Structural and immunological comparison of indigenous human O6-methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase with that encoded by a cloned cDNA

Understanding and manipulating O6-methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase expression

O6-Methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase (MGMT) is a DNA repair protein that transfers methyl and alkyl lesions from the O6 position of guanine to a cysteine in its structure. The ability of MGMT to also remove precytotoxic O6-alkylguanine lesions induced by chemotherapeutic chloroethylnitrosoureas has made down-regulation of MGMT expression the key component in strategies designed to sensitize tumors to the cytotoxic potential of chloroethylnitrosoureas. The study of how to regulate MGMT expression at the gene, mRNA, and protein levels has contributed not only to the development of effective inhibitors of MGMT action, but also, in a broader sense, to a better understanding of gene regulation and protein structure/function.

What structural features determine repair enzyme specificity and mechanism in chemically modified DNA?

A crucial question in repair is how do enzymes recognize substrates. In surveying the relevant literature, it becomes evident that there are no rules which can be clearly applied. At this time it appears that uracil glycosylase is the only repair enzyme for which all the known substrates can be rationalized on the basis of chemical structure. When surveying the multiplicity of substrates for m3A-DNA glycosylase, it is difficult, on the basis of present knowledge, to explain why 1,N6-etheno-A (epsilon A) is as good a substrate, if not better, than m3A for which the enzyme is named. There is no apparent unifying chemical structure which is required for recognition. It should also be noted that many studies of the mechanism of m3A-DNA glycosylase only utilized-N-3- and N-7-alkylpurines. On this basis, an electron-deficient purine, and later pyrimidine, was considered to be the recognition signal. Since epsilon A and Hx do not fall in this class, this is one illustration of why exploring new substrates becomes important in elucidating enzyme mechanisms. Ubiquitous enzymes, such as 5'-AP endonucleases, are present in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes. The primary function is the same, i.e., repair of an AP site which occurs through natural processes or from the action of DNA glycosylases. There are, however, completely unrelated substrates such as the exocyclic adducts pBQ-dC and pBQ-dG. pBQ-dC is repaired by both the human HAP1 and E. coli Exo III and Endo IV, while pBQ-dG is only repaired by the E. coli enzymes. Yet, when repair of these adducts occurs, it is by the same unusual pathway which differs from the usual base excision repair mechanism. This finding may ultimately not be as unusual as it now seems. The understanding of substrate recognition by repair enzymes, which can have different repair pathways, is complex. For example, three exocyclic derivatives which each have either the same modification (1,N4-epsilon dA and 3,N4-epsilon dC) or the same base with different modifying groups (3,N4-epsilon dC and 3,N4-pBQ-dC) are repaired by three separate enzymes and two mechanism (Figure 9). Investigators have also reported that two separate enzymes and pathways can be found for simple adducts such as m6G and O4T. It is not clear why, for these adducts, both MGMT and excision repair can be utilized. This could be visualized as a "backup" system and may be more common than now known. We cannot think like an enzyme or vice versa. In the absence of enough necessary information, we can only be descriptive. What information is necessary for further understanding? (1) More detailed structural studies of adducts in defined oligonucleotides would be useful. (2) New substrates should be explored. For example, is the mechanism for PBQ-dC (and pBQ-dG) repair unique? This involves guesswork and intuition. (3) For the adducts mentioned in this Perspective and others, understanding enzyme/substrate recognition will be facilitated by cocrystallography and site-directed mutagenesis. (4) Genetic approaches, such as knockouts or targeted mutations in repair genes, should be expanded in order to focus on the physiological role of a specific enzyme. Above all: structure, structure, structure! Enzymologists, organic chemists, physical chemiste, X-ray crystallographers, and others must combine forces if the fundamental problems addressed here are to be understood.

Specific recognition of O6-methylguanine in DNA by active site mutants of human O6-methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase

O6-Methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase (MGMT), a ubiquitous DNA repair protein, acts as a monomer in removing the mutagenic DNA adduct O6-alkylguanine (induced by alkylating carcinogens) via a stoichiometric reaction. The alkyl group is transferred without a cofactor to a specific cysteine acceptor residue of MGMT, Cys-145 in the case of human MGMT, containing 207 amino acid residues and thereby inactivates the protein. As a prelude to the investigation of the reaction mechanism of human MGMT by elucidation of its structure in free and substrate-bound forms via NMR spectroscopy and X-ray crystallography, two types of MGMT mutants were generated and characterized. First, systematic deletion analysis of the protein was carried out to determine the smallest size at which it is active or inactive but forms a stable complex with the substrate and so may be useful for NMR spetroscopic analysis. Deletion of more than 8 or 31 residues from the amino or carboxyl terminus, respectively, led to the loss of both activity and substrate binding. Removal of Arg-9 or Leu-176 and distal residues inactivated the protein, presumably by altering its tertiary structure. On the basis of the criteria of bacterial overexpression and solubility, the mutant MGMT with deletion of 28 residues at the carboxyl terminus should be suitable for NMR studies. In the second approach, we examined mutants at the active site (Cys-145) that retain substrate binding. Inactive C145A and C145S substitution mutants were found to form specific and stable complexes with an O6-methylguanine (m6G)-containing oligonucleotide substrate. Wild type MGMT also formed a similar complex, but only as a transient intermediate. Footprinting studies indicated a strong discriminatory effect of the base adduct on the binding of C145A to substrate DNA; 17-18 nucleotides on the m6G-containing strand and 13-14 nucleotides in the complementary strand spanning the base adduct were protected from DNase I digestion by the mutant protein. These results, as well as the identical protease sensitivity of the wild type and mutant proteins, suggest minimal structural change due to conservative mutations at the active site. Thus, the mutant proteins may be utilized for solving the structure and mechanism of human MGMT.

Requirement of the Pro-Cys-His-Arg sequence for O6-methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase activity revealed by saturation mutagenesis with negative and positive screening

O6-Methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase catalyzes transfer of a methyl group from O6-methylguanine and O4-methylthymine of DNA to a cysteine residue of the enzyme protein, thereby repairing the mutagenic and carcinogenic lesions in a single-step reaction. There are highly conserved amino acid sequences around the methyl-accepting cysteine site in eleven molecular species of methyltransferases. To elucidate the significance of the conserved sequence, amino acid substitutions were introduced by site-directed mutagenesis of the cloned DNA for Escherichia coli Ogt methyltransferase, and the activity and stability of mutant forms of the enzyme were examined. When cysteine-139, to which methyl transfer occurs, was replaced by other amino acids, all of the mutants showed the methyltransferase-negative phenotype. Methyltransferase-positive revertants, isolated from one of the negative mutants, had restored codons for cysteine. Thus the cysteine residue is essential for acceptance of the methyl group and is not replaceable by other amino acids. Using this negative and positive selection procedure, the analysis was extended to other residues near the acceptor site. At the histidine-140 and arginine-141 sites, all the positive revertants isolated carried codons for amino acids identical to those of the wild-type protein. At proline-138, five substitutions (serine, glutamine, threonine, histidine, and alanine) exhibited the positive phenotype but levels of methyltransferase activity in extracts of cells harboring these mutant forms were very low. This suggests that the proline residue at this site is important for maintaining the proper conformation of the protein. With valine-142 substitutions there were seven types of positive revertants, among which mutants carrying isoleucine, cysteine, leucine, and alanine showed relatively high levels of methyltransferase activity. These results indicate that the sequence Pro-Cys-His-Arg is a sine qua non for methyltransferase to exert its function.

In vitro methylation of the human O6-methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase promoter reduces transcription

Approx. 20% of human tumor cell lines (termed Mer-) are deficient in the DNA repair enzyme O6-methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase (MGMT; E.C.2.1.1.63). Such cells possess the MGMT gene and promoter sequences but have virtually no mRNA or protein. Cytosine methylation of gene sequences has been proposed as a mechanism by which MGMT could be suppressed in Mer- cells; however, the experimental evidence does not uniformly support this idea. We therefore investigated the effect of in vitro methylation of the MGMT promoter in a reporter gene construct transfected into cultured human cells. DNA methylation by HpaII or HhaI methylases suppressed the activity of the promoter, although the effect was not absolute. The occurrence of partial intracellular demethylation of promoter sequences may account for the incomplete inhibition of transcription. A model that attempts to reconcile the opposing views on the role of cytosine methylation in MGMT gene expression is presented.

Site directed mutagenesis of two cysteine residues in the E. coli ogt O6-alkylguanine DNA alkyltransferase protein

The E. coli ogt O6-alkylguanine-DNA alkyltransferase has two cysteine residues positioned identically with respect to cysteines in the E. coli ada O6-alkylguanine-DNA alkyltransferase. In order to assess their function, these residues were each substituted by a glycine to generate altered forms of the ogt protein. Mutagenesis of cysteine-139, located within a 'PCHRV' region of homology, eliminated functional activity confirming that this residue is the methyl-accepting cysteine in the active site of the protein. Substitution of cysteine 102 within the sequence 'LRTIPCG' had little effect on the ogt protein activity demonstrating that this cysteine is not directly involved with the transfer of O6-methylguanine adducts.

Characterization of cDNA encoding mouse DNA repair protein O6-methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase and high-level expression of the wild-type and mutant proteins in Escherichia coli

A mouse cDNA clone encoding O6-methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase (MGMT), responsible for repair of mutagenic O6-alkylguanine in DNA, was cloned from a lambda gt11 library. On the basis of an open reading frame in cDNA, the mouse protein contains 211 amino acids with a molecular mass of 22 kDa. The size and the predicted N-terminal sequence of the mouse protein were confirmed experimentally. The deduced amino acid sequence of the mouse MGMT is 70% homologous to that of the human MGMT. Cysteine-149 was shown to be the only alkyl acceptor residue in the mouse protein, in confirmation of the prediction based on conserved sequences of different MGMTs. Mouse MGMT protein is recognized by some monoclonal antibodies specific for human MGMT. Site-directed mutagenesis was utilized to reclone the mouse cDNA in a T7 promoter-based vector for overexpression of the native repair protein in Escherichia coli. The mouse protein has a tetrapeptide sequence, Pro-Glu-Gly-Val at positions 56-59, absent in the human protein. Neither deletion of this tetrapeptide nor substitution of valine-169 with alanine affected the activity of the mutant proteins.

The origin of O6-methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase in Chinese hamster ovary cells transfected with human DNA

Transfection of Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells with human DNA has been shown in several laboratories to produce clones which stably express the DNA-repair protein, O6-methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase (MGMT), that is lacking in the parent cell lines (Mex- phenotype). We have investigated the genetic origin of the MGMT in a number of such MGMT-positive (Mex+) clones by using human MGMT cDNA and anti-human MGMT antibodies as probes. None of the five independently isolated Mex+ lines has human MGMT gene sequences. Immunoblot analysis confirmed the absence of the human protein in the extracts of these cells. The MGMT mRNA in the lines that express low levels of MGMT (0.6-1.4 x 10(4) molecules/cell) is of the same size (1.1 kb) as that present in hamster liver. One cell line, GC-1, with a much higher level of MGMT (4 x 10(4) molecules/cell) has two MGMT mRNAs, a major species of 1.3 kb and a minor species of 1.8 kb. It has also two MGMT polypeptides (32 and 28 kDa), both of which are larger than the 25 kDa MGMT present in hamster liver and other Mex+ transfectants. These results indicate that the MGMT in all Mex+ CHO cell clones is encoded by the endogenous gene. While spontaneous activation of the MGMT gene cannot be ruled out in the Mex+ cell clones, the intervention of human DNA sequences may be responsible for activation of the endogenous gene in the GC-1 line.