Two new structured intermediates in the oxidative folding of RNase A

The Non-native Disulfide-Bond-Containing Landscape Orthogonal to the Oxidative Protein-Folding Trajectory: A Necessary Evil?

Oxidative protein folding describes the process by which disulfide-bond-containing proteins mature from their ribosomal, fully reduced and unfolded, origins. Over the past 40 years, a number of exemplar proteins including bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNaseA), bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor (BPTI), and hen egg-white lysozyme (HEWL), among others, have provided rich insight into the nature of the intermolecular interactions that drive the formation of the native, biologically active fold. In this Review Article, we revisit the oxidative folding process of RNase A with a focus on reconciling the role of non-native disulfide-bond-containing species that populate the oxidative folding landscape. Toward gaining such an understanding, we project the regeneration pathway onto a Cartesian coordinate system. This helps not only to recognize the magnitude of the seemingly "fruitless", non-native disulfide-bond-containing species that lie orthogonal to the "native-protein-forming" reaction progress but also to reconcile a role for their existence in the regenerative trajectory. Finally, we superimpose the folding funnel onto the regeneration trajectory to draw parallels between oxidative folders and conformational folders (proteins that lack disulfide bonds). The overall objective is to provide the reader with a semi-quantitative description of oxidative protein folding and the barriers to successful regeneration while underscoring a role of seemingly fruitless intermediates.

Securing Native Disulfide Bonds in Disulfide-Coupled Protein Folding Reactions: The Role of Intrinsic and Extrinsic Elements vis-à-vis Protein Aggregation and Neurodegeneration

Disulfide bonds play an important role in physiology and are the mainstay of proteins that reside in the plasma membrane and of those that are secreted outside the cell. Disulfide-bond-containing proteins comprise ∼30% of all eukaryotic proteins. Using bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A) as an exemplar, we review the regeneration (oxidative folding) of disulfide-bond-containing proteins from their fully reduced state to the biologically active form. We discuss the key aspects of the oxidative folding landscape w.r.t. the acquisition and retention of native disulfide bonds which is an essential requirement for the polypeptide to be biologically functional. By re-examining the regeneration trajectory in light of the symbiotic relationship between native disulfide bonds and a protective structure, we describe the elements that compete with the processes that secure native disulfide bonds in disulfide-coupled protein folding. The impact of native-disulfide-bond formation on protein stability, trafficking, protein misfolding, and neurodegenerative onset is elaborated upon.

The Formation of Native Disulfide Bonds: Treading a Fine Line in Protein Folding

The folding of proteins that contain disulfide bonds is termed oxidative protein folding. It involves a chemical reaction resulting in the formation of disulfide bonds and a physical conformational folding reaction that promotes the formation of the native structure. While the presence of disulfide bonds significantly increases the complexity of the folding landscape, it is generally recognized that native disulfide bonds help funnel the trajectory towards the final folded form. Here, we review the role of disulfide bonds in oxidative protein folding and argue that even structure-inducing native disulfide bond formation treads a fine line in the regeneration of disulfide-bond-containing proteins. The translation of this observation to protein misfolding related disorders is discussed.

Flexible Folding: Disulfide-Containing Peptides and Proteins Choose the Pathway Depending on the Environments

In the last few decades, development of novel experimental techniques, such as new types of disulfide (SS)-forming reagents and genetic and chemical technologies for synthesizing designed artificial proteins, is opening a new realm of the oxidative folding study where peptides and proteins can be folded under physiologically more relevant conditions. In this review, after a brief overview of the historical and physicochemical background of oxidative protein folding study, recently revealed folding pathways of several representative peptides and proteins are summarized, including those having two, three, or four SS bonds in the native state, as well as those with odd Cys residues or consisting of two peptide chains. Comparison of the updated pathways with those reported in the early years has revealed the flexible nature of the protein folding pathways. The significantly different pathways characterized for hen-egg white lysozyme and bovine milk α-lactalbumin, which belong to the same protein superfamily, suggest that the information of protein folding pathways, not only the native folded structure, is encoded in the amino acid sequence. The application of the flexible pathways of peptides and proteins to the engineering of folded three-dimensional structures is an interesting and important issue in the new realm of the current oxidative protein folding study.

Revisiting the Formation of a Native Disulfide Bond: Consequences for Protein Regeneration and Beyond

Oxidative protein folding involves the formation of disulfide bonds and the regeneration of native structure (N) from the fully reduced and unfolded protein (R). Oxidative protein folding studies have provided a wealth of information on underlying physico-chemical reactions by which disulfide-bond-containing proteins acquire their catalytically active form. Initially, we review key events underlying oxidative protein folding using bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A), bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor (BPTI) and hen-egg white lysozyme (HEWL) as model disulfide bond-containing folders and discuss consequential outcomes with regard to their folding trajectories. We re-examine the findings from the same studies to underscore the importance of forming native disulfide bonds and generating a “native-like” structure early on in the oxidative folding pathway. The impact of both these features on the regeneration landscape are highlighted by comparing ideal, albeit hypothetical, regeneration scenarios with those wherein a native-like structure is formed relatively “late” in the R→N trajectory. A special case where the desired characteristics of oxidative folding trajectories can, nevertheless, stall folding is also discussed. The importance of these data from oxidative protein folding studies is projected onto outcomes, including their impact on the regeneration rate, yield, misfolding, misfolded-flux trafficking from the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) to the cytoplasm, and the onset of neurodegenerative disorders.

Oxidative Protein Folding Using trans-3,4-Dihydroxyselenolane Oxide

trans-3,4-Dihydroxyselenolane oxide (DHS^ox), a water-soluble cyclic selenoxide reagent, is useful for rapid and quantitative formation of disulphide (SS) bonds in a reduced state of SS-containing proteins because the selenoxide is a strong but selective oxidant for thiol substrates (RSH) in a wide range of pH. Due to this advantage over common disulphide reagents, such as oxidized dithiothreitol (DTT^ox) and glutathione (GSSG), DHS^ox enables clear characterization of oxidative folding pathways of proteins. DHS^ox is also useful for facile diagnosis of weakly folded structure, or reactivity (i.e., pK_a) of the thiols, present in a reduced polypeptide chain and the partially oxidized folding intermediates, identification of the key SS intermediates that can be oxidized directly to the native state, and preparation of SS-scrambled misfolded protein species. In this chapter, these diverse utilities of DHS^ox in protein folding study are demonstrated.

The Structure-Forming Juncture in Oxidative Protein Folding: What Happens in the ER?

The folding of disulfide bond containing proteins proceeds in a biphasic manner. Initially, cysteines are oxidized to form disulfide bonds. Structure is largely absent during this phase. Next, when a minimally correct number of native linkages of disulfide bonds have been acquired, the biopolymer conformationally folds into the native, or a native-like, state. Thus, at the end of this "oxidative folding" process, a stable and biologically active protein is formed. This review focuses on dissecting the "structure-forming step" in oxidative protein folding. The ability to follow this pivotal step in protein maturation in somewhat detail is uniquely facilitated in "oxidative" folding scenarios. We review this step using bovine pancreatic Ribonuclease A as a model while recognizing the impact that this step has in subcellular trafficking and protein aggregation.

Kinetic and thermodynamic analysis of the conformational folding process of SS-reduced bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A using a selenoxide reagent with high oxidizing ability

Redox-coupled folding pathways of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A) with four intramolecular disulfide (SS) bonds comprise three phases: (I) SS formation to generate partially oxidized intermediate ensembles with no rigid folded structure; (II) SS rearrangement from the three SS intermediate ensemble (3S) to the des intermediates having three native SS linkages; (III) final oxidation of the last native SS linkage to generate native RNase A. We previously demonstrated that DHS^ox, a water-soluble selenoxide reagent for rapid and quantitative SS formation, allows clear separation of the three folding phases. In this study, the main conformational folding phase (phase II) has been extensively analyzed at pH 8.0 under a wide range of temperatures (5–45 °C), and thermodynamic and kinetic parameters for the four des intermediates were determined. The free-energy differences (ΔG) as a function of temperature suggested that the each SS linkage has different thermodynamic and kinetic roles in stability of the native structure. On the other hand, comparison of the rate constants and the activation energies for 3S → des with those reported for the conformational folding of SS-intact RNase A suggested that unfolded des species (desU) having three native SS linkages but not yet being folded are involved in very small amounts (<1%) in the 3S intermediate ensemble and the desU species would gain the native-like structures via X-Pro isomerization like SS-intact RNase A. It was revealed that DHS^ox is useful for kinetic and thermodynamic analysis of the conformational folding process on the oxidative folding pathways of SS-reduced proteins.

Characterization of kinetic and thermodynamic phases in the prefolding process of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A coupled with fast SS formation and SS reshuffling

In the redox-coupled oxidative folding of a protein having several SS bonds, two folding phases are usually observed, corresponding to SS formation (oxidation) with generation of weakly stabilized heterogeneous structures (a chain-entropy losing phase) and the subsequent intramolecular SS rearrangement to search for the native SS linkages (a conformational folding phase). By taking advantage of DHS(ox) as a highly strong and selective oxidant, the former SS formation phase was investigated in detail in the oxidative folding of RNase A. The folding intermediates obtained at 25 °C and pH 4.0 within 1 min (1S°-4S°) showed different profiles in the HPLC chromatograms from those of the intermediates obtained at pH 7.0 and 10.0 (1S-4S). However, upon prolonged incubation at pH 4.0 the profiles of 1S°-3S° transformed slowly to those similar to 1S-3S intermediate ensembles via intramolecular SS reshuffling, accompanying significant changes in the UV and fluorescence spectra but not in the CD spectrum. Similar conversion of the intermediates was observed by pH jump from 4.0 to 8.0, while the opposite conversion from 1S-4S was observed by addition of guanidine hydrochloride to the folding solution at pH 8.0. The results demonstrated that the preconformational folding phase coupled with SS formation can be divided into two distinct subphases, a kinetic (or stochastic) SS formation phase and a thermodynamic SS reshuffling phase. The transition from kinetically formed to thermodynamically stabilized SS intermediates would be induced by hydrophobic nucleation as well as generation of the native interactions.

Disulfide-linked protein folding pathways

Determining the mechanism by which proteins attain their native structure is an important but difficult problem in basic biology. The study of protein folding is difficult because it involves the identification and characterization of folding intermediates that are only very transiently present. Disulfide bond formation is thermodynamically linked to protein folding. The availability of thiol trapping reagents and the relatively slow kinetics of disulfide bond formation have facilitated the isolation, purification, and characterization of disulfide-linked folding intermediates. As a result, the folding pathways of several disulfide-rich proteins are among the best known of any protein. This review discusses disulfide bond formation and its relationship to protein folding in vitro and in vivo.

Impact of an easily reducible disulfide bond on the oxidative folding rate of multi-disulfide-containing proteins

The burial of native disulfide bonds, formed within stable structure in the regeneration of multi-disulfide-containing proteins from their fully reduced states, is a key step in the folding process, as the burial greatly accelerates the oxidative folding rate of the protein by sequestering the native disulfide bonds from thiol-disulfide exchange reactions. Nevertheless, several proteins retain solvent-exposed disulfide bonds in their native structures. Here, we have examined the impact of an easily reducible native disulfide bond on the oxidative folding rate of a protein. Our studies reveal that the susceptibility of the (40-95) disulfide bond of Y92G bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A) to reduction results in a reduced rate of oxidative regeneration, compared with wild-type RNase A. In the native state of RNase A, Tyr 92 lies atop its (40-95) disulfide bond, effectively shielding this bond from the reducing agent, thereby promoting protein oxidative regeneration. Our work sheds light on the unique contribution of a local structural element in promoting the oxidative folding of a multi-disulfide-containing protein.

pH dependence of the isomerase activity of protein disulfide isomerase: insights into its functional relevance

The isomerase efficacy of the oxidoreductase, protein disulfide isomerase (PDI), has been examined by a simple method. Using this technique, the pH-dependence of relative efficiency of isomerization reactions by PDI has been evaluated and its impact on a key structure-forming step in the oxidative folding pathway of a model protein determined. Results reveal that PDI has a greater relative impact on thiol-disulfide reshuffling (isomerization) reactions and consequently the structure-forming step in oxidative folding at pH 7, as opposed to pH's 8 and 9. These results suggest that PDI, which possesses an anomalously low thiol pKa, is fine-tuned to catalyze oxidative folding in the lumen of the endoplasmic reticulum where the ambient pH of approximately 7 would otherwise retard thioldisulfide exchange reactions and hinder acquisition of the native fold. The pH-dependent impact on isomerization catalysis has important implications for the development of synthetic chaperones for in vivo and in vitro applications.

Oxidative folding and N-terminal cyclization of onconase

Cyclization of the N-terminal glutamine residue to pyroglutamic acid in onconase, an anti-cancer chemotherapeutic agent, increases the activity and stability of the protein. Here, we examine the correlated effects of the folding/unfolding process and the formation of this N-terminal pyroglutamic acid. The results in this study indicate that cyclization of the N-terminal glutamine has no significant effect on the rate of either reductive unfolding or oxidative folding of the protein. Both the cyclized and uncyclized proteins seem to follow the same oxidative folding pathways; however, cyclization altered the relative flux of the protein in these two pathways by increasing the rate of formation of a kinetically trapped intermediate. Glutaminyl cyclase (QC) catalyzed the cyclization of the unfolded, reduced protein but had no effect on the disulfide-intact, uncyclized, folded protein. The structured intermediates of uncyclized onconase were also resistant to QC catalysis, consistent with their having a native-like fold. These observations suggest that, in vivo, cyclization takes place during the initial stages of oxidative folding, specifically, before the formation of structured intermediates. The competition between oxidative folding and QC-mediated cyclization suggests that QC-catalyzed cyclization of the N-terminal glutamine in onconase occurs in the endoplasmic reticulum, probably co-translationally.

A framework for describing topological frustration in models of protein folding

In a natively folded protein of moderate or larger size, the protein backbone may weave through itself in complex ways, raising questions about what sequence of events might have to occur in order for the protein to reach its native configuration from the unfolded state. A mathematical framework is presented here for describing the notion of a topological folding barrier, which occurs when a protein chain must pass through a hole or opening, formed by other regions of the protein structure. Different folding pathways encounter different numbers of such barriers and therefore different degrees of frustration. A dynamic programming algorithm finds the optimal theoretical folding path and minimal degree of frustration for a protein based on its natively folded configuration. Calculations over a database of protein structures provide insights into questions such as whether the path of minimal frustration might tend to favor folding from one or from many sites of folding nucleation, or whether proteins favor folding around the N terminus, thereby providing support for the hypothesis that proteins fold co-translationally. The computational methods are applied to a multi-disulfide bonded protein, with computational findings that are consistent with the experimentally observed folding pathway. Attention is drawn to certain complex protein folds for which the computational method suggests there may be a preferred site of nucleation or where folding is likely to proceed through a relatively well-defined pathway or intermediate. The computational analyses lead to testable models for protein folding.

Hydrophobic collapse in (in silico) protein folding

A model of hydrophobic collapse, which is treated as the driving force for protein folding, is presented. This model is the superposition of three models commonly used in protein structure prediction: (1) 'oil-drop' model introduced by Kauzmann, (2) a lattice model introduced to decrease the number of degrees of freedom for structural changes and (3) a model of the formation of hydrophobic core as a key feature in driving the folding of proteins. These three models together helped to develop the idea of a fuzzy-oil-drop as a model for an external force field of hydrophobic character mimicking the hydrophobicity-differentiated environment for hydrophobic collapse. All amino acids in the polypeptide interact pair-wise during the folding process (energy minimization procedure) and interact with the external hydrophobic force field defined by a three-dimensional Gaussian function. The value of the Gaussian function usually interpreted as a probability distribution is treated as a normalized hydrophobicity distribution, with its maximum in the center of the ellipsoid and decreasing proportionally with the distance versus the center. The fuzzy-oil-drop is elastic and changes its shape and size during the simulated folding procedure.

Evidence for the underlying cause of diversity of the disulfide folding pathway

The pathways of oxidative folding of disulfide proteins exhibit a high degree of diversity, which is illustrated by the varied extent of (a) the heterogeneity of folding intermediates, (b) the predominance of intermediates containing native disulfide bonds, and (c) the level of accumulation of fully oxidized scrambled isomers as intermediates. BPTI and hirudin exemplify two extreme cases of such divergent folding pathways. We previously proposed that the underlying cause of this diversity is associated with the degree of stability of protein subdomains. Here we present compelling evidence that substantiates this hypothesis by studying the folding pathway of alphaLA-IIA. alphaLA-IIA is a partially folded intermediate of alpha-lactalbumin (alphaLA). It comprises a structured beta-sheet (calcium-binding) domain linked by two native disulfide bonds (Cys(61)-Cys(77) and Cys(73)-Cys(91)) and a disordered alpha-helical domain with four free cysteines (Cys(6), Cys(28), Cys(111), and Cys(120)). Purified alphaLA-IIA was allowed to refold without and with stabilization of its structured beta-sheet domain by calcium. In the absence of calcium, the folding pathway of alphaLA-IIA resembles that of hirudin, displaying a highly heterogeneous population of folding intermediates, including fully oxidized scrambled species. Upon stabilization of its beta-sheet domain by bound calcium, oxidative folding of alphaLA-IIA undergoes a pathway conspicuously similar to that of BPTI, exhibiting limited species of folding intermediates containing mostly native disulfide bonds.

Characterization of the fast-forming intermediate, des [30-75], in the reductive unfolding of onconase

A fast-forming intermediate in the reductive unfolding of frog onconase (ONC), des [30-75], analogous to the des [40-95] intermediate found in the reductive unfolding of its structural homologue, bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A), has been isolated and characterized. The midpoints of the thermal transition and chemical denaturing curves (representing global unfolding) indicate that the conformation of des [30-75] is considerably less stable than that of the parent molecule, suggesting that the (30-75) disulfide bond plays a significant role in the conformational stability of ONC. While des [30-75] is formed very quickly by a partial reduction of the parent molecule in a local unfolding step, it is not as easily susceptible to further reduction, indicating that its three disulfides are much more buried compared to the (30-75) disulfide bond in the parent protein. The nature of des [30-75] is similar to that of des [40-95] RNase A, in that des [30-75] ONC is also a disulfide-secure species. In addition, based on the resistance to mild reducing conditions, structured des species appear to form in ONC from unstructured three-disulfide-containing ensembles. This step is key in the oxidative folding of RNaseA, and is much faster in ONC than the formation of the structured des [40-95] species in RNase A.

Role of kinetic intermediates in the folding of leech carboxypeptidase inhibitor

The oxidative folding and reductive unfolding pathways of leech carboxypeptidase inhibitor (LCI; four disulfides) have been characterized in this work by structural and kinetic analysis of the acid-trapped folding intermediates. The oxidative folding of reduced and denatured LCI proceeds rapidly through a sequential flow of 1-, 2-, 3-, and 4-disulfide (scrambled) species to reach the native form. Folding intermediates of LCI comprise two predominant 3-disulfide species (designated as III-A and III-B) and a heterogeneous population of scrambled isomers that consecutively accumulate along the folding reaction. Our study reveals that forms III-A and III-B exclusively contain native disulfide bonds and correspond to stable and partially structured species that interconvert, reaching an equilibrium prior to the formation of the scrambled isomers. Given that these intermediates act as kinetic traps during the oxidative folding, their accumulation is prevented when they are destabilized, thus leading to a significant acceleration of the folding kinetics. III-A and III-B forms appear to have both native disulfides bonds and free thiols similarly protected from the solvent; major structural rearrangements through the formation of scrambled isomers are required to render native LCI. The reductive unfolding pathway of LCI undergoes an apparent all-or-none mechanism, although low amounts of intermediates III-A and III-B can be detected, suggesting differences in protection against reduction among the disulfide bonds. The characterization of III-A and III-B forms shows that the former intermediate structurally and functionally resembles native LCI, whereas the III-B form bears more resemblance to scrambled isomers.

Oxidative Folding of Amaranthus α-Amylase Inhibitor

Oxidative folding is the fusion of native disulfide bond formation with conformational folding. This complex process is guided by two types of interactions: first, covalent interactions between cysteine residues, which transform into native disulfide bridges, and second, non-covalent interactions giving rise to secondary and tertiary protein structure. The aim of this work is to understand both types of interactions in the oxidative folding of Amaranthus alpha-amylase inhibitor (AAI) by providing information both at the level of individual disulfide species and at the level of amino acid residue conformation. The cystine-knot disulfides of AAI protein are stabilized in an interdependent manner, and the oxidative folding is characterized by a high heterogeneity of one-, two-, and three-disulfide intermediates. The formation of the most abundant species, the main folding intermediate, is favored over other species even in the absence of non-covalent sequential preferences. Time-resolved NMR and photochemically induced dynamic nuclear polarization spectroscopies were used to follow the oxidative folding at the level of amino acid residue conformation. Because this is the first time that a complete oxidative folding process has been monitored with these two techniques, their results were compared with those obtained at the level of an individual disulfide species. The techniques proved to be valuable for the study of conformational developments and aromatic accessibility changes along oxidative folding pathways. A detailed picture of the oxidative folding of AAI provides a model study that combines different biochemical and biophysical techniques for a fuller understanding of a complex process.

Shifting the competition between the intramolecular Reshuffling reaction and the direct oxidation reaction during the oxidative folding of kinetically trapped disulfide-insecure intermediates

The oxidative folding pathway(s) of single-domain proteins can be characterized by the existence, stability, and structural nature of the intermediates that populate the regeneration pathway. Structured intermediates can be disulfide-secure in that they are able to protect their existing (native) disulfide bonds from SH/SS reshuffling and reduction reactions, and thereby form the native protein directly, i.e., by oxidation of their exposed (or locally exposable) thiols. Alternatively, they can be disulfide-insecure, usually requiring global unfolding to expose their free thiols. However, such an unfolding event also exposes the existing native disulfide bonds. Thus, the subsequent oxidation reaction to form the native protein in a disulfide-insecure intermediate competes with the intramolecular attack by the thiols of the macromolecule on its own native disulfide bonds, resulting in a large population of intermediates that are reshuffled instead of being oxidized. Under stabilizing conditions, disulfide-insecure species become long-lived kinetically trapped intermediates that slowly and only indirectly convert to the native protein through reshuffling reactions. In this study, trans-[Pt(en)(2)Cl(2)](2+), a strong oxidizing agent which has not traditionally been used in oxidative folding, was applied to shift the competition between reshuffling and oxidation reactions in des [58-110] and des [26-84], two long-lived disulfide-insecure intermediates of RNase A, and oxidize them directly under stable conditions to form the native protein. Such a successful direct conversion of kinetically trapped intermediates to the native molecule by trans-[Pt(en)(2)Cl(2)](2+) may be helpful in facilitating the oxidative folding processes of multi-disulfide-containing proteins in general.

Major kinetic traps for the oxidative folding of leech carboxypeptidase inhibitor

The leech carboxypeptidase inhibitor (LCI) is a 66-amino acid protein, containing four disulfides that stabilize its structure. This polypeptide represents an excellent model for the study and understanding of the diversity of folding pathways in small, cysteine-rich proteins. The pathway of oxidative folding of LCI has been elucidated in this work, using structural and kinetic analysis of the folding intermediates trapped by acid quenching. Reduced and denatured LCI refolds through a rapid, sequential flow of one- and two-disulfide intermediates and reaches a rate-limiting step in which a mixture of three major three-disulfide species and a heterogeneous population of non-native four-disulfide (scrambled) isomers coexist. The three three-disulfide intermediates have been identified as major kinetic traps along the folding pathway of LCI, and their disulfide structures have been elucidated in this work. Two of them contain only native disulfide pairings, and one contains one native and two non-native disulfide bonds. The coexistence of three-disulfide kinetic traps adopting native disulfide bonds together with a significant proportion of fully oxidized scrambled isomers shows that the folding pathway of LCI features properties exhibited by both the bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor and hirudin, two diverse models with extreme folding characteristics. The results further demonstrate the large diversity of disulfide folding pathways.

Interactions that favor the native over the non-native disulfide bond among residues 58-72 in the oxidative folding of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A

In the initial stages of the oxidative folding of both bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A) and a 58-72 fragment thereof from the fully reduced, denatured state, the 65-72 correctly paired disulfide bond forms in preponderance over the incorrectly paired 58-65 disulfide bond. Since both disulfide-bonded loops contain the same number of amino acid residues, the question arises as to whether the native pairing results from interactions within the 58-72 segment that lead to a nativelike structure even in its fully reduced form. To answer this question, the chain buildup procedure, based on ECEPP, including a solvation treatment, was used to generate the low-energy structures for the 58-72 RNase segment, beginning with residue 72 and building back to residue 58; in this fragment, all three Cys residues (at positions 58, 65, and 72) initially exist in the reduced (CysH) state. After the open-chain energy minima of the 65-72 peptide were generated, these conformations were allowed to form the 65-72 disulfide bond, and the energies of the resulting oxidized conformations were reminimized and rehydrated. The global minimum of the loop-closed 65-72 structure and many of the low-lying loop-closed minima could be superimposed on the energy-minimized X-ray structure for residues 65-72. The low-energy structures for the full open chain 58-72 peptide were then computed and were allowed to form disulfide bonds either between residues 65 and 72 (native) or between residues 58 and 65 (non-native), and their energies were reminimized and rehydrated in the loop-closed state. Although the overall fold of the 65-72 loop-closed global minimum was the same as for the energy-minimized X-ray structure of these residues, the overall rms deviation was 3.9 A because of local deviations among residues 58-64. In contrast, the 65-72 segment of the global minimum of the 58-72 fragment could be superimposed on the corresponding residues of the energy-minimized X-ray structure. The lowest-energy structure for the 58-65 non-native paired 58-72 sequence was 6 kcal/mol higher in energy than that for the 58-72 peptide with the 65-72 disulfide bond formed. These results suggest that the native pairing of the 65-72 peptide arises from energetic determinants (adoption of left-handed single-residue conformations by Gly 68, and side chain interactions involving Gln 69) contained within this peptide sequence.

Formation of the hydrophobic core of ribonuclease A through sequential coordinated conformational transitions

With steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence energy-transfer measurements, we determined the distributions of intramolecular distances in nine mutants to study the conformations of wild-type ribonuclease A in the reduced state under folding conditions. Although far-UV-CD measurements show no evidence for a secondary-structure transition, temperature- and GdnHCl-induced changes in intramolecular distance distributions in the reduced state revealed evidence for long-range subdomain structures in the denatured protein. These poorly defined structures, reflected here by wide distributions corresponding to a wide range of energies, form during refolding in a complex sequence of multiple subdomain transitions. A more well-defined structure emerges only when this structural framework, which directs the successive steps in the folding process, matures and is reinforced by stronger interactions such as disulfide bonds.

Biphasic reductive unfolding of ribonuclease A is temperature dependent

The kinetics of the reversible thermal unfolding, irreversible thermal unfolding, and reductive unfolding processes of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A) were investigated in NaCl/Pi solutions. Image parameters including Shannon entropy, Hamming distance, mutual information and correlation coefficient were used in the analysis of the CD and 1D NMR spectra. The irreversible thermal unfolding transition of RNase A was not a cooperative process, pretransitional structure changes occur before the main thermal denaturation. Different dithiothreitol (dithiothreitolred) concentration dependencies were observed between 303 and 313 K during denaturation induced by a small amount of reductive reagent. The protein selectively follows a major unfolding kinetics pathway with the selectivity can be altered by temperature and reductive reagent concentration. Two possible explanations of the selectivity mechanism were discussed.

Pathway of oxidative folding of alpha-lactalbumin: a model for illustrating the diversity of disulfide folding pathways

The pathway of oxidative folding of alpha-lactalbumin (alpha LA) (four disulfide bonds) has been characterized by structural and kinetic analysis of the acid-trapped folding intermediates. In the absence of calcium, oxidative folding of alpha LA proceeds through highly heterogeneous species of one-, two-, three-, and four-disulfide (scrambled) intermediates to reach the native structure. In the presence of calcium, the folding intermediates of alpha LA comprise two predominant isomers (alpha LA-IIA and alpha LA-IIIA) adopting exclusively native disulfide bonds, including the two disulfide bonds (Cys(61)-Cys(77) and Cys(73)-Cys(91)) located within the beta-sheet calcium binding domain. alpha LA-IIA is a two-disulfide species consisting of Cys(61)-Cys(77) and Cys(73)-Cys(91) disulfide bonds. alpha LA-IIIA contains Cys(61)-Cys(77), Cys(73)-Cys(91), and Cys(28)-Cys(111) disulfide bonds. The underlying mechanism of the contrasting folding pathways of calcium-bound and calcium-depleted alpha LA is congruent with the cause of diversity of disulfide folding pathways observed among many well-characterized three-disulfide proteins, including bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor and hirudin. Our study also reveals novel aspects of the folding mechanism of alpha LA that have not been described previously.

Effect of protein disulfide isomerase on the rate-determining steps of the folding of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A

The effects of protein disulfide isomerase (PDI) on the four structured des species that accumulate in the rate-determining steps of ribonuclease A folding were investigated at pH 8.0 and 15 degrees C. The results indicate that PDI catalyzes the conversion of the kinetically trapped intermediates, des-[26-84] and des-[58-110], by reshuffling them into the on-pathway intermediate, des-[40-95], and the formation of native protein, by acting as both a chaperone and an oxidase on this on-pathway intermediate. These results provide the first strong evidence for the mechanism of PDI in the rate-determining steps of the oxidative folding pathways of ribonuclease A. Our approach, using PDI and blocked PDI, combined with the fast-blocking 2-aminoethyl methanethiosulfonate method, may be generally applicable to the clarification of the effect of PDI on folding intermediates.

Conformational propensities of protein folding intermediates: distribution of species in the 1S, 2S, and 3S ensembles of the [C40A,C95A] mutant of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A

A key problem in experimental protein folding is that of characterizing the conformational ensemble of denatured proteins under folding conditions. We address this problem by studying the conformational propensities of reductively unfolded RNase A under folding conditions, since earlier work has indicated that the equilibrium conformational ensemble of fully reduced RNase A resembles the transient conformational ensemble of a burst-phase folding intermediate of disulfide-intact RNase A. To assess these propensities, the relative disulfide-bond populations of the 1S, 2S, and 3S ensembles of the [C40A,C95A] mutant of RNase A were measured. Thirteen of the fifteen possible disulfide bonds are observed, consistent with earlier results and with the rapid reshuffling and lack of stable tertiary structure in these ensembles. This broad distribution contradicts recent observations by another group, but rigorous cross-checks show unambiguously that our data are self-consistent whereas their data are not. The distributions of disulfide bonds in the wild-type and mutant proteins show a power-law dependence on loop length, with an exponent that is significantly smaller than the exponents of either ideal or excluded-volume polymers. The 65-72 disulfide bond is much more strongly favored than would be predicted by this power law, consistent with earlier peptide studies and the disulfide-bond distributions of the 1S and 2S ensembles in wild-type RNase A. Experimental evidence suggests that this preference results from conformational biases in the backbone, rather than from differing accessibilities or reactivities of the two cysteine residues. In general, the other disulfide species do not deviate significantly from the power-law dependence, indicating that the conformational biases are relatively weak.

Top down characterization of larger proteins (45 kDa) by electron capture dissociation mass spectrometry

The structural characterization of proteins expressed from the genome is a major problem in proteomics. The solution to this problem requires the separation of the protein of interest from a complex mixture, the identification of its DNA-predicted sequence, and the characterization of sequencing errors and posttranslational modifications. For this, the "top down" mass spectrometry (MS) approach, extended by the greatly increased protein fragmentation from electron capture dissociation (ECD), has been applied to characterize proteins involved in the biosynthesis of thiamin, Coenzyme A, and the hydroxylation of proline residues in proteins. With Fourier transform (FT) MS, electrospray ionization (ESI) of a complex mixture from an E. coli cell extract gave 102 accurate molecular weight values (2-30 kDa), but none corresponding to the predicted masses of the four desired enzymes for thiamin biosynthesis (GoxB, ThiS, ThiG, and ThiF). MS/MS of one ion species (representing approximately 1% of the mixture) identified it with the DNA-predicted sequence of ThiS, although the predicted and measured molecular weights were different. Further purification yielded a 2-component mixture whose ECD spectrum characterized both proteins simultaneously as ThiS and ThiG, showing an additional N-terminal Met on the 8 kDa ThiS and removal of an N-terminal Met and Ser from the 27 kDa ThiG. For a second system, the molecular weight of the 45 kDa phosphopantothenoylcysteine synthetase/decarboxylase (CoaBC), an enzyme involved in Coenzyme A biosynthesis, was 131 Da lower than that of the DNA prediction; the ECD spectrum showed that this is due to the removal of the N-terminal Met. For a third system, viral prolyl 4-hydroxylase (26 kDa), ECD showed that multiple molecular ions (+98, +178, etc.) are due to phosphate noncovalent adducts, and MS/MS pinpointed the overall mass discrepancy of 135 Da to removal of the initiation Met (131 Da) and to formation of disulfide bonds (2 x 2 Da) at C32-C49 and C143-C147, although 10 S-S positions were possible. In contrast, "bottom up" proteolysis characterization of the CoaBC and the P4H proteins was relatively unsuccessful. The addition of ECD substantially increases the capabilities of top down FTMS for the detailed structural characterization of large proteins.

Oxidative folding of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A: insight into the overall catalysis of the refolding pathway by phosphate

The effects of the strong stabilizing anion, phosphate, on the oxidative folding of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A were examined. Phosphate was found to catalyze several steps involved in the oxidative folding process at pH 8.0 and 25 degrees C, resulting in an increase in the rate of pre-equilibration of unstructured species on the folding pathway. In the presence of 400 mM phosphate, the overall increase in the rate of regeneration of native protein was caused primarily by the increased formation and stabilization of tertiary structure in the nativelike intermediates, des-[40-95] and des-[65-72], involved in the rate-determining step. Based on the regeneration of native protein and the stability of Cys--> Ala substituted mutant analogs of the des-species, (C40A, C95A) and (C65A, C72A), it is suggested that the primary role of phosphate is to catalyze the overall regeneration of native protein through nonspecific electrostatic and hydrogen-bonding effects on the protein and solvent.

Folding of a disulfide-bonded protein species with free thiol(s): competition between conformational folding and disulfide reshuffling in an intermediate of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A

The conformational folding of the nativelike intermediate des-[40-95] on the major oxidative folding pathway of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A) has been examined at various pHs and temperatures in the absence of a redox reagent. Des-[40-95] has three of the four disulfide bonds of native RNase A and lacks the bond between Cys40 and Cys95. This three-disulfide species was unfolded at low pH to inhibit any disulfide reshuffling and was refolded at higher pH, allowing both conformational folding and disulfide-reshuffling reactions to take place. As a result of this competition, 15-85% of des-[40-95], depending on the experimental conditions, undergoes intramolecular disulfide-reshuffling reactions. That portion of the des-[40-95] population which has native isomers of essential proline residues appears to fold faster than the disulfide reaction can occur. However, when the folding is retarded, conceivably by the presence of non-native isomers of essential proline residues, des-[40-95] may reshuffle before completing the conformational folding process. These results enable us to distinguish among current models for the critical structure-forming step in oxidative folding and reveal a new model for coupling proline isomerization to disulfide-bond formation. These experiments also demonstrate that the reshuffling-folding competition assay is a useful tool for detecting structured populations in conformational folding intermediates.

Hierarchical protein folding: asymmetric unfolding of an insulin analogue lacking the A7-B7 interchain disulfide bridge

The landscape paradigm of protein folding can enable preferred pathways on a funnel-like energy surface. Hierarchical preferences may be manifest as a nonrandom pathway of disulfide pairing. Stepwise stabilization of structural subdomains among on-pathway intermediates is proposed to underlie the disulfide pathway of proinsulin and related molecules. Here, effects of pairwise serine substitution of insulin's exposed interchain disulfide bridge (Cys(A7)-Cys(B7)) are characterized as a model of a late intermediate. Untethering cystine A7-B7 in an engineered monomer causes significantly more marked decreases in the thermodynamic stability and extent of folding than occur on pairwise substitution of internal cystine A6-A11 [Weiss, M. A., Hua, Q. X., Jia, W., Chu, Y. C., Wang, R. Y., and Katsoyannis, P. G. (2000) Biochemistry 39, 15429-15440]. Although substantially disordered and without significant biological activity, the untethered analogue contains a molten subdomain comprising cystine A20-B19 and a native-like cluster of hydrophobic side chains. Remarkably, A and B chains make unequal contributions to this folded moiety; the B chain retains native-like supersecondary structure, whereas the A chain is largely disordered. These observations suggest that the B subdomain provides a template to guide folding of the A chain. Stepwise organization of insulin-like molecules supports a hierarchic view of protein folding.

Coupling of conformational folding and disulfide-bond reactions in oxidative folding of proteins

The oxidative folding of proteins consists of conformational folding and disulfide-bond reactions. These two processes are coupled significantly in folding-coupled regeneration steps, in which a single chemical reaction (the "forward" reaction) converts a conformationally unstable precursor species into a conformationally stable, disulfide-protected successor species. Two limiting-case mechanisms for folding-coupled regeneration steps are described. In the folded-precursor mechanism, the precursor species is preferentially folded at the moment of the forward reaction. The (transient) native structure increases the effective concentrations of the reactive thiol and disulfide groups, thus favoring the forward reaction. By contrast, in the quasi-stochastic mechanism, the forward reaction occurs quasi-stochastically in an unfolded precursor; i.e., reactive groups encounter each other with a probability determined primarily by loop entropy, albeit modified by conformational biases in the unfolded state. The resulting successor species is initially unfolded, and its folding competes with backward chemical reactions to the unfolded precursors. The folded-precursor and quasi-stochastic mechanisms may be distinguished experimentally by the dependence of their kinetics on factors affecting the rates of thiol--disulfide exchange and conformational (un)folding. Experimental data and structural and biochemical arguments suggest that the quasi-stochastic mechanism is more plausible than the folded-precursor mechanism for most proteins.

Effect of mutation of proline 93 on redox unfolding/folding of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A

Both the reductive unfolding and oxidative regeneration of a P93A mutant and wild-type RNase A have been studied at 15 degrees C and pH 8.0. The rate of reduction of the 40--95 disulfide bond is accelerated about 120-fold by the P93A mutation, while the reduction of the 65--72 disulfide bond is not accelerated by this mutation (within the experimental error). Moreover, the reduction of native P93A to des[40--95] is about 10 times faster than the further reduction of the same des[40--95] species. These results demonstrate that the reduction of the mutant proceeds through a local unfolding event and provides strong support for our model in which the reduction of wild-type RNase A to the des species proceeds through two independent local conformational unfolding events. The oxidative regeneration rate of the P93A mutant is comparable to that of wild-type RNase A, suggesting that a cis 92--93 peptide group that is present in native wild-type RNase A and in native des[40--95], is not obligatory for the formation of the third (final) native disulfide bond of des[40--95] by reshuffling from an unstructured 3S precursor. Thus, the trans to cis isomerization of the Tyr92-Pro93 peptide group during the regeneration of wild-type RNase A may occur after the formation of the third native disulfide bond.

Structural determinants of oxidative folding in proteins

A method for determining the kinetic fate of structured disulfide species (i.e., whether they are preferentially oxidized or reshuffle back to an unstructured disulfide species) is introduced. The method relies on the sensitivity of unstructured disulfide species to low concentrations of reducing agents. Because a structured des species that preferentially reshuffles generally first rearranges to an unstructured species, a small concentration of reduced DTT (e.g., 260 microM) suffices to distinguish on-pathway intermediates from dead-end species. We apply this method to the oxidative folding of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A) and show that des[40-95] and des[65-72] are productive intermediates, whereas des[26-84] and des[58-110] are metastable dead-end species that preferentially reshuffle. The key factor in determining the kinetic fate of these des species is the relative accessibility of both their thiol groups and disulfide bonds. Productive intermediates tend to be disulfide-secure, meaning that their structural fluctuations preferentially expose their thiol groups, while keeping their disulfide bonds buried. By contrast, dead-end species tend to be disulfide-insecure, in that their structural fluctuations expose their disulfide bonds in concert with their thiol groups. This distinction leads to four generic types of oxidative folding pathways. We combine these results with those of earlier studies to suggest a general three-stage model of oxidative folding of RNase A and other single-domain proteins with multiple disulfide bonds.

Distributions of intramolecular distances in the reduced and denatured states of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A. Folding initiation structures in the C-terminal portions of the reduced protein

The purpose of this investigation is to characterize the reduced state of RNase A (r-RNase A) in terms of (i) intramolecular distances, (ii) the sequence of formation of stable loops in the initial stages of folding, and (iii) the unfolding transitions induced by GdnHCl. This is accomplished by identifying specific subdomain structures and local and long-range interactions that direct the folding process of this protein and lead to the native fold and formation of the disulfide bonds. Eleven pairs of dispersed sites in the RNase A molecule were labeled with fluorescent donor and acceptor probes, and the distributions of intramolecular distances (IDDs) were determined by means of time-resolved dynamic nonradiative excitation energy transfer (TR-FRET) measurements. The mutants were designed to search for (a) a possible nonrandom fold of the backbone in the collapsed state and (b) possible loops stabilized by long-range interactions. It was found that, under folding conditions, (i) the labeled mutants of r-RNase A in refolding buffer (the R(N) state) exhibit features of specific (nonrandom) compact but very dispersed subdomain structures (indicated by short mean distances, broad IDDs, and a weak dependence of the mean distances on segment length), (ii) the backbone fold in the C-terminal beta-like portion of the molecule appears to adopt a native-like overall fold, (iii) the N-terminal alpha-like portion of the chain is separated from the C-terminal core by very large intramolecular distances, larger than those in the crystal structure, and (iv) perturbations by addition of GdnHCl reveal several conformational transitions in different sections of the chain. Addition of GdnHCl to the native disulfide-intact protein provided a reference state for the extent of expansion of intramolecular distances under denaturing conditions. In conclusion, r-RNase A under folding conditions (the R(N) state) is poised for the final folding step(s) with a native-like trace of the chain fold but a large separation between the two subdomains which is then decreased upon introduction of three of the four native disulfide cross-links.

Oxidative folding of proteins

The oxidative folding of proteins is reviewed and illustrated with bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A). The mutual effects of conformational folding and disulfide bond regeneration are emphasized, particularly the "locking in" of native disulfide bonds by stable tertiary structure in disulfide intermediates. Two types of structured metastable disulfide species are discerned, depending on the relative protection of their disulfide bonds and thiol groups. Four generic pathways for oxidative folding are identified and characterized.

Catalysis of the oxidative folding of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A by protein disulfide isomerase

The major oxidative folding pathways of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A at pH 8.0 and 25 degrees C involve a pre-equilibrium steady state among ensembles of intermediates with zero, one, two, three and four disulfide bonds. The rate-determining steps are the reshuffling of the unstructured three-disulfide ensemble to two native-like three-disulfide species, des-[65-72] and des-[40-95], that convert to the native structure during oxidative formation of the fourth disulfide bond. Under the same regeneration conditions, with oxidized and reduced DTT, used previously for kinetic oxidative-folding studies of this protein, the addition of 4 microM protein disulfide isomerase (PDI) was found to lead to catalysis of each disulfide-formation step, including the rate-limiting rearrangement steps in which the native-like intermediates des-[65-72] and des-[40-95] are formed. The changes in the distribution of intermediates were also determined in the presence and absence of PDI at three different temperatures (with the DTT redox system) as well as at 25 degrees C (with the glutathione redox system). The results indicate that the acceleration of the formation of native protein by PDI, which we observed earlier, is due to PDI catalysis of each of the intermediate steps without changing the overall pathways or folding mechanism.

Acceleration of oxidative folding of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A by anion-induced stabilization and formation of structured native-like intermediates

Phosphate anions accelerate the oxidative folding of reduced bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A with dithiothreitol at several temperatures and ionic strengths. The addition of 400 mM phosphate at pH 8.1 increased the regeneration rate of native protein 2.5-fold at 15 degrees C, 3.5-fold at 25 degrees C, and 20-fold at 37 degrees C, compared to the rate in the absence of phosphate. In addition, the effects of other ions on the oxidative folding of RNase A were examined. Fluoride was found to accelerate the formation of native protein under the same oxidizing conditions. In contrast, cations of high charge density or ions with low charge density appear to have an opposite effect on the folding of RNase A. The catalysis of oxidative folding results largely from an anion-dependent stabilization and formation of tertiary structure in productive disulfide intermediates (des-species). Phosphate and fluoride also accelerate the initial equilibration of unstructured disulfide ensembles, presumably due to non-specific electrostatic and hydrogen bonding effects on the protein and solvent.

Disulfide bonds and protein folding

The applications of disulfide-bond chemistry to studies of protein folding, structure, and stability are reviewed and illustrated with bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A). After surveying the general properties and advantages of disulfide-bond studies, we illustrate the mechanism of reductive unfolding with RNase A, and discuss its application to probing structural fluctuations in folded proteins. The oxidative folding of RNase A is then described, focusing on the role of structure formation in the regeneration of the native disulfide bonds. The development of structure and conformational order in the disulfide intermediates during oxidative folding is characterized. Partially folded disulfide species are not observed, indicating that disulfide-coupled folding is highly cooperative. Contrary to the predictions of "rugged funnel" models of protein folding, misfolded disulfide species are also not observed despite the potentially stabilizing effect of many nonnative disulfide bonds. The mechanism of regenerating the native disulfide bonds suggests an analogous scenario for conformational folding. Finally, engineered covalent cross-links may be used to assay for the association of protein segments in the folding transition state, as illustrated with RNase A.