Ligation of synthetic activated DNA substrates by site-specific recombinases and topoisomerase I

A Flp-SUMO hybrid recombinase reveals multi-layered copy number control of a selfish DNA element through post-translational modification

Mechanisms for highly efficient chromosome-associated equal segregation, and for maintenance of steady state copy number, are at the heart of the evolutionary success of the 2-micron plasmid as a stable multi-copy extra-chromosomal selfish DNA element present in the yeast nucleus. The Flp site-specific recombination system housed by the plasmid, which is central to plasmid copy number maintenance, is regulated at multiple levels. Transcription of the FLP gene is fine-tuned by the repressor function of the plasmid-coded partitioning proteins Rep1 and Rep2 and their antagonist Raf1, which is also plasmid-coded. In addition, the Flp protein is regulated by the host’s post-translational modification machinery. Utilizing a Flp-SUMO fusion protein, which functionally mimics naturally sumoylated Flp, we demonstrate that the modification signals ubiquitination of Flp, followed by its proteasome-mediated degradation. Furthermore, reduced binding affinity and cooperativity of the modified Flp decrease its association with the plasmid FRT (Flp recombination target) sites, and/or increase its dissociation from them. The resulting attenuation of strand cleavage and recombination events safeguards against runaway increase in plasmid copy number, which is deleterious to the host—and indirectly—to the plasmid. These results have broader relevance to potential mechanisms by which selfish genomes minimize fitness conflicts with host genomes by holding in check the extra genetic load they pose.

Plasmids of budding yeasts, exemplified by the 2-micron plasmid of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, and mammalian papilloma and gammaherpes viruses typify eukaryotic extra-chromosomal selfish DNA elements. The plasmid and the viral episomes, despite the long evolutionary divergence of their hosts, share striking similarities in lifestyles. These include the ability to segregate to daughter cells by hitchhiking on chromosomes and to switch from cell cycle regulated replication to iterative replication for copy number maintenance. While selfish elements, including those integrated into chromosomes, rely on their hosts’ genetic potential for long-term survival, their genetic load is carefully regulated to minimize fitness conflicts with the hosts. Our study focuses on the Flp site-specific recombinase, which is central to the copy number control of the 2-micron plasmid and whose steady state levels are regulated through transcriptional control by plasmid coded proteins and through post-translational modification by the host’s sumoylation machinery. We demonstrate that sumoylation, in addition, attenuates the catalytic activity of Flp by diminishing its DNA binding affinity and inter-monomer cooperativity, providing another layer of protection against runaway increase in plasmid copy number. Population control by self-imposed and host-mediated mechanisms is likely a general strategy among selfish elements to ensure nearly conflict-free coexistence with host genomes.

Real-time single-molecule tethered particle motion analysis reveals mechanistic similarities and contrasts of Flp site-specific recombinase with Cre and λ Int

Flp, a tyrosine site-specific recombinase coded for by the selfish two micron plasmid of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, plays a central role in the maintenance of plasmid copy number. The Flp recombination system can be manipulated to bring about a variety of targeted DNA rearrangements in its native host and under non-native biological contexts. We have performed an exhaustive analysis of the Flp recombination pathway from start to finish by using single-molecule tethered particle motion (TPM). The recombination reaction is characterized by its early commitment and high efficiency, with only minor detraction from ‘non-productive’ and ‘wayward’ complexes. The recombination synapse is stabilized by strand cleavage, presumably by promoting the establishment of functional interfaces between adjacent Flp monomers. Formation of the Holliday junction intermediate poses a rate-limiting barrier to the overall reaction. Isomerization of the junction to the conformation favoring its resolution in the recombinant mode is not a slow step. Consistent with the completion of nearly every initiated reaction, the chemical steps of strand cleavage and exchange are not reversible during a recombination event. Our findings demonstrate similarities and differences between Flp and the mechanistically related recombinases λ Int and Cre. The commitment and directionality of Flp recombination revealed by TPM is consistent with the physiological role of Flp in amplifying plasmid DNA.

Tyrosyl-DNA phosphodiesterase (Tdp1) (3'-phosphotyrosyl DNA phosphodiesterase)

Tyrosyl-DNA phosphodiesterase (Tdp1) hydrolyzes 3'-phosphotyrosyl bonds in vitro. Because topoisomerase I, a type IB topoisomerase, is the only enzyme known to form 3'-phosphotyrosine bonds in eukaryotic cells, it was proposed that Tdp1 is involved in the repair of dead-end topoisomerase I-DNA covalent complexes that may form in vivo. It has also been proposed that Tdp1 may represent a novel anticancer target since known anticancer agents (e.g., camptothecin) act by stabilizing topoisomerase I-DNA covalent adducts. The importance of Tdp1 in DNA repair is also demonstrated by the observation that a recessive mutation in the human TDP1 gene is responsible for the hereditary disorder Spinocerebellar Ataxia with Axonal Neuropathy (SCAN). Although it has been proposed that Tdp1 may be involved in the repair of multiple DNA lesions, this chapter describes the synthesis and characterization of substrates used to study the role of Tdp1 in repairing topoisomerase I-DNA adducts, and the methods used to study the catalytic mechanism and structure of this novel enzyme.

Human topoisomerase IIalpha possesses an intrinsic nucleic acid specificity for DNA ligation. Use of 5' covalently activated oligonucleotide substrates to study enzyme mechanism

Despite the importance of topoisomerase II-mediated DNA ligation to the essential physiological functions of the enzyme, the mechanistic details of this important reaction are poorly understood. Because topoisomerase II normally does not release cleaved DNA molecules prior to ligation, it is not known whether all of the nucleic acid specificity of its cleavage/ligation cycle is embodied in DNA cleavage or whether ligation also contributes specificity to the enzyme. All currently available ligation assays require that topoisomerase II cleave the initial DNA substrate before rejoining can be monitored. Consequently, it has been impossible to examine the specificity of DNA ligation separately from that of scission. To address this issue, a cleavage-independent topoisomerase II DNA ligation assay was developed. This assay utilizes a nicked oligonucleotide whose 5'-phosphate terminus at the nick has been activated by covalent attachment to the tyrosine mimic, p-nitrophenol. Human topoisomerase IIalpha and enzymes with active-site mutations that abrogated cleavage activity ligated the activated nick by catalyzing the direct attack of the terminal 3'-OH on the activated 5'-phosphate. Results with different DNA sequences indicate that human topoisomerase IIalpha possesses an intrinsic nucleic acid specificity for ligation that parallels its specificity for DNA cleavage.

Alcoholysis and strand joining by the Flp site-specific recombinase. Mechanistically equivalent reactions mediated by distinct catalytic configurations

The strand joining step of recombination mediated by the Flp site-specific recombinase involves the attack of a 3'-phosphotyrosyl bond by a 5'-hydroxyl group from DNA. The nucleophile in this reaction, the 5'-OH, can be substituted by glycerol or other polyhydric alcohols. The strand joining and glycerolysis reactions are mechanistically equivalent and are competitive to each other. The target diester in strand joining can be a 3'-phosphate covalently linked either to a short tyrosyl peptide or to the whole Flp protein via Tyr-343. By contrast, only the latter type of 3'-phosphotyrosyl linkage is a substrate for glycerolysis. As a result, in activated DNA substrates (containing the scissile phosphate linked to a short Flp peptide), Flp(Y343F) can mediate the joining reaction utilizing the 5'-hydroxyl attack but fails to promote glycerolysis. Wild type Flp promotes both reactions in these substrates. The strand joining and glycerolysis reactions are absolutely dependent on the catalytic histidine at position 305 of Flp. Our results fit into a model in which a Flp dimer, with one monomer covalently attached to the 3'-phosphate, is essential for orienting the target diester or the nucleophile (or both) during glycerolysis. The requirement for this dimeric complex is relaxed in the strand joining reaction because of the ability of DNA to orient the nucleophile (5'-OH) by complementary base pairing. The experimental outcomes described here have parallels to the "cleavage-dependent ligation" carried out by a catalytic variant of Flp, Flp(R308K) (Zhu, X.-D., and Sadowski, P. D. (1995) J. Biol. Chem. 270, 23044-23054).

DNA sequence determinant for FIp-induced DNA bending

The Flp site-specific recombinase from Saccharomyces cerevisiae induces DNA bending upon interaction with the Flp recognition target (FRT) site. The minimal FRT site comprises the inverted a and b binding elements, which flank a central 8 bp core region. The DNA bend in a complex of two Flp monomers bound to the FRT site is located in the middle of the core region. When the central AT basepair was replaced with a CG, the DNA bend was positioned at the outside end of the core region adjacent to the a binding element. The other basepairs surrounding the central AT basepair were not important to the position of Flp-induced bends. The change also decreased Flp-mediated cleavage of the top strand of the FRT site and increased Flp-mediated cleavage of the bottom strand. The overall recombination proficiency of the site was impaired. We conclude that the central AT basepair provides a point of flexure in the FRT site, which Flp uses to position the bend in dimeric Flp-DNA complexes, and that the structure of the core DNA influences the functionality of the site.

Polynucleotide ligase activity of eukaryotic topoisomerase I

Introduction of a single ribonucleoside immediately 5' of the scissile phosphate of a duplex DNA substrate converts eukaryotic topoisomerase I into an endoribonuclease. Here, I demonstrate that the RNase reaction is reversible. Vaccinia topoisomerase can ligate 2', 3'-cyclic phosphate and 5'-hydroxyl termini annealed to a bridging template strand. Remarkably, the ligase activity of topoisomerase does not require the active site tyrosine, implying that strand joining can occur via direct attack of the 5' hydroxyl on the cyclic phosphate without a covalent intermediate. Ligation does require other catalytic side chains on the enzyme. These findings underscore how a common ancestral mechanism of phosphoryl and nucleotidyl transfer can be harnessed to perform seemingly diverse tasks through subtle changes at the active site.

The role of single-stranded DNA in Flp-mediated strand exchange

The Flp recognition target site contains two inverted 13-base pair (bp) Flp binding sequences that surround an 8-bp core region. Flp recombinase has been shown to carry out strand ligation independently of its ability to execute strand cleavage. Using a synthetic activated DNA substrate bearing a 3'-phosphotyrosine group, we have developed an assay to measure strand exchange by Flp proteins. We have shown that wild-type Flp protein was able to catalyze strand exchange using DNA substrates containing 8-bp duplex core sequences. Mutant Flp proteins that are defective in either DNA bending or DNA cleavage were also impaired in their abilities to carry out strand exchange. The inability of these mutant proteins to execute strand exchange could be overcome by providing a DNA substrate containing a single-stranded core sequence. This single-stranded core sequence could be as small as 3 nucleotides. Full activity of mutant Flp proteins in strand exchange was observed when both partner DNAs contained an 8-nucleotide single-stranded core region. Using suicide substrates, we showed that single-stranded DNA is also important for strand exchange reactions where Flp-mediated strand cleavage is required. These results suggest that the ability of Flp to induce DNA bending and strand cleavage may be crucial for strand exchange. We propose that both DNA bending and strand cleavage may be required to separate the strands of the core region and that single-stranded DNA in the core region might be an intermediate in Flp-mediated DNA recombination.

Similarities and differences among 105 members of the Int family of site-specific recombinases

Alignments of 105 site-specific recombinases belonging to the Int family of proteins identified extended areas of similarity and three types of structural differences. In addition to the previously recognized conservation of the tetrad R-H-R-Y, located in boxes I and II, several newly identified sequence patches include charged amino acids that are highly conserved and a specific pattern of buried residues contributing to the overall protein fold. With some notable exceptions, unconserved regions correspond to loops in the crystal structures of the catalytic domains of lambda Int (Int c170) and HP1 Int (HPC) and of the recombinases XerD and Cre. Two structured regions also harbor some pronounced differences. The first comprises beta-sheets 4 and 5, alpha-helix D and the adjacent loop connecting it to alpha-helix E: two Ints of phages infecting thermophilic bacteria are missing this region altogether; the crystal structures of HPC, XerD and Cre reveal a lack of beta-sheets 4 and 5; Cre displays two additional beta-sheets following alpha-helix D; five recombinases carry large insertions. The second involves the catalytic tyrosine and is seen in a comparison of the four crystal structures. The yeast recombinases can theoretically be fitted to the Int fold, but the overall differences, involving changes in spacing as well as in motif structure, are more substantial than seen in most other proteins. The phenotypes of mutations compiled from several proteins are correlated with the available structural information and structure-function relationships are discussed. In addition, a few prokaryotic and eukaryotic enzymes with partial homology with the Int family of recombinases may be distantly related, either through divergent or convergent evolution. These include a restriction enzyme and a subgroup of eukaryotic RNA helicases (D-E-A-D proteins).

Asymmetry in Flp-mediated cleavage

Flp is a member of the integrase family of site-specific recombinases. Members of the integrase family mediate DNA strand cleavage via a transesterification reaction involving an active site tyrosine residue. The first step of the reaction results in covalent linkage of the protein to the 3'-phosphoryl DNA terminus, leaving a 5'-hydroxyl group at the site of the nick. We have used Flp recognition target (FRT) sites containing a 5'-bridging phosphorothioate linkage at the site of Flp cleavage to accumulate intermediates in which Flp is covalently bound at a cleavage site. We have probed these intermediates with dimethylsulfate using methylation protection and find that Flp-mediated cleavage is associated with protection of two adenine residues that are opposite the sites of cleavage and covalent attachment by Flp. Methylation interference studies showed that cleavage and covalent attachment are also accompanied by differences in the contacts of Flp with each of the two cleavage sites and with the surrounding symmetry elements. Therefore, we provide evidence that Flp-mediated cleavage and covalent attachment result in changes to the conformation of the Flp-FRT complex. These changes may be required for Flp-mediated strand exchange activity.

The Cre recombinase cleaves the lox site in trans

The Cre protein is a conservative site-specific recombinase that is encoded by bacteriophage P1. Its function in vivo is to resolve dimeric lysogenic P1 plasmids that arise by general recombination. In this way Cre facilitates effective partition of the P1 prophage. Cre is a member of the integrase family of conservative site-specific recombinases. Cleavage of the DNA by the integrases involves covalent attachment of a conserved nucleophilic tyrosine to the 3'-phosphoryl end at the site of the break. We have used in vitro complementation tests to show that the Cre protein, like the Flp protein of the 2-microm plasmid of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, cleaves its target lox site in trans. Moreover, the data are compatible with two modes of cleavage; one requires the reconstitution of a pseudo full-site from half-sites and the other requires the assembly of a higher order complex that resembles a synaptic complex.

The yeast site-specific recombinase Flp mediates alcoholysis and hydrolysis of the strand cleavage product: mimicking the strand-joining reaction with non-DNA nucleophiles

The yeast site-specific recombinase Flp is covalently linked to DNA via a 3'-phosphotyrosyl bond during the strand-breakage step of recombination. We show that this phosphotyrosyl diester bond formed between Flp and DNA can serve as the target for alcoholysis or hydrolysis in an Flp-assisted reaction. Flp does not mediate alcoholysis of the labile phosphodiester bond within the DNA chain under our assay conditions. The body of available evidence supports the notion that the alcoholysis/hydrolysis reaction is mechanistically analogous to the strand-joining step of the recombination pathway. The only difference is that the DNA 5'-hydroxyl group that acts as the nucleophile during recombination is substituted by a non-DNA nucleophile. We find that the alcoholysis reaction occurs only within the normal cleavage complex produced by the "shared active site" assembled at the interface of two Flp monomers. Unlike the strand-joining reaction, alcoholysis does not occur on an activated DNA substrate linked at its 3'-phosphate end to a short tyrosyl peptide (not to the full-length Flp), and bound non-covalently by a Flp monomer. However, even in this substrate that mimics the strand-cleaved state, the joining reaction is competitively inhibited by a polyhydric alcohol such as glycerol.

Cleavage-dependent ligation by the FLP recombinase. Characterization of a mutant FLP protein with an alteration in a catalytic amino acid

The FLP recombinase of the 2 microM plasmid of Saccharomyces cerevisiae belongs to the integrase family of recombinases whose members have in common four absolutely conserved residues (Arg-191, His-305, Arg-308, and Tyr-343). We have studied the mutant protein FLP R308K in which the arginine residue at position 308 has been replaced by lysine. Although FLP R308K was previously reported to be defective in ligation of certain substrates (Pan, G., Luetke, K., and Sadowski, P.D., Mol. Cell. Biol. 13, 3167-3175, 1993b), we show in this work that the protein is able to ligate those substrates that it can cleave (cleavage-dependent ligation activity). FLP R308K is defective in in vitro recombination and in strand exchange. It is able to carry out strand exchange at one of the two cleavage sites of the FLP recognition target site (FRT site), but is defective in strand exchange at the other cleavage site. These results are consistent with a model in which wild-type FLP initiates recombination only at one of the two cleavage sites. FLP R308K may be defective in the initiation of recombination.

Homology requirements for ligation and strand exchange by the FLP recombinase

The FLP recombinase of the 2-microns plasmid of Saccharomyces cerevisiae belongs to the integrase family whose members form a covalent bond between a conserved tyrosine of the recombinase and the 3'-phosphoryl group at the site of cleavage. Ligation takes place when the 5'-OH generated during the cleavage step attacks the phosphotyrosine bond and reforms a phosphodiester bond. When the incoming 5'-OH is from the partner duplex, strand exchange occurs. The FLP recognition target (FRT) contains two inverted 13-base pair (bp) FLP binding sequences that surround an 8-bp core region. It has been shown that heterology in the core regions of the recombinase FLP recognition target sites can dramatically impair recombination. Therefore, it was of interest to study the homology requirements of the core sequence for FLP-mediated ligation. Using nicked duplex substrates containing mismatches in the core sequence, we have demonstrated that the FLP ligation reaction can tolerate mismatches at all positions in the 8-bp core except the position immediately adjacent to the cleavage site. Using half-FRT substrates that contain a single-stranded core sequence, we showed that 4 base pairs adjacent to the cleavage site in the core are required for FLP to execute ligation with a single-stranded oligonucleotide. FLP is also able to ligate the protruding single strand on a half-FRT site to the opposite strand to form a hairpin. We have studied the effect of the base composition of the protruding 8-nucleotide single strand upon the efficiency of hairpin ligation. These studies revealed the importance of intrastrand complementarity in the formation of hairpin by FLP. Hence we conclude that the homology in the position adjacent to the cleavage site is most important, and the degree of the homology required is dependent on the nature of the ligation assay.

Specific targeting of antisense oligonucleotides to neutrophils

The ability of three different hydrophobic ligands (cholic acid, cholesterol, and the tetrapeptide fMLFY) to increase the uptake of an antisense (anti-actin) oligomer into neutrophils was analyzed. In agreement with the literature (Boutorin et al., 1989; Letsinger et al., 1989), we found that cholic acid and cholesterol conjugates greatly enhance the uptake of anti-actin oligomer. When fMLFY is the ligand, the cellular uptake is much less than that of anti-actin oligomer alone, but the biological consequences are much more significant. Our results are consistent with the hypothesis that the fMLFY conjugate of the anti-actin oligomer is internalized via a different route, and reaches its target site most efficiently.

Mechanistic and structural complexity in the site-specific recombination pathways of Int and FLP

This review focuses on two of the approximately 30 members of the diverse Int family of site-specific recombinases. The lambda recombination system represents those reactions involving accessory proteins and a complex higher-order structure. The FLP system represents the most streamlined reactions and has been the subject of detailed and informative studies on the mechanisms of DNA cleavage and ligation.