Class III alcohol dehydrogenase: consistent pattern complemented with the mushroom enzyme

Oikopleura dioica alcohol dehydrogenase class 3 provides new insights into the evolution of retinoic acid synthesis in chordates

Enzymes that synthesize retinoic acid (RA) constitute the first level of regulation of RA action. In vertebrates, enzymes of the medium-chain alcohol dehydrogenase (MDR-Adh) family catalyze the first step of the RA synthetic pathway by oxidizing retinol. Among MDR-Adh enzymes, Adh3 is the only member present in non-vertebrates, and whether Adh3 is actually involved in RA biosynthesis remains uncertain. Here, we investigate the MDR-Adh family in Oikopleura dioica, a urochordate representing the sister group to vertebrates. Oikopleura is of special interest because it has lost the classical RA role in development, which relaxed evolutionary constraints to preserve the RA-genetic machinery, leading to the loss of RA-system components. The hypothesis that Adh3 plays a role in RA synthesis predicts that the relaxation of selection in Oikopleura should have led to the loss of Adh3, or changes in residues related to retinol oxidation. The hypothesis also predicts changes in the expression pattern of Oikopleura Adh3 compared to other chordates that preserved RA-signaling. Our results, however, revealed the presence of a highly conserved Adh3 gene in Oikopleura, with no significant changes in functional residues. Our results also revealed that the Oikopleura Adh3 expression remains unchanged in comparison to other non-vertebrate chordates, restricted to specific compartments of the digestive system. Because Adh3 has been highly conserved in an animal that has dismantled the RA system, we conclude that Adh3 preservation is not due to a conserved role in RA synthesis. Thereby, if Adh3 plays a role in RA synthesis in vertebrates, it might be a lineage-specific neofunctionalization.

Analysis of planarian Adh3 supports an intron-rich architecture and tissue-specific expression for the urbilaterian ancestral form

The alcohol dehydrogenase class 3 enzyme (ADH3) is the presumed ancestral form of the medium-chain dehydrogenase-reductase ADH family. This enzyme has been involved in formaldehyde and nitric oxide metabolism of a variety of deuterostomes and ecdysozoan protostomes. We have now characterized the structure and expression of the Adh3 gene in the lophotrochozoan Schmidtea mediterranea, a freshwater planarian. The planarian gene expands over 8.7 kb and is organized into 7 exons. The 1340 bp long Adh3cDNA contains a 1137 bp open reading frame corresponding to a deduced protein of 379 amino acids. The protein sequence is consistent with that expected for a typical class III enzyme. Twenty out of the twenty-two amino acid positions associated with enzymatic roles are strictly preserved, which suggests that the enzymatic capabilities have been conserved. In situ hybridization experiments show that Adh3 is expressed along the intestine of S. mediterranea specimens. This is consistent with the pattern observed in invertebrates and in contrast with the widespread expression of vertebrate Adh3. The comparative study across bilateria, which now includes a lophotrochozoan representative, further supports the idea that the urbilaterian Adh3 ancestor showed an intron-rich architecture and tissue-specific expression, and strengthens the view that widespread expression of Adh3 was a vertebrate innovation.

Merging protein, gene and genomic data: the evolution of the MDR-ADH family

Multiple members of the MDR-ADH (MDR: Medium-chain dehydrogenases/reductases; ADH: alcohol dehydrogenase) family are found in vertebrates, although the enzymes that belong to this family have also been isolated from bacteria, yeast, plant and animal sources. Initial understanding of the physiological roles and evolution of the family relied on biochemical studies, protein alignments and protein structure comparisons. Subsequently, studies at the genetic level yielded new information: the expression pattern, exon-intron distribution, in silico-derived protein sequences and murine knockout phenotypes. More recently, genomic and EST databases have revealed new family members and the chromosomal location and position in the cluster of both the first and new forms. The data now available provide a comprehensive scenario, from which a reliable picture of the evolutionary history of this family can be made.