration of a dark-adapted sample was accompanied by a color change from purple to blue (pKa = 2.5-4.5 in 0.15 M K2SO4), and alkali titration resulted in the formation of a red species absorbing maximally at 480 nm (pKa = 7 to greater than 9), the pKa values and the extents of these color changes being dependent on the nature of lipid. When a vesicle suspension at neutral or weakly acidic pH was irradiated by continuous light so that a large pH gradient was generated across the membrane, either a purple-to-blue or a purple-to-red transition took place. The light-induced purple-to-red transition was significant in an unbuffered vesicle suspension and correlated with the pH change in the extravesicular medium. The result suggests that the purple-to-red transition is driven from the extravesicular side, i.e., from the C-terminal membrane surface. In the presence of buffer molecules outside, the dominant color change induced in the light was the purple-to-blue transition, which seemed to be due to a large decrease in the intravesicular pH. But an apparently inconsistent result was obtained when the extravesicular medium was acidified by a HCl pulse, which was accompanied by a rapid color change to blue. We arrived at the following explanation: The two bR isomers, one containing all-trans-retinal and the other 13-cis-retinal, respond differently to pH changes in the extravesicular and the intravesicular medium. In this relation, full light adaptation was not achieved when the light-induced purple-to-blue transition was significant; i.e., only the 13-cis isomer is likely to respond to a pH change at the N-terminal membrane surface.

Photoionization used as a tool for the study of biomembranes: fate of tetramethylbenzidine photocation in purple membrane

Photoionization of hydrophobic probes has been developed in micelles or synthetic vesicles. Studies of the yields, compartmentation, and lifetimes of the photo-produced charged species have gathered reliable information on the interfacial and structural properties of these assemblies. Such an approach has never been applied to biological membranes. The present system is tetramethylbenzidine as the probe in native or modified (deionized and/or bleached) purple membrane from halobacteria. The data on photocation formation yields (phi ion) and lifetimes (tau 1/2) allow two main conclusions to be made: (1) tetramethylbenzidine, as the cation, is buried in the membrane core, and (2) its incorporation does not alter the biological activity of the protein. In this biological membrane the photocation lifetime and yield present the same trend of variation with the surface potential but to less of an extent than in model membranes. Bleaching of purple membrane completely modifies the photoionization process and the photocation decay. In addition, these experiments reveal a tight correlation between membrane structure and probe photoionization. Further evidence for structural modification of purple membrane, either by deionization or by bleaching is pointed out.

Electrooptical studies on proton-binding and -release of bacteriorhodopsin

Electric field induced pH changes of purple membrane suspensions were investigated in the pH range from 4.1 to 7.6 by measuring the absorbance change of pH indicators. In connection with the photocycle and proton pump ability, three different states of bacteriorhodopsin were used: (1) the native purple bacteriorhodopsin (magnesium and calcium ions are bound, the M intermediate exists in the photocycle and protons are pumped), (2) the cation-depleted blue bacteriorhodopsin (no M intermediate), and (3) the regenerated purple bacteriorhodopsin which is produced either by raising the pH or by adding magnesium ions (the M intermediate exists). In the native purple bacteriorhodopsin there are, at least, two types of proton binding sites: one releases protons and the other takes up protons in the presence of the electric field. On the other hand, blue bacteriorhodopsin and the regenerated purple bacteriorhodopsin (pH increase) show neither proton release nor proton uptake. When magnesium ions are added to the suspensions, the field-induced pH change is observed again. Thus, the stability of proton binding depends strongly on the state of bacteriorhodopsin and differences in proton binding are likely to be related to differences in proton pump activity. Furthermore, it is suggested that the appearance of the M intermediate and proton pumping are not necessarily related.

High sensitivity electron diffraction analysis. A study of divalent cation binding to purple membrane

A sensitive high-resolution electron diffraction assay for change in structure is described and harnessed to analyze the binding of divalent cations to the purple membrane (PM) of Halobacterium halobium. Low-dose electron diffraction patterns are subject to a matched filter algorithm (Spencer, S. A., and A. A. Kossiakoff. 1980. J. Appl. Crystallogr. 13:563-571). to extract accurate values of reflection intensities. This, coupled with a scheme to account for twinning and specimen tilt in the microscope, yields results that are sensitive enough to rapidly quantitate any structure change in PM brought about by site-directed mutagenesis to the level of less than two carbon atoms. Removal of tightly bound divalent cations (mainly Ca2+ and Mg2+) from PM causes a color change to blue and is accompanied by a severely altered photocycle of the protein bacteriohodopsin (bR), a light-driven proton pump. We characterize the structural changes that occur upon association of 3:1 divalent cation to PM, versus membranes rendered purple by addition of excess Na+. High resolution, low dose electron diffraction data obtained from glucose-embedded samples of Pb2+ and Na+ reconstituted PM preparations at room temperature identify several sites with total occupancy of 2.01 +/- 0.05 Pb2+ equivalents. The color transition as a function of ion concentration for Ca2+ or Mg2+ and Pb2+ are strictly comparable. A (Pb2(+)-Na+) PM Fourier difference map in projection was synthesized at 5 A using the averaged data from several nominally untilted patches corrected for twinning and specimen tilt. We find six major sites located on helices 7, 5, 4, 3, 2 (nomenclature of Engelman et al. 1980. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 77:2023-2027) in close association with bR. These partially occupied sites (0.55-0.24 Pb2+ equivalents) represent preferential sites of binding for divalent cations and complements our earlier result by x-ray diffraction (Katre et al. 1986. Biophys. J. 50:277-284).

Substitution of amino acids in helix F of bacteriorhodopsin: effects on the photochemical cycle

The effects of amino acid substitutions in helix F of bacteriorhodopsin on the photocycle of this light-driven proton pump were studied. The photocycles of Ser-183----Ala and Glu-194----Gln mutants were qualitatively similar to that of wild-type bacteriorhodopsin produced in Escherichia coli and bacteriorhodopsin from Halobacterium halobium. The substitution of a Phe for either Trp-182 or Trp-189 significantly reduced the fraction of photocycling bacteriorhodopsin. The amino acid substitutions Tyr-185----Phe and Ser-193----Ala substantially increased the lifetime of the photocycle without substantially increasing the lifetime of the M photocycle intermediate. Similar results were also obtained with the Pro-186----Gly substitution. In contrast, replacing Pro-186 with the larger residue Leu inhibited the formation of the M photocycle intermediate. These results are consistent with a structural model of the retinal-binding pocket suggested by low-temperature UV/visible and Fourier transform infrared difference spectroscopies that has Trp-182, Tyr-185, Pro-186, and Trp-189 forming part of the binding pocket.