Migration of 40 S ribosomal subunits on messenger RNA when initiation is perturbed by lowering magnesium or adding drugs

Distance-dependent inhibition of translation initiation by downstream out-of-frame AUGs is consistent with a Brownian ratchet process of ribosome scanning

BACKGROUND

Eukaryotic ribosomes are widely presumed to scan mRNA for the AUG codon to initiate translation in a strictly 5'-3' movement (i.e., strictly unidirectional scanning model), so that ribosomes initiate translation exclusively at the 5' proximal AUG codon (i.e., the first-AUG rule).

RESULTS

We generate 13,437 yeast variants, each with an ATG triplet placed downstream (dATGs) of the annotated ATG (aATG) codon of a green fluorescent protein. We find that out-of-frame dATGs can inhibit translation at the aATG, but with diminishing strength over increasing distance between aATG and dATG, undetectable beyond ~17 nt. This phenomenon is best explained by a Brownian ratchet mechanism of ribosome scanning, in which the ribosome uses small-amplitude 5'-3' and 3'-5' oscillations with a net 5'-3' movement to scan the AUG codon, thereby leading to competition for translation initiation between aAUG and a proximal dAUG. This scanning model further predicts that the inhibitory effect induced by an out-of-frame upstream AUG triplet (uAUG) will diminish as uAUG approaches aAUG, which is indeed observed among the 15,586 uATG variants generated in this study. Computational simulations suggest that each triplet is scanned back and forth approximately ten times until the ribosome eventually migrates to downstream regions. Moreover, this scanning process could constrain the evolution of sequences downstream of the aATG to minimize proximal out-of-frame dATG triplets in yeast and humans.

CONCLUSIONS

Collectively, our findings uncover the basic process by which eukaryotic ribosomes scan for initiation codons, and how this process could shape eukaryotic genome evolution.

Differential effects of nucleotide analogs on scanning-dependent initiation and elongation of mammalian mRNA translation in vitro

Codon-anticodon interactions are central to both the initiation and elongation phases of eukaryotic mRNA translation. The obvious difference is that the interaction takes place in the ribosomal A-site during elongation, whereas the 40S ribosomal subunit and associated initiation factors scan the mRNA sequence in search of an initiation codon with Met-tRNA(i) bound in the P-site, ceasing once codon-anticodon interaction is established at the AUG. As an indirect test of whether the two mechanisms of mRNA sequence inspection are basically similar or not, the effects of six different uridine analog substitutions in the mRNA were examined in reticulocyte lysate translation assays and 80S initiation complex formation assays. Four constructs, each with the same reporter coding sequence, were used, differing in whether the initiation codon was AUG or ACG, and in whether the 5'-UTR had U residues or not. Three analogs (5-bromoU, 5-aminoallylU, and pseudoU) inhibited both elongation and initiation, but the other three had striking differential effects. Ribothymidine had a negligible effect on elongation but caused a approximately 50% inhibition of initiation, with little effect on actual AUG recognition, which implies that inhibition must have occurred at some earlier step in initiation. In complete contrast, 2' deoxyU was prohibitive to elongation but had no effect on initiation, and 4-thioU actually stimulated initiation but quite strongly inhibited elongation processivity. These results show that the detailed mechanisms of inspection of the mRNA sequence during scanning-dependent initiation and elongation must be considerably different.

The mechanism of an exceptional case of reinitiation after translation of a long ORF reveals why such events do not generally occur in mammalian mRNA translation

The subgenomic mRNA of feline caliciviruses is bicistronic with the two cistrons overlapping by four nucleotides, ..AUGA. The upstream cistron encodes a 75-kDa major capsid protein precursor (pre-VP1), and the downstream cistron a 10-kDa minor capsid protein. The kinetics of translation in reticulocyte lysates show that the downstream cistron is translated by a termination-reinitiation process, which is unusual in not requiring eIF4G or the eIF4F complex. Reinitiation requires the 3'-terminal 87 nucleotides (nt) of the pre-VP1 ORF, but no other viral sequences. The reinitiation site is selected by virtue of its proximity to this 87-nt element, and not its proximity to the pre-VP1 ORF stop codon, although this must be located not more than approximately 30 nt downstream from the restart codon. This 87-nt element was shown to bind 40S ribosomal subunits and initiation factor eIF3, and addition of supplementary eIF3 enhanced reinitiation efficiency. Mutants defective in reinitiation showed reduced affinity for eIF3 or defective 40S subunit binding (or both). These results suggest a mechanism in which some of the eIF3/40S complexes formed during disassembly of post-termination ribosomes bind to this 87-nt element in a position appropriate for reinitiation following acquisition of an eIF2/GTP/Met-tRNA i ternary complex.

Alternative mechanisms of initiating translation of mammalian mRNAs

Of all the steps in mRNA translation, initiation is the one that differs most radically between prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Not only is there no equivalent of the prokaryotic Shine-Dalgarno rRNA-mRNA interaction, but also what requires only three initiation factor proteins (aggregate size approximately 125 kDa) in eubacteria needs at least 28 different polypeptides (aggregate >1600 kDa) in mammalian cells, which is actually larger than the size of the 40 S ribosomal subunit. Translation of the overwhelming majority of mammalian mRNAs occurs by a scanning mechanism, in which the 40 S ribosomal subunit, primed for initiation by the binding of several initiation factors including the eIF2 (eukaryotic initiation factor 2)-GTP-MettRNA(i) complex, is loaded on the mRNA immediately downstream of the 5'-cap, and then scans the RNA in the 5'-->3' direction. On recognition of (usually) the first AUG triplet via base-pairing with the Met-tRNA(i) anticodon, scanning ceases, triggering GTP hydrolysis and release of eIF2-GDP. Finally, ribosomal subunit joining and the release of the other initiation factors completes the initiation process. This sketchy outline conceals the fact that the exact mechanism of scanning and the precise roles of the initiation factors remain enigmatic. However, the factor requirements for initiation site selection on some viral IRESs (internal ribosome entry sites/segments) are simpler, and investigations into these IRES-dependent mechanisms (particularly picornavirus, hepatitis C virus and insect dicistrovirus IRESs) have significantly enhanced our understanding of the standard scanning mechanism. This article surveys the various alternative mechanisms of initiation site selection on mammalian (and other eukaryotic) cellular and viral mRNAs, starting from the simplest (in terms of initiation factor requirements) and working towards the most complex, which paradoxically happens to be the reverse order of their discovery.

Studies on the posttranscriptional site of cAMP action in the regulation of the synthesis of tyrosine aminotransferase

Synthesis of L-tyrosine:2-oxoglutarate aminotransferase (EC 2.6.1.5) can be induced by N6,O2'-dibutyryl-adenosine 3',5'-monophosphate (Bt2cAMP) in Reuber H35 cell cultures. Actinomycin D fails to block this induction which indicates a target for Bt2cAMP at a posttranscriptional level. We have determined the influence of Bt2cAMP on several translational events during the tyrosine aminotransferase synthesis with the following results. (1) The number of nascent tyrosine aminotransferase chains increased, whereas no effect was measured on the number of nascent total protein chains. (2) The rate of elongation along the tyrosine aminotransferase mRNA and total mRNA is not enhanced by Bt2cAMP. (3) The induced synthesis of tyrosine aminotransferase is more sensitive to the inhibition of elongation. We conclude from our results that Bt2cAMP induces the synthesis of tyrosine aminotransferase by an increase in the rate of initiation on the tyrosine aminotransferase mRNA.

Linear Remodeling of Helical Virus by Movement Protein Binding

Previously we have shown that encapsidated potato virus X (PVX) RNA was nontranslatable in vitro, but could be converted into a translatable form by binding of the PVX-coded movement protein (termed TGBp1) to one end of a polar helical PVX virion. We reported that binding of TGBp1 to coat protein (CP) subunits located at one extremity of the helical particles induced a linear destabilization of the CP helix, which was transmitted along the whole particle. Two model structures were used: (i) native PVX and (ii) artificial polar helical PVX-like particles lacking intact RNA (PVX(RNA-DEG)). Binding of TGBp1 to the end of either of these particles led to their destabilization, but no disassembly of the CP helix occurred. Influence of additional factors was required to trigger rapid disassembly of TGBp1-PVX and TGBp1-PVX(RNA-DEG) complexes. Thus: (i) no disassembly was observed unless TGBp1-PVX complex was translated. A novel phenomenon of TGBp1-dependent, ribosome-triggered disassembly of PVX was described: initiation of translation and few translocation steps were needed to trigger rapid (and presumably cooperative) disassembly of TGBp1-PVX into protein subunits and RNA. Importantly, the whole of the RNA molecule (including its 3'-terminal region) was released. The TGBp1-induced linear destabilization of CP helix was reversible, suggesting that PVX in TGBp1-PVX complex was metastable; (ii) entire disassembly of the TGBp1-PVX(RNA-DEG) complex (but not of the TGBp1-free PVX(RNA-DEG) particles) into 2.8S subunits was triggered under influence of a centrifugal field. To our knowledge, transmission of the linear destabilization along the polar helical protein array induced by a foreign protein binding to the end of the helix represents a novel phenomenon. It is tempting to suggest that binding of TGBp1 to the end of the PVX CP helix induced conformational changes in terminal CP subunits that can be linearly transferred along the whole helical particle, i.e. that intersubunit conformational changes may be transferred along the CP helix.

Pushing the limits of the scanning mechanism for initiation of translation

Selection of the translational initiation site in most eukaryotic mRNAs appears to occur via a scanning mechanism which predicts that proximity to the 5' end plays a dominant role in identifying the start codon. This "position effect" is seen in cases where a mutation creates an AUG codon upstream from the normal start site and translation shifts to the upstream site. The position effect is evident also in cases where a silent internal AUG codon is activated upon being relocated closer to the 5' end. Two mechanisms for escaping the first-AUG rule--reinitiation and context-dependent leaky scanning--enable downstream AUG codons to be accessed in some mRNAs. Although these mechanisms are not new, many new examples of their use have emerged. Via these escape pathways, the scanning mechanism operates even in extreme cases, such as a plant virus mRNA in which translation initiates from three start sites over a distance of 900 nt. This depends on careful structural arrangements, however, which are rarely present in cellular mRNAs. Understanding the rules for initiation of translation enables understanding of human diseases in which the expression of a critical gene is reduced by mutations that add upstream AUG codons or change the context around the AUG(START) codon. The opposite problem occurs in the case of hereditary thrombocythemia: translational efficiency is increased by mutations that remove or restructure a small upstream open reading frame in thrombopoietin mRNA, and the resulting overproduction of the cytokine causes the disease. This and other examples support the idea that 5' leader sequences are sometimes structured deliberately in a way that constrains scanning in order to prevent harmful overproduction of potent regulatory proteins. The accumulated evidence reveals how the scanning mechanism dictates the pattern of transcription--forcing production of monocistronic mRNAs--and the pattern of translation of eukaryotic cellular and viral genes.

Cloning, expression, and transcriptional properties of the human enhancer factor TEF-1

We describe the cDNA encoding the SV40 transcriptional enhancer factor 1 (TEF-1) and show that its translation initiates exclusively at an AUU codon in vivo. Cloned TEF-1, which is unrelated to other known transcription factors, specifically binds the SV40 GT-IIC and Sph enhansons. Cloned TEF-1 does not activate these enhansons in lymphoid MPC11 cells where they are known to be inactive, but represses the endogenous HeLa TEF-1 activity in vivo and in vitro. Repression is also observed with chimeras where the DNA-binding domain of the GAL4 activator replaces that of TEF-1, showing that repression results from interference/squelching. Such chimeras stimulate transcription in HeLa, but not in MPC11, cells in vivo and in HeLa cell extracts in vitro. However, high concentrations result in self-interference/squelching. These results strongly suggest that the trans-activation function of TEF-1 is mediated by a highly limiting, possible cell-specific, titratable transcriptional intermediary factor(s).

Secondary structure and expression in vivo and in vitro of messenger RNAs into which upstream AUG codons have been inserted

We wanted to discover whether the conformation of the mRNA leader sequence is involved in translational fidelity. For this purpose we constructed several mutants of Semliki Forest virus 26S mRNA and inserted AUG codons into the leader sequence. We then analyzed the results of in vitro and in vivo translation of these mRNAs, probed enzymatically the secondary structure and performed minimal energy folding of the transcripts. Our results indicate that the position of a hairpin in the leader sequence determines at which AUG codon downstream from that hairpin translation is initiated.

Regulation of protein synthesis in virus-infected animal cells

This chapter summarizes the structural features that govern the translation of viral mRNAs: where the synthesis of a protein starts and ends, how many proteins can be produced from one mRNA, and how efficiently. It focuses on the interplay between viral and cellular mRNAs and the translational machinery. That interplay, together with the intrinsic structure of viral mRNAs, determines the patterns of translation in infected cells. It also points out some possibilities for translational regulation that can only be glimpsed at present, but are likely to come into focus in the future. The mechanism of selecting the initiation site for protein synthesis appears to follow a single formula. The translational machinery displays a certain flexibility that is exploited more frequently by viral than by cellular mRNAs. Although some of the parameters that determine efficiency have been identified, how efficiently a given mRNA will be translated cannot be predicted by summing the known parameters.

Increased ribosomal affinity for mRNA causes resistance to edeine in a mutant of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

The effect of edeine on the translation of mRNA or poly(U)-directed polyphenylalanine synthesis has been studied in an edeine-resistant mutant of Saccharomyces cerevisiae under three different experimental conditions: in the whole lysate system, in a micrococcal-nuclease-treated lysate, and in a high-salt-treated lysate. The results indicate that translation of messenger is more resistant to edeine in the whole lysate than in the depleted lysates; these observations suggest that resistance to edeine is associated with the presence of endogenous mRNA. It is shown that 40S mutant subunits have a higher affinity for polysomal RNA than 40S wild-type subunits. Since the mRNA binding is inhibited by 7-methylguanosine 5'-monophosphate, the interaction between polysomal RNA and 40S ribosomes is specific for mRNA. The data demonstrate that in each of the depleted lysates, with edeine initially present, the formation of the 80S initiation complex is inhibited. However, edeine inhibition of [3H]methionine binding to 80S ribosomes is overcome completely in the mutant extract by preincubation of this lysate with polysomal RNA. The results indicate that the mutant may carry a specific change in a messenger-binding factor or in a ribosomal protein thereby permitting an increased stability of the messenger-ribosome complex which consequently results in an increased resistance of the mutant lysate to edeine.

Formation of a 22S mRNA X rRNA X protein complex during translation of globin messenger RNA

Poly(A)-rich RNA was isolated from rabbit reticulocyte polyribosomes by affinity chromatography on oligo(dT)-cellulose and fractionated in sucrose gradients under non-denaturing conditions. Most of the translatable RNA sedimented in sucrose gradients both as free 9S mRNA and as a 22S complex containing 18S ribosomal RNA and a protein of Mr 66 000. The complex was characterized by identification of the translation products. Experiments with both labelled globin mRNA and Mr-66 000 protein indicate that the complex is not an artefact, but rather that it is formed during the initiation of protein synthesis. The Mr-66 000 protein appears to be a component of the 48S pre-initiation complex and recycles before 80S complex formation.

Multiple ribosome binding to the 5'-terminal leader sequence of tobacco mosaic virus RNA. Assembly of an 80S ribosome X mRNA complex at the AUU codon

Tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) RNA with a long 5'-terminal leader sequence, as well as its isolated leader fragment (called omega), can form disome initiation complexes with wheat germ ribosomes. The second ribosome of the disome complex is bound to the leader sequence, upstream of an 80S particle occupying the AUG-containing initiation site [ Filipowicz and Haenni (1979) Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 76, 3111-3115; Konarska et al. (1981) Eur. J. Biochem. 114, 221-227]. In order to identify the parts of omega important for interaction with ribosomes, the 5'-terminally-labelled omega was treated with alkali and the resultant fragments of different lengths were used in binding experiments. A 16-nucleotide-long fragment bearing the AUU sequence at the 3' end is the shortest oligonucleotide capable of forming 80S complexes with wheat germ ribosomes. Full-length (73 nucleotides) omega with AUG at the 3' terminus is the only RNA fragment supporting disome complex formation. Synthetic oligoribonucleotides were prepared for a study of 80S complex assembly at codons other than AUG. Hexadecanucleotide (A) 13A -U-U and, to lesser extent, also (A) 13A -U-C, (A) 13A -U-A and (A) 13A -C-G bind 80S ribosomes. Formation of the (A) 13A -U-U X 80S complex is dependent on the presence of initiator Met- tRNAMerf . Assembly of the 80S particle at the AUU sequence is not an artifact resulting from the terminal position of this triplet. (A) 13A -U-U elongated with over 100 A residues still efficiently binds an 80S ribosome positioned, as established by ribosome protection experiments, at the AUU triplet. The present results support the notion that 80S initiation-like complexes can be formed at sequences containing AUU codons. The possible function of these complexes as intermediates in initiation of translation of some viral RNAs is discussed.

Identification of the initiation site of poliovirus polyprotein synthesis

The complete nucleotide sequence of poliovirus RNA has a long open reading frame capable of encoding the precursor polyprotein NCVP00. The first AUG codon in this reading frame is located 743 nucleotides from the 5' end of the RNA and is preceded by eight AUG codons in all three reading frames. Because all proteins that map at the amino terminus of the polyprotein (P1-1a, VP0, and VP4) are blocked at their amino termini and previous studies of ribosome binding have been inconclusive, direct identification of the initiation site of protein synthesis was difficult. We separated and identified all of the tryptic peptides of capsid protein VP4 and correlated these peptides with the amino acid sequence predicted to follow the AUG codon at nucleotide 743. Our data indicate that VP4 begins with a blocked glycine that is encoded immediately after the AUG codon at nucleotide 743. An S1 nuclease analysis of poliovirus mRNA failed to reveal a splice in the 5' region. We concluded that synthesis of the poliovirus polyprotein is initiated at nucleotide 743, the first AUG codon in the long open reading frame.

Positive and negative cAMP-mediated control of tyrosine aminotransferase synthesis in Reuber H35 hepatoma cells

Induction of L-tyrosine:2-oxoglutarate aminotransferase (EC 2.6.1.5) by N6,O2'-dibutyryl-adenosine 3',5'-monophosphate (Bt2cAMP) in Reuber H35 hepatoma cells reaches a maximum value between 3-5 h after addition of Bt2cAMP and subsequently decreases in the continuous presence of Bt2cAMP. We have investigated the kinetics of the increase, i.e. induction, and the decrease, i.e. the repressed state, of the tyrosine-aminotransferase-synthesizing system under these conditions. Our experimental results are as follows. 1. The repressed state of the tyrosine-aminotransferase-synthesizing system is not caused by a decrease in the intracellular cAMP concentration. 2. The repressed state is inhibited by actinomycin D (while induction is not inhibited). 3. During the repressed state no effect of dexamethasone on tyrosine aminotransferase synthesis is found, while during induction Bt2cAMP and dexamethasone act synergistically. 4. Longer starvation of the cells in serum-free medium has no influence on the kinetics of the induction/repressed state curve. From these results we have concluded that the mechanism of the transition to the repressed state of the tyrosine-aminotransferase-synthesizing system is essentially different from the mechanism of deinduction which occurs after removal of the inducer. Moreover, the repressed state of the system is a phenomenon which is induced by Bt2cAMP separately from induction at a different level of protein synthesis.

Binding of ribosomes to linear and circular forms of the 5'-terminal leader fragment of tobacco-mosaic-virus RNA

The sequence of the 5'-terminal leader fragment preceding the AUG codon in the RNA of tobacco mosaic virus (TMV), tomato strain, SPS isolate, has been determined. This RNA, similarly to the RNAs of the U1 and Dahlemense strains of TMV [Kukla et al. (1979) Eur. J. Biochem. 98, 61--66] has the 7-methylguanosine(5')triphospho(5')guanosine cap separated from the initiation codon by a long stretch of nucleotides devoid of guanosine residues. The RNase-T1-resistant 73-nucleotide-long leader fragment of TMV RNA from the SPS isolate was assayed for its ability to interact with eukaryotic and prokaryotic ribosomes. The linear fragment, labelled either at its 5' or 3' end, efficiently formed disome initiation complexes when incubated with wheat-germ protein-synthesis extract. In contrast to its linear counterpart, the circular covalently closed RNA leader fragment, obtained in a reaction catalysed by T4 RNA ligase, was unable to interact with wheat germ ribosomes. Both kinds of leader fragment bound equally well to Escherichia coli 70-S ribosomes. The results offer further support to the notion that in eukaryotic initiation the free 5' end (either capped or uncapped) is required for mRNA interaction with ribosomes. Furthermore, they suggest that both ribosomes found in disome initiation complexes with the TMV RNA leader fragment enter the mRNA sequentially via the free 5' terminus.

Role of ATP in binding and migration of 40S ribosomal subunits

Two assays have been devised to demonstrate ATP-dependent migration of 40S ribosomal subunits on messenger RNA. The first is a two-step runoff assay. Reovirus mRNA was initially loaded with 40S subunits by incubation with wheat germ ribosomes in the presence of the antibiotic edeine. During the second phase of the incubation, in which further attachment of ribosomes was inhibited, the preformed complexes were shown to dissociate (presumably by runoff) only if ATP was included in the reaction. A more direct demonstration of ATP-dependent migration of 40S subunits was carried out using 3' end-labeled brome mosaic virus mRNA. In the presence of edeine and ATP, 40S ribosomal subunits were shown to advance all the way to the 3' end of the message, as shown by protection of the labeled 3'-proximal segment against nuclease digestion. Depletion of ATP by the addition of hexokinase prevented this migration. A variety of observations has raised the possibility that attachment of eucaryotic ribosomes to messenger RNA proceeds via a "scanning mechanism." The hypothesis is that a 40S subunit binds initially at or near the 5' terminus of the message and subsequently migrates toward the interior, stopping when it encounters the first AUG triplet. If migration of 40S subunits requires ATP, as the present studies suggest, the scanning mechanism predicts that in a system depleted of ATP a single 40S ribosome should be trapped near the 5' terminus of the message--upstream of the AUG initiator codon. This prediction was confirmed by analyzing binding of wheat germ ribosomes to a synthetic ribopolymer in which the 5'-proximal region (lacking AUG codons) and the AUG-containing segment near the 3' end of the molecule were differentially labeled.

Mutants of yeast initiating translation of iso-1-cytochrome c within a region spanning 37 nucleotides

We used a specially constructed strain, cyc1-345, of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae to isolate revertants that initiated translation of iso-1-cytochrome c at various sites along an extended region of the mRNA. Normal amounts of iso-1-cytochrome c occurred when translation initiated at the abnormal sites corresponding to amino acid positions -3, -2, 3 and 5, as well as the normal position -1; 20% of the normal amounts occurred when translation initiated at the abnormal position 9. These results with cyc1-345 revertants indicate that translation of iso-1-cytochrome c can initiate with the normal efficiency at any site within the region spanning 25 nucleotides. Furthermore, because the lower amount of the short iso-1-cytochrome c in the mutant initiating at position 9 may not necessarily reflect an inefficiency of translation, we believe that translation can initiate with normal or near-normal efficiencies at any site within a 37 nucleotide region, and presumably at any site preceding and following that of the normal initiation codon. These results establish that there is no absolute requirement for a particular sequence 5' to the initiation codon, and are consistent with our previous suggestion that translation starts at the AUG codon closest to the 5' end of the mRNA.

Influence of mRNA secondary structure on binding and migration of 40S ribosomal subunits

Reovirus messenger RNA was modified by reaction with bisulfite (in denaturing conditions) or by incorporation of IMP in place of GMP, thereby irreversibly unfolding the mRNA. Messenger RNA in which the secondary structure was weakened or abolished retained the ability to bind to wheat germ ribosomes, suggesting that conformational features around the AUG codon are not required for ribosome recognition of mRNA. Ribosomes were not able to attach (directly) to spurious internal sites, even in extensively unfolded RNA, indicating that the monocistronic character of eucaryotic messages (in which initiation is limited to a single 5' proximal site) is not simply due to conformational masking of all the internal AUG codons. The secondary structure in eucaryotic messages does contribute to the fidelity of the translation process, however, because when 40S ribosomal subunits were incubated with denatured mRNA they failed to stop at the 5' proximal AUG codon. Extensive migration beyond the 5' region occurred when 40S ribosomes (in the absence of 60S subunits) attached to unfolded mRNA, implying that the secondary structure in native mRNA facilitates correct translation by impeding migration of 40S subunits beyond the 5' proximal initiation region. Secondary structure in mRNA may also modulate the efficiency of translation. Studies with BrUMP-substituted mRNA, in which the secondary structure is enhanced, suggested that the efficiency of mRNA binding to ribosomes decreases as the stability of the secondary structure increases.